Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine

Page created by Felix King
 
CONTINUE READING
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
Accelerating            The Budget Pass-Through 41 | RAF-USAF Integration 52 | PACAF's Top Range 44
Hypersonics

28

      Chosen for Chief
             A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8
                                                                                   April 2020         $8

  Published by the
Air Force Association
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
WHEN
                                                          INNOVATION
                                                              STRIKES,
                                                          THE MISSION
                                                            SUCCEEDS.

                JOINT STRIKE MISSILE
                Powered by 5th-generation technology, Joint Strike Missile
                (JSM) delivers proven performance and precision against
                today’s evolving threats. JSM’s stand-off range of up to 350
                miles keeps pilots out of harm’s way, accurately engaging
                adversaries and enabling the mission.

                RAYTHEON.COM/JSM

       © 2020 Raytheon Company. All rights reserved.

20RMS598_Raytheon_JSM_AFMag_041320.indd 1                                      2/26/20 3:16 PM
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
STAFF
                                                                                                                                                                                             Publisher
                                                                                                               April 2020. Vol. 103, No. 4                                                   Bruce A. Wright
                                                                                                                                                                                             Editor in Chief
                                                                                                                                                                                             Tobias Naegele

                                                                                                                                                                                             Managing Editor
                                                                                                                                                                                             Juliette Kelsey
                                                                                                                                                                                             Chagnon

                                                                                                                                              Photo: Senior Airman Mya Crosby
                                                                                                                                                                                             Editorial Director
                                                                                                                                                                                             John A. Tirpak
                                                                                                                                                                                             News Editor
                                                                                                                                                                                             Amy McCullough
                                                                                                                                                                                             Assistant
                                                                                                                         U.S. Air Force                                                      Managing Editor
DEPARTMENTS                    FEATURES
                                                                                                                         Master Sgt.                                                         Chequita Wood
  2 Editorial:                   8 Q&A: What’s on the Mind of Gen. C.Q. Brown                                            Ricardo Sepul-                                                      Senior Designer
    Competition and
    COVID-19                       An exclusive interview with the PACAF Commander                                       veda finishes a                                                     Dashton Parham
                                                                                                                         quality check on
    By Tobias Naegele              days before his nomination to be the next Air Force                                   a GBU-31 Joint
                                                                                                                                                                                             Pentagon Editor
  3 Index to                       Chief of Staff.                                                                       Direct Attack
                                                                                                                                                                                             Brian W. Everstine
    Advertisers                                                                                                          Munition during                                                     Digital Platforms
                               28 The Hypersonics Push                                                                   the third annual                                                    Editor
  3 Letters                                                                                                              Air Force Com-                                                      Jennifer-Leigh
                                 By John A. Tirpak
  5 Verbatim                                                                                                             bat Operations                                                      Oprihory
                                  Pentagon leaders provide a first look at plans for                                     Competition at                                                      Senior Editor
 10 Airframes                    testing and producing future hypersonic weapons.                                        Davis-Monthan                                                       Rachel S. Cohen
 16 Strategy & Policy:                                                                                                   Air Force Base,
                               32 The Tanker Gap                                                                         Ariz., Jan. 24.
                                                                                                                                                                                             Production
    Putin’s Five New                                                                                                                                                                         Manager
    Nukes                         By Brian W. Everstine
                                                                                                                                                                                             Eric Chang Lee
18 World: The                     USAF’s budget seeks to swap capacity now for                                                                                                               Photo Editor
   Munitions Push;                capability in the future, but TRANSCOM is leery.                                                                                                           Mike Tsukamoto
   Piloted Aircraft
   Future; AFRICOM;
                               36 Missile Testing in the GBSD Era
   and more ...                   By Rachel Cohen
                                                                                                                                                                                             Contributors
27 Faces of the Force             A new era in land-based nuclear weapons could usher                                                                                                        John T. Correll,
61 Airman for Life                in changes to the Air Force’s missile test regime.                                                                                                         Robert S. Dudney,
   Chapter News;                41 The Budget and the Truth                                                                                                                                  Jennifer Hlad, Air
   Pitsenbarger film;                                                                                                                                                                        Chief Marshall
   Field Contacts ...              By Amy McCullough                                                                                                                                         Mike Wigston
64 Namesakes: Hill                 Pass-through funds inflate USAF spending by almost
                                   25 percent, hiding the truth from friends and foes alike.
                                   Is this the year it finally ends?
                               44 Range Roving
                                  By Jennifer Hlad
                                  Japan’s Draughon Range is now among the most                                                                                                               ADVERTISING:
                                  sophisticated training areas in the world.                                                                                                                 Kirk Brown
                                                                                                                         ON THE COVER                                                        Director, Media
                               48 Survivors of the Storm                                                                                                                                     Solutions
                                  By Jennifer-Leigh Oprihory                                                                                                                                 703.247.5829
                                                                                                                                                                                             kbrown@afa.org
                                  In the face of repeated natural disasters, Puerto Rico’s
                                                                                                                                                   Photo: Airman 1st Class Caitlin Russell

                                 Air Guard proves resilient.                                                                                                                                 SUBSCRIBE
                                                                                                                                                                                             & SAVE
                               52 The Future of RAF-USAF Integration                                                                                                                         Subscribe to
                                  By Air Chief Marshal Mike Wigston                                                                                                                          Air Force Magazine
                                  Constant competition and confrontation with rivals                                                                                                         and save big off
                                  demand evermore cooperation among allies.                                                                                                                  the cover price,
                                                                                                                         Gen. Charles Q.                                                     plus get a free
                               56 The Difference in Korea                                                                Brown Jr. See                                                       membership
                                                                                                                         “Q&A: What’s on
                                  By John T. Correll                                                                     the Mind of Gen.                                                    to the Air Force
                                                                                                                         C.Q. Brown,” p. 8.                                                  Association.
                                   Without U.S. air power, United Nations forces would                                                                                                       1-800-727-3337
                                   have lost Korea in 1950.
Air Force Magazine (ISSN 0730-6784) April 2020 (Vol. 103, No. 4) is published monthly, except for two double issues in January/February and July/August, by the Air Force
Association, 1501 Lee Highway, Arlington, VA 22209-1198. Phone (703) 247-5800. Periodical postage paid at Arlington, Va., and additional mailing offices. Membership Rate:
$50 per year; $35 e-Membership; $125 for three-year membership. Subscription Rate: $50 per year; $29 per year additional for postage to foreign addresses (except Canada
and Mexico, which are $10 per year additional). Regular issues $8 each. USAF Almanac issue $18 each. Change of address requires four weeks’ notice. Please include mail-
ing label. POSTMASTER: Send changes of address to Air Force Association, 1501 Lee Highway, Arlington, VA 22209-1198. Publisher assumes no responsibility for unsolicited
material. Trademark registered by Air Force Association. Copyright 2020 by Air Force Association.

