The Global Status of CCS: 2017 - Global CCS Institute
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
What’s About the Global CCS Institute: the world authority on carbon About the report: inside – capture and storage taking the heat away The Global CCS Institute is the world’s leading authority on carbon The Global Status of CCS 2017 capture and storage (CCS) – an international climate change organisation whose mission is to accelerate the deployment of CCS as an imperative technology in tackling climate change and providing documents the current status of CCS around the world and the significant operational 5– energy security. milestones over the past 12 Understanding Carbon months. The report tracks the Capture and Storage Working with a large and diverse membership, the Institute drives the worldwide progress of CCS 13– adoption of CCS by sharing expertise, building capacity and providing technologies and the key information, advice and advocacy to ensure this clean technology plays opportunities and challenges its rightful role in reducing greenhouse gas emissions. it faces. The Institute’s diverse international membership includes governments, It demystifies common CCS: A Critical global corporations, private companies, research bodies, academic misunderstandings about the Technology for Saving institutions, and non-governmental organisations, all of which are technology and identifies where our Environment 26– committed to CCS as a proven and pivotal part of a decarbonised future. and how it can, and must, be more widely deployed. The report is an indispensable CCS Facilities resource for governments, policy- makers, scientists, academics, Around the World List of acronyms media commentators and the millions of people who care about our climate and want 33– 2DS 2°C Scenario HELE High Efficiency Low to save our planet. The Policy B2DS Beyond 2°C Scenario Emission Landscape BECCS CCS Bioenergy with CCS Carbon capture and storage IEA IETA International Energy Agency International Emissions Currently, the world is way off track in meeting the Paris Agreement climate goals, 39– CCUS Carbon capture Trading Association and it cannot get back on Global Climate track without CCS. utilisation and storage IPCC Intergovernmental Advocacy CDM COP Clean Development Mechanism Conference of the Mtpa Panel on Climate Change Million metric tonnes With commentary from leaders and luminaries across the climate change echelon, this 43– Parties per annum The Cost of CCS report makes an indelible case CSLF Carbon Sequestration MW Megawatt for CCS as an indispensable Leadership Forum OECD Organisation for 47– climate change solution. CTCN Climate Technology Economic Co-operation Centre and Network and Development You can download the full EC European Commission R&D Research and report on the Institute’s website ENGO Environmental development at www.globalccsinstitute.com. Regional Overviews non-governmental UNFCCC United Nations organisation Framework Convention EOR EU-ETS Enhanced oil recovery European Union’s Emissions Trading on Climate Change US DOE United States Department of Energy 76– System WBCSD World Business Communicating CCS: GHG Greenhouse gas Council for Sustainable Taking it to the Streets Gt Gigatonne Development GW Gigawatt 3
Delivering the new It would not be an exaggeration Globally, the year was significant to say that the past year has in pure advocacy terms. With been particularly momentous concerted effort, and as part of energy economy for carbon capture and storage. our dedicated campaign – “Join the Underground” – CCS started Two new large-scale facilities to enjoy wider exposure for the came onstream and others, in safe, tested, commercial and China, Canada and Australia, versatile clean technology it is. moved closer to operation. The media started to sit up and It is one of the few technologies China demonstrated enormous able to alleviate emissions from take notice. commitment to ensuring CCS unabated gas and coal-fired becomes a mainstay of its Moving CCS from marginal player power, thus preserving jobs decarbonised future with eight to mainstream mitigator is a real and sustaining communities. large-scale facilities in varying focus of our efforts and we have stages of development, and struck a chord with a people- And it is distinctive in its ability levels of CCS funding and chain that straddles government, to remove historic CO2 emissions research hitting new heights. industry, academia and a myriad from the atmosphere when of key commentators. bioenergy is twinned with In Europe, CCS focus shifted to CCS (BECCS). industrial clusters potentially There remains, however, an using storage options in the overriding need to extend that These facts, well-proven in North Sea. people-chain beyond a small science and endorsed by fraternity. In a break from pre-eminent leaders in the Despite ongoing climate change field, as this report attests, tradition, this year’s report is not policy speculation in the United make CCS pivotal to a 2°C just intended for those “in the States, the start-up of Petra future – and indispensable to know”. It has been specifically Nova in Texas and of the Illinois anything beyond. designed to appeal to those Industrial CCS facility proved outside the circle who are less 2017 was a good year for CCS that CCS plants can proceed familiar with the technology but there is much, much more in any weather. and who do not appreciate its to be done. Weather has been the operative enormous potential. word. In Australia, blackouts With your support, we can Simply put, CCS is the conduit maintain the momentum of the and outages caused by extreme to a new energy economy; past year and allow CCS to climatic conditions and the well- an economy of clean and fulfil its true potential as the known limitation of intermittent sustainable energy across all technology that delivers a renewables to “do it all” in an Suddenly, CCS is part of forms – wind, solar, battery new energy economy. integrated electricity system, storage, hydrogen, bioenergy made climate change and the political discourse, and the raft of CO2 reuse energy security major topics applications. of conversation. however vexed, and we Suddenly, CCS is part of the CCS is the only clean technology capable of decarbonising major find ourselves talking political discourse, however vexed, and we find ourselves industrial sectors such as steel, cement, pulp and paper, refining BRAD PAGE directly to policy parity talking directly to policy parity issues around the world. and petrochemicals. Chief Executive Officer Global CCS Institute issues around the world. TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS I N T R O DU C T I O N 5 4
