Direct lending in Asia Pacific - A study on Asian middle market private credit opportunities - Acuris
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Direct lending in Asia Pacific A study on Asian middle market private credit opportunities 1
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Contents Foreword. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 04 Key findings . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 05 emand grows for direct. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D 06 lending in Asia sia's mid-market. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 A opportunity Key geographies and sectors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14 ielding value in Asian. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17 Y private credit Methodology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Foreword A sia’s corporate lending ecosystem is undergoing a transformation. This traditionally bank-dominated market, characterized by vanilla structures and conservative pricing, is shifting materially towards direct lending and private debt alternatives, mirroring trends in North America and Europe. The post-crisis regulation of the financial system and the focus banks have placed on return on assets (ROA) since has driven a shift away from the SME and mid-markets towards larger corporates, where in addition to lending, banks are able to service other customer requirements such as cash management, corporate finance and FX. These multiple revenue streams mean large corporate clients deliver a superior ROA for banks. Now, direct lenders are stepping in to fill the void, providing mid-market corporate borrowers and financial sponsors with a broad suite of alternative funding options and structures. These have ranged from trade finance, supply chain finance, general working capital and peer-to-peer loan options to Term Loan B and various subordinated debt offerings. Yet, even with an influx of interest and capital, there is still huge scope for direct lending in Asia to grow as borrowers become more familiar with the debt products now available to them. Likewise, international institutions will continue to increase allocations to Asian private debt managers to gain exposure to a less competitive and higher yielding market. To get a snapshot of the current market and gauge sentiments on recent trends, mid-market business executives across Asia and local and international lenders were interviewed to reveal the trends, challenges and opportunities shaping Asia’s direct lending space. Their opinions reveal the importance of private debt to corporate growth among mid-market firms and point to an increasing need and uptake of this financing source in the years ahead. 4
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Key findings Asia's mid-market is expanding, and 55% of these firms say their 68% of mid-market firms say 82% say they will seek business has been loans/financing from financing from growing over the non-traditional non-bank lenders past 3 years lenders in the year is critical ahead for their businesses 55% say they prefer debt Expansion of working capital (35%) and refinancing debt (32%) Mid-market businesses are willing to be flexible in terms of funding costs as opposed to equity are the top two reasons (45%), pay higher interest to fuel business that mid- rates (52%) and provide growth market firms collateral (90%) are seeking to access funding alternate funding 100% of credit fund managers And within Asia Pacific, 82% say China has the most direct lending 90% of credit funds say say Asia Pacific has opportunities, followed diversified funding some of the greatest by India and Indonesia is critical for opportunities (71% each) success worldwide in private lending in Asia 5
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Demand grows for direct lending in Asia While most mid-market firms in Asia have access to traditional sources of financing, non-bank lenders are becoming increasingly critical to these businesses. Recent trends show growing awareness and acceptance of direct lenders as non-bank financing allows mid- market businesses to reach new levels of growth. 6
Direct lending mid-market Asia study M any factors have coalesced counterparts in Europe and North to drive the growth of direct America. Asian banks have stepped Fig. 1 lending in an Asian market back in the face of new regulations Is it critical for you to receive loans/ that has historically been dominated like Basel III, which imposes tougher financing from lenders outside of by the banks. While it still lags the rules for bank capital adequacy traditional financing institutions (banks)? more mature markets in North America requirements, and expanding and Europe, Asia is following the trend portfolios of non-performing loans of western markets where regulation (NPLs). Asian banks held NPL stock 32% No and a focus on return on assets has of US$640 billion at the end of H1 facilitated a transition from bank-led to 2019, a 23% increase on the previous direct lender-led debt provision. year, according to a Deloitte report. In addition, the demand on compliance Direct lenders now account for at and AML processes have increased least half of the European leveraged finance market and around 90% of the cost of servicing mid-market borrowers and their counterparties. 