EFFECT OF ORGANIC FERTILIZERS ON SUSCEPTIBILITY OF POTTED DURIAN SEEDLINGS
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Journal of Fruit and Ornamental Plant Research Vol. 17(1), 2009: 67-77 EFFECT OF ORGANIC FERTILIZERS ON SUSCEPTIBILITY OF POTTED DURIAN SEEDLINGS TO Phytophthora DISEASES M ur yat i , Li z a Oct ri ana, Deni Em i lda , P anca J arot S ant os o and Di ah S unarw at i Indonesian Tropical Fruit Research Institute, Jl. Raya Solok-Aripan Km 8 PO Box 5 Solok, WEST SUMATRA, 27301 e-mail: mooryati@yahoo.com (Received February 14, 2009/Accepted April 15, 2009) AB ST R ACT This research was aimed on evaluating the effect of organic fertilizers on susceptibility of durian seedlings to Phytophthora palmivora. The green compost, chicken manure and rice husk, alone or in a mixture, significantly increased seedling survival. Therefore, such growing media composition should be taken into account as one of the elements of integrated Phytophthora control in durian. On the other hand, goat manure has a ruinous effect on the growth and survival of durian seedlings and shall be avoided in durian orchards. Key words: Phytophthora palmivora, durian, organic fertilizers, control INTRODUCT ION 11.086 tons of this fruit at a cost of 11.730.903 US$. This indicates that Durian is one of the important Indonesia is still open for durian fruit in Indonesia. Its production has market and for developing durian risen as much as 42.4% during 4 last orchards. years; from 525.064 tons in 2002 to There are several constraints in 747.848 tons in 2006 (Anonymous, developing durian orchard in Indo- 2007). However, even though this nesia. One of the most important is country is one of the biggest durian Phytophthora palmivora. This soilborne producers in the world, it was pathogen causes many diseases in reported that Indonesia imported various tissues of durian, including
Muryati et al. root rot on root, collar rot/foot rot toward the infection zone (Drenth and patch canker on stem, leaf blight and Guest, 2004; Linderman, 2003; on leaf, and fruit rot on fruit. (Lee Ristaino and Johnston, 1999). and Lum, 2004). When Phytophthora Some wild species of durian were attacks roots, the symptom will apear reported to be resistant to root rot on upper parts of the plant such as (Shamsudin et al., 2000; Kanzaki et leaf yellowing, particularly at the al., 1997). Hence, these materials shoot tips, leaf shed, slowed plant should be used as durian rootstock. growth, and possibly limb dieback Durian varieties with good quality occurring at early stages of the are then grafted onto these rootstocks disease (Hagan, 2008). to produce marketable durian trees This disease destroyed many that are resistant to P. palmivora. durian orchards in Indonesia. This Meanwhile, biological control can be can be indicated by very small applied by using antagonist fungi like supply of superior durian fruits on Gliocladium sp., Trichoderma sp., the market even though the farmers P. fluorescens. This measure can also have planted many superior durian be incorporated with other control varieties. According to Drenth and measures to control P. palmivora Sendall (2004), this pathogen caused (Drenth and Guest, 2004; da S. Costa losses in durian orchards in Indonesia et al., 2000). varying from 20-25% with economic Phytophthora palmivora can also value about US$ 780.000.000. The be controlled by using organic ferti- pathogen also destroyed up to 30% lizers such as manure and compost durian orchards in Penang, Malaysia because they can stabilize soil pH (Hasan and Siew, 2000) and up to 54% and be appropriate for developing in Australia (Zappala et al., 2002). antagonistic microorganism (Liu et Integrated management of P. pal- al., 2007; Drenth and Guest, 2004; mivora could be reached by incor- Linderman, 2003; Aryantha et al., porating several control measures, such 2000). Organic matters can induce as planting resistant varieties, biological systemic resistance in plants due to control, manipulation