PLANNING AWARDS 2020 Westin Hotel, Dublin 27th February 2020 - Irish Planning Institute
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 PRESIDENT’S WELCOME Welcome to the 2020 Irish Planning Awards. The Irish Planning Institute seeks, through the This year the Panel of Judges were • Ms Rachel Kenny FIPI – Director of Irish Planning Awards, to highlight innovation Planning, An Bord Pleanála and excellence in Irish planning. These Awards acknowledge the diverse range of plans taking • Professor Peter Roberts – place locally and nationally in complex and Chairman, NIHE dynamic planning environments. • Ms Orla Hegarty MRIAI RIBA – Assistant The calibre and quantity of projects submitted Professor, UCD School of Architecture, to the Irish Planning Awards has greatly Planning and Environmental Policy improved this year, reflecting the output of the Planning Sector across the country. We feel • Mr Paul Hogan – Acting Chief Planner, these shortlisted projects clearly demonstrate Department of Housing, Planning and the advantages of the participatory planning Local Government process, facilitated and enabled by professional planners. The shortlisted projects show how • Mr Tom Enright – Chief Executive, the cooperation and direct participation of Wexford County Council stakeholders can have a synergistic effect of benefit to the whole planning process. The • Dr. Conor Norton MIPI – President of the Institute are delighted to confirm a significant Irish Planning Institute increase in the quantity and quality of projects The President’s Awards were chosen personally submitted for consideration. In total the Panel by my predecessor, outgoing President Joe of Judges have shortlisted 34 projects across 7 categories from a total entry of 56 projects. Corr MIPI. This year our panel of judges noted in particular Every project shortlisted this evening has the strong interest in two new categories. demonstrated excellence and innovation in Climate Change was introduced this year as an Planning. Our panel of Judges were struck by Award category and recognises the necessity the dedication and energy of each shortlisted to link planning and climate action for climate entry and we look forward to the realisation change to be effectively addressed. The of these projects in the months and years Planning Workplace of the Year recognises ahead. As Planners, we sometimes struggle employers of planners who demonstrate to share the good news and the success excellence in customer service and business of our profession. As a colleague from the processes and who contribute to the industry Department of Housing Planning and Local and profession. Organisations shortlisted Government pointed out at one of our Planning under this category have been particularly Conferences last year – bad planning roars at dynamic in assisting their employees with their you – good planning is more subtle. Tonight, we professional development. celebrate the “subtle”. The Institute are extremely grateful to the My congratulations to every local authority Department of Housing, Planning and Local and every consultant who has had a project Government for their generous support for the shortlisted. My thanks again to the Department Awards Programme. We are also grateful to of Housing Planning and Local Government for Failte Ireland who have generously sponsored their generosity and support for the Awards the Planning and Economic Development programme, and my thanks to my fellow judges. Category. We are very grateful to colleagues who gave generously of their time to participate Dr Conor Norton MIPI with me on our Panel of Judges. President, Irish Planning Institute 2020/2021 2 3
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 Plan Making Category The Regional Spatial and Economic Strategy (RSES) for the Eastern and Midland Region e. An investment Framework – Included for the first time within a Regional Plan, the Investment Framework is aligned to This category is for plans representing the best of the art and science of spatial planning. This The RSES is the first plan of its kind prepared the National Development Plan and is can include plans, projects, strategies and the innovative use of technology in such plans. and successfully adopted in Ireland. The committed to the delivery of the National strategy is a strategic plan and investment • The Regional Spatial and Economic Strategy (RSES) for the Eastern and Midland Region Planning Framework through the essential framework to shape the future development of means of the RSES. the Region to 2031 and beyond. Prepared in • South Dublin County Council – Clonburris SDZ accordance with the provisions of the Planning f. An implementation and Monitoring and Development Act 2000, as amended, the Roadmap – Committed to ensuring that the • Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A Vision for Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town strategy defines a holistic vision for the Regional RSES is delivered over the lifespan of the Centre and provides a blueprint in plan making that for Strategy, providing clear mechanisms as to the first time combines a spatial, economic and how the Strategy will be finalised. • Dublin City Council – Cherry Orchard Local Area Plan climate strategy, whilst ensuring that people 2. The approach and input of the Planning • Tipperary County Council – Design and Best practice Guidelines for Cluster Housing and quality of life are central in shaping the Team: - Providing Evidence Driven Policy, Schemes in Rural Villages multitude of places within the most diverse Facilitating Meaningful Consultation and Region of the state. Ensuring Delivery. A number of complementary factors have The formation of policy was supported by a contributed to the pioneering nature of the Socio-Economic Evidence Baseline Report, Strategy. This includes: prepared in collaboration with the All -Ireland 1. The publication of an original and novel final Research Observatory (AIRO) at Maynooth document consisting of many firsts for Irish University. In addition, substantial qualitative Planning including; - research was carried out through the 3. production of a number of thematic research 1. a. A Spatial Strategy – Allied to International Park West - Cherry Orchard Local Area Plan 2019 papers which were used to inform the process, and European best practice, backed by 4. stimulate debate amongst stakeholders, evidence and developed to manage future 2. including Local Authorities, and validate the growth and ensure the creation of healthy 5. approach of the Planning Team. This was and attractive places to live, work, study, preceded by qualitative research carried out visit and invest in. on ‘Ensuring a Rigorous and Effective RSES Published November 2019 1. The Regional Spatial and b. An Economic Strategy – A new mandate for Process’, which was prepared to develop and Economic Strategy (RSES) for the Irish Planning, the Economic Strategy builds ripen the RSES planning concept. The RSES Eastern and Midland Region on the Region’s strengths to sustain a strong also incorporated a pioneering Asset- Based 2. Tipperary County Council economy and support the creation of quality Approach’ in order to credibly determine – Design and Best practice jobs that ensure a good living standard for strategic sites and settlements for the Region Guidelines for Cluster Housing all. Strategic sites and settlements were selected, Schemes in Rural Villages c. A Climate Action Strategy – Explicitly in consultation with local authorities. 3. Dublin City Council – Cherry included in a strategic Irish planning The planning team ensured that the Orchard Local Area Plan document for the first time, the Climate consultation process allowed for collaborative 4. Clonburris SDZ Action Strategy is built in to accelerate working in partnership with a number of climate action, ensuring mitigation coupled stakeholders. The new found approach of the 5. Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A with building resilience through adaptation. planning team, to ensure the RSES actively Vision for Portlaoise: A Strategy drives regional development, has opened up for a Better Town Centre d. A Metropolitan Area Strategic Plan (MASP) new opportunities to deliver the Regional for Dublin – The first MASP within the Strategic Outcomes through relationship Country to be prepared, the Plan takes a building, joint research prospects and holistic approach, planning to become a implementation funding mechanisms that are smart, climate resilient and global city region, intertwined within the Regional Assembly’s expanding access to social and economic functions. opportunities and improved housing choice, travel options and quality of life. 4 5