A time to coalesce around CCS 12 December 2015 was a seminal moment in the history of our planet and of international collaboration. Progress has continued rapidly, notwithstanding some hesitation Understanding in Washington, DC. carbon capture The Paris Agreement was ratified at an unprecedented rate and much has been achieved within a very short time to agree It is no secret that along with renewables, energy efficiency and carbon pricing, I am a supporter of the need to also Over the coming 12 months, I and storage and implement a variety of deploy carbon capture and mitigation measures in pursuit storage. We must pursue the sincerely hope of the Paris target to keep global atmospheric temperature low-carbon and zero-carbon growth story across the board in CCS garners What is CCS? increase to well-below 2˚C. our cities, infrastructure, and land the attention use. We must recognise, however, CCS is a critical CO2 emission abatement technology. We have seen 195 countries commit to measures designed as that it is likely that the world may and practical It encompasses an integrated suite of technologies that the first steps towards achieving not transition completely away from fossil fuels in the necessary support it can prevent large quantities of CO2 from being released the Paris targets. The G19 at the May 2017 Hamburg G20 time frames. Yet, we cannot deserves. in the atmosphere from the use of fossil fuels. It is a tolerate the continued emissions proven technology and has been in safe, commercial said, “Paris is irreversible”, and that are the consequence of the G20 as a whole declared this if Paris is to be realised. operation for 45 years. for the 2030 Sustainable Indeed, one of the key features in 2015, if we are really serious Development Goals agenda of the Paris Agreement was the about meeting those targets. and set its objectives as “strong, recognition that the temperature The challenge is to understand sustainable, balanced and target requires zero-net how scale can be built and inclusive growth”. emissions in the second half of costs reduced. Experience, Yet, two key things remain the century. That will require collaboration and mutual missing. some substantial negatives. In learning will be crucial. both these endeavours, CCS is First, we have not seen the Best wishes, absolutely necessary. It is likely acceleration needed to meet necessary, too, in major parts the ambitious targets set. That of economic activity outside the is the central issue for the next power sector. two or three Conferences of the Parties (COP) and for individual Over the coming 12 months, country action. I sincerely hope CCS garners the LORD NICHOLAS STERN attention and practical support it IG Patel Professor of Second, we have not yet deserves. Governments, policy- Economics & Government – witnessed countries embracing makers and the private sector London School of Economics the full array of clean must coalesce, in the same technologies needed to Chairman, Grantham way as signatories did in Paris achieve those targets. Research Institute TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS 6 7
CCS in numbers How does CCS work? 17 large-scale CCS facilities There are three major elements to CCS: Capture Transport Storage operating globally, four The separation of CO2 from Once separated, the CO2 is CO2 is injected into deep coming on stream in 2018 other gases produced at large industrial process facilities such compressed and transported via pipelines, trucks, ships or underground rock formations, usually at depths of 1 kilometre as coal and natural-gas-fired other methods to a suitable (km) or more. power plants, steel mills, cement site for geological storage. plants and refineries. these 21 220 million CCS is facilities have tonnes of the only Why do we need CCS: versatile, timely and utterly economic WHAT CAN BE DONE WITH CAPTURED CO2? a CO2 capture man-made technology CCS is a climate game-changer. It is one of the few technologies able • CO2 can be safely stored in deep underground capacity of CO2 has been able to to adequately displace CO2 from coal and gas-fired power stations and the only technology capable of reducing large-scale emissions geological formations. 37 million injected deep decarbonise from myriad industrial sources. • CO2 can be used as a value- tonnes per underground the industrial added commodity. This can CCS also has the unique capacity to be retrofitted to many existing result in a portion of the CO2 complexes to allow them to function cleanly for the term of their annum (Mtpa) to date sector natural life. being permanently stored – for example, in concrete that The equivalent of 8 million cars The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and International has been cured using CO2 or removed from the road each year Energy Agency (IEA) have both evidenced the critical role that CCS must in plastic materials derived play in meeting global emissions reduction goals. from biomass that uses CO2 as one of its key ingredients. CCS is ‘of its time’. Through enhanced oil recovery (EOR), it is proving its To reach the Paris 2˚C target... commercial worth by improving oil recovery from existing fields, using these same fields to permanently store the injected CO2. • CO2 can be converted into biomass. This can be achieved, for example, Through cleaning old industry and giving it a second life, CCS is 2,500 14% through algae farming using preserving jobs and keeping local economies alive. CO2 as a feedstock. The Most significantly, CCS is starting to demonstrate its climate change harvested algae can then prowess in delivering commercial returns in a new energy economy be processed into biofuels where hydrogen production and bioenergy are starting to gain traction. that take the place of non- biological carbon sources. And, it is proving itself economically comparable to all other clean CCS facilities operating in 2040 of cumulative emissions technologies. (Based on a CCS facility with a CO2 reductions must be capture capacity of ~1.5 Mtpa) derived from CCS TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS U N DE R S TA N DI N G C A R BO N C A PT U R E A N D S TO R AG E 8 9
11 The reason why some CCS facilities have not matured has nothing CCS: 12 key facts to do with technology, cost or capability. For example, the Kemper CCS facility in Mississippi made the decision to run the plant with natural gas instead of 1 CCS is a climate change technology. It is probably the most 3 There is no evidence to indicate that CCS causes earthquakes. CO2 injection like (or follow-up) facility.iii This demonstrates the declining costs of deployment. As a simple law to retrofit aged coal plants keeps jobs and economies alive as the world transitions to a low- 9 CCS works effectively and its wide adoption and escalating coal. This made the need for a gasifier redundant. Since carbon capture was linked to the gasifier, versatile and vital climate does have the potential to cause of economics, costs will continue carbon future. Even critical and deployment supports that CCS is now not applicable. The mitigation technology that micro-seismic activity in the to fall as more facilities come supercritical coal technologies fact. CCS still deserves greater Petra Nova CCS Plant in Texas exists. Irrefutable evidence by same way as other customary onstream. What is expensive like HELE (high-efficiency low- awareness and increased and the Boundary Dam facility the IPCC, IEA, plus numerous engineering activity, including is not doing anything at all. emission) technology, need CCS incentivisation through policy in Canada are testament to other international specialist mining, dam construction and oil to mitigate CO2 emissions. There parity with other low-carbon the capability of CCS and its bodies concur that international or gas development. This micro- is no such thing as clean coal emission technologies (the profitability in the power sector. 