                                                                    APRIL 2020          AIRFORCEMAG.COM             1
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
EDITORIAL
                                                             By Tobias Naegele

                     Competition and COVID-19
T
        his is the era of great power competition, and the means         responses to the pandemic, each nation—indeed, each state—is
        of competition are growing increasingly clear and diverse.       likewise competing, showing its people and its neighbors how
           We are building a Space Force because competition and         leaders believe the crisis should be handled. Is our country getting
risk is growing in space. The Air Force sent a B-52 bomber to Africa     it right? Is there a better way ahead?
in February, not to drop bombs, but to demonstrate U.S. military             Competition for superiority applies to every aspect of every
power and strength and communicate American resolve and com-             system, including diplomacy, commerce, and emergency response.
mitment. The message was for allies and enemies in Africa—and                Meanwhile, the business of government goes on. Even as
for China, which is competing for those allies’ allegiance. So, it is    Congress and the administration shift their focus to the crisis
no accident when President Donald Trump calls the coronavirus            before them, the legislative sausage-making—that is, the budget
that cased the COVID-19 pandemic “the Chinese Virus.” This, too,         process—continues. Here, we can see a different kind of intense
is competition.                                                          competition, as the military services grapple for relevance and
    It works both ways.                                                  funding at the end of an era of plenty.
    The virus originated in China’s Hubei province, and was initially        Budgets will be flat at best for the foreseeable future. Indeed, in
called, even by the Chinese, the Wuhan virus, after the city where it    the aftermath of the pandemic-fueled financial crisis, that may be
began. Now, fearful of a potential international backlash and eager      overly optimistic. At the same time, each of the military services is
to leverage its wealth, China is offering aid in the form of masks,      busy reinventing itself with an eye toward being capable of wag-
medical advice, and other equipment to eager recipients around           ing war with China a decade from now. The Air Force is giving up
the globe. This is the kind of generous aid for which the U.S. has       near-term capacity in tanker, fighter, and close-air-support aircraft
long been known. Indeed, during many past crises,                                      to develop future capabilities, including hypersonic
the U.S. was the only nation large and rich enough to          This is the era missiles and a combat-cloud-like connectivity that will
provide significant emergency relief.                                                  enable everyone in the battlespace to exchange target-
    No more.
                                                              of great power ing, location, and other data in real time. If successful, it
    China’s global charm offensive is competition of            competition,           will revolutionize warfare by presenting enemies with
another sort. Like its claim that it never “engaged in        and the means an overwhelming, complex, and perpetually changing
any form of cyber theft” (see “Verbatim,” p. 5), China’s      of competition threat picture.
declarations in mid-March that it had registered no new                                   Similarly, each of the services is trying to invent a
confirmed cases of the coronavirus are what President are growing in- new future in which its branch of the military is central
Trump might call “fake news” and former Vice President creasingly clear to a future contest with China. The Army is imagining
Joe Biden would dub “malarkey.” When China amended              and diverse.           long-range artillery with a range of 1,000 miles or
that claim a few days later, saying the only new cases                                 more—taking aim at target sets traditionally left to the
it registered were individuals arriving in China from someplace          Air Force or Navy. The Navy is rethinking its aircraft carrier battle
else, China was competing. Its message: China had overcome the           groups for an age when maneuverable hypersonic weapons could
crisis, while Western nations were shutting down under pressure.         turn those 4.5 acres of floating, sovereign U.S. territory into big,
    Was China lying? Not necessarily. China may well have stopped        slow targets—or worse, vast, mass graves at the bottom of the sea.
testing its citizens at home; doing so is only useful in tracking the    The Marine Corps’ plan is to cut back battalions, helicopters, and
spread of the disease, and once it has spread, further testing is        jump-jets—and dispense with tanks—in favor of new, unmanned
essentially pointless. Without a cure, only symptoms can be treated,     aircraft and long-range cruise missile batteries it can deploy from
and treatments are the same whether one tests positive or not.           high-speed landing craft.
    Projecting to the world that China is the good Samaritan, acting         Logic must prevail. Not every service will be relevant to every
as a kindly neighbor to its brother nations, is not altruism. It is      fight. Investment must be prioritized to fund capabilities and strat-
competition. Unburdened by the ugly business of democracy and            egies that will best deliver the needed effects. America will never
debate, China was able to present omniscient competence to a             fight a land war in China; it could not possibly win. China’s strategy is
world undergoing unprecedented economic upheaval. This was               designed to threaten its neighbors and to keep the United States at
opportunism, not altruism.                                               a distance. Russia’s strategy is similar—it, too, intimidates neighbors
    Over the past few years, as Pentagon leaders embraced the            and is developing long-range strike capabilities intended to hold
concept of great power competition, many failed to grasp the full        U.S. military assets at risk. Both are likewise highly skilled in cyber
context of that message. Now, it should be clearer. This competition     warfare, recognizing those skills as critical to threatening Western
is not just a 21st century arms race. It’s a full-on rivalry, the likes  democracies and their powerful modern economies.
of which we have not seen since the Cold War. Then, the Space                More than any other, two U.S. military services are critical to
Race and the Olympics were tests of national competence, used            neutralizing such long-range threats and, if necessary, to defeating
to demonstrate the merits of competing systems. It was messy de-         them. Unique in all the world, the capabilities wrought by the U.S. Air
mocracy and capitalism versus centralized, single-party authority.       Force and U.S. Space Force are unmatched today. The imperative
It was long-haired American amateurs against grim-faced Russian          for the Pentagon and Congress is to ensure that fact remains true
professionals, each playing for national pride. In their different       in 2030 and beyond.                                                    J

