Tax Alert on Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018 - EY Ford Rhodes

 
CONTINUE READING
Tax Alert on
Economic and Tax Reforms
        Package
          2018

                      EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018

This Alert is prepared as a general guide for the        Changes of consequential, administrative, procedural
benefit of our clients and is available to other         or editorial in nature have either been excluded or
interested persons upon request. This should not be      dealt with briefly.
published in any manner without the Firm’s consent.
This is not an exhaustive treatise as it sets out        It is suggested that the text of the Ordinances and the
interpretation of only the significant amendments        relevant laws and notifications, where applicable, be
proposed by the Foreign Assets (Declaration and          referred to in considering the interpretation of any
Repatriation) Ordinance, 2018, the Local Declaration     provision. Since these are only general comments, no
of Domestic Assets Ordinance, 2018, the Income Tax       decision on any issue be taken without further
(Amendment) Ordinance, 2018 and the Protection of        consideration and specific professional advice should
Economic Reforms (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018 in          be sought before any action is taken.
a concise form to amplify the important aspects of
the aforementioned Ordinances.

                                              Contents                                     Page

                 Highlights                                                                 1

                 The Foreign Assets (Declaration and Repatriation) Ordinance, 2018          2

                 The Local Declaration of Domestic Assets Ordinance, 2018                   5

                 The Income Tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018                                 8

                 The Protection of Economic Reforms (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018             11

09 April 2018

                                                                                             EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                              1

Highlights                                               •   The tax is required to be paid @ 2% and/or 5%,
                                                             depending on the category of asset declared.
The Foreign Assets (Declaration and Repatriation)
                                                         •   The information provided by the declarant shall
Ordinance, 2018 (FADR Ordinance)
                                                             remain confidential, notwithstanding any law for
•   Declaration of all foreign assets is to be made by       the time being in force.
    the citizens of Pakistan, except for holders of
                                                         Income Tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018
    public office and their spouses and dependent
    children.                                            •   Effective from tax year 2019, the rates of tax for
                                                             individual taxpayers (salaried and non-salaried)
•   The declaration and repatriation shall be made
                                                             have been significantly reduced. The highest rate
    on or after 10 April 2018 but on or before 30
                                                             will be 15% where taxable income exceeds Rs 4.8
    June 2018.
                                                             million.
•   The declaration of such foreign assets is to be
                                                         •   For the purposes of taxability of unexplained
    made at Fair Market Value, which shall not be
                                                             income or assets, as provided in section 111 of
    less than the cost of acquisition.
                                                             the IT Ordinance, concealed foreign assets and
•   The rates of tax applicable are 2%, 3%, and/or           concealed foreign income can be taxed in the
    5%, depending on the category of assets                  year of discovery, irrespective of the year of
    declared.                                                acquisition.

•   Declaration is to be made in Rupees, however the     •   Immunity from probe in respect of foreign
    payment is to be made in United States Dollars.          currency remitted to Pakistan has now been
                                                             restricted to Rs.10,000,000 in a tax year. This is
•   The information provided by the declarant shall
                                                             effective from tax year 2018.
    remain confidential, notwithstanding any law for
    the time being in force.                             •   Every resident individual having foreign income
                                                             equal to or in excess of USD 10,000 or foreign
The Local Declaration of Domestic Assets
                                                             assets with a value of USD 100,000 or more, are
Ordinance, 2018 (LDDA Ordinance)
                                                             now required to file a ‘Foreign Assets and Income
•   Declaration of all undisclosed income and                Statement’ pursuant to the newly inserted
    domestic assets of every Company, Association            section 116A of the IT Ordinance.
    of Persons, and the citizens of Pakistan,
                                                         •   Penalty @ 2% is applicable in relation to the non-
    wherever they may be, except for holders of
                                                             declaration of foreign assets and/or foreign
    public office and their spouses and dependent
                                                             income.
    children.
                                                         The Protection of Economic Reforms (Amendment)
•   The declaration and repatriation shall be made
                                                         Ordinance, 2018
    after 10 April 2018 but on or before 30 June
    2018.                                                •   Only a tax ‘Filer’ is now permitted to deposit cash
                                                             in his foreign currency account.
•   Declaration of different categories of asset, viz-
    a-viz: undisclosed income, immovable property,
    vehicles, shares and securities, precious stones
    and metals, etc., has been prescribed by the
    LDDA Ordinance.

