Country Profile: Indonesia - COUNTRY PROFILE

 
CONTINUE READING
Country Profile: Indonesia - COUNTRY PROFILE
COUNTRY PROFILE

Country Profile: Indonesia
                                                                             every district; the High Courts of Appeal, for every
                  Editor’s Note: This is the 16th in a series of articles summariz-
                  ing various countries’ government and SH&E legislative process-
                                                                             province; and the Supreme Court as the highest level of
                  es. It is intended to serve as a useful planning tool for SH&E
                                                                             the court hierarchy in Jakarta and for the country as a
                  professionals preparing to conduct business in profiled country.
                                                                             whole. In 2003, a constitutional court was established
                  Previous profiles have included Argentina, Australia, Brazil, Chile,
                                                                             with power to review, among other things, the constitu-
                  China, Germany, India, Ireland, Italy, Japan, Kuwait, Mexico,
                                                                             tionality of laws.
                  Singapore, Spain and the U.K. All country profiles are provided
                  courtesy of AECOM and are available on ASSE’s International   MPR is the only authority that may change the 1945
                  Practice Specialty (IPS) website. Direct requests for additional
                                                                             constitution. MPR amended the 1945 constitution in
                  country information to Halley Moriyama at halley.moriyama
                  @aecom.com; +1-978-589-3233 or to Jack Fearing, CPEA, at   October 1999, August 2000, November 2001 and August
                  +1-703-462-7294; jack.fearing@dyn-intl.com.                2002.
                                                                                Since the first amendment of the 1945 constitution,

                  O
                         n April 9, 2009 and July 8, 2009, Indonesia         the government has not had monopoly power on the ini-
                         successfully organized the second direct leg- tiation of bills for discussion and approval in the parlia-
                         islative and presidential elections. Dr. H.         ment. Both parliament and government can initiate bills.
                         Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono was reelected as After the bill is agreed to by the government and parlia-
                         president for a second term of office until         ment, it is submitted to the president for legalization for
           2014 with Dr. Boediono as his vice president.                     promulgation. According to Law No. 10 of 2004
                                   Furthermore, 34 new ministers have Regarding Establishment of Laws and Regulations, the
    The Pancasila, or been appointed and named as the                        types and hierarchy of legislation are as follows:
                                   Indonesia Unite Cabinet II to assist
 five principles pro- the president in establishing a peace- •1945                      constitution;
                                                                                •law/statute/act/government regulation as a replace-
 vides a framework ful,                prosperous, secure and demo-
                                   cratic nation with good corporate
                                                                             ment of law;
                                                                                •government regulation (to implement the law);
 for the Indonesian governance as its main principal. The •presidential regulation;
    Constitution and Pancasila,                or five principles (belief in
                                   the one and only God, just and civi-
                                                                                •regional regulation (Peraturan Daerah or Perda).
                                                                                Although it is not stipulated in the hierarchy of legis-
directs political life. lized humanity, unity of Indonesia, lation, in governance practice, ministers or the heads of
                                   democracy guided by consensus aris- executive departments can also issue regulations or
           ing from deliberations amongst representatives and                guidelines to implement laws, government regulations
           social justice for all people of Indonesia), provides a           and presidential decrees. These are:
           framework for the Indonesian Constitution and directs                •ministerial decrees;
           political life. Indonesia is a republic based on the 1945            •ministerial instructions;
           Constitution, as amended, or the Constitution of the                 •circular letters (which do not have the weight of a
           Proclamation.                                                     regulation).
               The central government is located in Jakarta on the              In addition to Perda, which must be approved by both
           island of Java. The central government of the Republic            local parliament and local government, local technical
           of Indonesia cooperates with other government institu-            regulations may also be proposed by the provincial gov-
           tions to arrange for state affairs, including the People’s        ernor or regent (Bupati)/mayor (Walikota) to implement
           Consultative Assembly (Majelis Permusyawaratan                    Perda as follows:
           Rakyat or MPR) and the House of Representatives                      •governor/regent/mayor decisions;
           (Dewan Perwakilan Rakyat or DPR). The MPR meets at                   •governor/regent/mayor instructions; and
           least once every five years to inaugurate the president              •circular letters (which do not have the weight of a
           and vice president. The president is advised by a                 regulation).
