Patents and forest fire control - PreventionWeb.net
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Patents and forest fire control MINISTERIO Oficina Española DE INDUSTRIA, COMERCIO Y TURISMO de Patentes y Marcas
© OEPM and INPI (2022) No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, except as permitted by law, without the prior permission of the copyright holder. NIPO (recycled paper): 116-22-004-0 / NIPO (on-line): 116-22-003-5 DL: M-8445-2022
Patents and forest fire control MINISTERIO Oficina Española DE INDUSTRIA, COMERCIO Y TURISMO de Patentes y Marcas Paseo de la Castellana, 75 – 28071 Madrid Campo das Cebolas, s/n. 1149-035 Lisboa Tel. 902 157 530 – 910 780 780 Tel. 218 818 100 – Fax: 218 869 859 información@oepm.es www.oepm.es servico.publico@inpi.pt https://inpi.justica.gov.pt
Portuguese Institute of Industrial Propriety, I.P Guilherme Távora Fedra Oliveira Luísa Silvério Sofia Antunes Inês Cristóvão da Silva Spanish Patent and Trademark Office, O.A. Patricia López Calvo MINISTERIO Oficina Española DE INDUSTRIA, COMERCIO Y TURISMO de Patentes y Marcas Fernando Olalquiaga del Prado Blanca Vila Riudavets Carmen Toledo de la Torre Authors and technical-scientific experts Javier Madrigal Olmo. Instituto Nacional de Investigación y Tecnología Agrarias y Alimentaria, Centro Nacional-Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (INIA-CSIC) Rubén Laina Relaño y Yolanda Ambrosio Torrijos. Escuela Técnica Superior de Ingeniería de Montes, Forestal y del Medio Natural. Universidad Politécnica de Madrid Alfonso Andrade Otero. Ministerio para la Transición Ecológica y el Reto Demográfico Tiago Martins de Oliveira e Arlindo Pinto dos Santos. Agência para a Gestão Integrada de Fogos Rurais, I.P. Carlos Fonseca. Laboratório Colaborativo para Gestão Integrada da Floresta e do Fogo Photography Javier Madrigal. Laboratorio de incendios forestales, Centro de Investigación Forestal (INIA-CSIC) J. Félix Mateo. COP Cuenca. Consejería de Desarrollo Sostenible JCCM. Plan INFOCAM
Institutional presentation The Portuguese Institute of Industrial Propriety, I.P. (INPI) and the Spanish Patent and Trademark Office, O.A. (OEPM) have been collaborating over the past few years in several fields, sharing the vision that Industrial Propriety, by stimulating and protecting the investments in innovation, is a strategic instrument for the scientific and technological development, as well as for a sustainable and integrative development of the economy. The aforementioned cooperation between the two entities has consisted, mainly, on the exchange of experiences and best practices, with the achievement of very positive results in projects with Iberian impact and in the bilateral organization of several events. This fruitful collaboration provided an opportunity to carry out a study, using the technical information provided by patents on the sustainable management of the forest, the fight against desertification, the prevention of the soil degradation and the loss of biodiversity, and it was then decided that the focus of that study would be on the analysis of the evolution of patents related to the control of forest fires. This is a matter of great importance for Portugal and Spain and represents a permanent challenge for both countries and, even on a global scale, it is undeniably a matter of current affairs, as it is closely associated to climate change, which has been identified as one of the biggest environmental, social and economic threats that the planet and mankind are facing. Forest fires are, by themselves, a scourge with the most varied repercussions, corresponding in the Iberian Peninsula to a complex problem that entails high risks for the population as well as for the environment. To minimize this general negative impact, innovation, through the knowledge resulting from scientific research and technologic development, has key potential. The emergence of technologies in the field of prevention, detection and fire extinguishing, as well as protection and post-fire restoration soil equipment, is a key ally to establish effective policies and to operate the firefight and control of wildfires. Industrial Propriety can play a highly relevant role in this context, since it secures the financial outcome of the high investments inherent to the Research and Development (R&D). On the other hand, the patent system, given its own nature, promotes innovation and attracts mores investments thus encouraging the invention of technologies consecutively more advanced in the fight against wildfires. In this study —which usefulness seems to us indisputable— the aim is precisely to present the most promising technologies in the field of firefight and control of wildfires, which have an associated patent document. However, it also offers a broader perspective, revealing the main initiatives and policies related to the fight and control of forest fires, adopted by the Iberian institutions. We sincerely hope that this study helps to ensure that firefighting, a cross-border key-challenge, is approached from a broader perspective and that it benefits the Iberian population as a whole. Ana Bandeira José Antonio Gil Celedonio President of the Directive Director General at Spanish Patent Council at Portuguese Institute and Trademark Office, O.A. of Industrial Propriety, I.P 6
Executive summary The number of patent applications related to forest fires has progressively increased in the last decade throughout the world. In particular, in the past 5 years, patent applications related to forest fires have increased at an accelerated pace. Spain is the leading country in the European Union in the filing of patent applications regarding forest fires. In Portugal, there are several awareness campaigns put in place such as «Portugal Chama», which aims to raise people’s awareness to the problem of severe forest fires. Most of the patent applications filed regarding forest fires are not internationalised. Only a small percentage files for protection in other countries. Russia, Australia and Spain are not the top patent filing offices globally; however, they do stand out in the field of forest fires, ahead of other offices such as Japan or the European Patent Office (EPO). More and more inventions are related to the use of artificial intelligence and the use of drones in fighting and controlling forest fires. Portugal has several R&D projects in the field of prevention and detection of rural fires. These projects involve different technologies that meet the ones mentioned in patent documents identified in this study, such as aerial technologies, artificial intelligence and sensors. The fire extinguishing field is the sector with the highest number of patent applications filed, ahead of the detection and prevention field or the protection equipment field. Post-fire restoration is the least patented sector and therefore presents many opportunities for innovation. There is a link between the countries where more patents related to forest fires are filed and those where more fires occur, reflecting the fact that patents are a good indicator of the technologic development generated by social needs. 8
