KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010

Page created by Shannon Mccormick
 
CONTINUE READING
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
Keepin’ It Real: Tyra Banks’ Performance of Authenticity

                Obreanna McReynolds

               RFS 366: Hollywood Stars

                     May 14, 2010
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 1

       In a scene near the end of the Disney Channel original movie Life-Size, Tyra

Banks and a young Lindsey Lohan gossip conspiratorially in Lohan’s character’s

fictional bedroom. During this revealing conversation, Lohan offers Banks’ character

some prescient advice: “Perfect is boring,” she says. Puzzled, Banks asks, “So being a

role model doesn’t mean that I have to be perfect all the time?” On the contrary––as Tyra

Banks’ stardom illustrates––being a role model in the public eye oftentimes hinges upon

imperfection.

       Tyra Banks’ star text deftly negotiates the perfect and the imperfect, but public

reception of her persona remains mixed. Like Banks’ character in Life-Size, the American

audience seems perplexed by perfection––at once drawn to the extraordinary, and

repelled by it. As “both any woman and a one-in a million star,” able to “continuously

transform herself” from “girl next door to supermodel to sex symbol to media mogul,”

Banks proves a contentious figure (Joseph 241). Fans commend “Tyra” for her beauty

and authenticity, while critics call her “fat,” “crazy” and “fake.” This tug-of-war mirrors

the duality of Banks’ public roles: on the one hand, she exists as a supermodel, a

performer whose very job it is to present an appealing front. Switch on her afternoon talk

show, however, and another version of the star appears, one that shakes her booty, flaunts

her cellulite, and gossips like a girlfriend. The varied reception of Banks’ stardom reflects

this duality––a precarious negotiation between the real and the fake, the ordinary and the

extraordinary. Consequently, the discourse surrounding Tyra Banks the star has

everything to do with authenticity, a measure that hinges upon her performance of race,

gender, beauty, and a narrative of transformation.
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 2

                                                  Over the years the site of Banks’

                                          stardom has shifted from the realm of the

                                          “extraordinary”––her fairytale rise to fame as a

                                          trailblazing supermodel––to the “ordinary”––

                                          the candid persona she now presents to the

                                          public. The Banks of today is a television

                                          personality first, and a model second. For

                                          television personalities, the question of

                                          “perceived ordinariness and authenticity”

                                          becomes especially critical in understanding

“the way they function as a site of meaning” (Bennett 50). In Banks’ own words, her

function––the current Tyra Banks brand––represents “attainable fantasy,” the promise

that any ordinary woman can make her “dreams come true through work and

determination” (Hirschberg 63). Banks’ official website urges women, who make up the

bulk of her audience, to achieve this ideal by seeking “empowerment” and “beauty inside

and out” (“Tyra’s Bio,” Hirschberg 63). The “obtainable fantasy” message hinges upon

Banks’ ability to relate to her audience by demonstrating that her seemingly extraordinary

experiences are in fact no different from those of the average woman. The oft-repeated

story of the model’s rise to fame functions to reinforce this narrative by portraying Banks

as just another benefactor of the American dream.

       A 2008 profile in The New York Times Magazine details Banks’ rise from

working class roots: she “grew up in Inglewood, Calif., a racially mixed suburb near

LAX. Her parents were divorced and her mother, Carolyn London, supported Tyra and
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 3

her brother…” (Hirschberg 44). “Discovered” at the age of seventeen, Banks opted to

forgo college, and instead flew to France to pursue modeling. What may initially seem

like an unobtainable Cinderella tale is tempered by various reiterations of the difficulties

that Banks, marked as an outsider by both race and inexperience, faced upon arrival in

Paris. “I was too thin,” she recalls. “A little strange, odd-looking. My eyes are too far

apart, my chin is narrow, my forehead is very wide” (Ferguson).

       Despite these setbacks, the Banks narrative tells of how the young model

persevered with hard work and tenacity, transforming her initial disappointments into a

shining example of bootstraps success. When she

finally did start booking fashion shows––in record

number at that––Banks remained pragmatic, thinking

of her career as not just glamour, but a business

(Hirshberg 44). To that end, she abstained from the

drinking, drugs, and late night partying enjoyed by

fellow models, and chose instead to focus on planning

her future career path with the help of mother turned

manager Carolyn London.

