SHIPPING MARKET REVIEW - MAY 2021 - Danish Ship ...

Page created by Ken Murray
 
CONTINUE READING
SHIPPING MARKET REVIEW - MAY 2021 - Danish Ship ...
SHIPPING MARKET REVIEW – MAY 2021
SHIPPING MARKET REVIEW - MAY 2021 - Danish Ship ...
DISCLAIMER
The persons named as the authors of this report hereby certify that: (i) all of the views expressed in the research
report accurately reflect the personal views of the authors on the subjects; and (ii) no part of their compensation was,
is, or will be, directly or indirectly, related to the specific recommendations or views expressed in the research report.
This report has been prepared by Danish Ship Finance A/S (“DSF”).
This report is provided to you for information purposes only. Whilst every effort has been taken to make the
information contained herein as reliable as possible, DSF does not represent the information as accurate or
complete, and it should not be relied upon as such. Any opinions expressed reflect DSF’s judgment at the time this
report was prepared and are subject to change without notice. DSF will not be responsible for the consequences of
reliance upon any opinion or statement contained in this report. This report is based on information obtained from
sources which DSF believes to be reliable, but DSF does not represent or warrant such information’s accuracy,
completeness, timeliness, merchantability or fitness for a particular purpose. The information in this report is not
intended to predict actual results, and actual results may differ substantially from forecasts and estimates provided in
this report. This report may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, without the prior written permission of DSF. To
Non-Danish residents: The contents hereof are intended for the use of non-private customers and may not be issued
or passed on to any person and/or institution without the prior written consent of DSF. Additional information
regarding this publication will be furnished upon request.

                                                                                                                             Shipping Market Review – May 2021   1
HEAD OF INNOVATION & RESEARCH
Christopher Rex, rex@skibskredit.dk

ANALYTICAL TEAM
Jonas Hoffmann, Senior Analyst
Sebastian Müllertz, Analyst
Pardeep Singh, Analyst
Stasia Winther, Junior Analyst

                                      Shipping Market Review – May 2021   2
TABLE OF CONTENTS
Fast forward, 4

Shipping Markets At A Glance, 13

Shipbuilding, 18

Container, 20

Dry Bulk, 27

Crude Tanker, 35

Product Tanker, 43

LPG Carriers, 50

                                   Shipping Market Review – May 2021   3
FAST FORWARD
Commercial levers for decarbonising the shipping industry

                                                            Shipping Market Review – May 2021   4
VESSELS COULD BECOME A CATALYST FOR CHANGE
The commercial levers facilitating decarbonisation could outpace global regulation

A transition to carbon neutrality in      large-scale fleet renewal programmes      allow new services to grow which, at
the shipping industry is possible. The    in place. Most seem to be waiting to      some point, may disintermediate the
industry is making progress with          see how the regulatory framework          traditional operator that delivers
existing     assets    and      known     plays out, as well as the selection of    transportation from A to B.
technologies but will at some point       the zero-carbon fuel of the future.
                                                                                    Existing owners and operators are
need to introduce zero-carbon fuels.
                                          THE COMPETITIVE LANDSCAPE                 working to transform themselves.
Hybrid-electric   and     hydrogen-       The next generation of zero-carbon        Few elements of the current industry
powered vessels could contribute          vessels could be owned by entities        structures are likely to remain
greatly to the short-sea shipping         that benefit not only from lower          untouched by the waves created by
industry reaching the next stage of       costs, but also from additional           the call to decarbonise.
efficiency.                               streams of revenue.
                                                                                    COMMERCIAL FORCES AT PLAY
For deep-sea shipping, the bulk of        We invite you to imagine a scenario       There is much discussion in the          Vessels-as-a-service
emissions need to be eliminated by        where vessels could be supplied to        shipping industry about the need for
switching to a zero-carbon fuel.          the market as-a-service.                  additional     global     regulation,   brings more value per
Existing players are burdened by          Over time, this could result in radical
                                                                                    (government) subsidies and carbon
                                                                                    taxes in one form or another. The
                                                                                                                               moved unit than
legacy assets that are hard to            changes to revenues and margins for
upgrade to a degree where additional      ship-owning companies. The entire
                                                                                    goal is to level the playing field to
                                                                                    enable the green transition to take
                                                                                                                             traditional shipping
value potential can be developed.         competitive landscape could be up for
                                                                                    off.
                                          review if vessels-as-a-service become
Many will simply upgrade existing
                                          the new norm in the shipping              In this report, we focus on the
vessels to extend their lifetimes while
                                          industry.                                 commercial forces of change that
hoping to enjoy another period of
                                                                                    could drive some aspects of the
higher freight rates and secondhand       We see multiple pathways towards
                                                                                    industry’s decarbonisation efforts.
prices.                                   vessels-as-a-service, but they all
                                          require consolidation and scale to
The risk of stranded assets will                                                    We invite our readers to imagine
                                          unlock    the    value   potential   of
become more apparent when new                                                       some quite fundamental changes to
                                          transport-as-a-service (i.e. the data
vessels burning zero-carbon fuels are                                               asset ownership and the competitive
                                          potential     from     supply     chain
delivered.                                                                          landscape.
                                          integration).
Few owners currently seem to have
                                          The benefits of vessel sharing could

                                                                                                                                   Shipping Market Review – May 2021   5
WILL MANY PLAYERS NEED TO TRANSFORM THEMSELVES?
Resetting the destination or navigating a new route?

                                                  Many shipowners currently seem to        medium-sized          owners       are   further via lower speeds or by
                                                  be postponing major investment           increasingly struggling to upgrade       blending conventional fossil fuels
                                                  decisions until a clearer pathway to     their digital capabilities to continue   with, for example, biofuels. These
                                                  the future becomes visible. Existing     bringing down costs and leverage         measures     are   hardly long-term
                                                  vessels are being retrofitted to lower   data to boost value generation.          solutions, though.
                                                  their emissions and make them
                                                                                           Market leaders are actively seeking      Fleets do not have much potential for
                                                  compliant with the upcoming new
                                                                                           additional revenue sources and ways      additional value creation. Vessels are,
                                                  environmental regulation.
                                                                                           to improve operational efficiency in     in general, non-standardised and
                                                  The     short-term market    outlook     order to lower costs. Many traditional   offer little scope for economies of
                                                  signals that many vessel segments        owners seem to be ‘going asset light’;   scale or valuable pools of data that
   The fuel transition could                      could enjoy another cycle of higher      few are exploring ways to maximise       can be monetised, even by the

  become an unprecedented                         freight     rates  and    increasing
                                                  secondhand prices in the years to
                                                                                           asset monetisation.                      largest     and    most   consolidated
                                                                                                                                    entities. The risk of stranded assets
                                                                                           There is a clear trend of increased
    business opportunity to                       come.
                                                                                           digital adaptation. So far, this has
                                                                                                                                    will increase in the coming years.