of the environ- the presence of microorganisms in ment by reducing humidity in orchards composts (Hoitink et al., 2000). It through pruning, weeding and impro- has been reported that certain plant ving soil drainage (Purwantara et al., growth promoting microorganisms 2004). Poor aeration of the growth (PGPM) could enhance defensive media may promote the growth of activity and stimulate plant resistance Phytophthora and increase vulner- against soil borne pathogens (Kilic- ability of plant to infection as well. All Ekici and Yuen, 2003; Zheng et al., Phytophthora species grow better under 2005) water lodging. In this condition the It is important to choose the spores germinate and produce sporangia appropriate organic fertilizer for con- that release zoospores which are trolling disease because composition of moving actively or passively in water organic matter has important effect on 68 J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77
…organic fertilizers on susceptibility…to Phytophthora… development of plant diseases. Hoitink 10) Soil + compost + goat manure + et al. (2000) stated that each type of rice husk (3 : 1 : 1 : 1). compost has its own properties that 11) Soil + compost + chicken manure + must be considered during its utili- rice husk (3 : 1 : 1 : 1). zation. 12) Control (soil without organic The aim of the research was to matter). evaluate the effect of organic matter The organic matters used in this composition in the growing media on experiment were the materials avail- the control of P. palmivora infecting able for farmers and usually used for durian seedling. fertilizing their orchards. MATERIAL AND M ETHODS Preparation of P. Palmivora ino- culum and plant inoculation The research was conducted in the P. palmivora used in the experi- screen house of Indonesian Tropical ment was S-20-Sut strain from Fruit Research Institute from January a collection of Indonesian Tropical to December 2007. Fruit Research Institute, isolated from durian root infected by Material P. palmivora in North Sumatra. The Durian seedlings of five cultivars postulate Koch had also been tested were planted in the plastic pots (10 l in to ensure that the pathogen gave the volume). The experiment was arranged same symptom on the tested durian in a completely randomized design seedlings. consisted of 12 treatments and 10 The isolate was cultured on PSM replications. The five unit samples (Phytophthora Selective Medium) were used in each replication. The for 7 days. To multiply and sporulate treatments, various media composi- the fungi, 15 Petri dishes (10 cm in tions for potted durian seedlings, diameter) of P. palmivora culture were as follows: were mixed with 1 litre of papaya juice and shaken for 2 days to get 1) Soil + cow manure (1 : 1). density of spore suspension 10 7 2) Soil + goat manure (1 : 1). spore/cm3 (counted with haemocy- 3) Soil + chicken manure (1 : 1). tometer). Two-month-old durian 4) Soil + green compost (1 : 1). seedling s were then inoculated 5) Soil + rice husk (1 : 1). with 10 ml/pot of such prepared 6) Soil + compost + cow manure (2 P. palmivora suspension by soil : 1 : 1). drenching. 7) Soil + compost + goat manure (2 : 1 : 1). Soil sampling and Phytophthora 8) Soil + compost + chicken manure (2 : 1 : 1). baiting 9) Soil + compost + cow manure + Soil sampling was done every rice husk (3 : 1 : 1 : 1). month to observe the dynamic of J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77 69