INDEX 1. INTRODUCTION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 1.1. Forest fires in the Iberian Peninsula. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 12 1.2. Spanish-Portuguese collaboration in the control of fires . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 Business incubator: FOIL-CILIFO . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 21 1.3. Purpose of the study. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 1.4. Using patent information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23 1.5. Methodology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 2. DETECTION AND PREVENTION OF FIRES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 2.1. Detection and prevention technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 30 2.2. Evolution of the industry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33 2.3. Relevant technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 35 Institution in the sector: Forestwise . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 38 R&D Projects on Detection and Prevention of rural fires in Portugal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40 Prevention and Detection of fires in Portugal – The opinion of the Agency for Integrated Rural Fire Management (AGIF, I.P.) . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 45 3. FIRE EXTINGUISHING . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 3.1. Fire extinguishing technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 3.2. Sector development. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 54 3.3. Relevant technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 56 9
Company in the sector: Drone Hopper . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58 Company in the sector: Nitrofirex . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61 UNE Standard 23530:2021 on long term Retardants . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 63 4. PROTECTION EQUIPMENT . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 66 4.1. Protection equipment technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 67 4.2. Sector development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 69 4.3. Relevant technologies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 71 Company in the sector: Vallfirest . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 73 5. POST-FIRE RESTORATION . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 76 5.1. Post-fire restoration technology . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 77 6. TECHNOLOGY AGAINST FIRES IN THE IBERIAN PENINSULA . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 79 7. CONCLUSIONS . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 82 ANNEX I. Glossary. Country codes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 85 ANNEX II. Search Strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 87 ANNEX III. List of figures and tables . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 89 10
01 INTRODUCTION
Introduction 1.1. Forest fires in the Iberian also publishes a daily evaluation of fire risk, Peninsula that combines the information of the annual map of fire risk with the daily weather Undoubtly rural and forest fires have a forecast. very significant impact on citizens and on natural heritage. It is also clear that Figure 1. Fire risk map for 20201 the effects of climate change, such as heat waves, desertification and other extreme meteorological phenomena, are increasingly visible and contribute in a large extent to the increased risk of forest fires. Climate change even adds to the longer risky season and to the prolonged heat and drought phenomena a bigger and faster accumulation of the fuel available to burn, which adds more obstacles to the management of this scourge. Therefore, there is a growing and clearly perceptible trend towards the rise of fire risk, of longer fire seasons and intense «mega fires» that rapidly spread and for which the traditional firefighting methods can do little. In the European Union, nine to ten fires are caused by man, either intentionally or by negligence or accident. Hence, the raising of public awareness and the use of educational campaigns about fire risk are fundamental to prevent such catastrophes. In Portugal, the Institute for Nature Conservation and Forests (ICNF, I.P.) produces every year, and at the beginning of each year, maps of fire risk, which indicate the areas that are most likely to be exposed to forest fires. These maps not only hold information on the risk of fire on a scale 1-5, but also indicate which areas over 500 ha have not burned for more than 10 years, in hazard classes «High» or «Very High» (Figure 1). With the same purpose of monitoring, prevention and risk analysis, the Portuguese The 21st annual report on forest fires in Europe, Institute for Sea and Atmosphere (IPMA, I.P.) Middle East and North Africa 2020, produced 1 21º annual report on forest fires in Europe, Middle East and North Africa 2020, produced by the Cross-border cooperation - European Commission in the prevention and forest fire extinguishing in the Atlantic axis (https://www.eixoatlantico.com/images/informes/secretaria_general/informe-incendios-ea_pt.pdf) 12
Introduction by the European Commission, shows that Figure 2. Distribution of burnt areas Romania was the most affected country, in Portugal in 20202 followed by Portugal, Spain and Italy. Specifically, in mainland Portugal the burnt surface in 2020 was 67,170 ha, which N represented about half the average of the last decade, which was 138,083 ha. In this timeframe, 2017 is a year worth noting, as it was the year in which fires in Portugal had an impact of unprecedented severity. This catastrophe triggered several structural, organising and operative measures, as well as the development of policy instruments related to the prevention and fight against rural fires, which have shown specific results. From the outset, it was approved in an extraordinary meeting of the Council LEGEND of Ministers, the change from the system Burnt area 2020 (>5 ha) (ICNF 15 October) that existed since 2006 into an Integrated District Management System of Rural Fires 0 25 50 km (SGIFR). The Agency for Integrated Rural Fire Management (AGIF), a public Institute, was also created, which is responsible for the integratedanalysis, planning, evaluation Comparing 2021 figures with the history of and strategic coordination of the SGIFR, the previous ten years, it is noted that there including the qualified intervention in were 54% fewer rural fires and 79% fewer high-risk events. burnt area, comparing the annual average over the same period. 2021 had, until 15 October, In 2020, the most affected area in Portugal the lowest number of fires and the second was the central region, with a total burnt lowest number of burnt area, since 2011. A area of about 32,000 ha, which represents change in the most affected geographical around half of the total registered in the regions is also highlighted, compared to 2020. Portuguese territory (Figure 2). In fact, From the district analysis, stood out with the the biggest fire of 2020 was yield exactly highest number of fires, and in descending in this region, with a burnt area of order, Porto (1,297), Braga (688) and Lisbon about 15,000 ha. Of fires with a specific (667). In either case, the fires were mostly cause, 38% were caused by intentional of small dimension (less than 1 ha of burnt acts (arson), while 50% were caused by area). Regarding burnt area, the most affected accident or negligence. The use of fire district was Faro, with 9,268 ha, about 34% for grassland renewal continues to have of the total burnt area until 15 October 2021, a considerable impact on the total area followed by Vila Real, with 4,041 ha (15% total) burned. and Braga with 2,117 ha (8% total) (Figure 3). 2 8th Provisional Report on Rural Fires – 2020 (https://www.icnf.pt/api/file/doc/7218b448c991d725) 13
