INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...

Page created by Ivan Norton
 
CONTINUE READING
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
INVESTING
IN GREEN
RESILIENCE
World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund
Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016
Korean Stone Art Museum and Four Seasons Hotel
Seoul, Republic of Korea
June 2–3, 2016
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
WELCOME TO
                KOREA
                GREEN
                INNOVATION
                DAYS 2016

B   KGID 2016
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
What Is
Korea Green
Growth
Trust Fund?

The Republic of Korea (RoK) and the World Bank Group
(WBG) established the Korea Green Growth Trust Fund
(KGGTF) in September 2011 to support client countries shift to
a green development path. Both partners shared a common
goal to support countries as they reduce poverty and promote
shared economic prosperity in an environmentally responsible
and socially inclusive way.

KGGTF finances and facilitates the sharing of Green Growth
technical know-how in an effort to support WBG, International
Finance Corporation (IFC), and client country project design
and investment. KGGTF’s emphasis is on implementing
economic pathways and solutions that integrate multi-
sector needs, technological innovation, social inclusion, and
Green Growth approaches. KGGTF leverages the real-world
experience of policy makers and Green Growth technical
practitioners to promote integrated Green Growth concepts
into investment decisions.

2   KGID 2016
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
Based on strong performance, as well as increasing demand
                for collaborative development implementation programs, our
                fund was replenished at the end of 2015 and today has grown
                from US$40 million to a US$88 million World Bank Group
                program through 2021.

                                                  1.
                                                  Fund, manage, coordinate, and monitor
                                                  KGGTF-funded programs, and

                  WHAT WE DO:

                                                  2.
                                                  Aggregate, facilitate, and leverage
                                                  Green Growth knowledge and learning,
                                                  institutionalizing global knowledge
                                                  sharing to promote sustainable
                                                  economic development.

4   KGID 2016                                                                   KGID 2016   5
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
LIVE     What Is
         KGID 2016
GREEN    All About?

GROWTH
         Have you been asked “what is Green Growth?
         Well, you’ll find all of the answers at KGID 2016 Seoul,
         where we will begin to discuss, share, and demonstrate
         possible Green Growth pathways and programs.

         Korea Green Innovation Days (KGID) is the WBG’s flagship Green Growth
         knowledge-sharing event, organized and funded by the Korea Green Growth Trust
         Fund (KGGTF). KGID 2016 is our 3rd annual event, which we are excited to be
         presenting in the Republic of Korea.

         The 3rd annual KGID 2016 is unique. We will share practical and tangible examples
         of multiple global partners working toward achieving sustainable development.
         A cadre of World Bank Group technical specialists, global decision makers from
         thirteen countries, RoK officials, Korean experts and practitioners in green growth
         and climate change will take part.

         We define Green Growth as a holistic innovative approach to achieve sustainable
         development and address climate change issues. Moreover, Green Growth leverages
         technical and multi-faceted perspectives to drive smarter future growth.

                                                                                    KGID 2016   7
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
Share
                                                                                         614 83.6

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         BILLION
Information
and
                                                                                         Did you know Korea has built more than 600                                             Did you know from 2009 to 2013 Korea spent USD 83.6
                                                                                         new towns and industrial zones since the 1960?                                         billion (2% of GDP annually) on Green Growth projects?

Experience
                                                                                           700,000             700,000 skilled workers were involved in Korea’s Cheonggye-cheon restoration project in the span of two and a half years

                                                                                         650 42.5
Reflections from the 2nd KGID (2015 in Seoul) and 1st KGID (2014 in DC) Events

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         BILLION
KGID 2016 builds on the success of the inaugural KGID 2014 event and the KGID
2015 experience, in which experts and practitioners presented Green Growth
implementation lessons from Korea and the WBG to about 650 WBG staff, their
clients, and external participants. These events covered policy, technology, and                                                                    KGID
                                                                                         Did you know 650 people attended the KGID 2014                                      Did you know the World Bank approved 42.5billion USD in
financing angles, as well as technical exchange on specific sectors (urban, transport,   flagship event in Washington D.C. and the KGID 2015                                 fiscal year FY15
                                                                                         in Seoul?
ICT, environment, water, energy, macro-economy, industry, and climate change). The

                                                                                         80
events significantly raised awareness and dialogue among participants and Green
Growth policy makers.

What We Hope You Will Gain from the KGID 2016 Event
Many presentations and discussions will take place that will expose you to new
                                                                                         As of 2015, the KGGTF has 80
information and experiences. Your participation, feedback, and ideas are critical.       Green Growth implementation
                                                                                         programs worldwide.
Below are just some of the possible take-aways:

1 LEARNING
      Learn how other countries, Korea, and WBG are sharing Green Growth
      technical knowledge globally. Learn about climate smart and green
      technologies, policies, and methods from other countries that may support

                                                                                         41 25 4.8
      your sustainable development growth plans and actions.

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                         BILLION
                                                                                                                                                                   MILLION
                                                                                                                      MILLION
2 MEET YOUR GLOBAL COLLEAGUES
      Make new contacts that can immediately help you better implement Green
      Growth and climate smart actions. Build a community and continue the
      dialogue on green innovation and implementation, post-KGID.                        The KGGTF has allocated USD 41            And has disbursed USD 25 million                               It has also supported WBG lending
                                                                                         million (from 2011 to 2016) for Green     from 2011–2016.                                                operations linked to USD 4.8 billion
                                                                                         Growth implementation programs.                                                                          from 2011–1016.