   create value significantly                     DECARBONISATION STRATEGIES
                                                  The call to decarbonise the industry
                                                                                           mostly been targeted at reducing
                                                                                           costs, while other industries have
                                                                                                                                    We see strong value potential for
                                                                                                                                    vessel owners that harvests not only
   beyond freight rates and                       could be a game changer. For some        managed to create new digital            significant cost savings but also
                                                  players, switching fuels may simply      business     models   that    deliver    manages to introduce additional
         the asset play                           be an operational challenge that         additional value.                        streams of revenue.
                                                  needs to be solved alongside the
                                                                                           NAVIGATING LEGACY ASSETS                 Vessel ownership models seem to be
                                                  issue of paying the green premium.
                                                                                           The number of straightforward levers     approaching a fork in the road: one
                                                  For others, the fuel transition could    that can be applied to existing          path leads to reinvention and
                                                  become an unprecedented business         vessels is limited. Only around 20-      potential long-term value generation,
                                                  opportunity      to    create    value   30% of emissions can be reduced          while the other means high volatility
                                                  significantly beyond freight rates and   through cost-efficiency levers such      and cyclicality continuing.
                                                  the asset play.                          as improved vessel design, more
                                                                                           efficient  operations   and   better
                                                  The shipping industry is approaching
                                                                                           routing.
                                                  a tipping point. Asset owning is
                                                  becoming more complex. Small and         The fleet’s emissions can be reduced

                                                                                                                                          Shipping Market Review – May 2021   6
EMBRACING A NEW-GENERATION OPERATING MODEL
Radical simplification and new capabilities

Digitalisation has never been the end      markets.                                  Imagine that some shipowners and
game but rather a means for                                                          new investors see great value
                                           The spark of decarbonisation could
developing new value drivers and                                                     potential in a framework where the
                                           initiate major changes in the shipping
new business models.                                                                 zero-carbon challenge is melded with
                                           industry’s competitive landscape.
                                                                                     a new     digital business model for
The shipping industry has yet to
                                           Zero-carbon fuels present a classic       vessel ownership.
identify  and commercialise new
                                           chicken-and-egg     problem     across
value drivers and new business                                                       Additional value can be created by
                                           industries. Decarbonisation is a global
models.                                                                              players that superscale and package
                                           challenge facing all industries and
                                                                                     levers    such   as  standardisation,
Experience from other industries           sectors of the economy, not just
                                                                                     economies of scale, digitalisation and
suggests that additional value can be      maritime players.
created if we reinvent the business
                                                                                     circularity into a redesigned ‘as-a-         In a digital future,
                                           Solving these issues represents an        service’ business model for vessel
models and allow more value to be
                                           extraordinary business opportunity to     ownership.                                   competition will no
created by opening the gates to a
broader ecosystem play that includes
                                           be tackled within the next decade.
                                                                                     Large-scale     asset     and     data    longer depend solely on
not only OEMs, shipyards and fuel
producers but also the connecting
                                           But the shipping industry typically       standardisation will allow costs to be
                                                                                     reduced and the data extraction from
                                                                                                                                 products or process
                                           generates low profits relative to the
industries and sectors across the          emissions it creates. Small and           the operation of the vessels to be        excellence but rather on
global supply chain.                       medium-sized ship owners may be
                                           finding little room for manoeuvre.
                                                                                     monetised.
                                                                                                                                   business models
In a digital future, competition will no                                             The initial market effect may be
longer depend solely on products or        NEW INVESTORS                             marginal but over a decade or more
process excellence but rather on           The shipping industry may not be a        could    evolve     into     a     true
business models.                           major attraction for investors looking    gamechanger.     Traditional    owners
                                           for a play on decarbonisation but         could find it increasingly difficult to
The idea behind a digital business
                                           could become so if the industry can       compete.
model for vessel ownership is not
                                           transform itself into a catalyst for
only to lower costs significantly, but
                                           change in the industries being
also to introduce additional streams
                                           served.
of revenue that can create value
beyond the boundaries of the freight

                                                                                                                                       Shipping Market Review – May 2021   7
HOW DO WE CREATE ADDITIONAL VALUE FROM DECARBONISATION?
We need growth potentials that can be scaled and monetised

                                                The task of creating value from the       NEW VALUE DRIVERS                        The vessel-as-a-service delivers value
                                                zero-carbon challenge in a framework      In the shipping industry, this could     to shareholders not only through
                                                of a new digital business model for       become possible for first movers that    freight rates but just as importantly
                                                vessel ownership is virgin territory.     can guarantee a large-scale offtake of   through the price difference on the
                                                                                          the fuel that allows producers to        price of a zero-carbon fuel.
                                                We do not have all the answers or a
                                                                                          scale production beyond current
                                                clear picture of the future, but we                                                First movers may attain a competitive
                                                                                          market maturity. The case becomes
                                                invite our readers to consider                                                     edge by offering zero-carbon vessel-
                                                                                          even stronger if resources are pooled
                                                alternatives to the status quo.                                                    as-a-service to customers while also
                                                                                          across industries and sectors (i.e.
                                                                                                                                   profiting from trading surplus zero-
                                                Imagine that the expected price           sector integration).
       Consider a scenario                      reduction from super-scaling the
                                                                                          First movers may secure long-term
                                                                                                                                   carbon fuel volumes to players that
                                                                                                                                   have inadequate or no direct access
    where some parts of the                     production of a zero-carbon fuel could
                                                be turned into a value pool that
                                                                                          purchase agreements (ten or 15           to the fuel.
                                                                                          years) with producers that allow
      shipping industry are                     directly  relates   to   the    vessel
                                                                                          them to buy the fuel at a significant
                                                                                                                                   This strategy is clearly not risk free.
                                                investment.                                                                        Much can go wrong. But the potential
     carved out by players                                                                discount to the market price.
                                                                                                                                   reward could be massive.
                                                The development within solar and
     that earn their money                      wind     energy   has    shown   that
                                                                                          NEW BUSINESS MODELS
                                                                                          Imagine the creation of a large and
       outside the freight                      production costs can be significantly
                                                                                          super-standardised fleet of vessels
                                                reduced      when     production   is
             markets                            sufficiently scaled. Some studies
                                                                                          supplied to the market as a service
                                                                                          (including fuel).
                                                suggest that production costs can
                                                decline by as much as 60%, 70% or         Recall the concept of urban mobility
                                                even 80% over a ten-year period.          services, which charge a fixed, all-
                                                                                          inclusive price per minute in traffic
                                                By bundling the investment in new
                                                                                          (i.e. car ownership, fuel, parking,
                                                vessels with the profit potential in
                                                                                          maintenance, etc.). If the mobility
                                                offering green transportation below
                                                                                          provider is able to buy the energy at
                                                market price (i.e. leveraging the
                                                                                          a lower cost than it charges the user,
                                                expected reduction in production
                                                                                          then value is also created from the
                                                costs   of    a   zero-carbon    fuel),
                                                                                          price arbitrage of the fuel.
                                                additional value can be created.

                                                                                                                                         Shipping Market Review – May 2021   8
CIRCULARITY COULD BRING DOWN THE GREEN PREMIUM
It will take more than a zero-carbon fuel to decarbonise the shipping industry

