Estimating the number and types of applications for 11 substances added to the Authorisation List in February 2020 February 2020 - ECHA

Page created by Leonard Soto
 
CONTINUE READING
Estimating the number and types of applications
for 11 substances added to the Authorisation List in February
2020

February 2020
2

Disclaimer

This publication is solely intended for information purposes and does not necessarily represent
the official opinion of the European Chemicals Agency. The European Chemicals Agency is not
responsible for the use that may be made of the information contained in this document.

 Version        Changes

 1.0            First version

Estimating the number and types of applications for 11 substances added to the
Authorisation List in February 2020

Reference: ECHA-20-R-02-EN
ISBN: 978-92-9481-396-1
Cat. Number: ED-03-20-113-EN-N
DOI: 10.2823/11134
Publ.date: February 2020
Language: EN

© European Chemicals Agency, 2020
Cover page © European Chemicals Agency

If you have questions or comments in relation to this document please send them (quote the
reference and issue date) using the information request form. The information request form
can be accessed via the Contact ECHA page at:
http://echa.europa.eu/contact

European Chemicals Agency

P.O. Box 400, FI-00121 Helsinki, Finland
3

Table of Contents

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................................................................... 5

INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................. 7

METHODS .................................................................................................................... 10

 Literature search and evaluation of ECHA background documents.................................... 10
  Assessment of current uses....................................................................................................... 10
  Substances in articles ............................................................................................................... 10
  Supplier search ....................................................................................................................... 11

 Analysis of information on alternatives ....................................................................... 11
 Stakeholder consultation .......................................................................................... 11
 Supply chain description and assessing likelihood of applications for authorisation.............. 12

RESULTS AND DISCUSSION ........................................................................................ 12

 Summary of uses and potential suppliers .................................................................... 12
 Potential alternatives to substances proposed for the Authorisation List ............................ 20
 Stakeholder consultation .......................................................................................... 22
  1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-alkyl esters ..................................................................... 23
  Trixylyl phosphate ................................................................................................................... 24
  Perboric acid, sodium salt (sodium perborate) ............................................................................. 24
  2-(2h-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-bis(1,1-dimethylpropyl)phenol [UV-328] ............................................ 25

 Supply chain description .......................................................................................... 25

CONCLUSIONS ............................................................................................................. 27

REFERENCES ................................................................................................................ 29

APPENDIX A ................................................................................................................ 30

APPENDIX B ................................................................................................................ 33

APPENDIX C ................................................................................................................ 38
4

Tables
Table 1 – Substances added to the Authorisation List on 6 February 2020 ........................................... 5
Table 2 - Substances added to the Authorisation List in 2020 ............................................................ 9
Table 3 - Summary of substance uses compiled from ECHA background documents and literature search
................................................................................................................................................13
Table 4 - Current use of substances in articles on EU market ............................................................ 19
Table 5 - Potential alternatives to 11 substances being placed on the Authorisation List .......................20
Table 6 - Classification and labelling notifications for unregistered substances on the Authorisation List .23
Table 7 - Patents owned by European companies (including in Switzerland and Norway) by substance...30
Table 8 - Substance patents by European company (including in Switzerland and Norway) ...................32
Table 9 - EU suppliers of 11 substances added to the Authorisation List in 2020 .................................33
Table 10 - Details of EU chemical suppliers for 11 substances added to the Authorisation List in 2020 ...35
Table 11 - List of substances, uses of which in mixtures and articles have been reported in the SPIN
database for 2017 by Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden .......................................................... 38
5

Executive Summary
The European Commission added 11 substances to the Authorisation List (Annex XIV to the
REACH Regulation) on 6 February 2020. In the run-up to the new entries’ publication in the
Official Journal, ECHA and wca1, an independent consultancy providing advice on the risk
assessment of chemicals in the environment and workplace, have carried out market research
to explore the likely numbers of applications for authorisation that might be received for these
substances in the future (Table 1).

Anticipating the potential number of applications for authorisation is instrumental for ECHA to
be able to plan its staff resources, the meetings of the Committees for Risk Assessment (RAC)
and Socio-economic Analysis (SEAC) and to ensure that it has the capacity to provide timely
opinions on any applications for these substances.

ECHA can expect to receive few applications for the 11 substances. The only substance for which
a potential applicant was found was trixylyl phosphate.

Table 1 – Substances added to the Authorisation List on 6 February 2020

    Substance                                                      EC number     Number of
                                                                                 applications

    1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, dihexyl ester, branched and      271-093-5           0
    linear*)

    dihexyl phthalate                                              201-559-5           0

    1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-alkyl esters; 1,2-      271-094-0;          0
    benzenedicarboxylic acid, mixed decyl and hexyl and octyl      272-013-1
    diesters with ≥ 0.3% of dihexyl phthalate

    trixylyl phosphate*)                                           246-677-8        Some**)

    sodium perborate*)                                             239-172-9;          0
                                                                   234-390-0

    sodium peroxometaborate                                        231-556-4           0

    5-sec-butyl-2-(2,4-dimethylcyclohex-3-en-1-yl)-5-methyl-            -              0
    1,3-dioxane [1], 5-sec-butyl-2-(4,6-dimethylcyclohex-3-en-1-
    yl)-5-methyl-1,3-dioxane [2] [covering any of the individual
    stereoisomers of [1] and [2] or any combination thereof]

    2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-ditertpentylphenol (UV-328) *)    247-384-8        Possibly
                                                                                    some**)

    2,4-di-tert-butyl-6-(5-chlorobenzotriazol-2-yl)phenol (UV-     223-383-8           0
    327)

1   https://www.wca-environment.com/index.php/about-us
6

    2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4-(tert-butyl)-6-(sec-butyl)phenol            253-037-1                0
    (UV-350)

    2-benzotriazol-2-yl-4,6-di-tert-butylphenol (UV-320)                   223-346-6                0
*)                           **)
     Registered substances         Some = under five applications

However, the market intelligence suggests that small volumes are being placed on the EU market
even for the unregistered substances, so it is important to ensure that there is adequate publicity
on the announcement of Authorisation List updates and to highlight to importers that these
substances should not be placed on the EU market after the sunset date unless they apply for
authorisation to continue specific uses of the substances.

A search for information on the presence of the 11 substances in articles on the EU market
revealed only limited information but indicated that some of these substances, particularly the
UV substances, may be present in imported articles. Therefore, ECHA will need to consider
preparing restriction dossiers according to Article 69(2) 2 of REACH after the sunset dates for the
relevant substances incorporated in articles and imported into the EU have passed.

The lead registrant of UV-328 posited that it is very likely that articles containing UV-328, as
well as a similar substance UV-327 (and possibly other UV substances), will continue to be
imported into the EU market. They, therefore, considered it essential for there to be an EU-wide
restriction on articles containing these substances.