8   KGID 2016
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
Sessions
                                                                                                       4
                                                                                                       Green Growth in the
                                                                                                       Present—It’s Never Too
            Start                                                                                      Late to Start                                                                                                                                                               Finish
                                                                                                                                                           7
                                                         3                                                                                                 Can We Anticipate Green Growth
                                                         Keynote Session: From                                                                             From the Start…. YES WE Can
                                                         Shared Green Growth                                                                               (Green)!
                                                         Concepts to Investment
                                                                                                                                                                                                               8
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Green Growth in the
                                                         Decisions—The World Bank
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Future, Ensuring a
                                                         Group and Republic of
      1                                                  Korea Greening Long-Term
                                                                                                        5                                                                                                      Sustainable Resilient
      JUNE 2                                                                                            A Focus on Green Growth                                                                                Future                                                       Concluding Remarks
                                                         Infrastructure Programs
      World Bank Group Korea                                                                            Through Energy
                                                         Together
      Green Growth Trust Fund
      2021 Replenishment
      Ceremony

                                      2
                                      JUNE 3                                                                                                                                                                     9
                                      World Bank Group Korea Green                                                      6                                                                                        Green Growth implementation:
                                      Growth Trust Fund 3rd Annual                                                      Green Growth Can Lead to                                                                 Lessons Learned, Scale Matters
                                      Korea Green Innovation Days 2016                                                  Opportunities for Change                                                                 for Success

                                               Opening Session
                                               World Bank Group’s Role in
                                               Promoting Green Investments

Session Summary                   3 9:40–10:40 AM                         technologies, or political priorities,   discusses various starting points
                                                                                                                                                         6 12:10–1:00 PM                        worlds and economies. Speakers          In this session the KGGTF           1. When designing Green Growth
                                                                          also challenge decision-makers.          and green investment pathways.                                               will share how as they develop new     activities highlight approaches to   programs, scale matters. The
                                  Governments invest billions of                                                                                         This panel session highlights the
JUNE 2                            dollars annually in infrastructure
                                                                          In other words, the realities of
                                                                                                                   This session highlights WBG           importance of knowledge-sharing
                                                                                                                                                                                                lives through new cities, Green        variable factors such as climate     KGGTF portfolio includes global,
                                                                          a limited understanding of the                                                                                        Growth thinking is influencing         effects, new economic growth.        regional, national, and municipal
1 5:00–9:30 PM                    projects in energy, water,
                                                                          world, along with a complex
                                                                                                                   and KGGTF engagement                  and capacity-building for Green
                                                                                                                                                                                                design and implementation.             So the focus of these KGGTF          activities. In this panel discussion,
                                  transport, and other sectors. This is                                            with clients who are leading          Growth. Panelists will discuss their
WBG KGGTF 2021                                                            political economy, challenge good                                                                                                                            programs is on opportunities for     speakers will share how they
                                  particularly true in the Republic of                                             innovative solutions to sustainable   efforts and the challenges they
REPLENISHMENT CEREMONY
                                  Korea as it implements its national
                                                                          decision-making.
                                                                                                                   development challenges, including     have run into absorbing, digesting,
                                                                                                                                                                                                8 3:25–4:40 PM                         jobs, innovation, and growth. They   designed their programs and how
By Invitation                                                                                                                                                                                   This is third of three sessions        showcase Green Growth policy,        they are progressing.
                                  Green Growth policy. These              This session highlights the              the use of energy and industrial      adapting, and applying lessons
Venue: Korean Stone Art Museum                                                                                                                                                                  in KGID 2016 that frames the           technology, and action.
                                  investments are critical, long-         important progress made possible         Green Growth opportunities, and       learned from other countries and                                                                                   2. Working across silos and scales
                                                                                                                                                                                                achievements and findings
                                  term, and will shape the course of      by the KGGTF to address these            fostering green economic growth       KGGTF programs.                                                                                                    matters, too. As we learn about
                                  country growth and development.         challenges and foster long-term          action lens to current sustainable
                                                                                                                                                                                                from Green Growth action and           9 4:40–5:50 PM                       Korea’s success in taking action
JUNE 3                                                                                                                                                   7 2:10–3:10 PM                         discusses various starting points      This session looks at some
                                                                          Green Growth, or innovative              development challenges.                                                                                                                                  toward a Green Growth economy,
WBG KGGTF 3RD ANNUAL              Yet deep uncertainties about                                                                                                                                  and green investment pathways.         initial lessons from the first
                                                                          methods and robust decision –                                                  This is second of three sessions                                                                                   a salient point emerges: inter-
KGID 2016                         future conditions pose formidable                                                                                                                                                                    three years of WBG’s Green
                                  challenges to making near-term
                                                                          making approach that work well           5 11:40 AM–12:10 PM                   in KGID 2016 that frames the           This session highlights multi-                                              agency and inter-governmental
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Growth KGGTF grant activities
2 9:00–9:40 AM                    decisions that make long-term
                                                                          no matter what the future brings.        This session sheds a light on an      achievements and findings              sectorial approaches toward
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       in terms of policy, expenditure,
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            communication and collaboration
A focus on the impact and                                                                                          important sector that is central to   from Green Growth action and           green development, as well                                                  is critical for success.
                                  investment sense. Climate change                                                                                                                                                                     investment decision-making, use
innovative partnership that has
                                  is one such uncertainty, but it
                                                                          4 10:50–11:40 AM                         Green Growth: Energy. Presenters      discusses various starting points      the increased need to take an
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       of and adaptation of knowledge,
blossomed into the World Bank                                             This is first of three sessions          from multiple supporting and          and green investment pathways.         integrative approach that includes                                              5:50–6:00 PM
                                  does not act in isolation. Other                                                                                                                                                                     institutional capacity-building,
Group’s KGGTF success:                                                    in KGID 2016 that frames the             implementing green energy                                                    ICT, creativity, and a paradigm                                             What have we we learned from
                                  uncertainties, such as urban                                                                                           This session highlights WBG clients                                           and more. Key learnings include:
                                                                          achievements and findings                programs will share their viewpoint                                          shift to ensure green economic                                              KGID 2016? Where do we go from
                                  development, population growth,                                                                                        and teams that are using the benefit
                                                                          from Green Growth action and             on challenges and opportunities.                                             growth into the future.                                                     here? What are the key takeaways?
                                                                                                                                                         of hindsight as they plan new

