Collaborative Low Energy Vision for the European Region (CLEVER): a pathway to bridge the climate neutrality, energy security and sustainability ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Collaborative Low Energy Vision for the European Region (CLEVER): a pathway to bridge the climate neutrality, energy security and sustainability gaps through energy sufficiency, efficiency, and renewables Project presentation
The négaWatt association
* A think tank on energy created in 2001
* A non-profit, independent group of experts and field-
practitioners
* A core of ~ 25 “companions” + 25 “ambassadors”,
1400 members
* 15 employees
* Producing scenarios (latest in 2021) and proposing
policies and measures for a sustainable energy future,
through a systemic approach
* Subsidiary created in 2009
* Operational branch of the association
The CLEVER nW team
Policy and dissemination
Research on policies and
measures, support on diss
Technical dialogue on energy
Network and external sector
management (dissemination,
policies, funding) Modelling tools
Technical dialogue on residential
and tertiary sectors
Operational Trajectories for not covered countries
management and commenting partners
Technical dialogue on industry
and transports
Methodological expertise,
strategic orientation
Reinforcement and harmonisation
of trajectories
1.
Sufficiency as a CLEVER
core value
Impact of ever increasing energy
services consumption in the EU
EU cars trends 1990-2015*: increase of CO2 emissions for cars despite efficiency improvements
Evolution
Index
(100 1990
level)
*https://www.eea.europa.eu/data-and-maps/figures/fuel-efficiency-and-fuel-consumption
CLEVER’s answer to this trend:
a transition including sufficiency
Sufficiency’s aims:
Ceiling
Foundation
Adjusting the nature and amount of
Fulfilling everyone's need for
services to keep demand at a level
services (e.g. accessing a
which does not endanger the carrying
building in the image)
capacity of the earth
Sufficiency embedded in an equity and
sustainable framework
Bringing individual services
between:
➢A foundation: of decent
live levels
➢A ceiling: containing the
collective impact below
planetary limits
➔Moderate global
consumption while
reinforcing solidarity and
redistribution
The “doughnut
economy” concept
(Raworth et al.)
Sufficiency at the start of the systemic
CLEVER energy transition approach
Delivery of final energy
Choice and preparation Design and
to the end-user
of the primary resource Conversion dimensioning
Transformation into into useful energy Conditions
the suitable carrier of use
Primary Energy
Energy Service
Losses
Losses
Losses Losses
Losses
Substitution Efficiency Sufficiency
1.
The CLEVER scenario
objectives
CLEVER: towards a sufficiency-based European vision
Based on the French experience, and considering the status of European energy and
climate scenarios and policies, felt need of raising awareness about the key potential of
sufficiency at the European level.
Primary energy consumption in the négaWatt scenario 2022-2050 for France
Sufficiency
Efficiency (prod)
Efficiency (cons)
Increased
Renewables efficiency and
sufficiency
Nuclear
Fossil gas
Oil 100%
Coal renewable
energy supply
Zero carbon Environmental benefits So-economics benefits
Reaching carbon Raw materials, pollution… Jobs, social, justice…
neutralityThe CLEVER approach based on the SER framework
Systemic
approach
Local
resources
Objective: to get sufficiency and deep sustainability higher up on the European
agenda
Means: a scenario matching climate necessity (1,5degrees compatible pathway)
with the description of necessary and feasible transformations2. CLEVER network and methodology
The large and diverse CLEVER network
A network of 22 organisations from 20 European countries (18 EU members +UK, CH)
AT TU Wien
BE negaWatt Belgium, ICEDD
BG Za Zemiata; Sofena
CH negaWatt Switzerland
CZ Charles University Environment
Centre
DE EnSu (Wuppertal Institut; EU Univ. of
Flensburg)
DK INFORSE Europe
ES Ecoserveis Association
FR negaWatt Association
EL National Observatory of Athens
(NOA)
HU Environmental Planning and
Active Education Network (EPEN)
IT EURAC Research; Politecnico di
partner
Milano
LT Lithuanian Energy Institute (LEI)
Commenting LU Consortium Cell/List
