Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics

Page created by Yolanda Hubbard
 
CONTINUE READING
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                             ISSN: 1548-7741

              Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From
               Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics

          Velvizhi V*1, Vijayalakshmi K.B. 1, Porkodi M1, ,1 Muruganathan U1 Asha K.R.T. 1,
                     Department of Biochemistry Government arts college Paramakudi
                                            *Corresponding Author

            Dr. Velvizhi V, Guest lecture, Department of biochemistry, Government arts college
                                   paramakudi. E-mail: velvizhig4@gmail.com

      Abstract
              Bougainvillea glabra is one of the most important ornamental plant mainly growing in
      garden and rich in red and pink pigments. In the present study, the dyeing pigments present in
      flowers of Bougainvillea glabra were extracted by using four different solvent extraction
      methods (acidic Bath, aqueous bath and alcohol bath at 1000C). The three different mordents
      (Ferrous sulphate, coppersulphate and stannous chloride) were used to set isolated dye on
      cotton fabric by forming a - ordination complex. The result revealed that, different shades of
      pink and yellow color were obtained from the dye when subjected to mordent. The sample shows
      the presence of certain colored product (Grey, yellow and light pink). The resultant sample was
      treated with cotton fabric, the color get deposited, after repeated washing the color remain the
      fabrics without any change. Thus, the color dye extracted from pink bougainvillea glabra flowers
      can be used for coloration of Cotton fabrics as a natural dye.
                                         Introduction
               Colors in the day to day life of man are very prominent and unavoidable. It is associated
      in the form of colored dress materials, hair, furnishings, upholstery etc. Dyes are mainly of two
      types: natural and synthetic. As far as natural colors and dyes are concerned, India has a very
      rich tradition of using natural dyes and also virtual monopoly in their production and
      applications. Dyeing & printing was a craft up to the middle of nineteenth century. There are
      many references in the literature and calico printing is an example. References are also available
      for silk dyeing with natural colors in China before 2600 BC [1].
              Dyes are one of the most important uses of the plants. Recently, interest in the use of
      natural dyes has been growing rapidly due to the result of stringent environmental standards
      imposed by many countries in response to toxic and allergic reactions associated with synthetic
      dyes. As a result with a distinct lowering in synthetic dyestuff costs, the natural dyes were
      virtually unused at the beginning of twentieth century [2]. Nowadays in most of the countries,
      natural dyeing is practiced only as a handcraft and synthetic dyes are being used in all

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                            1024                                         www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                               ISSN: 1548-7741

      commercial dyeing processes. However with the worldwide concern over the use of eco-friendly
      and biodegradable materials, the use of natural dyes has once again gained interest [3].
             Dyeing of cotton and silk with henna, indigo, marigold etc. is reported. [4]. There is a
      growing interest in the revival of natural dyes in textile coloration. In contrast, natural dyes are
      environmental friendly, exhibit better biodegradability and generally have a higher compatibility
      with the environment than synthetic dyes.
             . Synthetic dye is not easily degradable and bio-accumulated in natural environment. It
      has been estimated that, nearly 10, 00,000 tons of synthetic dye were used per annum. The
      synthetic dye may cause pollution, skin diseases, health hazards to human and other important
      organisms [5]. Hence the use of eco friendly and biodegradable dye has main concern in
      worldwide. The natural dyes from plants were traced long time ago. In India 450 plants are found
      to be good source of natural dye [6]. For the extraction of natural dye different plant parts are
      used such as seeds, flowers, leaves and barks. In the present study, an alternative dye yielding
      plant Bougain villeaglabra flower were studied for its potentiality for obtaining natural dye.
      Bougain      villeaglabra       is    a      one     of     the     most      attractive     and
      cutflower, which is mainly used as anornamental flower. Bougain villeaglabra has thinner
      branches that spread in many directions and have distinctive pointed triangle shaped bracts that
      come in a range of whites, lilacs, mauves, and purples [7].
                                     Materials And Method
      i. sample collection:
            The Bougainvillea glabraplant collected from garden.