       To the average woman, the tale of Banks’ initial struggle makes her eventual

accomplishments all the more relatable. She relied on traditional values of discipline and

family, rather than her physical attributes, to negotiate success. In fact, this telling frames

Banks’ unique look as an obstacle more than an aid. From the very beginning, it seems,

Banks shared the common woman’s insecurities about appearance, body shape, and

rejection. Moreover, by eschewing the wild lifestyle of high fashion Europe, she firmly
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 4

aligns against excess and frivolity, again driving home her middle-American values. Says

Banks, “I was successful, but I was intimidated by Paris… It was too much for my mass-

American self” (Hirschberg 44). This widely accepted account paints Banks as an

ordinary teenager who turned setbacks into advantages; as a result, the aspects of her

origins that might otherwise seem undeserved, lucky, or foreign become entirely relatable

and accessible. Both America’s Next Top Model and The Tyra Banks Show further

enforce the message of dreams and transformation within reach; Banks demonstrates to

young women that if they work hard and follow her example they too can “be on top,” as

the opening montage of Top Model promises.

       One scene stands out from the Banks biography as a particularly telling example

of how the star’s text is framed in terms of empowerment for the ordinary woman. In the

mid-nineties Banks started to gain weight. Her modeling agency reportedly created a list

titled “Designers who will not book Tyra because of hips and breasts” (Hirschberg 44).

Facing mounting pressure to shed pounds, Banks sat down with her mother over a slice of

pizza to discuss a career change. The star has repeated this tale relentlessly––on her talk

show, in interviews, and as a judge on America’s Next Top Model––each time

emphasizing the rebelliousness of the pizza, and the risk of defying fashion industry

norms. After that meeting, Banks decided to abandon the unforgiving world of European

haute couture in favor of more a body-friendly American market, a move that meshes

perfectly with her message of “beauty inside and out.” The choice also underlines Banks’

business acumen; her positioning as an advocate for curves has since been framed as an

astute career move, one that catapulted the star from mere clothes hanger to household

name entrepreneur. As model Veronica Webb explains to Vanity Fair, “That’s where the
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 5

                                         real action is in the fashion business: If you

                                         have great cleavage, you can make a fortune.

                                         When Tyra started to get really curvy, she

                                         signed a contract with Victoria’s Secret. For a

                                         black girl, that was incredible” (Hirschberg 45).

                                                 As Webb’s statement suggests, Banks

                                         reached the height of her modeling career in the

                                         early nineties during a period that “celebrated

                                         and hoisted up Colored-girl difference” (Smith-

Shomade 60). Besides Banks, other African-American faces––Halle Berry, Naomi

Campbell, Alek Wek, Brandy, Mary J. Blige––graced runways, products, and magazine

covers in record numbers (Smith-Shomade 60). Banks likewise transcended color as the

first African-American model to grace the covers of GQ and the Sports Illustrated

swimsuit issue.

       On the surface, this unprecedented level of representation suggested real progress

in America. And yet even as Banks was heralded for embodying “a universal appeal,” her

race remained the central defining factor of her fame. During this period, she was never

just a supermodel, but always the first black supermodel. Even as she symbolized

colorblindness, she also “embodie[d] niche desirability because of her positioning as a

racial specific, black female subject” (Joseph 238). Moreover, praise of the model’s

mocha skin functioned hegemonically to uphold the idea of “a near-white or lightly

complexioned black woman,” as opposed to one with darker skin, “as an image of

ultimate beauty” (Shaw 144). Perhaps mainstream American audiences found Banks
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 6

palatable because her brand of beauty downplayed racial differences, instead

emphasizing safe inner beauty––traditional values like self-esteem and work ethic––just

as much as, if not more, than the more progressive racial aspects of outward appearance.

As Ralina Joseph points out, “this tricky balance ultimately showcases race and gender as

malleable forces, deployed for strategic gain and untouched by structures and institutions

of racism” (238).

       In the decade and a half since her landmark Sports Illustrated cover, Banks’ race

has remained a “malleable force” for “strategic gain,” either highlighted or downplayed

in the media depending on how it jives with the Banks brand du jour (Joseph 283).