                                                    2     APRIL 2020       AIRFORCEMAG.COM
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
LETTERS

Mission Impossible                                  of these leaders are alive today, Gen. Lance
   As a civilian, I read with great interest        Lord, who was at one time commander of                                             Air Force Association
Rachel Cohen’s article “Space Force is Here”        AFSC, is alive and well. I am sure he could                                        1501 Lee Highway • Arlington, VA 22209-1198
[January/February, p. 44] and the editorial         provide a wealth of hands-on, organizational,                                      afa.org
“Launching the Space Force” by Tobias Nae-          and operational perspective that might be
                                                                                                                                       Telephone: 703.247.5800
gele about the challenges facing the newest         helpful. I hope that General Raymond will
branch of the military, from its operations to      turn to the current space operators and                                            Toll-free: 800.727.3337
its public image.                                   earlier generations to work out the knotty                                         Fax: 703.247.5853
   As a science fiction fan, I was admittedly       details he is facing..
intrigued by speculation over what the future                              Col. Quentin M. Thomas,                                     AFA’s Mission
uniforms for the sixth military branch might                                            USAF (Ret.)                                    Our mission is to promote a dominant
entail. Suggestions included necktie-less                                          Woodstock, Ga.                                      United States Air Force and a strong
suits and naval-style sleeve lace to create                                                                                            national defense and to honor airmen and
a distinctive military culture for the infor-          Gene Roddenberry based “Star Trek” on                                           our Air Force heritage.
mation age.                                         Project Solar Warden—“The Secret Space
   My 2 cents is that a uniform along the lines     Program.” It is said that Roddenberry attend-                                      To accomplish this, we:
of the 1990s minimalist Merrill McPeak ser-         ed a meeting at the Pentagon just before                                           ■ Educate the public on the critical need
vice dress—but fly-fronted with a mandarin          receiving a call from Desilu Productions (Desi                                       for unmatched aerospace power and a
stand-up collar—would look sharp. A retro           Arnaz & Lucille Ball)—the truth is stranger                                          technically superior workforce to ensure
peaked bell-style cap and black pants could         than fiction. The reason for the similar logo                                        US national security.
complete the uniform.                               is because of Roddenberry’s vision (along
                                                                                                                                       ■ Advocate for aerospace power
   On one hand, such a streamlined ser-             with some real intel). Of course, the public
                                                                                                                                         and STEM education.
vice dress uniform would be akin to those           will not see things this way. The public has
seen in “Star Trek” and “The Expanse,” yet          no idea that the “new Space Force” is about                                        ■ Support the Total Air Force family and
it also would be descended from historic            40 years old.                                                                        promote aerospace education.
uniforms—the blue service dress worn by                                            Donnie Brooke
the U.S. Navy from the 1880s through World                                         Grovetown, Ga.                                      Contacts
War I and the U.S. Army “shell jackets” of                                                                                             CyberPatriot . . . . info@uscyberpatriot.org
the Civil War.                                      McGee’s Flights                                                                    Field Services . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . field@afa.org
                               Benjamin Turon           The January/February issue men-                                                Government Relations . . . . . . . . . grl@afa.org
                              Ballston Spa, N.Y.    tioned Tuskegee Airman Charles McGee                                               Insurance . . . . . . . afa.service@mercer.com
                                                    being given an honorary promotion to                                               Membership. . . . . . . . membership@afa.org
  I would hope that Gen. [John] Raymond             the rank of brigadier general, an event                                            News Media. . . . communications@afa.org
and his transition staff will turn to original      that I applaud, partly because I have
source documents prepared in the mid-1970s          known him for many years. I have spoken                                            Magazine
by Gen. Bob Herres and Maj. Gen. Stuart             with him many times. Having worked at                                              Advertising. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . kbrown@afa.org
Sherman Jr., who designed the original Space        the Air Force Historical Research Agen-                                            Editorial Offices . . . . . . . . . . . afmag@afa.org
Command from several major Air Force                cy for 37 years, I have written multiple                                           Letters to Editor Column. . . letters@afa.org
commands under the watchful eye of CINC/            books and articles about the Tuskegee
SAC Gen. Russell Daugherty. Their bold              Airmen. There is one error in your article                                         Change of Address/Email
leadership laid the groundwork for what be-         I would like to see corrected. The article                                         In an effort to stay connected with AFA
came Air Force Space Command, under the             claimed that McGee’s 409 combat mis-                                               and your local chapter, please update your
command of a four-star general. While none          sions remains a record, suggesting that                                            mailing and email addresses. Change of
                                                    no other Air Force pilot who flew fighters                                         address requires four weeks’ notice.
 WRITE TO US                                        in World War II, Korea, and Vietnam,
                                                    had more combat missions. At least two                                             To update your contact information:
 Do you have a comment about a current              other USAF pilots, who also flew fighters                                          ■ Email: membership@afa.org
 article in the magazine? Write to “Letters,”       in the same three wars, flew more com-                                             ■ Visit: The Members Only area
 Air Force Magazine, 1501 Lee Highway,              bat missions in those wars: Col. Ralph                                               of our website, afa.org
 Arlington, VA 22209-1198 or email us at            S. Parr, with 641 combat missions, and
 letters@afa.org. Letters should be concise                                                                                            ■ Call: Our Membership Department
 and timely. We cannot acknowledge receipt            INDEX TO ADVERTISERS                                                               at 1-800-727-3337
 of letters. We reserve the right to condense
                                                                                                                                       ■ Mail your magazine label, including your
 letters. Letters without name and city/base       Bradford . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .Cover III
                                                                                                                                         first and last name, to our Membership
 and state are not acceptable. Photographs         American Hearing Benefits. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4
                                                                                                                                         Department at 1501 Lee Highway,
 cannot be used or returned.                       Raytheon Missile Systems. . . . . . . . . . . . .Cover II
                                                                                                                                         Arlington, VA 22209-1198.
                                —The Editors       Rolls-Royce. . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6-7
                                                   USAA. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Cover IV

                                                                 APRIL 2020                   AIRFORCEMAG.COM                      3
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
Col. Harold S. Snow, with 666 combat                   (Tactical Air Command) cousins, it could                                                need fuel, especially at night.
missions.                                              perform low-level, terrain-following cruise                                                Gen. Maryanne Miller has the power to
                        Daniel Haulman                 at 1.2 Mach. If you wished to go faster (up                                             fix this.
                      Montgomery, Ala.                 to 1.5 Mach), you had to hand-fly the bird.                                                Do the right thing, stop production on a
                                                                                   Cdr. John C. Hall,                                          platform that isn’t meeting the specifications
Speed Limits                                                                             U.S.N. (Ret.)                                         set forth, and send Boeing a message.
   I just read the excellent article “The Bone is                                 Newcastle, Wash.                                                                        Col. Clyde Romero,
Back” by Brian Everstine [January/February,                                                                                                                                       USAF (Ret.)
p. 34]. It was a great summary of the B-1B             OK, Boomer                                                                                                                Marietta, Ga.
recovery from “overuse” through the devo-                  The KC-46 tanker issue is a worrisome
tion of devoted maintainers. Unfortunately,            one for USAF. Boeing has left no options                                                   What is the “operational requirement” that
one piece of questionable information was              but to stop production on a platform that                                               drove moving the boomer from the rear of
repeated several times describing the B-1B             doesn’t meet the specifications set in the                                              the KC-10 and KC-135 to the front cockpit
as being “supersonic”—including attributing            contract. Convene a critical-design review                                              of the KC-46? How were the KC-10 and
its rapid deployment to these supersonic               panel and look strongly at the boom pod as                                              KC-135 failing with the boomer in the back
speeds.                                                it’s currently on the KC-10. The remote visual                                          of the aircraft? No one has ever answered
   The original B-1A was a supersonic bomb-            system isn’t working, and everyone knows it!                                            those questions. For over 60 years, boomers
er. For the production B-1B that was resur-                Ask yourself this: Would you like to be                                             have admirably performed the refueling
rected years later, the variable intake ramps          refueled by a system that requires multiple                                             mission from the back of the KC-10 and
were removed for cost reasons. This limits             cameras and have anyone of them go in-                                                  KC-135. There haven’t been any glitches
the B-1B to high subsonic speeds in virtually          operable while on the boom? What about                                                  with that system.
its entire envelope. The only exception would          when the tanker goes through the clouds                                                    Now, for some unknown reason, there’s
be a very high altitude dash—which doesn’t             and the receiver is on the boom? And don’t                                              a requirement for them to be in the front
help the rapid deployment. Deployability is            tell me it hasn’t happened because it’s                                                 cockpit, looking at a TV screen that gives
based on range, fuel capacity, fuel burn, and          against regulations, because there isn’t a                                              them 20/50 vision with no depth percep-
refueling capability. High subsonic is good            fighter pilot out there that has not had that                                           tion, which is delaying full employment and
enough for now.                                        happen to him to her when a tanker went                                                 deployment for years. I really hope they
   This, by the way, leaves the FB-111A as             through the clouds and they stayed on the                                               can articulate an operational requirement,
the last U.S. supersonic strategic bomber.             boom to get the gas they desperately need-                                              because if it was for the sake of technology
Back in 1975, we had a training require-               ed to complete the mission. The same goes                                               and cool points, we have failed.
ment to make a supersonic high-altitude                for the other platforms that are receivers.                                                                       Col. Seth Bretscher,
dash at 2.2 Mach. We never exercised the               It happens all the time. Nothing beats the                                                                                 USAF (Ret.)
low-level speed capability, but like its TAC           boomer with Mark One Eyeball when you                                                                                     Lafayette, In.