5 climate change targets cannot seismic activity is monitored, CCS is commercially without CCS. same sort of market instruments be achieved without CCS. and is of such a low magnitude, successful as the 17 large- that renewables enjoy). 12 Note: IEA findings maintain that to it cannot be felt on the surface scale facilities operating The Global CCS 7 reach Paris climate targets of 2˚C, 14% of the Earth. The meticulous around the world attest. Similarly, CCS complements Institute is an 10 of cumulative emissions reductions by characterisation of CO2 storage the four plants poised to come renewables by reducing CCS is needed independent, 2060 must derive from CCS.i sites to identify and understand onstream and the raft of other emissions in industries because the amount member-owned climate change below-ground stress and facilities in development that renewables cannot of fossil fuels we burn organisation that advocates pressure conditions minimises (seven in China alone) further penetrate – notably, steel, continues to rise. Last year, 2 CCS has been working for wider CCS deployment the risks of seismicity. It is also demonstrate its commercial cement, chemicals, fertilisers, fossil fuels reached a record 83.6 on behalf of its 55 members, safely and effectively worth noting that the injection viability and versatility. petrochemicals, paper and pulp. billion barrels of oil equivalent including governments, for 45 years (since the and geological storage of CO2, International climate change (Bboe) compared to 73.3 Bboe large and small companies, Apollo 17 moon landing in in conventional oil and gas fields bodies (IPCC, IEA) confirm that 10 years ago. There are no signs researchers, academics 1972). Operations undertaken 6 or deep saline formations, does CCS is not a “front” for CCS is the only mitigation of abatement. In 25 of the last and Environmental non- over almost half a century not require hydraulic fracturing. the coal or wider fossil technology able to decarbonise 26 years, we burned more fossil governmental organisations demonstrates that CO2 can be fuel industry. Rather, it is a large industrial sectors. CCS fuels than the year before. The (ENGOs). safely stored deep below ground. pragmatic technology with wide and renewables are partner only year recording a decrease Oil, gas and naturally occurring 4 On a like-for-like total application that can bridge the technologies working towards in the last 25 years was 2009 As the leading world authority on CO2 reservoirs have proven CCS, the Institute is an accredited system cost basis, CCS is gap between our current fossil the same decarbonised objective. (caused by the global recession). that fluids can be safely sealed member of reputable climate cheaper than intermittent fuel dependence and a future CO2 emissions have increased underground for millions of change organisations including renewables and costs continue that is fossil free. every year since 1960 and in years. CCS facilities target the 8 to decrease as more facilities There is abundant global the last two years, these hit the United Nations Framework same geology. It is the only clean technology Convention on Climate Change commercialise. In the power CO2 storage resources to all-time records.v able to address emissions (UNFCCC) and the IPCC, while it CCS technology is verifiably sector, CCS can provide the support widespread CCS across major industrial sectors The renewables’ (solar and enjoys very close and supportive well tested. Seventeen large- necessary backup and other deployment. Detailed surveys (including steel, cement, wind’s) share of gross electricity relationships with the IEA, the scale facilities are operating services to complement have been undertaken in many chemicals, fertiliser, petro- generation is currently less than International Emissions Trading successfully around the world intermittent renewables, and countries, including the United chemicals, paper and pulp). 5%, rising to 17% by 2040.vi Association (IETA), the World (with four more coming onstream costs continue to decrease as States (US), Canada, Australia, Fossil fuels’ share of electricity Business Council for Sustainable shortly). These 17 facilities are more facilities commercialise. Furthermore, CCS is the only Japan, China, Norway and the generation will equate to 50% by Development (WBCSD), the currently capable of capturing Since the Boundary Dam technology able to curtail United Kingdom (UK), where 2040. This confirms the urgency Climate Technology Centre and more than 30 Mtpa of CO2 CCS facility in Canada began emissions from the more than potential storage sites are well at which CCS must be applied to Network (CTCN) and the Carbon per annum.ii operations in 2014, savings of 500 new coal plants (Units) defined and well documented. power and wider industry. Sequestration Leadership Forum as much as 30% have been currently being built around the Many other countries are identified for construction of a world today (and an additional progressing storage studies. (CSLF), to name a few. 1,000 in planning).iv CCS’s ability TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS U N DE R S TA N DI N G C A R BO N C A PT U R E A N D S TO R AG E 10 11
Source: Global CCS Institute CUMULATIVE CO 2 INJECTION IN LEADING COUNTRIES Note: “Others” include Algeria, Brazil, China, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, CUMULATIVE CO 2 INJECTION 220 MILLION TONNES INUNDERGROUND CO 2 INJECTED LEADING COUNTRIES (APPROXIMATE VALUES) Germany and France. 220 MILLION TONNES CO 2 INJECTED UNDERGROUND (APPROXIMATE VALUES) Data refers to anthropogenic CO2. UNITED STATES UNITED STATES CANADA Storage: safe, There is considerable and very compelling evidence to support CANADA NORWAY permanent NORWAY EOR the storage aspect of CCS: EOR DEDICATED OTHERS CO2 is a common gas trapped in STORAGE DEDICATED and abundant geological systems for millennia OTHERS 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 STORAGE 160 and CO2 storage mimics natural 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 processes. Vast amounts of naturally A variety of monitoring occurring CO2 has been trapped Many people assume that one of the biggest technologies have been underground for millions of years. successfully deployed, challenges impeding the acceleration of CCS facilities The same kind of rock that keeps demonstrating our ability to is limited underground CO2 storage resources. naturally occurring CO2 (and measure, monitor and verify There is very high confidence oil and gas) underground for injected CO2 in the subsurface. that global CO2 storage The reality is, there is more underground storage resource than is millennia will trap injected CO2 resources are sufficient to actually needed to meet Paris climate targets. Monitoring of a CO2 storage permanently. Naturally occurring support CCS deployment In fact, a large proportion of the world’s key CO2 storage locations CO2 provides an understanding site occurs over its entire consistent with global have now been vigorously assessed and almost every high-emitting of storage processes. Knowledge lifecycle from pre-injection to emissions reduction goals. nation has demonstrated