Data from the Substances in Preparations in Nordic Countries (SPIN) database suggested that
six of these 11 substances were placed on the market in Nordic countries. As many of them have
not been registered it is likely that these are manufactured or imported by multiple actors under
one tonne each in 2017(see Table 11).

ECHA approached the lead registrants of the four registered Substances of Very High Concern
(SVHCs)3. They stated that it is very unlikely that a market exists in the EU for these substances
following their sunset dates. The specific findings were:

      •   Trixylyl phosphate (EC 246-677-8): there is some interest in continued use for very
          specific applications.

      •   2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-ditertpentylphenol (UV-328) (EC 247-384-8): UV-
          328 is currently imported to the EU as a UV absorber and light stabiliser for transparent
          plastics. A number of suitable alternatives are already available and the co-registrants
          for the substance are confident that downstream users will switch to plastics containing
          these substances. The registrants for UV-328 also supply these alternatives. They will
          cease placing UV-328 on the market after the sunset date, and do not intend to support
          any applications. One of the co-registrants thought that some of their downstream users,
          such as those in the automotive industry, may wish to apply for authorisation to support

2
  After the sunset date has passed for a substance included on the Authorisation List (Annex XIV), Article
69(2) of REACH requires ECHA to consider if the use of the substance in articles is adequately controlled
and, if it isn't, prepare a dossier which conforms to the requirements of an Annex XV dossier for restriction.
3
  As there were no registrations of the other seven substances, ECHA was unable to approach any
registrants.
7

        the use of this substance in specific plastic components. This might amount to one or two
        applications.

    •   Sodium perborate (EC 239-172-9; 234-390-0): This substance is currently used in
        niche applications in the EU. Suitable alternatives are readily available and substitution
        has apparently already largely occurred. It is unlikely that any applications would be
        received.

    •   1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-alkyl esters; 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic
        acid, mixed decyl and hexyl and octyl diesters with ≥ 0.3% of dihexyl phthalate
        (EC 271-094-0; 272-013-1): This is no longer used in the EU. Suitable alternatives are
        readily available and substitution has apparently already occurred.

ECHA received useful information from the lead registrants as well as sectoral trade associations
– AISE, ATIEL, CEPE, Concawe, Cosmetics Europe, ELiSANA, ETRMA, FEICA, Pinfa Plasticisers
Plus and Plastics Europe – all representing downstream users. The registrants, as manufacturers
or importers of the substances, were able to make definitive statements regarding whether they
would place these substances on the EU market after the sunset date.

This information was corroborated by confirmatory statements from sectoral trade associations
as well as the main users of the substances, such as lubricant manufacturers, manufacturers of
detergents, rubber and plastic products, as well as various other downstream user groups. ECHA
asked the stakeholders to verify or corroborate the findings of the market survey4.

While ECHA has made efforts to uncover the market situation of the 11 substances and, in
particular, to predict the number of applications it would receive, it is possible that it has not
been able to reach particular user groups.

By publishing this report, ECHA wants to increase the awareness around the need to apply for
substances placed on the Authorisation List. It also hopes that any potential applicants for
authorisation would inform ECHA if they find inaccuracies in this report about their intention to
apply.

Introduction
Title VII of the REACH Regulation concerning the authorisation procedure aims to ensure the
good functioning of the internal market while assuring that the risks from substances of very
high concern (SVHCs) are properly controlled and that these substances are progressively
replaced by suitable alternative substances or technologies, where these are economically and
technically feasible (Article 55).

The inclusion of a substance on the ‘Candidate List’ designates that the substance is an SVHC
and that it may be prioritised for placing on the REACH Authorisation List (Annex XIV). The
prioritisation is normally based on (1) the inherent properties of the substance, (2) high volume
and (3) the use (wide-dispersive).

Before sending its recommendation to the European Commission, ECHA launches a consultation

4
  Stakeholders were also asked to verify whether the statements attributed to them in the report were
accurate. At the request of the stakeholders, ECHA did not mention their names in the report.
8

which lasts for three months, in particular, on uses which should be exempt from the
authorisation requirement (Article 58(4) of REACH).

REACH allows companies to submit applications for authorisation to continue or start using
substances included on the Authorisation List. The initial draft recommendation for inclusion of
a substance on the Authorisation List includes (among other information) the ‘sunset date’, after
which the placing on the market and the use of a substance is prohibited unless an authorisation
is granted (or the use is exempt). It also includes the ‘latest application date’ (LAD) by which
applications must be received if applicants want certainty on continued use of their substances
after the sunset date, but when a decision (to grant or refuse the AfA) has not yet been adopted.

It is still possible to submit an AfA after the LAD, but the use of the substance must cease before
the sunset date if a decision on the application has not been made before then. It is also possible
to submit an application after the sunset date, but it is only possible to use the substance if the
authorisation is granted.

On 6 February 2020, the Commission added 11 substances to the Authorisation List. ECHA
needs to plan its staff resources and the workload of the Committees for Risk Assessment (RAC)
and Socio-economic Analysis (SEAC) to ensure it has the capacity to provide timely opinions on
any applications for authorisation relating to these substances. Therefore, ECHA carried out
market research in late 2019 and early 2020 to identify relevant industry associations and
companies that are likely to be the “movers and shakers” leading the supply chains toward
applications or substitution.

The project’s primary objective was to generate estimates of the number of applications, the
uses covered therein and the types of applications (e.g. by single downstream users, multiple
downstream users or upstream actors) that may be submitted for the 11 substances (listed in
Table 2).

Of the 11 substances, only four are registered under REACH. This means that the other seven
substances can only be placed on the EU market in amounts less than one tonne per year. ECHA
has prioritised some of the substances to avoid regrettable substitution with the understanding
that these are not currently used in the EU and, therefore, it is unlikely that ECHA would receive
applications for these substances.

The tasks of this market research project were to:

    -   identify the companies and associations leading the supply chains towards any potential
        applications for authorisation (or if not, substitution);
    -   describe the supply chains and market structures where the substances are used;
    -   determine whether substitutes are available and being used;
    -   describe which uses would authorisations be applied for; and
    -   if relevant, estimate how many applications would be made, by whom and when, and for
        how many uses.
9

Table 2 - Substances added to the Authorisation List in 2020
                                                 Intrinsic
                                                                 Latest
                                                properties
                    Substance                                  application   Sunset date
                                                referred to
                                                                  date
                                               in Article 57

