New-Onset Guttate Psoriasis: A Long- Term Follow-Up Study

Page created by Barry Garza
 
CONTINUE READING
Research Article

                                                              Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                                                Received: February 1, 2022
                                                                                                                                          Accepted: October 20, 2022
                                                              DOI: 10.1159/000527737                                                      Published online: December 8, 2022

New-Onset Guttate Psoriasis: A Long-
Term Follow-Up Study
Eran Galili Shir Rubinstein Levy Ido Tzanani Oz Segal Anna Lyakhovitsky
Aviv Barzilai Sharon Baum

                                                                                                                                                                                Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
Department of Dermatology, Tel Aviv University, Tel Aviv, Israel

Keywords                                                                                          the end of follow-up period (mean 6.2 years [±3.1]), 49.1% (n
Guttate psoriasis · Psoriasis vulgaris · Autoimmune disease                                       = 59) of the patients reported active persistent psoriasis. A
                                                                                                  switch to the psoriasis vulgaris phenotype occurred in 17.5%
                                                                                                  (n = 21) of the study cohort. Persistent psoriasis was associ-
Abstract                                                                                          ated with male sex (OR = 2.1, p < 0.05), multiple disease flares
Background: Guttate psoriasis (GP), a distinct variant of pso-                                    (>3; OR = 9.1, p < 0.001), switch to the vulgaris phenotype
riasis, is more common in children and adolescents. The                                           (OR = 4.16, p < 0.001), and palmoplantar involvement (OR =
long-term course of these patients has sparsely been exam-                                        5.2, p < 0.01). Conclusion: A persistent disease course is com-
ined, with few studies reporting the rates of relapse, persis-                                    mon among patients with new-onset GP, with most retain-
tence, and further development of the psoriasis vulgaris                                          ing their guttate phenotype throughout the disease course.
phenotype. Objectives: The objective of this study was to                                         Persistency was associated with male sex, multiple GP flares,
characterize the long-term outcomes of new-onset GP and                                           switching to the vulgaris phenotype, and palmoplantar in-
elucidate the potential factors associated with a persistent                                      volvement.                              © 2022 The Author(s).
disease course. Methods: This was a retrospective cohort                                                                                     Published by S. Karger AG, Basel

study. Patients diagnosed with new-onset GP between 2009
and 2020 with a follow-up period of at least 1 year, were en-
rolled. The examinees were evaluated by dermatologists.                                               Introduction
Detailed data retrieved from the examinees’ medical files in-
cluded demographics, disease characteristics, treatment,                                             Guttate psoriasis (GP) is a variant of psoriasis that has
and comorbidities. A structured telephone questionnaire                                           distinct epidemiological, clinical, and histological charac-
was used to determine the current psoriasis status: type, se-                                     teristics. Unlike psoriasis vulgaris (PV), GP is more com-
verity, and extent. At the end of follow-up, patients with a                                      mon in children and adolescents than in adults [1], it af-
persistent disease course, defined as having lesions at least                                     fects people of all races, as well as men and women [2].
a year after disease onset, were compared with patients in                                        GP manifests as several small (2–10 mm diameter) “drop-
complete remission without further psoriasis symptoms. Re-                                        like” scaly plaques. As an immune-mediated disorder, its
sults: A total of 120 patients (mean age 28.8 years [±15.2],
58.3% women) with new-onset GP flare were identified. At                                          Eran Galili and Shir Rubinstein Levy contributed equally to this work.