      Sample Extraction:
      (i) soxhlet extraction:
              The Soxhlet extraction was described by Franz Von Soxhlet (1879).
      III. Phytochemical Analysis:
                      The determination of Carbohydrate was described by the Molicsh 1980. The
               detection of Polysterols was described by the reducing sugar: (Fehling’s solution test),
               Test for alkaloids: (Dragendorff’s test), The of saponin was characterion by the
               Paclitaxel. The assessed of flavonoids by Anderson ( Lead acetate test), Test for steroids
               :( Liebermann-Burchard’s test), The dection of Phenol was determined by method of
               Hertog (1950). Protein was described by the method of Siegfried Ruhemann in 1910
               (Biuret test). Column Chromatography was analysed by Govindaraj and Vivek (8), Uv-
               Spetrocopy by Jain et al. (9).
      Gc-Ms (Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectroscopy):
      Dye Praparation:

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                             1025                                         www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                           ISSN: 1548-7741

      Materials Required:
             Source-Fresh flowers of Bougainvillea glabra collected from paramakudi area.
             Substrate -The 100 % soft cotton fabric was used as substrate.
             Chemical Mordant -The different chemicals such as Ferrous Sulphate (FeSO4), Stannous
      Chloride (SnCl4), Copper Sulphate (CuSO4), 95 % ethanol.

      Methods:
      Extraction of dye from petals Extraction of color dye was carried out by four different methods.
      Aqueous Extraction Method:10 gm. fresh petals of bougainvillea glabra were boiled in 100 ml
      distilled water at 1000C for 30 minutes. The decolorized petals were taken out from extraction
      solvent.
      Alkaline extraction methods:
                  In alkaline extraction method, 10 gm. fresh petals were boiled in 1 % Sodium
                   hydroxide for 30 minutes.
                  The decolorized petals were taken out from extraction solvent. Finally, filter the
                   solution and used for further study.
      Acidic Methods:
                  In acidic extraction method, 10 gm. fresh petals were treated with 1 % of acidic
                     solution boil at 1000C for few minutes. Finally, filter the solution and used for
                     further study.
      Alcoholic Extraction Methods:
                  In alcoholic extraction method, 10 gm. fresh petals were boiled in 50 % alcohol
                     for 30 min. filtrate was used for further study.
      Scouring Of Cotton Cloth:
                  Cotton cloths used for dyeing were boiled in 10 % NaOH solution for 10 min. to
                   remove starch and other impurities from the cloth. The NaOH treated cotton
                   cloths were then thoroughly washed with cold distilled water.
                  Dyeing and mordanting the clean scouring cotton cloths were treated with
                   different Mordent such as Ferrous Sulphate (FeSO4), Stannous Chloride (SnCl2)
                   and Copper Sulphate (CuSO4).
      RESULT:
      III. Phytochemical Analysis:

      Test for carbohydrate    Test for reducing sugar Test for tannins

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                           1026                                        www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                           ISSN: 1548-7741

        Test for saponin            Test for phenol          Test for alkaloid
      Phytochemical (Figure 2.) A-aqueous,B-chloroform,C-ethanol

      Table: 1

        Phytochemicals               Water             Chloroform                Ethanol

        Carbohydrate                 +                 -                         +
        Reducing sugar                +                +                         +
        Alkaloids                     -                -                         +
        Saponins                      -                +                         +
        Tannins                       -                -                         +
        Flavonoids                   -                 -                         -
        Steroids                     +                 -                         -
        Terpenoids                   -                 -                         -
        Phenols                      +                 +                         +
        Antrhaquinones               +                 -                         -
        Glycosides                   -                 +                         -
        Phlobotannins                -                 -                         -
        Protein                      +                 -                         +

                   Present (+), Absent (-)
      VI. UV-Vis Spectroscopy:
      i) The absorption of extraction in UV-Vis analysis :( Table: 2)

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                              1027                                   www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                          ISSN: 1548-7741

