Musculoskeletal Injuries Related to Yoga: Imaging Observations
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
M u s c u l o s k e l e t a l I m a g i n g • C l i n i c a l Pe r s p e c t i ve Le Corroller et al. Musculoskeletal Injuries Related to Yoga Musculoskeletal Imaging Clinical Perspective Musculoskeletal Injuries Related to Yoga: Imaging Observations Thomas Le Corroller 1 OBJECTIVE. The purpose of this article is to describe the imaging appearances of mus- Alexandra T. Vertinsky culoskeletal injuries related to yoga. We performed an automated search in the database of a Rikin Hargunani large tertiary care center and conducted a retrospective analysis of the imaging findings in 38 Khalid Khashoggi patients over a 9-year period. Peter L. Munk CONCLUSION. The most frequently encountered musculoskeletal injuries were tendi- nous lesions, including tears of the supraspinatus, Achilles, and peroneus brevis tendons and Hugue A. Ouellette fibrocartilaginous tears involving the medial meniscus, acetabular labrum, glenoid labrum, Le Corroller T, Vertinsky AT, Hargunani R, Khashog- and lumbar disk with extrusion. gi K, Munk PL, Ouellette HA Y oga, a discipline developed 5000 scribe the specific appearances of musculo- years ago in ancient India incor- skeletal injuries related to yoga with imaging porating and uniting principles studies from a general population. of posture, breathing, and medi- tation, is thought to bring physiologic and Materials and Methods psychologic benefits to practitioners [1, 2]. This study was approved by our institutional Characterized as a science of self-study and review board with exemption status for individ- development of awareness through a series ual informed consent. A retrospective automated of specific asanas (body postures), pranaya- search in the database of a large tertiary care cen- ma (controlled breathing patterns), and med- ter radiology department was performed and re- itation, yoga has been embraced in modern ports generated for 2,175,000 consecutive imag- Western settings as a form of exercise and ing examinations from January 2002 to January stress reduction. 2011. Radiology reports were filtered for selection In the century since yoga was introduced of cases with yoga injuries by searching history, into the West, there has been a substantial pro- body, and impression for the term, “yoga.” Exclu- liferation in the number of schools of yoga. As sion criteria included duplicate cases and use of of May 2011, the Yoga Alliance, a profession- the word “yoga” out of context. Demographic data al credentialing body for yoga, listed 1220 ap- including age and sex of the patients, history, and proved schools in the United States and 26,690 imaging modality were recorded. registered yoga teachers. According to a 2008 Radiographic, sonographic, CT, and MRI Keywords: complementary and alternative medicine, survey, an estimated 6.9% (15.8 million) of studies obtained were reviewed in consensus by imaging, sports injuries, yoga people in the United States practice yoga [3]. one staff radiologist with 10 years of experience Additionally, another 4.1% (9.4 million) of in musculoskeletal imaging and three fellows in DOI:10.2214/AJR.11.7440 those who are not currently practicing yoga musculoskeletal radiology. Imaging analysis fo- Received June 28, 2011; accepted after revision said they would definitely try yoga during the cused on bone and soft-tissue injuries, including December 4, 2011. next year [3]. Currently, yoga programs are rel- fractures; dislocations; and muscular, tendinous, 1 atively low in cost; widely available in the form ligamentous, and fibrocartilaginous tears. Full- All authors: Department of Radiology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver General Hospital, 899 West of classes or through home video or book pro- thickness tendon tears were diagnosed when com- 12th Ave, Vancouver, BC, V5Z 1M9, Canada. Address grams; and, when performed properly, have lit- plete rupture of the tendon was noted [11–13]. Par- correspondence to P. L. Munk (peter.munk@vch.ca). tle risk of adverse effects. tial-thickness tendon tears were diagnosed when a Despite a large number of yoga practitio- defect in the tendon was noted and when there was AJR 2012; 199:413–418 ners worldwide, only a few case reports are evidence of at least some intact tendon fibers [11– 0361–803X/12/1992–413 available in the literature of injuries incurred 13]. The fibrocartilaginous tears were diagnosed by practitioners of this discipline [4–10]. To according to previously published MRI descrip- © American Roentgen Ray Society our knowledge, our study is the first to de- tions [14–17]. The selected patients were divid- AJR:199, August 2012 413