10   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 KGID 2016       11
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
June 2                                                                                                      June 3
WORLD BANK GROUP KOREA GREEN GROWTH TRUST FUND                                                              WORLD BANK GROUP KOREA GREEN GROWTH TRUST FUND
2021 REPLENISHMENT CEREMONY (BY INVITATION)                                                                 3RD ANNUAL KOREA GREEN INNOVATION DAYS 2016
KOREAN STONE ART MUSEUM, SEOUL, REPUBLIC OF KOREA;                                                          FOUR SEASONS HOTEL, SEOUL, REPUBLIC OF KOREA;
THURSDAY, JUNE 2, 2016                                                                                      FRIDAY, JUNE 3, 2016
1                                                                                                           2

5:00 PM          Optional: Pre-event Opportunity for a Guided Tour of the Museum                            9:00 AM    Opening Session
                                                                                                                       MASTER OF CEREMONIES
6:00 PM          Registration at Museum Lobby                                                                          Jie Ae Sohn

6:30 PM          World Bank Group’s Korea Green Innovation Days (KGID) Official Opening                                • Welcome: Eun Joo Yi, KGGTF, Climate Change Group, WBG
                                                                                                                       • Opening remarks: WBG
                 MASTER OF CEREMONIES
                                                                                                                       • Keynote
                 Jie Ae Sohn
                 • KGGTF montage video
                                                                                                            9:25 AM    World Bank Group’s Role in Promoting Green Investments
                 • Welcoming remarks: Zoubida Kherous Allaoua, Senior Regional Advisor, WBG
                 • Welcome address: Hong Koo Lee, Former Prime Minister of Republic of Korea                           • Eun Joo Yi, KGGTF, Climate Change Group, WBG

6:50 PM          KGGTF Replenishment Ceremony                                                               9:40 AM    Keynote Session: From Shared Green Growth Concepts to Investment
                 • KGGTF, where we are today: Eun Joo Yi, KGGTF, Climate Change Group, WBG                  3          Decisions—The World Bank Group and Republic of Korea Greening Long-
                 • Keynote speech: Ministry of Strategy and Finance, Republic of Korea                                 Term Infrastructure Programs Together
                                                                                                                       MODERATOR AND PRESENTER
7:05 PM          Intermission                                                                                          • Julie Rozenberg, Economist, Sustainable Development Practice Group, WBG
                                                                                                                       PANELIST
7:15 PM          KGGTF Special Program: Technical Partner Appreciation                                                 • Kangsoo Kim, Director and Vice President of Department of Land and Infrastructure Policy, Korea
                 VENUE                                                                                                   Development Institute
                 The Rooftop Garden                                                                                    • Oh Jae hak, Vice President, Korea Transport Institute
                                                                                                                       • Shomik Raj Mehndiratta, Lead Urban Transport Specialist, Transport and ICT Group, WBG
                 PRESENTERS
                 Eiko Wataya and Inhye Bak, KGGTF, Climate Change Group, WBG
                                                                                                            10:40 AM   Coffee Break
                 • Agim Kukaj, Head of ICT Department, Ministry of Economic Development:
                   ICT Innovative and Green Growth: Investing and Scoping in Kosovo (video)
                                                                                                            10:50 AM   Green Growth in the Present—It’s Never Too Late to Start
                 • Zhenia Viatchaninova Dalphond, ICT consultant, Transport and ICT Global Practice, WBG:
                   The Negawatt Challenge for Energy Efficiency in Africa (video)                           4          MODERATOR AND PRESENTER

                 • KGGP Partnership Awards                                                                             • Mihoon Jeong, Manager, Industrial Location and Environment Department,
                                                                                                                         Korea Industrial Complex Corp.

7:45 PM          Reception                                                                                             PRESENTERS AND PANELISTS
                                                                                                                       • Dalia Sakr, Operations Officer, Clean Energy & Resource Efficiency, IFC
9:30 PM          End of Event                                                                                          • Jaime Diaz, Advisor to the Executive Director, WBG

12   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                 KGID 2016   13
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
June 3                                                                                                                     June 3