 1,2-Benzenedicarboxylic acid, dihexyl            Toxic for
                                                                7 August     27 February
 ester, branched and linear*)                   reproduction
                                                                  2021          2023
 EC 271-093-5; CAS 68515-50-4                  (category 1B)
                                                  Toxic for
 Dihexyl phthalate                                              7 August     27 February
                                                reproduction
 EC 201-559-5; CAS 84-75-3                                        2021          2023
                                               (category 1B)
 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-
 alkyl esters; 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid,
 mixed decyl and hexyl and octyl diesters         Toxic for
                                                                7 August     27 February
 with ≥ 0.3% of dihexyl phthalate (EC 201-      reproduction
                                                                  2021          2023
 559-5)                                        (category 1B)
 EC 271-094-0; 272-013-1;
 CAS 68515-51-5; 68648-93-1
                                                  Toxic for        27
 Trixylyl phosphate*)
                                                reproduction    November     27 May 2023
 EC 246-677-8; CAS 25155-23-1
                                               (category 1B)      2021
 Sodium perborate; perboric acid, sodium
                                                  Toxic for        27
 salt*)
                                                reproduction    November     27 May 2023
 EC 239-172-9; 234-390-0;
                                               (category 1B)      2021
 CAS 15120-21-5; 11138-47-9
                                                  Toxic for        27
 Sodium peroxometaborate
                                                reproduction    November     27 May 2023
 EC 231-556-4; CAS 7632-04-4
                                               (category 1B)      2021
 5-sec-butyl-2-(2,4-dimethylcyclohex-3-
 en-1-yl)-5-methyl-1,3-dioxane [1], 5-sec-
 butyl-2-(4,6-dimethylcyclohex-3-en-1-yl)-
                                                               27 February    27 August
 5-methyl-1,3-dioxane [2] [covering any of         vPvB
                                                                  2022          2023
 the individual stereoisomers of [1] and [2]
 or any combination thereof]
 EC -; CAS -
 2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-
                                                                             27 November
 ditertpentylphenol (UV-328) *)                 PBT, vPvB      27 May 2022
                                                                                 2023
 EC 247-384-8; CAS 25973-55-1
 2,4-di-tert-butyl-6-(5-chlorobenzotriazol-
                                                                             27 November
 2-yl)phenol (UV-327)                              vPvB        27 May 2022
                                                                                 2023
 EC 223-383-8;CAS 3864-99-1
 2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4-(tert-butyl)-6-
                                                                             27 November
 (sec-butyl)phenol (UV-350)                        vPvB        27 May 2022
                                                                                 2023
 EC 253-037-1; CAS 36437-37-3
 2-benzotriazol-2-yl-4,6-di-tert-
                                                                             27 November
 butylphenol (UV-320)                           PBT, vPvB      27 May 2022
                                                                                 2023
 EC 223-346-6;CAS 3846-71-7
*)
     Registered substances
10

This was the first time that ECHA carried out such market research to engage proactively with
relevant stakeholders to gauge their interest in applying for authorisations for the concerned
substances. This research has helped to build internal capabilities and competences for similar
projects in the future.

Methods
This section details how the market research was undertaken to assess the market reaction to
the 11 substances being classified as substances of very high concern (SVHCs) and then placed
on the Authorisation List (Annex XIV), with the objective of determining the likelihood of
applications for authorisation being submitted.

Literature search and evaluation of ECHA background documents

ECHA carried out an initial market research based on the registrations of the substance and by
contacting the lead registrants and sector organisations. It then contracted wca to follow up
certain aspects of the initial research.

The wca project team undertook a brief review of available literature (primarily internet
resources) to obtain an overview of uses of the substances and screen those within the scope of
authorisation. This provided only limited information and more relevant information was obtained
from ECHA ‘background documents’ such as reports detailing the proposal for identification of
an SVHC (Annex XV).

Assessment of current uses
Information on substance uses were initially compiled from the following sources:

     •   Annex XV reports published by ECHA;

     •   US EPA CPCat Database (21 May 2014 release) – this details substance use information
         categorised by product, function and user group (industrial or consumer) from the United
         States (various EPA chemical datasets), Australia (NICNAS) and industry (Dow Chemical
         Company);

     •   SPIN and KEMI databases (the SPIN database also provides information on the amount
         of a substance used in Nordic countries); and

     •   Hazardous Substances DataBank (HSDB) and PubChem.

Industrial uses were collated on the basis of substance CAS numbers. Patent searches were
conducted to understand specific substance uses and industrial processes that may be situated
in the EU. Searches were conducted on Derwent Innovation, based on substance CAS numbers
for all available years (1900 to 2019) and European companies holding active and inactive
patents were identified.

Substances in articles
Information on the presence of the substances in articles was gathered by wca from internet
searches. The main information targeted were manufacturer/supplier declarations under REACH
Article 33(1) to identify Candidate List substances in articles.
11

Searches were conducted using search terms such as ‘articles containing [substance name] [CAS
number]’ (e.g. ‘articles containing dihexyl phthalate 84-75-3’). Results from the first five pages
were screened and information on the types of product and manufacturer/supplier for each
substance were recorded.

Supplier search
Chemical suppliers were identified to gain insight on the availability of substances on the
European market as these suppliers may hold information on downstream uses and market
demand. Searches were conducted in SciFinder based on substance CAS numbers. The
substance record contains information on commercial sources, including the product quantities,
purities and seller contact details. The contact details for European sellers were collated and
product quantities over 1 kg (bulk) were noted.

Analysis of information on alternatives

The wca project team investigated whether substitutes are available for the substances placed
on the Authorisation List. By reviewing Annex XV reports, the CHEMSEC database and
consultation with trade associations and companies, wca could determine if there has already
been any substitution (or there are plans) since substances were listed as SVHCs.

Stakeholder consultation

ECHA carried out a number of preliminary tasks for the project. The first of these was to approach
the registrants of the substances and ask for their collaboration in this study, in particular to
identify the relevant supply chains and actors therein.

An initial letter was sent by ECHA to lead registrants for the 11 substances requesting that they
provide information on the supply chain for each substance and their opinion on the likelihood
of applications for authorisation being submitted following the substance’s inclusion on the
Authorisation List.

ECHA also set up a “call for information” to inform stakeholders about this work and urge actors
in the supply chain to provide information on the likely response to the inclusion of these
substances on the Authorisation List.

ECHA also sent a letter to trade associations representing sectors concerned in the supply chain
for these substances requesting them to invite member companies to participate in an online
survey that requested information on:

   •   their contact details;

   •   whether they manufacture, import, formulate, distribute or use any of the 11
       substances within the European Union?;

   •   what the substance is used for;

   •   whether the company is a downstream user, manufacturer, importer/only representative
       or distributor;

   •   whether there was an intention to apply for authorisation to continue using the substance;
12

     •   whether there was a plan to apply for authorisation alone or through an upstream
         applicant;

     •   whether the respondent would apply for authorisation on behalf of downstream users;
         and

     •   if the respondent did not plan to apply for authorisation, what was the reason (i.e.
         substance will no longer be used or an alternative substance/technology has already been
         identified to switch to)?

ECHA and the wca project team then identified companies and associations leading the supply
chains toward applications for authorisation or substitution and used telephone interviews to
gather relevant information.