substantial underground storage resources. is also gained from naturally- operations to post-injection; it As an example, there is between 2,000 and 20,000 billion tonnes of occurring CO2 formations that enables the progress of CO2 Assessments of storage storage resources in North America alone. Countries including China, have been used as the primary injection to be measured and resources have been undertaken In short, we have the Canada, Norway, Australia, US and the UK all boast significant storage source of CO2 for EOR in the provides assurance that storage in more than 60 countries “underground” – we have availability, and other countries such as Japan, India, Brazil and South US for decades, providing up is developing as expected. and these assessments have the rocks, the experience Africa have also proven their storage capability.vii to 45 Mtpa.ix Operational and research indicated that global CO2 storage and technology. experience over several decades resources available to support The IEA has indicated that over 100 billion tonnes of (cumulative) storage Over 200 million tonnes demonstrates that injected CO2 CCS deployment are potentially All we need is everyone capacity is needed by 2060 if CCS is to contribute its targeted 14% of of anthropogenic CO2 has can be monitored to confirm its vast, and exceed what we need standing above-ground to emissions reductions under the IEA’s 2˚C scenario (2DS). In the year been successfully injected containment. over coming decades. support the cause. 2040, for example, the annual amount of CO2 captured and stored underground. Leakage of CO2 from geological Storage is proven across DR CHRIS CONSOLI deep underground under the 2DS is approaching 4 billion tonnes.viii Accumulated experience of CO2 storage presents a very low dedicated storage facilities Senior Consultant – Storage This means that the issue, and current challenge, has nothing to do injection worldwide over several risk to human health and the around the world and Global CCS Institute with storage resources, it is all about identifying storage sites and decades has proven there are no environment. across a range of geological that comes down to issues taking place above-ground – policy, technical barriers preventing the environments. funding and awareness. implementation of storage. Over Research indicates that the 40 sites have or are presently impacts of (unintended) CO2 There is extensive operational This last point is very important to those who may not be familiar leakage on land or in marine experience to show that properly safely and securely injecting with storage and how it works. environments are unlikely assessed subsurface formations man-made CO2 underground, CO2 storage is safe, secure and highly effective. Storage sites can mainly for EOR or explicitly for to cause permanent harm to can easily accommodate CO2 be selected, characterised, operated and sealed-off, based on well- dedicated geological storage.x ecosystems and communities. and in a commercially viable established practices and techniques gained from decades of relevant Additional experience is also If CO2 was discovered to be way. Commercial operations industry experience in a variety of settings around the world. Over gained from industrial analogues migrating towards the surface, have injected and stored CO2 these years, many millions of tonnes of CO2 have been injected and such as waste water, acid-gas operational experience from across a range of environments stored, with no tangible evidence of leakage. and natural-gas storage. large-scale projects, and pilot- from onshore through to deep scale programs, have informed a offshore sites and in different range of interventions to control, geological settings, depths and minimise and prevent leakage. storage rock types. TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS U N DE R S TA N DI N G C A R BO N C A PT U R E A N D S TO R AG E 12 13
Global storage resources CCS: A critical technology for saving our NOR 80 CAN 190 UK 70 environment USA JPN 2300 CHN 140 EU 1500 70 MEX 100 100 75 BRA 2000 AUS 400 50 SAF 140 25 0 Source: Global CCS Institute (November 2017) Colour scale is based on the level of detail and technical understanding of storage formations in an individual country, which reflects the confidence in storage resource estimate and storage prospectivity. The storage resource estimates (in gigatonnes CO2) of key nations based on published national storage resource assessments. TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS 15 14
Father of If you embrace climate science, embrace climate math. the phrase Global Warming The Paris Agreement has defined global climate targets for 2050 of 2ºC and “well below” 2°C (commonly stated as 1.5°C). By setting temperature limits (and by extension, limits to atmospheric greenhouse gas The question concentrations) in a fixed time, one can estimate the amount of climate budget left in a global climate ledger. Many have done so, including is, really, are the UNEP’s annual Emission Gap Report. we smart – P R O F E S S O R WA L L AC E S M I T H B R O E C K E R The arithmetic is formidable and daunting. At current rates of GHG enough to emissions worldwide, we have 20 years before we exceed the 2°C limit with 50% likelihood. To avoid a 1.5°C world with a 66% likelihood, we do what we have six years. This is grim news. More grim still is that global GHG emissions continue to rise, even as CO2 emissions appear to have know needs A viable backstop the size of the energy industry, Eventually the dependence on plateaued, due to rising methane, black carbon, and nitrous oxides. to be done. creating huge employment and fossil fuels will come to an end against a bad economic opportunities. and the world will be powered If the atmosphere were a business, the board would be worried by renewables. But, as this and demand more action of the leadership. So it is now with the CO2 trip It is of the utmost importance energy utopia lies many decades deployment of clean energy technology. Although renewables have that a research and development made impressive gains, and coal use appears to be flattening in many Despite all the talk about in the future, by the time we effort is launched to enhance CO2 countries, the climate faces great challenges and increasing urgency. reducing fossil fuel CO2 arrive there we will be saddled capture and storage. Currently, Specific sectors, including industry, land-use, and transportation lack emissions, the amount produced with an atmosphere laden with the people carrying out the solutions either actionable or affordable. each year keeps rising. Little excess CO2. research are involved with for- of any consequence is being This is the context in which CCS remains a critical and required part of profit companies and progress Garbage brought disease to our done to meet the challenge. the global solutions set. has been very slow. No-one streets. We learned to dispose We continue to nibble when has found the money necessary of it. Sewage poisoned our To make deep, rapid reductions in greenhouse gas emissions, CCS bold action is needed. Our to move at the needed speed. waters. We learned to treat it. must be deployed swiftly and at scale. One key application is in heavy military spends billions of