Consolidated    fleets  of     super-    their used parts to the manufacturer.     long-payback investments.
standardised    vessels   offer    an    In a model where standardised fleets
                                                                                   The asset game does not form part of
attractive business case for circular    of vessels supply vessels-as-a-service
                                                                                   a servitisation model that aims to
maintenance, as spare parts can be       at a fixed all-inclusive price per
                                                                                   improve the long-term efficiency of
remanufactured, reused and recycled      ‘minute      in     traffic’,  circular
                                                                                   the   assets    rather  than   take
multiple times to save costs (and        maintenance adds value by lowering
                                                                                   advantage of short-term market
reduce the environmental footprint).     costs.
                                                                                   imbalances.
This becomes particularly interesting    In the future, all elements of a
                                                                                   The    servitisation   model     allows
in a servitisation model, where          vessel, its maintenance and its
                                                                                   investments with long repayment
equipment    manufacturers      extend   demolition could be designed for
                                                                                   periods to be made – maybe even
their business to include the use of     circularity. All    materials    and
                                                                                   stretching to the next lifetime.
their equipment instead of selling it.   components    could   be    recycled,
                                         remanufactured and reused.                REDUCED RISK OF STRANDED ASSETS
                                                                                                                             Savings are partly passed on
In this case, the data extraction from
operating the standardised fleet of      Increased customer loyalty could be
                                                                                   The risk of stranded assets is reduced    to customers to ensure that
                                                                                   in a servitisation model, since
vessels becomes valuable, since it
allows the equipment manufacturer
                                         obtained through the channel of cost-
                                         competitive             carbon-neutral
                                                                                   equipment manufacturers are able to       they turn in their used parts
to improve performance and optimise      operations (cradle-to-cradle).
                                                                                   upgrade the performance of a vessel
                                                                                   as long as they do not increase the
                                                                                                                                 to the manufacturer
the vessel.
                                         REINVENTING THE BUSINESS MODEL            cost of its use.
CIRCULAR VALUE CREATION                  This kind of change will require not
Circular maintenance is not new.         only shipowners but also equipment
Many companies have experimented         manufacturers to change their go-to-
with    refurbishing, reusing and        market model to one that sells ‘time
recycling their used products and        in traffic’ rather than a product.
parts.
                                         Many vessels are currently operated
Industry players like Renault and        under a business model where the
Caterpillar have worked with these       asset play guides decision making.
principles for the past 30 years.        Retrofits and operational upgrades
                                         are done if they deliver immediate
Savings are partly passed on to
                                         cost savings without the need for
customers to ensure that they turn in

                                                                                                                                       Shipping Market Review – May 2021   9
CIRCULAR VALUE CREATION

Three levels of circularity

1. Maintenance (e.g. spare parts)

2. Vessel ownership (cradle-to-cradle)

3. Cargo volumes (customer loyalty)

                                                      Shipping Market Review – May 2021   10
WHAT COULD CHANGES LOOK LIKE?
Shared vessel capacity

                               To maximise the benefits of a             low-priced utility.                      fundamental changes to not only the
                               servitisation model, vessel ownership                                              business model of vessel ownership
                                                                         Players can create additional value
                               could be aggregated across fewer                                                   but also the competitive landscape.
                                                                         even when competing with the
                               entities, even across ship segments.
                                                                         lowest-priced alternative, because       So far, we have discussed a
                               Vessel    operation    could   remain     the new supply and the traditional       centralised ownership model whereby
                               fragmented but may over time              vessel supply do not have the same       individual operators manage and
                               consolidate    in   line   with   the     value drivers.                           employ individual fleets of vessels.
                               application of new technologies that                                               But could we take it even further?
                                                                         Traditional players generate income
                               are likely to reduce margins and
                                                                         through freight rates, while players     Could there be a scenario where
                               increase competition.
                                                                         operating with the new business          individual operators simply book
      Individual operators     Circularity relates not only to the       model can generate revenue from          cargo transportation on vessels
                               vessels but can also be expanded to       freight rates, trading of zero-carbon    shared between many to optimise
         booking cargo         encompass the industries being            fuels and the data exhaust from          capacity utilisation and reduce their
                               served by the vessels.                    vessel operation.                        environmental footprint?
   transportation on vessels
                               To illustrate the potential, consider a   Traditional players may struggle to      Experience from other industries (the
     shared between many       case where an ecosystem player            compete on costs, since the new          telecommunications    industry,    for
                               works     to    connect    the   global   players can reduce costs via circular    example) suggests that structural
                               construction sector with the Dry Bulk     maintenance and economies of scale       separation can allow more value to
                               industry to facilitate not only the       while offering additional services       be created if infrastructure sharing
                               transportation of virgin materials but    through     the   advanced    vessel     allows massive scaling on a larger
                               also circular material flows.             connectivity system that has been        customer base.
                                                                         scaled    across    the  centralised
                               This type of ecosystem play could
                                                                         ownership base.
                               become a catalyst for change not
                               only in the shipping industry but also    The borders of industries, the role of
                               in the industries being served.           assets and the types of competitors
                                                                         are likely to change.
                               A PREMIUM PRODUCT AT SCALE
                               The    vessel-as-a-service concept        GREATER ADDRESSABLE MARKET
                               allows a premium product to be            We describe      here   the potential
                               supplied to shipping markets as a         introduction     of     some   quite

                                                                                                                        Shipping Market Review – May 2021   11
INFRASTRUCTURE SHARING
Transport-as-a-service: growing beyond the core

Infrastructure sharing is nothing new     The aim will be to create a fully            Companies in other industries are
in    the  shipping   industry.  Many     integrated        transport-as-a-service     aggressively generating value from
segments utilise the benefits of          transit system that includes a digital       data.
operational pools, while the Container    platform, access to the latest cargo
                                                                                       The vessel-as-a-service model will
industry also shares capacity through     mobility offerings, incentives (e.g.
                                                                                       allow players to focus on data
alliances. Freight forwarders and         lower costs, zero-carbon mobility,
                                                                                       monetisation throughout the lifecycle
trading houses provide services that      transparency), and measurement tools
                                                                                       of vessels through recurring revenues
benefit from economies of scale by        (including CO2) to ensure that all
                                                                                       and paid over-the-air upgrades, which
bringing together the demands of          transport services are running at full
                                                                                       may eventually include those related
multiple customers.                       efficiency. The objective will be to fully
                                                                                       to autonomous vessel capabilities.
                                          integrate and orchestrate all available
The main difference between past
experience and the vision described
                                          services throughout the global supply
                                          chain, from origin to destination.
                                                                                       In today’s market, the absence of an
                                                                                       established ecosystem often results in
                                                                                                                                  Infrastructure sharing allows
here is asset owners’ ability to scale
and harvest economies of scale            This will involve increasing integration
                                                                                       hard-to-scale island solutions between     digital investments to target
(through standardisation) and to          across the modes of cargo mobility
                                                                                       few players, which end up generating
                                                                                       significantly less value than they would
                                                                                                                                   value creation beyond the
establish a critical asset base that      and    infrastructure   operators   and
allows major investments in new           ensuring that providers can collect all
                                                                                       have done with a scaled solution.           boundaries of the shipping
digital technologies.                     the data they need to establish                                                                    industry
                                          transport options that direct cargo
TRANSPORT-AS-A-SERVICE
                                          flows toward the most efficient and
Initial investments will be aimed at
                                          environmentally sound sourcing and
increasing operational efficiency and
                                          travel modes.
routing (in order to lower fuel
consumption), but the focus will soon     DATA DRIVES VALUE GENERATION
shift to moving into adjacent domains     Experience from       other industries
to     establish   a    platform-based    suggests that the service play that is
ecosystem play that orchestrates data-    fuelled by the data from operating the
driven insights across supply chains to   standardised asset base could become
optimize value creation and develop       at least as valuable as the asset
new revenue streams.                      operation.