           Presidential Advisory Council (Dewan Pertimbangan                    These many sources of legislation result in regula-
           Presiden) and chooses the ministers who will assist               tions, licenses, permits, fees, inspectors and other
           him/her.                                                          bureaucratic requirements. Jurisdictions may overlap,
               MPR comprises DPR and the Regional Represen-                  resulting in duplicative efforts.
           tative Council (Dewan Perwakilan Daerah or DPD); the                 Indonesia is subdivided into 33 provinces, including
           president and DPR form the country’s legislative power. three special autonomy regions (Aceh, Papua and Papua
           Independent from the executive and legislative branches, Barat), one special capital city (DKI Jakarta) and one
           the Supreme Court serves as the country’s judiciary               special region (Daerah Istimewa, Jogyakarta), each of
           power. Indonesia’s judiciary is comprised of the District which is led by a governor in cooperation with a regional
           Courts (also known as the Courts of First Instance) for           house of representatives. The sidebar, p. 7, provides a list

                                                                    4
                                                          World Focus www.asse.org
of Indonesian provinces, special autonomy regions, the
special region and the special capital region. Each of
these areas is sub-divided into regencies, headed by a
regent in cooperation with a local house of representa-
tives. Currently, a total of 397 regencies (Kabupaten) and
98 (Kotamadya) municipalities exist throughout
Indonesia. Each municipality (Kotamadya) is comprised
of several local administrative units/districts (Kecamatan)
that coordinate the approximately 76,546 subdistricts
(Kelurahan) and villages (Desa).

                   SH&E AUTHORITIES
   Presidential Regulation No. 7 of 2005 Regarding the
National Medium Range Development Plan of 2004-
2009, dated Jan. 19, 2005, identifies the issues in the
environmental sector that are the basis for establishing
the national environment development plan. Current            adopted by sectoral (technical) agencies to implement
environmental issues in Indonesia include a decrease in       pollution control. Sectoral departments, such as the
Indonesian forests, damage to coastal areas and the sea       Ministry of Industry and the Ministry of Manpower and
ecosystem, increases in air and water pollution and a         Transmigration, are responsible for environmental man-
lack of enforcement of environmental laws.                    agement within their technical jurisdictions, while local
   Given the environmental issues in Indonesia, the           governments are mandated by government regulations to
objective of the national environmental development           manage environmental concerns within their regional
plan is to improve natural resources and environmental        jurisdiction as part of an integrated national environmen-
management systems to establish a reasonable equilibri-       tal management program.
um between natural resource utilization as economic               The national environmental impact management
growth capital and environmental protection as a life         agency, Badan Pengendalian Dampak Lingkungan
support system. All activities conducted in Indonesia         (BAPEDAL), established in 1990 by Presidential Decree
should confirm to the three sustainable development           No. 23 of 1990 Regarding BAPEDAL, was dissolved at
principles, namely: (i) economic profitability; (ii) social   the Central Government level in 2002. BAPEDAL’s
acceptance and (iii) environmental friendliness. The          tasks and functions were merged into MOE. BAPEDAL
environmental development plan seeks to prioritize the        offices continue to exist at the provincial, regency and
sustainable principles in all development sectors,            municipality levels. Based on Presidential Regulation
increase environmental management coordination at             No. 9 of 2005, MOE is currently responsible and
national and regional levels, increase environmental law      empowered to formulate national policy, coordinate the
development and consistent enforcement and increase           implementation of this policy and control environmental
environmental impact management efforts related to            impacts.
development activities.                                           Other SH&E institutions include the following:
   Based on Presidential Regulation No. 9 of 2005                 •National Development Planning Board (Badan
Regarding Position, Task, Function, Composition and           Perencanaan Pembangunan Nasional): assessment of the
Work of the State Minister of the Republic of Indonesia       development plans of central and provincial government
(as amended by Presidential Regulation No. 62 of 2005         agencies.
Regarding the Amendment to Presidential Regulation                •Ministry of Industry (Departeman Perindustrian):
No. 9 of 2005; Presidential Regulation No. 90 of 2006         nuisance control, pollution from industries, among other
Regarding the Second Amendment to Presidential                issues.
Regulation No. 9 of 2005; Presidential Regulation No.             •Ministry of Health (Departeman Kesehatan): drink-
94 of 2006 Regarding the Third Amendment to                   ing water quality, sanitation and pesticide use.
Presidential Regulation No. 9 of 2005; and Presidential           •Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources
Regulation No. 20 of 2008 Regarding the Fourth                (Departemen Energi dan Sumber Daya Mineral): issuing
Amendment to Presidential Regulation No. 9 of 2005),          permits, monitoring mining activities and enforcing rele-
the minister for the environment (MOE) acts as a coordi-      vant regulations.
nating and policy formulating body and is responsible             •Ministry of Agriculture (Departemen Pertanian):
for preparing drafts of environmental legislation to be       renewable resources, fisheries and the use of fertilizers.
adopted by the executive branch.                                  •Ministry of Law and Human Rights (Departemen
   The MOE also issues the guidelines to determine            Hukum dan Hak Asasi Manusia): environmental legisla-
ambient air quality and effluent quality standards for        tion and codification.