Introduction Of the total of 7,610 rural fires in 2021, 6,438 Prevention is one of the main actions in the were investigated (85% of the total number fight against rural fires. Therefore, it is worth of fires, responsible for 96% of the total burnt mentioning a series of measures which area). Of these, the research allowed the were carried out with the goal of preventing attribution of a cause to 4,327 fires (67% of the and minimizing the impact of fires, such as investigated fires – responsible for 90% of the renovation and development of new water total burnt area). The most frequent causes reservoirs, the creation of new forest paths in 2021 were: negligent use of fire (47%) and and awareness-raising campaigns such as arson – attributable (23%), with relevance to «Portugal Chama»4 (Figure 4). The main goal the burning of forest or agricultural surplus of the latter is to warn about risky behaviour (20%), burning of heaps of forestry or and to raise public awareness in order to help agricultural waste (10%) and burning for cattle and protect the country from serious rural grazing management (14%). The reignitions fires. The work that is carried out in close represented 4% of the total of established cooperation with the population, through causes, a lower figure compared to the average the local authorities, in «Aldeia Segura» and of the previous ten years (17%).3 «Pessoas Seguras» programs, is also very important to create structural measures for Figure 3. Distribution of burnt areas in the protection of people and goods and to Portugal in 2021 raise awareness about the prevention of risky behaviour and self-protection measures. Figure 4. Portugal Chama Campaign5 N Also, in the context of «Portugal Chama» National Campaign, the project «Raposa Chama» was developed. It is a collective and LEGEND inclusive movement, designed for reaching all Burnt area 2020 (>5 ha) (ICNF 15 October) children and young people, aged 5 to 12, District 0 25 50 km through school, teachers, family and all community. With the seal of the Portuguese Republic and the collaboration of the Ministry of Education, the aim is to raise awareness and educate children and young people about fire 3 8th Provisional Report on Rural Fires – 2020 – 2021 (https://www.icnf.pt/api/file/doc/504914cdd1a211bb) 4 Campaign video at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k4wb-EH4poY 5 Image taken from https://portugalchama.pt/ 14
Introduction risk behaviour, believing that in the present Reinforcement Brigades (BRIF) also they can play a crucial role in raising awareness perform a very important job not only in among adults, mainly through their family raising public awareness but also in acting network. in situ, by carrying out actions aimed at fire prevention and extinguishing in the forest. In Portugal, The National Plan of Integrated Regarding BRIF (Figure 5), these highly Management of Rural fires 20-30 (PNGIFR) specialised squads of helicopter transport also stands out. The Plan introduces an can operate in any part of the country. innovative governance model of risk, These teams receive constant training and identifying the strategic goal and the coaching, which allows them to act in the measures to apply, clarifying the roles and most demanding situations and the most responsibilities of the different entities complicated fires. The mastery of all fire cooperating to achieve the goals set. It extinguishing techniques, including backfiring, intends to achieve a vision of a Portugal that is essential to their performance. is protected from severe rural fires, defining a strategy to achieve such goal, to which action Figure 5. Reinforcement Squad against forest programs will be associated, on national and fires of Tabuyo del Monte, at the extinguishing regional levels, with the annual setting of of a fire in Lobios (Ourense) on 08-08-20206 necessary goals and indicators, on which the PNGIFR monitoring will focus. In Spain, the 2020 figures were also lower than the average of the last decade. Specifically, the total number of fires decreased in about 30% (from 11,684 to 8,068), while the total burnt area decreased in about 32% (123,944 ha to 84,257 ha). In terms of geographical regions, the Northwest region was the most affected, both as regards the number of large fires and total area burnt, followed by Mediterranean and interior regions and Canary Islands. In the case of Spain, according to data of the General Statistics of Forest Fires (EGIF), As aforementioned, prevention and firefight which is the national database integrating measures are essential to minimise the forest fire reports from all over the impact that fires have on people and on country since 1968, the annual average, in environmental ecosystems. Community approximate figures, of forest affected area awareness has a key role in the prevention is 100,000 ha, from which, 2/3 are accidents of fires. During 2020, the travelling exhibition (casualties of less than 1 ha). Likewise, the «50 years of knowledge and prevention fire scheme in Spain is characterised by the of forest fires», created to celebrate the following indicators, among others: 50th anniversary General Statistics of Forest Fires, crossed the Spanish territory. h A high interannual and regional variability Wildfire Prevention Teams (EPRIF), the related to affected areas and number of Preventive Work Brigades and the Wildfire causalities (Figures 6, 7 and 8). 6 21st Annual Report on Forest Fires in Europe, Middle East and North Africa 2020, developed by the European Commission; Transborder Cooperation on the prevention and suppression of forest fires in the Atlantic axis (https://www.eixoatlantico.com/images/informes/secretaria_general/informe-incendios-ea_pt.pdf 15