Muryati et al. Phytophthora and other microbes as times in a proportion of 1 : 10 to well in each media. Twenty five obtain final dilution 10-3, 3) One cm 3 grams of media were taken from of diluted suspension was put into each replication and the samples 9 cm Petri dish and 10 cm3 PDA or taken from the same treatment were NA media were added. After bulked. To analyse the dynamic of incubation at 26oC for 5 days, the Phytophthora growth in each treat- morphology of developed cultures ment, the baiting was done using was observed under microscope in apple fruit. The procedures of Phy- order to determine their affiliation to tophthora isolation from the soil systematic groups. were as follows: 1) The surface of Observations were done on: apple fruits was sterilised with 70% alcohol and then air dried; 2) Three 1. The density of microbial popula- holes 5 mm in diameter were made tion. The density of bacteria was in each apple using cork borer, where determined based on the number each hole represented a replication; of colonies per gram of soil 3) Three grams of soil sample were sample (Schaad et al., 2001) put into each hole and covered with while the density of the fungi cellulose tape; 4) The apples with was determined based on the soil samples inside were then number of spores per gram soil incubated at room temperature for sample (Barnet, 1962). 3 days, 5) After incubation, usually 2. The number of plants showing rot symptom appeared on the edge of Phytophthora symptoms (die the inoculated holes. The edge of the back, yellowing of the foliage, rot symptom on the apple was sliced, leaf shed) and/or dead plants due inoculated on PSM medium and to Phytophthora. incubated for 3-5 days; eventually the 3. The plant growth rate (number of cultures were observed to investigate leaves, diameter of stems, height the presence of Phytophthora. of plants). The observations were Observations were also made on made at 2 week intervals. the presence of other microorganisms as well. For this purpose, the soil Statistical analysis. The data were samples were cultured on the PDA subjected to analysis of variance and medium for fungi and on the NA means were separated by LSD test at medium for bacteria. The proce- p ≤0.05. The relationships between dures were as follows: 1) Ten grams the parameter observed were of soil sample were mixed with 90 analyzed by correlation analysis (p ≤ cm 3 of sterile distilled water and the 0.05) followed by analysis of mixture was gently shaken 2) One regression (p ≤0.05). The regression cm 3 of soil/water suspension was model showing the highest R2 was taken out and put into test tube chosen as the fitted model. All containing 9 ml distilled water. The calculations were performed using suspension was then diluted three the statistical program SPSS 2000. 70 J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77
…organic fertilizers on susceptibility…to Phytophthora… RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 4). This might be explained by the fact that the better growth of plant led to the better defence against Addition of goat manure to the pathogen infection (induced resistance). growing media resulted in a strong Similar results were obtained by Tan et increase of durian seedling mortality al. (2008) who reported that the (Tab. 1). This phenomenon may be incorporation of chicken manure into explained by the lowest microbe the potting mix resulted in enhanced diversity in the media containing survival of P. palmivora-infected goat manure. The regression analysis papaya plants, stimulation of root showed that there is a significant regeneration, and reduction of P. pal- positive correlation between the mivora to undetectable levels within number of microbes present in the 4 weeks. The enhanced survival of media and the survival rate of the infected papaya and durian plants seedlings (Fig. 1). grown in chicken manure-amended The high microbe diversity present potting mix was attributed to the higher in the media tended to promote high levels of antagonistic microorganisms, competition among the microbes, such as Actinomycetes, which led to the hence, the ability of Phytophthora to suppression of the pathogen. infect plant became lower. This fact There are several ways in which is in accordance with the principle of organic matters in the soil can in- biological control of Phytophthora, directly control Phytophthora, namely: that the improvement of the environ- 1) Increasing the activity of the ment, especially of the