                                                                                             EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                 2

The Prime Minister of Islamic Republic of Pakistan         appropriate legislation may be enacted at a later
announced an Economic Reforms package on 05 April          stage in order to bring the above proposals as part of
2018, which provides wide ranging measures to              law.
solicit the declaration of undeclared foreign as well as
local assets and income.                                   Our comments on these Ordinances are given below:

To give effect to the Economic Reforms Package, it is      1.   THE FOREIGN ASSETS (DECLARATION AND
understood that the President has promulgated the               REPATRIATION) ORDINANCE, 2018 – FADR
following Ordinances on 08 April 2018. The Gazetted             ORDINANCE
copy of the Ordinances is not available so far,
however, we have access to the unsigned copies of          1.1 Overriding effect
the following:
                                                           The provisions of the FADR Ordinance override all
1.   The Foreign Assets (Declaration and                   contrary provisions contained in any other law for the
     Repatriation) Ordinance, 2018                         time being in force.

2.   The Local Declaration of Domestic Assets              1.2 Application
     Ordinance, 2018
                                                           The FADR Ordinance shall apply to all foreign assets
3.   The Income Tax (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018            of the citizens of Pakistan, except:

4.   The Protection of Economic Reforms                    (a) Those owned by holders of public office and their
     (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018                               spouses and dependent children;

It is pertinent to note that the tax reforms package       (b) Foreign assets in respect of which any
announced by the Prime Minister of Pakistan on 05              proceedings are pending in any court of law: and
April 2018, also mentioned matters relating to
declaration/valuation of immovable properties which        (c) Foreign assets or proceeds that are involved in or
inter-alia include:                                            derived from the commission of a criminal
                                                               offence.
     (a) Introduction of unified valuation rates of
         properties across Pakistan.                       It is worthwhile to highlight that the application of the
                                                           FADR Ordinance is to the Citizens of Pakistan only,
     (b) Right of government to buy local immovable        therefore, any such persons who are not citizens of
         properties registered in 2018-2019, 2019-         Pakistan but are resident for taxation purposes in
         2020 and 2020-21 within six months of             Pakistan, would not be eligible to take benefit of the
         registration at prescribed percentages.           FADR Ordinance.

     (c) Restriction on non-filers to buy property over    1.3 Important definitions
         Rs.4 million
                                                                (a) Foreign Assets means any movable or
However, no legislation has been made with regard to                immovable assets held outside Pakistan and
the above proposed reforms. We understand that                      includes real estate, mortgaged assets, stock

                                                                                                 EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                    3

      and shares, bank accounts, bullion, cash,                General of Pakistan, Political
      jewels, paintings, accounts and loan                     Secretary;
      receivables, beneficial ownership or beneficial
      interests or contribution in offshore entities    iii.   the Chief Minister, Speaker Provincial
      and trusts.                                              Assembly, Deputy Speaker Provincial
                                                               Assembly, Provincial Minister, Adviser
   (b) Government Security means a bond, note or               or Consultant or Special Assistant to
       other debt instrument issued by the Federal             the Chief Minister and who holds or
       Government with a promise of repayment                  has held a post or office with the rank
       upon maturity.                                          or status of a Provincial Minister,
                                                               Provincial Parliamentary Secretary,
                                                               Member of the Provincial Assembly,
   (c) Liquid assets means cash or an asset that can
                                                               Advocate-General for a Province
       be readily converted into cash with a minimal
                                                               including Additional Advocate-General
       impact on the assets’ value and includes bank
                                                               and Assistant Advocate-General,
       notes, marketable securities, stocks,
                                                               Political Secretary;
       promissory notes, government bonds, deposit
       certificates and other similar instruments.
                                                        iv.    the Chief Justice or, as the case may
                                                               be, a Judge of the Supreme Court,
   (d) Holder of Public Office means a person who is           Federal Shariat Court, a High Court or
       or has been at any time since 1st day of                a Judicial Officer whether exercising
       January 2000 –                                          judicial or other functions or
                                                               Chairman or member of a Law
          i.   the President of the Islamic Republic           Commission, Chairman or Member of
               of Pakistan or the Governor of a                the Council of Islamic Ideology;
               Province;
                                                        v.     holding an office or post in the service
         ii.   the Prime Minister, Chairman Senate,            of Pakistan or any service in
               Speaker of the National Assembly,               connection with the affairs of the
               Deputy Chairman Senate, Deputy                  Federation or of a Province or of a
               Speaker National Assembly, Federal              local council constituted under any
               Minister, Minister of State, Attorney-          Federal or Provincial law relating to
               General for Pakistan and other Law              the constitution of local councils, co-
               Officers appointed under the Central            operative societies or in the
               Law Officers Ordinance, 1970 (VII of            management of corporations, banks,
               1970), Adviser or Consultant or                 financial institutions, firms, concerns,
               Special Assistant to the Prime                  undertakings or any other institution
               Minister and holds or has held a post           or organization established,
               or office with the rank or status of a          controlled or administered by or
               Federal Minister or Minister of State,          under the Federal Government or a
               Federal Parliamentary Secretary,                Provincial Government or a civilian
               Member of Parliament, Auditor-                  employee of the Armed Forces of
                                                               Pakistan;