                                                                                                                                            Shipping Market Review – May 2021   12
SHIPPING MARKETS AT A GLANCE

                               Shipping Market Review – May 2021   13
SHIPPING MARKETS AT A GLANCE
Market sentiment is weakening, but we see light at the end of the tunnel                                                                           DS:FUNDAMENTALS
Seaborne trade volumes are suffering from the effects of the pandemic, while fleets have          MARKET CYCLE POSITION – APRIL 2021
been expanding. The supply side is becoming more manageable, but the orderbook is                                                    Freight rates are well above the median, and
heavily frontloaded. Capacity equivalent to 4.2% of the fleet is scheduled to be delivered                                            have increased by 62% in the past 6 months
during 2021, while demand is only likely to regain the lost territory. Seaborne trade
                                                                                                     [Secondhand prices 2017:2021]
volumes are expected to grow more strongly than the fleet from 2022, which, combined
with older, less efficient vessels being scrapped, should improve freight rates and
                                                                                                   Min                                           Median                                    Max
secondhand prices. The market outlook for 2023 and beyond clearly depends on future                [0%]                                          [50%]                                 [100%]
contracting, but signs are that fleet availability will tighten, since older vessels are likely                                                                             Period [2000:2021]

to slow steam or be scrapped.                                                                                                  Secondhand prices are just above the median,
                                                                                                                               and have increased by 40% in the past 6 months

CLARKSEA INDEX AND SECONDHAND PRICES                                                              Global demand for seaborne trade contracted by 3.6% in 2020, but travel
The ClarkSea Index was anchored at around USD 15,000 per day for large parts of 2020              distances increased by 2%, absorbing some of the decline. Fleet utilisation
but surged to USD 22,000 in April 2021. Current earning levels are in the top 20%                 weakened during the period, since the world fleet grew by 3.1%. Vessel supply
observed since 2010. The average secondhand price dropped to its lowest level in 3.5              was slightly reduced by slower speeds (-1%), but the effect was somewhat offset
years in October 2020 but has since gained 38% and reached index 120 in April 2021.               by more vessels returning from docking (+0.5%).
Secondhand prices are currently in the top 30% seen since 2000.

The improved earnings environment has            freight rates and secondhand prices, while       Deliveries decreased by 10% in 2020                Activity has surged during 1Q2021.
impacted the secondhand prices of older          Tanker markets are struggling to exit the        versus 2019, with 87 million dwt
vessels the most.                                doldrums. Freight rates and secondhand           added to the fleet. The inflow of new              The orderbook is up by 7 million dwt
                                                                                                  vessels continued to soften during the             (since January 2021) and now
                                                 prices have weakened, although we are
The risk of seaborne demand peaking is on                                                         first 2 months of 2021, when 14                    represents 7.8% of the fleet.
                                                 seeing some degree of improvement.               million dwt was delivered.
the rise across industries and sectors. This                                                                                                         Seaborne trade volumes hardly
is beginning to weigh on long-term               Markets for Gas Carriers are highly              Scrapping intensified in 2020 with 23              increased during 2019 and shrank by
earnings expectations not only for vessels       volatile. Players are struggling to absorb a     million dwt scrapped (54% more than                3.6% in 2020. Longer travel distances
transporting fossil fuels but also for large     supply surplus that is expected to widen         in 2019). The average scrapping age                absorbed some of the decline.
Container vessels, Car Carriers and              further during 2021. The smaller vessels         dropped by 4 months to 27.7 years
                                                                                                  from 2019 to 2020, and was stabile in              Distance-adjusted vessel demand
Offshore-related vessels.                        are better positioned than the larger ones.                                                         decreased for Crude and Product
                                                                                                  the first quarter of 2021.
                                                                                                                                                     Tankers and Containers in 2020, while
Dry Bulk and Container vessels are               Offshore-related vessels are in significant      Contracting activity declined by 25%               Dry Bulk, LPG and LNG managed to
currently experiencing strong growth in          oversupply.                                      in 2020. 54 million dwt was ordered,               expand volumes and increase travel
                                                                                                  compared to 72 million dwt in 2019.                distances.

                                                                                                                                                               Shipping Market Review – May 2021   14
STRONG INFLOW OF NEW VESSELS DOMINATES THE SHORT-TERM OUTLOOK
But the orderbook is rapidly emptying
The supply side is becoming more manageable, as the                               during 2021. This reflects the consolidation process that is                     The imbalance between supply and demand is raising
orderbook is shrinking quickly while few new vessels are                          shaping the yard industry. Many of the smaller yards are                         expectations for scrapping of older, less efficient vessels
being ordered. Still, the short-term outlook is for                               quickly running out of employment.                                               across segments. The sooner capacity is taken out of
significant fleet expansion.                                                                                                                                       service, the better the remaining vessels will fare.
                                                                                  Three vessel segments are maintaining extraordinarily
The orderbook represents 7.8% of the fleet, and 57% of                            large orderbooks: LNG, LPG and large Container vessels.                          Surplus vessel capacity cannot be absorbed by scrapping
the vessels on order (40% of capacity) are scheduled for                          These segments do not have exceptionally strong demand                           vessels older than 25 years alone. In 2022, economic
delivery in 2021. 85% of the current orderbook is                                 outlooks. If demolition does not take off, these segments                        lifetimes could drop in segments where younger, less
scheduled for delivery before year-end 2022.                                      could be heading for a difficult period of low income and                        efficient vessels are demolished to balance the market.
                                                                                  depreciating secondhand prices.
The world fleet is projected to take delivery of new vessels                                                                                                       The effect is only expected to be temporary. The low
with a capacity equivalent to 4.2% of the fleet in 2021 and                       Seaborne trade volumes are working to regain the lost                            contracting activity, combined with increased demand,
2.8% in 2022.                                                                     territory but are not expected to return to 2019 levels until                    creates potential for higher freight rates and secondhand
                                                                                  late 2021. Crude and Product Tankers are not expected to                         prices sometime after 2022. The duration of the upturn
The ten largest yard groups control more than 80% of the
                                                                                  recover until 2022.                                                              depends on future contracting activity.
orderbook but will deliver only 40% of their orderbook
ACTUAL AND EXPECTED DELIVERIES                 (MILLION DWT)                      FLEET RENEWAL POTENTIAL               (DWT)                                      DELIVERIES AND OUT FOR SPECIAL SURVEY                    (MILLION DWT)
120                                                                          6%    5                                                                               160
                     5%
                                                                                            Fleet renewal
                                                                                            Orderbook / Fleet (20 yr+) dwt
                                 5%
                                                                                                                                                   Container
       4%                                     4%
                                                                                                                                                     Liner
 90                                                                          5%    4                                                                               120

                                                           3%
 60                                                                          3%    3                                                                                80

                                                                     1%                                                       Crude Tanker
 30                                                                          2%    1                                                                                40
                                                                                             Bulk Carrier                                              LPG

                                                                                                                    Product Tanker
                                                                                       Chemical Tanker                  Container Feeder
                                                                                                                                             Orderbook / Fleet
  0                                                                          0%    0                                                                                 0
       2018          2019        2020         2021         2022     2023               0%                   5%               10%             15%             20%          2021     2021             2022     2022               2023      2023
      Bulk Carrier          Chemical Tanker    Container          Crude Tanker                                                                                           Fifth survey 25YR+   Fourth survey 20YR    Third survey 15YR    Deliveries
      LPG                   Product Tanker     Orderbook
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Source: Clarksons, Drewry, Danish Ship Finance