                Take advantage of
           your member discounts now
     As a member of the Air Force Association,
        you and your family are eligible for
      exclusive American Hearing Benefits.
               Discounts on today’s latest technology,
               including rechargeable hearing aids and
               tinnitus options
               FREE annual hearing consultations
               60-day trial period*

             Call (888) 809-7786 to schedule your
          FREE CONSULTATION and receive your discounts.
               www.americanhearingbenefits.com/partners/AFA

                                                *Professional service fees may apply. American Hearing Benefits is a trademark of Starkey Laboratories, Inc. ©2020 Starkey. All Rights Reserved. 3/20 TJAD3128-00-EE-HB

                                                             4         APRIL 2020                    AIRFORCEMAG.COM
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
VERBATIM

                                                                                                                                                                                                        KEEP
                                                                                                                                                                                                        OUT
                                                                                                                                                                                                        “We are not
                                                                                                                                                                                                           going to
                                                                                                                                                                                                       fight against
                                                                                                                                                                                                        anyone. We
                                                                                                                                                                                                          are going
                                                                                                                                                                                                          to create
                                                                                                                                                                                                       conditions so
                                                                                                                                                                                                        that nobody
                                                                                                                                                                                                       wants to fight

                                                                                                                                                                        Photo: Mike Tsukamoto/staff
                                                                                                                                                                                                         against us.”
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Russian President
                                                                                                                                                                                                       Vladimir Putin
                                                                                                                                                                                                       in an interview
                                                                                                                                                                                                      with the state-run
                                                                                                                                                                                                      TASS news agen-
                                                                                                                                                                                                        cy about new
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Russian weapons,

                             Space Power
                                                                                                                                                                                                         March 2020.

                                                                                                                                                                                                        Nuclear
  “We now live in a world where there are threats in space, there are actors who wish to do us
harm in space and we need to understand deeply what’s there, who owns it, what its capabilities
                                                                                                                                                                                                      Crossroads
 are, what it’s likely to do and whether or not it poses a threat. … There are plenty of people who                                                                                                      “The entire
  are watching and have been watching for decades and those people live in China and those                                                                                                            triad is reach-
  people live in Russia. ... The first thing they’ve been preparing to do is to take away our space                                                                                                   ing the end of
  capabilities. The second thing they are doing is recognizing how powerful space power is as                                                                                                          its useful life.
                                           part of a joint force.”                                                                                                                                     Either we re-
                                                                                                                                                                                                      place what we
        Lt. Gen. David Thompson, vice commander of U.S. Space Force, speaking at AFA’s Air Warfare Symposium                                                                                           have now, or
                                            in Orlando, Fla., on Feb. 27.                                                                                                                             start to divest.”
                                                                                                                                                                                                        Adm. Charles

   Who,                                                                                                                                                                                                 Richard head
                                                                  Illustration: Mike Tsukamoto/staff

                                                                                                                                                                                                       of U.S. Strategic

   Us?                                                                                                                                                                                                    Command
                                                                                                                                                     Photo: Roland Balik/USAF

                                                                                                                                                                                                       [Defense News,
                                                                                                                                                                                                           Feb. 28].
“The Chinese
  military has
   never en-
 gaged in any
form of cyber                                                                                                                                                                                          Think
theft. The U.S.
                                                                                                                                                                                                       Twice
 accusation is
  groundless
  and totally
 hegemonic.”
                           Hole-y War                                                                        Unsung
                                                                                                         “Those in sustainment are heroes,
                                                                                                                                                                                                      “You don’t get
                                                                                                                                                                                                        to shoot at
                                                                                                                                                                                                      our bases, kill
                       “If I see one more slide with a big red                                          keeping old airplanes flying decades                                                           and wound
   Senior Col. Wu
                       dome over China I’m going to execute                                            past the point they were originally en-
 Qian, spokesper-                                                                                                                                                                                      Americans,
                                                                                                       visioned to serve. … That logistics and
   son for China’s     choke-con on the slide builder. China                                                                                                                                          and get away
     Ministry of                                                                                       sustainment is the difference between
                       cannot put a … red dome over itself. It                                                                                                                                            with it.”
National Defense,                                                                                       having an Air Force and an airshow.
    on Feb. 13 in       can put a block of Swiss cheese. My                                             Lots of countries have airplanes they                                                           Defense Secre-
  response to the        job is to know where the holes are,                                            can go fly at events. But … to deploy,                                                        tary Mark Esper,
 U.S. Department        get in, and hold targets at risk at the
of Justice charging                                                                                      anywhere around the world? That                                                                 at a March 12
four Chinese mili-      time and place of the Commander in                                             capability is undergirded by that sus-                                                           Pentagon press
                                                                                                                                                                                                       conference after
 tary members for                  Chief’s choosing.”                                                    tainment and logistics enterprise.”                                                            Iranian rockets
hacking Equifax, a
                                                                                                                                                                                                      struck Camp Taji,
U.S. credit-report-            Chief of Staff of the Air Force                                         Will Roper, Air Force acquisition chief, Feb. 28                                                Iraq, killing three
  ing firm, in 2017.     Gen. David Goldfein to the House Armed                                        press conference at AFA’s Air Warfare Sympo-                                                   and wounding 12.
                            Services Committee on March 4.                                                          sium in Orlando, Fla.

                                                       APRIL 2020                                       AIRFORCEMAG.COM         5
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
The Rolls-Royce F130 brings a highly reliable and proven engine to the
                B-52 Engine Replacement Program. With well over 25 million flight hours in
                the family of engines, the F130 is already in the US Air Force fleet in numerous
                applications. F130 engines for the B-52 will be digitally engineered, manufactured,
                assembled and tested in the US, at Rolls-Royce North America.
                American-made power for the B-52.

GTP_10341_2020_AirWarfare_MagSpread_v05.indd All Pages                                                2/12/20 11:30 AM
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
QUESTIONS & ANSWERS

  What’s on the Mind of Gen. C. Q. Brown
   The Air Force announced Gen. Charles Q. Brown Jr.’s nomina-
tion to become Chief of Staff in March, just days after Air Force
Magazine News Editor Amy McCullough and Editor-in-Chief
Tobias Naegele caught up with him for an interview during the
Air Force Association’s Air Warfare Symposium in Orlando, Fla.
Once confirmed, Brown will become the 22nd Air Force Chief of
Staff, replacing Gen. David Goldfein. His comments here have
been edited for space.

   Q. The National Defense Strategy focuses on the pivot to
the Indo-Pacific. How do you change the playbook to make
that happen, and what kind of progress are you seeing so
far?
   Part of it is education. And, what I mean by that is, the
decision-makers [and] policymakers have to have a better
understanding of the Indo-Pacific Theater. Because of what
we’ve done over the past 25-plus years since the Cold War in
Europe, and in our alliance with NATO, we have a comfort zone
there. I don’t know that the Indo-Pacific is an area that is well
understood. The more we have decision-makers come out and
visit the region and get to know the partners [there], they will

                                                                                                                                                Photo: Mike Tsukamoto/staff
have a better appreciation of the region and how we need to
look at the threat as well as our partners. It’s not one size fits all.
   The size of the region is roughly five times the size of the [U.S.
European Command] AOR. But then you also have different
dynamics in the AOR. You know, Japan, Korea, Mongolia,
are a bit different from India, which is at the other end of the
spectrum, or Australia and New Zealand.
   The other difference we have there, too, is that our econo-            Gen. Charles Q. Brown Jr., Pacific Air Forces commander,
mies are pretty well intertwined. If you look in the region, a            discussed China and agile combat employment during
large percentage of the world’s population is in the Indo-Pa-             AFA’s Air Warfare Symposium in February. Brown has been
cific.                                                                    nominated to be the next USAF Chief of Staff.

