BEEF AUSTRALIA 2021 - A GREAT FUTURE AHEAD - ANZ

Page created by Nathaniel Allen
 
CONTINUE READING
BEEF AUSTRALIA 2021 - A GREAT FUTURE AHEAD - ANZ
BEEF AUSTRALIA 2021
- A GREAT FUTURE AHEAD
MAY 2021

A YEAR OF STRENGTHS AND                                          While the recovery from the initial Covid impacts in many
CHALLENGES                                                       countries will be unpredictable, and potentially longer
                                                                 than anticipated, the eventual economic recovery will see
On many counts, the Australian beef and cattle sector is
                                                                 demand for beef strengthen, both in domestic and export
in one of the strongest positions in its history. Its recovery
                                                                 markets, whether through consumers eating out again, or
from the drought period has been strong, the prices
                                                                 seeing a recovery in their household spending budgets. Yet
producers are receiving for their cattle are at record levels,
                                                                 while demand for beef globally remains strong, if anything,
and despite the unprecedented pandemic disruptions
                                                                 Australia’s competitors are growing even more strongly,
to the global economy, demand for beef remains
                                                                 whether in scale, sophistication, or food safety.
fundamentally strong.
                                                                 Domestically, the structural position of Australia’s beef
Importantly, with strength comes a positive challenge –
                                                                 production landscape continues to strengthen, as the
the need to maximise on the position in which the industry
                                                                 number of farms goes down, while the size of the average
finds itself, and ensure that the good fortune isn’t taken
                                                                 farms goes up. At the same time, many beef producers
for granted, or leads to complacency. Given the renowned
                                                                 are looking to the industry challenges facing them, and
resilience and innovativeness of all stakeholders across
                                                                 translating these into tools for success. These include an
the Australian beef supply chain, it is clear that this is the
                                                                 increased use of family succession to build operations,
stance that the industry is continuing to take.
                                                                 a re-evaluation of many farm strategies as producers
Approaching the middle of 2021, it is clear that for most        increasingly look at diversification options, and a move
of Australia, the good season which followed the end of          to embrace sustainability developments as a potential
two difficult years of drought is largely continuing. And        economic benefit, rather than a threat.
while only the brave would forecast the weather a long
                                                                 There will always be discussion, debate and disagreement
way ahead, knowing that droughts will always happen
                                                                 on issues within the beef and cattle industries, and so there
eventually, there is every indication that the positive
                                                                 should be - that’s how ideas are analysed and dissected,
rainfall patterns are likely to continue for some time. For
                                                                 and how new strategies arise.
many producers, the aim will be not just to restore herds
to pre-drought levels, but if anything to make them even         We trust that you will find this an interesting discussion,
stronger, to capitalise on what they see as boom times           and we look forward to working with many of you as part
ahead for beef demand.                                           of this exciting and essential industry.
For decades, the demand story has been driven by the
same strong factors which continue to be important today
– the growing incomes and changing diets of consumers
across middle income countries, as they can increasingly
afford to buy beef, and continue to increase it as a
component of their diets.
BETTING THE FARM                                                                        The process of consolidation across all parts of the
                                                                                        Australian agri landscape, resulting in greater levels of
Australia’s cattle industry entered 2021 on a strong note
                                                                                        efficiency and increased strategic options for producers,
with record high cattle prices, better weather conditions,
                                                                                        also remained fundamental to the growth of successful
and minimal disruption to operations due to Covid. With all
                                                                                        multi-generational family operations.
the positivity, it can be easy to forget that around a decade
ago, the mood was arguably somewhat different. For                                      As the chart shows, one increasing trend over the past
many observers around the start of the 2010s, farming and                               thirty years has been the growth of diversified operations,
agricultural production were inevitably heading to a model                              rather than pure play cattle or sheep operations.
where the larger corporate farms would dominate, and                                    Importantly, while the findings are based on revenue
many family farms would be unable to compete.                                           sizes of farms, rather than acreage or stock numbers, they
                                                                                        still highlight the trend toward consolidation. While the
Fast forward to the present time, when family farms have
                                                                                        biggest growth in consolidation has come from wheat
clearly emerged stronger than ever and find themselves
                                                                                        and cropping operations, the next two strongest areas of
in a robust position both financially and agronomically.
                                                                                        consolidation are either sheep and cattle operations, or
Importantly, many are making long term strategic decisions
                                                                                        mixed livestock and grazing.
with far more complexity than would have been the case a
decade ago.                                                                             Where Are We In The Cycle?
The New Family Farm                                                                                                    Interest Rates vs Cattle Prices
One sign of the relative strength of the family farm is                                                9.0%                                                         900
how the average operation has evolved not just in scale,                                               8.0%                                                         800
but generationally. While it is hard to quantify, it is clear                                          7.0%                                                         700
across many parts of rural Australia that the approach                                                 6.0%                                                         600
                                                                                      Interest rates