68% Yes the US market. The beginnings of a Facing these pressures, banks have 0% – Unaware of non-bank lenders as similar shift are now well underway been reluctant to take on risk and lend a source for financing in Asia too, as the region's banks to mid-market companies. pivot towards larger corporate clients, where this demand for multiple Respondents to the survey also services that banks can provide. cited a potential global economic slowdown, sparked by escalating Turning to non-traditional trade tensions between the US and financing China. Concerns that the current While most mid-market firms in Asia credit cycle may be peaking was have continued to access traditional another reason for diversifying their sources of finance, non-bank and sources of funding. direct lenders have established themselves as an essential source of The IMF forecasts that the US-China finance during the last decade. More trade war will reduce global GDP than two-thirds (68%) of respondents growth in 2019 by as much as 0.8%, say loans and financing from lenders with China's GDP output exposed to outside of traditional financing a 2% decline in GDP under the current institutions and banks have become tariff scenario. critical to their businesses, reflecting growing awareness and acceptance Asia's banks, which have already of direct lenders across the borrower seen profits squeezed as super- universe (Figure 1). charged Asian economic growth has moderated, will find it difficult to "Earlier, credit from "Earlier, credit from non-bank lenders avoid the side-effects of this ongoing non-bank lenders was only was only entertained as an option, volatility in global trade. According entertained as an option, but but with passing time, direct lenders to McKinsey, Asia-Pacific's share of with passing time, direct are considered as mainstream global banking pre-tax profits has sources. Their capacity to provide been declining since the financial lenders are considered as larger sums has also increased," crisis, from around a 50% share in mainstream sources. Their one survey respondent said. 2009 to a 37% share in 2018. capacity to provide larger sums has also increased." Now, there is every opportunity for Management teams have recognized the direct lending community to this and are broadening their portfolio Respondent follow a similar growth path to their of lenders in response. 7
Direct lending mid-market Asia study As one respondent says, "In case from lenders outside the traditional have used non-bank financing there is any problem with bank financing units. Their procedures vary in the past year (Figure 2). Most lending or there are any unforeseen from those that are conducted by respondents (82%) also plan to use delays, we need to be sure that banks, which are definitely stricter," these channels in the years ahead, funding at proper intervals is one respondent says. with 70% saying these alternative maintained to all departments in the financing options will be even more organization." Another survey respondent said: important during the next three years "When you compare the two sources and 75% saying the same for the Direct lenders have also impressed of funding (banks and direct lenders), next five-year horizon (Figure 3). with fast, flexible credit approval their lending policies and approval processes when compared to more procedures are different. Non-bank Indeed, such is the strategic bureaucratic and compliance-driven lenders have new and improved importance of non-bank credit banking institutions. Direct lenders personalized services to offer." lines that they are willing to make have burnished their credentials concessions on pricing to access the further by demonstrating their ability Short-term outlook and the value faster decision-making and flexible to deliver larger checks. of direct lenders terms that bank lenders do not Given these dynamics, and the offer. More than half of respondents "Over a period of time and the changes pressures that banks are facing, (52%) said they would pay higher in the banking system, it has become it comes as no surprise that the interest rates for access to additional critical that we receive financing majority of respondents (88%) non-bank financing (Figure 4). Global trends shaping private credit The growing popularity of private look for diversification and yield in a In this fast-growing but less mature credit in Asia has tracked similar low-interest rate environment. Direct market, there is less competition lending dynamics around the world, lending has been well-positioned for deals. Private debt managers where all banks have retrenched to to tick these boxes, with Preqin in the region also tend to focus repair balance sheets following the reporting that, on a five-year horizon, predominantly on special situations global financial crisis. private debt managers have posted and distressed opportunities, or an average net IRR of 13.5%. blend direct lending and mezzanine This has opened up opportunities strategies, which increases investor for new lenders to enter and disrupt Private debt is a broad church and return expectations. the market, sparking significant includes