   Q. What impact does China’s relationship with its neigh-               There’s some natural friction that we don’t necessarily have
bors play in the region?                                                  with our partners, where we’re able to work closely together.
   The Russians aren’t economically intertwined with a lot of                Some of our partners have capabilities we don’t have. One
things that are going on in Europe, not like the Chinese [across          of the things I share with you is, as I talk to our partners with
Asia]. You’ve heard people talk about, ‘cooperate where you               small forces, they look at me and go, ‘You guys are big Air
can, compete where you must.’ Economically, there is a level              Force, there’s a lot of things you can do.’ I say, ‘You’re a small
where cooperation can occur.                                              air force, there’s a lot of things you can do that I can’t do.’ You
                                                                          can be flexible in certain areas. There’s some things we can
   Q. You’ve cited increased military cooperation between                 learn from smaller partners with smaller air forces.
Russia and China in the past. Is that still an issue?
   I don’t know, I think they’d be hard-pressed to have a stra-             Q. In Europe, the European Deterrence Initiative sets mon-
tegic relationship, partly because I don’t know that they have            ey aside for regional defense and reassurance efforts. With
the same outlook on the geopolitical aspects of what’s going              the pivot to the Pacific and the focus on countering China, is
on in our region. They have exercised together, but they don’t            there a need for something similar in the Indo-Pacific? Has
exercise like we do. You could probably describe it as exercising         that been discussed at all?
in the same location, same day; parallel play, less integration.            Oh, it has been discussed. We’ve talked about it quite often.
We’re much more integrated and operable with our partners                 We do need to think about how we invest in the region. It
than they are.                                                            doesn’t initially need to be big investments or large invest-
   The other part is, because I’ve asked this question rhetor-            ments, but we do need to think about how we invest in the
ically, ‘who’s going to be the junior partner?’ Because I don’t           Pacific vis-a-vis in Europe.
think either one of them wants to be the junior partner. You                I [went] to Ramstein [Air Base, Germany] as A3 for USAFE-AF-
don’t necessarily have to have a junior partner, but you have to          AFRICA the week after the Russians went into Crimea. So, that
have an understanding of [the relationship] between the two.              event drove what I will call a mini crisis, to actually energize a
                                                     8     APRIL 2020     AIRFORCEMAG.COM
Chosen for Chief A Pre-Nomination Interview with Gen. C.Q. Brown | 8 - Air Force Magazine
lot of things. In the Indo-Pacific, what is the mini crisis? What      of, ‘My ACE is better than your ACE.’ And so, what I pushed
is the [chance] the PRC is going to do something that actually         for last June, was to get all the Majcoms and get our deputy
is going to drive a big spike to get us to say, ‘yes,’ and throw a     commanders to come together in a forum to look at and talk
bunch of money in a different direction? They’re looking at it         about ACE. The goal was not to debate ACE. The goal was to
long-term, and I think they do just enough below the radar, so         figure out what things can we agree on? We know the first
that it doesn’t spike. Because they don’t want it to spike, but        thing you need to agree on is some lexicon, so we’re using the
they are able to do certain things. That’s how the features got        same terminology. But then what things are we doing? Okay,
built in the South China Sea.                                          let’s codify that part. And then let’s continue to work on some
                                                                       other areas that we’re pretty close on.
   Q. As the coronavirus spreads, what kind of safety pre-
cautions are you taking for Airmen in your theater? What                  Q. Can you elaborate on the things you agreed on beyond
impact is that having on exercises, and are they being                 the lexicon?
quarantined when they come back from these exercises?                     We’re using the expeditionary center to build a training
   We’re actually being proactive. We look at every exercise and       syllabus for multicapable Airmen. There are certain scenarios
the environment in that particular location, and we look at the        where regardless of AFSC, you can do more than one thing. I
additional travel restrictions put in place by various countries.      look at when we do our contingent response groups. We have
We don’t want to put ourselves in a position where we send             a small team that is multicapable. I wouldn’t say every Air
forces to an exercise, and they get sick. But then, we also don’t      Force Specialty Code has to be multicapable. There are certain
want to send a unit off to a location, and they come back and          ones that ought to be only capable on one thing because the
have to quarantine for X amount of time. That impacts our              thing that they’re doing is really important. But there’s others
ability to go do something else, so we’re being very judicious         where they have bandwidth based on the tempo of a conflict,
in our planning as we work through the exercises.                      or contingency, to do something else.

    Q. PACAF launched the Agile Combat Employment (ACE)                   Q. Should some of those AFSCs be collapsed, or is this like
concept several years ago; the idea of operating from austere          a secondary specialty?
bases and quickly getting there. How much have you tested                 It’s almost like a secondary specialty. It gets rid of some of the
that? What have you learned since that concept was first               union cards, and the idea that you can’t do this because you’re
launched? And how is it evolving?                                      not fully trained. If we go into conflict, and we start losing people,
    We’ve learned a fair amount. I think the one thing I’ve learned    and I need somebody to go refill aircraft or help load an aircraft,
is that if we can give the concept and some broad guidance to          or help unload a C- 130, we’re going to figure out some folks
our Airmen, they can come up with ideas on how to do things            who can work with someone who is actually trained and go,
differently. There’s an aspect of being able to trust an Airman        ‘Here’s what I need you to do. You stand here and you do this.’
to go do what we’ve asked him to do, and then they need to feel           What I want to be able to do is to give the Air Staff a one-pag-
confident to go do what you asked them to do without having to         er, ‘Here’s what we’re trying to achieve.’ I think on the training
report back to the AOC or ask for permission. So, that is a cultural   aspect, because the syllabus is being worked on with the expe-
aspect that we’ve got to continue to work on. As I travel around       ditionary center, we’re actually in a pretty good spot.
and talk to squadron commanders, I tell them, ‘I want to trust
you. I do trust you,’ but, unfortunately, some of our guidance           Q. The Arctic has been an area of increasing attention
actually lays out all the things that a commander shall, must          recently. And you’re probably one of the very few people
do. So, we have probably more work to do.                              who can say, ‘I’ve been to the Antarctic.’ Why are these polar
    We’ve asked commanders at the squadron level to do more            regions so important right now?
things, and they probably have the bandwidth, guidance, time,            When you look at the Arctic, if you’re a late mover there, op-
and resources that we’ve provided them. I asked them to tell           portunities may be lost, whether it’s a great power competition,
me what you can’t do. And then we can talk about the risk as-          economically, whatever the case may be. The capabilities that
sociated with this. That dialogue I have with my commanders            you need in the Arctic are some of the same capabilities you
[is important], and we should be able to talk about the aspects        need today in the Antarctic. And there’s a Russian presence
where I’ve shorted them, or the Air Force has shorted them.            on Antarctica. There’s also a Chinese presence on Antarctica.
There’s going to be a risk factor associated with that, and we have    And the Chinese presence is growing. And it’s all supposed to
to determine where that risk lies, and then how we approach            be about science.
it. Because there’s certain things [where] you can say, ‘We just
can’t get there. We can’t do this.’ And we may go, ‘We’re all good         Q. U.S. Northern Command boss Gen. Terrence O’Shaugh-
with that, because we just can’t get there from here, but these        nessy has said this is not one of those areas where you can
are things we’ve got to be able to do.’                                just hop into and be successful. So, eventually the Antarctic
    The other aspect is how do we go lighter and leaner with what      is not going to be all about science. Are you considering
support equipment we take? Sometimes we bring things just              exercising in that area? How do you do something like that?
in case. What if you didn’t bring it? Or what if we had another            I wouldn’t call it exercising, but you know, whatever training
partner who is flying the same airplane at a third location? How       we do for Arctic training, Arctic survival, those kinds of things
do we set up an ACSA [acquisition cross servicing agreement],          are probably the same things you do in the Antarctic. If you talk
so I could actually borrow that part from you and not have to          about the ice melting in the Arctic, there’s potential for the ice
ship it to that location, so having that understanding of what         to melt in Antarctica, and it may open up some things. I bring
capacity lays with our partners.                                       it up so we’re thinking about it, and it is not just written off. ...
    The last thing I will tell you is that what I found was there      If you don’t think about it, when 2040 comes around, you don’t
was a lot of entities across the Air Force doing ACE-like              want to go, ‘If I coulda, woulda, shoulda,’ because you weren’t
events, maybe with different names. And there was a little bit         thinking about it.                                                 J