                                                                                                                                                                                                      Shipping Market Review – May 2021                     15
DEEP DIVE: ARE WE APPROACHING A PERIOD OF LOWER VESSEL AVAILABILITY?
The IMO may be supporting a market recovery by bringing forward phase 3 of the EEDI
Many of the major shipping segments are burdened by            increasing their fuel efficiency and reducing speeds if        The performance level will be recorded in the ship’s Ship
structural overcapacity that is somehow being absorbed         competition allows it. This applies beyond the boundaries      Energy Efficiency Management Plan (SEEMP).
by slow steaming.                                              of new regulation.
                                                                                                                              A ship rated D or E for three consecutive years will have
Container, Dry Bulk, Crude and Product Tankers are slow        NEW REGULATION SUPPORTS THE MARKET OUTLOOK                     to submit a corrective action plan, to show how the
steaming to reduce costs and curb the market effects of a      The International Maritime Organization (IMO) is working       required index (C or above) will be achieved.
structural supply surplus. Vessels have on average             to develop and implement new regulation aimed at
reduced speeds by between 18% and 25% compared to              reducing the carbon dioxide (CO2) intensity of the
their 2008 levels.                                             shipping industry by at least 40% from 2008 levels by
                                                               2030 and lowering absolute GHG emissions to at least
There is little doubt that the call to decarbonise the
                                                               50% below 2008 levels by 2050.
shipping industry is currently reducing the short-term
appetite for ordering new vessels while supporting the         In 2020, additional measures were approved to further
demolition of older, less efficient vessels in the coming      reduce the industry’s carbon footprint. The new regulation
years.                                                         require ships to combine a technical and an operational
                                                               approach to reduce their carbon intensity.
A PERIOD OF SIGNIFICANT VALUE CREATION
If this trend gains momentum, it may create a foundation       From 2023, the Energy Efficiency Design Index (EEDI) will
for significant value creation, if only for a period. We see   be applied to all existing cargo and Cruise ships above a
potential for this developing from 2023 and lasting for a      certain size, regardless of year of build, and is intended
period of maybe three to five years.                           as a one-off certification. This is to be known as the
                                                               Energy Efficiency Design Index for Existing Ships (EEXI).
Additional slow steaming is widely considered an
attractive short-term mechanism to further reduce the          A mandatory Carbon Intensity Indicator (CII) is to be
industry’s CO2 emissions while absorbing the inflow of         introduced, measuring grams of CO2 per dwt-mile.
new vessels to be delivered in 2021 and 2022.                  Vessels will obtain a rating from A to E every year. In
                                                               accordance with the EEDI (and EEXI), the rating
Vessel speed and fuel consumption are closely linked.
                                                               thresholds will become increasingly stringent towards
Engine load is proportional to the cube of vessel speed —
                                                               2030.
meaning that a 10% decrease in the cruise speed reduces
fuel usage by almost 30%.                                      The CII will determine the annual reduction factor needed
                                                               to ensure continuous improvement of a vessel’s
Fuel represents by far the largest share of operational
                                                               operational carbon intensity within a specific rating level.
costs, which gives operators an intrinsic motive for

                                                                                                                                                        Shipping Market Review – May 2021   16
DEEP DIVE (CONTINUING): THE CASE FOR ACTION IS CLEAR
Older, less efficient vessels are likely to be scrapped in the coming years
MARKET IMPACT UNCLEAR                                         are already operating below the de facto speed limit          It is for these older vessels where the regulation may well
The likely impact on the market of the implementation of      implied by the required EPL. This means that the              incentivise owners to look at recycling, rather than
the EEXI and the Carbon Intensity Indicator is unclear.       effectiveness of technical efficiency measures like the       investing in vessel upgrades.
                                                              EEXI needs to be evaluated in real-world conditions.
Early calculations suggest that only a small part of the                                                                    Vessel supply could be squeezed either temporarily when
world fleet is likely to comply without any reduction in      In 2021, Containers, Oil Tankers, and Bulk Carriers have      vessels exit service to be retrofitted or permanently when
engine power from their designed levels. Some estimates       on average been operating at between 11 knots and 14          vessels are scrapped prematurely.
suggest that half the fleet will have to make some            knots, or between 38% and 50% of their maximum
                                                                                                                            LIMITED SHORT-TERM EFFECTS
energy-efficiency adjustments by installing energy-           continuous rating (MCR). This is well below the engine
                                                                                                                            The upcoming regulation sends a clear signal to the
efficiency retrofits, imposing main engine power              loads that would be allowable under the EEXI, which
                                                                                                                            market but could, in some segments, prove relatively
limitation, using new fuel blends with a lower carbon         range from 65% to 77% of MCR. If the EEXI does not
                                                                                                                            ineffective in the first few years after implementation.
content or through early retirement.                          limit engine power below what ships are already
                                                              operating at, it will not result in reductions of vessels’    We could see a situation where market base measures
Main engine power limitation (EPL), a semi-permanent,
                                                              speeds or CO2 emissions.                                      have a similar impact before the new regulation takes
overridable limit on a ship’s maximum power, is believed
                                                                                                                            effect from 2023.
to be the easiest way for older ships to meet EEXI            OLDER AND LESS EFFICIENT VESSELS WILL BE IMPACTED
requirements.                                                 Dealing with average figures is never accurate. We are in     There is obviously still a lot to be confirmed, with the IMO
                                                              no doubt that the IMO’s intention is for large parts of the   expected to finalise and adopt the regulation at MEPC 76
For mechanically controlled engines, this   would take the
                                                              fleets to be upgraded to become more efficient. Most          in June this year.
form of a mechanical stop screw sealed      by a wire that
                                                              younger vessels will already be in the vicinity of the
limits the amount of fuel that can enter    an engine. For                                                                  Still, the case for action is clear. Shipowners’ access to
                                                              required EEXI threshold. Some may be required to make
newer, electronically controlled engines,    EPL would be                                                                   cargo, capital and ports could be at risk if they are
                                                              smaller-scale alterations.
applied via a password-protected software   fuel limiter.                                                                   considered not to be doing enough about their CO2
                                                              The issues become clearer amongst older vessels. The          footprint.
Engine power limitation (EPL) will be overridable if a ship
                                                              scale of reduction required is likely to be more expensive
is operating under adverse weather conditions and
                                                              and require major changes, for example larger engine
requires extra engine power for safety reasons; in this
                                                              power limits which could affect actual operational speeds
situation, the override should be recorded and reported to
                                                              and vessels’ prospect for future hire.
the appropriate regulatory authority.
                                                              The new regulation could drive additional market
EPL could cut fuel usage and CO2 emissions if it reduces
                                                              segmentation where vessel earnings (and secondhand
the operational speeds of affected vessels. The EEXI will
                                                              prices) are increasingly subject to the vessels ratings.
not directly reduce fuel usage and CO2 emissions if ships

                                                                                                                                                       Shipping Market Review – May 2021   17
SHIPBUILDING

               Shipping Market Review – May 2021   18
SHIPBUILDING: UPDATE
High capacity but few new orders                                                                                                               DS:FUNDAMENTALS
Contracting activity increased significantly from October to April 2021 but the total for the   MARKET CYCLE POSITION – APRIL 2021
past 12 months remains at a low level. Owners are holding back, since uncertainty related
                                                                                                Newbuilding prices have increased 6% in the past six months
to the decarbonisation of the shipping industry are increasing risks. Many yards are
quickly running out of orders. A group of 64 first-tier yards, representing half the global                [Newbuilding prices 2017:2021]
capacity but 80% of the orderbook, are performing more strongly than the 221 second-
tier yards. Yard capacity has kept fairly stable at 57 million cgt since 2019, but 133
                                                                                                 Min                               Median                                            Max
second-tier yards with a combined capacity of 10.5 million cgt (20% of capacity) are             [0%]                              [50%]                                         [100%]
scheduled to deliver their last orders during 2021. It seems that 2022 is currently                                                                                   Period [2000:2021]

scheduled to be more difficult.