                                                                                    EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                4

         vi.    the Chairman or Mayor or Vice                                                            Rate (as a
                Chairman or Deputy Mayor of a zila                                                      percentage
                                                              S.                                           of the
                council, a municipal committee, a                            Foreign Assets
                                                              No.                                         value of
                municipal corporation or a                                                                foreign
                metropolitan corporation constituted                                                      assets)

                under any Federal or Provincial law            1.   Liquid assets not repatriated           5%

                relating to local councils;                         Immovable assets outside
                                                               2.                                           3%
                                                                    Pakistan
                Explanation.– For the purpose of this               Liquid assets repatriated and
                sub-clause the expressions                          invested in Government
                                                                    securities upto 5 years in US
                "Chairman" and "Vice Chairman" shall                dollars denominated bonds with
                                                               3.                                           2%
                include "Mayor" and "Deputy Mayor"                  six-monthly profit payment in
                as the case may be, and the                         equivalent Rupees (rate of return
                                                                    3%) and payable on maturity in
                respective councilors therein; and                  equivalent Rupees
                                                               4.   Liquid assets repatriated               2%
         vii.   a District Nazim or District Naib
                Nazim, Tehsil Nazim or Tehsil Naib
                                                          The tax so calculated is to be paid along with the
                Nazim or Union Nazim or Union Naib
                                                          declaration of the foreign assets, which are to be
                Nazim;
                                                          declared at Fair Market Value (FMV). The expression
                                                          FMV has been defined to mean the price of the
The definition of holder of public office is quite
                                                          foreign asset determined and declared by the
extensive, covering a wide range of offices and
                                                          declarant himself, which should not be less than the
positions held by persons both at the Federal and
                                                          cost of acquisition of the foreign asset. In case of a
Provincial level, and such offices and positions being
                                                          mortgaged asset, the cost of acquisition would be the
held since 01 January 2000. Therefore, any person
                                                          sum of mortgaged payments and other mortgage
who was a holder of public office before this date, and
                                                          related costs incurred. The declaration is to be made
has not assumed any such office or position
                                                          in the manner provided in Form-A in the FADR
thereafter, will be eligible to take benefit under the
                                                          Ordinance.
FADR Ordinance.

                                                          1.5 Payment of tax
1.4 Value for declaration
                                                          The FADR Ordinance requires the foreign assets to be
The declaration in respect of the foreign assets can
                                                          valued and declared in Pak Rupees, whereas the
be made on or after 10 April 2018 and on or before
                                                          payment of tax is to be made in US Dollars, in the
30 June 2018. The declaration is to be filed with the
                                                          mode and manner prescribed by the State Bank of
Federal Board of Revenue (FBR). The foreign assets
                                                          Pakistan (SBP). It also maintains that the SBP will
held by any citizen of Pakistan are to be declared in
                                                          prescribe the mode and manner of repatriation of
the following categories and tax is required to be paid
                                                          liquid assets to Pakistan.
as a percentage of the value of foreign assets as
given in the table below:                                 The value in Rupees shall be converted into United
                                                          States Dollars at the SBP’s rate applicable between
                                                          the United States Dollar and the Pak Rupee, on the
                                                          date the declaration is made.