11:40 AM         A Focus on Green Growth Through Energy                                                                    3:25 PM   Green Growth in the Future, Ensuring a Sustainable Resilient Future
5                MODERATOR AND PANELIST                                                                                    8         MODERATOR AND PRESENTER
                 Todd Johnson, Lead Energy Specialist, Energy and Extractives Group, WBG                                             • Jean Baptiste Migraine, Disaster Risk Management Specialist, Urban, Rural & Social Group, WBG
                 PANELISTS                                                                                                           PRESENTERS AND PANELISTS
                 • Ministry of Trade, Industry and Energy (MoTIE)                                                                    • François Zougmoré, Director of Materials and Environmental Laboratory (LAME) and Raincell partner,
                 • Janina Andrea Franco Salazar, Senior Energy Specialist, Energy and Extractives Group, WBG                           University of Ouagadougou, Burkina Faso
                 • Chilean Delegation                                                                                                • Cheick Fanta Mady Kone, Officer in the Civil Protection General Directorate, Mali
                                                                                                                                     • Dinkneh Tefera, Urban Development Specialist, Urban, Rural & Social Group, WBG
12:10 PM         Green Growth Can Lead to Opportunities for Change                                                                   • Mathewos Asfaw, General Manager and Chief Architect Planner in the Addis Ababa City Planning
                                                                                                                                       Project Office, Ethiopia
6                MODERATOR
                                                                                                                                     • Arnab Bandyopadhyay, Lead Transport Specialist, Transport and ICT Group, WBG
                 • Hyoung Gun Wang, Senior Economist, Urban, Rural & Social Group, WBG
                                                                                                                                     • Rajesh Bhushan, Joint Secretary, Ministry of Rural Development, Government of India
                 PANELISTS                                                                                                             Ministry Science ICT and Future Planning
                 •   Mansha Chen, Urban Specialist, Urban, Rural & Social Group, WBG
                                                                                                                                     Moderated Discussion
                 •   Pyush Dogra, Senior Environmental Specialist, Environment Group, WBG
                 •   Shrikan Baldi, Additional Chief Secretary (Finance), Government of Himachal Pradesh, Shimala, India
                 •   Taesun Shin, General Manager at the Business Planning & Coordination Department, K-water Corp         4:40 PM   Green Growth Implementation: Lessons Learned, Scale Matters for Success
                 Moderated Discussion
                                                                                                                           9         PRESENTER AND MODERATOR
                                                                                                                                     • Carter J. Brandon, Lead Economist, Environment Group, WBG
                                                                                                                                     • Andreas Kopp, Lead Transport Economist, Transport and ICT Group, WBG
1:00 PM          Lunch
                                                                                                                                     PANELISTS

2:10 PM          Can We Anticipate Green Growth From the Start…. YES WE Can (Green)!                                                 • Todd Johnson, Lead Energy Specialist, Energy and Extractives Group, WBG
                                                                                                                                     • Kyu Hong Hwang, Research Fellow, Urban Regeneration Research Department, Korea Land and
7                MODERATOR
                                                                                                                                       Housing Corporation
                 • Sang Joo Lee, Director of Overseas Construction & Development Cooperation, Ministry of Land,
                                                                                                                                     • Shashank Ojha, Senior E-Government Specialist, Transport and ICT Group, WBG
                   Infrastructure and Transport, Korea
                 PRESENTERS AND PANELISTS
                                                                                                                           5:50 PM   Concluding Remarks
                 • Kyu Hong Hwang, Research Fellow, Urban Regeneration Research Department,
                   Korea Land and Housing Corporation                                                                                • Eun Joo Yi, KGGTF, Climate Change Group, WBG
                 • Farouk Mollah Banna, Urban Specialist, Urban, Rural & Social Group, WBG
                 • Ibrahima Diagne, Director of the Coordination Unit of the National Solid Waste                          6:00 PM   End of the KGID 2016
                   Management Program, Senegal
                 • Janvier Murenzi, Vice Mayor in Charge of Economic Development, Rubavu District, Rwanda                  6:00 PM   Cocktails and Dinner
                 Moderated Discussion

3:10 PM          Coffee Break

14   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                               KGID 2016      15
INVESTING IN GREEN RESILIENCE - World Bank Group Korea Green Growth Trust Fund Third Annual Korea Green Innovation Days 2016 Korean Stone Art ...
SHARE
                       ICT INNOVATIVE AND GREEN                                      NEGAWATT CHALLENGE FOR
                       GROWTH FOR RURAL KOSOVO:                                      ENERGY EFFICIENCY
                       INVESTING & SCOPING

GREEN
                       COUNTRY: Kosovo                                               COUNTRY: Ghana, Kenya
                       REGION: ECA                                                   REGION: AFR
                       SCALE: National                                               SCALE: Regional
                       SECTOR: ICT                                                   SECTOR: ICT (Energy)
                       TECHNICAL AREAS: ICT, broadband, innovation, job creation     TECHNICAL AREAS: ICT, Energy Efficiency, innovation, job creation
                       GRANT AMOUNT: $485,000                                        GRANT AMOUNT: $500,000

GROWTH
                       PARTNERS: National IT Industry Promotion Agency of Korea,     PARTNERS: Accra and Nairobi city authorities; utilities and energy
                       European Commission                                           regulators in both countries; private sector, academia and research
                                                                                     institutions, tech innovation communities in both cities.
                       PROGRAM GOAL:
                       To serve as a model for programming of rollout of             PROGRAM GOAL:

                       broadband infrastructure in rural areas and its utilization   To pioneer an open innovation model for private
                       for green jobs and digital businesses                         and public sector engagement in the process of
                                                                                     identification of ICT-enabled energy efficiency
Program Descriptions   Government of Kosovo recognizes that broadband
                       connectivity enables green growth. KGGTF’s two-year
                                                                                     solutions for green growth

                       program aims to provide technical assistance to help          With rapid urbanization in Africa, public sector ability
                       Kosovo design a rural broadband program to give               to deliver high-quality services becomes increasingly
                       access to broadband Internet for everyone in selected         constrained. While a number of initiatives aim to
                       underserved areas. Moreover, its objective is to identify     expand access to energy, a significant emphasis should
                       pilot opportunities to save costs and increase revenues       be placed on the efficient use of existing resources.
                       by applying green ICT in rural areas in both the public       KGGTF’s two-year Negawatt Challenge initiative aims
                       and private sectors.                                          to highlight how digital technology solutions can
                                                                                     improve energy efficiency for fast-growing cities in
                                                                                     Ghana and Kenya. It does so through a competition
                                                                                     and a design-thinking methodology, which provide a
                                                                                     platform to engage local, national, and global problem-
                                                                                     solvers in identification of local energy challenges,
                                                                                     and build capacity of high-potential entrepreneurs to
                                                                                     adapt lean business models and develop innovative
                                                                                     software and hardware to respond to these challenges.
                                                                                     Another objective is to marry indigenous knowledge
                                                                                     with international know-how, such as the one exhibited
                                                                                     by South Korean technology companies and public
                                                                                     sector. After the successful kickoff of the initiative,
                                                                                     the Negawatt Challenge was successfully scaled up in
                                                                                     Tanzania and Brazil.