rhisosphera, indigenous microflora, resulting in is important to support the antago- suppression of pathogen population nistic microorganisms in suppressing through competition or specific Phytophthora infecting the plants. inhibition (Konam and Guest, 2002; Adding organic matter to the soil is Broadbent and Baker, 1974); 2) the key factor to stimulate antagonistic Releasing degrading compounds such activity (Linderman, 2003; Bulluck et as carbon dioxide, ammonia, nitrites, al., 2002). saponins or enzymes that are generally The use of goat manure mixed toxic to Phytophthora (Tsao and with soil for durian media not only Oster, 1981); 3) Acting as a trap, since caused the highest mortality of durian Phytophthora will be attracted to and seedling but also was unfavourable for encyst on organic matter (Grant et al., their growth. The most favourable 1985); 4) Inducing plant defence media for durian growth was the soil mechanisms (Gilpatrick, 1969); and 5) mixed with green compost, chicken Creating an environment that stimulates manure, and rice husk, since the root development by physically highest of leaves number, stem inhibiting Phytophthora (Turner and diameter and plant height as well as Menge, 1994). 100% seedling survival were Experiments with the soil baiting observed in these treatments (Fig. 2- have shown that the organic matters J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77 71
Muryati et al. T a b l e 1 . Effect of growth media composition on survival of durian seedlings Mean percentage of Treatment dead plant [%] 1. Soil + cow manure (1 : 1) 2 a* 2. Soil + goat manure (1 : 1) 18 b 3. Soil + chicken manure (1 : 1) 0 a 4. Soil + green compost (1 : 1) 0 a 5. Soil + rice husk (1 : 1) 0 a 6. Soil + compost + cow manure (2 : 1 : 1) 4 a 7. Soil + compost + goat manure (2 : 1 : 1) 4 a 8. Soil + compost + chicken manure (2 : 1 : 1) 2 a 9. Soil + compost + cow manure + rice husk (3 : 1 : 1 : 1) 0 a 10 Soil + compost + goat manure + rice husk (3 : 1 : 1 : 1) 0 a 11. Soil + compost + chicken manure + rice husk (3 : 1 : 1 : 1) 0 a 12. Control (soil without organic matter) 4 a *Means followed by the same letter are not significantly different by LSD test at p ≤0.05 20 The percen tage of dead plant (%) 10 Y = 172.853 – 61.471X + 5.4464X2 2 R = 0.585; P = 0.019 0 -10 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5 6.0 6.5 The number of microbes (number of colony/gr soil) Figure 1. Relationship between the number of microbes in the growing media and the survival of durian seedlings 72 J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77
…organic fertilizers on susceptibility…to Phytophthora… 25 23 Th e n u m ber of du rian leaves 21 19 17 15 13 11 9 7 5 3 1 -1 7 7 00 2007 20 07 2007 2007 2007 2007 20 07 200 2007 2007 007 2007 007 / 5 /2 5 / 5 / 6 / 6 / 7 / 7 / 8 / / 9/ / 0/ 0/ 2 / 11/ 1/ 2 2 / / / / / / / 4 /9 15 30 14 26 12 26 10 20 4/ 1 23/ 1 6 2 1 /1 Observation date T reatment 1 T reatment 2 T reatment 3 T reatment 4 T reatment 5 T reatment 6 T reatment 7 T reatment 8 T reatment 9 T reatment 10 T reatment 11 T reatment 12 Figure 2. Effect of growth media composition on development of leaves on durian seedling 8 7.5 7 The diameter of durian stem (mm) 6.5 6 5.5 5 4.5 4 3.5 3 2.5 2 07 07 07 07 07 07 07 07 07 07 07 7 07 20 /2 0 /20 /20 / 20 / 20 /2 0 /2 0 20 /20 / 20 00 /2 0 /5/ /5 /5 / 6 / 6 / 7 /7 /8 /9/ / 9 0 0/2 1 2 4 1 /1 1 15 30 14 26 12 26 10 20 4/ 23 6/ Observation date T reatment 1 T reatment 2 T reatment 3 T reatment 4 T reatment 5 T reatment 6 T reatment 7 T reatment 8 T reatment 9 T reatment 10 T reatment 11 T reatment 12 Figure 3. Effect of growth media composition on stem diameter of durian seedlings J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77 73