Introduction h A high percentage of fires whose causes h A small number of events is responsible are associated with human action, where for a very significant part of the total of more than 50% of fires are intentional, forest area affected. Specifically, less than while fires due to natural causes account 0.2% of events comprise more than 40% for less than 5% of the total (Figure 9). of the total forest area affected. Figure 6. Evolution of the number of events and affected area. Period 1968-2015. Source: The forest fires in Spain. Decade 2006-20157. Page 6 500,000 30,000 Non-wooded area (ha) Wooded area (ha) 450,000 Number of events 25,000 400,000 350,000 20,000 300,000 Areas (ha) 250,000 15,000 Nº events 200,000 10,000 150,000 100,000 5,000 50,000 0 0 1984 1986 1974 1983 1985 1994 1976 1979 2004 1982 1978 1987 2000 2001 2010 1996 1999 2006 1990 2009 1973 1989 1998 1969 1975 2008 1980 1988 1968 1972 1993 2014 1977 1995 2003 2005 1992 1997 2002 2007 1970 1971 2015 1981 2012 2011 2013 1991 7 https://www.miteco.gob.es/es/biodiversidad/estadisticas/incendios-decenio-2006-2015_tcm30-521617.pdf 16
Introduction Figure 7. Evolution of the affected area by geographical area. Source: The forest fires in Spain. Decade 2006-20158. Page 18 Northwest Interior communities 120,000 50.000 Wooded area (ha) 45.000 Wooded area (ha) 100,000 40.000 Forest area (ha) Forest area (ha) 35.000 80,000 30.000 60,000 25.000 20.000 40,000 15.000 20,000 10.000 5.000 0 0 20062007200820092010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 20062007200820092010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Canary Islands Mediterranean 40,000 Wooded area (ha) 90,000 35,000 80,000 Forest area (ha) 30,000 70,000 Wooded area (ha) 60,000 Forest area (ha) 25,000 20,000 50,000 40,000 15,000 30,000 10,000 20,000 5,000 10,000 0 0 20062007200820092010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 20062007200820092010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 Figure 8. Monthly distribution of the total number of events throughout all decade, 2006-2015. Source: The forest fires in Spain8. Decade 2006-2015. Page 51 Northwest Interior communities 14,000 6,000 Fire outbreak Fire Fire outbreak Fire 12,000 5,000 10,000 4,000 8,000 3,000 6,000 2,000 4,000 2,000 1,000 0 0 y h il y t r ar uary arc Apr Ma June July gus be obe be r r r ar y y rch pril y e ly st er r er r nu r m be ar nu bru Ma A Ma Jun Ju ugu mb tobe mb mbe Ja Feb M Au pte Oct vem cem Ja Fe A pte Oc ve o ece Se No De Se N D Canary Islands Mediterranean 250 4,000 Fire outbreak Fire Fire outbreak Fire 3,500 200 3,000 150 2,500 2,000 100 1,500 1,000 50 500 0 0 y h il y t r r r r y h il y t r r ar uary arc Apr Ma June July gus be obe be r be r ar uary arc Apr Ma June July gus be obe be be nu r m nu r M m Au pte Oct vem cem Ja Feb M Au pte Oct vem cem Ja Feb e o e Se No De S N D 8 https://www.miteco.gob.es/es/biodiversidad/estadisticas/incendios-decenio-2006-2015_tcm30-521617.pdf 17
Introduction Figure 9. Forest fires by group of causes, 2006-2015. Source: The forest fires in Spain. Decade 2006-20159. Page 56 4.92% Lightning 2.20% 28.07% Replica Negligence and accidents 12.11% Unknown 52.70% 5 Deliberate D Furthermore, an increase of the risk indices (CCAA) resources, which are responsible for and of the intensity and dangerousness fire prevention and firefighting tasks, as well as for society of forest fires is foreseen in the the General Administration of the State (AGE) upcoming decades, as a consequence of the resources, which supports the former with a Global Change (climate change and change national coverage system. in the uses of territory), thus becoming more and more complex, dangerous and difficult Also, in the past years, the AGE as well as the to manage causalities, although the statistical CCAA have made a commitment to improve trends reflected in the General Statistics of management of forest fires through the Forest Fires indicate, at present, a reduction of contracting of IT development, communication the number of fires and of the affected forest platforms and technological resources, such area. as fire spread simulators, risk index calculation programs, big data analytics systems, day and As a consequence of the aforementioned, night forest fire monitoring platforms, etc. and responding to the legal mandate reflected in forest fires and in civil protection An example is the ARBARIA project, which legislation, Spain has developed, since the started to be implemented in 2020. This 1970s, a national system for prevention project consists of a computer system for and extinguishing of forest fires. It is forest fires analysis and forecasting, using professionalised, standardised and with a high artificial intelligence techniques associated number of personal and material resources, to machine learning and deep learning. including the Autonomous Communities ARBARIA uses historical data from forest fires 9 https://www.miteco.gob.es/es/biodiversidad/estadisticas/incendios-decenio-2006-2015_tcm30-521617.pdf 18
Introduction that occurred in Spain in the last decades, as 1.2. Spanish-Portuguese well as weather data and socioeconomical collaboration in the control of fires elements. Through two algorithmic models, ARBARIA allows to explain and predict the The forest ecosystems and the fires that weekly occurrence of fires regionally, as well threatens them are the same reality on both sides as to identify causal socioeconomical patterns, of the Spanish-Portuguese border. Fires that start providing very valuable information for fire at one country and cross the border causing extinguishing and prevention actions. severe damage in the neighbouring country are not rare. For example, the cross-border From the outset this project shows the area between Galicia and the north of Portugal importance of technological development in represents one of the geographical areas with fire control. As it is well known, the innovation the largest forest fire concentration of the Iberia and the Research and Development (R&D) are Peninsula (see Figure 10), which prompts the inseparable partners of Industrial Propriety, authorities of both countries to underline the and play a key role in the ability to adapt importance of reinforcing the cross-border quickly and effectively to the challenges operations in the fight against forest fires. humanity systematically faces. Therefore, the collaboration between Portugal Given the high level of uncertainty in the short, and Spain in the fight and prevention of forest medium and long term that the Global Change fires is of great importance. For example, casts, the Forest Fires Fight Commission in 2020, the same as preceding years, the approved, in 2019, the Strategic guidelines for Protocol of Technical Cooperation and Mutual the management of forest fires in Spain. These Assistance regarding Civil Protection and guidelines set out general, specific goals and the Additional Protocol on mutual help in priority courses of action that should inform border areas between Portugal and Spain the activities of all public administrations with were activated on several occasions, both competence in this area. In particular, the need in Portuguese and Spanish territory, with for improvement of the technology used in firefighting resources made available. the prevention and extinguishing of forest fires, identifying, among others, the systems Figure 10. Location of extinguished fires by of «fleet tracking, remote detection through the Ministry for the Ecological Transition and satellite or aero transported elements as well Demographic Right in 202010 as spectral image processing, simulation of fire behaviour, risk indices associated with forest, phenological and atmospheric variables, creation of fuel models, vulnerability, danger or habitability indices associated to the urban-forest interface, large historical series of data analysis (Big Data), improvement of the technical requirements for the use of fire in both fire extinguishing and fire prevention», among others. These institutional demands assume a motivation for innovation in the field of forest fires. 10 21st Annual Report on Forest Fires in Europe, Middle East and North Africa 2020, developed by the European Commission; Transborder Cooperation on the prevention and suppression of forest fires in the Atlantic axis (https://www. eixoatlantico.com/images/informes/secretaria_general/informe-incendios-ea_pt.pdf 19