Publicity surrounding 2000’s Life-Size, for example, made no mention of Banks’ race

even as she acted alongside an otherwise all-white cast. In the film Banks plays Eve, a

plastic doll animated through a misdirected spell. Although the film never directly

                                         references Eve’s skin color, numerous incidents

                                         in which the character violates societal norms

                                         obliquely indicate her otherness. However, the

                                         overt focus of the film is, yet again, inner

                                         beauty, a tenet of the Banks brand that

                                         downplays her race. By contrast, when Banks

                                         appeared as a youth correspondent on The

                                         Oprah Winfrey Show between 1999 and 2000,

                                         several of her segments expressly addressed

                                         race-specific issues, highlighting ongoing

tension surrounding topics such as interracial dating (Sales 170). These more racially
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 7

conscious appearances set the tone for what would eventually develop into The Tyra

Banks Show.

        The discourse surrounding the supermodel’s race, as well as her authenticity, was

further complicated when she began to assume roles that revealed more facets of the “real

Tyra” than magazine covers or film appearances ever could. Specifically, the current

combination of The Tyra Banks Show in daytime and America’s Next Top Model in

primetime paints a complex picture of Banks that depends on performances of both

gender and race. America’s Next Top Model premiered in 2003, and marked Banks’ first

credit as a producer. Fifteen cycles later the hit reality program still adheres to its original

formula: a group of young women compete in the hopes of winning a modeling contract

that will grant access to a career path like Banks’. The Tyra Banks Show debuted two

years later in 2005, and over its five season run earned its namesake and host two

Daytime Emmy’s (“Tyra’s Bio”). Unlike modeling gigs, film roles, and scripted

television parts, these series gave Banks her first opportunity to truly play “herself.”

However, the selves that emerge from the respective shows hardly match, a fact that even

Banks admits to:

        There’s a Nighttime Tyra and there’s a Daytime Tyra…The Daytime Tyra is who

        I am…And then there’s Nighttime Tyra. The Nighttime Tyra is a character…A

        character that has been created over time––by me. (Sales 187)

Whether fabricated or not, the disjointed star image that results from concurrent viewing

of Top Model and The Tyra Show creates a very real conflict in the minds of audiences,

what Vanity Fair christens a “Jekyll-and-Hyde conflict” (Sales 169). Not every fan

possesses the motivation or resources to interrogate the reasoning behind Banks’
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 8

opposing personas; to the middle-of-the-road consumer, reality-television Banks and talk

show Banks are both equally “true” representations. This belief shades the reception of

the star’s performance of black femininity, which reads very differently depending on

which text she appears in.

       The “Nighttime Tyra” of America’s Next Top Model plays up the most

extraordinary, inaccessible aspects of Banks’ persona. Banks the judge enjoys a position

of absolute authority on the show, acting not only as a

producer, but also as a guru, instructor, and critic. To

this end, during the elimination segment of each Top

Model episode, Banks stands tall and still, and addresses

the contestants formally. The New York Times

Magazine’s Lynn Hirschberg describes Banks’ attitude

during these encounters as “quite stern and maternal:

she treats would-be models as if the rest of their lives

depended on their behavior during their time on the

show” (Hirschberg 45). In haute supermodel form, Banks comes across as powerful and

intimidating, not exactly the relatable everywoman who prefers pizza to couture. By

contrast, “Daytime Tyra” provides a mass-appeal answer.

        “Daytime Tyra” represents a much more “ordinary” iteration of the star, one that

faces hurdles because of her race and gender. James Bennett confirms, “Television

personalities’ ‘will to ordinariness’ insists that they position themselves as ‘just like’ the

audience in many ways” (37). Race-wise, the Banks of The Tyra Show “flavors her

performance with elements of black English,” her “hey girls” and idioms crafting a
KEEPIN' IT REAL: TYRA BANKS' PERFORMANCE OF AUTHENTICITY - OBREANNA MCREYNOLDS RFS 366: HOLLYWOOD STARS MAY 14, 2010
McReynolds 9

relatable image of a “sister next door” (Rudy 11). She also addresses issues of race

openly and often, with a whole series of “Focus On Race” episodes highlighting issues

such as “Kids & Race,” “Interracial Dating,” and “I Hate My Race.” These nods to color

serve to further “break down the separation between [Banks] and her audience” by

presenting the star as a relatable and “real” figure facing her own set of socially imposed

obstacles (Rudy 11).