Le Corroller et al. ed into those with positive imaging findings and tear (4.3%, 1/23), and peroneus brevis par- TABLE 1: Imaging for 23 Injuries those with negative imaging findings. tial-thickness tear (4.3%, 1/23) (Fig. 1). Related to Yoga in Descriptive statistics were computed for all Fibrocartilaginous injuries represented 20 Patients study parameters in both groups with positive and 34.8% (8/23) of all injuries. The lesions in- Parameter No. negative imaging findings. Continuous variables cluded medial meniscus tears (8.7%, 2/23), were described by the mean and range and quali- acetabular labrum tears (8.7%, 2/23), gle- Imaging modality tative variables by the count and proportion. noid labrum tears (8.7%, 2/23), and lumbar Radiography 2 disk annular tears with disk extrusion (8.7%, Sonography 7 Results 2/23) (Fig. 2). Transient patellar dislocation CT 3 The term “yoga” was found in fifty-six ra- was observed in two cases (8.7%, 2/23) (Fig. diologic reports over a 9-year period at our 3). The other encountered injuries were one MRI 8 institution. The prevalence of the use of the disassociation of the polyethylene liner from Anatomic region word “yoga” was low in radiology reports its acetabular cup in a total hip replacement Knee 5 (0.000026%). Eighteen reports were exclud- (Fig. 4), one inguinal hernia, and one frac- Shoulder 4 ed, representing either duplicate cases or use ture of the proximal phalanx of the great toe. of the word “yoga” out of context. A solitary joint effusion was identified in two Hip 4 Thirty-eight patients (10 men and 28 other individuals. No other musculoskeletal Ankle 4 women; mean age, 46 years; age range, 19– injury was diagnosed. Spine 2 67 years) with acute symptoms related to Eighteen individuals (three men and 15 Abdominal wall 1 yoga were included in our study. The select- women; mean age, 46 years; age range, 19– ed patients were divided into those with pos- 67 years) presented negative imaging studies Elemental lesion itive imaging findings and those with nega- (47.4%, 18/38). These imaging examinations Tendon 8 tive imaging findings. included CT (n = 9), MRI (n = 4), radiography Fibrocartilage 8 There were 23 injuries attributable to yoga (n = 4), and sonography (n = 1). The anatom- Other 7 in 20 patients (seven men and 13 women; ic regions screened included the head in seven mean age, 45 years; age range, 19–67 years). cases; the spine in three cases; the wrist in two These imaging examinations included eight cases; the foot and ankle in two cases; and the life [1, 2]. Currently, the practice of yoga for MRI, seven sonographic, three CT, and two elbow, abdominal wall, hip, and leg in one case fitness and wellness in yoga studios, gyms, radiographic studies. The anatomic regions each. The most common symptom in our pop- and community centers is broadening into screened included the knee in five cases, the ulation was headache after yoga observed in yoga therapy provided in schools, communi- shoulder, hip, and ankle in four cases each, seven patients (18.4%, 7/38), which was con- ty treatment centers, and even hospitals. Al- the spine in two cases, and the abdominal sistently associated with negative imaging. though many clinicians remain unfamiliar wall in one case (Table 1). with the practice of yoga, a 2008 survey in- The tendinous lesions represented 34.8% Discussion dicated that 6.1% (14 million) of Americans (8/23) of all injuries. The lesions includ- Yoga classically aims at facilitating devel- said a doctor or therapist had recommended ed Achilles tendon partial-thickness tears opment and integration of the human body, yoga to them [3]. Yoga is recognized by the (13.0%, 3/23), supraspinatus tendon artic- breath, and mind to facilitate self-transfor- National Institutes of Health (NIH) National ular-sided partial-thickness tears (13.0%, mation at every level of functioning, with Center for Complementary and Alternative 3/23), supraspinatus tendon full-thickness the goal of improving the overall quality of Medicine (NCCAM) as a form of comple- A B Fig. 1—55-year-old woman. A and B, Longitudinal sonographic (A) and color Doppler (B) images show intratendinous tear (arrowheads, A) of Achilles tendon. 414 AJR:199, August 2012
