Evaluation of the efficacy and safety of "Diaper Rash Cream" in the management of infantile irritant diaper dermatitis (IIDD)
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Evaluation of the efficacy and safety of “Diaper Rash Cream” in the management of infantile irritant diaper dermatitis (IIDD) SUKANTA CHATTERJEE, NILANJANA PRAMANICK, SANTA CHATTOPADHYAY, KINKOR MUNIAN, KOLHAPURE S.A. Abstract Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis (IIDD) is an inflammation of the infantile skin covering the groin, lower stomach, upper thighs and buttocks. Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis may become difficult to treat, if the area becomes infected or the infant develops allergy to medications applied to the area. This study was conducted to evaluate the efficacy and safety of “Diaper Rash Cream” in the management of IIDD. The study was a prospective, phase III clinical trial, conducted as per the good clinical practice guidelines. A total of 15 infants, who were suffering from IIDD, and whose parents were willing to give informed written consent were included in the study. At the initial visit, a detailed medical history was obtained by interviewing the parents regarding any dermatological problem, or any adverse effect following the use of any baby product previously in the infant. Then, a detailed physical examination of the infant was done including the dermatological system. Before beginning the study, the “Diaper Rash Cream” was applied in a test dose and observed for the development of any immediate hypersensitivity manifestations, for a period of 30 minutes. If there were no immediate hypersensitivity manifestations, the parents were advised to apply the “Diaper Rash Cream” once daily, after bath for a period of 2 weeks, on the skin covering the groin, lower stomach, upper thighs and buttocks. All the infants were followed up on the 7th and 14th day of application, and at each follow-up visit, a detailed clinical examination was done. All the adverse events, either reported or observed by the parents were recorded along with information about the onset, severity, duration and site of the adverse reaction. The signs and symptoms of immediate skin irritation and delayed hypersensitivity reactions were evaluated as per the standard reference guidelines. There was a significant improvement in the clinical manifestations of IIDD in all the included infants, in 3 days, and there was complete recovery from the clinical manifestations of IIDD, after a week’s application, in all the included infants. There was a significant reduction in itching in 10 babies, from the 3rd day onwards, and all the infants were relieved of itching from the 5th day. There was also a significant reduction in 7 babies, with regard to erythematous scaly diaper area, which often involves papulovesicular or bullous lesions, fissures, and erosions from the 3rd day onwards, and all the infants were relieved of papulovesicular or bullous lesions, fissures, and erosions by the 6th day. Also, there were no clinically significant adverse reactions, with excellent compliance. The positive benefits observed in this study might be due to the synergistic action of the active ingredients of the formulation viz. anti-inflammatory activities (of Aloe vera, Vitex negundo and Rubia cordifolia), antibacterial activities (of Zinc calx, Aloe vera, Vitex negundo and Rubia cordifolia), wound healing activities (of Aloe vera), and antioxidant activities (of Vitex negundo, Prunus amygdalus and Rubia cordifolia). Therefore, it can be concluded that “Diaper Rash Cream” is effective and safe in the management of IIDD. Dr. Sukanta Chatterjee Professor & Head Introduction emollient delivering diapers, and Dr. Nilanjana Pramanick Diapers are used for the care of breathable diapers, and these newer Dr. Santa Chattopadhyay types of diapers reduce the incidence Dr. Kinkor Munian infants, young children and Department of Pediatrics incontinent or paralyzed individuals, of diaper dermatitis. The non- Medical College and Hospital, to prevent fecal soiling and for social biodegradable material used in super Kolkata, India Dr. S.A. Kolhapure*, MD convenience. However, the use of absorbent diapers is, however, a Senior Medical Advisor diaper poses a risk of developing matter of serious concern because of R&D Center its toxic effects and environmental The Himalaya Drug Company “irritant diaper dermatitis”, which is Bangalore, India commonly known as “diaper rash”. pollution.1 *Corresponding author Recent innovations in diaper Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis technology have led to development is an inflammation of the infantile Specially Contributed to "The Antiseptic" Vol.102 No.5 & P : 251-255 of super absobent disposable diapers, skin covering the groin, lower 251 THE ANTISEPTIC May 2005