dollars Governments are only marginally CO2 threatens to change our industry, which produces 21% of global emissions. This is particularly each year to maintain the involved. Industry sees it as climate. Hence, we must learn true for cement, steel, biofuels, and petrochemicals production. Another capability to deal with a global either too far off or as a threat to how to capture and bury it. is on the new, high-efficiency coal plants built in Asia and Europe, which war. The US National Institutes its bottom line. Venture capitalists will have long lives and eat up the carbon budget quickly. Another is on of Health spends untold tens of don’t see any short-term profit in natural gas plants, which are becoming mainstays of the power sector. DR JULIO FRIEDMANN millions of dollars preparing to it. There should be a government- PROFESSOR WALLACE We know enough today to deploy CCS projects to capture and reduce Distinguished Associate – ward off a pandemic. Yet, we only funded entity run along the same SMITH BROECKER all these emissions. The question is, really, are we smart enough to do Energy Future Initiative spend a pittance preparing to lines as the Manhattan Project what we know needs to be done. cope with a global climate crisis. Newberry Professor – CEO, Carbon Wrangler LLC where a wide range of scientists Department of Earth and Looked at in a positive way, share in the effort and work to Environmental Sciences the capture and storage of CO2 set goals and timetables. would create an industry 10–20% Columbia University TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS C C S : A C R I T I C A L T E C H N O LO G Y F O R SAV I N G O U R E N V I R O N M E N T 16 17
In December 2015, at the COP 21 in Paris, 195 countries adopted the Paris Agreement. These testimonials are not surprising given the inherent strengths of CCS: CCS deployment The Agreement’s longer-term climate goals are defined as: • It produces dispatchable electricity that complements intermittent power from solar in IEA scenarios • Limit average global warming to well below 2°C above pre-industrial and wind; times, with the aspiration of limiting warming to 1.5°C. JUMP-STARTING OUR CLIMATE FUTURE • It is the only technology • In the second half of this century, achieve a balance between option available to emissions sources and sinks (often referred to as net-zero emissions). significantly reduce emissions CCS technologies can play a critical role in the There simply cannot be a cost-effective mitigation response to climate from industrial processes; sustainable transformation of the global energy change without CCS. • It provides the major pathway system. They offer a solution to some of the most So far, global climate models have been unable to achieve cost-effective to “negative emissions” when vexing energy and climate challenges we face, outcomes consistent with the goals of the Paris Agreement without combined with biomass-fired including the need to significantly reduce emissions factoring in critical technologies such as CCS, bioenergy and their power plants. from industrial processes and from a large and combination of BECCS. relatively young global fleet of coal and gas-fired generation units. CCS also provides the means to The IPCC maintains that without CCS, the cost of achieving long-term deliver “negative emissions” to offset emissions from climate goals is nearly 140% more costly (much more than if other sectors where direct abatement is not economically technologies are not available). However, the scale of the CCS challenge can vary or technically feasible. The versatility and potential considerably. Some CCS plants have been operating The IEA has repeatedly confirmed the importance of CCS as part of a importance of CCS is reflected in the IEA’s “Energy on a commercial basis in the US since the 1970s, suite of low-carbon technologies in meeting global climate goals. In its Technology Perspectives 2017” analysis, which with limited or no public subsidies. Revenue from “Energy Technology Perspectives 2017” report, it states: highlights a growing role for CCS with greater EOR has been a major factor, and more recently has climate ambition. “Carbon capture and storage is vital for reducing energy emissions underpinned CCS investment decisions in China and across the energy system in both the Energy Technology Perspectives One question is whether CCS is really needed the Middle East. Other factors that have served to 2°C Scenario (2DS) and the Beyond 2°C Scenario (B2DS). The potential now, at a time when we’re seeing remarkable lower the barrier to investment include applications for CCS to generate negative emissions when coupled with bioenergy is improvements in the cost and performance of key where relatively pure CO2 is already being captured integral to energy use becoming carbon dioxide (CO2) emission-neutral renewable technologies like solar and wind? The or separated in industrial processes, where transport in 2060.”xi answer is unequivocally, yes. The gap between infrastructure is accessible, where CO2 storage is where global efforts are currently heading and a in close proximity, and where project revenues are “So just to be clear, CCS 2°C pathway is immense. It requires around 760 sufficiently large to accommodate the additional gigatonnes (Gt) of CO2 emissions reductions across cost of CCS operations. There is a strong case isn’t experimental – it’s a the energy sector between now and 2060. This for governments and industry to work together to CCS as a climate mitigation technology reworking of existing oil and is equivalent to more than 20 years of energy identify and cultivate CCS investment opportunities Global status of CCS 3,800 Mtpa of CO2 captured gas technologies. With CCS, emissions and – importantly – comes on top of (November 2017) by 2040 (IEA 2DS)* where one or more of the above factors converge. the carbon dioxide will remain the anticipated impact of current policy efforts and With strategic planning, these early opportunities 37 large-scale CCS trapped deep below the earth’s contributions. Therefore, all technologies will be could also become the launching pad for future facilities – combined CO2 capture capacity of surface as oil and natural needed as part of a significantly strengthened and CO2 transport and storage networks. approximately 65 Mtpa gas has remained trapped for accelerated international effort to bridge this gap. Renewed momentum and substantially increased • 21 facilities in operation or millions of years and, yes, CCS construction (~37 Mtpa) Today’s investment in CCS provides a critical investment in CCS is both critical and urgent if we will be necessary to solve the foundation for achieving deep emissions reductions • 5 facilities in advanced are to achieve long-term energy and climate goals. development (~11 Mtpa) climate problem.” in the future. Early CCS projects have delivered Focusing on lower-cost opportunities for CCS offers • 11 facilities in earlier significant technology learnings with the potential to a pragmatic and effective approach to jump-starting ~37 Mtpa stages of development DAVID HONE reduce future capital and operating costs by as much the next wave of investment. (~17 Mtpa) Non-OECD capacity Chief Climate Change Advisor as 30%. Investment in CO2 storage exploration and OECD capacity DAVE TURK at Shell International in his appraisal is supporting greatly improved confidence latest book Putting the Genie in the availability and integrity of storage solutions. Acting Director – Sustainability, * Source: Data sourced from International Energy Agency (2017), Energy Technology Perspectives 2017, OECD/IEA, Paris Back: Solving the Climate CCS is now at a stage where the major challenge is Technology and Outlooks Note: 2040 IEA 2DS data includes ~600 Mtpa “negative emissions” from BECCS and Energy Dilemma no longer technological; it is commercial. International Energy Agency TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS C C S : A C R I T I C A L T E C H N O LO G Y F O R SAV I N G O U R E N V I R O N M E N T 18 19