Introduction The Common Strategy of Cross-border example of how a Spanish-Portuguese development also includes several measures association can work. It is a project that aimed at fire-fighting and prevention of fires, intends, through the expected results of its such as: activities, to become a permanent centre for development and promotion of training, h Reinforce the coordination of border awareness, research and cooperation in the resources linked to civil protection; sign fight against forest fires. Its main goals are: agreements between Civil Protection National Authorities to continue on h To reinforce and promote cooperation, developing the ARIEM project related to the working procedures and training between Civil Protection and Emergencies; adapt the the Devices of Prevention and Extinguishing action protocols between the firefighting of Forest Fires in the cooperation field and emergency teams on both sides of of the Euroregion Alentejo – Algarve – the border; facilitate the coordination of Andalucia). fire management, with the creation of the Iberian Center for the Investigation and h To promote the creation of sustainable and Fighting of Forest Fires (CILIFO). quality employment in the area of influence of the project; reduce the economic cost h Continue the cooperation on forest fires of fires by promoting the forest economy in the framework of existing protocols linked to the landscape. (Évora Protocol) and through the already established national and regional channels. h To improve the responsiveness to forest fires of entities and authorities involved The Iberian Center for the Investigation and in the fight against them in the three Fighting of Forest Fires (CILIFO) is a good participant regions. 20
Business incubator: FOIL-CILIFO 21
The Firefighting Open Innovation Lab-CILIFO (FOIL-CILIFO)11 is the first worldwide business and technology accelerator/incubator focused on the prevention and extinguishing of forest fires, adaptation and mitigation of climate change, created in the framework of the Iberian Center for the Investigation and Fighting of Forest Fires (CILIFO)12 project, financed by the European Union FEDER fund in 75% through the Cross-border Cooperation Programme Interreg VA Spain-Portugal 2014-2020 (POCTEP). The CILIFO project has a 24.6-million-euro budget. The incubator FOIL/CILIFO is managed by the Fundación Finnova as one of the beneficiary entities of the project13. The FOIL/CILIFO, besides representing an efficient work space, offers services in multiple fields. The accelerator not only offers the possibility to test innovative technologies with pilot tests, supporting the implementation of new ideas in the framework of euro-projects, but also allows consultancy and mentoring through experts, enabling the search of international partners and providing legal advice. The FOIL/CILIFO currently has 30 accelerated entities at a European level and three at an intercontinental level (México, Chile and Brazil). These initiatives are presented in «Innovative solutions catalogue». Since the 16 June 2021, the FOIL-CILIFO takes part in the EIT Climate KIC Open Accelerator - The ClimAccelerator, the accelerator of climate change accelerators, which enables that entities accelerated and mentored by FOIL-CILIFO, through Finnova, can have an international networking space with entities that are working on adaptation and mitigation of climate change, and other environmental issues. EIT Climate KIC is a European community of knowledge and innovation, supported and powered by the European Commission, to work on the transition to a carbon-neutral economy. In this context FOIL-CILIFO and EIT Climate KIC Open Accelerator are boosting several initiatives and project proposals where the prevention and extinguishing of forest fires is a priority issue. Furthermore, FOIL-CILIFO has been selected as the representative of Spain in the European Business Promotion Awards (EEPA) in category 4: «Support for the internationalisation of companies» and on the 16 November 2021 it was proclaimed the winner in this category at European level by the European Commission, in association with the Committee of Regions. 11 https://innovation.cilifo.eu/startups 12 https://cilifo.eu/ 13 https://finnova.eu/ 22
Introduction 1.3. Purpose of the study The report also includes explicit references to other subjects related to the control of Intended for both public and private fires in the Iberian Peninsula, such as research organisations related to the prevention, control projects, public-private partnership initiatives, and fight against forest fires, as well as the innovative companies or the recently published management and post fire restoration of UNE standard on long-term retardants, pioneer the affected ecosystems, this study aims to in Europe. analyse the evolution of patent applications filed in this technological field that have been published worldwide between 2010-2021. 1.4. Using patent information The report was elaborated by patent Patents are industrial propriety titles that grant examiners from the Portuguese Institute of its owner the right to prevent unauthorized Industrial Propriety, I.P. (INPI) and from the third parties to use their invention, whenever Spanish Patents and Trademarks Office O.A. this invention is new, inventive and industrially (OEPM), with the scientific-technical advice applicable. Nevertheless, in order for an from experts in the Academic sector as well inventor to obtain such right, in addition to as relevant national bodies with competence following a certain administrative procedure in the fight and control of fires in Spain and and paying annual maintenance fees for up to Portugal. 20 years, he must disclose the invention in the corresponding patent application. Four relevant technological fields were identified, each of which is the subject of a Therefore, patent documents constitute a separate section in this report: source of technological information with extraordinary value, since they are a means h Detection and prevention of fires. of dissemination in which an enormous number of inventions are recorded every year. h Fire extinguishing. Considering only the five most important patent offices in the world (European, h Protection equipment. American, Chinese, Japanese and Korean), the number of applications filed in 2020 rose to h Post-fire restoration. 