higher returning mezzanine, growth in private lending. Annual special situations and distressed debt The faster growth of Asian global private debt fundraising strategies (where return expectations economies relative to more mature has more than quadrupled during can push into the mid-to-high teens) markets (according to the IMF, the last decade, rising from US$25 in addition to direct lending (where Asia-Pacific GDP is growing at 4.8% billion in 2009 to US$110 billion in return expectations are in the mid- annually vs 1.5% in Europe and 2.1% 2018, with a peak of US$129 billion single digits, around 5-7%). The in North America) and the demand in 2017. The Alternative Credit inclusion of these strategies does for credit this creates, is another Council says that by the end of push up overall returns for the private reason for greater investor attention. 2020 private debt assets could total debt as an asset class. as much as US$1 trillion. Asia’s private debt market, which is Borrower demand for new sources not as developed as US and European of finance has come at the same markets, has gained increasing time as institutional investors investor attention in recent years. 8
Direct lending mid-market Asia study This is based predominantly on Fig. 2 Past 12 months the expectation that direct lenders Have you in the past have faster credit committee sign- 12 months received off processes, but also reflects the financing from non-bank financing sources? In the 88% 12% flexible, bespoke approach to loan structuring that direct lenders bring next 12 months, will you Next 12 months to the table. seek such financing? Banks, for example, are typically 82% 15% straight-jacketed into providing amortizing senior secured loan Yes No Unsure tranches at fixed prices. These cookie- 3% cutter structures are not always suitable, especially for growing mid-market companies that could Fig. 3 Next 10 years benefit from more flexible terms. Non- How important would bank lenders, in contrast, can lay on non-bank financing 45% 25% 30% everything from conventional senior be for you in the next Next 5 years debt and mezzanine to a plethora of 3-, 5- and 10-year customized structures that include horizon? 57% 18% 25% equity kickers, bullet repayments, Next 3 years PIK paper and other subordinated 42% 20% 27% 12% capital with a view to meeting each company’s specific needs. Very important Moderately important Neutral Not important Unsure “For faster access to additional financing, we would be ready to opt for higher interest rates rather than Fig. 4 stall operations. Our willingness to Willingness to pay higher interest rates; provide collateral, insurance and guarantees; pay higher interest rates will also rely and be flexible in terms of funding costs and structure if alternate sources of funding on the kinds of services provided by are available. non-bank lenders. There should be some additional benefits in terms of Would you be willing to pay more (higher interest rates) for new access to additional the repayment schedules and fewer non-bank financing? allowances for delays,” a survey respondent said. 52% 42% 7% Would you be able to provide collateral, insurance, guarantees for non-bank financing? 90% 10% Would you be flexible in terms of funding cost and structure if alternate sources of funding are available? 45% 27% 27% Yes No Unsure 9
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Asia's mid-market opportunity Growth has been and will continue to be on the agenda of Asia-based mid-market firms, as indicated by high levels of respondents pointing to business expansion over the past three years. These businesses will use debt financing to fuel this growth going forward, creating opportunities for creditors. 10
Direct lending mid-market Asia study D espite escalating trade tensions over the last two Fig. 5 years, Asian companies Will you be relying more on debt or equity will continue to place growth at to fuel growth within your organization in the center of their strategies as the year ahead? (Please select one) 45% Equity they position themselves to expand in-line with the region’s swelling middle-class consumer base. According to the OECD, China and India alone will account for up to 55% Debt two-thirds of the world’s middle class population by 2030, with this demographic climbing by 500% in Fig. 6 the two decades to the end of 2030 Has your business been shrinking, versus flat or declining growth in stable or growing over the past 3 years? Europe and the US. 55% Growing As Asia’s middle class grows, the opportunity for business to service 23% Stable a wealthier population is already emerging. And it is Asia’s fast- 22% Shrinking growing middle market companies that will be the engines of this wealth creation. As respondents point out, debt "Earlier, we did contemplate A study commissioned by the allows owners to maintain control equity financing and increasing Asian Development Bank Institute of their businesses as they grow, (ADBI) estimates that SMEs an important factor as many mid- the efforts in this direction. account for more than 96% of market firms may be family-owned But we soon realized that Asian businesses and provide two or closely-held, and therefore it would be better from the out of three jobs in