       As for femininity, Tyra Show Banks frequently engages in “girl talk,” the practice

of sharing personal stories, making physical contact with her guests, maintaining eye

contact with the camera, and reacting to situations “in an emotional ‘no holds barred’

manner” (Rudy 8). These practices

“[create] a sense of intimacy between

viewer and performer,” and mark Banks

as uniquely in tune with women’s

concerns because she too must deal with

them (Bennett 41). As The Tyra Show’s

slogan promises, "Every woman has a

story...and it happened to Tyra too” (“Tyra’s Bio”). The take-home message, in other

words, is that despite inequity women of all colors (and all shapes, sizes, and

backgrounds) can, like Tyra, find empowerment through a focus on “inner beauty” and

sisterhood. In this way, the show “solves problems of racism, patriarchy, and

discrimination” by “magically equalizing all through multicultural celebrations of

‘women’” (Joseph 243). Again, race and gender are deployed for strategic gain––they
McReynolds 10

uphold the Banks brand, and support Bennett’s notion of the “will to ordinariness” at

work in the development of television stardom.

       Physical appearance, especially regarding fashion, further contributes to the

“Daytime/Nighttime Tyra” split. In a 2007 interview with People Magazine, the star

revealed that she deliberately dresses to suit her distinctive roles, again playing up her

femininity and race for The Tyra Banks Show:

       Banks admitted that her stylists on Top Model make a point to dress her in

       fashions that cover her problem areas, slim her figure and cinch her at the waist to

       create the illusion of a severe hourglass figure. On her talk show, however, Banks

       chooses shorter skirts and looser fabrics that showcase her full thighs and

       voluptuous breasts and hips and soften her entire appearance. (Rudy 12)

The acknowledgment that she consciously costumes and performs “Nightime Tyra”

would seem to confirm “Daytime Tyra” as the genuine article. However, the very

knowledge that “Team Tyra”––the name Banks uses to refer to her manager, agent,

publicist, and producers––deliberately manufacture “the whole dichotomy” calls into

question the authenticity of any representation of the star (Sales 170). As Lynn

Hirschberg points out, “Banks’ looks could be off-putting to her audience, but she

counteracts this possibility by accentuating her flaws” (42). Ebony’s Adrienne Samuels

agrees: “Tyra Banks goes to extraordinary lengths to show just how ordinary she is”

(Samuels). It seems conceivable to some that if Banks knows enough to manufacture a

strategic version of herself for America’s Next Top Model, then the face she presents on

The Tyra Banks Show might prove similarly disingenuous.
McReynolds 11

       Tabloids and gossip blogs capitalize on this uncertainty by undermining Banks’

overtures at “keepin’ it real.” Each of these sources promise a glimpse at the “true Tyra,”

a being that Banks purportedly would never share with her audience intentionally.

Allegations involving Banks hold particular import because they clash with the star’s

own well-documented account of self as presented on her talk show and in interviews.

When former Top Model judge and supermodel Janice Dickenson blasted Banks during

an interview on British television, American sources immediately picked up the story.

Dickenson questioned both Bank’s credibility as a television personality and her physical

credentials: “You could land a helicopter on her forehead…She’s a big woman. I used to

think she was a man,” Dickenson laughed (Castina). Adrianne Curry, winner of

America’s Next Top Model cycle one, also made headlines when she alleged that Banks

acted friendly and professional in front the cameras, but became “a diva” and “a bitch”

behind the scenes (Ingrid).

       One of the most popular moments of Top Model came during a Cycle Four

episode that seemed to, at least partially, confirm these allegations. In footage that has

since circulated under such telling titles as “Tyra Banks’ Tantrum” and “Tyra Banks

Gone Wild,” Banks furiously berates a Top Model hopeful whose eye-roll she interprets

                                                  as a sign of disinterest in the

                                                  competition. A 2006 Slate magazine

                                                  article aptly encapsulates the ferocious

                                                  tone that made the clip go viral: "‘I have

                                                  never in my life yelled at a girl like this!’