industry, as well as other technical guidance, which are          •Ministry of Home Affairs (Departemen Dalam

                                                                 5
                                                       World Focus www.asse.org
Negeri): local government supervision, establishment of        Law revoked Law No. 23 of 1997 Regarding Environ-
provincial and local environmental agencies.                   mental Management. Law No. 23 of 1997 was perceived
    •Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration                   to be ineffective in reducing environmental pollution and
(Departemen Tenaga Kerja dan Transmigrasi): working            damage, which have been increasing. The New
environment, occupational health.                              Environmental Law sets out provisions for obtaining
    •Ministry of Forestry (Departemen Kehutanan):              environmental permits for businesses and/or activities
forestry.                                                      that are obligated to implement environmental impact
    •Ministry of Maritime and Fisheries (Departemen            assessments (Analisis Mengenai Dampak Lingkungan or
Kelautan dan Perikanan): coral reefs safety.                   AMDAL) and/or environmental management efforts
    •Nuclear Energy Supervisory Agency (Badan                  (Upaya Pengelolaan Lingkungan or UPL) and environ-
Pengawas Tenaga Nuklir): use and supervision of                mental monitoring efforts (Upaya Pemantauan
nuclear energy.                                                Lingkungan or UKL).
    In addition, interministerial and interagency teams have      Such environmental permits are issued by MOE, gov-
been formed to address diverse aspects of the environment.     ernor or regent/mayor pursuant to each of their respec-
    A private entity, State Enterprise for Oil and Gas         tive jurisdictions. In addition, an environmental permit is
Mining or PERTAMINA, was previously entrusted with             a prerequisite to obtain a business license for the busi-
the exploration and exploitation of oil and natural gas.       ness and/or activity; therefore, if an environmental per-
With the promulgation of Government Regulation No.             mit is revoked, then the business license is also revoked.
31 of 2003 regarding the change of status of PERTAMI-          Under the New Environmental Law, AMDAL is required
NA to become a state-owned limited-liability company,          for a business and/or activity that has a significant
PERTAMINA no longer has authority to issue regula-             impact on the environment.
tions. The Regulatory Body for Downstream Oil and Gas             Pursuant to Law No. 32 of 2004 Regarding Regional
(Badan Pengatur Hilir Migas or BPH Migas) and Imple-           Autonomy as last amended by Law No. 12 of 2008
mentation Body for Upstream Oil and Gas (Badan                 Regarding the Second Amendment to Law No. 32 of
Pelaksana Hulu Migas or BP Migas) have been estab-             2004, each province functions as a responsible and real
lished to provide and monitor upstream and downstream          autonomous region and administrative territory. There-
activity in the field of oil and gas. BPH Migas was estab-     fore, the provincial and local environmental impact
lished on Dec. 30, 2002, and BP Migas was established          management agencies (Badan Pengendalian Dampak
on Jul. 16, 2002.                                              Lingkungan Daerah or BAPEDALDA) are expected to
    Law No. 22 of 2001 Regarding Oil and Gas also              take up more of the enforcement tasks in their specific
includes some provisions regarding environmental,              areas, such as adherence to the monitoring requirements
health and safety matters by stipulating:                      of industrial operating licenses, and responding to public
    •Policies on oil and gas operations shall be based on,     reports of environmental damage.
among others, environmental aspects and preservation of
the living environment, the national potential and devel-                ENFORCEMENT OF SH&E REGULATIONS
opment policies.                                                   In practice, the multiple sources of environmental leg-
    •Companies engaged in oil and gas business operations      islation have frequently resulted in duplicative and con-
(legal entities and permanent establishments) shall ensure     flicting requirements, which make enforcement difficult.
occupational safety and health, management of the living       The provincial and local BAPEDAL agencies were
environment and compliance with the prevailing law and         expected to take the lead on enforcement within their
regulations in oil and gas business operations;                individual jurisdictions. However, the reality has been
    •Management of the living environment shall be in          that the regional authorities lack the clear mandate,
the form of an obligation to prevent and overcome pollu-       financial support and skills to sufficiently carry out this
tion and restore damages to the living environment,            function.
including the obligation to carry out post-exploration and         The formation of BAPEDAL in 1990 as part of the
production operations by way of rehabilitation of sites.       central government improved the enforcement of envi-
    •The responsibility for controlling work and executing     ronmental provisions in several ways. Unlike the sectoral
oil and gas business operations (including the manage-         departments (e.g., the Ministry of Industry) which have
ment of the living environment) in compliance with the         environmental issues as only one of many concerns,
prevailing law and regulations shall be the authority of       BAPEDAL was charged specifically with managing
the department whose duties and authorities include oil        environmental impact analysis and environmental impact
and gas business operations and with other relevant            management and with providing technical assistance.