                                                                                                                                       KGID 2016     17
INFRASTRUCTURE                                                   CLEANER PRODUCTION                                           USING ICT TO INCREASE                                        OPERATIONALIZING
RESILIENCE AND ROBUST                                            FOR COMPANIES IN                                             GREEN COMPETITIVENESS                                        URBAN LAND MANAGEMENT
DECISION MAKING                                                  THE MIDDLE EAST AND                                          IN GUATEMALA                                                 TOOLS FOR GREEN, INCLUSIVE
                                                                 NORTH AFRICA                                                                                                              AND RESILIENT GROWTH

COUNTRY: N/A                                                     COUNTRY: Pakistan, Egypt                                     COUNTRY: Guatemala                                           COUNTRY: N/A
REGION: Global                                                   REGION: MNA                                                  REGION: LAC                                                  Region: Global
SCALE: Global                                                    SCALE: Regional                                              SCALE: National                                              SCALE: Global
SECTOR: Climate Change                                           SECTOR: Energy                                               SECTOR: ICT                                                  SECTOR: Urban
TECHNICAL AREAS: Climate resilience planning, policy decision-   TECH AREAS: Emergency infrastructure Program, energy         TECHNICAL AREAS: EIP, EE                                     TECHNICAL AREAS: Land readjustment, land value capture, Transit
making                                                           efficiency                                                   GRANT AMOUNT: $605,000                                       Oriented Development, flood risk management
GRANT AMOUNT: $1,150,000                                         GRANT AMOUNT: $304,000                                       PARTNERS: National Committee for Clean Production            GRANT AMOUNT: $500,000
                                                                 PARTNERS: National Productivity Organization, Cleaner        and PRONACOM (National Agency for the Promotion of           PARTNERS: SMG, Seoul Housing Corporation
PROGRAM GOAL:
                                                                 Production Institute                                         Competitiveness), KEA, KICOX
To investigate new decision-making methodologies                                                                                                                                           PROGRAM GOAL:
addressing climate change risks and uncertainties, and           PROGRAM GOAL:                                                PROGRAM GOAL:                                                To build and strengthen Green Growth strategic,
apply the methods in pilot projects                              To help Pakistan continue its natural resource efficiency    To stimulate small- and medium-sized enterprises             practical, and technical know-how to improve urban land
                                                                 efforts and their associated cost savings                    (SMEs) to adopt clean production protocols and               use planning, and contribute to resilient, participatory,
Robust Decision-Making (RDM) is a state-of-the-art
                                                                                                                              technologies, while improving SME competitiveness            and environmentally and socially inclusive urban growth
method for making sound investment and planning                  Industry in Pakistan is competing more and more
decisions in the face of uncertainties, such as climate,         with the country’s agricultural and power sectors            Supporting national programs to promote efficient
                                                                                                                                                                                           Urban populations are expected to double in developing
economic conditions, population, technology, and                 for limited water and energy resources. The country          industries, KGGTF’s two-year program in Guatemala
                                                                                                                                                                                           countries within a generation. Tools for green land
regulations. Used extensively in many countries—for              already faces a 5-gigawatt shortage and severe load          is providing technical assistance to implement the
                                                                                                                                                                                           management, including land readjustment, land-market
instance, in making water and energy investment                  shedding and blackout problems, causing factory              country’s energy policy. Program activities includes
                                                                                                                                                                                           assessment, and land-based financing can help create
decisions—RDM uses new analytical tools to help                  closures and unemployment. This KGGTF-funded Green           institutional capacity to develop strategies, policies and
                                                                                                                                                                                           sustainable, inclusive Green Growth, but are often costly
stakeholders understand investment options and                   Growth implementation program would help Pakistan            programs to stimulate Clean Production, promotion of
                                                                                                                                                                                           and inaccessible.
evaluate future scenarios. Pilot programs will test and          continue its natural resource efficiency efforts and their   clean production among productive sector that is being
                                                                 associated cost savings. The next phase of this ongoing      achieved through the support of a Voluntary Agreement        Many developing countries are eager to implement new
validate the decision-making tools for possible use in
                                                                 program would target, investigate, and plan for cleaner      on Clean Production between the government and the           approaches, markets, technologies, and values for green
appropriate KGGTF-supported investment programs.
                                                                 production technologies for textiles, sugar, pulp and        Association of the Chemical Industry (GREQUIM), and          economic growth. These new approaches can build
                                                                 paper, and leather. If resource-efficient technologies       Information generation and opportunity analysis for          and strengthen Green Growth strategic, practical, and
                                                                 can be put into play, manufacturers can become more          investments on clean production                              technical know-how to improve urban land use planning.
                                                                 resilient and better protect themselves and their                                                                         They can also contribute to resilient, participatory, and
                                                                 employees from closures, in addition to preparing for        .                                                            environmentally and socially inclusive urban growth.
                                                                 resource shifts expected with climate change.                                                                             This KGGTF program, through the Capacity Building
                                                                                                                                                                                           for Urban Green Growth Initiative, has developed a
                                                                                                                                                                                           series of e-learning programs that encourage city
                                                                                                                                                                                           leaders and practitioners to operationalize innovative
                                                                                                                                                                                           approaches. These programs provide specific entry
                                                                                                                                                                                           points and practical tools for facilitating Green Growth,
                                                                                                                                                                                           inclusiveness, and resilience and are designed to be
                                                                                                                                                                                           “living courses,” in which participants bring their own
                                                                                                                                                                                           problem statements and then jointly create solutions.
                                                                                                                                                                                           The Initiative also facilitates peer-to-peer learning
                                                                                                                                                                                           through knowledge exchange workshops and virtual
                                                                                                                                                                                           practitioner networks, and has developed customized
                                                                                                                                                                                           learning programs in China, Mexico, and India. The
                                                                                                                                                                                           initiative also makes technical assistance available to
                                                                                                                                                                                           Vietnam, so that the country can pilot land readjustment
                                                                                                                                                                                           approaches to redeveloping poor neighborhoods.