Musculoskeletal Injuries Related to Yoga A B Fig. 2—Sagittal T1-weighted MR arthrography image Fig. 3—34-year-old man with transient lateral patellar dislocation. with fat-saturation shows tear of anterior acetabular A and B, Transverse (A) and coronal (B) proton density–weighted MR images with fat-saturation show bone labrum (arrowhead) in 36-year-old woman. marrow edema in medial aspect of patella (asterisks, A) and lateral femoral condyle (asterisk, B) in keeping with transient lateral patellar dislocation. mentary and alternative medicine (CAM) in [1, 2, 20]. However, given the great variabil- possibly resulting from muscle tension in the the category of “mind-body” medicine [18]. ity of yoga practices and teaching styles, cau- supporting musculature of the head and neck. Other surveys assessing the familiari- tion is required and yoga practices need to Flowing forms of yoga, for example ashtan- ty and acceptance of CAM practices by the be tailored to the individual. Albeit rare in ga, vinyasa, flow, or power yoga, are popular general public and medical practitioners re- the literature, a few yoga injuries have, in- and involve a repetitive connected and flow- port that yoga was ranked fifth of 39 ther- deed, been reported including, pneumome- ing sequence of postures that often requires apies in terms of its perceived effectiveness diastinum, traumatic lymphocele, cervical the practitioner to flex the shoulder joint with and document a growing trend of yoga prac- artery dissection, and various musculoskel- or without weightbearing on the hands. tice by adults and children, in particular by etal lesions [4–10, 35]. For instance, verte- In the setting of poor shoulder joint flex- children whose parents use CAM [19]. Be- bral artery dissection has been described af- ibility, the larger stabilizers of the shoulder sides, several studies have been conducted, ter minor head and neck trauma during yoga girdle, in particular the trapezius, rhomboid, with recent epidemiologic research indicat- practice [35]. Subcutaneous emphysema, air ing that many individuals perceive yoga to in the retroparapharyngeal spaces, and pneu- be beneficial for musculoskeletal problems, momediastinum have been reported after a mental health conditions, and overall health Valsalva maneuver during a yoga exercise [1, 20]. In particular, yoga has been exam- called pranayam [5]. In a similar fashion, ined in the management of asthma, chronic rectus sheath hematoma has been observed obstructive pulmonary disease, cardiovascu- after a pranayama session of yoga [6]. lar diseases, irritable bowel disease, eating Pranayama consists of breathing exercises disorders, anxiety, fibromyalgia, and even in whereby the breath is manipulated through children with attention deficit or hyperactiv- varying the actions of inhaling and exhaling ity disorder [21–28]. air, keeping the abdomen taut and relaxed Only a few works have focused specifical- alternately [6, 7]. In addition, progressive ly on the impact of yoga on musculoskeletal glaucomatous optic neuropathy with visual conditions, such as chronic low back pain, field loss was reported, related to the sirsasa- rheumatoid arthritis, hand osteoarthritis, na (headstand) yoga posture practiced daily or carpal tunnel syndrome [29–33]. Stud- for many years [36]. In the same way, mus- ies generally resulted in amelioration of pain culoskeletal injuries related to yoga, such and improved mobility. One MRI study even as pseudoarthrosis of the first rib and later- showed that a group of long-term practitio- al collateral ligament rupture, have been re- ners of yoga studied had significantly less de- ported [8, 9]. Thus, there is a need to provide generative disk disease than a matched con- clinicians with practical information about trol group [34]. yoga-related injuries. The popularity of yoga has created a need In our study population, headaches were for empirical studies to evaluate the limita- the most frequent yoga-related symptom re- tions and potential risks of yoga as a meth- quiring imaging. The frequent occurrence Fig. 4—Frontal radiograph of pelvis shows disassociation of polyethylene liner from its od of wellness. Yoga is thought to have great of headaches after yoga asana practice is not acetabular cup (arrowhead) in total hip replacement potential mental and physical health benefits surprising. Tension headaches are common, in 65-year-old woman. AJR:199, August 2012 415