      S.no   Cell name               Concentration(µg)    Absorption
      1.     Stock solution          10 µg/ml             0.470 µg/ml
      2.     Working solution        1 µg/ml              0.043 µg/ml

            The Stock solution was 10µg/mlabsorpted in 0.470µg/ml and working solution was
      1µg/mlabsorpted in 0.043µg/ml.
      VII. GC-MS Analysis Report:
              The GC-MS analysis and identified of component in nitrogen, hydrazine, Acetic acid,
      hydrazine, (S)-(-)-2 Chloropropionic acid, Methylamine,Succinic anhydride,Carbon
      monoxide,Nickel tetracarbonyl,N-Metyl-2,2 bis (trifluorometyl) aziridine,Butanedioic acid
      cyclic hydrazide.,Carbonic dihydrazide, Nitrogen fluoride, Ethyl hydrogen oxalate, Amino
      acethydrazide, Carbonyl sulfide, Propane, Formic acid, ethenyl ester, Methyl alcohol,
      Aminocyanoacetic acid, Hydantoin
      The Identified Of Component Structure:
             Figure 3, 4 A an B shows that the presence of components are Nitrogen, Hydrazine,
      Acetic acid, hydrazine(S)-(-)-2 Chloropropionic acid, Methylamine, Succinic anhydride, Carbon
      monoxide, Nickel tetracarbonyl, N-Metyl-2,2 bis (trifluorometyl) aziridine, Butanedioic acid
      cyclic hydrazide, Carbonic dihydrazide, Nitrogen fluoride, Ethyl hydrogen oxalate, Amino
      acethydrazide, Carbonyl sulfide, Propane, Formic acid, ethenyl ester, Methyl alcohol,
      Aminocyanoacetic acid, Hydantoin were identified.

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                           1028                                       www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science          ISSN: 1548-7741

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                           1029     www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science          ISSN: 1548-7741

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                           1030     www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                   ISSN: 1548-7741

      S.no      Compound name                Formula       Molecular   Structure
                                                           weight
      1.        Nitrogen                     N2            28
      2.        Hydrazine                    H4N2          32

      3.        Acetic acid, hydrazine       C2H6N2O       74

      4.        (S)-(-)-2 Chloropropionic    C3H5CIO2      108
                acid

      5.        Methylamine                  CH5N          31

      6.        Succinic anhydride           C4H4O3        100

      7.        Carbon monoxide              CO            28
      8.        Nickel tetracarbonyl         C4NiO4        170

      9.        N-Metyl-2,2 bis              C5H5F6N       193
                (trifluorometyl) aziridine

      10.       Butanedioic acid cyclic      C4H6N2O2      114
                hydrazide

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                            1031                             www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                             ISSN: 1548-7741

      11.       Carbonic dihydrazide          CH6N4O             90

      12.       Nitrogen fluoride             F2N2               66

      13.       Ethyl hydrogen oxalate        C4H6O4             118

      14.       Amino acethydrazide           C2H7N3O            83

      15.       Carbonyl sulfide              COS                60

      16.       Propane                       C3H8               44
      17.       Formic acid, ethenyl ester    C3H4O2             72

      18.       Methyl alcohol                CH4O               32

      19.       Aminocyanoacetic acid         C3H4N2O2           100

      20.       Hydantoin                     C3H4N2O2           100

      Chemical mordant:
      Ferrous sulphate (Feso4)           stannous chloride (Sncl2) copper sulphate (Cuso4)
         Cotton fabrics (Fig.no 20)

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                             1032                                      www.joics.org
Extraction And Purification Of Natural Dye From Bougainvillea Glabra Using For Cotton Fabrics
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                               ISSN: 1548-7741

              Table-4:     Rating Of Fastness Properties Of Dye And Mordent.
                   S.no        Solvent                       Cotton fabrics
                   1.          Aqueous                       Good
                   2.          Alkaline                      Good
                   3.          Acidic                        Good
                   4.          Alcoholic                     Good

      The different shades of grey and yellow were obtained from solvent extraction with combination
      of Mordent (Fig.no21, 22 and 23).

       i)     Before the cotton fabrics absorption the color Figure 5.