stomach, upper thighs and buttocks. responsibilities, the importance of pruritus and urticaria – 0, very slight Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis compliance, ethical aspects, and pruritus and urticaria – 1, well may become difficult to treat, if the overall plan of the study. Informed defined pruritus and urticaria – 2, area becomes infected or the infant consent was obtained in writing from moderate to severe pruritus and develops allergy to medications the parents of all the included infants. urticaria – 3, and severe pruritus and applied to the area. At the initial visit, a detailed urticaria – 4. The “Diaper Rash Cream” is a medical history was obtained by The relation of adverse events to polyherbal formulation recommended interviewing the parents regarding the study product was predefined as for the prevention and treatment of any dermatological problem, or any “Unrelated” (a reaction that does irritant diaper dermatitis, and adverse effect following the use of not follow a reasonable temporal contains the powders of Zinc calx, any baby product previously in the sequence from the time of application extract of Aloe vera and the oils of infant. Then, a detailed physical of the product and not localized to Prunus amygdalus, Vitex negundo examination of the infant was done the whole site of application), and Rubia cordifolia. This study was including the dermatological system. “Probable” (follows a known conducted to evaluate the efficacy Before beginning the study, the responsible pattern to the suspected and safety of “Diaper Rash Cream” “Diaper Rash Cream” (Batch No.: product, but could have been in the management of IIDD. 40601-RD) was applied in a test dose produced by the baby’s clinical state and localized at the site of Aim of the study and observed for the development of any immediate hypersensitivity application), “possible” (follows a This study was planned to known responsible pattern to the manifestations, for a period of 30 evaluate the clinical efficacy and suspected product that could not be minutes. If there were no immediate safety (short- and long-term) of reasonably explained by the known hypersensitivity manifestations, the “Diaper Rash Cream” in the mana- characteristics of the baby’s clinical parents were advised to apply the gement of IIDD. state and localized at the site of “Diaper Rash Cream” once daily, Study design after bath for a period of 2 weeks, on application). The study was a prospective, the skin covering the groin, lower Results phase III clinical trial, conducted at stomach, upper thighs and buttocks. There was a significant impro- the Well Baby Clinic, at the All the infants were followed up vement in the clinical manifestations Department of Pediatrics, Medical on the 7 th and 14th day of application, of IIDD in all the included infants, College and Hospital, Kolkata, from and at each follow-up visit, a detailed in 3 days and there was complete September to December 2004, as per clinical examination was done. The recovery from the clinical mani- the good clinical practice guidelines. parents were advised to discontinue festations of IIDD, after a week’s the product, if they noticed any application, in all the included Methods and materials adverse effect. infants. Inclusion and exclusion criteria Adverse events There was a significant reduction A total of 15 infants, who were in itching in 10 babies, from the 3rd suffering from IIDD, who were born All the adverse events, either reported or observed by the parents day onwards, and all the infants were at term, with a birth weight of more relived of itching from the 5th day. than 2500 grams (having appropriate were recorded along with information about the onset, severity, duration There was also a significant reduction gain in weight, length, and head in 7 babies, with regard to circumference, and a normal psycho- and site of the adverse reaction. The signs and symptoms of immediate erythematous scaly diaper area, which motor development on pediatric often involves papulovesicular or physical examination), and whose skin irritation and delayed hyper- sensitivity