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 Design and Best practice Guidelines for also included a number of worked examples in tradition of development which is unique to Collaboration with key stakeholders added Cluster Housing Schemes in Rural Villages – village in the county, from infill, to brownfield rural Ireland. It is believed that the publication, significant value to the project by ensuing that Tipperary County Council to greenfield sites supported by the demonstrator project will an integrated Planning Scheme was prepared have significant and positive impact on both by implementing a multi-disciplinary approach Tipperary, like many rural local authorities has National Guidelines on residential development planning practice and in ensuring the viability to addressing the opportunities and challenges faced many challenges including decline in have to date focused on high to medium design of villages in County Tipperary and beyond. presented by the SDZ lands. The SDZ Planning population, loss of services and community residential development in our urban cities facilities. The future viability, and in many and towns. This publication is the first of its Clonburris SDZ – South Dublin County Team was the central actor in the coordination cases the survival of villages is one of the key kind in providing a best practice approach in Council of a range of professions and stakeholders challenges for rural Ireland and for national developing schemes which offer viable and which resulted in a collaborative and iterative In December 2015, a Government Order approach to the plan making process and and local policy makers, communities and sustainable alternatives to building homes in designated 280 hectares as an SDZ at which ultimately resulted in a multifaceted stakeholders. the open countryside. The design approach Clonburris. Clonburris SDZ is the largest sustainable Planning Scheme. can be applied successfully in any village and SDZ in Ireland and is identified as a Major Following the establishment of Tipperary therefore as a model for development across Urban Housing Development Site (MUHDS). The Masterplanning approach added significant County Council in 2014, the Planning the country. The Planning Scheme was approved by An value to the project by ensuring the Planning Department and the Elected Members began the preparation of the first county-wide rural Facilitating the development of cluster schemes Bord Pleanala subject to modifications and Scheme captured the most up to date and best settlement strategy. A number of workshops on a phased basis was raised at a consultation clarifications in May 2019. practice approaches to concepts, urban design were held with the Elected Members with event– as demand often only exists for 1-2 and SDZ development. The SDZ Planning The incubation of Clonburris SDZ at such discussion centred around the revitalisation of houses at a time, the guidelines demonstrate Team led a range of urban design workshops a pivotal time in Irish planning history has our village and what the Council could do to how the local infrastructure can be developed throughout the plan making process. resulted in a final Planning Scheme which reverse this trend. The discussions concluded on a phased basis, with road and water will be an outstanding model in sustainable Each of the workshops served as a participatory that a strong policy response was needed, services infrastructure built in tandem with the community development, including the forum for multi-disciplinary teams. whereby a local need would apply in all areas individual houses. The Council also updated integration of green infrastructure, sustainable in the countryside, supported by a pro-active the Taking in Charge Policy providing new 10 The phasing approach added significant value urban drainage and the consideration of energy to the project by ensuing the Scheme is centred policy response to promote low density and standard and guidance to streamline the taking and climate change mitigation options. viable alternatives to one-of housing in all our in charge process for cluster housing schemes. on the balanced delivery of infrastructure, villages. The strategic site of Clonburris SDZ has urban centres and community services in Many of our villages do not benefit from the potential to become an exemplar and tandem with projected population increase, in The preparation of the Cluster Guidelines is public waste water treatment systems or distinctive new community into the future, order to ensure sustainable communities and both a direct response to delivering Project have capacity issues which are often seen as centred on the provision of a choice of high- place making. Ireland 2040 and a rural spatial planning and a significant barrier to development. However, quality homes and access to a range of local development priority. The ambition for the following comprehensive background research, The Scheme delivers a network of high-quality services and amenities, together with the document is to make a national contribution including consultation with Irish Water and green and blue infrastructure spaces and delivery of reliable public transport options. in rural housing design and place-making and the EPA, the team determined that small scale public parks while protecting, enhancing and Open spaces and parks will be a central feature help to ensure that our villages remain at the housing schemes (subject to environmental sensitively upgrading the natural, built and of this sustainable community and the public heart of rural communities for generations to assessment and individual treatment plants) cultural assets of the Clonburris lands. realm to be created at Clonburris will be critical come. may be supported. in place making and ensuring that pedestrians The scheme is designed to be highly accessible In order to develop best practice in placemaking, The Planning Department is now embarking on and cyclists have maximum access to a range of for pedestrians and cyclists and to promote a a multi-disciplinary approach was required. The the design and development of a demonstrator local facilities and amenities. sustainable modal shift for shorter journeys. Planning Department led the direction of the project ‘on a site in Kilsheelan Village, located The Planning Scheme demonstrates an The development of the entire Planning document in all aspects, including research 8km east of Clonmel on the banks of the River integrated approach to land use zoning and Scheme is expected to deliver a target of: requirements stakeholder consultation, and Suir. This project seeks to use public owned transportation. design and guidance. land to support the regeneration of the village, • 9,416, new homes The SDZ Planning Team sought to expand by offering opportunity for local people to buy • A Minimum of 7,300 sq. m gross the scope of consultation and developed a The Guidelines are structured around a ‘5 a site and build the first home and live in a rural community floorspace Consultation Strategy with particular emphasis step approach’ in designing and developing a community. placed on web-based consultation with Cluster Housing Scheme, addressing each step • A Maximum of c. 22,520 sq. m gross retail in the process. The Planning Department and Villages are the heart of our rural communities; floorspace and supplementary ‘face to face’ interaction with the team also agreed at the outset that the they are part of our heritage and culture, and the public. This resulted in a level of public • A Minimum of 30,000 sq. m employment participation which went beyond planning document should be ‘easy to read and easy contribute to quality of life in our rural areas. floorspace. to use’. With this in mind, the publication is a These guidelines seek to deliver on an objective professionals and landowners and reached the short (40 pages), avoids jargon. The document of Project Ireland 2040 and address a type and wider non-technical community. 6 7