      Figure.5 Application of different mordants react with different extract on cotton fabrics.

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                             1033                                          www.joics.org
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                               ISSN: 1548-7741

      Ii) After The Cotton Fabrics Absorption Color Figure 6.

      Figure.6 Application of different mordants react with different extract on cotton fabrics.

      III) Washing The Cotton Fabrics To Not Remove The Color Absorption Figure 7.

                    Aqueous                                     Alcohol

                    Acidic                                         Alkaline

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                             1034                                          www.joics.org
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                               ISSN: 1548-7741

      Fig.no 23: Application of different mordants react with different extract on cotton fabrics.
              Aq- Aqueous extraction, Alk- Alkaline extraction, Alc-Alcoholic extraction, Ac- Acidic
               extraction, F- Ferrous sulphate, S- Stannous chloride, C-Copper sulphate
                                                 Discussion
              Colors in the day to day life of man are very prominent and unavoidable. It is associated
      in the form of colored dress materials, hair, furnishings, upholstery etc. Dyes are mainly of two
      types: natural and synthetic. S Dyeing & printing was a craftup to the middle of nineteenth
      century. They, also available for silk dyeing with natural colors in China before 2600 BC. Caves
      of Ajanta & Bag (6thcentury AD) are undoubted proof of the natural colors. Numerous specimens
      of dyeing and printing of ancient period are still available in the museums. All this happened due
      to the excessive use of synthetic dyes which is esteemed around 1million tons per annum of
      which more than 50% were azo dyes. After the advent of synthetic dyes in the middle of 19th
      century, natural dyes were bandoned as a part of history due to neglect for about 150 years. It is
      only during thelast two decades, when concern for environment as well as carcinogenicity in
      synthetic dyes created an interest in biodegradable, eco-friendly, non-toxic and aesthetically
      appealing natural dyes [10].
              The present study was undertaken to find out the phytochemicals present in Bougain
      villeaglabra flowers extract and comparative study between B.glabra ‘choisy’ and B.
      glabra‘califorina gold’. Fresh flowers and bracts of botanically identified plant was collected
      andwere processed for preparation of plant extract using specified technique.The plant
      extractwas then subjected for different qualitative chemical tests to investigate the chemical
      profileof B.glabra extracts. Analysis showed the presence of alkaloids, Flavonoids,
      phenoliccompounds and tannins in the extract as confirmed by implying different qualitative
      testsspecified for these phytochemicals.
               Synthetic dyes are today's established dyes for applications such as textile coloration.
      However, there are some serious drawbacks of these new dyes. Therefore, there is increasing
      interest in the natural dyes. The present study was emphasized to use the optimized extraction
      conditions so as to get maximum amount of the dye from bracts of Bougainvillea glabraJuss.
      Taguchi design was implemented to know optimum extraction conditions: 150 micron particle
      size, 1:20 solid-solvent ratio, one hour extraction and enzyme addition as assistance for
      extraction. The dye was extracted from both optimized and control experiments. Fourier
      Transform Infrared Spectroscopy and UV-VIS spectroscopy techniques were used to identify
      chemical nature of the extracted dye. The absorbance, mass transfer rates and dye yields were
      compared. The optimized extraction showed mass transfer rate of about 3.3 times enhanced than
      that in the control extraction. The yield was 9.88 % more in case of optimized extraction [11].
              Dye-sensitized solar cells (DSSC) were fabricated using red bougainvilleaglabra flower
      dye extracts as natural dye sensitizers at three dye pH values of 1.23, 3.0, and 5.7. Water was
      used as dye-extracting solvent. DSSCs from dye extract of pH 3.0 had the highest photocurrent
      density Jsc of 3.72 mA/cm2 and fill factor FF of 0.59. While the DSSCs from dye sensitizer pHs
      of 1.23 and 5.7 had Jsc of 1.13 and 2.27 mA/cm2, and fill factors of 0.43 and 0.61, respectively.