Karger@karger.com       © 2022 The Author(s).                                                     Correspondence to:
www.karger.com/drm      Published by S. Karger AG, Basel                                          Eran Galili, egalily @ gmail.com
                        This is an Open Access article licensed under the Creative Commons
                        Attribution-NonCommercial-4.0 International License (CC BY-NC)
                        (http://www.karger.com/Services/OpenAccessLicense), applicable to
                        the online version of the article only. Usage and distribution for com-
                        mercial purposes requires written permission.
onset is typically 1–3 weeks following an acute infection,             sant, and phosphodiesterase 4 inhibitor), phototherapy, and topi-
such as streptococcal tonsillitis [3–5]. Immunohisto-                  cal steroids.
                                                                           Current psoriasis severity and extent were rated according to
chemical analysis of the tonsils and skin lesions in pa-               validated patient-reported scales: the Patient Global Assessment of
tients with GP demonstrated shared T-cell clones, sug-                 Psoriasis (PGA) scale and Patient Report of Extent of Psoriasis In-
gesting that GP is caused by autoimmune cross-reactivity               volvement (PREPI) scale collected from all study participants us-
to streptococcal antigen [6]. Additional risk factors for              ing a structured telephone questionnaire [14–17]. At the time of
GP include stressful life events and family history of pso-            interview, occurring at least a year since the first GP onset, those
                                                                       with psoriatic lesions within the last 3 months were defined as hav-
riasis [7]. Prognosis is considered better than other types            ing persistent psoriasis, while those without any psoriatic lesions
of psoriasis because of rapid involution even without                  within the last 3 months were defined as having complete remis-
treatment within a few weeks to months following its ap-               sion.
pearance [8].                                                              The PREPI scale is composed of a single question for measuring
   Data evaluating the natural history of GP are scarce,               body surface area (BSA) affected by psoriasis, “If you had to take
                                                                       the palm of your hand and cover up all of the patches of psoriasis
particularly the question of long-term outcomes. The re-               on your body today, how many palms of your hand do you think
ported rates of persistent disease course, lasting over a              that it would take?” Patients were also instructed that “One palm
year are 25–38.9% over a follow-up period of 5–10 years                of your hand is equal to about 1% of your BSA” and “Do not in-

                                                                                                                                                Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
[9–11]. Risk factors for a prolonged disease course could              clude areas in which psoriasis has faded, leaving only changes in
not be identified in most studies, possibly because of the             the color of the skin.” The PGA is a five-point severity scale, as
                                                                       previously reported, from 0 = clear to 4 = severe (very marked
small sample size [10]. Additionally, the risk of acquiring            plaque elevation, scaling, and erythema). Pruritus was rated using
the vulgaris phenotype is yet to be fully characterized. Pf-           the Itch Scale (“no itching” at the 0 point to “severe itching” at the
ingstler et al. [9] revealed that the risk of acquired vul-            10 end of the scale). The change in the clinical picture from the GP
garis was higher in patients with prolonged GP disease for             to PV phenotype was determined by the clinician based on chang-
a year. Svedbom et al. [12] and Ko et al. [10] reported op-            es in the clinical shape of the lesions from small guttate-sized pap-
                                                                       ules to large scaly plaques with one or more of the following: in-
posing findings, as a majority versus a minority of pa-                volvement of the extensor body parts, scalp, or palmoplantar sur-
tients with a persistent disease course had acquired the               faces. Patients were also questioned about having comorbidities:
Vulgaris phenotype. However, no previous study has re-                 arthritis (whether they were diagnosed by a physician or reported
ported the clinical importance of this event. In this study,           morning stiffness), diabetes, hyperlipidemia, hypertension
we aimed to evaluate the long-term outcomes of new-                    (whether they were given a physician diagnosis), and obesity (cal-
                                                                       culated BMI over 30). A follow-up period of less than 12 months
onset GP and to elucidate which factors are associated                 and other preexisting psoriasis variants served as the exclusion cri-
with a prolonged disease course and acquired PV pheno-                 teria.
type.                                                                      The authors confirm that the ethical policies of the journal, as
                                                                       noted on the journal’s author guidelines page, were adhered to.
                                                                       Ethical approval for this study was obtained from the Research
   Materials and Methods                                               Ethics Committee of the Sheba Medical Center (no. SMC-7082-
                                                                       20). Written informed consent was obtained from participants.
    This retrospective study included patients with first episode of
GP that occurred between 2009 and 2020. The patients were eval-            Statistical Analysis
uated by board-certified dermatologists at the Dermatology De-             Values are presented as mean (standard deviation) or number
partment of the Sheba Medical Center, Israel. The GP was diag-         (percentage). Categorical variables were compared using the χ2
nosed clinically. Detailed data were retrieved from the patients’      test, and continuous variables were tested using the independent
medical records. The data retrieved included demographics, dis-        samples t test. All statistical tests were two-sided, and statistical
ease characteristic and recurrence, treatments applied, response to    significance was set at p < 0.05. All data were included in an Excel
treatments, family history of psoriasis, and comorbidities. The GP-    document, and statistical analyses were performed using SPSS
flaring triggers were also recorded. The triggers were deemed rel-     (IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, version 23.0. Released 2015;
evant when they occurred up to 3 weeks before the GP flare. Acute      IBM Corp., Armonk, NY, USA).
streptococcal tonsillitis was diagnosed based on upper respiratory
tract symptoms with at least one of the following criteria: throat
culture positive for group A β-hemolytic Streptococcus or positive
antistreptolysin O (ASLO) titer (>200 μ/mL, taken up to 5 weeks           Results
from the onset of symptoms). Of note, the antibody level measured
by the ASLO titer starts to rise at 1–3 weeks after a streptococcal       Baseline Characteristics and Disease Course of the
infection and peaks at 3–5 weeks but cannot be detected at 5–6
weeks and thereafter [13]. Disease treatments were grouped based          Study Population
on reported product efficacy, with biological treatment being the         In total, 120 patients with new-onset GP were included
most potent, followed by oral agents (acitretin, immunosuppres-        in this retrospective cohort study. Mean age was 28.8