                                                  screamed Tyra, her face contorted, her
McReynolds 12

auburn coif swinging. "I was rooting for you, we were all rooting for you. How dare

you!’” (Dahl). “Team Tyra” categorized the incident as just one more example of Banks’

status as a “flaws and all” everywoman. This attempt to reframe the scandal proved

largely unsuccessful, however; four years later the representation of Banks as a “wild”

unruly woman still fascinates critics. In its 2010 list of “Top 9 Reality TV Temper

Tantrums,” for example, E! Online exclaims, “We knew Tyra was outspoken. It's not

even a shock when she's loud. But Tyra yelling?!” (Heldman and Nessif). The angry

Banks captured in this footage proves so intriguing because she breaches both poles of

her public persona; this Banks is neither the staid mentor/authority figure of Top Model

nor the affable, flawed-but-friendly “sister next door” seen on The Tyra Banks Show.

       Rather, this Banks seems disingenuous, out of control, even “crazy,” as some

                                    commentators contend (Samuels). The image of

                                    Banks as an unruly woman was further compounded

                                    in February 2007 when the gossip website Egotastic

                                    posted unflattering images of the star vacationing in a

                                    one-piece bathing suit under the blunt heading “Tyra

                                    Banks is Fat.” The unfortunate photos quickly

                                    saturated the Internet and gossip magazines, leading

                                    to all kinds of mean-spirited headlines, including

                                    “Tyra Pork Chop” and “America’s Next Top Waddle”

(Ferguson). Many media outlets used the unflattering pictures to insinuate that Banks was

not only a failure in her chosen profession, but also a hypocrite and a fraud. As a

supermodel, Banks made a living by disciplining her body; as a panelist on Top Model,
McReynolds 13

she judges hopefuls on their ability to do the same. Even on The Tyra Banks Show she

preaches beauty inside and out. Allegations about her weight go hand in hand with her

portrayal as an unruly woman; the archetype is characterized by a physicality that refuses

to adhere to cultural norms (Petersen).

       To critics, such contradictions severely undercut Banks’ authenticity. As Bennett

suggests, “the television personality’s success is predicated on ensuring the audience

believes there is a ‘perfect fit’ between their ‘real’ persona and the television personality

as image” (38). Especially for a performer playing herself, a disruption of this perceived

seamlessness can prove toxic. Initially, the “fat Tyra” photos were just that; they

undermined Banks’ “attainable fantasy” narrative by displaying a side of the star that

revealed too much of the ordinary, and not enough of the fantastical. In Shaded Lives:

African-American Women and Television, Beretta Smith-Shomade suggests that “rarely

does television ‘do fat’,” especially in the case of black women, who are already once

removed from mainstream standards of physical beauty by their skin color (60). Those

overweight women who do receive representation “are stigmatized as unfeminine,

rebellious,” and deviant, much like Banks (60).

       Considering the importance of all these characteristics––transformation, fantasy,

feminine beauty, and mainstream values––to Bank’s star persona, Team Tyra quickly

sprang to the defensive. The events that followed Egotastic’s harsh pronouncement

marked an attempt to refocus the “fat Tyra” scandal to sustain, rather than violate, the

Banks brand. Soon after scandal broke, Banks appeared on her talk show wearing the

infamous unflattering swimsuit, and tearfully told critics to “Kiss my fat ass!” She invited

her audience to join her “So What?” movement, a new rally against the number on the
McReynolds 14

                                     scale. Banks made the rounds on other talk shows as

                                     well, using each mention of the tabloid brouhaha as

                                     an opportunity to promote empowerment, self-

                                     esteem, and body love. These efforts not only

                                     managed the threat to Banks’ public persona, but in

                                     many cases bolstered it by reframing her as a

                                     positive role model for young women.

                                             The rhetoric of Banks’ talk show revelation

                                     particularly reinforced the narrative of her stardom.