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                             1035                                            www.joics.org
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                              ISSN: 1548-7741

      The maximum powers Pmax of the DSSCs were 0.50, 1.64, and 0.94 mW/cm2 for dye sensitizer
      pH of 1.2, 3.0, and 5.7, respectively [12].
              This investigation aimed to extraction and purification of natural dye in bougainvillea
      glabra for using cotton fabrics. The pink colored Bougainvillea glabra flowers were collected
      from paramakudi area and subjected to extraction using ethanol. After extraction the samples
      were subjected to phytochemical analysis. The presence of alkaloid, saponins, tannins, reducing
      sugar and cardigo glycoside were identified. The extract was subjected to column
      chromatography. The pure sample was collected. The collected sample was subjected to GC-MS
      analysis. The presence of components are Nitrogen, Hydrazine, Acetic acid, hydrazine(S)-(-)-2
      Chloropropionic acid, Methylamine, Succinic anhydride, Carbon monoxide, Nickel
      tetracarbonyl, N-Metyl-2,2 bis (trifluorometyl) aziridine, Butanedioic acid cyclic hydrazide,
      Carbonic dihydrazide, Nitrogen fluoride, Ethyl hydrogen oxalate, Amino acethydrazide,
      Carbonyl sulfide, Propane, Formic acid, ethenyl ester, Methyl alcohol, Aminocyanoacetic acid,
      Hydantoin were identified. Dry powder of the sample was extracted with acidic bath, alkaline
      bath, aqueous bath and alcohol bath at 1000C. Chemical mordants were added Such as Ferrous
      sulphate, Copper sulphate and stannous chloride. The sample shows the presence of certain
      colored product (Grey, yellow and light pink). The resultant sample was treated with cotton
      fabric, the color get deposited, after repeated washing the color remain in fabrics without any
      change. Thus, the color dye extracted from pink bougainvillea glabra flowers can be used for
      coloration of cotton fabrics as a natural dye.
               The color of the stained dye was grey in color. The hot dyeing procedure of this plant
      extract showed grey color when it was stained at 1000C in a water bath and in the meantime
      the stained cloth at room temperature showed pink color. Moreover the stannous chloride,
      ferrous sulphate,copper sulphatemordant treated cloth the staining process was little bit increased
      and it was the formation of grey color at room temperature and at 450C treatment it was
      light pink in color.
              The different color shades were obtained from various extracts of pink Bougainvillea
      glabra flower. The extracts shows variation in color and which is mainly depends upon the
      extraction solvents. The Rating of fastness properties of dye and Mordent are given in the
      (Table-4).The color strength also depends upon use of Mordent. Mordents are the metals salts
      having tendency to co-ordinate with dye and fibers. The aqueous extract gives gray colored
      shade with combination of Mordent such as FeSO4, SnCl2 while, in combination with CuSO4
      gives dark black colored shade on cotton fabrics. The brown, yellow and Spanish olive color
      shades were obtained in alkaline extract with FeSO4, SnCl2 and CuSO4 Mordent respectively.
      The acidic extract with FeSO4, SnCl2 and CuSO4mordant gives pink, dark red and copper
      colored shades respectively. While, alcoholic extract gives Black color with FeSO4, violet with
      SnCl2 and dark pink shade with CuSO4 Mordent. They obtained various color shades with three
      different Mordent viz. FeSO4, SnCl2 and CuSO4.