                                                        APRIL 2020     AIRFORCEMAG.COM         9
AIRFRAMES

Public health medics from the 51st Aerospace Medicine
Squadron screen occupants of a car outside Osan Air Base
in South Korea on March 4, 2020. At the time, the COVID-19
outbreak was still limited to a handful of countries in Asia and

                                                                                                                         Photo: Staff Sgt. Greg Nash
Europe. Just eight days later, the World Health Organization
declared a global pandemic, the White House barred travel
by Europeans to the United States, and the Pentagon stopped
nonessential travel as the worst health crisis in a century
came into focus.

                                         10 DECEMBER
                                             10 APRIL 2020
                                                      2019     AIRFORCEMAG.COM
                                                               AIRFORCEMAG.COM   DECEMBER
                                                                                     APRIL 2019
                                                                                           2020   AIRFORCEMAG.COM   11
AIRFRAMES

                                                                                                                           Photo: U.S. Air Force photo by Airman Thomas S. Keisler IV
An
USAFHH-60G
       STaggPave Hawk helicopter from the 56th Rescue
Squadron soars over Aviano Air Base, Italy. The all-weather
search-and-rescue unit relocated from Lakenheath, U.K., to
join the 31st Fighter Wing based at Aviano in May 2019. The
Air Force announced in February that the Pave Hawks are
slated to be replaced by HH-60Ws. The new helicopters will
be dubbed “Jolly Green II,” in honor of the Vietnam-era HH-3E
rescue choppers, known as Jolly Green Giants.

                                        12 DECEMBER
                                            12 APRIL 2020
                                                     2019       AIRFORCEMAG.COM
                                                                AIRFORCEMAG.COM       APRIL 2019
                                                                                  DECEMBER  2020   AIRFORCEMAG.COM   13
                                                                                                                      13
AIRFRAMES

                                                                An F-35A Lightning II on the ramp at Nellis

                                                                                                                Photo: Airman 1st Class Bryan Guthrie
                                                                Air Force Base, Nev., in February. The jet is
                                                                among 78 F-35As operating out of Hill in
                                                                four operational squadrons. The Air Force is
                                                                seeking 48 more F-35As in its 2021 budget
                                                                request, well short of the 72 required per
                                                                year the Air Force has said are needed
                                                                to rejuvenate the fighter force with fifth-
                                                                generation stealth and sensors.

14 DECEMBER
   14 APRIL 2020
            2019   AIRFORCEMAG.COM
                   AIRFORCEMAG.COM   DECEMBER
                                         APRIL 2019
                                               2020   AIRFORCEMAG.COM   1515
STRATEGY & POLICY
                                                            By John A. Tirpak

        What Are Putin’s Five New Nukes For?
A frame grab
from a Russian
Ministry of
Defense video
shows the new
Sarmat heavy
intercontinental
ballistic missile
(ICBM) as it

                                                                                                                                              Photo: Frame grab from Russia Ministry of Defense video via RT
undergoes
its second
test launch at
the Plesetsk
Cosmodrome in
northwest Russia
on March 30,
2018. The Sarmat
is part of Russia’s
new arsenal
announced in
2018 by President
Vladimir Putin.