Guttate Psoriasis: Long-Term Follow-Up                                 Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                                      189
                                                                       DOI: 10.1159/000527737
Fig. 1. Prevalence of persistent psoriasis by
follow-up years. Rates of disease persisten-
cy remained elevated for the entire range of

                                                                                                                              Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
follow-up periods (lasting 1–12 years).

years (±15.2) with 58.3% females. A total of 36.1% of the      sistent disease was also associated with palmoplantar in-
patients had a family member with psoriasis. The upper         volvement at the first GP flare (OR = 3.1; CI, 1.0–9.4) or
respiratory tract infection (URTI) was regarded as a trig-     at least one of the GP flares (OR = 5.2; CI, 1.8–15.5).
gering event in 63.3% of the first GP episodes. During         Among patients with persistent disease, severe disease
follow-up, a single GP flare occurred in a minority of the     (BSA >10%) was not affected by the disease phenotype
patients (40.8%), while most patients had multiple GP          (43.8% of the PV phenotype vs. 25.6% of the GP pheno-
flares (2–3 flares, 26.7%; over 3 flares, 32.5%). Of all the   type, p = 0.18). However, the disease phenotype did affect
patients with GP, 17.5% (n = 21) further developed the         treatment potency, as 43.8% with the vulgaris phenotype
PV phenotype.                                                  compared to 11.6% with the guttate phenotype being
                                                               treated with oral or biological treatment (OR = 5.9; CI,
   Factors Associated with Persistent Psoriasis                1.5–23). Comorbidities, family history of psoriasis, or GP
   All study patients completed a telephonic question-         triggering factors were not associated with persistent dis-
naire to assess their current disease state. At that time      ease.
(average follow-up period of 6.2 years (±3.1)), persistent
psoriatic lesions were reported in 49.1% (n = 59) of pa-           Factors Associated with Acquired PV Phenotype
tients, while the rest had complete remission (50.9%, n =          Patients with only GP episodes (n = 99) were com-
61). Disease persistence remained high throughout the          pared with patients who acquired the PV phenotype (n =
follow-up period (1–12 years), as illustrated in Figure 1.     21), as reported in Table 2. The follow-up period was sim-
   Patient-reported disease severity scales were calculat-     ilar in both groups. Patients with multiple GP flares (>3)
ed for patients with persistent disease. A BSA of >10%,        were found to have higher odds of acquiring the PV phe-
indicating severe disease, was reported in 30.5% of the        notype than those with nontransformed GP (52.4% vs.
patients. The mean PGA was 1.6 (±0.8), and mean itch           28.3%; OR = 2.8; CI, 1.1–7.3; respectively). The PV phe-
index was 3.1 (±3.4) with 54.2% of the patients reporting      notype switch was underrepresented among patients with
consistent itchiness. Of those with persistent disease,        a single GP flare, compared to nontransformed GP (19.9%
72.9% retained the guttate phenotype, while the remain-        vs. 45.5%; OR = 0.28; CI, 0.1–0.9, respectively). Addition-
ing 27.1% acquired the vulgaris phenotype.                     ally, the PV phenotype was associated with scalp involve-
   Persistent disease was compared with disease remis-         ment in previous GP flares (81% vs. 50%; OR = 4.3; CI,
sion (Table 1). Persistent disease was associated with male    1.3–13.5). Furthermore, patients with the PV phenotype
sex (OR = 2.1; confidence interval [CI], 1.0–4.4), vulgaris    were more commonly prescribed potent treatment. Oral
phenotype switch (OR = 4.2; CI, 1.4–12.3), and having          or biological treatment at the first GP and over the disease
more than three GP flares (OR = 9.1; CI, 3.5–23.4). Per-       course, respectively, were prescribed in 23.8% and 42.9%