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 Ensuring the involvement and participation The core aim of the plan was to make Portlaoise Cherry Orchard Local Area Plan Dublin City • Ability to plan for all sectors of housing of a range of professionals in the plan making Ireland’s first Low Carbon Town centre. The Council need and inclusiveness; process resulted in the delivery of a robust, approach was to utilise the potential of The Park West Cherry Orchard Local Area • Enhancing the health of the community by comprehensive and multifaceted framework, the natural and built environment from the Plan (LAP) covers an area of approximately encouraging and facilitating more active considerate of an extensive range of issues perspective of ‘ecosystem services’ and ‘green 267.51 hectares and contains approximately lifestyles by creating a more walkable and to ensure proper planning and sustainable infrastructure’. 46 hectares of land available of development. cycle friendly urban environment. development of the area. The end result is One of the key innovations of the Project to The Park West Cherry Orchard Local Area Plan a Planning Scheme which is built upon an • Placemaking initiative to foster the deliver participation and engagement has been sets out the framework for the regeneration evidence-based approach to plan making and a creation of viable communities, the development of a bespoke Environment and sustainable development of a strategic foundation of extensive research and baseline underpinned by exemplary urban design. Information Model (EIM) for Portlaoise Town area of the City. The LAP is a key strategic studies The Cherry Orchard LAP seeks to create a Centre. This resource allows for local people, planning document of the City Council and a Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A Vision for business and other stakeholders as well as the road map for active land management. It has legible built environment by capitalising on Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town Local Authority to visualise, understand and a key role to play in delivering the City’s vision existing assets. Within Cherry Orchard it is Centre Laois County Council and Avison influence the Town’s development. and core strategy as set out in the Dublin City proposed to consolidate the existing hub of Young Development Plan 2016-2022. community uses at the church, school and The Planners’ role was to bring a strategic community centre through the provision of A Vision for Portlaoise’ is a plan that re-examines but delivery–focused approach with which The LAP for Park West – Cherry Orchard new local retail units along Cherry Orchard the Town Centre of Portlaoise to succeed in a to take stakeholders through a dynamic and provides a strategic vision and development Avenue, in order to create an identifiable changing social, environmental and economic adaptive plan-making process. This required strategy for the coordinated development of neighbourhood centre, with improvements to context to 2040 and beyond. The primary the team to integrate strategic vision with local key land banks within the Plan area, to provide the streetscape and landscaping. achievement of the project to date has been knowledge and micro-level understanding housing and employment opportunities to formalising a shared vision that focuses on of how Portlaoise functions, with the aim of serve the existing and future population, Extensive consultation at the pre-draft issues improving the public realm, underpinned by a developing a suite of interventions that would while simultaneously contributing to wider paper stage enabled a multitude of voices more coherent spatial framework. transform Portlaoise Town Centre for a better regional and national policy objectives. This to be heard and for local concerns and future. will be underpinned by a strong placemaking objectives to be encapsulated in the plan. The project involved the development of a strategy, which will implement public realm The planning team was then tasked with the plan that focussed on the contemporary public The core aim of the project was to put in improvements within existing neighbourhoods. need to balance local needs and requirements spaces and buildings and the development of place a platform to reinvigorate Portlaoise Furthermore, the LAP endeavours to with National and Regional policy objectives. linkages and walkways between the heritage Town Centre as a people-focussed town; the improve and enhance connections to the The resulting LAP expertly merges these assets of the Town. The plan-making methods ‘People’s Town’. The need to retain a town that existing communities, while capitalising on requirements, maintaining a strong local focus. sought to improve legibility and usability of was for local residents and businesses, and existing assets such as the Grand Canal and The presence of large vacant sites, suitable Portlaoise by delivering a public realm that one that they could be proud of and continue Gallenstown Waterworks, which can become for development that are located along key provides well-connected and useable urban to invest in over a long-term period was catalysts for economic development, tourism public transport corridors and adjoining spaces for residents, businesses and visitors. recognised by the project team. An adaptive and recreation. a range of existing social and community and comprehensive approach alongside the The project has brought a strategic approach cohesive and holistic output made the project By re-imagining this part of the City there is facilities, places the development of this area that fuses public realm improvement with land original and innovative. real potential to create a high density attractive firmly to the fore in its ability to deliver future use and spatial planning. A main feature of residential and employment hub, that can take sustainable communities. Since its adoption the project is its dual nature as a public realm full advantage of the available public transport on the 7th October 2019, the City Council enhancement strategy, and also as a town systems, proximity to City Centre and proximity has already begun the process of setting centre plan that deals with transportation, to nearby social and community infrastructure. up an implementation team to drive future movement, green infrastructure and land use By redeveloping this land, the following development and to develop and regenerate planning. Initially focussing on public realm outcomes are possible: this strategic land bank within the City enhancement, the project evolved to resolve alongside the local community and key local broader and more fundamental issues of • Reduced greenfield land take; stakeholders. how the town functioned and which would • Utilisation of existing infrastructure, and heavily influence the form and potential of the reducing the need to travel long distances, future public realm. This demanded that the thus reducing energy consumption and project team resolve traffic flows, car parking, carbon emission; public transport, green infrastructure and the utilisation of heritage assets within the Town • Improved viability of public transport centre. services; 8 9