18 KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                                              KGID 2016 19
GREEN SMART CITY DEVELOPMENT                                                                                           DEVELOPMENT POLICY LOAN                                     IMPROVING SOLID WASTE
WITH CITIZEN PARTICIPATION                                                                                             TO PROMOTE INCLUSIVE GREEN                                  SERVICE DELIVERY
                                                                                                                       GROWTH AND SUSTAINABLE
                                                                                                                       DEVELOPMENT IN HIMACHAL PRADESH

COUNTRY: India, Tunisia                                     India’s capital, and a city of 19 million people. The      PROGRAM GOAL:                                               COUNTRY: N/A
REGION: Global                                              World Bank Group KGGFT-funded program provides             To create socially responsible and environmentally          REGION: AFR
SCALE: Global                                               examples for cities on how to overcome economic            sustainable economic opportunities from the region’s        SCALE: Municipal
SECTOR: Urban                                               growth obstacles. Using South Korean experiences from      rich natural resource base.                                 SECTOR: Urban
TECHNICAL AREAS: e-government, cadastre, Geographical       Seoul, a global leader in e-government, the KGGTF will                                                                 TECHNICAL AREAS: SWM
                                                                                                                       The mountain state of Himachal Pradesh, located in
Information System                                                                                                                                                                 GRANT AMOUNT: $600,000
                                                            create a case study to help Tunisia acquire data for its   Northern India, is rich in natural resources, serving as
GRANT AMOUNT: $800,000                                                                                                                                                             Partners: N/A
                                                            cadastre system. The program will also share knowledge     a critical, species-rich watershed for Northwest India.
PARTNERS: KRIHS, LH
                                                            on South Korean land management to Tunisia and other       Dense forests cover more than 27 percent of its land        PROGRAM GOAL:
PROGRAM GOAL:                                               developing countries. For Mumbai, KGGTF program            area, helping define the weather in much of Northern        To improve solid waste management in four Sub-
To develop a national master plan to enable Tunisian and    training workshops will demonstrate best practices         India and acting as a carbon sink for greenhouse gases      Saharan African cities
Mumbai authorities to access digital land information to    to government officials. The program will also study       (GHGs). The state government realizes the fragility
                                                                                                                                                                                   There are several obstacles to managing municipal
address urban challenges                                    establishment of a civil participation system (CPS) for    of this system and has developed ambitious and
                                                                                                                                                                                   solid waste in Sub-Saharan Africa, including a lack of
Cities face a number of challenges to green urban           Mumbai, including piloting CPS applications for the        innovative sustainable development goals that move
                                                                                                                                                                                   infrastructure, regulatory and legal challenges, rapid
development, including poor land cadaster systems           Mumbai Municipal Corporation, whereby citizens will be     away from the manufacturing-led growth and toward
                                                                                                                                                                                   urbanization, and a scarcity of financial resources.
(a comprehensive land ownership register), poor             able to submit information through mobile-phone-based      natural-resource-based sources of income, specifically
                                                                                                                                                                                   Uncollected and untreated waste in many of the region’s
public services and living environments, and high           surveys, hotlines, and user-generated maps. Applications   hydropower, tourism, and horticulture. This WBG project
                                                                                                                                                                                   cities impacts human health, especially for the poor
unemployment and poverty-related violence. These            will include community mapping for urban disaster risk     identified the environmental aspects of growth sectors
                                                                                                                                                                                   who live nearby, the environment, and local economies,
challenges call for innovative and tested urban             management. This Green Smart City program is part          that need the immediate attention of policymakers;
                                                                                                                                                                                   and it represents a serious impediment to inclusiveness
management solutions that promote shared prosperity         of a larger effort in partnership with the 72-member       redefined strategies, policies, and operational roles
                                                                                                                                                                                   and Green Growth. By improving municipal solid waste
and reach the poorest 40 percent of citizens in the         World e-Government Organization of Cities and Local        to address resource and environment challenges;
                                                                                                                                                                                   collection, cities can create opportunity and cultivate
world. Following on the heels of the World Bank’s           Governments, Seoul Metropolitan Government, and the        defined institutional and policy frameworks, revitalizing
                                                                                                                                                                                   resilience: Solid waste management can help keep
e-Government program on ICT for urban management,           Korea Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, and Transport.     capacity and skills and implementable action plans for
                                                                                                                                                                                   drainage channels open, thus reducing their vulnerability
this KGGTF program tackles city challenges. Among its                                                                  effective results; ensured maximum public participation
                                                                                                                                                                                   to the anticipated frequent and intense rainfall and sea
goals, the two-year program will pilot ICT innovations to                                                              in management of natural resources and protection
                                                                                                                                                                                   level rise that accompanies climate change. This KGGTF
help authorities address urban challenges in Mumbai,                                                                   of the environment; and promoted climate resilient
                                                                                                                                                                                   implementation program will foster Green Growth by
                                                                                                                       development and carbon neutrality. The project helped
                                                                                                                                                                                   identifying the solid waste investment needs of four
                                                                                                                       state of Himachal Pradesh to support in the improved
                                                                                                                                                                                   Sub-Saharan African cities and assuring that policy
                                                                                                                       management of its natural resources across growth
                                                                                                                                                                                   makers have direct access to implementable policy
                                                                                                                       engines of the economy and in turn helped to promote
                                                                                                                                                                                   recommendations, as well as support to improve solid
                                                                                                                       inclusive green growth and sustainable development.
                                                                                                                                                                                   waste management in their city.