departments.                                                       Also, unlike the State Ministry of the Environmental
    The major development in the environment sector            Affairs, which was meant to function as a policy-forming
is the passing of Law No. 32 of 2009 Regarding the             and coordinating body and the provincial governments,
Environmental Protection and Management, Oct. 3, 2009          who were meant to function only as coordinating bodies,
(New Environmental Law). The New Environmental                 BAPEDAL was specifically created to implement and

                                             6
                                   World Focus www.asse.org
fine of $1,620,000 if it causes death or severe
                                                                           injury). Negligent actions may be punishable
        INDONESIAN ADMINISTRATIVE DIVISIONS                                by a maximum of 3 years imprisonment
                                                                           and/or a fine to a maximum of $324,000 or a
      Provinces                           Sulawesi Barat
                                                                           maximum imprisonment of 9 years and a
      Bali                                Sulawesi Selatan
                                                                           maximum fine of $972,000 if the negligent
      Bengkulu                            Sulawesi Tengah
                                                                           action causes death or severe injury.
      Banten                              Sulawesi Tenggara
                                                                               Intentionally acting against the prevailing
      Gorontalo                           Sulawesi Utara
                                                                           laws (e.g., by dumping hazardous or toxic sub-
      Jambi                               Sumatera Barat
                                                                           stances, energy and/or other components into
      Jawa Barat                          Sumatera Selatan
                                          Sumatera Utara                   the ground, air or surface water, importing,
      Jawa Tengah                                                          exporting, trading, containing, storing or doing
      Jawa Timur                                                           any related dangerous activities while under-
      Kalimantan Barat                 Special Autonomy
                                       Regions                             standing that those acts may cause environ-
      Kalimantan Selatan                                                   mental pollution and/or damage or endanger
      Kalimantan Tengah                Nanggroe Aceh Darussalam
                                       Papua                               human health) may be punishable by up to a
      Kalimantan Timur                                                     maximum of 15 years imprisonment and a
      Kepulauan Bangka Belitung Papua Barat                                maximum fine of $1,620,000. Furthermore, the
      Kepulauan Riau                                                       law introduces new criminal and fine penalties
      Lampung                          Special Region
                                       DI Yogyakarta                       related to genetically engineered products.
      Maluku                                                               Under Article 101 of the New Environmental
      Maluku Utara                                                         Law, any person releasing and/or circulating
      Nusa Tenggara Barat              Special Capital City
                                       DKI Jakarta                         genetically engineered products to environ-
      Nusa Tenggara Timur                                                  mental media in contravention of regulations
      Riau                                                                 or an environmental license (as referred to in
                                                                           Article 69 of the New Environmental Law) is
develop measures to prevent and mitigate environmental                     subject to a maximum 3 years imprisonment
pollution and destruction. However, with the abolishment     and  a fine of  up to $324,000.
of BAPEDAL in January 2002, environmental activists             Article  5  of  Law No. 1 of 1970 Regarding Work Safety
question the effectiveness of the Minister of Environ-       delegates  the  control  of legislation related to work safety to
ment in carrying out the enforcement tasks, although         the Department      of Manpower     and Transmigration. The
almost all BAPEDAL mandates have been integrated             Minister  of Manpower      and   Transmigration   appoints safety
into MOE.                                                    inspectors  as  technical  officers  of the Department   of
   The New Environmental Law names the judiciary as          Manpower     and   Transmigration.    In addition, the Minister  of
the guardian and supervisor for the proper execution of      Manpower and Transmigration appoints qualified people
the law. The New Environmental Law also provides the         from outside the Department of Manpower and Trans-
basis for civil, criminal and strict environmental liability migration to supervise health and safety compliance. These
under Indonesian law. Articles 53 and 54 of the New          appointees are called safety experts. Despite the existence
Environmental Law set forth the obligations for every        of these enforcement officers and Indonesia’s fairly well-
person polluting and/or damaging the environment to          developed body of safety and health legislation, it appears
conduct remediation and to recover the environmental         that the enforcement of occupational safety and health is
functions. Furthermore, Article 87 of the New Environ-       not a governmental priority, at present.
mental Law stipulates that each person who damages or
pollutes the living environment is liable for payment                            ENFORCEMENT PRACTICES
of compensation or restitution to victims. The New              The   New    Environmental     Law specifically allows an
Environmental Law also provides administrative sanc-         individual  or   a group  of  legal standing to sue for envi-
tions against an entity to prevent and stop any violation    ronmental   damages.     In  1989,  the  Indonesian Forum for
and to take action to repair the damage.                     the Environment       (WALHI),    as  a representative  of the
   Strict liability in activities using hazardous and toxic  public  interest,  was  granted   standing  to  sue five national
materials with significant impact on the environment is      government     agencies   and   the pulp  and  paper  industry  in
established by Article 88, with strict liability resting     the Jakarta  District   Court   for environmental    pollution,
upon those who cause the damage and/or pollution.            damages and noncompliance with environmental laws.