Muryati et al. 66 64 62 60 58 56 54 52 Plant height (cm) 50 48 46 44 42 40 38 36 34 32 30 28 26 24 22 20 7 07 07 07 07 07 07 07 7 07 07 7 07 7 00 00 00 00 5/ 2 5 /20 5 / 20 6/ 20 6/ 20 7 /2 0 7 /2 0 8 / 20 9/2 9 /20 0 /20 0/2 1/ 20 1/2 2 / / / / / / / / 4 / / 1 /1 1 /1 15 30 14 26 12 26 10 20 4/ 23 6/ 21 Observation date T reatment 1 T reatment 2 T reatment 3 T reatment 4 T reatment 5 T reatment 6 T reatment 7 T reatment 8 T reatment 9 T reatment 10 T reatment 11 T reatment 12 Figure 4. Effect o growth media composition on height of durian seedlings T a b l e 2 . Phytophthora propagules isolated from growth media before and after artificial inoculation Propagule incidence one month after inoculation (months) Treatment before 1 2 3 4 inoculation 1 – + + – – 2 – + + – – 3 – + + – – 4 – + + + – 5 – + – – – 6 – + + – – 7 – – + – – 8 – + + – – 9 – + + – – 10 – + + – – 11 – + + – – 12 – + + – – Note: – = absent; + = present did not affect the Phytophthora inci- increasing diversity of microorga- dence in the soil (Tab. 2). However, nism in the soil, which in turn hinters the presence of organic matter could Phytophthora activity due to com- generate a favourable condition for petition mechanism. In other words, 74 J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77
…organic fertilizers on susceptibility…to Phytophthora… in the suitable plant growth media, Broadbent P., Baker K.F. 1974. Behavior Phytophthora does not threaten the of Phytophthora cinnamoni in soils plant because of existing competitors suppressive and conducive to root and increased plant defence reaction. rot. AUSTRAL. J. AGR. RES. 25: 121-137. CONCLUSION Bulluck L.R., Brosius M, Evanylo G. K., Ristaino J.B. 2002. Organic and 1. Growing media supplemented with synthetic fertility amendments compost, chicken manure and rice influence soil microbial, physical husk were the best compositions for and chemical properties on organic promoting durian seedling’s growth and conventional farms. and limiting the incidence of P. pal- http://www.sciencedirect.com/scienc mivora-related plant mortality. This e? Accessed on 9 June 2008. composition is, therefore, recom- da S. Costa J.L., Menge J.A., Casale mended as a component of the W.L. 2000. Biological control of Phytophthora root rot of avocado integrated durian orchard mana- with microorganisms grown in gement components. organic mulches. BRAZILIAN J. 2. Goat manure has a ruinous effect MICROBIOL. 31 (4): 239-246. on the growth of durian seedling Drenth A., Guest D.I. 2004. Phyto- and does not provide protection phthora in the tropics. In: Drenth A., against P. palmivora attack. dan Guest D.I. (eds), Diversity and Management of Phytophthora in Acknow ledgment : We wish to Southeast Asia. ACIAR Monograph thank: Dr. A. Soemargono and Ir. Sri 114, 238 p. Hadiati, MSc. for their comments in Drenth A., Sendall B. 2004. Economic impact of Phytophthora diseases in the preparation of the manuscript; Southeast Asia. In: Drenth A., Guest Anang Wahyudi and Subhana for their D.I. (eds), Diversity and Mana-gement valuable assistance during the study. of Phytophthora in Southeast Asia. This study was funded by the DIPA of ACIAR Monograph 114, 238 p. Balitbu Tropika fiscal year 2007. Gilpatrick J.D. 1969. Role of ammonia in control of avocado root rot with REFERENCES avocado meal soil amendment. Anonymous 2007. Agricultural Statistics. PHYTOPATHOLOGY 59: 973-978. Ministry of Agriculture, Republic of Grant B.R., Irving H.R., Radda M. 1985. Indonesia, 302 p. The effect of pectin and related Aryantha I.P., Cross R., Guest D.I. 2000. compounds on encystment and Suppression of Phytophthora cin- germination of Phytophthora palmi- namoni in potting mixes amended vora zoospores. J. GEN. MICRO- with uncomposted and composted BIOL. 131: 669-676. animal manures. PHYTOPATHO- Hagan A. 2008. Phytophthora Root Rot LOGY 90: 775-782. on Woody Ornamentals. Barnet H.L. 1962. Illustrated genera of http://www.aces.edu/. Accessed on imperfect fungi. Bunjess Publishing 17 June 2008. Company, USA. J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77 75