Supply chain description and assessing likelihood of applications for
authorisation

Based on the outputs of earlier activities, the basic supply chain and market structures for the
substances were identified to help determine whether applications for authorisation are likely to
be received for the substances placed on the Authorisation List in 2020.

Both ECHA and the wca project team requested information from suppliers on the market for
the substances, highlighting the priority uses (and substance functionality) for which
authorisation is most likely to be applied for. The wca project team also requested information
on how companies are organised along the supply chain to assess which are most likely to be
applicants for authorisation (either alone or through a joint application).

Both ECHA and the wca project team sought to determine whether there are likely to be
‘upstream applications’ (fewer in total but broader applications) or specific ‘downstream user
applications’ (specific to a certain use and likely to result in a greater number of applications).

Results and discussion

Summary of uses and potential suppliers

Information on uses of the 11 substances to be placed on the Authorisation List was compiled
by the wca project team from ECHA documents and various databases covering Europe, the
United States and Australia (see Section 2.1.2 for details) and is summarised in Table 3. Based
on the uses identified for each substance, the most relevant European trade associations were
identified and these are also detailed in Table 3.

Wide-ranging uses were identified for all 11 substances, indicating the theoretical possibility of
numerous applications for authorisation being submitted following the placing of these
substances on the Authorisation List, and specifically for the four substances already registered
under REACH. This highlighted the need for a targeted stakeholder consultation to gather up-to-
date information on the supply chain and market for these substances, to pinpoint the most
important uses that could drive applications and identify which actors would most likely make
the application, i.e. whether this would come from manufacturers or downstream users acting
alone or in a consortium.
13

Patent searches were conducted to identify European companies holding active and inactive
patents (Tables 7 and 8). The results (see Appendix A) revealed that a significant number of
patents are held by several European companies for most of the substances, although there are
no patents held in the EU for trixylyl phosphate and sodium perborate (and only one patent held
in the EU for sodium peroxometaborate).

The patents are generally held by large chemical manufacturing companies and the majority are
still live patents. It is uncertain what can be read from this information in terms of predicting
the likelihood of applications for authorisation but the holding of live patents for most of the
substances would indicate an ongoing commercial interest in them that has the potential to
motivate submission of applications for authorisation.

Table 3 - Summary of substance uses compiled from ECHA background documents and
literature search
                        Regis-
                                                                                  Relevant
                        tered
     Substance                                  Use summary                       industry
                        (Yes/
                                                                                associations
                         No)

                                  1. Plasticiser (sealant/jointing agents in
                                     US market) in polymers. Occurring in      Plastics Europe,
                                                                               European Tyre
                                     consumer articles. Automotive gear
 1,2-                                                                          & Rubber
                                     lubricant on German market. Possible
 Benzenedicarboxylic                                                           Manufacturers’
                                     replacement for other low/transitional
 acid, dihexyl ester,     Yes                                                  Association
 branched and linear                 phthalates being phased out (ECHA         (ETRMA),
 EC 271-093-5                        2014a).                                   Concawe
 CAS 68515-50-4                   2. Rubber and plastic products.              (petroleum
                                  3. Lubricants and additives, gear oils,      refining), ATIEL
                                     automotive.                               (lubricants)

                                  1. Plasticiser for cellulose and vinyl
                                     plastics. DnHP is used in the making of
                                     plastisols that are subsequently used
                                     to manufacture automobile parts (air
                                     filters, battery covers) and dip-
                                     moulded products (tool handles,
                                     dishwasher baskets). Substances
                                     containing DnHP may also be used in
                                     traffic cones, toys, vinyl gloves,
                                     weather stripping, flea collars, shoes,
 Dihexyl phthalate
                          No         and conveyor belts used in food           Plastics Europe,
 EC 201-559-5
                                     packaging operations. Due to its          ETRMA
 CAS 84-75-3
                                     similar physicochemical properties to
                                     other transitional phthalates with C4-
                                     C6 carbon backbone lengths, dihexyl
                                     phthalate can possibly be used as a
                                     substitute for these phthalates (ECHA
                                     2013a).
                                  2. Rubber and plastic products, inert
                                     pesticides, children’s products.
                                  4. Commercial phthalate substances
                                     containing DnHP may be added to the
14

                       Regis-
                                                                                   Relevant
                       tered
     Substance                                Use summary                          industry
                       (Yes/
                                                                                 associations
                        No)

                                   PVC utilised to manufacture flooring,
                                   canvas tarps, and notebook covers.
                                   DnHP is often found as a minor
                                   component (less than 1 %) of C6-10-
                                   phthalate mixtures; it may also be an
                                   isomer in mixtures of diisohexyl
                                   phthalates (DIHP) (CAS RN 68515-50-
                                   4) at levels of 25 % or lower.

                                1. Phthalates are well known to be used
                                   as plasticisers and lubricants, and the
                                   registered uses of the substance are
1,2-                               for example in adhesives, lubricants,
benzenedicarboxylic                coatings, building material, cable
acid, di-C6-10-alkyl               compounding, polymer foils, PVC
esters; 1,2-                       compounds and artist supply (ECHA
benzenedicarboxylic
                                   2015a).                                      FEICA
acid, mixed decyl
                                2. Rubber and plastic products,                 (adhesives and
and hexyl and octyl
                        No         adhesives, sealants, plasticisers,           sealants),
diesters with ≥
                                   custom compounding of purchased              Plasticisers
0.3% of dihexyl
                                   resins (CAS 68648-93-1).                     Plus, Plastics
phthalate (EC 201-
                                3. Adhesives, binding agents, resins for        Europe, ETRMA
559-5)
EC 271-094-0; 272-                 1- and 2-component hardening
013-1                              adhesives, softeners (CAS 68515-51-
CAS 68515-51-5;                    5).
68648-93-1                      4. Plasticiser in PVC products and in
                                   paints and can also be used in
                                   adhesive and lubricant materials.

                                1. TXP is mainly used as a functional fluid
                                   (fire resistant fluids, hydraulic fluids,
                                   lubricants, lubricant additives, grease
                                   products, metal working fluid) and as
                                   a flame retardant in the production of
                                   plastics. Internet sources recommend
                                   TXP mixtures as a plasticiser of
                                   vinylite, cellulosic resin and natural
                                   and synthetic rubber. It may also be         Concawe,
Trixylyl phosphate
                        Yes                                                     ATIEL, Pinfa
EC 246-677-8                       used for anti-mildew cables, electricity
                                                                                (flame
CAS 25155-23-1                     and as a plasticiser and flame
                                                                                retardants)
                                   retardant for PVC convey belts,
                                   artificial leather and flooring materials1
                                   (ECHA 2013b).
                                2. Greases, petroleum lubricating oil and
                                   grease manufacturing.
                                3. Flame retardant, lubricant and
                                   additives, manufacture of computer,
                                   electronic and optical products.
15

                     Regis-
                                                                              Relevant
                     tered
   Substance                                Use summary                       industry
                     (Yes/
                                                                            associations
                      No)

                              4. Flame retardant plasticiser for wire
                                 and cable insulation usually used in
                                 blends with phthalates. The major
                                 current area of use is in power
                                 generation fluids.