Criminal liabilities are addressed in Articles 98 to 115.    Although the court rejected the substantive issues of the
Intentional acts of damage to or pollution of the environ- suit, the case has set a strong precedent for similar legal
ment may be punishable by a maximum of 10 years              suits against polluters and has raised public awareness of
imprisonment and/or a maximum fine of $1,080,000 (or legal protections against environmental pollution.
a maximum of 15 years imprisonment and a maximum                Another case occurred in 2001, when the Counsel of

                                                                    7
                                                          World Focus www.asse.org
Judges at the South Jakarta District Court ruled against     license requirements. Similarly, the inspection officers of
           PT Freeport Indonesia (PTFI), based on WALHI’s law-          Department of Industry are also assigned to tasks other
           suit, and decided in its verdict that PTFI was guilty of     than environmental compliance.
           disseminating misleading information regarding an acci-         Because Indonesia lacks a defined enforcement sys-
           dent involving toxic overflows at their Wanagon Lake         tem, police are usually involved in enforcement actions.
           mining location in Irian Jaya. This incident allegedly       Thus far, cases of environmental enforcement actions are
           claimed four lives on May 4, 2000.                           rare, however, attention to environmental quality and
               In 2007, a lawsuit was filed by WALHI, which was         enforcement has increased. The New Environmental
           represented by the Advocacy Team for Humanitarian            Law provides the legal basis for the establishment of
           Victims of the Sidoarjo Mudflow (TAKLUSI), against           dedicated environmental inspectors at the national,
           PT Lapindo Brantas Incorporated, Kalila Energy               provincial and local levels of government.
           Limited, Pan Asia Enterprise, PT Medco Energi, Tbk,             In the area of occupational health and safety, enforce-
           Santos Australia Ltd, and Government of the Republic of      ment is somewhat greater, as a result of the institutional-
           Indonesia (the president, Minister for Energy and            ization of health and safety inspectors. The law has
                                Mineral, Executive Agency for           assigned special inspectors or civil enforcement officers
  Specific laws and Upstream               Oil and Gas Activity,
                                Minister of Environment), the
                                                                        called Labor Inspection Officers (Pegawai Pengawas
                                                                        Ketenagakerjaan) of the Directorate of Industrial Relation
regulations related Governor of East Java Province and                  Management and Manpower Supervision (Pembinaan
                                the Regent of Sidoarjo Regency. The     Hubungan Industrial dan Pengawasan Ketenagakerjaan) of
   to contaminated suit, filed in the South Jakarta District            the Department of Manpower and Transmigration in
  land do not exist Court, alleged liability for environ-               Jakarta. At the provincial level, the officer from the provin-
                                mental destruction, including damag-    cial office of the Department of Manpower and Trans-
       in Indonesia. ing the ecological function in the                 migration performs the inspection, and at the district level,
                                region affected by the mudflow since    district officers perform inspections.
           the mudflow was of such magnitude that it altered the           For all of Indonesia, approximately 2,100 inspectors at
           landscape and also allegedly damaged river flow and          the district and provincial levels oversee 200,000 regulated
           local ecosystem functions.                                   companies. According to the Department of Manpower
               On March 28, 2007, WALHI filed another lawsuit           and Transmigration, the number of inspectors is insuffi-
           against PT Newmont Minahasa and the Government of            cient to effectively oversee the regulated community. If an
           the Republic of Indonesia (the Minister for Mineral          inspector notes a violation, the district office will issue a
           Resources of the Republic of Indonesia) for damaging         warning letter; if the violation is not corrected, the case
           the environment at Buyat Bay. WALHI filed a legal-           may be prosecuted, although, to date, prosecution has
           standing suit following the report of the Buyat Pante vil-   rarely occurred.
           lage residents about environmental damage and
           community unrest in August 2004.                                                INFORMATION ACCESS
               PT Newmont Minahasa was operating without a per-             A variety of provisions in Indonesian environmental
           mit from MOE for waste disposal into the sea and for         law allow for public access to information. Article 62 of
           processing of waste (Bahan Beracun Berbahaya). The           the New Environmental Law stipulates that the national
           disposal of tailings caused damage to the marine ecosys-     and regional governments must develop an environmen-
           tem, including turbidity in the eutrophic zone, a decline    tal information system to support the implementation
           in the quantity and quality of coral reefs in Buyat Bay,     and development of policies on environmental protection
           bioaccumulation of sediments in marine biota in the          and management. This environmental information sys-
           eutrophic zone, a decline in phytoplankton and zoo-          tem must be formulated in an integrated and coordinated
           plankton levels due to a high arsenic content in sedi-       manner and be published for the public.