                                                                                                Yards delivered 28 million cgt in 2020, which was only 80% of scheduled orders.
EMPTYING ORDERBOOKS AND IDLE YARD CAPACITY
                                                                                                First-tier yards delivered 84%, while second-tier yards only delivered 73%. South
The increased contracting activity between October and April 2021 allowed newbuilding           Korean yards delivered according to schedule, and Chinese and Japanese yards
prices to rise by 6%. Still, newbuilding prices were only settled between 60 yards,             each delivered 75% of scheduled orders. Higher contracting activity increased the
representing 60% of yard capacity and 70% of the orderbook. The remaining 225 yards             orderbook by 5% to 70 million cgt from October to April. Still, with a global
did not receive any new orders during the period. These yards are expected to deliver           capacity of 57 million cgt, yards could deliver the orderbook in 16 months if
50% of their orderbooks during the last eight months of 2021.                                   orders were placed to utilise capacity fully.
Contracting activity picked up in the period    to be delivered before year-end 2022. The       Yard    utilisation:   Yard    capacity          The average South Korean yard is
from October to April, with 18 million cgt      front-loaded nature of the orderbook is         remains poorly utilised. The average             only scheduled to utilise 63% of its
contracted. Container vessels accounted         most severe in Japan, where 95% of the          yard only utilised half of its capacity          capacity in 2021. The country’s six
for half of the contracted capacity,            orderbook is scheduled to be delivered in       during 2020.                                     first-tier yards are performing better,
distributed evenly between Chinese and          the period, compared with 73% in China                                                           utilising 70%, while the four second-
                                                                                                This is expected to increase to 60% in           tier yards are scheduled to utilise only
South Korean yards. Contracted volumes          and 60% in South Korea.                         2021. The group of first-tier yards are          15% of their capacity this year.
account for 25% of the current orderbook.                                                       performing significantly better than
                                                South Korea is performing best in terms of      their      second-tier     competitors.          Yards with a combined capacity of
China and South Korea are gaining market        the size of the orderbook relative to yard      Japanese and Chinese first-tier yards            10.5 million cgt, representing 20% of
share at Japan’s expense, but all three         capacity (order cover of 1.5), but the          are scheduled to utilise more than               global yard capacity, are set to run
regions are struggling to secure enough         orderbook is more stretched than, for           85% of their capacity in 2021, while             out of orders in 2021. Yards
new orders to utilise their yard capacity.      example, the Chinese, which is creating         the average second-tier yard is                  accounting for another 13 million cgt
                                                                                                scheduled to utilise less than 40% of            are currently projected to run out of
                                                periods of low utilisation, especially at
Two-thirds of the orderbook is scheduled                                                        its capacity.                                    orders in 2022.
                                                second-tier yards.

                                                                                                                                                          Shipping Market Review – May 2021   19
CONTAINER

            Shipping Market Review – May 2021   20
CONTAINER
Strong earnings but relatively weak fundamentals                                                                                              DS:FUNDAMENTALS
The network of alliances has managed to exercise strict capacity control, allowing box          MARKET CYCLE POSITION – APRIL 2021
rates to rise sharply during a period when the supply surplus has increased. At its peak in
                                                                                                                                 Freight rates have increased by 100% in the past six months
2020, vessels with capacity of more than 2.6 million teu (the equivalent of two years of
fleet expansion) were excluded from service. The box rate outlook is subject to the                  [Secondhand prices 2017:2021]
commercial discipline of the alliances, since the balance between supply and demand is
expected to be largely unchanged in the years to come. Once the effects of Covid-19 have                                                   Median
                                                                                                 Min                                                                                  Max
subsided, the fragile market balance could easily be jeopardised if one party attempts to        [0%]                                      [50%]                                  [100%]
gain market share, or the recent profits are (over)invested in new vessels. The orderbook                                                                              Period [2000:2021]

is low but largely oriented towards large vessels. We see a long-term risk of surplus             Secondhand prices have recovered 50% in the past six months
vessel capacity in these vessel segments.
                                                                                                Surplus vessel capacity continues to build. The fleet expanded by 4% in 2020,
FREIGHT RATES AND SECONDHAND PRICES
                                                                                                while demand contracted by 1.2%. Travel distances were relatively stable. Still,
Container box rates have experienced a record-breaking bull run since the fourth quarter        volumes resumed strongly from the fourth quarter of 2020, as reduced travel and
of 2020 and into the first quarter of 2021. The temporal shift in consumption patterns          leisure spending shifted consumer spending towards containerised goods,
towards containerised goods has driven a surge in cargo demand, while active capacity           including personal protective equipment. Landside bottlenecks have contributed
has struggled to keep pace. The average secondhand prices index increased by 16%                to the current Container shortage, while carriers have proved to be very adept at
during the fourth quarter of 2020 and another 28% during the first quarter of 2021.             managing capacity.
HIGH BOX RATES...                              The carrier bonanza was clearly driven by        Deliveries continued to decrease,               months: 0.75 million teu during the
Box rates on the major westbound Asia-         logistical issues rather than a shortage of      from 1.3 million teu in 2018, 1 million         fourth quarter and 1.4 million teu
Europe trade almost doubled over the           vessels.                                         in 2019 to 0.9 million (140 vessels) in         during the first quarter of 2021.
course of the fourth quarter 2020 to reach                                                      2020. Still, 1.1 million teu is
                                               …AND LONGER CHARTER PERIODS                      scheduled to enter the fleet in 2021.           Orderbook:         The       orderbook
their highest level in over ten years. The
                                               Tonnage providers did not all benefit                                                            represented 10% of the fleet for large
CCFI Composite Index climbed 50%                                                                Scrapping: Few vessels are being                parts of 2020 but increased to 15% as
                                               equally during 2020, but the average
during     the    fourth    quarter.   This                                                     scrapped,    despite      the    surplus        per April 2021. For vessels larger than
                                               timecharter index gained 42% during the          capacity. Only 79 vessels (one above
represented the fourth consecutive quarter                                                                                                      15,000 teu, the orderbook represents
                                               fourth quarter and an additional 34%             8,000 teu) were scrapped (0.2 million           a somewhat concerning 65% of the
of rising average freight rates and was by
                                               during the first quarter of 2021. The            teu) in 2020. Still, scrapping absorbed         fleet.
far the steepest rise on record.
                                               average fixture period has become                83% of the intake below 12,000 teu.
                                                                                                                                                Demand is temporarily strong, but
The development continued into the first       significantly longer, signalling that carriers   Contracting: Surplus vessel capacity            annual figures for 2020 declined by
quarter of 2021, and in February the CCFI      expect the strong market to last at least        has not been enough to keep                     1.2%, while forecasts for 2021
Composite Index passed Index 2,000.            until the end of 2021.                           contracting low. More than 2 million            suggest a 4% increase compared to
                                                                                                teu has been contracted in the last six         2019.