20 Gt C 10 2DS 0 2015 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 CCS in IEA Scenarios CCS IS EQUALLY IMPORTANT CCS by sectors and regions in the 2DS Nuclear 6% Source: International Energy Efficiency 40% IN INDUSTRY AND POWER AND Cumulative CO2 captured by sectors and regions by 2060 in 2DS (approximate values) Agency, “Energy Technology Fuel switching 5% 800 Renewables 35% ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT IN Perspectives 2017”, Paris: CCS 14% NON-OECD ECONOMIES 5% OECD/IEA, 2017 700 6% • Much of the focus around 600 14% Gt CO 2 EMISSIONS CCS has been around its 500 application to power – what CCS in the 2DS CCS IS CRITICAL TO THE 2DS PATHWAY 35% 140 140 CCS in the B2DS is often not appreciated is its 400 GtCO 2* GtCO 2* • Achieving a 2°C pathway is challenging and Gt CO2 cumulative 50 2DS to B2DS reductions in 2060 importance in decarbonising 300 POWER involves 50 a radical reduction in CO2 emissions. industrial processes. NON-OECD 73% 52% Reference scenario – current ambition 200 INDUSTRY OECD 40 • Current climate policies Reference and –current scenario pledges only slow ambition • Emissions in many OECD 40% 27% 48% 40 100 emissions growth and fall well short of the major Gt CO 2 EMISSIONS countries have either 30 redirection required. plateaued or are in decline; 0 30 CUMULATIVE EFFICIENCY RENEWABLES CCS NUCLEAR FUEL 31 Gt Gt CO 2 going forward, the emphasis CO2 EMISSION SWITCHING • CCS is a key technology to a 2°C pathway, REDUCTIONS 20 on emissions reduction falls 2015–2060 providing 20 14% of cumulative CO2 emissions very much on non-OECD Source: Data sourced from International Energy Agency, “Energy Technology Perspectives reduction through 2060 when compared to 2017”, Paris: OECD/IEA, 2017 10 “current ambitions”. To put this in perspective, economies, and especially 2DS 10 * Note: the 140 GtCO2 captured by CCS includes around 36 GtCO2 in “negative emissions” in the year 2050, over 5,000 million tonnes on China. from BECCS which act to compensate for emissions elsewhere in the energy system. 0 of CO2 (over 5 Gt) must be captured using 0 2015 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 CCS 2015 technologies 2020 –equivalent 2030 2040 to2050 present-day 2060 0 100 200 300 400 Source: International Energy Agency, Efficiency 40% annual CO2 emissions in the US. “Energy Technology Perspectives 2017”, Renewables 35% Source: International Energy Efficiency 34% Fuel switching 18% Paris: OECD/IEA, 2017 CCS 14% •Agency, Many thousands “Energy Technologyof CCS facilities Nuclearmust 1% be CCS 32% Perspectives 2017”, Paris: Nuclear 6% deployed in the coming decades if Renewables these 15% CCS IS ESPECIALLY IMPORTANT CCS deployment in non-OECD and OECD countries in the 2DS OECD/IEA, 2017 Fuel switching 5% targets are to be achieved. IN NON-OECD ECONOMIES Cumulative CO2 captured by non-OECD and OECD countries by 2060 in 2DS (approximate values) 160 • China, the US and India CCS in the power and industry sectors in the 2DS 140 currently account for around 140 Cumulative CO2 captured by industry and power sectors by 2060 11 in 2DS (approximate values) 38 CCS IS MUCH MORE WIDELY DEPLOYED IN CCS in the B2DS half of global CO2 emissions. 120 10 Gt CO 2 CAPTURED Gt CO2 cumulative 800 17 MOVING FROM 2DS TO B2DS 2DS to B2DS reductions in 2060 • Emissions from the US have 5% 50 100 700 40 102 6% • CCS is key to achieving net zero emissions across Reference scenario stabilised at around 5 Gt per 80 600 14% Gt CO 2 EMISSIONS the energy system. – current ambition annum, while China’s have 40 almost doubled in the past 60 500 9 Gt CO 2 EMISSIONS • CCS accounts for 32% of the additional emission 12 35% decade at around 10 Gt. 40 400 140 140 reductions needed in moving from the 2DS to 30 41 GtCO 2* GtCO 2* India is at 2 Gt. the B2DS. 20 300 POWER 40% NON-OECD 52% 20 • It is unsurprising that the 0 73% • In the B2DS, cumulative CO2 captured by 2060 200 CHINA INDIA ASEAN OTHERS NON- USINDUSTRY bulk of emissions reduction OECD 48% EU OTHERS OECD TOTAL is nearly 100 Gt higher than under the 2DS. 100 27% OECD 10 effort rests with non-OECD NON-OECD OECD • Much of this (additional) contribution is delivered countries, with China alone 0 Data sourced from International Energy Agency, “Energy Technology Perspectives Source: CUMULATIVE CO 2 EMISSION REDUCTIONS 2015–2060 EFFICIENCY RENEWABLES CCS NUCLEAR FUEL SWITCHING through increased use of CCS in industry where 0 accounting for 30% of total 2017”, Paris: OECD/IEA, 2017 CO2 is captured from smaller streams. 2015 2020 2030 2040 2050 2060 0 100 200 300 400 required reductions. • The combination of BECCS is one of the few Source: International Energy Agency, Efficiency 34% • This dominance of coal-based technologies that can remove historic CO2 “Energy Technology Perspectives CCS 32% emissions in China is reflected fired generation fleet is one of the youngest in the world, with two- 2017”, Paris: OECD/IEA, 2017 Source: Data sourced from International Energy Agency, emissions from the atmosphere (resulting in Fuel switching 18% in both electricity generation thirds “Energy of the plants Technology built2017”, Perspectives since 2005. Paris: Retrofitting OECD/IEA, 2017carbon capture Renewables 15% “net-negative emissions”). This combination and many industrial processes facilities to existing plants is a major decarbonisation opportunity.xii * Note: the 140 GtCO captured by CCS includes around 36 GtCO Nuclear 1% 2 2 is integral to achieving carbon-neutrality. In and signals the high potential in “negative emissions” from BECCS which act to compensate for • emissions China’s emissions elsewhere in thefrom cement energy system. production at least equal the total the 2DS and B2DS, BECCS accounts for 40% for CCS in China. emissions from the German economy (0.7–0.8 Gt per annum).xiii China or more of captured CO2 in the year 2060. • China presently has over accounts for around half of the world’s steel production – its annual CCS deployment in non-OECD and OECD • An unprecedented increase in near-term climate 900 gigawatts (GW) of CO2 emissions from this industry sector alone is estimated at between countries in the xiv2DS mitigation actions is required if limiting warming installed coal-fired power 1.0 and 1.5 Gt. Petroleum processing and related petrochemical Cumulative CO captured by non-OECD and OECD countries by 2060 2 towards 1.5°C is to be more than aspirational. capacity, with around 150 GW activities (along with in 2DS considerable (approximate values) coal-to-chemical activities) are under construction. The coal- also major CO2 emitters. 160 140 140 11 38 10 120 O 2 CAPTURED C C S : A C R I T I C A L T E C H N O LO G Y F O R SAV I 17 20 TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS NG OUR ENVIRONMENT 21 100 40 102 16 80