Le Corroller et al. A B C Fig. 5—Yoga positions. A–D, Photographs show padmasana or lotus posture (A), eka pada sirsasana or leg behind head posture (B), salamba sirsasana or headstand posture (C), and adho mukha svanasana or downward facing dog posture (D). D and levator scapulae, can become overused sure through increased resistance to venous headaches from yoga practice is certainly and go into spasm in these yoga practic- drainage, although this is unlikely to affect the possibility of cervical artery dissection, es. Inverted postures, such as the shoulder healthy individuals. Heated forms of yoga which can result from minor trauma, in- stand (salamba sarvangasana) and head- (Bikram, Moksha, and hot yoga) are also cluding twisting or torquing motions of the stand (shirshasana) (Fig. 5) can also put sig- quite popular, and practitioners may experi- neck. Any patient presenting with headaches nificant strain on the neck when performed ence headaches due to dehydration or elec- should have a full neurologic examination, with improper alignment because the body trolyte imbalances from excessive sweating and head CT and CT angiography from arch weight is directed downward toward the in temperatures up to 108°F or may expe- to the circle of Willis should be considered in shoulders, head, and neck in these positions. rience symptoms from hyperventilation patients with neurologic symptoms. It is conceivable that such inverted postures or holding the breath during exertion. The Musculoskeletal injuries related to yoga can also cause slightly elevated intracranial pres- greatest concern in patients presenting with occur as a chronic repetitive strain injury, an 416 AJR:199, August 2012
Musculoskeletal Injuries Related to Yoga acute event, or a combination of an acute event movements performed in all forms of yoga. juries related to yoga can occur as a chron- superimposed on chronic strain. Anatomical- If an intervertebral disk is already degen- ic repetitive strain injury, an acute event, or a ly, tendons, myotendinous junctions, and fi- erated, forward folding movements can in- combination of an acute event superimposed brocartilages are the most vulnerable struc- crease pressure on the disk and result in a on chronic strain. In this article, we have re- tures to injury [6]. Yoga postures can be fairly disk herniation. Yoga practitioners who per- ported our experience with imaging of yoga demanding of flexibility and require strength form deep back bends may put pressure on injuries in a retrospective analysis of radio- of the stabilizing muscles to be performed the facet joints if the backbend is performed logic studies performed at our institution. We safely and provide benefits. Particularly in in an unbalanced fashion with accentuation have observed that tendons and fibrocartilag- large classes without adequate instruction, of the bend usually in the lower back. Be- es are the most vulnerable structures to injury new yoga practitioners may attempt to per- cause yoga is more commonly practiced by and have described yoga postures that may be form postures that their bodies are not ready women, we found a higher prevalence of this linked to the reported cases. to accommodate. Even if a movement or pos- injury in women in our population. ture does not elicit immediate injury, if per- In our study, injury was more frequent in References formed incorrectly, it can strain structures women (65%). Note that, given the usual sex 1. Posadzki P, Ernst E. Yoga for low back pain: a over time at the weakest point, which eventu- ratio in yoga classes, with between 80% and systematic review of randomized clinical trials. ally may progress to a frank injury. 