R
              ussian President Vladimir Putin made a grand an-           Putin may also see the weapons as a counter to perceived
              nouncement in March 2018, declaring that Russia         threats from the U.S. and its allies, which he may fear are trying to
              is developing five new nuclear or nuclear-powered       back a “color revolution” against Russia to achieve regime change
              weapons. The new nukes would be in addition to          there. While these are not stated U.S. policies, the report states,
              Russia’s extant, START-compliant strategic nuclear      Russian officials “appear to be genuinely fearful of the possible
              forces and thousands of nonstrategic nuclear weap-      spread of democracy to Russia with U.S. backing.”
ons ranging from torpedoes to artillery and short-range missiles.        On the more speculative side, the Atlantic Council report
    Russia’s existing nuclear force already holds the U.S. at risk.   posited that Russia could seek a “decapitation” strike against
These new weapons wouldn’t appreciably change the nuclear             Washington, D.C., in the event of a war with NATO. “To be sure,
deterrence equation. So why does Putin need them?                     this would be an extreme scenario, but military plans and postures
    The Atlantic Council’s Scowcroft Center for Strategy and Secu-    are sometimes developed to deal with remote, but important,
rity took up that question, in conjunction with experts from Los      contingencies,” the report noted. Still, a nuclear cruise missile
Alamos National Laboratory. In a March report, “Russia’s Exotic       deployed from a commercial vessel could achieve similar effects
Nuclear Weapons and Implications for the United States and            less expensively.
NATO,” 28 strategic arms experts confessed they’re still scratch-        More mercenary explanations for Russia’s new programs could
ing their heads. It’s hard to see the rationale for expending so      include a make-work program for Russia’s defense industrial
much Russian treasure on a prodigious nuclear modernization           base or to promote foreign sales of Russian military hardware.
program that doesn’t really give Russia more capability than it          “It is unclear,” the report concluded, “what advantages these
already has, participants said.                                       new systems provide.”
    Perhaps the most plausible rationale could be “a genuine
paranoia about the vulnerability of Russia’s nuclear deterrent        COUNTERS, AND COUNTER-COUNTERS
and a desire to signal Russia’s great-power status to foreign and        How should the U.S. respond to Russia’s new weapons? The
domestic audiences.”                                                  Atlantic Council offers three options: “Ignoring, or even ridiculing,
    A second would be a desire to overwhelm U.S. and allied theater   Russia’s new systems; pushing to include a wider range of systems
missile defenses. A third, that the new weapons could be used as      in negotiations over New Strategic Arms Reduction Treaty (New
coercive measures in a crisis. The new nukes could be a backstop      START) renewal; and strengthening the U.S. and NATO deterrence
to Russia’s conventional weakness as it threatens countries on        posture, including by continuing to introduce low-yield warheads
its borders or to achieve what Russia oxymoronically has called       to the U.S. nuclear arsenal.” This last step was actually called for
“de-escalation:” the use of low-yield nuclear weapons to scare        in the 2018 Nuclear Posture review, drawing widespread debate
adversaries into capitulation to avoid all-out nuclear war.           in Congress and criticism from some think tanks.
                                                 16     APRIL 2020    AIRFORCEMAG.COM
Russia has relied on its nuclear arsenal in the post-Cold War         U.S. should also develop countermeasures to Poseidon, it said.
era to preserve its status as a world power and, in recent years              “Fond hopes” that the world could be rid of nuclear weapons
has made “explicit military threats” to use it, the Atlantic Council     after the Cold War “have not been borne out by the facts,” the
report pointed out. Recent Russian exercises have concluded              report said. “Great power competition has returned, and with
with simulated nuclear strikes on European targets, and Putin            it, the importance of nuclear weapons to international politics.”
placed his nuclear forces on alert during the Georgian and               Such weapons “remain the ultimate instrument of military force,
Ukraine crises.                                                          and Russia is emphasizing nuclear force as a central pillar of its
   Viewed in this context, “Russia is building the nuclear force pos-    military strategy.” Western leaders, therefore, must again make
ture necessary to back up this ambitious strategy,” the report said.     effective nuclear deterrence the “foremost priority of the NATO
The Atlantic Council also noted that even while the Intermediate         alliance.”
Nuclear Forces treaty was in effect, Russia cheated, “developing
and deploying multiple batteries of nuclear-capable, intermedi-          THE EU’S CAPABILITY DEFICITS
ate-range, ground-launched cruise missiles.”                                The latest comprehensive analysis of the global military balance
                                                                         from the International Institute for Strategic Studies (IISS) suggests
STRATEGIC DEBUTANTES                                                     America’s NATO allies will have to invest more in defense if the
   Russia’s new nuclear weapons are:                                     U.S. continues to focus on the Indo-Pacific region. In fact, NATO
       Sarmat ICBM: Replaces the SS-18 heavy ICBM, code-named            allies may fall short by a third of a trillion dollars’ worth of capa-
Satan by NATO. It can carry either 10 reentry vehicles or at least one   bility in “enablers” alone if the U.S. devotes the bulk of its military
hypersonic glide vehicle. Russia has said it will begin production       attention elsewhere.
of Sarmat this year. Plans call for six Sarmat regiments, the first to      Since 2019, global defense spending grew by 4 percent, in 2015
be deployed in 2021.                                                     dollars, according to the IISS’s annual assessment, “The Military
       Avangard Hypersonic Glide Vehicle: This is a very long-range,     Balance 2020.” This was the largest increase in 10 years. Non-U.S.
maneuverable weapon that would be difficult to defend against.           NATO defense spending was back to where it was before the 2008
It would be pushed to hypersonic speed by Sarmat, eventually,            financial crisis.
but in the near-term, it has been fitted to the SS-19, code-named           The emergence of a new economic crisis with the global
Stiletto by NATO. Russia tested Avangard successfully in 2016 and        COVID-19 pandemic raises new questions about NATO’s ability to
2018 and said it had activated two in December.                          maintain such spending. Time will tell, but as governments pour
       Kinzhal hypersonic missile: This weapon would be carried to       funds into bailouts and emergency measures, there could well be
altitude on wing pylons or in bomb bays. Russia has boasted about        inevitable calls to curb spending on defense.
having developed such a weapon before the U.S.                              “The Military Balance 2020,” which was published before
       Burevestnik nuclear-powered, long-range missile: Putin            the pandemic hit, paints a picture of what could happen in the
claims this weapon has unlimited range. Code-named SSC-X-9               event the U.S. becomes fully engaged in a Pacific war and cannot
“Skyfall”by NATO, its existence was disclosed in 2018 when Putin         respond in full force to a European conflict. In such case, NATO
showed a video animation of the missile traversing huge distances        allies would be operating at a serious deficiency in key enablers,
on a map—crossing Europe, the Atlantic Ocean, and parts of South         such as mobility, airborne tankers, and intelligence, surveillance,
America before approaching a target in Florida. Russia claims the        and reconnaissance, the IISS pointed out.
weapon features a low-radar cross section.                                  Indeed, that is also the case with allies in other regions, such as
       Poseidon nuclear-armed, autonomous underwater drone:              the Middle East. “It may transpire that Washington cannot always
Previously known as “Status-6,” six of these torpedoes could be          supply capabilities needed by allies and partners,” the report said.
carried by a Russian guided-missile submarine. Armed with a                 The IISS estimates that it would cost America’s NATO allies
conventional or nuclear warhead, it would operate at depths too          between $288 billion and $357 billion “to fill gaps highlighted by
deep to use satellite navigation, rendering it an imprecise weapon       a scenario where they would have to defend their territory without
intended for use against a large target, such as a coastal city. The     U.S. support against a state-level attack.”
Atlantic Council report speculated that Poseidon could be “laden            Mobility, for example, is a key area where NATO partners are
with a multimegaton warhead seeded with cobalt—which would               badly underinvested. The entire European Union tanker/transport
result in particularly deadly nuclear fallout.”                          fleet totaled just 49 aircraft in 2019, less than a tenth the size of the
   The report noted that Russia is having trouble with developing        U.S. fleet, which numbered 555.
some of these weapons—Skyfall, particularly, had a noteworthy               “Were a crisis to erupt that required rapid mobility of U.S.
accident. But Russia has been “comfortable rushing weapons               equipment, for instance in the Asia-Pacific, it is highly likely that
systems into the field at a pace that would not be possible in the       the U.S. would look to move relevant enabling assets from where
United States,” the authors noted.                                       they are currently stationed.”
   In response, the Atlantic Council report recommends the U.S.             While great power competition “continues to dominate long-
Intelligence Community invest resources to capture “more detailed        term Western defense policymaking and procurement … there
information about the origins of these programs, and what prompt-        is now less apparent coherence than before in terms of political
ed Putin to unveil them in a major public address in March 2018.”        responses,” the IISS said. The growing disharmony evidenced by
   The authors also suggest the U.S. seek to reassure Russia that it     French President Emmanuel Macron’s famous declaration that
is not seeking a first-strike capability while modernizing the U.S.      NATO is “brain dead,” means NATO allies will be challenged to
strategic nuclear arsenal. Failing that, the U.S. should proceed on      overcome these problems.
the findings of the Nuclear Posture Review, the Atlantic Council            The fundamental problem is that military assets are limited. If
said, to “strengthen their deterrent and defensive measures” and         the U.S. is suddenly faced with a conflict in the Asia-Pacific, it may
“develop low-yield capabilities.”                                        have no choice but to move ISR, mobility, and other assets out of
   The report also urged the U.S. to develop its own hypersonic          theaters where they have historically been available, sounding a
missiles and defensive countermeasures to such weapons built by          wake-up call to allies that have grown too reliant on those capa-
Russia and China, following a “deterrence-by-denial” strategy. The       bilities. 						                                                       J
                                                          APRIL 2020     AIRFORCEMAG.COM         17
WORLD
                                 USAF Rebuilds
                               Precision Munition
                                   Stockpiles

An F-15E Strike Eagle
armed with a variety
of Joint Direct Attack
Munitions on a May
7, 2019, mission over

                                                                                                                                          Sgt. Russ Scalf
                                                                                                                                          Photo: Master
Southwest Asia.