                                                                                                                                                                          EYCI (c/kg)
to succession and generational change has evolved in                                                   5.0%                                                         500

a positive way. Not that long ago, many families viewed                                                4.0%                                                         400
                                                                                                       3.0%                                                         300
succession as the departure of the parents and the arrival
                                                                                                       2.0%                                                         200
of the children onto the property. These situations were
                                                                                                       1.0%                                                         100
often quite difficult, with issues such as management
                                                                                                          -                                                         -
responsibility handover, as well the financial restructuring                                                  1996-97 2000-01 2004-05 2008-09 2012-13 2016-17 2020-21
required for parents to move on from the farm.                                                                      Long term Interest rate     EYCI (c/kg)
                                                                                                                    Short term Interest rate
With the ongoing process of farm consolidation growing
the scale of many operations, the ability increasingly exists                                Source: ABARES, RBA, ANZ
for two generations to work together on a farm positively                               Like every agri sector, the Australian cattle industry is
and constructively. In addition, more and more, the                                     currently in the midst of a cycle encompassing high cattle
younger generation will return from a tertiary education                                prices, escalating farmland prices, a generally good season,
not just with training in agriculture, but with new skills and                          and a bumper grain crop. Combined they created a great
knowledge of areas such as agtech and new financial skills,                             deal of confidence for many in the sector, a view which
which positively benefit a farming operation.                                           may well shape many of their individual farm strategies
This all translates back into more innovative and efficient                             going forward.
farming operations, and ultimately adds to the strength of                              It is interesting to compare cattle prices over the past two
the overall sector.                                                                     decades to the direction of interest rates over the same
        Share of Medium & Large Scale Farms By Sector                                   period of time and it is quite notable that cattle price
70%
                                                                                        rises have moved very much in contrast with interest rate
                                                                                        declines. Accepting that many other factors impact cattle
60%
                                                                                        prices, it is also worth considering that interest rate rises,
50%                                                                                     whenever they will inevitably happen, will have an impact
40%
                                                                                        on producer decisions, including stock and land purchasing,
                                                                                        as well as the prices they may receive for these. While this
30%
                                                                                        observation shouldn’t dampen confident strategies for
20%                                                                                     many producers, it should still consider some reflection that
10%
                                                                                        the market will inevitably change at some stage.

    -                                                                                   The Agri Investment Flow
        1991    1995    1999    2003           2007    2011        2015      2019
                   Beef      Sheep            Sheep-Beef                                A lot of the questions in past years about the future
                   Mixed Livestock            Wheat and other crop                      of average farms and not just been about their own
  Source: Agsurf data from ABARES, ANZ
                                                                                        performance, but how they would compete with the
                                                                                        “corporate farms”, with their forecast higher levels of
Note: Medium scale is defined as farms with revenue between $0.5 to $1 m per annum,
while large scale is defined as farms with over $1min revenue per annum
                                                                                        efficiency, or whether many family farms would be
                                                                                        purchased by an influx of new investors.
The position of the family farm on the agri investment                                            Australian Beef
landscape now is a far stronger one. With many investors                                Exports and Gross Value of Production
actively seeking skilled agri managers, this opens up                          15,000                                                       100%
further possibilities to attract new capital partnerships into
                                                                               12,000                                                       80%
their operations, although bringing its own challenges of