                                                                                                                                                          Shipping Market Review – May 2021    21
MARKET DYNAMICS IN THE LAST SIX MONTHS
A change in consumer behaviour has supercharged Container demand and sent box rates through the roof
Container demand was stronger than anticipated during                      demand, but global box throughputs declined by just 1.2%
the fourth quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2021.                  in 2020 and are projected to end 2021 6% above the 2019      STRONG TRANSACTION ACTIVITY
                                                                           level.                                                       S&P activity has increased strongly, with 80 vessels traded
HIGH CONTAINER DEMAND
                                                                                                                                        during the fourth quarter and another 100 during the first
We have seen a massive shift – albeit only temporary – in                  INFRASTRUCTURAL BOTTLENECKS
                                                                                                                                        quarter. Few expect the high market to last for long. The
consumer spending. Social distancing has subdued                           The Container market was bordering on chaos during the
                                                                                                                                        blockage of the Suez Canal in March may extend the
contact-intensive activities, dampening leisure spending on                fourth quarter of 2020 and into the first quarter of 2021.
                                                                                                                                        current run by a few months. Still, price spreads between
vacations abroad and eating out. Consumers have not                        Ports were finding it difficult getting back up to speed,
                                                                                                                                        young and older vessels have begun to widen during 2021.
stopped spending; rather, they have redirected their                       many encountered a shortage of Container equipment, and
                                                                                                                                        Younger vessels currently appear to be priced at high
spending to Container-intensive physical goods.                            carriers struggled to reintroduce capacity to the market.
                                                                                                                                        levels.
                                                                           Although new services were added during the fourth
BUT MANY MARKET PARTICIPANTS WERE UNPREPARED
                                                                           quarter, there likely would have been more had the supply
The change in consumer behaviour took many by surprise.
                                                                           chain been working properly.
During the second and third quarters of 2020, many
operators prepared for a double-digit percentage fall in

BOX RATES AND SECONDHAND PRICES                                            SECONDHAND PRICES     (4,500 TEU)                            S&P ACTIVITY     (NUMBER OF VESSELS)
2,200                                                                 60     40                                                           350

1,650                                                                 49     30                                                           263

1,100                                                                 38     20                                                           175

                                                                                                                                                                                         4Q

  550                                                                 26     10                                                            88

               >                                            5YR      10YR   15YR
    0                                                                 15      0                                                             0
        2017         2018          2019      2020           2021                  2017    2018         2019          2020      2021               2017        2018        2019           2020           1Q2021

                                                                                                                                                                                 Source: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance

                                                                                                                                                                     Shipping Market Review – May 2021                    22
SUMMARY: CONTAINER MARKET OUTLOOK
Surplus capacity continues to build, but box rates could maintain healthy levels

The box rate outlook depends on the commercial discipline of the alliances. With the fleet running ahead of demand, if a battle over
market share begins, it will have a material impact on box rates until a new balance has been restored. In today’s market, earnings
are strong. Some are investing in new vessels, while others seem to be waiting – maybe for more clarity on the pathway to zero-
carbon shipping. Early movers will clearly increase their risk of stranded assets if they choose the wrong path.

The ten largest Liner companies accounted for 85% of deployed Container capacity at the         leapfrog LNG as a fuel by expanding trials of biofuel blends and zero-carbon fuels such as
beginning of 2021 compared to 63% at the start of 2009. Tonnage providers own a fleet           ammonia.
of 2,455 vessels with a combined capacity of 10.3 million teu – equivalent to 43% of the
                                                                                                The risk of stranded assets is clearly highest for first movers that risk investing in the
Container fleet.
                                                                                                wrong technology, while late adopters may simply choose to retrofit vessels or postpone
The Container market is oversupplied, but operators are strictly managing capacity by           investments.
carefully planning the composition of vessels on specific routes. Cascading and slow
steaming continue to help operators adjust capacity, fuel costs and emissions. Overall,
the average Container vessel sailed at 14.4 knots in 2021, which is 26% slower than in
2008.                                                                                           CAPACITY MANAGEMENT WORKS TO BALANCE THE MARKET                   (TEU)

The orderbook has risen to 15% of the fleet on the back of new orders coming in during          1,800,000

the fourth quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2021. 90% of the orderbook is
scheduled to be delivered between 2021 and 2023. Overall supply growth is therefore
expected to be “manageable” in relation to annual demand growth of somewhere between            1,350,000
3% and 6%, but the massive fleet expansion among the largest vessels may create
periods of surplus vessel capacity.
                                                                                                 900,000
Liner companies have managed capacity tightly throughout the pandemic. At its peak in
May 2020, 11% of the fleet, or 2.6 million teu (more capacity than that delivered in 2019
                                                                                                                                                                                                    1Q

                                                                                                                                                                                                                Full year
and 2020), was idle in anticipation of a drop in demand. This figure more than halved
when infrastructural bottlenecks reduced the fleets’ cargo-carrying capacity and demand          450,000

increased throughout the fourth quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2021.

The largest risk to the outlook is if the recent appetite for ordering new vessels turns into
                                                                                                       0
an over-investment competition, with the green transition serving as an excuse to order                        2017            2018                    2019                  2020                        2021
“LNG capable” vessels (currently 21% of the orderbook). Some carriers are working to                                                  Out of service (Idle/Laid Up)   Delivery

                                                                                                                                                                                    Source: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance

                                                                                                                                                                      Shipping Market Review – May 2021                      23
CONTAINER FLEET OUTLOOK
A strong inflow of large vessels continues to dominate the fleet outlook
The Container fleet is scheduled for growth with an                      sea routes, while a renewed appetite for vessels between                                    teu have on average been idle in one form or another
orderbook-to-fleet ratio of 15%. Annual deliveries are                   15,000 and 18,000 teu indicates that versatility and                                        since 2010. Still, annual demolition peaked in 2016 at 0.6
scheduled to reach 1.1 million teu in 2021 (up 29%                       flexibility have become increasingly important in the                                       million teu and has remained below 0.2 million teu since
compared to 2020), dipping to 0.8 million teu in 2022 but                context of the 133 vessels larger than 18,000 teu (plus 47                                  2018.
bouncing back to 1.5 million teu in 2023.                                on order) that dominate the east-west services.
                                                                                                                                                                     OLDER INEFFICIENT VESSELS MAY BE SCRAPPED SOON
LARGE VESSELS DOMINATE THE ORDERBOOK                                     STRONG APPETITE FOR NEW VESSELS                                                             The upcoming IMO regulation could, at some point,
Owners seem to be favouring vessels between 1,000 and                    Contracting activity surged during the fourth quarter of                                    facilitate the early retirement of the oldest and less
3,000 teu, and vessels larger than 12,000 teu. The smaller               2020 and the first quarter of 2021. A total of 105 vessels                                  efficient vessels – including some of the first-generation
segments are at varying stages of fleet renewal, while in                were contracted in 2020, with 60% contracted during the                                     large vessels – since new bigger ships are simply more fuel
the larger segments fleets are expanding quickly.                        fourth quarter. Another 138 vessels were contracted                                         efficient per unit. But until then, it will continue to be
                                                                         during the first quarter of 2021.                                                           challenging to employ the 3 million teu orderbook that is
BUT INCREASED FOCUS ON FLEXIBILITY
                                                                                                                                                                     scheduled for delivery before 2024.
The polarised orderbook clearly signals that marginal cost               FEW VESSELS SCRAPPED
per moved unit still dictates fleet compositions on deep                 Demolition activity remains low. Approximately 1 million

AGE DISTRIBUTION     (MILLION TEU)                                       FLEET DEVELOPMENT             (MILLION TEU)                                                 FLEET RENEWAL POTENTIAL                                     (TEU)
  8                                                                      2.0                                                                               20 .0%

                                                                                                                                                                                                   2
                                                                                                                     Fleet growth
                                             Percentage of fleet
                                                                                7%     8%                                                                                                                                                 12.000 teu +
                                                                                                                                                    6%
             28%
                                                                                                                                                           10 .0%

                                                                         1.5
                                                                                                               6%
  6                                                                                                    4%                                                                                         1.5

                                                                                                                                                                      Orderbook / fleet >20 yrs
                                                                                                                      4%
                                                                                                                                                           0.0 %

                                                                                                                                    5%
                                                                                                1%
      19%               21%                                              1.0                                                 3%              3%            -10.0 %