reactions were evaluated bullous lesions, fissures, and erosions parents were willing to give informed from the 3rd day onwards, and all the written consent were included in the as per the standard reference guidelines. The scoring scales for infants were relieved of papulo- study. Infants who were under some vesicular or bullous lesions, fissures, medication for systemic or topical various adverse effects were as follows: Scoring scale for evaluating and erosions by the 6 th day. Also, disease, and those babies, whose there were no clinically significant parents were unwilling to give written erythema: no erythema – 0, very slight erythema – 1, well defined adverse reactions, with excellent informed consent before entering the compliance. study, were excluded from the study. erythema – 2, moderate to severe erythema – 3, and very severe There were no clinically Study procedure erythema – 4. Scoring scale for significant adverse reactions (either The parents who brought their evaluating edema: no edema – 0, reported by the parents or observed infants for routine check up at the very slight edema – 1, slight edema by the investigators) during the entire Well Baby Clinic were informed – 2, moderate edema – 3, and severe study period. There were no dropouts, about the study product, its effects, edema – 4. Scoring scale for and the overall compliance to the duration of study period, their evaluating pruritus and urticaria: nil product use was excellent. May 2005 THE ANTISEPTIC 252
Discussion C. zeylanoides. Other organisms results revealed that, exposure to the Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis, present in the mixed culture from the formulations directly on adult skin a frequent condition, is a form of diaper area were Staphylococcus prior to an irritant challenge was contact dermatitis, occurs due to the aureus, Escherichia coli, and few associated with significant reduction interaction of multiple factors strains of streptococci (groups B and in skin barrier damage and skin (increased wetness, elevated local D), and Proteus mirabilis. Infants erythema, and greatest reductions skin pH, fecal enzymes and diapered exclusively in disposable were seen for the zinc containing microorganisms), and manifests as diapers showed less rash than those formulations. Wearing of the an erythematous rash. Increased diapered exclusively or sometimes in formulation treated diaper was also wetness in the diaper area makes the cloth diapers.5 associated with a significant skin more susceptible to damage by reduction in skin erythema and diaper The principle of treatment of rash compared to the control physical, chemical, and enzymatic diaper dermatitis is to keep the skin product.9 mechanisms. Wet skin increases the in the nappy area as dry as possible penetration of irritant substances. The with frequent nappy change, and The principle constituents of Aloe urease enzyme found in the stratum barbadensis are anthraquinones absorbent disposable diapers are corneum liberates ammonia from (aloe-emodin and aloin A (barbalin),10 known to reduce the incidence of cutaneous bacteria, which has an diaper dermatitis. Absorbent dis- cinnamoyl, p-coumaroyl, feruloyl, irritant effect on nonintact skin. caffeoyl aloesin, aloemannan, 11 posable diapers do not allow urine to Lipases and proteases in feces mix acemannan, verectin,12 elgonica dimer come into contact with the skin, and with urine on nonintact skin and can hold large amounts of urine. For A and bisbenzopyran.11 Aloe vera has cause an alkaline surface pH, adding anti-inflammatory, antifungal, all practical purposes these diapers to the irritation. (Feces in breastfed immunosuppressive, and wound only need to be changed when they infants have a lower pH, and become soiled with feces or they get healing properties. The active breastfed infants are less susceptible ingredients of Aloe vera have been so heavy that they are down near the to diaper dermatitis.) The bile salts found to exhibit immunosuppressive, child’s ankles. 6 in the stools enhance the activity of anti-inflammatory activities, fecal enzymes, adding to the effect.2,3 This study observed complete bradykinin degrading and cell recovery from IIDD in all the proliferation-stimulating activities.12 Candida albicans has been Ali et al. found that anthraquinones included babies, after a week’s identified as a contributing factor to application. Also, there were no from Aloe vera are responsible for diaper dermatitis, and the infection the antifungal activity. 