                                                                                                                                                   Exports as % GVP
co-managing with a new entity. Certainly, as the flow of

                                                                 GVP/Exports
                                                                                9,000                                                       60%
capital into Australian agri increases, the opportunities also
increase for farms to increase scale through consolidation                      6,000                                                       40%

Investment flows into Australian agri has been somewhat                         3,000                                                       20%
stifled by the recent travel restrictions, but will grow
strongly when disruptions ease further. This could provide                                                                                  -
                                                                                    1988–89      1996–97     2004–05      2012–13   2020–21 f
the incentive for interested producers to explore their
                                                                                              Gross value of Production (GVP)
options to take advantage of these opportunities.
                                                                                              Exports       Exports as % GVP
Importantly, investors will increasingly be looking for data         Source: ABARES, ANZ
to a greater degree than before, including agronomic and
financial. With the modern institutional investor motivated      Looking ahead, export growth is forecast to continue
by the metrics of long term returns, many are looking for        for at least the next four years. As the Australian herd
as much data as they possibly can from agri partnerships         rebuild continues, the flow of cattle back into saleyards
or assets, putting the onus on the producer to collect and       will gradually increase, as producers’ restocking strategies
maintain this.                                                   generally reach farm capacity. Given that the main reason
                                                                 for the recent decline in exports has been tightness of
Sustainability Opportunities                                     supply, exports are likely to resume steady upward growth
While it is a complex and evolving field to a lot of             and continue to influence producer revenues.
people, many innovative farmers are now exploring the            Globally, the outlook for beef consumption over the rest
opportunities that the increasing emphasis on sustainable        of this decade continues to be strong. According the FAO/
practices are likely to bring. Inevitably, sustainability        OECD (Food and Agriculture Organisation of the United
practices and requirements will become more a part of the        Nations/Organisation for Economic Co-operation and
agri landscape, and while that may feel uneasy to some,          Development), global beef consumption is forecast to
many producers will understand that this is path they have       rise by almost seven percent between 2020 and 2029.
been heading down for years in their own operations.             Unsurprisingly, growth is forecast to be considerably higher
These opportunities are likely to come in a number of            for developing countries (ten percent) than developed
forms, from sustainability-linked animal management              countries (2.6 percent). Between them, the US and Brazil
practices and new beef certification projects, to on -farm       are expected to account for almost one fifth of the global
carbon projects. While many of these opportunities               increase in demand over that period.
may not eventuate for some time, and may take a while
to become clearer, they are certainly prospects being            Interestingly, of the next seven markets forecast to see
explored by many innovative producers.                           major increases in their beef consumption, few are on the
                                                                 radar of Australia’s major export markets. Between them
                                                                 – Pakistan, South Africa, Turkey, Indonesia, Egypt, India
AUSTRALIA VERSUS THE WORLD
                                                                 and Vietnam – they are forecast to account for around 33
The Big Picture                                                  percent of the world’s increased beef consumption by
The importance of export markets to the Australian beef          2029. For some of them, ample domestic beef production
industry cannot be overestimated. Last year marked the           means they will remain exporters, particularly Brazil and
fiftieth anniversary of the first year that the exports of       India, while for most of the others, the beef import needs
Australian beef surpassed domestic consumption. Since            are likely to be met by a different quality of exports, such as
that year, the share of exports has continued steadily           those from India.
upwards, to the point where exports now account for 70           The FAO/OECD forecasts provide interesting reading on
percent of the volume of Australian beef.                        some of Australia’s other markets. South Korea is forecast
Since 1960, beef export volumes have grown by around             to see reasonable consumption growth of around 4.5
3.5 percent, almost eight times the rate of domestic             percent, while Japan’s beef consumption growth is forecast
growth, (0.45 percent per annum) from 165,000 tonnes to          to decline by 3.7 percent. Also notable is that Australia
a forecast 1.39 m tonnes in 2021. In terms of the value of       is forecast to see marginal growth of 2.2 percent, while
exports to the beef industry, the numbers become even            China’s beef consumption is forecast to fall by three
stronger again. While the numbers have dipped in the past        percent, albeit subject to its recovery in its domestic pork
couple of years due the drought and tight supply through         sector.
restocking, in 2013/14 and again in 2018/19, exports
accounted for around 90 percent of the total gross value of
production of the overall Australian beef industry.
Australian Beef Exports by Destination
                        1.4                                                                                                                             100%