20   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                               KGID 2016    21
ENHANCING GREEN                                               REAL TIME URBAN FLOOD RISK                                      AFFORDABLE AND RESILIENT                                      TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT                                          MANAGEMENT AND DECISION                                         HOUSING AND URBAN                                             PROMOTE INTEGRATED GREEN
IN SECONDARY CITIES                                           SUPPORT TOOL BASED UPON                                         LAND USE PLANNING                                             URBAN PLANNING IN ADDIS ABABA
IN RWANDA                                                     ANALYSIS OF ATTENUATION OF
                                                              CELLULAR PHONE NETWORK SIGNALS

COUNTRY: Rwanda                                               COUNTRY: Mali                                                   COUNTRY: Vanuatu                                              COUNTRY: Ethiopia
REGION: AFR                                                   REGION: AFR                                                     REGION: EAP                                                   REGION: AFR
SCALE: National                                               SCALE: Municipal                                                SCALE: National                                               SCALE: Municipal
SECTOR: Urban                                                 SECTOR: Urban                                                   SECTOR: Urban                                                 SECTOR: Transport
TECHNICAL AREAS: Urban development, local economic            TECHNICAL AREAS: Big data, mobile technology, open source       TECHNICAL AREAS: Affordable housing, land use planning, DRM   TECHNICAL AREAS: Integrated land use and transport
development, ICT                                              data, GIS                                                       GRANT AMOUNT: $675,000                                        GRANT AMOUNT: $1,100,000
GRANT AMOUNT: $650,000                                        GRANT AMOUNT: $495,000                                                                                                        PARTNERS: KRIHS, KOTI
                                                              Partners: Kyungpook National University, University of          PROGRAM GOAL:
PROGRAM GOAL:                                                 Ouagadougou, University of Bamako, Orange-Mali, Mali-Météo,     To establish the basis for increasing the availability of     PROGRAM GOAL:
To enable Rwanda to develop the Green Growth                  DNH, DGPC, INSS/CNRST Burkina Faso, Urban Local Government      affordable serviced land and housing, particularly for        To help Addis Ababa Urban Planning Institute revise and
economic potential of secondary cities                        Support Program, Sahel Disaster Resilience Program, Sahel
                                                                                                                              the poor, and reducing the risk of urban populations to       implement the city’s master transportation plan
                                                              Drought Response TA, Mainstreaming Disaster Reduction in Mali
The Rwandan government’s 2013 Economic                                                                                        natural hazards and climate change
                                                                                                                                                                                            With a population of 3 million, and growing 4 percent
Development and Poverty Reduction Strategy envisions          PROGRAM GOAL:
                                                                                                                              Vanuatu is a small island nation of 250,000 in the            a year, Addis Ababa faces rapid urbanization that
urbanization as a driver of growth. The KGGTF’s multi-        To reduce flood risk in Mali’s urban areas,
                                                                                                                              South Pacific and rated as the most vulnerable country        strains its infrastructure and services and poses serious
year program is providing technical assistance to make        particularly Bamako
                                                                                                                              in the world to natural disasters including cyclones,         challenges to the city’s development and its decade-
sure Rwanda meets its need for a network of secondary         Urban flood risk is increasing in African cities, often         earthquakes, and tsunamis. The government of Vanuatu          old master plan. This program is providing technical
towns to absorb rural migrants. The government expects        because of inadequate urban planning and building               sought support in both WBG technical assistance and           assistance to the city’s Urban Planning Institute (UPI)
the agricultural workforce to decrease to 50 percent by       codes, uncontrolled occupation of flood-prone                   lending for urban land management and housing,                to help revise and implement the master plan. The
2020, and then 30 percent by 2040. At the government’s        lowlands, and climate variability and change. Flood             particularly for the poor living in informal settlements      program supports an international conference that
request, the World Bank Group had assessed investment         risk in Bamako, Mali, is a typical. At the same time, the       that are particularly vulnerable to climate change            builds planners’ capacity by highlighting the experiences
priorities in six target cities. The KGGTF program will, in   availability of hydro-meteorological observing stations         impacts such as landslides and flooding. This program         of similar cities, and paying for local and international
part, support further investment prioritization.              has dropped dramatically all over Africa since the 1970s.       aims to establish the basis for increasing the availability   consultants to work on master plan revisions. Bringing
                                                              The problem is currently worsening in Mali because              of affordable serviced land and housing, particularly for     together the Addis Ababa and Seoul municipal
                                                              of security conditions. Setting innovative public-              the poor, and reducing the risk of urban populations to       administrations and the UPI and the Korean Research
                                                              private partnerships between National Meteorological            natural hazards and climate change.                           Institute for Human Settlements, this program also
                                                              and Hydrological Services, cell phone operators, civil                                                                        facilitates Korean Transport Institute training programs
                                                              protection services and food security institutions                                                                            on public bus systems. Trainings are on transport
                                                              would directly increase competitiveness with regards                                                                          strategies, and related issues for stakeholders, including
                                                              to (i) generation of data, information and services;                                                                          the Addis Ababa Transport Branch, Roads Authority,
                                                              (ii) data transmission and archiving; and (iii) service                                                                       Oromiya Roads Authority, and the Federal Ministry of
                                                              delivery to end users. Funding for this Green Growth                                                                          Transport. The program links to the World Bank Group
                                                              implementation program will be used to create real-                                                                           transport-sector support program and the urban local-
                                                              time, high-resolution rain maps based on cellular                                                                             government development program.
                                                              network signal attenuation. Such data can be used
                                                              to model rainfall runoff and flood risk. Eventually,
                                                              authorities will be able to issue response plans with
                                                              more lead-time and shift habitation patterns away from
                                                              flood-prone areas.