13 The clinically significant adverse often occurs after 48-72 hours of constituents of Aloe barbadensis have reactions, with excellent compliance. active eruption. Candida albicans has The positive benefits observed in this wound healing properties. 14,15 Davis been isolated from the perineal area et al. evaluated the extracts of Aloe study might be due to the synergistic in as many as 92% of children with vera for topical anti-inflammatory action of the active ingredients of diaper dermatitis. Other microbial the formulation. activity, and the results showed that agents have been isolated less small amounts of Aloe vera given frequently, perhaps more as a result Zinc has been widely used in the topically inhibit inflammation of secondary infections. In a clinical treatment of diaper dermatitis and induced by a moderate amount of study, Ferrazzini et al. investigated various studies have demonstrated irritant.16 Another study by the same the relevance of Candida sp. and the antibacterial efficacy of zinc author demonstrated the antioxidant Staphylococcus aureus colonization oxide. Collipp et al. observed and anti-inflammatory effects of in IIDD and determined the significant reduction in the incidence aloesin derivative (isorabaichromone) correlation between the extent of of diaper rash, with oral zinc in Aloe vera. As Aloe vera has long colonization and the severity of supplementation.7 In another study, been used to promote wound healing, disease. The results showed a Collipp et al. noted that IIDD was the inhibitory effects of aloesin significant, positive correlation associated with reduced hair zinc, derivatives for cyclooxygenase between severity of disease and and infants with the least hair had (Cox)-2 and thromboxane (TXA 2) extent of Candida spp. colonization lower zinc levels than infants with synthase were examined and the at all swab locations (the colonization the most hair. 8 Baldwin et al. participation of p-coumaroyl and by Staphylococcus aureus was conducted a study to determine the feruloyl ester groups in the aloesin nonsignificant).4 In a study by Dorko clinical benefits of a novel disposable skeleton was demonstrated, which et al. the occurrence of Candida spp. diaper designed to deliver a zinc explain, the wound healing effects of was determined in infants, with diaper oxide and petrolatum-based Aloe vera. 17 Bautista-Perez et al. dermatitis, and the most frequently formulation continuously to the skin demonstrated the antibradykinin isolated species was Candida during use. They evaluated the effect and hence anti-inflammatory albicans, followed by C. prevention of skin irritation and activities of Aloe vera. 18 In a study parapsilosis, C. tropicalis, C. barrier damage from a standard skin by Vazquez et al. the aqueous extract pulcherrima, C. guilliermondii, and irritant in an adult arm model. The of Aloe vera gel inhibited 253 THE ANTISEPTIC May 2005
prostaglandin E2 production from Conclusion 71(10): 907-908. arachidonic acid. The chemical tests Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis 2. Ather ton DJ. A review of the performed on the aqueous extract for is an inflammation of the infantile pathophysiology, prevention and anthraglycosides, reductor sugars and skin covering the groin, lower treatment of irritant diaper dermatitis. cardiotonic glycosides were stomach, upper thighs and buttocks. Curr. Med. Res. Opin . 2004; 20(5): positive.19 Infantile irritant diaper dermatitis 645-649. Prunus amygdalus is a rich source may become difficult to treat, if the 3. Flagothier C, Pierard-Franchimont C, of antioxidants (tocopherols, squalene area becomes infected or the infant Pierard GE. How I explore ... diaper and phytosterols).20 Kayano et al. develops allergy to medications dermatitis. Rev. Med. Liege . 2004; documented high antioxidant applied to the area. This study was 59(2): 106-109. activities of Prunus amygdalus.21 conducted to evaluate the efficacy 4. Ferrazzini G, Kaiser RR, Hirsig Cheng The principle ingredients of Vitex and safety of “Diaper Rash Cream” SK, Wehrli M, Della Casa V, Pohlig G negundo are flavone vitexcarpin,22 in the management of IIDD. et al. Microbiological aspects of diaper dermatitis. Dermatol . 