                        1.2                                                                                                                             90%

                                                                                                                                                               Top4 (US, Japan, S Korea and China) as %
                        1.0
 Million tonnes (swt)

                                                                                                                                                        80%

                                                                                                                                                                             Exports/Production
                        0.8
                                                                                                                                                        70%
                        0.6
                                                                                                                                                        60%
                        0.4

                        0.2                                                                                                                             50%

                         -                                                                                                                              40%
                              1988        1992          1996             2000             2004               2008      2012         2016         2020

                                                                                        Calendar year

                                     US               Japan               South Korea                China          Indonesia          Other
                                     Top4 as % of Total Production                      Top4 as % Total Exports
          Source: MLA, ANZ

What Is The Outlook For The Big Four?                                                                currencies of the major South American beef exporting
In looking to the future for Australian beef exports, it is                                          competitors. The US market relies largely on manufacturing
unavoidable that the focus needs to be on the big four                                               beef, to feed the unquenchable hamburger appetite of
markets – China, Japan, South Korea and the US. Between                                              Americans, but the rebuilding and restocking process has
them, these four markets have accounted for an average of                                            added to the challenge in this market. Farmers are holding
around 75 percent of Australia’s annual beef exports over                                            back many of theirs cows to build their own herds, which
the past ten years. While this figure has fluctuated, the fact                                       would otherwise have been destined for manufacturing
that it has not fallen below 70 percent in the past three                                            beef, while those cows which do hit the market are often
decades is testament to the importance of these markets                                              being sold at very high prices.
to the Australian industry.                                                                          Regardless of the headlines over the past year, and
On the other hand, however, even though having four                                                  accepting the uncertainty of future trade changes, the
major buyers is less risky than one, it still highlights the                                         Chinese beef market remains a fundamentally strong
concentration risk, and the need to be aware of the                                                  one for Australian exports. While it is difficult to predict
possible actions of these markets.                                                                   any sudden trade restrictions which may arise impacting
                                                                                                     Australian beef exports to China, a number of major
South Korea has long been a steady market for Australian                                             reasons would suggest that China would be unlikely to
beef, and in recent months has become the second largest                                             drastically reduce its imports of Australian beef.
market for exports, behind Japan. South Korea brings in
over 90 percent of its beef imports from Australia and the                                           China’s consumers will continue to require major
US. Interestingly, until very recently, beef from the EU has                                         supplies of beef, which the country is unable to
been banned from export to South Korea since 2000, due                                               provide from domestic production. While the impact
to BSE (bovine spongiform encephalopathy, or “mad cow                                                of African Swine Fever on the Chinese pig herd, and its
disease”). The market has recently opened to exports from                                            subsequent reduction on domestic pork production is
the Netherlands and Denmark, with Ireland also in the                                                declining, the rate is apparently slower than originally
process of seeking market access.                                                                    forecast. Impressively, China is taking the opportunity
                                                                                                     of the rebuilding of its pig herd to refine the entire pork
The Japanese beef market, which in recent months                                                     production process, into a more industrial one, with far
has regained its mantle as Australia’s largest market, also                                          greater food safety characteristics, and far less likely to
provides a reminder of the importance of food safety to                                              see a repeat of similar food safety cares. However, while
particular consumers and countries. Australia’s biggest                                              pork production can be achieved on an industrial scale,
competitor in the Japanese beef market, the US, was                                                  replicating this for beef would be a far greater challenge,
largely banned from exporting to Japan from 2003 until                                               given the difference in scale between China’s beef needs,
2007, due to BSE. The US remains a strong competitor                                                 and its availability of pasture, water, and feed production
to Australia’s beef market share in Japan, having steadily                                           capacity. This is despite China’s announcement in its most
rebuilt its market share since the ban was lifted.                                                   recent Five Year Plan that it would seek to achieve far
Longer term, the Australian beef trade with Japan would                                              higher levels of domestic production in areas such as beef.
appear to be one of the strongest trading relationships,                                             Looking ahead, it seems quite foreseeable that America
although the need to maintain market share through                                                   may look to gain further market access into China for its
strong trade agreements will need to be a focus of trade                                             beef producers, given the tight supplies from Australia as
negotiators.                                                                                         well as the opportunity for the new US administration to
The US market continues to be a strong one for Australia,                                            boost its support with US cattle producers. That said, it