the region. reluctant to dilute control and business perspective to rely on An EY survey of executives within decision-making to a third-party debt financing, as we can set these mid-market companies equity investor. According to one shows that these businesses are of these executives, “Our company more measurable goals for the particularly optimistic about future is fairly new, so our primary future." growth prospects, with many intentions would be maintaining expecting double-digit growth and complete control of our business. Respondent confident about economic prospects. Debt financing will thus be used to fuel growth in the organization.” Demand for debt Debt financing will be a Securing debt is also generally cornerstone for supporting this perceived to be simpler and quicker growth going forward, and a than negotiating a deal with an deeper, more diverse debt market equity partner. Expanding on will create opportunities for both this, another respondent says, lenders and creditors. Indeed, “Earlier, we did contemplate more than half of the respondents equity financing and increasing say they prefer debt (55%) as a the efforts in this direction. But financing tool as opposed to equity we soon realized that it would (45%) to fuel growth (Figure 5). be better from the business 11
Direct lending mid-market Asia study perspective to rely on debt financing, as we can set more Fig. 7 measurable goals for the future.” How much of your business is expected to be within each of the following regions? Asia Pacific Growth agenda: Going global Despite the risk to growth posed by the US-China trade war, the survey shows a clear 7% 12% 81% ambition within the Asian mid- Global emerging markets market to expand internationally. Commenting on this and echoing the sentiments of others, one respondent says, “The stage at 46% 46% 8% which the business is in now Western developed requires additional financial input for accelerating growth and maintaining decision-making 55% 36% 9% control at the same time.” Less than 25% 26-50% 51-75% More than 75% 12
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Some 55% of respondents say their businesses have been Fig. 8 growing over the past three years How capital intensive is your business? with a further 23% saying business Very capital intensive had at least been stable (Figure 6). The survey findings show 57% that while much of this growth Moderately capital intensive had come from a foundation in 30% domestic and regional Asian Neutral markets, there was a recognition 13% and ambition to pursue growth Not very capital intensive beyond home borders. 0% For companies that have outgrown Unsure their home markets, looking for 0% business abroad is the next step in their growth trajectory, with Europe and North America the most attractive markets to expand Fig. 9 into. Although most respondents Which of the following best describes why you are seeking funding? (Select one) (81%) still see Asia Pacific Expansion working capital remaining their primary market, 55% want to expand into the 35% developed markets of the West Refinance debt and 46% see opportunity in other 32% emerging markets (Figure 7). Project financing needs Financing needs 25% The confidence among respondents in their growth prospects and the Capex funding ambition to pursue geographic 8% expansion is influencing the strategic rationale for seeking finance. While more than half of respondents categorized their businesses as “very capital financing needs, with a quarter intensive” (57%), funding for capex citing project financing as the main was selected as the main reason reason (Figure 9). Low interest for seeking finance by less than a rates across the region have also tenth (8%) of those polled (Figure encouraged borrowers to refinance 8). For most respondents, their existing loans at more favorable use of financing proceeds was pricing, with just under a third focused on investment in resources (32%) citing refinancing as their to support expansion and cover primary financing requirement. operational costs and working Refinancing is also being done capital requirements. to reprofile debt to match appropriate funding to assets and More than a third (35%) of activities – which was previously respondents said expansion and bootstrapped from various private working capital best defined their sources or self-financed. 13
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Key geographies and sectors Asia Pacific stands out among global markets, as local and offshore creditors point to the regionfor its opportunities in the direct lending space. Both emerging market and advanced economies hold creditor interests. 14