190                     Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                                Galili/Levy/Tzanani/Segal/Lyakhovitsky/
                        DOI: 10.1159/000527737                                      Barzilai/Baum
Table 1. Characteristics of patients with persistent GP versus complete remission

Characteristic                                           Persistent disease   Complete remission      OR        CI 95%          p Value
                                                         (N = 59)             (N = 61)

Follow-up, years, mean (SD)                              6.5 (3.3)            5.7 (2.9)               1.09      0.97–1.22       0.08
Age at first event, years, mean (SD)                     27.9 (14.3)          29.3 (16.3)             0.99      0.97–1.01       0.44
Female gender (%)                                        29 (49.2)            41 (67.2)               0.47      0.22–0.98       0.04
Family history of psoriasis                              25 (42.2)            18 (30.0)               1.71      0.80–3.65       0.16
Missing data                                             n=1                  n=1
Episodes, n (%)
    1                                                    7 (11.9)             42 (68.9)               0.06      0.02–0.15       0.001
    2–3                                                  20 (33.3)            12 (19.6)               2.09      0.91–4.80       0.07
    Over 3                                               32 (54.2)            7 (11.5)                9.14      3.57–23.38      0.001
Area involved
    Trunk                                                50 (90.9)            54 (94.7)               0.55      0.12–2.44       0.43
    Limbs                                                52 (94.5)            55 (96.5)               0.63      0.10–3.92       0.61
    Head                                                 24 (43.6)            28 (49.1)               0.80      0.38–1.68       0.56

                                                                                                                                             Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
    Diffuse                                              23 (41.8)            27 (47.4)               0.79      0.37–1.68       0.55
Missing data                                             N=4                  N=4
URTI anticipating GP flare
    At first GP episode                                  37 (62.7)            39 (63.9)               0.94      0.45–1.99       0.88
    At some GP episodes                                  41 (67.2)            41 (69.2)               1.11      0.51–2.40       0.78
        With confirmed streptococcal infection a         13 (65.0)            10 (40.0)               2.78      0.82–9.42       0.95
        Missing data                                     N = 39               N = 36
Hand and foot involvement
    At first GP episode                                  15 (30.0)            5 (12.2)                3.08      1.03–9.40       0.04
    At some GP episodes                                  21 (42.0)            5 (12.2)                5.21      1.75–15.52      0.002
Missing data                                             N = 18               N = 11
Scalp involvement
    At first episode                                     30 (50.8)            26 (43.3)               1.35      0.65–2.78       0.41
    At some GP episodes                                  38 (64.4)            28 (46.7)               2.06      0.99–4.31       0.05
Missing data                                             N=0                  N=1
Comorbidity, n (%)
    Arthritis                                            12 (20.3)            6 (9.8)                 2.34      0.81–6.71       0.10
    Hypertension                                         5 (8.5)              3 (4.9)                 1.79      0.40–7.85       0.43
    Hyperlipidemia                                       6 (10.2)             3 (4.9)                 2.18      0.52–9.19       0.27
    Diabetes                                             4 (6.8)              1 (1.6)                 4.36      0.47–40.24      0.15
    Obesity                                              5 (8.5)              6 (9.8)                 0.84      0.24–2.94       0.79
Disease state
    Transformed to vulgaris phenotype                    16 (27.1)            5 (8.2)                 4.16      1.41–12.27      0.006
Most potent treatment at first GP episode
    Topical                                              4 (7.0)              10 (16.9)               0.37      0.10–1.25       0.10
    Phototherapy                                         48 (84.2)            46 (78.0)               1.50      0.58–3.86       0.39
    Oral agentsb                                         5 (8.8)              3 (5.1)                 1.79      0.40–7.88       0.43
    Biological                                           0 (0)                0 (0)
    Missing data                                         N=2                  N=2
Most potent treatment along disease course
    Topical                                              5 (8.5)              10 (16.4)               0.47      0.15–1.47       0.19
    Phototherapy                                         42 (71.2)            43 (70.5)               1.03      0.47–2.27       0.93
    Oral agentsb                                         8 (13.6)             5 (8.2)                 1.75      0.54–5.71       0.34
    Biological                                           4 (6.8)              3 (4.9)                 1.40      0.30–6.57       0.66