2.8 million.14 Each section includes a detailed analysis of the Patent databases, many of them free of most innovative patent applications published charge, enable the access to the global between 2019-2021, as well as statistic analysis patent collection estimated in more than 130 on the development of the sector in the past million documents. The statistical analysis 10 years, reflected by patent applications of all this information provides indicators on published worldwide. Furthermore, a list of technological innovation in a specific field, patents considered to be the most relevant shows where the obtained research results are has been included, meaning those related to protected or who the main actors are, hence inventions which protection has been extended enabling to ascertain the competitors and to more than one country (2010-2021), and those with whom one should alliances. On the are therefore expected to have a greater other hand, a detailed analysis of published commercial and technological impact. patent applications enables to discover 14 https://www.fiveipoffices.org/statistics/statisticsreports/2020edition. IP5 Statistics Report 2020 Edition. 23
Introduction the most innovative technology and spot relevant to conduct a study from which technological trends. significative conclusions may be obtained and, consequently, as noted above, it was The information contained in patents provides decided to include in the report all the knowledge of great utility for decision retrieved documents that meet the search making in innovative companies, research requirements. public entities, other parties related to the commercialisation and transfer of technology, Between 2010 and 2021, 3,137 patent or utility as well as organisations responsible for model documents have been published in innovative public policies. the world, directly related to forest fires. In general terms (Figure 11), it is noted that the For the analysis of the obtained data, every number of published documents has been patent and utility model retrieved have progressively increasing throughout the been considered, without limiting it to those decade. In 2015, 61.26% more documents were forming part of International Patent Families, published than in 2010, and from that year given that the documents published in the onwards the number rises at an accelerated PCT system (Patent Cooperation Treaty), pace: in 2021, 357.66% more documents were in the European Patent Office (EPO) or published than in 2011. in more than one national office15, i.e., those that fall under the definition of the In 2020, a year marked by the COVID-19 International Patent Families, are only 378. pandemic, 58.30% more documents were This amount of publications does not seem retrieved than in 2019. Figure 11. Total patent documents on forest fires 2010-2021 505 508 333 319 275 228 205 189 179 159 111 118 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 15 Dernis et al., 2001; Harhoff et al., 2003; Van Pottelsberghe and van Zeebroeck, 2008; Frietsch and Schmoch, 2010; Martinez, 2011; Squicciarini et al., 2013; Dechezleprêtre et al., 2017). 24
Introduction Figure 12. Publishing Offices 2010-2021 GR 8 PT 8 DE 9 FR 11 GB 13 CA 18 JP 20 EP 44 ES 44 AU 47 US 87 WO 91 RU 99 KR 203 CN 2,392 0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500 76.25% of documents (patents and utility Specifically, in the field of forest fires, the models) were published by the Chinese Patent consulted databases16 reveal that 97.41% Office (China National Intellectual Property of retrieved Chinese applications refer to Administration, CNIPA), which corresponds innovations protected only in China. to a total of 2,392 documents. South Korea published 6.47%, Russia 3.16% and USA 2.77%. The country where the first application of a PCT international publications were 2.90%. The patent’s invention was filed is, frequently, the total number of shared documents by these home country of that invention. Thus, the offices can be seen in Figure 12. data about the countries where the patent or utility model application was filed, from Over the past few years, the Chinese which ulterior applications claim priority, government has been implementing different offers information on the geographical origin types of measures aimed at supporting the of the invention. In the field of forest fires, country’s innovation. That can explain the it is possible to observe that China is the high number of patent applications filed to country where most inventions have been CNIPA, related to several types of technology. filed between 2010-2021. Thus, it is of interest However, the great majority of these patent to study the data related to the country that applications are «domestic applications», claims priority excluding the documents that is, national requests which are not published in China, due to the reason subsequently internationally extended. mentioned in the previous paragraphs. 16 GPI (Global Patent Index). 25
Introduction Figure 13. Countries and Offices that claim priority of patent documents. China excluded 1,.19% 1.46% PT NL 1.6% 6.1% 28.51% GR Others KR 2.25% % FR R 2.39% EE 2.39% JP 3.18% % DE 3.18% GB 4.38% 116.58% EP US U 6.23% AU 6.76% ES 113.79% RU R Figure 13 shows that the countries with the The three applicants that have filed the highest highest number of inventions (after China) are number of published patent or utility model South Korea (28.51%), USA (16.58%), Russia applications have their headquarters in China (13.79%), Spain (6.76%) and Australia (6.23%). as shown in Table 1. As to Portugal, the obtained number is 1.19%. Table 1. Applicants with the highest number of patent applications Applicant Publications STATE GRID CORP CHINA 77 NANJING FOREST POLICE COLLEGE 47 UNIV NORTHEAST FORESTRY 45 26
Introduction Table 2. Applicants with the highest number of patent documents. China excluded Applicant Publications TYCO FIRE PRODUCTS LP (US) 17 FRS GROUP LLC (US) 14 NAT INST FOREST SCIENCE (KR) 10 JABE BEHEER B V (NL) 10 FEDERAL NOE G BJUDZHETNOE OBRAZOVATEL NOE UCHREZHDENIE VYSSHEGO 9 PROFESSIONAL NOGO OBRAZOVANIJA MO GU (RU) ARVILLE TEXTILES LTD (GB) 8 WILKENING DAVID W (US) 7 STS DEFENCE LTD (GB) 7 SMART PACKAGING SOLUTIONS SPS (FR) 7 SCHNARR MICHAEL S (US) 7 NIKOLAJEVA IRINA (RU) 7 MCLELLAN JOSEPH (US) 7 HULBERT DENNIS (US) 7 Excluding China, eight companies and one h Classification of the information retrieved individual are among the top nine applicants. in four technological fields: detection and After the 10th, the proportion of individual prevention, extinguishing, protection and applicants rises (Table 2). post-fire restoration equipment. It should be noted that the applicant’s country h Analysis of the information in patent of origin does not always correspond to the documents to spot the relevant country where the patent application has been technologies of each field. filed. h Statistical analysis 1.5. Methodology The patent classification systems used were the International Patent Classification (IPC) and The following steps were followed in the the Cooperative Patent Classification (CPC). preparation of the report: Both specific and less specific classifications of forest fires have been taken into consideration. h Definition of a search strategy with key These have been combined with key words to words and patent classification codes limit the search results obtained on the subject concerning technologies related to forest of the report.17 fires. The search has been concluded in full-text h Search on worldwide-specialized patent databases and patent documents that were databases, to which INPI and OEPM have not specifically aimed at forest fires have been access. discarded. 17 For more information on methodology, see Annex II. 27