           ments in Buyat Bay and more than 100 fish deaths                 Law No. 26 of 2007 Regarding Spatial Planning
           recorded either around the tailings disposal pipe in Buyat   states that proper spatial planning is based on openness,
           Bay or washed ashore. The Buyat Bay Case also alleges        unity, justice and legal protection. Provisions in this law
           a decline in the health of Buyat Bay residents and infec-    recognize the public’s right to information about and par-
           tion by a range of diseases due to consumption of drink-     ticipation in spatial planning, as well as the government’s
           ing water and fish contaminated by heavy metals              responsibility to disseminate information regarding
           (arsenic and manganese).                                     plans. Government Regulation No. 27 of 1999 Re-
               Although Indonesia has environmental inspectors,         garding Environmental Impact Analysis EIA and Head
           they are not highly trained and specialized. For example,    of BAPEDAL Decree No. 8 of 2000 Concerning Public
           although MOE (since taking over BAPEDAL tasks) has           Access to Information and Participation in the EIA
           regulatory involvement in controlling hazardous waste        Process have provisions for access to information and
           management, the agency does not have enough inspec-          community involvement.
           tors with sufficient training to control compliance with         Government Regulation No. 27 of 1999 established

                                                         8
                                               World Focus www.asse.org
that public involvement entails an obligation of govern-         damaging the environment to conduct mitigation and
ment agencies to inform the public of planned activities,        restoration. Article 87 of this Law provides that every
public access to EIA documents and possible involve-             party in charge of a business and/or activity committing
ment of the public and interest groups in the process of         a violation in the form of environmental pollution and/or
drafting and evaluating EIAs and in managing and moni-           destruction which inflicts a loss to another party or the
toring environmental factors. These rights are even more         environment is obligated to pay compensation and/or to
strongly established in an older law, the Nuisance Ordi-         take certain actions. Further, Article 88 requires that any
nance of 1926. The Nuisance Ordinance of 1926 obli-              person whose action, business and/or activity includes
gates the municipal or district authorities to inform the        the use of hazardous and toxic materials, manages haz-
owners, people living or otherwise using premises in             ardous and toxic (B3) waste and/or
neighborhoods surrounding any proposed development.              poses a serious threat to the environ- For all of
In addition, pursuant to Article 5 of the Nuisance               ment will be held strictly liable for
Ordinance of 1926, the responsible authority must make           the resulting loss without any            Indonesia, approxi-
all application letters and enclosures at their office avail-    requirement to prove fault.               mately 2,100
able to any person who is interested.
    Although some indirect references are found in the                    CLEANUP STANDARDS                 inspectors at the
New Environmental Law regarding access to facility                  To date, no laws or regulations
records, no specific regulations exist regarding public          specifically set forth cleanup stan-       district and provin-
access to these facility records. In practice, it would be       dards. However, Article 54(2) of the cial levels oversee
difficult for the public to obtain free access to a facility’s   New Environmental Law sets forth
records. The enactment of the Transparencies of Public           the phases to restore environmental        200,000 regulated
                                                                 functions by way of 1) discontinua-
Information Law is expected to help in accessing envi-
ronmental information.                                           tion of the source of pollution and
                                                                                                            companies.
                                                                 cleaning of pollutants, 2) remedia-
                    CONTAMINATED LAND                            tion, 3) rehabilitation, 4) restoration and 5) other meas-
                 Applicable Regulations                          ures in accordance with scientific and technological
    Specific laws and regulations related to contaminated        developments. The implementing regulations of the New
land do not exist in Indonesia. Related legislation              Environmental Law will provide further provisions
includes Government Regulation No. 82 of 2001                    regarding cleanup standards.
Regarding Water Quality Management and Water
Pollution Control and Government Regulation No. 18 of                         PROPERTY TRANSFER LEGISLATION
1999, as amended by Government Regulation No. 85 of                  For persons or companies engaged in the purchase or
1999 Regarding Hazardous and Toxic Material Waste                sale of a business or property, no statutory or policy
Management. Government Regulation No. 82 of 2001                 requirement exists to undertake pretransaction environ-
includes the obligation of the central government and the        mental investigations. Such investigations are not common
regional government (provincial, regency and/or city)            but by contract are often required in transactions involving
pursuant to its respective jurisdictions, to eradicate water     foreign parties. There is also no legislation or policy that
contamination and improve the recovery of water quality.         requires sellers of businesses or property to provide the
    Administrative sanctions may be imposed by the               potential buyer with any document or statement concern-
MOE/regent/mayor on the manager of the business                  ing the environmental condition of the property.
and/or activity causing the pollution or who is in viola-            By law, sellers are obliged to guarantee that no hidden
tion of the requirements as set forth under Government           defects exist on the property and all risks are passed on
Regulation No. 82 of 2001. Government Regulation No.             to the buyer upon the transfer of title to the property. As
18 of 1999 includes provisions that obligate the produc-         such, it is not unusual for the parties involved in a prop-
er, collector, user, transporter, storer and processor of        erty or business transaction to seek, by way of contract
waste to remediate the contaminated area or environmen-          negotiations, warranties and indemnities and to receive
tal damage caused as a result of their activity (Article         environmental disclosures in respect of the same.