CCS in industrial and power sectors in the 2DS Cumulative CO2 captured by industry and power sectors by 2060 in 2DS (approximate values) 160 73 140 140 CCS on BECCS CCS on gas-fired power plant 120 Gt CO 2 CAPTURED 100 CCS on coal-fired power plant POWER: • Simply encouraging renewables and fuel CCS has considerable • Depending on the type of CO2 capture and 80 switching to unabated natural gas and/or the health benefits conversion technologies applied, in addition to 60 31 67 adoption of best available coal technology will other installed pollution control measures for not deliver the necessary emissions reductions • Poor air quality is a major threat to human regulatory and/or operational requirements, 40 9 to meet climate goals. health. Globally, about 3 million premature deployment of CCS technologies can deliver 20 11 deaths are annually attributed to outdoor air significant reduction in conventional atmospheric 16 • Around 40% of the world’s electricity presently 0 pollution with predictions that this will rise to pollutants: comes from coal, with the youngest coal “fleet” 6–9 million by 2060. CEMENT IRON & STEEL CHEMICALS OTHERS INDUSTRY POWER TOTAL witnessed in decades. More than 500 gigawatts −− A 90% reduction in sulphur oxide emissions (GW) of capacity has been added since 2010, • Children remain most vulnerable to bronchitis and can be achieved (through integrated flue gas mainly in emerging economies.xv asthma, but the health risk extends to the wider desulfurisation); population and increases in hospital admissions, Source: Data sourced from International Energy Agency, • These plants have the potential to operate for health expenditure and restricted work days. −− A reduction of over 70% in nitrogen oxides “Energy Technology Perspectives 2017”, Paris: OECD/IEA, 2017 another 30 to 40 years and are unlikely to be emissions (from selective catalytic reduction); retired in a timeframe adequate for meeting • The annual global welfare costs associated with the premature deaths from outdoor air pollution −− 100% removal of fly ash from electricity CCS IS EQUALLY IMPORTANT IN INDUSTRY long-term climate goals. are staggering – US$3 trillion currently and generation (electrostatic precipitators and AND POWER • Retro-fitting carbon capture facilities to existing fabric filters), which can be recycled for use projected to rise to US$18–25 trillion by 2060.xvii • Industrialisation will continue to drive major generating plants presents a considerable in the construction industry; economies. Cities will multiply and expand opportunity to decarbonise the power sector −− Heavy metals (mercury) and particulate matter and infrastructure requirements will follow suit. in many regions. Otway Facility. Photography can also be effectively managed. courtesy of CO2CRC. • This will require massive amounts of industrial • There has been a “dash for gas” in many countries goods such as steel, cement and petrochemicals, over recent years and gas now accounts for over the production of which emits high levels of CO2. 20% of global electricity generation, with more plants slated for construction. • CCS is the only technology available to make deep emissions cuts in these industries. • While a gas-fired power plant is considered “cleaner” than a coal-fired plant, it is far from • In the 2˚C pathway, near half of the cumulative being low-carbon (a combined cycle plant has emission reductions to 2060 come from industry an emissions profile of around 370 grams of (around 70 Gt). CO2 per kilowatt hour (gCO2/KWh) vs around 700 • Many industry sectors (examples include fertiliser gCO2/ KWh for an ultra-supercritical coal plant).xvi production and natural-gas processing) already • Application of CCS technologies to these plants separate out CO2 as part of their production is therefore vital. processes and provide lower-cost “beacons” for supporting further development. 22 23 TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS C C S : A C R I T I C A L T E C H N O LO G Y F O R SAV I N G O U R E N V I R O N M E N T
CCS and the new energy economy CCS is a key component in The opportunity to turn Victoria’s • CCS transforms high-emission reconciling the so-called “energy brown coal into clean hydrogen industries to low-carbon trilemma” – the challenges is just one example of the new factories of the future that can associated with meeting opportunities CCS can create; prosper under increasingly international climate change and to set the stage for a clean stringent carbon constraints. commitments, keeping the lights energy hub that harnesses jobs This has stimulated several on, and reducing electricity costs, and creates a new, decarbonised industrial hub and cluster all at the same time. economy. initiatives, most notably in Europe, aimed at maximising Inclusion of CCS within a portfolio The clean energy revolution can economies of scale. These of low-carbon technologies is not also open new opportunities for initiatives will retain skilled just the most cost-effective route CCS elsewhere: jobs, create new industries at to global decarbonisation, it also • Deployment of CCS can cluster-points and in Europe’s delivers energy reliability and generate economy-wide case, give life to a globally lower costs. employment growth in the significant CO2 storage As the energy matrix continues provision of services (such industry in the North Sea; to evolve, CCS also facilitates as project management, • Early deployment of CCS, and the creation of new energy engineering, finance, legal especially retrofits to existing economies, which are yet to and environment), the facilities, avoids the early reach their zenith. A good manufacture of components retirement of highly productive example is the work Kawasaki (such as boilers and The Teesside Collective Teesside Collective, United Kingdom. assets. It provides significant Heavy Industries is undertaking turbines), CO2 infrastructure Photography courtesy of Teesside benefits to local communities Collective UK. Photographer: with Iwatani, J-Power and Shell development (such as storage that have grown up around Dave Charnley. Japan to scope a hydrogen characterisation) and general Developing a full-scale industrial • Around 6,000 jobs moved high-emitting industries and energy supply chain in Australia’s construction activities; carbon capture cluster in the Tees to the low-carbon economy, face significant dislocation Latrobe Valley. Valley region in the UK shows including those associated in and economic hardship from premature closures. significant economic benefits:xviii the relevant supply chains; • Creation of hundreds of long- • An annual increase of around term jobs, directly and indirectly £85 million in gross value- Inclusion of CCS within a portfolio of low-carbon technologies is associated with the operation (including maintenance) of the added flowing to the UK economy over the first four not just the most cost-effective route to global decarbonisation, CCS network; years of operation. it also delivers energy reliability and lower costs. 25 24 TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS C C S : A C R I T I C A L T E C H N O LO G Y F O R SAV I N G O U R E N V I R O N M E N T