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 Participation and Engagement Category Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A Vision for Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town Local Authority to visualise, understand and influence the Town’s development. Centre - Laois County Council with Avison This category is for plans, studies, strategies and projects which demonstrate how public The Communication Strategy set out concisely Young participation has been effective in changing outcomes. It can include measures to increase the Who, When and How of the engagement engagement and awareness of planning or innovative public consultation. A Vision for Portlaoise’ is a plan that re- process, and how stakeholders at the different examines how the Town Centre of Portlaoise stages of the process would be consulted. The • Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A Vision for Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town will succeed in a changing social, environmental project not only engaged fully with stakeholders Centre Laois County Council & Avison Young and economic context to 2040 and beyond. The but also sought to reflect their identity in the primary achievement of the project to date has urban design and plan output. • Church Lane Heritage Regeneration Project – Donegal County Council been formalising a shared vision that focuses The core aim of the project was to put in place a on improving the public realm, underpinned • Limerick City and County Living Georgian City: A Strategy for Compact Growth platform to reinvigorate Portlaoise Town Centre by a more coherent spatial framework. The as a people-focussed town; the ‘People’s Town’. • Ireland’s Collaborative Town Centre Health Check Training Programme – Heritage project involved the development of a plan that The need to retain a town that was for local Council and Project Partners focussed on the contemporary public spaces residents and businesses and one that they and buildings and the development of linkages could be proud of and continue to invest in • Galway Public Realm Strategy – Galway City Council with Allies & Morrison and walkways between the heritage assets of over a long-term period was recognised by the the Town. project team. The Planners’ role was to bring a strategic Overall, the Portlaoise 2040 process approach with which to take stakeholders was ‘geared to hear’ and respond to local through a dynamic and adaptive plan-making stakeholder ideas and concerns and to bring process, following the preparation of the interested parties through an inclusive process project Communication Strategy. This provided towards a common vision. All of the elements 1. 2 a step-by-step approach which outlined Avison of the consultation were synthesised into the Young’s systematic but innovative view on final Portlaoise 2040 And Beyond – A Vision 3 4 stakeholder engagement. The main phases of for Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town consolation were built around the following Centre. 5. flagship events: Church Lane Heritage-Led Regeneration • Public Workshop 1 Project Donegal County Council • Public Workshop 2 The heritage-led regeneration project is • Shared Vision Workshop an innovative partnership project between Planning Services and Culture Division, Donegal • Presentation of the Draft Plan County Council, Letterkenny Cathedral These were the main consultations events Quarter Group, the local community and with which served as focal points within a wider the benefit of the expertise from Dedalus programme of engagement with the Planning Architecture to proactively initiate a package Authority, Strategic Planning Committee and of capital works for a high quality urban living Municipal District. The project team sought and working environment within the historic to engage with local people, including young core of Letterkenny. The project consisted of a adults and schools. This was a fundamental package of capital works to conserve and repair 1. Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A Vision for Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town Centre Laois County Council & Avison Young goal as participation within the town has been seven properties, reinforce civic pride in the poor historically and reversing this trend was an area, enhance attractiveness and promote the 2. Church Lane Heritage Regeneration Project – Donegal County Council important priority for the Local Authority. tourism potential of the town’s historic core by putting into action relevant plans, policies and 3. Limerick City and County Living Georgian City: A Strategy for Compact One of the key innovations of the Project to strategies for this area. Growth deliver participation and engagement has been the development of a bespoke Environment The historic core of Letterkenny like so many 4. Ireland’s Collaborative Town Centre Health Check Training Programme – Heritage Council and Project Partners Information Model (EIM) for Portlaoise Town Irish towns has suffered vacancy and dereliction Centre. This resource allows for local people, over the years requiring, regeneration and 5. Galway Public Realm Strategy – Galway City Council with Allies & Morrison business and other stakeholders as well as the investment to attract people back into living in 10 11
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 the centre of the town to realise these national Donegal County Council planning services The LGC programme focussed on three key • The LGC programme implementation targets. The project focused on heritage-led undertook a public participation process for pillars (Pillar 1: Investment Modal/ Governance team included LCCC Senior Architect, regeneration as a key stage of reversing this the preparation of the Local Area Plan in 2018 Feasibility, Pillar 2: Demonstration and Capital and two planners from the Housing trend and of bringing life back into the heart of in which approximately 700 people took part. Works and Pillar 3: Citizen Solutions) Development Directorate of LCCC. this once vibrant traditional market town. Donegal County Council planning services Under Pillar 1, the LGC programme considers • The planners involved in the programme worked with Queen’s University Belfast in Church Lane is a key street within the historic the financial, governance, procurement and led on the development of a cross- 2018 on a Collaborative Town Centre Health core of the town centre and contributes to regulatory mechanisms for land and building professional working relationship within a Check working directly with the Cathedral the setting for Letterkenny’s most important activation. Design enabling and review based multi-disciplinary team. Quarter Group and local residents. historical structures. These modest 19th on the successful UK CABE model will be • The development of a distinct vision and century buildings are incredibly important to The Donegal County Council Culture Division investigated and implemented in Limerick physical, economic and social framework. the area’s sense of place. Buildings on Church has facilitated the Cathedral Quarter Group’s with a view to inform a similar model for local Lane had deteriorated over a long period of and local residents’ vision of the area becoming authorities nationally. • The development of pillars and work time and many on lower Church Lane were a cultural quarter through supporting various programme. The preparation of an vacant, derelict and close to collapse. events such as Cultural Night and Heritage Under Pillar 2, four demonstration projects are economic input/output model to test the Week. being enabled by local authority buildings and viability of the LGC programme. The Church Lane Historic Towns Initiative has land with the intent to replicate throughout the resulted in conservation works to seven historic The Church Lane project is essentially a city and indeed will form the basis of a new • The preparation and adaption at properties that include roof and chimney place-making and place regeneration project model of city centre regeneration through the Management Team level of a planning led