   CI, confidence interval; GP, guttate psoriasis; OR, odds ratio; URTI, upper respiratory tract infection; SD, standard deviation; ASLO,
antistreptolysin O.

Guttate Psoriasis: Long-Term Follow-Up                                 Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                                    191
                                                                       DOI: 10.1159/000527737
Table 2. Characteristics of patients who initially presented with GP and acquired PV phenotype (n = 21) compared
      to patients with nontransformed GP phenotype (n = 99)

      Characteristic                                     PV (n = 21),     GP (n = 99),      OR        CI             p Value
                                                         N (%)            N (%)

      Follow-up, years, mean (SD)                        6.2 (2.6)        6.1 (3.2)         1.00      0.86–1.17      0.07
      Age at first event, years, mean (SD)               23.1 (14.5)      29.8 (15.3)       0.96      0.93–1.00      0.36
      Female gender (%)                                  11 (52.4)        59 (59.6)         0.74      0.29–1.92      0.54
      Family history of psoriasis                        11 (52.4)        32 (32.7)         2.26      0.87–5.89      0.08
      Missing data                                       N=1              N=2
      GP episodes, n (%)
          1                                              4 (19.0)         45 (45.5)         0.28      0.08–0.90      0.02
          2–3                                            6 (28.3)         26 (26.3)         1.12      0.39–3.20      0.82
          Over 3                                         11 (52.4)        28 (28.3)         2.78      1.06–7.29      0.03
      Area involved
          Trunk                                          18 (94.7)        86 (92.5)         1.46      0.17–12.65     0.72
          Limbs                                          18 (94.7)        89 (95.7)         0.80      0.08–7.66      0.85

                                                                                                                                 Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
          Head                                           8 (42.1)         44 (47.3)         0.81      0.29–2.19      0.67
          Diffuse                                        8 (42.1)         42 (45.2)         0.88      0.32–2.39      0.80
      Missing data                                       N=2              N=6
      URTI anticipating GP flare
          At first GP episode                            10 (47.6)        66 (66.7)         0.45      0.17–1.17      0.10
          At some GP episodes                            5 (23.8)         14 (14.1)         0.55      0.21–1.45      0.27
          With confirmed streptococcal infectiona        4 (66.7)         19 (48.7)         2.10      0.34–12.86     0.41
          Missing data                                   17               60
      Hand and foot involvement
          At first GP episode                            6 (35.3)         14 (18.9)         2.33      0.73–7.40      0.14
          At some GP episodes                            7 (41.2)         19 (25.7)         2.02      0.67–6.07      0.20
          Missing data                                   N=5              N = 24
      Scalp involvement
          At first episode                               12 (57.1)        44 (44.9)         1.63      0.63–4.23      0.30
          At some GP episodes                            17 (81.0)        49 (50.0)         4.25      1.33–13.54     0.01
          Missing data                                   N=0              N=1
      Comorbidity, (%)
          Arthralgia/Arthritis                           5 (23.8)         13 (13.1)         2.06      0.64–6.60      0.21
          Hypertension                                   1 (4.8)          7 (7.1)           0.65      0.07–5.64      0.70
          Hyperlipidemia                                 1 (4.8)          8 (8.1)           0.56      0.06–4.80      0.60
          Diabetes                                       1 (4.8)          4 (4.0)           1.18      0.12–11.19     0.88
          Obesity                                        1 (4.8)          10 (10.4)         0.44      0.05–3.67      0.44
      Most potent treatment at first GP episode
          Topical                                        2 (10.0)         12 (2.5)          0.77      0.16–3.78      0.75
          Phototherapy                                   14 (70.0)        80 (83.3)         0.46      0.15–1.39      0.16
          Oral agentsb                                   4 (20.0)         4 (4.2)           5.75      1.30–25.36     0.01
          Biological                                     0 (0)            0 (0)
      Most potent treatment along disease course
          Topical                                        3 (14.3)         12 (12.1)         1.20      0.30–4.72      0.79
          Phototherapy                                   9 (42.9)         76 (76.8)         0.22      0.08–0.60      0.002
          Oral agents b                                  5 (23.8)         8 (8.1)           3.55      1.03–12.25     0.03
          Biological                                     4 (19.0)         3 (3.0)           7.52      1.54–36.6      0.004