                                                                                                EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                 5

1.6 Incorporation in Books of Accounts                     1.9 Misrepresentation

The foreign assets so declared shall be incorporated       Under the FADR Ordinance, the immunity provided
in the declarant’s books of accounts. For the purpose      shall not apply to a declaration made by
of the Income Tax Ordinance, 2001 (IT Ordinance), it       misrepresentation or suppression of facts. In such a
has been provided that the cost of acquisition, and        case the declaration shall be treated as void.
the date of acquisition, of foreign assets, shall be the
value declared by the declarant and the date on which      2.   THE LOCAL DECLARATION OF DOMESTIC
the declaration has been made, respectively.                    ASSETS ORDINANCE, 2018

1.7 Investment in Government Securities                    2.1 Overriding effect

In case the declarant decides to invest in Government      The provisions of the LDDA Ordinance override all
securities, he shall do so in accordance with a scheme     contrary provisions contained in any other law for the
to be introduced by the Government of Pakistan             time being in force.
through the SBP.
                                                           2.2 Application
1.8 Immunity and Confidentiality
                                                           The LDDA Ordinance shall apply to all undisclosed
The FADR Ordinance provides following immunities:          income and domestic assets of every Company,
                                                           Association of Persons and all citizen of Pakistan
    (a) That the declarant would not be required to        wherever they may be, except:
        pay any further tax under any law for the time
        being in force including the I.T. Ordinance             (a) Holders of public office and their spouses and
        where the declarant has paid tax on the                     dependent children;
        declared assets under this Ordinance.
                                                                (b) Undisclosed income and domestic assets in
    (b) That the particulars of the declarant and the               respect of which any proceedings are pending
        information received in the declaration shall               in any court of law; and
        be confidential notwithstanding the provisions
        of section 216 of the I.T. Ordinance, the Right         (c) Any proceeds or assets that are involved in or
        of Access to Information Act, 2017 and any                  derived from any criminal offence.
        other law for the time being in force.
                                                           The term proceeds, in our view, would encompass any
    (c) That nothing contained in the declaration          receipts in relation to such undisclosed income.
        shall be admissible as evidence against the
        declarant under any other law including the        It may be noted that contrary to the FADR Ordinance,
        I.T. Ordinance for the time being in force, for    this Ordinance applies to every Company, Association
        the purpose of any penalty proceedings or for      of Persons (AoP) and all citizens of Pakistan wherever
        the purpose of prosecution.                        they may be. Therefore, the purview of this
                                                           Ordinance is more extensive as compared with the
                                                           FADR Ordinance, as it covers Companies and AoPs as
                                                           well.

                                                                                                EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                       6

2.3 Important definitions                                    The assets declared are to be valued in accordance
                                                             with the valuation guidelines given in section 10,
    (a) Domestic assets means assets of every kind           which is reproduced below:
        other than foreign assets under Foreign
        Assets (Declaration and Repatriation)                  S.    Undisclosed income     Value for the purpose of
        Ordinance, 2018                                        No.       and assets               section 5(2)
                                                               1.    Undisclosed income    As declared
    (b) Holder of public office has the same
                                                                                           Cost of acquisition or FBR
        definition as given in 1.3(d) above.                   2.    Open plots and land
                                                                                           rates, whichever is higher

2.4 Declaration                                                3.    Super structure       Rs.400 per square feet
                                                                                           Cost of acquisition or
                                                                     Apartments and
The declaration in respect of the undisclosed and              4.
                                                                     flats
                                                                                           Provincial stamp duty
domestic assets can be made after 10 April 2018 and                                        rates, whichever is higher

on or before 30 June 2018. The declaration is to be                                                      A-B
filed with the FBR. The undisclosed income and                                             Where –
domestic assets acquired before the commencement                                           A = CIF value plus the
                                                                                           amount of all charges,
of the LDDA Ordinance held by a Company, AoP and                                           customs-duty, sales tax,
any citizen of Pakistan, are to be declared in the                                         levies, octroi, fees and
following categories and tax is required to be paid as                                     other duties and taxes
                                                                     Imported motor
                                                               5.                          leviable thereon and the
a percentage of the value of the asset as given in the               vehicles
                                                                                           costs incurred till their
table below:                                                                               registration.