repairs, installation of cast-iron rainwater that owes its success to the cooperation of country. At a micro level, these projects realise programme. goods, reinstatement of timber sash windows the local partners. The lasting impact will be significant levels of subsequent benefits to local • The promotion of LGC through meetings, and doors, and the repair of a historic shopfront through the repeated delivery of plans and businesses, reduction in energy costs, creation talks and publications. using traditional materials and informed by best projects that build on this foundation of trust of jobs and reduction in welfare payments. conservation practices. and collaboration. • The effective liaison with key partners to By enabling Limerick City and County Council use their expertise and enthusiasm and to Visually this project has transformed Church Limerick City and County Council Living (LCCC) owned property in the first instance drive forward opportunities for the LGC Lane’s streetscape and has been the final major Georgian City – A Strategy for Compact as demonstrators, other landowners will be programme. milestone in ‘Saving Church Lane’. Regeneration Growth attracted to consolidate and proactively land The LGC programme is a replicable programme works has had a positive visual impact on the Limerick’s Living Georgian City (LGC) assemble to unlock the future compact growth old town centre and ensure that cultural and for urban regeneration nationally and programme involves making positive, of the city. Extending these benefits to the built heritage is a key contributor to the quality internationally. It demonstrates how city centre innovative and transformational change to wider city would have significant impacts. of the built environment in Letterkenny. It is living and redevelopment is economically viable, Newtown Pery, the heart of Limerick city’s hoped that this development will encourage Pillar 3 focuses on citizen-centric solutions engenders a sense of community, and delivers outstanding Georgian architectural heritage. appropriate new investment, halt the decline that leverage the value of Horizon 2020, enjoyable places where people want to live The Georgian District is a key piece of the and reinforce the traditional town centre as a substantial EU-funded project of and work. It harnesses the active commitment architectural and cultural heritage of Limerick the heart of the town and will complement the €6.5 million awarded to LCCC in July 2018 of local government, public bodies, and other but has suffered from high levels of vacancy, work of the Planning Services in implementing to develop Ireland’s first lighthouse smart stakeholders to support citizens to effectively underinvestment and speculative land- the Urban Regeneration and Development city. Key deliverables impacting directly on engage in the LGC process to deliver place- banking. The Living Georgian City programme Fund investments in the town centre. LGC to geographically network. The scale and based change. is exemplary of urban regeneration in a The level of community participation and historic city centre development, which is impact of this element of the proposal will, engagement was significant. The project built environmentally and physically sustainable, therefore, have a wide-ranging impact on the upon the community-led initiative begun by socially just, economically inclusive and development of policies in city and town centre the Letterkenny Cathedral Quarter group to embraces smart city living. development both locally and nationally. conserve their historic built environment. The LGC programme focusses on targeted Donegal County Council Planning Services, interventions and underutilised stock, to were involved in the Heritage Streets Alive increase the level of residential use in the Project in 2015 undertaken by architect city, showcase the transition to a low carbon and community engagement animator Mary and resilient city, deliver compact growth, Kerrigan. This engendered the creation of a strengthen the economy through innovation shared vision for Church Lane among residents, and enhance the existing public amenity and the local community and the local authority. heritage. These interventions are in accordance with national, regional, county and local policy. 12 13
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 Ireland’s Collaborative Town Centre Health Town Renewal Plan. The collaborative and Galway Public Realm Strategy – Galway City The project has brought people together to Check Training Programme – Heritage participative approach adopted includes the Council with Allies & Morrison forge a shared vision of Galway City Centre. Council and Project Partners operation of a ‘Rotating Chair’ at all meetings. The importance of accessibility, arts and Those who live and work in Galway know their This is to ensure that the representatives sustainability rose in significance. The result Ireland’s collaborative Town Centre Check city; they possess immense local knowledge of involved have a collective voice and role in has been a public realm strategy for Galway Programme, created by the Heritage Council the way Galway is, both in terms of what really the project, i.e. 12 no. representatives from which is rooted in local knowledge, and much and its Partners in 2016, aims to establish makes the city special, and understanding various partner groups, including the Heritage stronger for it. a collaborative and robust approach to what are they key priorities for change. A Council Programme Coordinator. The CTCHC undertaking Town Centre Health Checks in commitment to consultation at the outset and Planners and designers from Allies and Programme coordinator is project manager Irish Towns. This informs the design, delivery a belief that people can positively shape the Morrison and Galway City Council worked on a day to day basis working closely with the and evaluation of economic development, strategy underpins the Public Realm Strategy. collaboratively to design, deliver and facilitate a keep partners. regeneration and investment programmes – consultation programme which was ambitious Consultation was central to Galway City both public and private – at various levels. The The 15 – step CTCHC process commenced and rooted in best practice principles of Council policy approach and brief. The project CTCHC Training Programme strongly supports in earnest with Dundalk IT undertaking key engagement. began with a two-day pop up event asking the implementation of the National Planning steps including, a land use survey, using a people what works, what doesn’t and what The public Realm Strategy sets out the Framework and National Development Plan classification and GIS colour coding town centre improvements could be made to Galway’s following six principles: 2018 – 2027 – project Ireland 2040. land use, which was formulated by the CTCHC streets and spaces. Being at the outset of the Programme Coordinator in cooperation with • Celebrating Galway’s uniqueness CTCHC Training programme is based on the project, the feedback set priorities and focus the MyPlan team with the Department of • Making Galway inclusive premise that changing demographics and for the Strategy going forward; making streets Housing. Dundalk IT also undertook footfall, living/travel to work patterns, along with places for people rather than cars was a top • Making space traffic counts and car parking surveys in the changing consumer preferences and trends, are priority, all the while protecting the traits that town centre. Ina addition, following a public • Getting around the city all impacting on the overall vitality and viability make Galway so special and not making it feel tender organised by the Heritage Council, Red of our historic town centres. In addition, like anywhere else. The times and location of • Greening Galway C was appointed to undertake fieldwork (400 existing available information and data the event were carefully selected to be easily no. people sample size) in