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                            1036                                         www.joics.org
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                            ISSN: 1548-7741

                                               Conclusion
              The results of the present investigation showed the flower extract of Bougainvillea
      glabra have potential to be a natural coloring agent. The obtained from present investigation
      revealed that, the pink bougainvillea glabra flower has the desying potential as a source for
      cotton dying. Dyes obtained from pink bougainvillea glabra can be used as cost effective and
      economically commercial for various industries such as textile, cosmetics, leather, food and
      pharmaceuticals. The extract was examined under visible and UV light for the proximate
      analysis at 200-480 nm. Further, the sample analysis in GC-MS for separated the components.
      The presence of component in Nitrogen Hydrazine, Acetic acid, hydrazine(S)-(-)-2
      Chloropropionic acid, Methylamine, Succinic anhydride, Carbon monoxide, Nickel
      tetracarbonyl, N-Metyl-2,2 bis (trifluorometyl) aziridine, Butanedioic acid cyclic hydrazide,
      Carbonic dihydrazide, Nitrogen fluoride, Ethyl hydrogen oxalate, Amino acethydrazide,
      Carbonyl sulfide, Propane, Formic acid, ethenyl ester, Methyl alcohol, Aminocyanoacetic acid,
      Hydantoin. So, the pink bougainvillea glabra naturally contain the colored pigments. Which
      naturally dyeing, the dyeing purpose produced into dye using cotton fabrics.

      Reference
      [1] R. Siva, “Status of natural dyes and dye-yielding plants in India”, Current Science, vol. 92,
      (2007), pp. 916-925.
      [2] M. Kumaresan, P. N. Palanisamy and P. E. Kumar, “Application of Eco-friendly Natural dye
      obtained from flower of Spathodeacampanulata on silk using combination of mordants”, Europe
      Journal ScicenceReseach, vol. 52, (2011), pp. 306-312.
      [3] M. L. Gulrajani and D. Gupta, “Natural dyes and application to textiles, Department of
      textile technology, Indian Institute of Technology, New Delhi, India”. (1992),
      [4] A. Agarwal, A. Goel, and K. C. Gupta, “Textile Dyers and Printer”. Vol. 25, (1992), pp. 28.
      [5] Z. A. Mehanta and I. A. Tiwari, “Natural dye-yielding plants and indigenous knowledge on
      dye preparation in Arunachal Pradesh” Northeast Indian Current Science, vol. 88, (2003), pp.
      1474-1480.
      [6] V. N. Meena Devi, V. N. Ariharan, P. Nagendra Prasad, Annottav, “Eco-friendly and
      Potential Source for natural dye”, International Research JournalPharmaceutical, vol. 4,
      (2013), pp. 106-108.
      [7] A. K. Samanta, and P. Agarwal, “Application of natural dyes on textiles, Indian J Fibre
      Textile Res, 34: Schoelhorn, Richard and Alavrez, Erin.“Warm Climate Production Guidelines
      for Bougainvillea.Tweet 36 In Bougainvillea, Plant Points University of Florida/ IFAS
      Extension”, (2009),
      [8] L. Govindaraj and S. Vivek, “Evaluation of phytochemical screening & extraction of
      lycopene from Citrullus lanatus by using column chromatography”, International Journal of
      Phytopharmacy, Vol. 5, (2015), pp. 53-57.

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                           1037                                         www.joics.org
Journal of Information and Computational Science                                          ISSN: 1548-7741

      [9] P. K. Jain, A. Soni, P. Jain, J. Bhawsar, “ Phytochemical analysis of Mentha spicata plant
      extract using UV-VIS, FTIR and GC/MS technique”, Journal of Chemical and Pharmaceutical
      Research, vol. 8, (2016), pp. 1-6.
      [10] H. O. Saxena, R. Tiwari and A. K. Pandey, “Optimization of Extraction and Dyeing
      Conditions of Natural Dye from Butea monosperma (Lam.) Kuntze Flowers and Development of
      Various Shades”, Environ. We Int. J. Sci. Tech, vol. 7, (2012), pp. 29-35.
      [11] D. Pravinkumar, C. R. Patil, A. I. Rao, J. R. Wasif, Nagla, International Journal of
      Research in Engineering and Technology, (2014),
      [12]     U. A. H. AdamuIdris, M. K. UnoEssang, U. M. M. N. NobleAlu,“Material              for
      renewable and sustainable Energy”, (2015),

Volume 10 Issue 1 - 2020                           1038                                      www.joics.org
You can also read