         CI, confidence interval; GP, guttate psoriasis; OR, odds ratio; URTI, upper respiratory tract infection; SD, standard
      deviation; ASLO, antistreptolysin O. a Throat culture positive for group A β-hemolytic Streptococcus or positive
      ASLO titer (>200 U/mL, taken up to 5 weeks from the onset of symptoms). b Acitretin, immunosuppressants, and
      phosphodiesterase 4 inhibitors.

192   Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                                              Galili/Levy/Tzanani/Segal/Lyakhovitsky/
      DOI: 10.1159/000527737                                                    Barzilai/Baum
of the patients with the PV phenotype versus 7.1% and          ment approaches. This seems unlikely from our study, as
11.1% of the nontransformed GP patients (ORs = 6 and           we found similar comorbidities in both GP and acquired
4.1; Cis, 2.1–17.5 and 1.6–14.5, respectively). Sex, family    PV phenotypes; however, there is a need for different
history of psoriasis, comorbidities, or GP triggering fac-     treatment potency.
tors were found to be associated with acquiring the PV            Other studies have also reported rates of chronic pso-
phenotype.                                                     riatic disease. However, these ambiguously define the
                                                               endpoint of the disease phenotype. Pfingstler et al. [9] re-
                                                               ported that in a retrospective cohort of 79 patients with
   Discussion                                                  GP, more than a single GP episode was regarded as equiv-
                                                               alent to plaque psoriasis, occurring in approximately 25%
    This study assessed the long-term outcomes of new-         of the patients. Martin et al. [11] reported that over a fol-
onset GP. In almost half of the patients (49.1%), persistent   low-up period of 10 years, 5 of 15 (33.3%) patients devel-
psoriatic lesions that presented more than a year after GP     oped persistent psoriasis. Furthermore, in their study,
onset were recorded at the end of follow-up. Although the      multiple GP events were recorded in most of the patients.
switch to the vulgaris phenotype was significantly associ-     While it is well documented that GP is associated with a