90% women, men in our study were at relative- Clin Rheumatol 2011; 30:1257–1262 The rotator cuff is particularly vulnera- ly increased risk of injury during yoga [3]. Be- 2. Shannahoff-Khalsa DS. An introduction to ble in forms of yoga that involve flowing se- cause women tend to come to yoga with greater Kundalini yoga meditation techniques that are quences that put weight on the hands. Sun overall flexibility than men but less upper body specific for the treatment of psychiatric disorders. salutations (surya namaskar) are a common strength, men have an overall increased injury J Altern Complement Med 2004; 10:91–101 sequence of postures performed in flowing rate but women present a higher incidence of 3. Yoga Journal Website. Yoga Journal releases forms of yoga practice whereby the practitio- shoulder pain. In addition, men may also have 2008 “Yoga in America” market study. www.yo- ner moves from standing to the downward dog a tendency to “go for it” more. gajournal.com/advertise/press_releases/10. Ac- (ado mukha svanasana) position (Fig. 5) in a Some limitations may be considered in- cessed May 27, 2011 repeated fashion. The combination of move- herent to the materials and methods used in 4. Paul P. When yoga hurts: practicing it is supposed ment through postures while partially bearing this study. First, the population included in to make you feel better, but doing it wrong is dan- weight on the hands through different shoul- our study was obtained after a retrospective gerous. Time 2007; 170:71 der positions can result in impingement on the search in the database of our radiology de- 5. Kashyap AS, Anand KP, Kashyap S. Complica- rotator cuff, particularly the supraspinatus. partment for a specific keyword. This proba- tions of yoga. Emerg Med J 2007; 24:231 In the same way, excessive stretching of bly underestimated the incidence of yoga in- 6. Sharma H, Shekhawat NS, Bhandari S, Memon B, the Achilles tendon may occur in yoga pos- juries in our institution because cases could Memon MA. Rectus sheath haematoma: a rare tures that require squatting. However, giv- have been missed, misspelled, or misinter- presentation of non-contact strenuous exercises. en the lack of impact, the posture would be preted in the original radiology report. Sec- Br J Sports Med 2007; 41:688–690 unlikely to cause sufficient pressure to tear ond, we have to emphasize that the preva- 7. Johnson DB, Tierney MJ, Sadighi PJ. Kapalabhati the Achilles unless it was tight or already lence of yoga injuries in this study refers to pranayama: breath of fire or cause of pneumotho- strained. In the knee, excessive pressure is injury detection in a large consecutive popu- rax? A case report. Chest 2004; 125:1951–1952 particularly common in yoga practices that lation of patients undergoing imaging for an 8. Patel SC, Parker DA. Isolated rupture of the lat- involve variations of lotus position (padma- assortment of conditions. Our prevalence there- eral collateral ligament during yoga practice: a sana) or half lotus. In practitioners whose fore does not reflect the true prevalence of mus- case report. J Orthop Surg (Hong Kong) 2008; hip joints and groins are not flexible enough culoskeletal injuries in yoga practitioners. Fi- 16:378–380 to accommodate the external rotation re- nally, we do not have detailed information of 9. Tarazona Velutini P, Romo Rodríiguez R. Pseudo- quired for this posture, torque of the knee the preexisting medical conditions of the pa- arthrosis of the first rib in a patient who practices joint is common and results in compres- tients or of the detailed mechanisms of their in- yoga: a case report. [in Spanish] Acta Ortop Mex sion of the medial joint space, with chronic juries. In the same way, the years of experience 2009; 23:383–385 changes or acute tears of the posterior horn in yoga was not available in the report or clini- 10. Khalil PN, Ladurner R, Mussack T, Hallfeldt K. of the medial meniscus. cal notes for our patients. Traumatic lymphocele after yoga exercise. [in More advanced practitioners who perform The growing number of yoga schools in the German] MMW Fortschr Med 2008; 150:39 postures that put the leg behind the head West is evidence that this tailoring to differ- 11. Papatheodorou A, Ellinas P, Takis F, Tsanis A, (Fig. 5) may also experience stretching of ent needs, interests, and conditions persists. Maris I, Batakis N. US of the shoulder: rotator the lateral aspect of the knee joint that re- The process of matching and individualiz- cuff and non-rotator cuff disorders. RadioGraph- sults in strain of the iliotibial band, distal bi- ing yoga to each participant is quintessential ics 2006; 26:e23 ceps tendon, or lateral collateral ligament. In to yoga and is recommended for yoga class- 12. Wang XT, Rosenberg ZS, Mechlin MB, Sch- addition, the extreme abduction, flexion, and es, but it is an even more significant aspect of weitzer ME. Normal variants and diseases of the internal rotation required by leg-behind-the- yoga therapy. In the environment of burgeon- peroneal tendons and superior peroneal retinacu- head postures may result in tears of the ante- ing large yoga studios aimed at profit, the spe- lum: MR imaging features. RadioGraphics 2005; rior and lateral acetabular labrum. cific needs of the individual student are likely 25:587–602 The spine may be injured from either flex- to be missed, and physicians should be aware 13. Hartgerink P, Fessell DP, Jacobson JA, van Hols- ion (forward folds) or extension (back bends) of the potential for injury. Musculoskeletal in- beeck MT. Full- versus partial-thickness Achilles AJR:199, August 2012 417