In a February 2007 episode of The Tyra Banks Show entitled “Tyra Confronts Her Fat

Tabloid Photos,” “Daytime Tyra” reiterates the

importance of overcoming obstacles through hard work

and family, offering thanks for “a good support

system…my Mama [who] has helped me be a strong

woman so I can overcome these kinds of attacks.” She

underlines her ordinariness by admitting her personal

flaws: “People are used to seeing me looking…like all

that…but for some reason people have a serious

problem when I look like that [sticking out her stomach and grabbing her behind].” Then,

most importantly, she takes the personal public, employing girl talk and “sister next

door” finger-wagging as she issues a challenge “to all of you who have something nasty

to say about me, about women who are built like me…women who have been picked on,

women whose husbands put them down, women at work or girls at school.” Finally, in
McReynolds 15

the defiant voice of no-nonsense “Nighttime Tyra” she declares, “You can kiss my fat

ass!”

        For many, the “Fat Ass” episode increased Banks’ credibility as a “real” woman.

The reframing of the star’s embarrassment in terms of self-esteem bolstered sympathy

and audience sisterhood, and succeeded in marrying the disparate elements of Banks’

personas around a central theme. An April 2007 profile in Great Britain’s The Guardian

identifies this common thread by crowning Banks “the queen of self-esteem and body

image––every woman's girlfriend…the flaws-and-all friend fans love” (Ferguson). As

Ralina Joseph points out, “The Banks ‘fat scandal’ is emblematic of the manner in which

women, and specifically women of color, are consumed and spat out in the popular

sphere” (238). With Banks standing as the cheerleader for female empowerment, women

of all types can unite behind her.

        However, even as it strengthened Banks’ fan base, the “So What?” movement

also served to bolster the criticism against her. To some, her attempt to monopolize body-

love read as opportunistic and, once again, disingenuous. Though the star has taken up

weight discrimination as a cause––incorporating it into both her talk show and America’s

Next Top Model––her sincerity is undercut

on several levels. First, Top Model

presents serious causes like body image

and eating disorders alongside issues of

such little concern to the vast majority of

the viewing public as imitation designer

handbags, thus effectively trivializing the
McReynolds 16

former. In addition, one episode of The Tyra Show showcases Banks’ attempt to reveal

size-ism in America by going “undercover” in a fat suit. These undercover forays ––

Banks also moonlights as a homeless person and as a man––undermine the star’s

authenticity, speaking once again to her ability, and willingness, to transform, and to take

on any cause that will attract viewers. Therefore, while Banks’ fans may read her post-

“Fat Ass” star text in a positive light, detractors perceive her actions as an abuse of her

newfound power as an advocate for empowerment. Some call her “melodramatic antics”

self-serving and maudlin; certainly, they render her “an easy target for the blogosphere

and shows like E!’s The Soup” (Stack). Blog “Pop on the Pop,” for instance, disparages

Banks as “self-absorbed and fake,” while users on a public forum at Oxygen.com call her

“full of herself, pitiful,” “fake,” and “vain” (“Top Model Obsessed”).

       Naturally, Banks’ loyal fans spring to her defense––“Tyra Banks is an awesome

person…she helps people find the inner beauty that everyone has”––by defending her

persona (“Top Model Obsessed”). Banks remains a celebrity figure exactly because of

the conundrum of her stardom, illustrated again and again in message board debates like

these. To detractors she is either she is too real (“fat” and “crazy”) or not real enough

(“fake”). At best, the public discourse surrounding her performances of race, gender and

transformation render the star at once extraordinary because of her looks, and yet still

relatable because of her personal defects and can-do attitude. Fans revel in this “Tyra-

world where beauty is within everyone’s reach,” secure in the belief that each

transformation represents one step closer to the “real” Tyra Banks (Samuels).

       Ultimately, Banks enjoys continued stardom because of the intrigue sparked by

this dissent. In fact, Banks’ narrative of “obtainable fantasy” resonates exactly because it
McReynolds 17

speaks to a larger cultural shift toward imperfection, which serves as a marker of

authenticity. By bringing celebrity within the reach of the average citizen, both the

Internet and reality television blur the boundary between the ordinary and the

extraordinary. Beyond America’s Next Top Model, popular shows like American Idol,

America’s Got Talent, and The Biggest Loser, as well as websites like YouTube,

celebrate the obstacles, achievements, and quirks of ordinary people. These texts uphold

the populist belief that anyone with determination, and perhaps a bit of talent, can achieve

star status. Despite her extra-textual scandals––or more likely, because of them––Tyra

Banks confirms this conviction. Banks’ stardom offers a heartening success story to a

public that simultaneously covets and rejects the extraordinary aspects of celebrity; after

all, Banks managed to transform from an average woman into a superstar, and then back

again. Today, as a television personality who projects “sister next door” authenticity,

Banks proves a study in contrast, but as such, also serves as a prime example of a

uniquely American ideal of authenticity.
McReynolds 18

                                       References

America’s Next Top Model, Seasons 1-15. The CW. 2005-2010. Television.