relation to Step 5 • Delivering Quality about traditional town centres needs to be accessed by a diverse range of people, including of the 15 step CTCHC process in November significantly upgraded as it is currently limited groups who are typically hard-to-reach. The Galway Public Realm Strategy explores 2018, using a detailed consumer questionnaire in scope and is out of date – i.e. the programme the current condition of central Galway’s that was supplied by the programme All the events were advertised using a range of seeks to close the gaps. townscape and network of public and green coordinator. In addition, Dundalk BID carried channels and maximising the use of databases spaces, and sets out a vision and strategy There are currently 13 towns involved in the out commercial surveys with 30 no. randomly of stakeholders, including the community for improvements to guide investment and CTCHC Training programme with over 70 – selected business owners in the town centre voluntary sector (PPN) and allowed people to development in the future. The strategy looks project partners involved from the public, – the programme Coordinator provided a engage in either Irish or English. to further the previous innovative steps which private and civic sectors in Ireland and further questionnaire to support this key step. Following the first engagement event, the team have already been taken, such as creating the afield. In addition, there are currently 13 towns The innovative and transformative Dundalk carried out a baseline analysis and collated and pedestrianised zone, investment in the Fish on a waiting list wishing to join the programme. CTCHC Project, which is part of the CTCHC analysed the comments to develop emerging market and Eyre Square, and the opening of It is anticipated that a further strand to cover/ Training Programme, has overwhelmingly principles. A stakeholder workshop and waking the riverside walk. service the East of the country will be created if enhanced and improved evidence – based audit to delve further into the details around additional resources are made available. planning and economic development practice the issues and opportunities identified and to In October 2018, the first-ever Dundalk and processes in Dundalk. The project has test emerging principles. CTCHC Project was established by the created solid and long-lasting partnerships, To continue the conversation, a weekday Programme Coordinator, in partnership with relationships and networks, which did not and weekend pop-up were held to share the Dundalk Business Improvement District (BID), exist before the project was established. Strategy and to ask whether it succeeded in Dundalk IT, Louth County Council and Dundalk Fundamentally, the project has created a new delivering the community’s ambitions for their Credit Union. Monthly project meetings and way for the public, private and civic sectors city. the delivery of agreed actions commenced in to engage and work together on the planning November 2018 and continue as the project and economic development of this important moves from Phase 1 (preparation of Dundalk Border Town. 14 15
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 Design Category Design & Best Practice Guidelines for Cluster Housing Schemes in Rural Villages- Tipperary also included a number of worked examples in village in the county, from infill, to brownfield County Council to greenfield sites This category rewards the best in design from urban design or public realm plans to individual projects which respond to their context in an urban or rural setting. Tipperary, like many rural local authorities has National Guidelines on residential development faced many challenges including decline in has to date focused on high to medium design 1. Design & Best Practice Guidelines for Cluster Housing Schemes in Rural Villages – population, loss of services and community residential development in our urban cities Tipperary County Council facilities. The future viability, and in many and towns. This publication is the first of its 2. Portlaoise 2040 and beyond – A vision for Portlaoise: A Strategy a Better Town Centre cases the survival of villages is one of the key kind in providing a best practice approach in challenges for rural Ireland and for national developing schemes which offer viable and 3. Cherrywood Town Centre Urban Form Development Framework and local policy makers, communities and sustainable alternative to building homes in the 4. Carrick–on–Shannon Public Realm Improvement Scheme stakeholders. open countryside. The design approach can be 5. Marianella, Rathgar, Dublin – Cairn Homes plc applied successfully in any village and therefore Following the establishment of Tipperary 6. Dublin Landings – Ballymore as a model for development across the country. County Council in 2014, the Planning 7. Galway Public Realm Strategy 1. 2. 3. Department and the Elected Members began Facilitating the development of cluster the preparation of the first county-wide rural schemes on a phased basis was raised at a 8. Rejuvenation of Fitzmaurice Place Portlaoise 4. 5. 6. settlement strategy. A number of workshops consultation event– as demand often only 9. 2018 Public Realm Plan for Sligo City were held with the Elected Members with exists for 1-2 houses at a time, the guidelines 7 8. 9. discussion centred around the revitalisation of demonstrate how the local infrastructure can our village and what the Council could do to be developed on a phased basis, with road and reverse this trend. The discussions concluded water services infrastructure built in tandem that a strong policy response was needed, with the individual houses. The Council also whereby a local need would apply in all areas up-dated the Taking in Charge Policy providing in the countryside, supported by a pro-active new 10 standard and guidance to streamlines policy response to promote low density and the taking in charge process for cluster housing viable alternatives to one-of housing in all our schemes. villages. Many of our villages do not benefit from The preparation of the Cluster Guidelines is public waste water treatment systems or both direct responses to delivering Project have capacity issues which are often seen as Ireland 2040 and a rural spatial planning and a significant barrier to development. However, development priority. The ambition for the following comprehensive background research, document is to make a national contribution including consultation with Irish Water and in rural housing design and place-making and the EPA, the team determined that small scale help to ensure that our villages remain at the housing schemes (subject to environmental heart of rural communities for generation to assessment and individual treatment plants) come. may be supported. In order to develop best practice in placemaking, The Planning Department is now embarking on a multi-disciplinary approach was required. The the design and development of a demonstrator Planning Department led the direction of the project ‘on a site in Kilsheelan Village, located document in all aspects, including research 8km east of Clonmel on the banks of the River requirements stakeholder consultation, and Suir. This project seeks to use public owned design and guidance. land to support the regeneration of our village, by offering opportunity for local people to buy The Guidelines are structured around a ‘5 a site and build the first home and live in a rural step approach’ in designing and developing a community. Cluster Housing Scheme, addressing each step in the process. The Planning Department and Villages are the heart of our rural communities; the team also agreed at the outset that the they are part of our heritage and culture, and document should be ‘easy to read and easy contribute to quality of life in our rural areas. to use’. With this in mind, the publication is a These guidelines seek to deliver on an objective short (40 pages), avoids jargon. The document of Project Ireland 2040 and address a type and 16 17