A vision for an integrated low-carbon energy system that allows both renewable and CCS technologies to flourish DISPATCHABLE INTERMITTENT INTERMITTENT Dispatchable fossil-based generation with CCS requires no additional grid integration costs or risks making it affordable and reliable. Fossil fuel power Wind power Solar power with carbon capture The most affordable and reliable An electricity system with a further be complemented by a low-emissions electricity system high penetration of intermittent fleet of long-distance vehicles Surplus power requires everything – fossil- renewable generation requires operated on fuels from refineries based dispatchable power back-up and augmentation using capture technologies on with CCS, and intermittent renewable energy sources systems to ensure reliability and resilience. Dispatchable crude oil produced from CO2- EOR systems. H2 with energy storage. fossil-based generation with CCS requires no additional grid Such vehicles could also employ CO2 Safe, reliable and affordable hydrogen fuel cells with the integration costs or risks making electricity is reliant on a suite of hydrogen produced from fossil it affordable and reliable. Decentralised technologies to meet changing fuels with CCS. power supply and demand patterns. A power system comprising These long-distance vehicles Intermittent renewable energy renewables complemented may be transporting chemical with energy storage will be by a suite of decarbonised H2 or fertiliser products from plants Dedicated Battery an important part of the future fossil energy plants will supply that have captured carbon storage storage global energy mix but renewable electricity day and night, at times for permanent storage. These energy alone cannot provide of low wind and poor sunlight, Green H2 for vehicles will pass through major Low CO2 buildings reliable electricity at acceptable and during peak needs. home heating cities that have redesigned CO2 + other uses cost and risk. Electricity generated by this existing natural-gas grids to system that is not dispatched use “green” hydrogen for home can be stored in batteries for heating purposes backed by CO2 other purposes such as powering significant CCS development. H2 production electric vehicles, which can with carbon This integrated energy system Enhanced capture enables both renewable and hydrocarbon CCS technologies to develop recovery Low-CO2 fleet CCS and and flourish while also securing the most cost-effective global mitigation response. CO2 renewables for Oil electricity surety Ethanol plant with Low-CO2 Long-distance Electric/H2 fuel carbon capture biofuel freight + airplanes cell vehicles 26 C C S : A C R I T I C A L T E C H N O LO G Y F O R SAV I N G O U R E N V I R O N M E N T 27 TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS
LARGE-SCALE CCS FACILITIES BY REGION Advanced Development CCS large-scale facilities by industry and operations start date Early Development In Construction BOUNDARY DAM PETRA NOVA POWER GENERATION Operating Since then, more than 200 million Four additional large-scale CCS facilities ILLINOIS INDUSTRIAL CHEMICAL tonnes of CO2 has been captured facilities are currently in Total PRODUCTION YANCHANG and injected deep underground. construction, all planned to IRON & STEEL ABU DHABI be operational in 2018, and Americas PRODUCTION Early application of CCS capable of capturing an around the world technologies in the 1970s and - United States - 2 - 9 11 additional 6 Mtpa of CO2. SYNTHETIC GREAT PLAINS 1980s involved processes in - Canada - - 2 3 5 NATURAL GAS which CO2 was already routinely There are around 15 smaller- - Brazil - - - 1 1 FERTILISER ENID ACTL AGRIUM separated, such as in natural- scale CCS facilities in operation PRODUCTION Asia Pacific gas processing and fertiliser or under construction around the ACTL STURGEON production. This was then world. The CO2 capture capacity - China 6 1 1 - 8 OIL REFINING SHUTE CENTURY PLANT augmented with the demand of these individual facilities - Australia 1 1 1 - 3 CREEK SANTOS TERRELL BASIN UTHMANIYAH for CO2 for use in EOR. Today, ranges from around 50,000 - South Korea 2 - - - 2 NATURAL GAS PROCESSING GORGON the portfolio of CCS facilities is to almost 400,000 tonnes per Carbon capture and storage is proven and highly versatile. SLEIPNER SNØHVIT LOST Europe CABIN much more diverse, including annum. In total, these facilities HYDROGEN - Norway - 1 - 2 3 applications in coal-fired power, can capture over 2 Mtpa of CO2. It has been applied in a wide range of industries since 1972 when several natural-gas PRODUCTION AIR PRODUCTS QUEST steel manufacture, chemical and - UK 2 - - - 2 processing plants in the Val Verde area of Texas began employing carbon capture to All this carbon capture capacity hydrogen production and BECCS. Middle East adds up to the equivalent of over supply CO1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2 for EOR operations. While CO2-EOR remains a key 8 million motor vehicles taken off - Saudi Arabia - - - 1 1 1 MTPA OF CO 2 (AREA OF CIRCLES business driver for CCS, wider EOR DEDICATED STORAGE PROPORTIONAL TO CAPACITY) the roads. - United Arab - - - 1 1 geological storage solutions Source: Global CCS Institute Database (November 2017) Emirates are now represented among Total 11 5 4 17 37 operating projects. CCS large-scale facilities in operation and construction by industry and operations start date Much has been achieved over BOUNDARY DAM the last four decades: POWER GENERATION PETRA NOVA CO2 capture history • Capture technologies are now CHEMICAL ILLINOIS INDUSTRIAL widely employed at scale 50 250 YANCHANG PRODUCTION globally, and costs are falling IRON & STEEL ABU DHABI rapidly as new facilities come (MILLION TONNES, APPROXIMATE) onstream and next generation 40 200 CO 2 CAPTURE CAPACITY (Mtpa) PRODUCTION CUMULATIVE CO 2 INJECTION GREAT PLAINS technologies are unleashed; SYNTHETIC NATURAL GAS • More than 6,000 kilometres 30 150 ENID FERTILISER FERTILIZER COFFEYVILLE ACTL AGRIUM (km) of CO2 pipelines are PRODUCTION operational with an excellent 20 100 ACTL STURGEON safety record; OIL REFINING TERRELL SANTOS BASIN • CO2 is injected securely into DEPLOYMENT OF CCS CONTINUES NATURAL GAS (VAL VERDE) a variety of strata with no 10 TO PROGRESS 50 SHUTE SNØHVIT CREEK PROCESSING SLEIPNER LOST UTHMANIYAH evidence of leakage to the GORGON CABIN HYDROGEN CENTURY PLANT atmosphere. QUEST 0 0 PRODUCTION AIR There are 17 large-scale CCS 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005 2010 2016 2012 2018 2014 PRODUCTS facilities in operation globally, capturing more than 30 Mtpa 2020 1970 1980 1990 2000 2010 2019 2015 2016 2018 2014 2017 Source: Global CCS Institute CO2 capture capacity (Mtpa) — large and smaller- of CO2. (November 2017) scale facilities in operation and under construction 1 MTPA OF CO 2 (AREA OF CIRCLES Cumulative CO2 injection (Mt, approximate) EOR DEDICATED STORAGE PROPORTIONAL TO CAPACITY) Source: Global CCS Institute Database (November 2017) 28 29 TH E G LOBAL S TAT US OF CCS C C S FAC I L I T I E S A R O U N D T H E WO R L D
You can also read