Bennett, James. “The television personality system: televisual stardom revisited after film

       theory.” Screen 49.1 (Spring 2008): 32-50.

Castina. “Janice Dickenson blasts Tyra on British TV.” [Weblog entry.] PopCrunch. 21

       February 2010. (http://style.popcrunch.com/janice-dickinson-slams-tyra-banks-

       on-british-tv-i-thought-she-was-a-man/). 24 April 2010.

Dahl, J.E. “Is Tyra Banks racist? The peculiar politics of America’s Next Top Model.”

       Slate. 18 May 2006. 3 April 2010. /.

Ferguson, Euan. “The supermodel turned spokeswoman.” The Guardian. 15 April 2007.

       .

Heldman, Breanne L., and Bruna Nessif. “Top 9 Reality-TV Temper Tantrums.” E!

       Online. 30 March 2010. 3 May 2010. < http://www.eonline.com/uberblog/

       b174160_top_9_reality-tv_temper_tantrums.html>.

Hirschberg, Lynn. “Martha. Oprah. Tyra: Is she the next big female branded self? The

       New York Times Magazine (June 1, 2008): 38-45, 58, 62-63.

Ingrid. “Adrianne Curry Disses Tyra Banks.” [Weblog entry]. Crushable. 10 January

       2006. (http://crushable.com/entertainment/adrienne-curry-disses-tyra-banks/). 25

       April 2010.

Joseph, Ralina L. “’Tyra Banks is Fat’: Reading (Post-)Racism and (Post-) Feminism in

       the New Millennium.” Critical Studies in Media Communication 26.3. (August

       2009): 237-254.

Life-Size. Dir. Mark Rosman. Pacific Motion Pictures Corporation, 2000.
McReynolds 19

Petersen, Annie H. “Star Types.” Whitman College. Walla Walla, WA. 4 Feb. 2010.

Rudy, Jessica. "When Worlds Collide: Tyra Banks and Spheres of Performance" Paper

       presented at the annual meeting of the NCA 94th Annual Convention, San Diego,

       CA, Nov 20, 2008.

Sales, Nancy Jo. “How Tyra Banks Catwalked her Way from Mannequin to Mogul.”

       Vanity Fair (2007): 168-70, 186-88.

Samuels, Adrienne P. “Tyra Unexpected: smart but not cheap, Tyra Banks swears she’s

       just an ordinary lady.” Ebony. Dec. 2008. 2 April 2010 

Shaw, Andrea. “The Other Side of the Looking Glass: The Marginalization of Fatness

       and Blackness in the Construction of Gender Identity.” Social Semiotics 15.2

       (August 2005): 143-52.

Smith-Shomade, Beretta E. Shaded Lives: African-American women and television. New

       Jersey: Rutgers University Press, 2002.

Stack, Tim. “Tyra Banks: America’s Next Top Mogul.” Entertainment Weekly. 19 Feb.

       2008. 

The Tyra Banks Show, Seasons 2 and 3. The CW. 2007-2009.

“Top Model Obsessed.” Message board. 1 June 2009. Oxygen Boards. 24 April 2010.

       .

“Tyra Banks Gone Wild.” 24 February 2006. Online video clip. YouTube. Accessed 25

       April 2010. .

“Tyra Banks is Fat.” [Weblog entry.] Egotastic. 3 Jan 2007. (http://www.egotastic.com/

       entertainment/celebrities/tyra-banks/tyra-banks-is-fat-002038). 5 April 2010.
McReynolds 20

“Tyra Banks is so fake.” [Weblog entry.] Gallery. Pop on the Pop. 29 June 2009.

       (http://poponthepop.com/gallery/tyra-banks-is-so-fake/). 25 April 2010.

“Tyra’s Bio.” The Tyra Banks Show. 2010. Web. 23 April 2010. .
You can also read