2003; 206(2): negundins A and B, diasyringaresinol, There was a significant impro- 136-141. lyoniresinol, vitrofolal E and F,23 6- vement in the clinical manifestations phenyldihydronaphthalene-type of IIDD in all the included infants, 5. Dorko E, Viragova S, Pilipcinec E, lignan, vitedoin A, phenyl- in 3 days and there was complete Tkacikova L. Candida—agent of the naphthalene-type lignan alkaloid, recovery from the clinical diaper dermatitis? Folia. Microbiol. (Praha) 2003; 48(3): 385-388. vitedoamine A, and trinorlabdane- manifestations of IIDD, after a week’s type diterpene, and vitedoin.24 Vitex application, in all the included 6. Prasad HR, Srivastava P, Verma KK. negundo has anti-inflammatory, free infants. Diaper dermatitis—an overview. Indian radical scavenging, analgesic, J. Pediatr . 2003; 70(8): 635-637. There was a significant reduction antihistaminic, and antibacterial in itching in 10 babies, from the 3 rd 7.Collipp PJ. Effect of oral zinc activities. Chawla et al. reported the day onwards, and all the infants were supplements on diaper rash in normal anti-inflammatory activity of Vitex relived of itching from the 5 th day. infants. J. Med. Assoc. Ga. 1989; 78(9): negundo. 25 Munasinghe et al. There was also a significant reduction 621-623. demonstrated the free radical in 7 babies, with regard to 8. Collipp PJ, Kuo B, Castro-Magana M, scavenging activity of Vitex erythematous scaly diaper area, which Chen SY, Salvatore S. Hair zinc, scalp negundo. 26 Dharmasiri et al. often involves papulovesicular or hair quantity, and diaper rash in normal confirmed the anti-inflammatory, bullous lesions, fissures, and erosions infants. Cutis 1985; 35(1): 66-70. analgesic and antihistamine from the 3rd day onwards, and all the 9. Baldwin S, Odio MR, Haines SL, properties of Vitex negundo. 27 infants were relieved of papulo- O’Connor RJ, Englehart JS, Lane AT. Perumal et al. reported the potent vesicular or bullous lesions, fissures, Skin benefits from continuous topical antibacterial activity of Vitex negundo and erosions by the 6 th day. Also, administration of a zinc oxide/ against Escherichia coli, Klebsiella there were no clinically significant petrolatum formulation by a novel aerogenes, Proteus vulgaris, and adverse reactions, with excellent disposable diaper. J. Eur. Acad. Pseudomonas aerogenes. 28 compliance. Dermatol. Venereol . 2001; 15 (Suppl 1): 5-11. The principal constituents of The positive benefits observed in Rubia cordifolia are purpurin, this study might be due to the 10.ElSohly MA, Gul W, Murphy TP. munjistin, purpuroxanthin, pseudo- Analysis of the anthraquinones aloe- synergistic action of the active emodin and aloin by gas purpurin and rubiadin, 28,29 ingredients of the formulation viz. anthraquinones (cordifoliol and chromatography/mass spectrometry. anti-inflammatory activities (of Aloe Int. Immunopharmacol . 2004; 4(14): cordifodiol) 30 and a naphthoic ester vera, Vitex negundo, and Rubia 1739-1744. (rubialactone). 31 Rubia cordifolia has cordifolia), antibacterial activities (of antioxidant antibacterial and anti- zinc calx, Aloe vera, Vitex negundo, 11.Saleem R, Faizi S, Siddiqui BS, inflammatory activities. Tripathi et Ahmed M, Hussain SA, Qazi A, et al. and Rubia cordifolia), wound healing Hypotensive effect of chemical al. demonstrated the antioxidant activities (of Aloe vera), and activity of Rubia cordifolia, which constituents from Aloe barbadensis . antioxidant activities (of Vitex Planta Med. 2001; 67(8): 757-760. inhibited lipid peroxidation in a dose negundo, Prunus amygdalus and dependent manner. 32 Cai et al. Rubia cordifolia). Therefore, it can 12.Yagi A, Takeo S. Anti-inflammatory demonstrated the antioxidant activity constituents, aloesin and aloemannan be concluded that “Diaper Rash in Aloe species and effects of of hydroxyanthraquinones from Cream” is effective and safe in the Rubia cordifolia. 33 Qiao et al. tanshinon VI in Salvia miltiorrhiza on management of IIDD. heart. Yakugaku. Zasshi. 2003; 123(7): demonstrated the antibacterial 517-532. activity of the constituents in Rubia References cordifolia.34 Jain et al. demonstrated 1.Prasad HR, Srivastava P, Verma KK. 13.Ali MI, Shalaby NM, Elgamal MH, the anti-inflammatory activity of the Mousa AS. Antifungal effects of Diapers and skin care: merits and constituents of Rubia cordifolia.35 different plant extracts and their major demerits. Indian J. Pediatr . 2004; May 2005 THE ANTISEPTIC 254