  4                                                                      0.5                                                                               -20.0 %
                                                                                                                                                                                                   1
                                                                   15%
                                13%
                                                                                                                                                           -30.0 %

                                                                         0.0

  2                                     5%
                                                                                                                                                           -40.0 %
                                                                                                                                                                                                  0.5

                                                                         -0.5                                                                                                                                3-11,999 teu
                                                     2%
                                                                                                                                                           -50.0 %

                                                                                                                                                                                                                  < 2,999 teu
  0                                                                      -1.0                                                                              -60.0 %
                                                                                                                                                                                                   0
       0-5    5-10      10-15   15-20   20-25       25+      Orderbook          2014   2015     2016   2017   2018   2019    2020   2021     2022   2023                                                0%      10%             20%        30%             40%             50%
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Orderbook/fleet
                                                                                              < 2,999 teu     3-11,999 teu    12.000 teu +      Orderbook
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                          Sources: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                Shipping Market Review – May 2021                   24
CONTAINER DEMAND OUTLOOK
Container demand is expected to grow in tandem with the global economy in 2021 and 2022
The temporary factors supporting Container demand during the fourth quarter of 2020       BUT PERIODS OF LOW DEMAND ARE EXPECTED
and the first quarter of 2021 are not expected to last, but stronger global economic      Nonetheless, demand conditions are expected to normalise later in 2021 or into 2022.
growth is expected to drive demand growth of 5-6% in 2021 and 3-4% in 2022.               Initially, there is likely to be a temporary drop in Container demand, since consumers may
                                                                                          spend more than usual on services after months of lockdowns without travel and leisure
THE GLOBAL ECONOMY IS FORECAST TO EXPAND BY   6% IN 2021
                                                                                          spending. Knock-on effects from unemployment and business closures could intensify the
The IMF expects global GDP to increase by 6% in 2021 and 4% in 2022. All major
                                                                                          effect and create a period of low activity and low box rates if capacity is not managed
economies are expected to grow, but not all may regain the territory lost in 2020.
                                                                                          carefully.
CONTAINER VOLUMES ARE LIKELY TO REGAIN THE LOST TERRITORY DURING 2021
                                                                                          EARLY SIGNS OF NORMALISATION
Current projections for Container volumes seem to indicate that the robust volume
                                                                                          Chinese PMIs dipped briefly in February but recovered in March. Still, growth in credit,
rebound will likely continue until a significant proportion of consumers have been
                                                                                          electricity generation and rail freight has declined. This could indicate that we are likely to
vaccinated, although the peak impact of the change in consumer spending is likely to be
                                                                                          see the peak in global manufacturing growth very soon. If this is the case, the outlook for
behind us. If that turns out to be fairly accurate, Container demand could grow by 5-6%
                                                                                          Container volumes should be revised downwards sooner rather than later. Still, Container
during 2021, with volumes ending up 4% above the 2019 level.
                                                                                          volumes are projected to grow by 3-4% in 2022, but the outlook is clearly uncertain.

CONTAINER THROUGHPUT   – CHINESE PORTS MONTHLY INDICATOR (YOY)                             CHINESE PMI DATA

 60%                                                                                      55

 40%                                                                                      50

 20%                                                                                      45

 0%                                                                                       40

-20%                                                                                      35
    2017              2018               2019               2020               2021            2017             2018                2019                 2020                      2021

                                                                                                                                                                 Source: Clarksons, Danish Ship Finance

                                                                                                                                                       Shipping Market Review – May 2021                  25
DEEP DIVE: LONG-TERM TRENDS IN CONTAINER DEMAND
Structural shifts could be lowering the long-term outlook for the largest vessels but improving it for mid-sized vessels
The pandemic has introduced some unusual short-term          years, due to underinvestment, underemployment and          supply chains with automated         production closer to
effects on consumer spending that have benefited             labour force declines in many economies. Global GDP is      consumers have been going on for     the last ten years. The
Container demand hugely. Still, it will have some            expected to be about 3 percentage points lower in 2024      pandemic could be the shock that     kickstarts the trend in
medium-    and    long-term   repercussions    that,  in     than pre-pandemic projections suggested, according to       some sectors and industries, while   others may simply opt
combination with pre-existing structural trends, weaken      the IMF.                                                    to hold more inventory.
the demand outlook for the largest Container vessels.
                                                             CONTAINER VOLUMES MAY GROW MORE SLOWLY THAN GDP             LABOUR COSTS ARE NO LONGER THE MAIN FACTOR
There seems to be little to suggest that Container
                                                             Container demand has historically outpaced GDP growth,      Offshoring production to markets with low labour costs
volumes will not continue to grow, but trading patterns
                                                             but ageing global consumers and the ensuing shift in        and then shipping it to consumer markets on mega
could mean that the largest vessels start falling out of
                                                             consumption patterns towards the service sector (e.g.       vessels originally made a lot of sense when labour costs
favour.
                                                             healthcare and leisure spending) have reduced this trend.   were the focus. But in today’s market, where automation
HEAD-HAUL RECOVERY                                           Emerging global consumers are generating less deep-sea      is reducing manufacturers’ dependence on labour costs
Head-haul demand volumes should rebound quickly, as          head-haul demand per dollar growth than their               and the climate agenda has expanded to include supply-
advanced economies are expected to recover sooner and        predecessors. Most live in Asia (a back-haul route on the   chain emissions (Scope 3 emissions) and circularity, there
more strongly than emerging economies, likely reflecting     east-west trade) and are more likely to demand access to    seems little indication that production will continue to be
earlier access to vaccines and therapies.                    rather than ownership of goods, weakening the               highly centralised. Naturally, some production will remain
                                                             relationship between economic growth and Container          centralised, but a large share may become regionalised.
BUT MANY EMERGING CONSUMERS ARE BEING LEFT BEHIND
                                                             volumes further.
Still, large swathes of the next-generation consumers are                                                                REDUCED LONG-TERM OUTLOOK FOR THE LARGEST VESSELS
finding it difficult to regain their footing. Young people   SUPPLY CHAINS ARE UP FOR REVIEW                             Container demand is unlikely to decline in the coming
and lower-skilled workers (many employed in highly           The supply chain disruptions caused by the pandemic         years, but there is a question mark over the dominance of
contact-intensive sectors) have been among the most          have accelerated pre-existing trends, hastening the shift   the mega vessels trading east-west. Many of these will
heavily impacted, with sharp rises in unemployment           towards automation, reshoring of production and supply      still be required, but alternative lanes with more flexibility
rates, declines in labour force participation, reduced       chain resilience across sectors and industries. Few of      are likely to emerge alongside these main infrastructures.
incomes and permanent shifts in consumer preferences.        these trends are supportive of long-term demand for the     We expect to see more regionalisation, shorter travel
Worker reallocation across sectors is likely, but it will    largest Container vessels.                                  distances and mid-sized vessels defining the long-term
come at a cost, as average earnings for those who make                                                                   outlook for a decarbonised Container industry.
the switch will fall.                                        SOME PRODUCTION COULD BE MOVED CLOSER TO CONSUMERS
                                                             The pandemic – and the recent blockage of the Suez
GLOBAL GDP COULD BE 3 PP LOWER IN 2024
                                                             Canal – has reminded us that our super cost-effective,
The pandemic is expected to have long-lasting adverse
                                                             just-in-time manufacturing ecosystem, with many
effects on global activity. It is likely to worsen the
                                                             companies holding near-zero inventories, comes at a
slowdown in global growth projected for the next few
                                                             cost. Yet, discussions about having more regionalised

                                                                                                                                                     Shipping Market Review – May 2021    26
You can also read