                                                Rate (as a
                                               percentage                                  B = a sum equal to 10% of
    S.                                            of the                                   the said value for each
                         Assets                                                            successive year upto a
    No.                                          value of
                                                 foreign                                   maximum of five years.
                                                 assets)                                                 A-B
          Foreign currency held in a foreign                                               Where –
          currency account in Pakistan as
    1.                                             2%                                      A = The price paid by the
          on the 31st March, 2018 and
                                                                                           purchaser, including the
          encashed in equivalent Rupees.
                                                                                           amount of all charges,
          Foreign currency held in a foreign                                               customs duty, sales tax
          currency account in Pakistan as                            Motor vehicles        and other taxes, levies,
          on the 31st March, 2018 which is                           purchased from a      octroi, fees and all other
          invested in Government                               6.    manufacturer or       duties and taxes leviable
          securities upto 5 years in US                              assembler or dealer   thereon and the costs
    2.                                             2%
          dollars denominated bonds with                             in Pakistan           incurred till their
          six-monthly profit payment in                                                    registration.
          equivalent Rupees (rate of return
          3%) and payable on maturity in
                                                                                           B = a sum equal to 10% of
          equivalent Rupees.
                                                                                           the said value for each
    3.    Other assets                             5%                                      successive year upto a
                                                                                           maximum of five years.
The tax so calculated is to be paid along with the                                                   (table continued)
declaration of the assets.

                                                                                                  EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                      7

            Undisclosed                                                 Undisclosed
     S.                        Value for the purpose of         S.                         Value for the purpose of
            income and                                                  income and
    No.                              section 5(2)               No.                              section 5(2)
               assets                                                      assets
                              Value determined in the                                     Market rate as on the 09
                                                                13.   Stock-in-trade
                              manner specified in S.N. 5                                  April 2018
                              or 6, as the case may be,
          Used motor                                                  Plant and           Actual cost of acquisition
                              as reduced by an amount           14.
    7.                                                                machinery           with no depreciation
          vehicles            equal to 10% for every
          purchased locally   year following the year in              Accounts
                              which it was imported or          15.                       Actual cost of acquisition
                                                                      receivable
                              purchased from a
                              manufacturer                      16.   Other assets        Actual cost of acquisition

                              Day-end price of the share              Prize bonds, cash
                              or security quoted on                   and bank
                              registered stock exchange               accounts
                                                                11.                       Face value
                              as on the 9th April, 2018               including foreign
                              and where no day-end                    currency
          Securities and                                              accounts
                              price of such share or
    8.    shares traded on
                              security is quoted on stock
          stock exchange
                              exchange on the 09 April,
                              2018 day-end price of the
                                                            The assets so declared shall be incorporated in the
                              share or security quoted      declarant’s books of accounts. For the purpose of the
                              on a date nearest to the      IT Ordinance it has been provided that the cost of
                              09 April 2018
                                                            acquisition and the date of acquisition of domestic
                              Break-up value or face        assets shall be the value declared by the declarant
                              value, whichever is higher.
                              Breakup value shall be the    and the date on which the declaration has been made,
                              sum of paid-up capital,       respectively.
          Securities and
                              reserves and balance as
          shares not traded
    9.                        per profit and loss account
          on stock                                          2.5 Immunity and Confidentiality
                              as reduced by the value of
          exchange
                              preference shares and
                              divided by the amount of      The LDDA Ordinance provides the following
                              the paid up ordinary share
                              capital                       immunities –

          National saving
          schemes, postal                                      (a) That the declarant would not be required to
          certificates,                                            pay any further tax under any law for the time
          bonds, securities                                        being in force, including the IT Ordinance,
          and other similar
    10.   investments in      Face value                           where the declarant has paid tax on the
          capital                                                  declared assets under the LDDA Ordinance;
          instruments not
          traded or quoted
          on stock                                             (b) That the particulars of the declarant and the
          exchange                                                 information received in the declaration shall
    11.   Gold                Rupees 4000 per gram                 be confidential, notwithstanding the
                              Market rate as on the 09             provisions of section 216 of the IT Ordinance,
    12.
          Other precious      April 2018 or cost of                the Right of Access to Information Act, 2017,
          stones and metals   acquisition, whichever is            and any other law for the time being in force;
                              higher
                                                                   and
                                      (table continued)

                                                                                                 EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                              8