Muryati et al. Hasan N.M., Siew L.B. 2000. Pengurusan and infection of pepper. EURO- bersepadu penyakit kanker durian. PEAN J. PLANT PATHOL. 120 (3): Dalam: Prosiding Seminar Durian 273-287. 2000: ”Ke arah menstabilkan Purwantara A., Manohara D., Warokka pengeluaran kualiti dan pasaran”. J.S. 2004. Phytophthora diseases in Zaenal Abidin dkk (editor). Ipoh, Indonesia. In: Drenth A., Guest D.I. Perak, Malaysia. hal 114-121. (eds), Diversity and Management of Hoitink H.A.J., Krause M.S., Stone A.G. Phytophthora in Southeast Asia. 2000. Disease Control Induced by ACIAR Monograph 114, 238 p. Composts in Container Culture and Ristaino J.B., Johnston S.A. 1999. Ground Beds. Bulletin of Orna- Ecologically based approaches to mental Plants Annual Reports and management of Phytophthora blight Research Reviews 2000. on bell pepper. PLANT DISEASE http://ohioline.osu.edu/. Accessed on 83 (12): 1080-1089. 9 June 2008. Schaad N.W., Jone J.B., Chun W. 2001. Kanzaki S., Yonemori K., Sugiura A., Laboratory guide for identification Subhadrabandhu S. 1997. Phylo- of plant pathogenic bacteria. St. Paul genetic relationships of the common Minnesota. APS. durian (D. zibethinus Murr.) to other Shamsudin M., Redzuan A., Abidin Z., edible fruited Durio spp. by RFLP Zaharah T. 2000. Penggunaan durian analysis of an amplified region of hutan, Durio lowianus sebagai cpDNA. J. HORT. SCI. BIOTECH. pokok penanti. In: Mohamed Z.A., 73(3): 317-321. Othman M.S., Sapii A.T., Mahmood Kilic-Ekici O., Yuen G.Y. 2003. Induced Z. and Idris S. (eds.), Prosiding resistance as a mechanism of Seminar Durian 2000: Kearah biological control by Lysobacter Menstabilkan Pengeluaran Kualiti enzymogenes strain C3. PHYTOPA- dan Pasaran, 1-3 Ogos 2000. Ipoh, THOLOGY 93: 1103-1110. Perak, Malaysia, pp. 26-36. Konam J.K., Guest D.I. 2002. Leaf litter Tan K.S.R., O’Gara E., Guest D., mulch reduces the survival of Phyto- Vawdrey L. 2008. Effect of fertilizer phthora palmivora under cocoa trees on susceptibility of durian and in Papua New Guinea. AUST. papaya to Phytophthora PLANT PATHOL. 31(4): 381-383. palmivora. ACTA HORT. 575. Lee B.S., Lum K.Y. 2004. Phytophthora http://www.actahort.org/. Accessed diseases in Malaysia. In: Drenth A., on 9 June 2008. dan Guest D.I. (eds), Diversity and Tsao P.H., Oster J.J. 1981. Relation of Management of Phytophthora in ammonia and nitrous acid to Southeast Asia. ACIAR Monograph suppression of Phytophthora on 114, 238 p. soils amended with nitrogenous Linderman R.G. 2003. Biological control substances. PHYTOPATHOLOGY options for Phytophthora species. 71: 53-59. http://www.apsnet.org/. Accessed on Turner J., Menge J. 1994. Root health- 9 June 2008. mulching to control root disease in Liu B., Gumpertz M.L., Shuijin Hu, avocado and citrus. Calif. Avocado. Ristaino J.B. 2007. Effect of prior Soc. Circ. No. CAS.94/2. tillage and soil fertility amendments Zappala G., Zappala A., Diczbalis Y. on dispersal of Phytophthora capsici 2002. Durian Germplasm Evaluation 76 J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77
…organic fertilizers on susceptibility…to Phytophthora… for Tropical Australia. Phase 1. A changes of lignification-related report for Rural Industries Research enzymes in pepper response to and Development Corporation. Glomus intraradices and/or Phyto- RIRDC Publication, pp. 98. phthora capsici. J. ZHEJIANG Zheng H., Cui C., Zhang Y., Wang D., UNIVER. SCI. 6 (8): 778-786. Jing Y., Kim K.Y. 2005. Active WPŁYW NAWOŻENIA ORGANICZNEGO NA ĆSIEWEK DURIANA NA CHOROBY WRAŻLIWOŚ POWODOWANE PRZEZ Phytophthora Muryati , Liza Octriana, Deni Emilda, Panca Jarot Santoso i Diah Sunarwati ST RE S Z C ZE NI E Celem badań był o określenie wpływu róż nego organicznego nawoż enia na wrażliwośćsiewek duriana na Phytophthora palmivora. Kompost z roś lin, nawóz kurzy i ł uski ryż u, zastosowane osobno lub w ich mieszankach, istotnie podwyższał y zdrowotnoś ćsiewek duriana. Tak więc te nawozy organiczne powinny byćwzię te pod uwagęjako czynniki integrowanej ochrony siewek duriana przed Phytophthora. Sł owa kluczowe: Phytophthora palmivora, durian, nawozy organiczne, ochrona J. Fruit Ornam. Plant Res. vol. 17(1) 2009: 67-77 77
You can also read