Introduction The statistics have been performed with Furthermore, a list of patents relating to the Global Patent Index (GPI) tool of the inventions whose protection was extended to European Patent Office (EPO). These more than one country between 2010-2021 has statistics cover a larger period (2010-2021) been included. than the analysis of patent documents (2019-2021) and reflect the number of Both for the establishment of the technological inventions assigned to each technological fields to be analysed, as to the tracking of field, regardless of the fact that some of relevant patents, scientific and technical advice these inventions are also classified in other has been provided by national experts on the fields. control of forest fires in the Iberian Peninsula. 28
02 DETECTION AND PREVENTION OF FIRES
Detection and prevention of fires 2.1. Detection and prevention Application EP2741264A1 (BOEING CO technologies [US]) regards the «Forest sensor deployment and monitoring system», wherein soil sensor Detection and prevention technologies units are deployed in a forest from aerial concern the identification of a fire outbreak or vehicles and the collected information is determining the risk of a fire event. transmitted to a remote location for analysis. The application PT110537A (UNIV DE TRAS The interest in developing early warning OS MONTES E ALTO DOURO [PT]), with the systems and, therefore, investigate and title «System for remote detection of risk develop equipment and software to alert about situations», that comprises monitoring points these extraordinary events, should be taken distributed by sensor units that transmit into consideration in risk management. data to an unmanned aerial vehicle, also efficiently illustrates the relevance of these Seven technologies for the detection technologies. and prevention of fires are highlighted. These technologies are, in most cases, Artificial Intelligence and Machine learning interconnected, and the cases where only one of them shows up alone in a patent document There are several applications where data are rare. Since there is not a complete analysis and processing in fire detection is partitioning of technologies, it was decided processed, with artificial intelligence and to select the most determining technology machine learning technologies standing in each of the applications. Nevertheless, out. a subsection was created comprising applications where several technological Many technologies use artificial intelligence fields stand out, referred to as combined and machine learning to detect fire events technologies. through data analysis. For example, patent DETECTION AND PREVENTION Monitoring Stationary platforms IA and Machine Learning Aerial technologies Risk analysis Retardant products Sensors and Cameras Combined technologies Monitoring application WO2019048604A1 (FCM DIENSTLEISTUNGS AG [CH]) concerns an Monitoring is the field that stands out the «Automatic early detection of smoke, soot and most in fire detection and prevention, and fire with increased detection reliability using there is a high incidence of this innovation, machine learning» wherein an analysis is made specially detection. Technologies concern the from a smoke coloured-optimised pixel region supervision of a certain region with risk of by a detection algorithm that uses a machine forest fire. learning calculation model. 30
Detection and prevention of fires Still in this field, «An emergency response also disclosed, concerning «An emergency system and method» is disclosed in response system and method», that consists application WO2021174291A1 (STEPHEN of several sensors which, when sensing CHRISTOPHER COLIN [AU] et al.), that several emergency variables, communicate comprises sensors which sense emergency that information, through a communication variables that communicate with a server channel, to a server, which analyses those which analyses and determines how to variables, estimates the risk and determines respond to an emergency situation. A sensor the best way to respond to the emergency is also disclosed which, through artificial situation, by resorting, specially, to the use intelligence or machine learning, predicts the of drones. probability of ignition after a lightning. On the other hand, patent application As to patent application US2021260421A1 US2021142537A1 (GEN ELECTRIC [US]), (RAYA GIDEON [IL]), with the title «Fire with the title «Multi source geographic control and prevention», it uses sensors that information system (GIS) web based data detect certain parameters of animal activity visualization and interaction for vegetation and an analysis is made by a computerized management», consists of a system and module in order to identify fire escape method that receives the data from images behaviours, wherein that identification can about the vegetation of a certain region and be made by artificial intelligence. assigns scores to the fire risk of that region. Risk analysis Sensors and cameras Data analysis and processing is often used Technologies relating to sensors have as for purposes of performing a risk analysis, main goal the fire detection at an early estimating the likelihood of a forest fire stage. event. Patent application WO2019244094A1 Application WO2021091021A1 (ALCHERA (LADEIRA JOAO [PT]) with the title INC [KR]) describes a «Fire detection «Wildfire detection system and method system», capable of detecting in a quick using array of CO2 sensors and artificial and precise way the beginning of a fire in a intelligence», describes a sensorial unit certain region, using images and light flows for retransmitting the data, a server and captured by analysis modules that estimate a software with an algorithm projected the likelihood or the presence of fire, by for processing the incoming data and resorting to a classification system. Patent trigger the fire detection alarms at an early application US2014027131A1 (BOEING CO stage. The application AU2021105697A4 [US]), titled «Wildfire arrest and prevention (ACADEMY OF WATER RESOURCES system», claims an apparatus, operation CONSERVATION FOREST OF QILIAN controller and method, that enables the MOUNTAINS GANSU PROVINCE [CN]), control of unmanned aerial vehicles for with the epigraph «A Monitoring Device for detection, prevention and suppression Forest Ecological Environment» discloses a of fires in a designated area, through broader monitoring with high accuracy of information gathering and analysis, fire the air in forests, with an automatic video risk estimation and its extinction using and rapid positioning. Patent application the use of retardants. Patent application WO2021038407A1 (UNIV KING ABDULLAH WO2021174291A1 (STEPHEN CHRISTOPHER SCI & TECH [SA]), refers to a «Versatile COLIN [AU] et al.), mentioned previously, is optical fibre sensor and method for 31