                              1. Used as a source of oxygen in laundry
                                 detergents and peroxide-based
                                 bleaches. Mainly used as a bleaching
                                 agent in laundry detergents and
                                 machine-washing products (clothes).
                                 Cosmetic products. Other minor uses
                                 include non-agricultural pesticides and
                                 preservatives, conductive agents and
                                 cleaning/washing agents for
                                 dishwashing machines. Also, used as a
                                 bleaching agent in denture cleansers
                                 and stain removers (cited from 2007
                                 risk assessment report) (ECHA             International
                                 2014b).                                   Association for
Sodium perborate;             2. Personal care products, fracking,         Soaps,
perboric acid,                   biocides, antimicrobials, fragrances,     Detergents and
sodium salt           Yes        pharmaceuticals, inert pesticides.        Maintenance
EC 239-172-9; 234-            3. Cleaning and washing agents,              Products
390-0                            conductive agents, non-agricultural       (AISE),
CAS -                            pesticides/preservatives, bleaching       Cosmetics
                                 agents, building materials/additives,     Europe,
                                 dyestuff/pigments, textile auxiliaries,   Concawe
                                 photo chemicals.
                              4. Denture cleaner, oxygen source (e.g.
                                 oxidiser in tooth powders and
                                 toothpaste). Topical antiseptic.
                                 Bleaching agents for textiles;
                                 component of detergents, mouthwash;
                                 laboratory reagent; agent in
                                 neutralising cold wave preparation;
                                 electroplating agent; germicide;
                                 deodorant; agent in developing vat
                                 dye.

                              1. As for sodium perborate (ECHA
                                 2014c).
Sodium                        2. Food additive, inert pesticides, active
                                                                           AISE,
peroxometaborate      No         biocide, fracking.                        Cosmetics
EC 231-556-4                  3. Cleaning agent, laundry and               Europe
CAS 7632-04-4                    dishwashing products, surface
                                 treatment, and cosmetics.
16

                            Regis-
                                                                                        Relevant
                            tered
        Substance                                     Use summary                       industry
                            (Yes/
                                                                                      associations
                             No)

                                       1. Information on use is ‘confidential and
                                          therefore cannot be provided’ (ECHA
                                          2015b).
                                       3. CAS 117933-89-8 used in cosmetics
                                          and PCPs. ECHA has no public
    5-sec-butyl-2-(2,4-
    dimethylcyclohex-3-                   registered data indicating whether or
    en-1-yl)-5-methyl-                    in which chemical products the
    1,3-dioxane [1], 5-                   substance might be used5. Stated to
    sec-butyl-2-(4,6-                     be manufactured and/or imported in
    dimethylcyclohex-3-                   the European Economic Area in 1-10
    en-1-yl)-5-methyl-                    tonnes per year. Raw material for
    1,3-dioxane [2]            No         cosmetic manufacturing, fragrance          Cosmetics
    [covering any of the                  (CAS 117933-89-8).                         Europe
    individual                         4. PubChem: Cleaning/washing,
    stereoisomers of                      fragrance (consumer use), chemical
    [1] and [2] or any
                                          manufacturing, raw material for
    combination
                                          personal care products/cosmetics
    thereof]
                                       5. Known as amber dioxane6 and used as
    EC -
                                          a woody fragrance in PCPs. Trade
    CAS -
                                          name is Karanal; alternative CAS
                                          given as 186309-28-4 (available from
                                          China). Recently used in a number of
                                          perfumes.

                                       1. UV absorber. Phenolic benzotriazoles
                                          are technically the most important UV
                                          absorbers and specifically for
                                          transparent plastics. UV stabiliser in
                                          plastic shrink films (including food
                                          packaging), outdoor furniture and
                                          clear coat automotive finishes. UV-328
    2-(2H-benzotriazol-                   is also used for light stabilising in
    2-yl)-4,6-                            coatings, Acrylonitrile butadiene          CEPE (inks and
    ditertpentylphenol                    styrene resin, epoxy resin, fibre resin,      pigments),
                               Yes        propylene and polyvinyl chloride. It is
    (UV-328)                                                                         Plastics Europe,
    EC 247-384-8                          also effective in light stabilisation of    FEICA, ETRMA
    CAS 25973-55-1                        unsaturated polyester, polyacrylate
                                          and polycarbonate (ECHA 2014d).
                                       2. Consumer fragrances,
                                          fabric/textile/leather products,
                                          furniture/furnishings, inert pesticides,
                                          automotive.
                                       3. Construction materials, fillers, surface
                                          treatment, adhesives,

5
    https://echa.europa.eu/substance-information/-/substanceinfo/100.120.617
6
    http://www.thegoodscentscompany.com/data/rw1038591.html
17

                       Regis-
                                                                                  Relevant
                       tered
    Substance                                 Use summary                         industry
                       (Yes/
                                                                                associations
                        No)

                                   intermediates/additives in plastics
                                   manufacture,
                                   paint/lacquers/varnishes, reprographic
                                   agents, printing inks, raw materials for
                                   production of plastic, manufacturing of
                                   machinery/equipment/transport
                                   equipment, manufacture of
                                   basic/fabricated metals, serigraphic
                                   printing.
                                4. UV stabiliser in polyolefin films,
                                   outdoor furniture and clear coat
                                   automotive finishes. Used as a UV
                                   absorber in plastic applications.
                                   Particularly recommended for
                                   polyolefins, polyurethanes, PVC,
                                   polyacrylate, epoxy, and elastomers.

                                1. One company indicated that 50 % of
                                   all of their products of this substance
                                   class are used as UV-protection agents
                                   in coatings especially for cars and
                                   special industrial wood coatings. Ca.
                                   40 % are used as UV-protection
                                   agents for plastics, rubber and
                                   polyurethanes. The rest is used in
                                   cosmetics (e.g. as sun protection
                                   agents). UV stabiliser for a wide range
                                   of plastics and articles, for example:
                                   polycarbonates, acrylic polymers,
2,4-di-tert-butyl-6-               polyester (saturated and unsaturated),
(5-                                styrene mono- and copolymers,               CEPE (inks and
chlorobenzotriazol-
                        No         polyvinyl chloride, polyolefins,            pigments),
2-yl)phenol (UV-
                                   polyvinylbutyle, and polyurethanes.         Plastics Europe,
327)
                                   UV-327 is also a UV stabiliser for          FEICA, ETRMA
EC 223-383-8
CAS 3864-99-1                      rubber and constituents in
                                   formulations used for coating of
                                   surfaces, e.g. cars or special industrial
                                   wood coatings (ECHA 2015c).
                                2. Drinking water and food contact
                                   material.
                                3. Adhesive, binding agent, automotive,
                                   construction material, colouring agent,
                                   filler, tightening material (putty),
                                   manufacture of rubber and plastic
                                   products, paint, lacquers and
                                   varnishes, reprographic agent,
                                   serigraphic printing, printing inks,
18

                             Regis-
                                                                                        Relevant
                             tered
           Substance                                 Use summary                        industry
                             (Yes/
                                                                                      associations
                              No)

                                          sealing compounds, UV stabilisers, raw
                                          material for plastics production.