                                                                                                                                Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
ated with persistent disease, it only occurred in a minor-     family history of psoriasis [7], in our study, it did not pre-
ity of these patients. Overall, 17.5% of the patients devel-   dict a switch to the vulgaris phenotype or a persistent dis-
oped PV phenotypes during the follow-up period. Addi-          ease course. Additionally, the data from our study did not
tionally, persistent psoriasis was also associated with male   identify URTIs to be associated with persistent disease or
sex, over three GP flares, and palmoplantar involvement.       development of the vulgaris phenotype. This contrasts
    The long-term outcomes of new-onset GP have been           with the results of a study by Pfingstler et al. [9] who
rarely described. A recent comprehensive study by Sved-        showed that patients with the acquired vulgaris pheno-
bom et al. [12] prospectively evaluated 116 patients with      type were less likely to test positive for streptococci infec-
GP and reported persistent disease rates of 68% at 10          tion. However, only one subgroup of his cohort was test-
years of follow-up. Importantly, in our study, disease per-    ed for throat infections.
sistence remained elevated during the entire follow-up            Additionally, we identified several predictors associ-
period (up to 12 years), highlighting the clinical signifi-    ated with a persistent course of psoriasis. At the onset of
cance of this finding. Contrary to our findings, in the        GP, persistent disease course predictors were male sex
study by Svedbom et al. [12], the majority of patients with    and palmoplantar involvement. However, it is unknown
persistent disease ultimately acquired the vulgaris pheno-     whether early therapeutic interventions are helpful in
type. Ko et al. [10] also reported a persistent GP course of   lowering the risk of persistence. Along the GP disease
over a year in 38.9% of their retrospective cohort of 36       course over three GP flares, the acquired vulvar pheno-
patients. In line with our findings, only 15% of patients      type was also found to be associated with a persistent dis-
with a persistent disease course transformed to plaque         ease course.
psoriasis, while the rest remained with a guttate pheno-          This study has several limitations, including its retro-
type.                                                          spective nature, although of a considerably large scale.
    In our study, persistent disease end-phenotype affect-     Second, the endpoint disease severity and extent were
ed prognosis, as a significantly larger proportion of the      based on patient reports; however, validated scales were
PV phenotype needed oral or biological agents. To the          used [14–17]. Third, we could not differentiate between
best of our knowledge, this is the first study to assess the   bacterial and viral URTI triggers because these data were
clinical importance of acquired PV phenotypes among            unavailable for most patients. Further research is re-
patients with persistent GP. Although patient-reported         quired to validate our findings.
severity scales did not differ between the groups, they
were completed under treatment. In our study, well-
known psoriatic comorbidities were similarly distributed          Conclusions
among the entire spectrum of GP presentations, includ-
ing those who ultimately acquired the PV phenotype.               In a long-term follow-up study, a persistent GP course
Further studies are needed to assess whether the persis-       of greater than 1 year was common among patients with
tent GP phenotype should practically be regarded as            new-onset GP. A minority of patients with persistent dis-
“small plaque” PV, with similar comorbidities and treat-       ease acquire the vulgaris phenotype, with a negative im-

Guttate Psoriasis: Long-Term Follow-Up                         Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                              193
                                                               DOI: 10.1159/000527737
pact on disease prognosis. Persistent GP was associated                                Funding Sources
with male sex, over three GP flares, switch to the vulgaris
                                                                                       The study was conducted without funding sources.
phenotype, and palmoplantar involvement.

                                                                                       Author Contributions
   Key Message
                                                                                      Eran Galili and Sharon Baum: conception and design. Eran
   A persistent disease course was found to be common among
                                                                                   Galili, Shir Rubinstein Levy, Ido Tzanani, and Oz Segal: data ac-
patients with new-onset guttate psoriasis.
                                                                                   quisition and analysis. Anna Lyakhovitsky, Aviv Barzilai, and Sha-
                                                                                   ron Baum: supervision. All authors: critical revision and final ap-
                                                                                   proval of the version to be published.
   Statement of Ethics

   This study was approved by the Human Research Ethics Com-
                                                                                       Data Availability Statement
mittee of the Sheba Medical Center (No. SMC-7082-20) and was
conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki. Written
                                                                                      The data that support the findings of this study are available on

                                                                                                                                                                     Downloaded from http://karger.com/drm/article-pdf/239/2/188/3922414/000527737.pdf by guest on 22 June 2023
informed consent was obtained from participants.
                                                                                   request from the corresponding author. The data are not publicly
                                                                                   available due to privacy or ethical restrictions. Further inquiries
                                                                                   can be directed to the corresponding author, Eran Galili.
   Conflict of Interest Statement

   The authors have no conflicts of interest to declare.