though has recently struggled with Australia’s tight                                                 seems reasonably unlikely that China would reduce beef
supplies, as well as the challenging impacts of the relatively                                       imports from Australia much further than the current
high AUD/USD exchange rate, particularly in relation to the                                          restrictions on a set of Australian processors.
In addition, while markets such as Vietnam and the                                                                   The US beef export sector has largely recovered from the
  Philippines may currently be continuing to be impacted                                                               Covid disruptions to its processing sector in 2020. At the time,
  economically by Covid disruptions, their long term                                                                   Covid related shutdowns of US processing operations led to
  population and income growth will provide important                                                                  a build-up of animals, until current meatworks could resume
  opportunities for Australia to increase exports of quality beef.                                                     normal operations. There were also concerns that this backlog
                                                                                                                       would flood onto world markets, reducing global beef prices,
  Finally, while the Middle East has long been a target for
                                                                                                                       though this didn’t occur. With Australia’s tight supply, the US
  increased exports, sometimes more so for sheep meat, a
                                                                                                                       is now the world’s second largest beef exporter, well behind
  range of factors may increase its potential. The opening up
                                                                                                                       Brazil and marginally in front of Australia.
  of a number of these countries, particularly Saudi Arabia,
  may well see opportunities for beef at a restaurant level to                                                         The US and Australia “co-exist” as the major suppliers to
  grow, and per capita consumption to increase.                                                                        two of their biggest markets – Japan and South Korea.
                                                                                                                       Both countries dominate those markets, but are restricted
  Aust Beef’s Competitors – how are they looking?                                                                      from advancing their market share much further than the
  In the global beef trade, Australia has three major                                                                  current figure, due to safeguard tariffs which kick in under
  competitors in terms of volume, but each with very                                                                   each country’s free trade agreements, in a bid to protect
  different characteristics. Of the largest exporters, India                                                           the domestic cattle sectors of Japan and South Korea.
  provides potentially the least competition with Australia,
                                                                                                                       Australia’s biggest competitive challenge remains
  though still requires attention. Indian beef exports are
                                                                                                                       from South America. Each of the major players – Brazil,
  essentially buffalo meat, or carabeef. While the carabeef is
                                                                                                                       Argentina, Uruguay and Paraguay - have their own
  highly unlikely to compete directly with Australian beef in
                                                                                                                       characteristics, from beef quality and price to political
  high end markets, or as manufacturing beef in the US, it
                                                                                                                       relations with major importers. Additionally, each are
  could increasingly provide an affordable alternative protein
                                                                                                                       also continuing to grow strongly in terms of their market
  in countries such as Indonesia, as well as Vietnam and
                                                                                                                       sophistication, as well as the quality of their product.
  Malaysia, three of its biggest current markets.
                                                                                                                       In the longer term, the competition from South American
                                 Top 4 Beef Exporters: Exports vs Production                                           exporters shows every sign of continuing to strengthen. The
                               3,000                                                                                   inflow of global investment money to the supply chains,
                                                                                                                       from production to processing to infrastructure, and the
Beef Exports ('000 MT cwe)

                               2,500
                                                                                                                       consolidation and growth of major farms in the main cattle
                               2,000                                                                                   production regions will only see this grow further.
                               1,500
                                                                                                                       Outside of these major competitors, the Australian beef
                               1,000                                                                                   industry will continue to be aware of the fortunes of other
                                 500                                                                                   reasonable sized beef exporters, and where they may
                                                                                                                       compete in the same markets. While Canada is currently
                                  -
                                          -   2,000       4,000     6,000      8,000   10,000        12,000   14,000   the world’s seventh largest beef exporter, around 70
                                                          Beef Production ('000 MT cwe)                                percent of its product ends up in the US. New Zealand
                                               Brazil      Australia         United States           India             will also continue to provide some competition in the
                    Source: USDA PSD, ANZ                                                                              China and US markets, although the impact of incoming
                                                                                                                       environmental regulations on its beef production and
                                 Next 6 Beef Exporter: Exports vs Productions                                          export volumes remains to be seen.
  Beef Exports ('000 MT cwe)