60). If the responsible party is unable to perform the                            REPORTING OBLIGATIONS
remedial activity, or if what they have done is improper,           Under Article 70 of the New Environmental Law,
BAPEDALDA or MOE may perform the remediation or                  public participation related to environmental protection
oversee a third-party contractor at the cost of the respon-      and management may take the form of social monitor-
sible party (the violator).                                      ing, opinions/recommendations/ complaints and con-
                                                                 veyance of information and/or reporting.
                       LIABILITY FOR
              PREEXISTING CONTAMINATION                          ACCIDENTAL SPILLS & RELEASES
   Articles 53 and 54 of the New Environmental Law set   Under Government Regulation No. 18 of 1999, as
forth the obligations for any person polluting and/or  amended by Government Regulation No. 85 of 1999 on
                                                                    9
                                                          World Focus www.asse.org
the Management of Waste of Hazardous and Toxic                        Jakarta 13410
            Materials, Government Regulation No. 41 of 1999 on                    [62- 21] 858 0102, 859 04926
            the Control of Air Pollution and Government Regulation                Fax: [62- 21] 851 7184, 859 04926
            No. 82 of 2001 on the Management of Water Quality                     Department of Industry
            and Water Pollution Control, accidents that either pollute            Ir. Muhammad S. Hidayat (Minister)
            or may pollute the environment must be reported to the                Jl. Jend. Gatot Subroto Kav. 52-53
            competent agency (the Regional National Environmental                 Jakarta Selatan 12950
            Impact Management Agency or BAPEDALDA) in the                         [62-21] 525 2194, 527 1380, 5271387-88
            region and/or to the governor or the agency appointed by              Fax: [62- 21] 526 1086
            the governor of the region, the nearest village head/head
            of subdistrict, district head and local police officers.              Department of Trade
               In the event of an accidental spill or release of haz-             Dr. Marrie Elka Pangestu (Minister)
            ardous or toxic materials, the responsible party must                 Jl. M.I. Ridwan rais No. 5 Jakarta Pusat 10110
            immediately take actions to contain the spillage or release,          [62-21] 3841961
            restore the damaged environment and notify the nearest                National Development Planning Board
            local governmental agency, either orally or in writing. The           (BAPPENAS)
            local governmental agency must forward the report to the              Prof. Dr. Armida S. Alisjahbana
            competent authorities within at least three working days              Jl. Taman Suropati No. 2
            after receipt of the notification. Notification of accidental         Jakarta 10310
                                   spills or releases of other materials          [62-21] 390 5650
  No reporting obli- should be done as soon as possible.                          The Department of Health (DEPKES)
                                   However, the regulations have not              Dr. Endang Rahayu Sedyaningsih (Minister)
     gation exists for established quantitative thresholds                        Jl. H.R. Rasuna Said Blok X-5
soil or groundwater below which there are no require-                             Kav. No. 4-9, Blok A, 2nd Floor, Kuningan
                                   ments to notify the authorities.               [62-21] 520 1587, 520 1591, 520 1590
       contamination Any concerned person or party is                             Fax: [62-21] 520 1591
    identified during also              entitled to report to the compe-
                                   tent authority any damage or potential
                                                                                  The Department of Manpower and
                                                                                  Transmigration (DEPNAKERTRANS)
      the course of a damage to the environment due to any                        Dr. H.A. Muhaimin Iskandar, Msi (Minister)
                                   activity, accidental spill or and release
  sampling program of hazardous and/or toxic or other                             Jl. Jenderal Gatot Subroto Kav. 51
                                                                                  Jakarta Selatan
that is independent materials.                                                    [62-21] 525 5683, 525 5688
                                                                                  Fax: [62-21] 525 6559
     of an accident or                         CONTAMINATION IDENTIFIED
                                                    DURING SAMPLING               The Department of Energy and Mineral Resources
         spill incident.                     Generally, no reporting obligation   Dr. Darwin Zahedi Saleh (Minister)
                                          exists for soil or groundwater con-     Jl. Medan Merdeka Selatan No. 18
                   tamination identified during the course of a sampling          Jakarta Pusat
                   program that is independent of an accident or spill inci-      [62-21] 381 3232, 384 6596
                   dent. The governor of the region or the agency appointed       Fax: [62-21] 384 7461
                   by the governor is responsible for the supervision and                      REGULATORY INFORMATION
                   monitoring of business activities within his/her region.       Pusat Informasi Lingkungan Hidup
                       For this purpose, the responsible officials may enter      (Center for Environmental Information)
                   the premises and take soil or water samples for analysis.      Jl. Tumenggung Wiradireja No. 216 RT. 03/06
                   If the sample indicates that the water quality is below the    Cimahpar, Bogor 16155
                   required standard or the soil is contaminated, the respon-
                                                                                  National Information and Telecommunication
                   sible person must immediately take the necessary actions
                                                                                  Body (Badan Informasi dan Telekomunikasi
                   to rectify the situation. The same procedure applies
                                                                                  Nasional-BIKN)
                   when sampling is undertaken in response to a reported
                                                                                  Jl. Merdeka Barat 9
                   accident. 