   References
 1 Langley RGB, Krueger GG, Griffiths CEM.              7 Naldi L, Peli L, Parazzini F, Carrel CF. Family     13 Sato H, Ishikawa H. Unspecific increase of
   Psoriasis: epidemiology, clinical features, and        history of psoriasis, stressful life events, and       antistreptolysin-O titer in acute guttate pso-
   quality of life. Ann Rheum Dis. 2005;64(Sup-           recent infectious disease are risk factors for a       riasis. J Dermatol. 1977;4(5):187–91.
   pl 2):ii18–25.                                         first episode of acute guttate psoriasis: results   14 Valenzuela F, Paul C, Mallbris L, Tan H, Pa-
 2 Psoriasis G. Overview of Guttate Psoriasis,            of a case-control study. J Am Acad Dermatol.           pacharalambous J, Valdez H, et al. Tofacitinib
   Pathophysiology of Guttate Psoriasis, Epide-           2001;44(3):433–8.                                      versus etanercept or placebo in patients with
   miology of Guttate Psoriasis. 2020. (accessed        8 Durham GA, Morgan JK. A y-year follow-up               moderate to severe chronic plaque psoriasis:
   March 30, 2020) Available from: https: //              study of ninety patients with psoriasis. Br J          patient-reported outcomes from a Phase 3
   emedicine.medscape.com/article/1107850-                Dermatol. 1974;91(1):7–11.                             study. J Eur Acad Dermatol Venereol. 2016;
   overview#a3.                                         9 Pfingstler LF, Maroon M, Mowad C. Guttate              30(10):1753–9.
 3 Leung DYM, Travers JB, Giorno R, Norris                psoriasis outcomes. Cutis. 2016;97(2):140–4.        15 Shikiar R, Bresnahan BW, Stone SP, Thomp-
   DA, Skinner R, Aelion J, et al. Evidence for a      10 Ko HC, Jwa SW, Song M, Kim MB, Kwon KS.                son C, Koo J, Revicki DA. Validity and reli-
   streptococcal superantigen-driven process in           Clinical course of guttate psoriasis: long-term        ability of patient reported outcomes used in
   acute Guttate psoriasis. J Clin Invest. 1995;          follow-up study. The J Dermatol. 2010;37(10):          psoriasis: results from two randomized clini-
   96(5):2106–12.                                         894–9.                                                 cal trials. Health Qual Life Outcomes. 2003;1:
 4 Baker BS, Bokth S, Powles A, Garioch JJ, Lew-       11 Martin BA, Chalmers RJG, Telfer NR. How                53.
   is H, Valdimarsson H, et al. Group A strepto-          great is the risk of further psoriasis following    16 Dommasch ED, Shin DB, Troxel AB, Margo-
   coccal antigen-specific T lymphocytes in gut-          a single episode of acute guttate psoriasis?.          lis DJ, Gelfand JM. Reliability, validity and re-
   tate psoriatic lesions. Br J Dermatol. 1993;           Arch Dermatol. 1996;132(6):717–8.                      sponsiveness to change of the Patient Report
   128(5):493–9.                                       12 Svedbom A, Mallbris L, Larsson P, Nikamo P,            of Extent of Psoriasis Involvement (PREPI)
 5 Telfer NR, Chalmers RJG, Whale K, Colman               Wolk K, Kjellman P, et al. Long-term out-              for measuring body surface area affected by
   G. The role of streptococcal infection in the          comes and prognosis in new-onset psoriasis.            psoriasis. Br J Dermatol. 2010;162(4):835–42.
   initiation of guttate psoriasis. Arch Dermatol.        JAMA Dermatol. 2021;157(6):1–8.                     17 Raychaudhuri SK, Maverakis E, Raychaud-
   1992;128(1):39–42.                                                                                            huri SP. Diagnosis and classification of pso-
 6 Diluvio L, Vollmer S, Besgen P, Ellwart JW,                                                                   riasis. Autoimmun Rev. 2014;13(4–5):490–5.
   Chimenti S, Prinz JC. Identical TCR β-chain
   rearrangements in streptococcal angina and
   skin lesions of patients with psoriasis vulgaris.
   J Immunol. 2006;176:7104–11.

194                        Dermatology 2023;239:188–194                                                       Galili/Levy/Tzanani/Segal/Lyakhovitsky/
                           DOI: 10.1159/000527737                                                             Barzilai/Baum
You can also read