    2-(2H-benzotriazol-
    2-yl)-4-(tert-butyl)-
                                       1. As for UV-327 (ECHA 2015d).
    6-(sec-butyl)phenol        No
    (UV-350)                           2. UV stabiliser.
    EC 253-037-1
    CAS 36437-37-3
                                       1. According to general knowledge on
                                          phenolic benzotriazoles, it is expected
                                          that UV-320 will be used as UV
                                          stabiliser for plastics, polyurethanes
    2-benzotriazol-2-yl-
                                          and rubber and constituent in
    4,6-di-tert-
                                          formulations used for coating of
    butylphenol (UV-           No
    320)                                  surfaces, e.g. cars or special industrial
    EC 223-346-6                          wood coatings. Constituent in rubber
    CAS 3846-71-7                         and plastic products (ECHA 2014e).
                                       2. Manufacturing rubber and plastic
                                          products, automotive, absorbent and
                                          adsorbent, UV stabiliser.

Sources:

      1.    ECHA Annex XV report for the substance.
      2.    Information compiled from US EPA CPCat Database.
      3.    SPIN/KEMI.
      4.    HSDB/PubChem.

An internet search for the presence of the 11 substances in articles on the EU market did not
yield results for the majority of the substances, with the exception of the three substances
detailed in Table 4.

Two of the phthalates (CAS 84-75-3 and 68515-51-5/68648-93-1) are listed as constituents of
Christmas decorations and one of them (dihexyl phthalate) is listed as occurring in consumer
electronics and aerospace applications. Sodium perborate is listed as a constituent of a magnetic
tripod7.

The volume used seems to be low and the production seems to take place outside the EU. As
such, this niche use of the substance is unlikely to result in an application. There is also ongoing
use of this substance in antiseptic mouth rinse8 and as a bleaching agent in a product imported

7
 https://www.festool.ch/de-ch/zubehoer/499814---ma-kal
8
 https://www.mouthulcers.co.uk/amosan-
bocasan?gclid=EAIaIQobChMIo8iE4PqC5QIVD44YCh1ESgjdEAkYAiABEgJePvD_BwE#.XZdqj1VKipo
19

from the US9 but these uses are unlikely to be continued once the substance is placed on the
Authorisation List as virtually all oxygen bleaches now use sodium percarbonate as an alternative
to sodium perborate.

Table 4 - Current use of substances in articles on EU market
                                                     Registered
                    Substance                                                    Articles
                                                      (Yes/No)

                                                                     Consumer electronics,
    Dihexyl phthalate                                    No          aerospace applications
    (CAS 84-75-3)
                                                                     Christmas decorations

    1,2-Benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-
    alkyl esters; 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid,
    mixed decyl and hexyl and octyl diesters             No          Christmas decorations
    with ≥ 0.3% of dihexyl phthalate
    (CAS 68515-51-5,
    68648-93-1)
    Sodium perborate; perboric acid, sodium
    salt                                                Yes          Electric tools
    (CAS 11138-47-9)

ECHA undertook a search of the SPIN database (Table 11), which indicated that several of the
substances are used in Nordic countries alone in volumes of several tonnes per year, including
one substance not currently registered under REACH (UV-327). This is likely to be because the
substance is imported by multiple importers under one tonne each from outside of the EU.

The list of the substances for which entries have been recorded in the SPIN database for 2017
is given in Appendix C. The latest information available in the SPIN database is from 2017 (i.e.
there are no data records for 2018 and 2019). Given the absence of data for the last two years,
it is not possible to fully assess the recent trends in the use of the concerned substances or to
ascertain whether their uses have been discontinued.

An internet search for commercial suppliers of the 11 substances indicated a number of suppliers
worldwide for all substances and the existence of EU suppliers for most of the substances (except
sodium perborate), although there was only one EU supplier identified for the following
substances:

      •   1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-alkyl esters; 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid,
          mixed decyl and hexyl and octyl diesters with ≥ 0.3% of dihexyl phthalate;
      •   5-sec-butyl-2-(2,4-dimethylcyclohex-3-en-1-yl)-5-methyl-1,3-dioxane [1], 5-sec-butyl-
          2-(4,6-dimethylcyclohex-3-en-1-yl)-5-methyl-1,3-dioxane; and
      •   UV-350.

A full list of all suppliers identified by this search is provided in Tables 9 and 10 of Appendix B.
The results of this search indicate the existence of an active market for most of the substances
although it is uncertain what the actual size of the market is and whether the amount placed on

9
 https://uk.ninthavenue.com/products/sodium-perborate-granular-1-lb?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI-P-
pufuC5QIVGomyCh3SIAxKEAkYEiABEgL4GvD_BwE
20

the EU market exceeds the one tonne per year threshold for registration under REACH (it was
only possible to determine where quantities greater than 1 kg are available and this is indicated
in Table 10 in Appendix B).

Potential alternatives to substances proposed for the Authorisation
List

A brief assessment of potential alternatives indicated that a number of possible alternatives are
available for each of the 11 substances placed on the Authorisation List; these are detailed in
Table 5.

The consultation with registrants and sectoral trade associations indicated that substitution has
already taken place for three of the four substances that are currently registered under REACH,
either following or shortly before their designation as substances of very high concern (SVHCs).

Sodium perborate has been replaced by the less toxic but equally effective sodium percarbonate.
1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, dihexyl ester, branched and linear has been replaced by other
plasticisers, and trixylyl phosphate is no longer placed on the EU market, having been replaced
by other flame retardants in its previous main use in lubricants and other functional fluids.

Non-SVHC listed light stabilisers are available as substitutes for UV-328 and it is envisaged that
they will be phased in during the run up to the sunset date; with the most appropriate
replacement depending upon the specific end use. UV-328 is a phenolic benzotriazole and while
other substances from this chemical class have hazardous properties and are also proposed for
the Authorisation List, other related benzotriazoles are not SVHCs and can be used as
substitutes. Other possible UV absorbers and light stabilisers include benzophenones and
hindered amine light stabilisers (HALS), which also protect plastics from UV radiation but are not
UV absorbers, instead functioning as degradation inhibitors by acting as proton-donators.