components of selected Aloe species. 21.Kayano S, Kikuzaki H, Yamada NF, 28.Perumal Samy R, Ignacimuthu S, Sen Phytother. Res. 1999; 13(5): 401-407. Aoki A, Kasamatsu K, Yamasaki Y, et A. Screening of 34 Indian medicinal al. Antioxidant properties of prunes plants for antibacterial properties. J. 14.Choi SW, Son BW, Son YS, Park YI, ( Prunus domestica L.) and their Ethnopharmacol . 1998; 62(2): 173-182. Lee SK, Chung MH. The wound- constituents. Biofactors . 2004; 21(1- healing effect of a glycoprotein fraction 29.Tripathi YB, Sharma M, Manickam M. 4): 309-313. isolated from Aloe vera . Br. J. Rubiadin, a new antioxidant from Rubia Dermatol. 2001; 145(4): 535-545. 22.Diaz F, Chavez D, Lee D, Mi Q, Chai cordifolia. Indian J. Biochem. Biophys . HB, Tan GT, et al. Cytotoxic flavone 1997; 34(3): 302-306. 15.Chithra P, Sajithlal GB, Gowri analogues of vitexicarpin, a constituent Chandrakasan. Influence of Aloe vera 30.Abdullah ST, Ali A, Hamid H, Ali M, of the leaves of Vitex negundo . J. Nat. on the glycosaminoglycans in the Ansari SH, Alam MS. Two new Prod. 2003; 66(6): 865-867. matrix of healing dermal wounds in anthraquinones from the roots of Rubia rats. J. Ethnopharmacol. 1998; 59(3): 23.Azhar-Ul-Haq, Malik A, Anis I, Khan cordifolia Linn. Pharmazie. 2003; 58(3): 179-186. SB, Ahmed E, Ahmed Z. Enzymes 216-217. inhibiting lignans from Vitex negundo . 16.Davis RH, Rosenthal KY, Cesario LR, 31.Hua HM, Wang SX, Wu LJ, Li X, Zhu Chem. Pharm. Bull. (Tokyo). 2004; Rouw GA. Processed Aloe vera TR. Studies on naphthoic acid esters 52(11): 1269-1272. administered topically inhibits from the roots of Rubia cordifolia L. inflammation. J. Am. Podiatr. Med. 24.Ono M, Nishida Y, Masuoka C, Li JC, Yao. Xue. Xue. Bao. 1992; 27(4): 279- Assoc . 1989; 79(8): 395-397. Okawa M, Ikeda T. Lignan derivatives 282. and a norditerpene from the seeds of 17.Yagi A, Kabash A, Okamura N, 32.Tripathi YB, Sharma M. Comparison Vitex negundo . J. Nat. Prod . 2004; Haraguchi H, Moustafa SM, Khalifa of the antioxidant action of the 67(12): 2073-2075. TI. Antioxidant, free radical scavenging alcoholic extract of Rubia cordifolia and anti-inflammatory effects of 25.Chawla AS, Sharma AK, Handa SS, with rubiadin. Indian J. Biochem. aloesin derivatives in Aloe vera . Planta Dhar KL. Chemical investigation and Biophys . 1998; 35(5): 313-316. Med. 2002; 68(11): 957-960. anti-inflammatory activity of Vitex 33.Cai Y, Sun M, Xing J, Corke H. negundo seeds. J. Nat. Prod. 1992; 18.Bautista-Perez R, Segura-Cobos D, Antioxidant phenolic constituents in 55(2): 163-167. Vazquez-Cruz B. In vitro antibradykinin roots of Rheum officinale and Rubia activity of Aloe barbadensis gel. J. 26.Munasinghe TC, Seneviratne CK, cordifolia : Structure-radical scavenging Ethnopharmacol. 2004; 93(1): 89-92. Thabrew MI, Abeysekera AM. activity relationships. J. Agric. Food Antiradical and antilipoperoxidative Chem . 2004; 52(26): 7884-7890. 19.Vazquez B, Avila G, Segura D, effects of some plant extracts used by Escalante B. Antiinflammatory activity 34.Qiao YF, Wang SX, Wu LJ, Li X, Zhu Sri Lankan traditional medical of extracts from Aloe vera gel. J. TR. Studies on antibacterial practitioners for cardioprotection. Ethnopharmacol. 1996; 55(1): 69-75. constituents from the roots of Rubia Phytother. Res. 2001; 15(6): 519-523. cordifolia L. Yao Xue Xue Bao . 1990; 20.Maguire LS, O’Sullivan SM, Galvin K, 27.Dharmasiri MG, Jayakody JR, Galhena 25(11): 834-839. O’Connor TP, O’Brien NM. Fatty acid G, Liyanage SS, Ratnasooriya WD. profile, tocopherol, squalene and 35.Jain A, Basal E. Inhibition of Anti-inflammatory and analgesic phytosterol content of walnuts, Propionibacterium acnes-induced activities of mature fresh leaves of almonds, peanuts, hazelnuts and the mediators of inflammation by Indian Vitex negundo . J. Ethnopharmacol . macadamia nut. Int. J. Food Sci. Nutr . herbs. Phytomed. 2003; 10(1): 34- 2003; 87(2-3): 199-206. 2004; 55(3): 171-178. 38. Functional Somatic Syndromes are illnesses The Australian government is proposing that characterized by symptoms that, as yet, have no clear by mid 2005 every packet of cigarettes and pathophysiology. These include chronic fatigue tobacco sold there will feature graphic images syndrome, fibromyalgia, Gulf War illness, irritable bowel of smoking related diseases over half the front syndrome, and premenstrual dysphoria. Although the and rear panels. clinical manifestations of these illnesses are not The proposals warnings covering half each identical, they have in common increased sensitivity to pack in January 2001, and Brazil, which pain, sleep disturbances, difficulty with concentration, introduced similar images in February 2002. and labile mood. (NEJM – December 23, 2004) (BMJ – May 2004) 255 THE ANTISEPTIC May 2005
You can also read