Direct lending mid-market Asia study A s private debt has expanded and won increasing Fig. 10 market share from banks Which geographical markets do you see the greatest dislocations and opportunities? worldwide, Asia Pacific has offered (Select all that apply) domestic and international direct Asia Pacific lenders an attractive mix of growth and market inefficiencies. Although 100% the US and European markets may North America be much larger and more mature, neither can match the economic 55% growth and attractive competitive South America dynamic of the burgeoning direct lending scene in Asia. 35% Europe Asia Pacific is identified as having the greatest dislocations and 15% opportunities according to 100% of survey respondents. North America is the next closest market, although Fig. 11 some way behind at 55%, followed Which countries specifically? by South America (35%) and Europe China (15%) (Figure 10). 82% Indeed, Asia offers lenders a broad India mix of jurisdictions to back, ranging 71% from faster-growing emerging Indonesia markets in China, Indonesia and India to steadier, more advanced 71% jurisdictions such as Australia, Australia Singapore, Japan, Hong Kong 53% and South Korea. The majority Hong Kong of respondents identified Asia’s emerging economies as most 53% attractive, although more than Singapore half picked out mature markets 47% like Australia and Hong Kong as South Korea offering the best opportunities 41% (Figure 11). Additionally, Thailand respondents seem to be focused on the region’s larger economies, 35% leaving mid-market businesses in Vietnam smaller markets neglected – which 35% creates ample opportunities for Japan lenders to tap those markets. 18% In emerging Asia, rapid economic Malaysia growth, which is still outpacing 18% western markets despite recent Philippines slowdowns and trade war concerns, 6% has been the key attraction for 15
Direct lending mid-market Asia study lenders. Economic expansion and a growing middle class has supported Fig. 12 an average growth rate of just Where should Asia risk be priced relative under 9% across emerging Asian to Europe and North America? economies over the last decade, 40% Equally according to the IMF. Direct lenders have also found the market to be less intermediated and competitive. Equally, a growing number of mid-market companies 60% Higher than that are seeking third-party finance to support expansion overseas are emerging. In more developed markets in the region, meanwhile, English and US-style laws and governance Sectors a third of invested global venture provide inbound lenders with It comes as no surprise that lenders capital, up from a miniscule 4% as frameworks they are familiar with, operating across Asia expect to see little as five years ago. According and provide a less risky way to gain the most opportunities in sectors to Nikkei, meanwhile, Asia is now exposure to the Asian growth story. focused on production (90%) and home to half of the world’s fastest- trading (60%). Industries within these growing companies, with more than Pricing and risk verticals have sat at the heart of the 1,679 Asian companies growing their Asian markets also provide private region’s growth over the last two market capitalizations more than ten- investors with additional scope to decades, with Asia running a current fold over the last decade. diversify their portfolios beyond account surplus with the rest of the Western markets and gain exposure world of just under 2%, according While private equity and venture to a higher credit pricing dynamic. to the IMF. capital has been heavily involved There are few pure play direct in financing on the equity side lending managers in Asia, with the Yet, while direct lenders will be eager during the start-up phases for these majority of managers either running to participate in these core sectors companies, a lack in working capital special situations, distressed debt within the Asian economy, they will and expansion capital at present is or mezzanine strategies, or blending also be excited by the opportunities creating further demand for funding. these strategies within the credit that Asian companies are creating Indeed, the growth for tech and space to offer a higher return profile. in “new economy” sectors. The services will create additional need growing global aspirations of Asian for flexible and more sophisticated Many respondents (60%) companies mentioned above coincide and bespoke financing, which direct acknowledged that risk should be with a shift in economies across the lenders are ideally positioned to priced higher in Asia than in the more region. Export-driven industries like provide in a way that regulatory- stable and predictable European and manufactured goods remain the constrained banks are unable to. North America markets (Figure 12). bedrock of Asia’s biggest economies, The remaining participants (40%) said but the entire region is expanding that risk should be priced in line with rapidly into the fast-growing services, the levels seen in the west, but not a consumer and technology sectors too. single respondent said pricing should be lower than in developed markets. Bain & Company research shows that China, for example, is now “Asia should be priced higher where producing Unicorn companies (start- risks are concerned. Markets here are ups valued at US$1 billion or more) a bit more vulnerable to the changes at a faster rate than the US, while in global atmosphere,” one survey Chinese internet and technology participant said. firms are now receiving just under 16