Table 5 - Potential alternatives to 11 substances being placed on the Authorisation List
               Substance                                   Source of information

                                            Alternative substances could be other phthalates
 1,2-Benzenedicarboxylic acid, dihexyl      with short or long carbon backbones, depending on
 ester, branched and linear                 the physicochemical property needed10 (ECHA
 EC 271-093-5                               2014a).
 CAS 68515-50-4
                                            Various options depending on phthalate function11.

10
   However, these may have similar reprotoxic effects as 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, dihexyl ester,
branched and linear.
11
   https://chemsec.org/publication/endocrine-disruptors,substitution/replacing-phthalates
21

             Substance                                Source of information

                                        Alternative substances might be phthalates with
                                        short or long carbon backbones, depending on the
                                        physicochemical property needed. Depending on
                                        the functionality needed, chemicals like citrates
                                        (biodegradable and not toxic), adipates,
                                        phosphates (resistant to ignition and burning),
                                        trimellitates (exceptional thermal properties.) etc.
Dihexyl phthalate                       could be used as alternatives of dihexyl phthalate.
EC 201-559-5                            Potential alternatives as assessed in the case of the
CAS 84-75-3                             restriction proposal for bis(2-ethylhexyl)phthalate
                                        (DEHP, CAS 117-81-7), Benzyl butyl phthalate
                                        (BBP, CAS 85-68-7), Dibutyl phthalate (DBP, CAS
                                        84-74-2), and Diisobutyl phthalate (DIBP, CAS 84-
                                        69-5) could be of interest for dihexyl phthalate
                                        (ECHA 2013a).

                                        Various options depending on phthalate function15.

1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-
10-alkyl esters; 1,2-
                                        Substance itself containing less than 0.3 % (w/w)
benzenedicarboxylic acid, mixed decyl
                                        of dihexyl phthalate (ECHA 2015a).
and hexyl and octyl diesters with ≥
0.3% of dihexyl phthalate
(EC 201-559-5)                          Various options depending on phthalate function15.
EC 271-094-0; 272-013-1
CAS 68515-51-5; 68648-93-1
                                        Other phosphate esters, e.g. BuTTP (less
                                        problematic triarylphosphate) or polyol esters are
Trixylyl phosphate                      alternatives as hydraulic fluids. Isopropylphenyl
EC 246-677-8                            diphenyl phosphate (IPDPP) and tris-
CAS 25155-23-1                          (isopropylphenyl) phosphate (IPPP) are alternatives
                                        for PVC products and lubricants (ECHA 2013b).

Sodium perborate; perboric acid,        In the EU, sodium perborates have almost
sodium salt                             exclusively been replaced by the alternative sodium
EC 239-172-9; 234-390-0                 percarbonate, which is less toxic (ECHA 2014b).
CAS - 15120-21-5; 11138-47-9
Sodium peroxometaborate
EC 231-556-4                            As for sodium perborate (ECHA 2014c).
CAS 7632-04-4
22

                    Substance                                          Source of information

 5-sec-butyl-2-(2,4-dimethylcyclohex-
 3-en-1-yl)-5-methyl-1,3-dioxane [1],
 5-sec-butyl-2-(4,6-dimethylcyclohex-
                                                        Information on alternatives is ‘confidential and
 3-en-1-yl)-5-methyl-1,3-dioxane [2]
 [covering any of the individual                        therefore cannot be provided’ (ECHA 2015b).
 stereoisomers of [1] and [2] or any
 combination thereof]
 EC / CAS -
                                                        Other phenolic benzotriazoles (but may also have
                                                        PBT/vPvB properties). Benzophenones are other
                                                        technically important UV absorbers for transparent
 2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-
                                                        plastic materials but may be potential endocrine
 ditertpentylphenol (UV-328)
 EC 247-384-8                                           disruptors. Hindered amine light stabilisers (HALS)
 CAS 25973-55-1                                         also protect plastics from UV radiation – not
                                                        UV absorbers but function as degradation inhibitors
                                                        by being proton-donators (ECHA 2014d).

 2,4-di-tert-butyl-6-(5-
 chlorobenzotriazol-2-yl)phenol (UV-                    As above for UV-328 and other potential alternative
 327)                                                   substances acting as UV stabilisers are triazines,
 EC 223-383-8                                           oxanilides, and cyanoacrylates (ECHA 2015c).
 CAS 3864-99-1
 2-(2H-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4-(tert-
 butyl)-6-(sec-butyl)phenol (UV-350)
                                                        As for UV-327 (ECHA 2015d).
 EC 253-037-1
 CAS 36437-37-3
 2-benzotriazol-2-yl-4,6-di-tert-
 butylphenol (UV-320)
                                                        As for UV-328 (ECHA 2014e).
 EC 223-346-6
 CAS 3846-71-7
Sources: ECHA Annex XV report for the substance and ChemSec Marketplace12.

Stakeholder consultation

The stakeholder consultation led by ECHA focused on four of the 11 substances to be placed on
the Authorisation List that had active REACH registrations when the project commenced at the
beginning of September 2019, i.e.

       EC                         CAS                EC Name
       271-094-0                  68515-51-5         1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-c6-10-alkyl esters
       246-677-8                  25155-23-1         trixylyl phosphate
       234-390-0                  11138-47-9         perboric acid, sodium salt
       247-384-8                  25973-55-1         2-(2h-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-ditertpentylphenol (UV-328)

The results of the stakeholder consultation detailed in this section of the report for these four
substances are a combination of responses received by both ECHA and the wca project team.

12   https://chemsec.org/business-tool/marketplace
23

ECHA investigated PPORD13, substances in articles14, and C&L notifications15 for the seven
unregistered substances. ECHA investigated PPORD16, substances in articles17, and C&L
notifications18 for the seven unregistered substances. It has been observed that ECHA has
received only one substance in article notification for 2,4-di-tert-butyl-6-(5-chlorobenzotriazol-
2-yl)phenol (UV-327), whereas no PPORD notification has been received for any of the
substances. On the other hand, C&L notifications have been received for the six substances
detailed in Table 6.

Table 6 - Classification and labelling notifications for unregistered substances on the
Authorisation List
                                                                                  Total number              Number of
                                                             Number of             of members            notifications not
     EC Number                  EC Name                        group                part of the           submitted on
                                                            notifications             group                 behalf of a
                                                                                  notifications                group

 201-559-5           dihexyl phthalate                              3                     27                        5
                     2-benzotriazol-2-yl-4,6-di-
 223-346-6                                                          3                    104                       15
                     tert-butylphenol
                     2,4-di-tert-butyl-6-(5-
 223-383-8           chlorobenzotriazol-2-                         16                    373                       54
                     yl)phenol
 231-556-4           sodium peroxometaborate                        6                    159                       18
                     2-(2h-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4-
 253-037-1           (tert-butyl)-6-(sec-                           5                    147                        8
                     butyl)phenol
                     1,2-benzenedicarboxylic
 271-093-5           acid, dihexyl ester,                           2                     14                        2
                     branched and linear

It is impossible to infer from C&L notifications whether any of the notifiers still use the substance,
even more so, whether they intend to submit an application for authorisation. ECHA sent a short
survey to the notifiers to gauge their potential interest in submitting an application for
authorisation in the future. Only one response was received.