                               3,000                                                                                   Looking Ahead
                               2,500                                                                                   With Australian cattle prices having continued to hit record
                               2,000                                                                                   levels in the first few months of 2021, market observers will
                               1,500                                                                                   continue to speculate about where the market will head,
                               1,000                                                                                   not just over coming months but years. Given that few
                                 500                                                                                   observers would have forecast the current situation a year
                                      -                                                                                ago, it’s unsurprising that forecasts will differ widely.
                                          -             1,000               2,000            3,000            4,000
                                                        Beef Production ('000 MT cwe)                                  While this paper makes no claims to be able to look
                                                                                                                       into the future, we have constructed a model aimed at
                                              Argentina           New Zealand          Canada
                                                                                                                       identifying the variables which, when combined, may have
                                              Uruguay             Paraguay             Mexico
                                                                                                                       the strongest impact on the direction of cattle prices, and
                   Source: USDA PSD, ANZ
                                                                                                                       as a result, be able to provide some slight guide on where
  While the short term challenge may not be immense, in                                                                they may head in future.
  the longer term, the consumption of Indian beef could                                                                Our pricing model utilised three variables (female cattle
  potentially start to impact the live cattle trade to Indonesia.                                                      slaughter ratio (FCSR), Australian and USA cattle herd
  Many Indonesian consumers currently base their beef                                                                  ratio and the AUD/USD exchange rate) in seeking to
  buying habits on the lack of a sophisticated cold storage                                                            understand changes in EYCI annual average between 1971
  supply chain. As this gradually develops, consumers may                                                              and 2020. While there are certainly other variables which
  move away from the wet markets, to retail beef options.                                                              impact the EYCI, these three variables were used due to the
  When this happens, Australian product may remain                                                                     sophisticated forecasts available.
  expensive compared to other options that are more
  budget friendly.
As the chart shows, while there has been some deviation                           THE CONSUMER
at times, the predictions from the forecast have relatively
                                                                                  While much of the analysis of the beef supply chain
closely reflected the actual price.
                                                                                  can focus on the production aspect, it is ultimately the
                                                                                  consumer who will have the final say in much of the
EASTERN YOUNG CATTLE INDICATOR PRICE                                              direction of the beef industry. In terms of per capita
FORECASTING MODEL                                                                 animal protein consumption, the average Australian diet
      1,200                                                                       has barely changed over the last fifty years, remaining at
                                                                                  around 100kg per year. What has changed markedly has
      1,000
                                                                                  been the composition of the different meats which make
              800                                                                 up that diet. From making up around two thirds of the
                                                                                  average Australian meat diet fifty years ago, the proportion
EYCI (c/kg)

              600
                                                                                  of beef consumed has plummeted, now making up around
              400                                                                 only twenty percent. For twenty years Australians have
                                                                                  eaten more chicken than beef, for the past seven years
              200
                                                                                  they have eaten more pork.
               -
                    2021F
                    2022F
                                                                                  While these figures are not catastrophic, they do
                    2023F
                    2024F
                     1997
                     1998
                     1999
                     2000
                     2001
                     2002
                     2003
                     2004
                     2005
                     2006
                     2007
                     2008
                     2009
                     2010
                     2011
                     2012
                     2013
                     2014
                     2015
                     2016
                     2017
                     2018
                     2019
                     2020