                                                                      to which it related. This has been
     (c) That nothing contained in the declaration                    fundamentally changed with regard to
         shall be admissible as evidence against the                  concealed foreign assets and concealed
         declarant under any other law, including the                 foreign source income.
         IT Ordinance, for the time being in force for
         the purpose of any penalty proceedings, or for           (b) In respect of foreign assets and foreign
         the purpose of prosecution.                                  income, the concept of taxability in the
                                                                      year of acquisition has been replaced with
2.6 Misrepresentation                                                 the ‘year of discovery’, while for income
                                                                      or assets that are not foreign sourced, the
Under the LDDA Ordinance, the immunity provided                       concept of ‘year of acquisition’ remains
shall not apply to a declaration made by                              intact.
misrepresentation or suppression of facts. In such a
case the declaration shall be treated as void.                    (c) This would mean that if the tax authorities
                                                                      have found a person holding foreign
3.   THE INCOME TAX (AMENDMENT) ORDINANCE,                            income or assets, which have not been
     2018                                                             declared, they are now empowered to
                                                                      require such person to file a return in
In order to give effect to the Ordinances above,                      respect of such foreign assets and foreign
amendments have also been made in the I.T.                            income for any prior tax year without any
Ordinance through the Income Tax (Amendment)                          time limitation. For this purpose, section
Ordinance, 2018 (hereinafter referred to as the “Tax                  114 of the Ordinance has suitably been
Amendment Ordinance”) with immediate effect.                          amended authorizing the Commissioner
                                                                      to issue such a notice while recording the
The Tax Amendment Ordinance has amended                               reasons of issuing the notice in writing.
sections 111, 114, 118 and section 182, while a new
section 116A has also been inserted. In addition, the     3.1.2   Limiting the Immunity to Foreign currency
First Schedule to the Ordinance has also been                     repatriation
amended to provide for the rates of tax applicable to
an individual including a salaried individual, and an             (a) In terms of sub-section (4) of section 111,
Association of Persons (“AoP”).                                       any amount of foreign exchange remitted
                                                                      to Pakistan through normal banking
3.1 Unexplained income or assets – Section 111
                                                                      channels and encashed in Pak rupees
3.1.1   Removal of statute of limitation for taxing                   enjoy immunity for income tax purposes
        undeclared foreign assets and income:                         as regards the source. This has now been
                                                                      restricted to Rs.10,000,000 in a tax year.
        (a) Under the provisions of section 111, all
            undeclared, concealed or unexplained                  (b) It is to be noted that since the Tax
            assets were chargeable to tax in the tax                  Amendment Ordinance is effective from
            year to which such amount was related                     the date of its promulgation, the above
            i.e. such discovered income or asset was                  discussed amendments will come into
            to be added to the income of the tax year                 force forthwith. If the Tax Amendment
                                                                      Ordinance is made effective from this tax

                                                                                              EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                9

            year, this would result in lifting the            (b) any foreign assets transferred by the person
            immunity from probe of remittances of                 to any other person during the tax year and
            foreign exchange to Pakistan, exceeding               the consideration for the said transfer; and
            the threshold of Rs.10,000,000 for which
                                                              (c) complete particulars of foreign income, the
            earlier an immunity under section 111(4)
                                                                  expenditure incurred during the tax year and
            of the I.T. Ordinance was in place without
                                                                  the expenditure wholly and necessarily for the
            any limitation.
                                                                  purposes of deriving the said income.
3.2 Foreign income and assets statement – Section
    116A                                                   Like section 116 of the I.T. Ordinance, section 116A
                                                           also empowers the Commissioner to issue a notice to
In terms of section 116 of the Ordinance, a resident       a person (being an individual) who was required to
individual is mandatorily required to file a “Wealth       furnish the ‘Foreign Income and Assets Statement’
Statement” along with the Return of Income for a tax       and has failed to do so, to furnish such a statement
year, declaring therein his total assets and liabilities   on the date specified in the notice. However, the
(including assets held in others’ name) as on the 30th     Commissioner is required to give reasons in writing
day of June preceding the due date for filing of the       on the basis of which he has issued such a notice.
Return of Income. Although the Wealth Statement
was meant to declare all assets and liabilities            It is pertinent to highlight that unlike section 116,
including those held outside Pakistan, the declaration     which authorizes the revision of a Wealth Statement
of foreign assets had been a debate in the past.           (in case where any omission or wrong statement is
                                                           made therein), section 116A does not provide for the
The new section 116A now requires resident persons         revision of the ‘Foreign Income and Assets
who have foreign income or foreign assets, to furnish      Statement’.
a separate statement namely “Foreign Income and
Assets Statement” in addition to filing a Wealth           3.3 Return of income – section 114
Statement under section 116, as discussed above.
The minimum threshold of foreign assets and foreign        As discussed above, section 114 of the I.T. Ordinance
income for filing of the ‘Foreign Income and Assets        has consequently been amended. The amendments in
Statement’ is as follows:                                  section 114 include:

    (a) Foreign income equal to or in excess of USD           (a) a requirement of filing a Return of Income for
        10,000                                                    a person who holds foreign assets or income
    (b) Foreign assets with a value of USD 100,000
        or more                                               (b) the return of income is to be accompanied
                                                                  with the Foreign Income and Assets Statement
The following particulars are to be incorporated in the
‘Foreign Income and Assets Statement’ to be filed by          (c) the exclusion of a time limitation for issuance
the person:                                                       of a notice to a person holding foreign income
                                                                  or assets which have not been declared even
    (a) total foreign assets and liabilities as on the            after promulgation of the Foreign Assets
        last day of the tax year;                                 (Declaration and Repatriation) Ordinance,
                                                                  2018

                                                                                              EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                                        10

3.4 Method of furnishing returns and other                  aligned and reduced significantly to provide relief to
    documents – section 118                                 all individuals. No amendment has been made in the
                                                            rate of tax applicable on AoPs. The newly inserted
Section 118 of the Ordinance has also been amended          table is as follows:
to include reference of section 116A prescribing the
                                                                     Annual Income                    Rate of Tax
filing of a Foreign Income and Assets Statement.
                                                             Less than Rs.1,200,000            0%
                                                             Exceeding Rs.1,200,000            5% of the amount exceeding
3.5 Penalties – section 182
                                                             but less than 2,400,000           Rs.1,200,000
                                                                                               Rs.60,000 + 10% of the
A penalty for failure to file the Foreign Income and         Exceeding Rs.2,400,000
                                                                                               amount exceeding
Assets Statement has also been prescribed. This              but less than 4,800,000
                                                                                               Rs.2,400,000
would be 2% of the value of foreign income or foreign                                          Rs.180,000 + 15% of the
assets as the case may be, for each year of default.         Exceeding Rs.4,800,000            amount exceeding
                                                                                               Rs.4,800,000
3.6 Division I of the First Schedule
                                                            A sample comparison of the tax payable by salaried
Previously, non-salaried individuals were taxed on a        and non-salaried individuals, under the existing rates
higher bracket as compared to salaried individuals.         and the new rates is provided below:
Effective 01 July 2018, the rates of tax applicable on
salaried and non-salaried individuals have been
                                                Salaried Individuals
   Monthly Salary       Annual Salary      Existing Tax        New Tax               Benefit         Percentage of Relief
       100,000           1,200,000             59,500            -                   59,500                    100%
       150,000           1,800,000            137,000           30,000          107,000                          78%
       200,000           2,400,000            242,000           60,000          182,000                          75%
       250,000           3,000,000            359,500         120,000           239,500                          67%
       300,000           3,600,000            497,000         180,000           317,000                          64%
       350,000           4,200,000            652,000         240,000           412,000                          63%
       400,000           4,800,000            817,000         300,000           517,000                          63%
       400,001           4,800,012            817,003         180,002           637,002                          78%
       450,000           5,400,000            982,000         270,000           712,000                          73%
       500,000           6,000,000           1,147,000        360,000           787,000                          69%
       550,000           6,600,000           1,312,000        450,000           862,000                          66%
       600,000           7,200,000           1,482,000        540,000            942,000                         64%
       650,000           7,800,000           1,662,000        630,000          1,032,000                         62%
       700,000           8,400,000           1,842,000        720,000          1,122,000                         61%
     1,000,000          12,000,000           2,922,000      1,260,000          1,662,000                         57%

                                                                                                       EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                                                              11