Detection and prevention of fires detecting red palm weevil, farm fires, and collapsible web or frame structure, placed soil moisture» and consists of an integrated above the ground by a combination of system which includes an optical fibre to lifting balloons and positioning machines be applied on trees and an acoustic sensor for managing the elevation, the shape and connected to the optical fibre, configured the geolocation of the sunshade device. to process three optical signals, one to A sunshade management system controls determine the presence of red palm weevil, the said device, collapsing in the evening, the second to determine the temperature or on rainy or cloudy days, or when severe of the location and the third to determine weather-related events are detected the humidity, thus allowing to identify the (thunderstorms, earthquakes, etc.). presence of a fire. Also worth mentioning the application Camera image technologies are essentially WO2021091473A1 (HUGNORA INVEST & connected to detection and monitoring of TJAENSTEPRODUKTION [SE]), with the title smoke and flames in forests. «System and method for limiting spread of wildfire», that defines a fire limiting Patent application WO2018226128A1 area, positioning a plurality of droplet (GORYACHENKOV DMITRY generating units along the fire limiting area ANATOLYEVICH [RU]), with the title and connecting the units to a liquid source, «Video camera for the early detection of a forming a mist which is applied along the fire wildfire» comprises a housing with a rotating limiting boundary. mechanism, an image capturing sensor and a lens, which in turn are connected to Aerial Technologies a data transmission unit and to a remote monitoring console, capable of identifying Aerial technologies are present in the smoke and/or flames from wildfires. As spectrum of fire detection and prevention to patent application WO2020089541A1 through information gathering and (UNIV DE CORSE P PAOLI [FR] et al.), it transmission. refers to a «Device for characterizing a fire and associated method for determining Patent application KR20210072954 (KOREA radiant fluxes», that comprises at least one ELECTRONICS TECHNOLOGY [KR]), named stereovision system, comprising a first and «Disposable IoT System for distribution second image capturing unit and at least of Disposable IoT Terminal using drone» one processing unit configured to determine sets a disposable IoT (Internet of Things) at least one geometrical feature of the fire at device, equipped with one or more sensors, an early stage. at the lower end of a drone which is used to predict the spread of forest fires and Stationary Platforms monitoring reignitions. Stationary platforms are associated with A «Fire-fighting prevention and response structures or barriers that have as main goal system and method for using such a to hold and/or to stop the spread of forest system» is described in patent application fires. WO2020064923A1 (AIRBUS DEFENCE & SPACE SAS [FR]), in which drones that The application titled «Canopy For Climate communicate with a central station have And Solar Mitigation», US2021332604A1 a fire detection unit comprising a thermal (AINTABI JASON [US] ), discloses a camera and a fire response unit comprising reflective sunshade connected to a a container with gas. The drones also have 32
Detection and prevention of fires monitoring modules for a certain path and a composition for preventing wildfires», control module to trigger the response unit where the aqueous composition consists and communicate with the central station. of a fire retardant and fibrillar cellulose. Document US2021283439A1 Combined Technologies (RAPIDDEPLOY INC [US]) concerning the «Dispatching UAVs for Wildfire Surveillance», This subchapter addresses retrieved patent discloses an «interface» of unmanned applications that encompass, in synergy, aerial vehicles, wherein at least one of several technologies, described previously, said UAV has wildfire detection means. related to the detection and prevention of The UAV interface transmits an instruction forest fires. so that an UAV moves to the location of the potential wildfire, and receives Patent application US2019176987A1 data captured by, at least, one sensor. (BEECHAM JAMES E [US]), with the The system is capable of processing the title «System and method for fire received data and sending a wildfire alert. suppression via artificial intelligence» describes a computer enabled with Retardant Products artificial intelligence connected to several stationary and mobile sensors, that collect Technologies related to fire retardants data and communicate it to the system, have as main goal to slow down or to stop which indicates possible fires and takes the spread of flames. Patent applications action for the extinguishing of those fires that were found about fire retardants by resorting, namely, to drones. Patent describe, mostly, retardants that are used application WO2021010912A1 (TAYSI separately or that are part of the chemical OLCAY [TR]), whose title is «Early fire composition of the coating of buildings detection system and a detector suitable and structures which are intended to thereof», enables early detection of protect from possible fires. fires in different environments, through one or more detectors thrown from the Regarding isolated retardants, it is aerial vehicles, which are configured to worth mentioning patent application analyse collected data about humidity, US2021154502A1 (M FIRE HOLDINGS temperature, smoke, carbon/carbon LLC [US]), which refers to a «Method of dioxide and wind direction, and that obtain and system network for managing the energy from a solar panel. Finally, patent application of fire and smoke inhibiting application US2021232818A1 (AIDASH INC compositions on ground surfaces before [US]), with the title «System and method the incidence of wild-fires, and also of intelligent vegetation management» thereafter, upon smoldering ambers and claims a system that enables image ashes to reduce smoke and suppress fire data collection with aerial technologies, re-ignition», namely, a wireless mobile determining the fire risk on a given area, information network, that manages the by resorting to a convolutional neural application of a slurry composed of fire network. retardants and cellulose or wood fibre, mixed with water and other additives. 2.2. Evolution of the industry Patent application WO2020109654A1 (XPYRO OY [FI]) is also worth noting, Over the study period, 1,737 patent or which discloses a «Method and aqueous utility model documents were published 33
You can also read