                                                                                  emphasise the need for the beef industry to continue
                    52 Week High - Low Range    EYCI (Actual)   EYCI (Predict)
                                                                                  campaigns to push the benefits of beef to consumers. This
                                                                                  is especially so, given that the challenge now is not just
               Source: MLA, ABARES, BOM, USDA, ERS, ANZ
               Source: MLA, ABARES, BOM, USDA, ERS, ANZ                           from other animal proteins, but from the steady growth in
                                                                                  plant based proteins.
Using these variables, the model comes up with quite an
interesting result. Rather than prices beginning to decline
                                                                                                                  Australian Domestic Consumption vs Retail Price
later in 2021 as restocking eases (which is the view of most
                                                                                                                  3,000
observers – including the authors of this report), the model
forecasts prices to stay around the 1,000 c/kg mark for the                                                       2,500
next two years, before returning to the high 900s by 2024.                                                                        2019 - 20
                                                                                 Retail price (real, Ac per kg)

Accepting that the average standard deviation of error                                                            2,000
(predict vs actual) averaged 17 percent in the historical                                                                                     2014 - 15
data, this could mean prices heading back to the mid 800s.                                                        1,500                               2009 - 10
                                                                                                                                                  2004 - 05
While we make no strong claims to the accuracy of these                                                           1,000           1994 - 95         1999 - 00
forecasts, it does importantly raise the question of how                                                                              1989 - 90
the industry would operate in the longer term if prices did                                                        500
                                                                                                                                       19841979
                                                                                                                                            - 85 - 80
indeed remain around current levels, or even higher.
                                                                                                                                                            1974 - 75
                                                                                                                      -
Some of the implications could include:                                                                          600  400700500 800       900                           1,000   1,100
•	An increasing number of re-stockers finding difficulty in                                                    Domestic Consumption (kt cw)
                                                                                        Source: ABARES, MLA, RBA, ANZ
   accessing affordable cattle
•	Strong returns, potentially for larger operators, able to                      One interesting discussion point in this is whether the record
   strategically offload stock                                                    cost of cattle could translate into noticeably high beef prices
•	Tighter feedlot economics, potentially enhancing the                           on the retail shelves, and the impact this could have on
   need to lock in ample feed supplies                                            consumer behaviour. To examine that possibility, this report
                                                                                  modelled the correlations between the retail price of beef
•	Challenging processor margins, possibly leading to                             and the average level of domestic consumption. Interestingly,
   further capacity reductions                                                    the model found the impact of price on consumption rates
•	Increased retail beef prices and possible consumer                             was actually declining. With consumption continuing to fall,
   reaction.                                                                      this would indicate a more structural change in Australian
While these scenarios are all speculation, it is worth                            diets, such as developing a preference for other meats,
considering that many across the supply chain are basing                          or basing their diets on their perceptions of the health
their outlook on prices easing, and while this may well turn                      implications of other foods versus beef.
out to be the case, it could also be prudent to prepare for                       On top of the declining per capita consumption, this trend
the opposite.                                                                     again emphasises the need for the industry to maintain
                                                                                  strong and positive marketing campaigns around beef to
                                                                                  Australian consumers.
CONTACTS

              MICHAEL WHITEHEAD                                                               VIVEKA MANIKONDA

              Head of Agribusiness                                                            Senior Associate, Institutional
              Insights, Institutional                                                         Client Insights & Solutions
              T: +61 3 8655 6687                                                              T: +91 8067 953 036
              E: michael.whitehead@anz.com                                                    E: vivekasri.manikonda@anz.com