      Production surge slows as Air Force nears weapons goal.
By John A. Tirpak

A
                                                                                tory. This rapid usage was exacerbated by allied air
                                                                                forces “borrowing” munitions from the U.S. because
            fter an intense period of restocking, Air                           their own limited stocks were depleted from action
            Force precision weapon inventories are                              in Afghanistan and Libya.
            almost back to acceptable levels, Air Force                            Precision munitions were the weapon of choice in
            leaders say. Now they are throttling back      “What I would        the fight against ISIS due to the rules of engagement.
            planned purchases for fiscal 2021.             hope we              Because civilians were mixed in with ISIS combat-
   “We have been able to make a dent” in the muni-         would do, is         ants, extremely accurate targeting and strikes were
tions shortage, said Gen. Arnold Bunch Jr., head of                             required to avoid civilian casualties.
Air Force Materiel Command during the Air Force As-        level off … at          The shortages prompted the Air Force to surge
sociation’s Air Warfare Symposium in February. The         this year’s          production of weapons like the JDAM, Small Diam-
sharp reduction of U.S. air attacks against the Islamic    level, maybe         eter Bomb 1, and the AGM-114 Hellfire.
State group “has allowed us to get in a better place       plus or minus           In planning the fiscal 2021 budget, Bunch said,
and on a better trajectory” in terms of war reserves.                           the Air Force had to “focus on the high-end fight,”
                                                           a little bit.”
   Bunch has previously referred to ups and downs                               reducing its appetite for JDAMs. The Air Force bought
in purchasing as a “sine wave” that plays havoc with       —Gen. Arnold         30,872 JDAMs in fiscal 2019, which was its high water-
budgets and frustrates weapon producers, who have          Bunch, head of       mark. It requested 37,000 in fiscal 2020, but Congress
had to add tooling and shifts to meet USAF’s urgent        Air Force Materiel   only approved 25,000. The request for fiscal 2021 is
demands for replacement weapons in recent times.           Command              only for 10,000 JDAMs, including both “base budget”
   “What I would hope we would do, is level off …                               and Overseas Contingency Operations accounts.
at this year’s level, maybe plus or minus a little bit,”                           Production of the SDB 1 increased from 5,743 units
Bunch said.                                                                     in fiscal 2019 to 7,078 in fiscal 2020; USAF is seeking
   During Operation Inherent Resolve, the Air Force                             only 2,462 in fiscal 2021.
was using up Joint Direct Attack Munitions (JDAMs)                                 Was the munitions downshift a bill payer for other
so quickly that they were being loaded onto combat                              programs? Or was it a signal that the Air Force in-
aircraft in the Middle East a scant 24 hours after being                        tends to start buying longer-range weapons that can
crated up and shipped from Boeing’s St. Louis fac-                              be released farther away from enemy air defenses?
                                                  18   APRIL 2020      AIRFORCEMAG.COM
Production Slowdown
The Air Force is seeking to slow production of six key precision munitions in its 2021 budget request, as combat demand throttles
down and concern over shortages abates.
                                    2019                        2020                          2020                                2021
Weapon                            (Enacted)                   (Request)                     (Enacted)                           (Request)
JDAM                               30,872                      37,000                       25,000                               10,000
SDB I                               5,743                        7,078                        7,078                               2,462
SDB II Stormbreaker                   510                         1,175                        1,175                               1,133
AGM-1145 Hellfire                   2,771                       3,859                        3,859                                2,497
AGM-158 JASSM-ER                     360                           430                          390                                 400
AGM-158C LRASM                         15                             -                            -                                   5
   “It might be a little bit of all of                                                            of the weapon.
those,” said Gen. James “Mike”                                                                       With help from Congress, “we
Holmes, head of Air Combat                                                                        stood up an additional JASSM

                                                                                                       Illustration: Boeing
Command. “After several years Boeing’s                                                            production facility,” which is now
of the Air Force working hard to Powered JDAM, now in development,                                under construction, Bunch said.
replenish the JDAM stocks, we’re would add a motor and wing kit to extend the                     Lockheed Martin Missiles and
approaching the objectives that weapon’s range by 20 miles or more.                               Fire Control builds the JASSM and
we set, and those objectives are                                                                  LRASM in Troy, Ala.
set by looking at the war plans                                                                      Bunch said the National De-
and the different contingencies.”                                                                fense Strategy tells the Air Force
   Holmes said “the right bal-                                                                   “we need to take more risk in the
ance of risk was to continue to                                                                  near, and look for the far. Those

                                                                                                  Photo: 1st Lt. Savanah Bray
acquire those weapons, but as                                                                    standoff and those more advanced
we approach the objective, to                                                                    weapons are the far, and we’re try-
start slowing down a little bit on                                                               ing to make the move to that area.”
the JDAM,” which is a gravity-fall                                                                  Multiple studies have argued
weapon.                                                                                          for increased purchases of lon-
   The Air Force is investing in                                                                 ger-range weapons in recent years.
“the things we’ll need for long-                                                                 Some have suggested adding mo-
range fires, across the joint force, An F-16 loaded with a JASSM-ER prior to an operational      tors to conventional gravity weap-
to challenge a peer adversary,” test sortie at Eglin Air Force Base, Fla. The Air Force          ons. Indeed, Holmes has told Air
Holmes said. “When you look wants to buy 400 of the weapons in 2021.                             Force Magazine that USAF needs
at everything that had to fit in                                                                 new munitions that combine lon-
the budget, some pretty good work was done over the last            ger range and a degree of stealth in an package that’s inexpen-
several years to replenish the JDAM stocks and work toward          sive enough to buy in mass quantities.
the objective, and in the Department they made the decision            The Air Force developed the precision-guided GBU-39
that they’re getting close enough that they can slow down that      Small Diameter Bomb I because it found that JDAM-sized
buy rate a bit.”                                                    weapons were too large for the small, precise attacks necessary
   While contractors have purchased tooling and hired staff         in wars like the counterinsurgencies in Afghanistan and Iraq.
to meet larger production goals, the Air Force footed the bill,     Its 250-pound warhead was a better size for many targets, and
Holmes said. “When they go to tool, we actually pay for it,” he     its lighter weight meant USAF aircraft could carry more weap-
explained. “The industry comes to us and says ‘to go to what-       ons. The SDB I uses GPS/INS, laser, and even radar-homing
ever rate, this is what it will cost you.’” Now that the tooling is guidance for some variants, and has a range of about 45 miles,
in place, it provides the potential to surge production in the      for use against stationary targets.
event of a large-scale conflict, Holmes said.                          The GBU-53 SDB II, built by Raytheon and named “Storm-
   Bunch said the Air Force budget plan does not throw con-         Breaker,” increases that range to some 70 miles. It adds Link
tractors back to low production, but rather creates an “op-         16 connectivity and can attack moving targets in brownout or
portunity” for allies to replenish their stocks, as well, through   adverse weather. An F-15E can carry up to 28 SDB IIs.
increased foreign military sales. U.S. military demand had             Boeing, the maker of JDAMs, showed off a new variant of
made such sales difficult in recent years. Now the Air Force        that bomb at the AFA 2020 Air Warfare Symposium. Called
wants allies to know those weapons are available again.             “Powered JDAM,” it adds a wingset and power module to
   “We want them to buy ahead,” so the U.S. is not seen as the      increase JDAMs’ range by 20 times. The company is pitching
store in a contingency. “We want them … to replenish, buy           the munition as a lower-cost alternative to a cruise missile.
ahead, so they’re prepared,” Bunch said.                               The munitions would have the range to “stand outside the
   The longest-range conventional weapon the Air Force is           engagement zone,” said Wade Kirkbride, a business develop-
buying is the Joint Air-to-Surface Standoff Munition (JASSM),       ment representative for Boeing, calling the weapon the “cen-
which is on its fourth variant. The JASSM-ER (for Extended          terpiece” of the company’s plan to “evolve JDAM for the future.”
Range) has maintained a steady production rate, with buys of        The munitions, which could use any of a number of sensors
360 in 2019, 390 in ’20, and a request for 400 in ’21. Beginning    for targeting, could also be used as a decoy for more expensive
in 2021, the Air Force would also acquire five Long-Range           missiles such as JASSM, which cost more than $1 million per
Anti-Ship Missiles, or LRASMs, the counter-maritime version         round.                                                         J
                                                     APRIL 2020           AIRFORCEMAG.COM    19
You can also read