                                            Non-Salaried Individuals
   Monthly Income       Annual Income      Existing Tax        New Tax          Benefit      Percentage of Relief
          100,000         1,200,000             99,500             -               99,500            100%
          150,000         1,800,000            204,500           30,000           174,500            85%
          200,000         2,400,000            324,500           60,000           264,500            82%
          250,000         3,000,000            469,500          120,000           349,500            74%
          300,000         3,600,000            619,500          180,000           439,500            71%
          350,000         4,200,000            779,500          240,000           539,500            69%
          400,000         4,800,000            959,500          300,000           659,500            69%
          400,001         4,800,012            959,503          180,002           779,502            81%
          450,000         5,400,000          1,139,500          270,000           869,500            76%
          500,000         6,000,000          1,319,500          360,000           959,500            73%
          550,000         6,600,000          1,529,500          450,000         1,079,500            71%
          600,000         7,200,000          1,739,500          540,000         1,199,500            69%
          650,000         7,800,000          1,949,500          630,000         1,319,500            68%
          700,000         8,400,000          2,159,500          720,000         1,439,500            67%
        1,000,000        12,000,000          3,419,500         1,260,000        2,159,500            63%

Based on the above sample calculations, there             Since the amendments have increased the threshold
appears to be an inadvertent error in the base tax        of income subject to tax to Rs. 1.2 million, this clause
amount for annual income exceeding Rs. 4,800,000.         now appears to be redundant.
Such base tax has been calculated at Rs. 180,000 in
the new table, whereas the tax on a person earning        4.    THE PROTECTION OF ECONOMIC REFORMS
Rs. 4,800,000 actually amounts to Rs. 300,000.                  (AMENDMENT) ORDINANCE, 2018

In view of the above, based on the new table, a           The Ordinance is stated to come into force at once.
change of income from 4,800,000 to 4,800,001
would result in a reduction of tax payable by             A significant amendment has been made in sub
approximately Rs. 120,000. This appears to be a           section (4) of section 5 of the Protection of Economic
calculation mistake in the newly inserted table and       Reforms Act, 1992 having effect notwithstanding
should, in our view, be corrected.                        anything contained in the Foreign Currency Accounts
                                                          (Protection) Ordinance, 2001.
Additionally, the amendments have retained the
provisions of clause 3 which provides a 50% reduction     Under the existing provisions, the deposits in and
in the tax liability of taxpayers who hold a              withdrawals from foreign currency accounts can be
Computerized National Identity Card for disabled          made without any restriction from the State Bank of
persons or those who are of the age of sixty years, or    Pakistan or any other bank.
above, on the first day of the tax year, provided that
the annual income of such taxpayers, other than their     Through this amendment, a proviso has now been
income on which the deduction of tax is final, does       inserted in terms of which a restriction has been
not exceed Rs. 1 million.                                 provided whereby only a “Filer” (as defined under the

                                                                                               EY Ford Rhodes
Tax Alert – Economic and Tax Reforms Package 2018                    12

I.T. Ordinance) is allowed to deposit cash in a foreign
currency account.

This would mean that the immunity from probe
available to any person under the Protection of
Economic Reforms Act, 1992 with respect to deposits
in the foreign currency account is now only available
to “Filers”.

The Protection of Economic Reforms Act, 1992 is
enacted in order to provide legal protection to
citizens of Pakistan in respect of transactions carried
out in foreign currency accounts. We understand that
in order to implement the restrictions with regard to
cash deposits, corresponding amendments would also
be made in the relevant banking regulations.

                                                          EY Ford Rhodes
Caveat

This Alert provides a brief on the significant amendments proposed by the Foreign Assets (Declaration and
Repatriation) Ordinance, 2018, the Local Declaration of Domestic Assets Ordinance, 2018, the Income Tax
(Amendment) Ordinance, 2018 and the Protection of Economic Reforms (Amendment) Ordinance, 2018. Our
comments herein provide a general overview and do not in any manner or form constitute an opinion or advice
that may be relied on. Our comments are based on the law as applicable on the date of this Alert. The tax laws
are subject to changes from time to time and, as such, any changes therein may affect the comments contained
in this Alert.

We are not under an obligation to update our comments for events and circumstances occurring after the date of
this Alert. Further, our comments are a matter of interpretation of law and are based on our experience with the
tax authorities. Accordingly, it cannot be said with certainty that the comments expressed above will be accepted
by the tax authorities.

We do not, in giving these comments, accept or assume responsibility for any other purpose or to any other
person to whom these comments are shown or in whose hands it may come, unless expressly agreed by us in
writing.

                                                                                               EY Ford Rhodes
You can also read