              DISCLAIMER
              The distribution of this document or streaming of this video broadcast (as applicable, ‘publication’) may be restricted by law in certain
              jurisdictions.
              Persons who receive this publication must inform themselves about and observe all relevant restrictions.
              1.	Disclaimer for all jurisdictions, where content is authored by ANZ Research: Except if otherwise specified in section 2 below, this publication
                  is issued and distributed in your country/region by Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (ABN 11 005 357 522) (‘ANZ’), on
                  the basis that it is only for the information of the specified recipient or permitted user of the relevant website (collectively, ‘recipient’). This
                  publication may not be reproduced, distributed or published by any recipient for any purpose. It is general information and has been
                  prepared without taking into account the objectives, financial situation or needs of any person. Nothing in this publication is intended
                  to be an offer to sell, or a solicitation of an offer to buy, any product, instrument or investment, to effect any transaction or to conclude
                  any legal act of any kind. If, despite the foregoing, any services or products referred to in this publication are deemed to be offered in the
                  jurisdiction in which this publication is received or accessed, no such service or product is intended for nor available to persons resident in
                  that jurisdiction if it would be contradictory to local law or regulation. Such local laws, regulations and other limitations always apply with
                  non-exclusive jurisdiction of local courts. Before making an investment decision, recipients should seek independent financial, legal, tax
                  and other relevant advice having regard to their particular circumstances.
              	The views and recommendations expressed in this publication are the author’s. They are based on information known by the author and
                  on sources which the author believes to be reliable, but may involve material elements of subjective judgement and analysis. Unless
                  specifically stated otherwise: they are current on the date of this publication and are subject to change without notice; and, all price
                  information is indicative only. Any of the views and recommendations which comprise estimates, forecasts or other projections, are subject
                  to significant uncertainties and contingencies that cannot reasonably be anticipated. On this basis, such views and recommendations may
                  not always be achieved or prove to be correct. Indications of past performance in this publication will not necessarily be repeated in the
                  future. No representation is being made that any investment will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those achieved in the past,
                  or that significant losses will be avoided.
              	Additionally, this publication may contain ‘forward looking statements’. Actual events or results or actual performance may differ materially
                  from those reflected or contemplated in such forward looking statements. All investments entail a risk and may result in both profits and
                  losses. Foreign currency rates of exchange may adversely affect the value, price or income of any products or services described in this
                  publication. The products and services described in this publication are not suitable for all investors, and transacting in these products or
                  services may be considered risky. ANZ and its related bodies corporate and affiliates, and the officers, employees, contractors and agents of
                  each of them (including the author) (‘Affiliates’), do not make any representation as to the accuracy, completeness or currency of the views
                  or recommendations expressed in this publication. Neither ANZ nor its Affiliates accept any responsibility to inform you of any matter that
                  subsequently comes to their notice, which may affect the accuracy, completeness or currency of the information in this publication.
              	Except as required by law, and only to the extent so required: neither ANZ nor its Affiliates warrant or guarantee the performance of any
                  of the products or services described in this publication or any return on any associated investment; and, ANZ and its Affiliates expressly
                  disclaim any responsibility and shall not be liable for any loss, damage, claim, liability, proceedings, cost or expense (‘Liability’) arising
                  directly or indirectly and whether in tort (including negligence), contract, equity or otherwise out of or in connection with this publication.
              	If this publication has been distributed by electronic transmission, such as e-mail, then such transmission cannot be guaranteed to be
                  secure or error-free as information could be intercepted, corrupted, lost, destroyed, arrive late or incomplete, or contain viruses. ANZ and its
                  Affiliates do not accept any Liability as a result of electronic transmission of this publication.
              	ANZ and its Affiliates may have an interest in the subject matter of this publication as follows:
                  •	They may receive fees from customers for dealing in the products or services described in this publication, and their staff and
                       introducers of business may share in such fees or receive a bonus that may be influenced by total sales.
                  •	They or their customers may have or have had interests or long or short positions in the products or services described in this
                       publication, and may at any time make purchases and/or sales in them as principal or agent.
                  •	They may act or have acted as market-maker in products described in this publication.
              	ANZ and its Affiliates may rely on information barriers and other arrangements to control the flow of information contained in one or more
                  business areas within ANZ or within its Affiliates into other business areas of ANZ or of its Affiliates.
              	Please contact your ANZ point of contact with any questions about this publication including for further information on these disclosures
                  of interest.
              2.	Country/region specific information:
              	Australia. This publication is distributed in Australia by ANZ. ANZ holds an Australian Financial Services licence no. 234527. A copy of ANZ’s
                  Financial Services Guide is available at http://www.anz.com/documents/AU/aboutANZ/FinancialServicesGuide.pdf and is available upon
                  request from your ANZ point of contact. If trading strategies or recommendations are included in this publication, they are solely for the
                  information of ‘wholesale clients’ (as defined in section 761G of the Corporations Act 2001 Cth). Persons who receive this publication must
                  inform themselves about and observe all relevant restrictions

anz.com
Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited (ANZ) ABN 11 005 357 522. Item No. 958404 05.2021 WZ105536
You can also read