Le Corroller et al. tendon tears: sonographic accuracy and charac- childhood asthma. J Asthma 1991; 28:437–442 care book for chronic low back pain: a random- terization in 26 cases with surgical correlation. 22. Fulambarker A, Farooki B, Kheir F, Copur AS, ized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med 2005; Radiology 2001; 220:406–412 Srinivasan L, Schultz S. Effect of yoga in chronic 143:849–856 14. Rakhra KS. Magnetic resonance imaging of ace- obstructive pulmonary disease. Am J Ther 2012; 30. Williams K, Abildso C, Steinberg L, et al. Evalu- tabular labral tears. J Bone Joint Surg Am 2011; 19:96–100 ation of the effectiveness and efficacy of Iyengar 93:28–34 23. Mamtani R, Mamtani R. Ayurveda and yoga in yoga therapy on chronic low back pain. Spine 15. Major NM, Browne J, Domzalski T, Cothran RL, cardiovascular diseases. Cardiol Rev 2005; 2009; 34:2066–2076 Helms CA. Evaluation of the glenoid labrum with 13:155–162 31. Dash M, Telles S. Improvement in hand grip 3-T MRI: is intraarticular contrast necessary? 24. Kuttner L, Chambers CT, Hardial J, et al. A ran- strength in normal volunteers and rheumatoid ar- AJR 2011; 196:1139–1144 domized trial of yoga for adolescents with irrita- thritis patients following yoga training. Indian J 16. Robinson G, Ho Y, Finlay K, Friedman L, Harish ble bowel syndrome. Pain Res Manag 2006; Physiol Pharmacol 2001; 45:355–360 S. Normal anatomy and common labral lesions at 11:217–223 32. Garfinkel MS, Schumacher HR Jr, Husain A, MR arthrography of the shoulder. Clin Radiol 25. Carei TR, Fyfe-Johnson AL, Breuner CC, Brown Levy M, Reshetar RA. Evaluation of a yoga based 2006; 61:805–821 MA. Randomized controlled clinical trial of yoga regimen for treatment of osteoarthritis of the 17. Grossman JW, De Smet AA, Shinki K. Compari- in the treatment of eating disorders. J Adolesc hands. J Rheumatol 1994; 21:2341–2343 son of the accuracy rates of 3-T and 1.5-T MRI of Health. 2010; 46:346–351 33. Garfinkel MS, Singhal A, Katz WA, Allan DA, the knee in the diagnosis of meniscal tear. AJR 26. Kirkwood G, Rampes H, Tuffrey V, et al. Yoga for Reshetar R, Schumacher HR Jr. Yoga-based inter- 2009; 193:509–514 anxiety: a systematic review of the research evi- vention for carpal tunnel syndrome: a randomized 18. National Center for Complementary and Alterna- dence. Br J Sports Med 2005; 39:884–891 trial. JAMA 1998; 280:1601–1603 tive Medicine Website. What is complementary 27. Carson JW, Carson KM, Jones KD, Bennett RM, 34. Jeng CM, Cheng TC, Kung CH, Hsu HC. Yoga and alternative medicine? nccam.nih.gov/health/ Wright CL, Mist SD. A pilot randomized con- and disc degenerative disease in cervical and lum- what is cam? Accessed May 27, 2011 trolled trial of the Yoga of Awareness program in bar spine: an MR imaging-based case control 19. Birdee GS, Legedza AT, Saper RB, et al. Charac- the management of fibromyalgia. Pain 2010; study. Eur Spine J 2011; 20:408–415 teristics of yoga users: results of a national survey. 151:530–539 35. Caso V, Paciaroni M, Bogousslavsky J. Environ- J Gen Intern Med 2008; 23:1653–1658 28. Abadi MS, Madgaonkar J, Venkatesan S. Effect mental factors and cervical artery dissection. 20. Birdee GS, Yeh GY, Wayne PM, et al. Clinical ap- of yoga on children with attention deficit/hyperac- Front Neurol Neurosci 2005; 20:44–53 plications of yoga for the pediatric population: a tivity disorder. Psychol Stud (Mysore) 2008; 36. Gallardo MJ, Aggarwal N, Cavanagh HD, Whit- systematic review. Acad Pediatr. 2009; 9:212–220 53:154–159 son JT. Progression of glaucoma associated with 21. Jain SC, Rai L, Valecha A, et al. Effect of yoga 29. Sherman KJ, Cherkin DC, Erro J, Miglioretti DL, the sirsasana (headstand) yoga posture. Adv Ther training on exercise tolerance in adolescents with Deyo RA. Comparing yoga, exercise, and a self- 2006; 23:921–925 418 AJR:199, August 2012
You can also read