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 tradition of development which is unique to One of the key innovations of the Project to and cycling environment was provided within • Retail (20,284 sqm); rural Ireland. It is believed that the publication, deliver participation and engagement has been the urban and built form. • High Intensity Employment (22,946 sqm); supported by the demonstrator project will the development of a bespoke Environment The UFDF focus is to masterplan a new Town have significant and positive impact on both Information Model (EIM) for Portlaoise Town • Non-Retail including a primary care unit Centre for Cherrywood and surrounding areas planning practice and in ensuring the viability Centre. This resource allows for local people, (31,115 sqm); which would have a rich urban diversity, whilst of villages in County Tipperary and beyond. business and other stakeholders as well as the • Community uses including a new library respecting the historical and natural setting, as Local Authority to visualise, understand and (1,437 sqm); Portlaoise 2040 and Beyond – A Vision for well as facilitating innovation and creativity. influence the Town’s development. Portlaoise: A Strategy for a Better Town Cherrywood was planned to be a place • Associated roads, public spaces and Centre – Laois County Council with Avison The Planners’ role was to bring a strategic which would develop a cohesive yet diverse services infrastructure; Young but delivery – focused approach with which community, promote economic growth and to take stakeholders through a dynamic and provide a safe and attractive environment for • Reconciling levels across the site. A Vision for Portlaoise’ is a plan that re-examines adaptive plan-making process. This required employees, residents and visitors. Overall the town Centre can accommodate the Town Centre of Portlaoise to succeed in a the team to integrate strategic vision with local 362,909 sqm of development including circa changing social, environmental and economic The UFDF considers urban and built design knowledge and micro-level understanding 1,600 apartments. context to 2040 and beyond. The primary quality to create active frontages and vitality, of how Portlaoise functions, with the aim of achievement of the project to date has been in addition to the treatment of buildings to Carrick-On-Shannon Public Realm developing a suite of interventions that would formalising a shared vision that focuses on ensure interesting and attractive facades. The Improvement Scheme – Leitrim County transform Portlaoise Town Centre for a better improving the public realm, underpinned by a Plan also focusses on the treatment of spaces Council future. more coherent spatial framework. between buildings, with guidance on materials The core aim of the project was to put in Leitrim County Council is presently undertaking The project involved the development of a and finishes to provide a high quality, legible place a platform to reinvigorate Portlaoise a transformative urban regeneration and plan that focussed on the contemporary public and inclusive environment. The UFDF is an Town Centre as a people-focussed town; the development project in the historic core spaces and buildings and the development of all-encompassing framework which guides ‘People’s Town’. The need to retain a town that of Carrick-On-Shannon. Following the linkages and walkways between the heritage planning, design and implementation, whilst was for local residents and businesses, and announcement of the URDF Scheme, the Chief assets of the Town. The plan-making methods maintaining a focus on the quality of the one that they could be proud of and continue Executive appointed the Senior Planner to lead sought to improve legibility and usability of finished environment. to invest in over a long-term period was the preparation of the application on behalf of Portlaoise by delivering a public realm that The UFDF is a clear example of a successful recognised by the project team. An adaptive Leitrim County Council. There was no agreed provides well-connected and useable urban urban design and public realm project that and comprehensive approach alongside the Master Plan in place in which to ground such spaces for residents, businesses and visitors. has moved from design to implementation – cohesive and holistic output made the project an application for funding. The design team The project has brought a strategic approach original and innovative. including starting the construction of the single was procured within six weeks of the scheme that fuses public realm improvement with land largest development application in the history being announced and work began in earnest Cherrywood Town Centre Urban Form use and spatial planning. A main feature of of the State – in 2 years. in devising and designing the contents of the Development Framework – Dun Laoghaire the project is its dual nature as a public realm application. Rathdown County Council The influence of the planning team is also enhancement strategy, and also as a town evident in the masterplan preparation process; The planning authority engaged with the centre plan that deals with transportation, Cherrywood Town Centre Urban Form building on the land uses set out in the Planning Elected Members of the Carrick on Shannon movement, green infrastructure and land use Development Framework (UFDF) for Scheme, the UFDF builds and layers detail in Municipal District from the outset. The project planning. Initially focussing on public realm Cherrywood Town Centre forms part of the terms of urban grain, land use arrangement, team also engaged with the Town Team in enhancement, the project evolved to resolve Cherrywood Planning Scheme. The Planning building form, frontages, activation, primary addition, the Design Team met with the owners broader and more fundamental issues of Scheme area extends over a 360ha site and and secondary civic spaces and thoroughfares, of both cruise hire businesses who occupy a how the town functioned and which would plans for a Town Centre, 3 villages, 6 schools, and streetscapes. critical interface to the water edge in the town. heavily influence the form and potential of the 3 main parks, circa 8,500 new hoes and future public realm. This demanded that the associated infrastructure. The UFDF puts in place the planning and The agreement to include lands in private project team resolve traffic flows, car parking, design guidance necessary for the detailed ownership was considered critical to indicating The preparation of the UFDF was considered public transport, green infrastructure and the design and development of the new Town the catalyst effect which the project could necessary dur to the design challenge the town utilisation of heritage assets within the Town Centre. It is essential to guide the creation of develop in time. The other landowners who centre site presented in terms of ground levels centre. world-class streetscapes, quality public realm, would be affected by the proposals to develop as well as the scale of the project which will form and a vital and viable new town. the proposed car park were also met with and The core aim of the plan was to make Portlaoise the heart of Cherrywood. The development of their support was secured for the submission of Ireland’s first Low Carbon Town centre. The the four town Centre quadrants, identified as Via the first application (TC1. TC2 and TC4) the the application. approach was to utilise the potential of TC1, TC2, TC3 and TC4, had to relate to the project will see the delivery of: the natural and built environment from the ground level established by the luas line viaduct Following the application being submitted, the • 191,115sq.m in 15 blocks including; perspective of ‘ecosystem services’ and ‘green which spans the town centre site. The challenge Planning Authority continued the next stage of 18 infrastructure’. was to ensure that a comfortable pedestrian • 1,269 no. residential units (115,332 sqm); the design of the project that included bringing 19