Given the absence of responses it may be inferred with some degree of certainty that the notifiers
did not have a particular interest in applying for authorisation for the given substances. It is also
possible that the notifiers no longer use the substances.

1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-C6-10-alkyl esters
The lead registrant for this substance indicated to ECHA that they ceased production of the
substance in the EU approximately two years ago, after the substance was identified as a

13 https://echa.europa.eu/support/dossier-submission-tools/reach-it/ppord
14
   https://echa.europa.eu/regulations/reach/candidate-list-substances-in-articles/notification-of-substances-in-articles
15 https://echa.europa.eu/regulations/clp/cl-inventory/notification-to-the-cl-inventory
16 https://echa.europa.eu/support/dossier-submission-tools/reach-it/ppord
17 https://echa.europa.eu/regulations/reach/candidate-list-substances-in-articles/notification-of-substances-in-articles
18 https://echa.europa.eu/regulations/clp/cl-inventory/notification-to-the-cl-inventory
24

substance of very high concern (SVHC) and it became apparent that it was likely to be placed
on the Authorisation List. The lead registrant was the only manufacturer of the substance in the
EU (and worldwide) and their registration status is currently “inactive”.

1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-c6-10-alkyl esters was used as plasticiser for very niche and
specific applications and the registrant manufactures other (non-SVHC listed) plasticisers that
are suitable alternatives for the required functions. They, therefore, consider that there is no
need to continue manufacturing the substance and were definitive in their assertion that there
would not be any applications for authorisation for this substance, especially as imported articles
cannot contain this substance, as the lead registrant was the only global manufacturer.

Trixylyl phosphate
Regarding trixylyl phosphate, ECHA received opinions from both the current lead registrant, and
the trade association ATIEL (representative body of the European lubricants industry). The lead
registrant does not intend to support any applications for authorisation. However, one of the
customers of the co-registrant intends to make a downstream application for the use of the
substance in power plant turbines.

ATIEL reported that the use of trixylyl phosphate has been discontinued by all of its members
(i.e. manufacturers of lubricants). Evaluation of EU downstream uses has shown that acceptable
alternatives are available and are already being used in the EU.

At the appropriate time before an established sunset date, the registration dossier will be
updated by the lead registrant to delete all authorisable uses. Discussions within the Phosphate
ester Flame Retardants (PFR) Consortium will be held to transfer the lead registration to another
member if one does intend to support end uses within the EU.

Perboric acid, sodium salt (sodium perborate)
ECHA determined that there are currently only two manufacturers of sodium perborate in the
EU. Both manufacturers largely export outside the EU. However, one of them still continues to
supply the substance for very few specific applications in the EU. One former manufacturer, and
original member of the REACH Registration Consortium for sodium perborate, completely
stopped manufacturing sodium perborate before the substance was identified as a substance of
very high concern (SVHC) and added to the Candidate List in 2014. This was largely their
business decision unrelated to REACH. The main uses for sodium perborate nowadays are in the
oil and gas industry, whereas formerly they were widely used in powder detergents below specific
concentration limits.

Several sources have confirmed to ECHA that sodium percarbonate is the main alternative
substance to replace sodium perborate and that it fully meets functionality/performance
requirements without the hazards associated with sodium perborate. A former manufacturer
stated that they switched to manufacturing sodium percarbonate after discontinuing the
manufacture of sodium perborate. Another company manufactures both sodium perborate and
sodium percarbonate.

Both manufacturers had many EU-based customers, but when discussions started that the
substance might be listed as an SVHC, the detergent industry started slowly moving away from
sodium perborate and they lost most of their EU customers. Additionally, the detergent industry
has moved rapidly towards liquid detergent (as opposed to powder-based products) meaning
that overall demand for both sodium perborate and its main alternative sodium percarbonate
25

has seen a rapid decline as both substances are used as solids.

Given these developments, both existing manufacturers of sodium perborate stated that they
do not see any business sense in applying for authorisation in the hope of ‘winning back the lost
customers’. These customers would not want to switch back to sodium perborate anyway, given
that a safer (non-SVHC listed) alternative is already readily available on the market at a
reasonable/competitive price.

2-(2h-benzotriazol-2-yl)-4,6-bis(1,1-dimethylpropyl)phenol [UV-328]
Both registrant and co-registrant stated that 100 % of the UV-328 is imported into the EU,
mainly from Asia as a pure substance or in mixtures. The substance is not used as an
intermediate or monomer.

One registrant stated that they will supply the substance until the sunset date but they will not
apply for authorisation on their own as they already have several viable alternatives to UV-328
that are not substances of very high concern (SVHCs) (e.g. phenolic benzotriazoles that are non-
PBT and non-vPvB) and see little value in preparing an application given the number of
economically/technically feasible alternatives. However, there is a possibility that some of their
downstream users (e.g. the automotive industry) may submit an application if they were
confronted with a lengthy and involved ‘recertification process’ for parts. This was thought to
result in no more than one or two applications from the automotive industry.

The registrant expressed a concern that after UV-328 and the other phenolic benzotriazoles
stabilisers (e.g. UV-327 and UV-350, which are unregistered) are officially added to the
Authorisation List, the import of articles containing these substances will continue from outside
the EU. The registrant, therefore, expressed the view that industry should strongly advocate for
EU-wide measures to address this.

The co-registrant for UV-328 confirmed that they had similar views and stated that they will not
continue to import and supply UV-328 after the sunset date. They will not submit an application
on their own and do not expect any of their downstream users to submit it either, as there are
readily available alternatives as UV stabilisers, which they also market (these were stated to be
non-benzotriazoles but further details were considered commercially sensitive and confidential).

Following discussion with the wca project team, the sectoral trade association for downstream
users of this type of substance, ELiSANA (European Light Stabilisers and Antioxidants
Association) publicised this project to their members and encouraged them to make contact if
they anticipated submitting an application for UV-328 or other related substances to be placed
on the Authorisation List. No responses were received, which is another indication that ECHA is
unlikely to receive applications for continued use of these substances.

Supply chain description

There is no supply chain to consider for 1,2-benzenedicarboxylic acid, di-c6-10-alkyl as it is no
longer manufactured in the EU.

Sodium perborate is no longer placed on the EU market by one of the two existing European
manufacturers, who only exports their product to countries outside of the EU. The other
manufacturer still supplies the substance for very niche applications in the EU and may continue
to do so until the sunset date. It appears that there is a small residual market for bleaching
You can also read