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Yielding value in Asian private credit Regional and international credit funds highlight best practices to follow to succeed and achieve scale in the Asia private credit lending space. L enders and borrowers Full utilization of the flexibility that acknowledge that there are direct lending fund structures can lessons to be learned from how accommodate is seen as crucial if the large direct lenders in mature non-bank lenders are to continue markets have grown their franchises taking market share away from and supported their portfolios. These banks, who can still price debt best practices, along with a tailored competitively despite the regulatory approach to target markets in Asia, requirements they are obliged to can help creditors take full advantage meet. Most survey participants said of the favorable fundamentals and this diversified funding was the top growing opportunities to provide factor critical for success, with 75% direct lending in Asia. also identifying collateral servicing 17
Direct lending mid-market Asia study "Relationship managers have become an important part of Fig. 13 dealing with clients and aiming What do you think is critical for success in the private credit lending space? (Select all that apply) to offer the best service in Diversified Funding the market. Clients' needs are better understood and faster 90% processing of loans can be Collateral Servicing ensured in this manner." 75% Origination Respondent 55% Loan servicing as important, to demonstrate the 45% competence and credibility of direct lenders in the market (Figure 13). “Factors such as collateral servicing Fig. 14 and diversified funding are also Do you have dedicated origination/relationship managers in your team? Do you have an equally important in showcasing in-house loan servicing team (that tracks underlying activities on the use of proceeds)? the vision and capabilities of the In-house loan servicing team private credit lending space,” a survey respondent said. Credit teams: Boots on the ground Respondents also recognize 65% 30% 5% the importance of investing in dedicated local teams for the future Dedicated origination/relationship managers growth of non-bank lending. Most credit funds said they utilized in-house loan servicing teams (65%) and dedicated origination and relationship managers (95%) 95% 5% to source deal flow and provide additional value add to clients and borrowers (Figure 14). Yes No Unsure “Relationship managers have become an important part of dealing with clients and aiming to offer the best service in the market. Clients’ needs are better understood and faster processing of loans can be ensured in this manner. The investment in-house servicing teams to monitor use of finance has also been equally important,” one survey respondent said. 18
Direct lending mid-market Asia study Methodology In November 2019, a market on the state of and current trends Within the graphed survey results, participant in the direct lending shaping direct lending in Asia. percentages may not sum to space commissioned Acuris 100% due to rounding or when Studios and Debtwire to canvass For credit fund respondents, respondents were allowed to the opinions of 60 mid-market all survey participants were choose more than one answer. firms in Asia Pacific and 20 private dedicated Asia-based private debt credit lenders with operations in managers and have dedicated the region to gauge their opinions private debt funds. (Mid-market firm) Where is your APAC HQ located? (Mid-market firm) What was your company's most recent annual revenue (US$m)? 47% 23% 17% 13% 49% 18% 30% Singapore Hong Kong Australia Rest of Asia 3% (please specify) 100 - 300 300 - 500 500 - 1B 1B to 3B (Mid-market firm) Which of the following best describes your (Lenders) Are you a dedicated Asia-based private debt business operations? Please select one. manager, and where are your HQ based in Asia? 22% 41% 13% 12% 12% 60% 30% Manufacturing Production Trading Singapore Hong Kong Australia China 5% Distribution Services 5% (Lenders) Do you specialize in a strategy? (Lenders) What is your total AUM (in US$)? 25% 30% 40% 10% 25% 65% 5% Special Situation Distressed Direct Lending Less than 300MM 300 - 500MM 500 - 1BN Mezzanine/ Leveraged Loans A combination More than 1BN 19
www.acuris.com 1501 Broadway, 10 Queen Street Place 16/F Grand Millennium Plaza 8th Floor New York, London 181 Queen's Road Central NY 10036 EC4R 1BE Hong Kong USA United Kingdom t: +1 212 686 5606 t: +44 20 7059 6100 t: +852 2158 9769 Disclaimer This publication contains general information and is not intended to be comprehensive nor to provide financial, investment, le- gal, tax or other professional advice or services. This publication is not a substitute for such professional advice or services, and it should not be acted on or relied upon or used as a basis for any investment or other decision or action that may affect you or your business. Before taking any such decision, you should consult a suitably qualified professional adviser. Whilst reasonable effort has been made to ensure the accuracy of the information contained in this publication, this cannot be guaranteed and neither Mergermarket nor any of its subsidiaries or any affiliate thereof or other related entity shall have any liability to any per- son or entity which relies on the information contained in this publication, including incidental or consequential damages arising from errors or omissions. Any such reliance is solely at the user’s risk.
You can also read