IR IS H P LANNI NG I NS T I T UTE I R I S H PL A N N I N G AWA R D S 2 0 2 0 the project through the Part 8 consultation They include: Buildings were then designed to continue the The ability of planners in large schemes such as process. When the application received woodland character of the area. this to work together with a large team of sub- • Significant enhancement of the quality the green light for funding from the URDF consultants and specialists is vital to delivering and extent of the public realm of the town The urban pattern is based on the principle Scheme the next stage in the process was the quality homes and spaces. Marianella is centre. of ease of movement and a logical sequence application to confirm Compulsory Purchase a high-quality example of this successful • Strengthening the town’s physical from the public realm to the private domain. Order of the lands to develop the car park to collaboration and innovative features within infrastructure through the provision of off The layout is organised with a series of public An Bord Pleanála. Following an Oral Hearing the scheme such as the residential amenity street car parking. spaces, streets and small courtyards. It is in June 2019, the CPO was confirmed by the space, sensitive extension to the gate lodge designed to respect the existing content and Board without modifications on 11 September • Increase footfall and facilitation of visitors protected structure, high tech specification neighbouring properties while providing for 2019. The project is currently in procurement through the extension of existing routes and furnishing of apartments, trees projecting quality public, shared and private open space. through the podium from below and swales stage for the appointment of contractors with and the creation of new links. construction expected to commence January The development considers the existing within the amenity space. • Celebrating the town’s commercial 2020. character of surrounding lands and streets, Dublin Landings - Ballymore development by improving visitor The availability of funding under the URDF while also recognising the scale and presence facilities. Dublin Landings is a new urban quarter in Scheme allowed for individual policies to of the previously existing Marianella monastery • Celebrating the town’s cultural strengths buildings. Traditional houses (reflecting the Dublin’s Docklands, comprising 1 million sq be brought together in the preparation of ft of workspace and retail spaces, as well as through a high-quality public realm villa typology of Orwell Park) are located a comprehensive Master Plan, from which residential accommodation over 13 buildings. addition. along the southern boundary in response emerged the Public Realm Improvement On completion the site will comprise 560,000 Scheme. It has also allowed the Local Authority • Increasing the residential potential and to the neighbouring existing character and scale. Apartment buildings in the remainder sq. ft. of Grade A office space, around 300 one, to begin a meaningful dialogue with the owners quality of the town. two and three bed apartments and a number of the international boating hire companies of the site, bounding and defining the new Marianella, Rathgar, Dublin – Cairn Homes of retail units. It will be home to 5,500 people along the riverside to reimagine their interface public park, while interspersed with landscape PLC who will live and work in the area, creating a with the river, to open up private lands for gardens eastward towards Saint Luke’s land. vibrant new community in a dynamic, new part the enjoyment of the general public but also Cairn Homes PLC acquired the former Each unit has access to a private outdoor of the city. enhance the connectivity of the town centre. Redemptorist Congregation Monastery site at space, terrace or balcony. A variety of semi- Orwell Road, Rathgar, Dublin 6, along with a At the outset of the scheme, Ballymore held The project will have gone from inception private open space is arranged in courtyards, planning permission for an apartment. A number an architectural competition to explore design to construction including the obtaining of terraces and gardens. The design maximises of amendments were made to the planning potential and kick start the development the necessary planning consent, the need the number of homes with dual aspects. The applications to maximise the development proposals. This exercise created a compelling to pursue the acquisition of the site through that would enhance its surrounding area and location of fenestration has been arranged urban vision which has been refined in the CPO which necessitated an Oral Hearing, the architecture, John Spain Associates were the to provide privacy for the existing and new process of dialogues with the commercial procurement of consultants and contractors planning consultant on the parent application. residents. stakeholders, planners, utility providers and within the space of approximately 18 months. The units are also aimed at the downsizer contractors – without losing the focus on the Leitrim County Council would therefore Marianella is an infill development on a previously underutilised central, serviced site. market i.e. those who have raised their families benefits for the key stakeholder group. contend that the Carrick on Shannon Public and willing to sell family homes that are often The consolidation of the urban area through The resulting aesthetic has largely been Realm Improvement Scheme demonstrates dated and inefficient and costly to maintain. high quality, high density infill development inspired by the heritage of this area of the both effective and innovative management has been a central tenet of the planning The development therefore helps other people city, with the new buildings influenced by the and success in delivery in planning, The Chief system for the past 15 years. In the midst of a stay in their local area while releasing older architecture, through augmented by a clean Executive demonstrated his thrust in the housing crisis, the provision of over 300 units family homes to new families interested in and modern aesthetic. Much of the inspiration, contribution of planners in the management, in a central established residential area is a moving into the area or in some cases facilitating for the materials, comes from the immediately and project management. Planners held a significant planning gain. redevelopment and the more sustainable use adjacent waterfront – with the traditions robust central leadership role within multi-disciplinary teams, in forging and maintaining relationships The primary objective of the overall design of urban land. By bringing new people into materials previously used in the docklands with key stakeholders, and use of work was to ensure it complements and enhances the area, the development helps support local employed in the buildings’ designs. Durable programmes for delivery. the existing surroundings, reinforcing a sense businesses and services, such as local schools. materials such as wood, bricks and darkly of place by creating distinctive and individual A new public park is a welcome addition to the painted iron feature prominently. An overall masterplan was developed which buildings of quality. The centrepiece of the amenities in the area. The development also The aesthetic is already evident in Buildings 1 provided the basis for a series of projects that design is a new public park that faces onto includes social housing which in an area where and 2 which are now complete, with feature are interdependent and rooted in the fabric of Orwell Road, which incorporates the existing there is a shortage of such units, contributes façade clad in precast brick panels, glazed the town. landscape assets of mature trees and enhances greatly to social integration in the area. screens with anodised aluminium and a large the existing sylvan character of Rostrevor Park. 20 21
You can also read