partner LV Green Liberty - Zala Briviba
NL Michiel den Haan
PL WiseEuropa
Observing PT ZERO
partner RO Energy Policy Group (EPG)
SE Air Clim Coalition
UK CREDS, Center for Alternative
Technologies (CAT)The CLEVER bottom-up construct
A three-stage bottom-up integration approach:
Set to progressively harmonise and reinforce national trajectories to form a coherent European vision
Improvement
European Vision
Integrating into a
European scenario
Stage 3
Comparing,
harmonizing and
Country 1 Country 2 Country 3 . . . Country n aggregating
Stage 2
Raising the level of
ambition and
comprehensiveness
... Country n Stage 1
Country 1 Country 3
Starting with diverse
Country 2
national scenarios
Integration3. First results and planning
The CLEVER methodology to harmonise national
assumptions
Corridors of convergence for energy services on key sufficiency indicators
Industrial stories to set
corridors of production,
energy consumption
and intensity by branch
Average distance per person excl. Air and soft
Average residential floor area per person (m2/cap)
mobility (p.km/cap)
Corridor of projections based on the first set of national
Corridor of projections in the first set of national
trajectories
trajectoriesEU legislative timeline
Jul 2022 Oct 2022 Jan 2023 Apr 2023 Jul 2023 Oct 2023 Jan 2024 Apr 2024 Jul 2024
1st FF55 laws (ETS, ESR,
CO2/Cars)
2nd FF55 laws (EED, RED)
EPBD and mobility package
Circular economy package 1 and 2
Legislations on trucks
EU
elections
EU Climate Law rev: 2040 target
NDC revision?
NECPs update
20CLEVER planning towards publication in 2023
November December
July 2022 September 2022 Spring 2023
2022 2022
Technical
CLEVER webinar Final and
First
presenting political
dissemination deliverables first presentation
results
Trajectory finalisation
CLEVER
construction
Stronger policy focus towards advocacy
➢ -50% energy consumption in 2050 (/ 2015) already reached by V0
➢ Energy sufficiency as key to bridging the gap between climate necessity and a
feasible, democratic and deeply sustainable pace of transformation
➢ 2 major focus: strong implementation of the 2030 framework (FF55), and (2035 and)
2040 target levelsFocus on trajectories finalisation
June 2022 July 2022 September 2022 November 2022 December 2022 2023
Bilateral and Review of Technical Last modif.
multilateral w. Finalise energy tab Last modif. webinar carriers in
Active carriers in transp., presenting transp.,
FEC tabs towards imports/exports …
partners first results imports/export
EU traj. V2 s…
Bilateral w. Feedback 2nd round of
Commenting analysis, exchanges and
partners adjustments finalisation
negaWatt Materials module : calculating batteries’ material
footprint
22Focus on policies planning
July 2022 September 2022 November 2022 December 2022 Spring 2023
Technical
Final and
CLEVER First webinar
political
dissemination publications presenting
presentation
first results
Prioritised and
First policies Prioritised
trajectory- and EU
Policy content to support the policies by
context-aligned
assumptions sector
policies
- Sectoral policies and
Policy Alignment of policies with EU context and trajectory
national best practices
research Drafting of final policies
- Meetings in Brussels
23Focus on dissemination and communication
Sept 2022 Oct 2022 Nov 2022 Dec 2022 Jan 2023 Feb 2022 Mar 2022 Apr 2022 May 2022
CID + Official CID +
Website Website creation
External
Regular posting and emailing on publications and events
comm
Major Technical and Pwpt
Final report, infographics and open data
Publications concept notes presentation
Technical
Major events Final event
webinar
EU Political
Consortium and bilateral meetings with key EU decision makers
diss
EU Technical Sectoral Webinars,
diss Conference participation
National workshops and
National diss
publicationsCLEVER contacts
We are happy to share, extend our network and develop new exchanges about
sufficiency-based, ambitious energy and climate scenarios and policies in Europe
Nicolas TAILLARD Stephane BOURGEOIS
CLEVER project European relations and
manager policies manager
nicolas.taillard[at]negawatt.org stephane.bourgeois[at]negawatt.org
+33 6 33 32 09 93
Contact[at]negawatt.org
https://negawatt.org/Scenario-europeenYou can also read