                                                                                  Jakarta Pusat 10110
                                      LIST OF KEY CENTRAL                         [62-21] 385 9625, 384 1972, ext. 131
                             GOVERNMENT AGENCIES & CONTACTS                       Fax: [62-21] 344 0051
                      Office of the State Minister for Environmental              adjudikasi@bikn.every1.net
                      Affairs (LH)                                                Center for Occupational Health Research
                      Prof. Gusti Muhammad Hatta (Minister)                       (HIPERKES)—Dept. of Manpower
                      Jl. D.I. Pandjaitan Gedung B, 2nd Fl., Kav.24               Jl. Jend. A.Yani 69-70
                                                                10
                                                      World Focus www.asse.org
Jakarta Pusat                                        Law Faculty University of Indonesia
[62-21] 424 0284                                     Gedung F, Lantai 1
Balai HIPERKRES and Work Safety, Bandung             Depok, Indonesia
Jl. Golf No. 34,                                     [62-21] 788 81487
Ujung Berung, Bandung 40294                          Email: pri@makara.cso.ui.ac.id
Tel. & Fax: [022] 780 0995                           Gedung Unit Pelayanan Teknis (UPT)
Balai HIPERKRES and Work Safety, Surabaya            University of Indonesia
Jl. Dukuh Mananggal No. 122                          University of Indonesia Campus, Depok
Surabaya 60234
                                                                      OTHER CONTACTS
[031] 828 0440
                                                     Embassy of Indonesia
Fax: [031] 829 4277
                                                     2020 Massachusetts Ave. NW
Balai HIPERKRES and Work Safety, Medan               Washington, DC 20036
Jl. Medan Belawan KM. 11, 5 No. 64                    (202) 775-5200
Medan 20244                                          Fax: (202) 775-5365
[061] 685 0262
                                                     U.S. Department of State
Fax: [061] 685 7322                                  Overseas Travel Advisories
Balai HIPERKRES and Work Safety, Samarinda           (202) 6475225
Jl. Santosa No. 9                                    Indonesia Desk
Samarinda 75117                                      (202) 647-1221
[054] 732941
                                                     Visa Information
Balai HIPERKRES and Work Safety, Makassar            (202) 663-1225
Jl. Ujung Pandang Baru No. 59
Makassar 90214                                       U.S. Department of Commerce
Tel. & Fax: [0411] 452 390                           Desk Officer for Indonesia & ASEAN
                                                     Market Access and Compliance
Indonesian Center for Environmental Law (ICEL)       U.S. Department of Commerce
Jl. Dempo II No. 21, Kebayoran Baru                  Room 2325
Jakarta 12120                                        14th and Constitution Ave. NW
[62-21] 726 2740, 723 3390                           Washington, DC 20230
Indonesian Society of Environmental Professionals    (202) 482-3894
(IPLHI)                                              American Indonesian Chamber of Commerce
Secretariat                                          317 Madison Ave., Ste. 520
Jl. Bekasi Timur Raya No. 146, Cipinang              New York, NY 10017
Jakarta 13410                                        (212) 6874505
[62-21] 819 8010                                     Fax: (212) 6875844
Fax: [62-21] 850 5050
                                                     The Embassy of the United States
iplhi@cbn.net.id
                                                     Merdeka Selatan 4-5, Box 1
Jl. Martimbang II/B                                  Jakarta 10110, Indonesia (APO AP 96520)
Kebayoran Baru                                       Tel: [62-21] 3435-9000
Jakarta Selatan 12120                                Fax: [62-21] 3435-9922
[62-21] 726 2654                                     Telex: 44218 AMEMB JKT
PDH (Pusat Dokumentasi Hukum, Center                 American Chamber of Commerce in Indonesia
for Law Documentation)                               World Trade Center, 11th Fl.
Law Faculty University of Indonesia                  Jl. Jendral Sudirman, Kav. 29-31
Jl. Cirebon No. 5                                    Jakarta 12084, Indonesia
Jakarta Pusat                                        [62-21] 5262860
Tel: [62-21] 335 432                                 Fax: [62-21] 5712861
Fax: [62-21] 315 7334                                Telex: 62822 LMARK IA

                                                        11
                                              World Focus www.asse.org
You can also read