22   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                                           KGID 2016 23
TECHNICAL ASSISTANCE TO PROMOTE                                 PROMOTING THE USE OF GREEN                                  ICT APPLICATIONS                                                     TRAINING HUB
SOLID WASTE MANAGEMENT AND                                      CONSTRUCTION TECHNOLOGY IN                                  TO ACHIEVE                                                           “TRANSPORT FOR
URBAN GREENERY IN SELECTED                                      THE ROAD SECTOR                                             GREEN GROWTH                                                         GREEN GROWTH”
ETHIOPIAN SECONDARY CITIES

COUNTRY: Ethiopia                                               COUNTRY: India                                              COUNTRY: India                                                       COUNTRY: N/A
REGION: AFR                                                     REGION: SAR                                                 REGION: SAR                                                          REGION: Global
SCALE: Municipal                                                SCALE: National                                             SCALE: Municipal                                                     SCALE: Global
SECTOR: Urban                                                   SECTOR: Transport                                           SECTOR: ICT                                                          SECTOR: Transport
TECHNICAL AREAS: SWM, landfill operation                        TECHNICAL AREAS: Road material, construction technology     TECHNICAL AREAS: Smart city diagnostic toolkit                       TECHNICAL AREAS: Evaluation for growth and reduction of
GRANT AMOUNT: $400,000                                          GRANT AMOUNT: $500,000                                      GRANT AMOUNT: $1,700,000                                             external costs

PARTNERS: Ministry of Urban Development of Ethiopia, Bishoftu   PARTNERS: KICT                                              PARTNERS: Ministry of Science, ICT and Future Planning of Korea,     GRANT AMOUNT: $500,000
City Administration                                                                                                         Korea Institute of Energy Technology Evaluation Planning, National   PARTNERS: KOTI, other Multilateral Development Banks,
                                                                PROGRAM GOAL:                                               Information Society Agency of Korea, KEA, K-water, Korea Smart       technical staff of national transport agencies
PROGRAM GOAL:                                                   To share knowledge about options and innovative             Card Corporation
To make the recently completed landfill operational in                                                                                                                                           PROGRAM GOAL:
                                                                materials based on successful examples from Korea
                                                                                                                            PROGRAM GOAL:                                                        Integration of Green Growth objectives into
Bishoftu, Ethiopia, that will help the city remain resilient,   and other countries
                                                                                                                            To share knowledge for greening cities, improving                    project evaluation
competitive, and clean
                                                                India has been implementing a large road infrastructure     quality of life, and reaching the poorest people, while
The Government of Ethiopia (GoE) has identified the                                                                                                                                              The program will use a new methodology to count the
                                                                program since 2000. The KGGTF’s program promotes            optimizing energy use, reducing GHG emissions, and
management of solid waste as a national priority and                                                                                                                                             value of the reduction of GHG emissions, of reduced
                                                                the use of green construction technology in the road        helping cities apply cost-saving innovations.
is developing strategies and guidelines on integrated                                                                                                                                            health costs of local air pollution and the reduction of
                                                                sector and addresses an urgent need for sustainable         The ICT sector has proven to be a key in reducing carbon
solid waste management systems and urban greenery.                                                                                                                                               road safety risks as project value added.
                                                                construction practices. Traditional low-productivity        emissions from other sectors of the economy, such
This GoE initiative is being supported by the World Bank                                                                                                                                         It will go beyond classical (partial equilibrium)
                                                                construction technologies use a great deal of energy        as transport or power transmission and distribution.
through the Urban Local Government Development                                                                                                                                                   Cost Benefit Analysis in accounting for trade and
                                                                and emit a great deal of greenhouse gases. This             The objective of this project is to provide a preliminary
Project (ULGDPII). ULGDP is helping to strengthen the                                                                                                                                            agglomeration economies, the mechanisms through
                                                                program directly contributes to a road modernization        ICT assessment in the energy sectors of three Indian
capacity of urban local governments to plan, deliver,                                                                                                                                            which transport contributes to macroeconomic
                                                                project in Rajasthan that aims to bolster the local rural   cities in order to facilitate the formation of smart
operate and maintain priority municipal infrastructure                                                                                                                                           development. The training will focus on multiplicators
                                                                economy by improving transit connectivity in remote         communities and the introduction of smart technology.
and services including solid waste management. This                                                                                                                                              in international organizations and national agencies to
                                                                rural areas. Mineral-rich Rajasthan state will save money   Project partners, including Korean technical experts, will
program is to support undertaking assessments on the                                                                                                                                             implement transport projects that serve green growth.
                                                                and create local green jobs by building roads using its     recommend the best ICT solutions for implementing
status of solid waste management and urban greenery             large quantities of quarry waste, along with materials      a green-growth transformation toward smart city
in four secondary cities; review federal level strategy and     such as fly ash and low-cost concrete. The program is       implementation. For each city, detailed diagnosis have
service standard; conduct capacity building activities to       organizing a workshop for officials from the Ministry       been conducted across five predefined sectors – energy,
improve SWM.                                                    of Road Transport and Highways, India’s National            water, urban, transport, and ICT. Detailed project reports
                                                                Highway Authorities, National Rural Roads Development       help city authorities understand their current readiness
                                                                Authority, and Rajasthan’s Public Works Department.         and the key steps required to transform.
                                                                The program will then pilot a selection of green options
                                                                for at least 10 percent of roads that India’s national
                                                                program will build.

24   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    KGID 2016 25
LEARN
                  THE NEGAWATT                                              housing, energy, and water. Energy
                                                                            efficiency is one of the building
                  CHALLENGE         CONTEXT                                 blocks of Green Growth. It is widely
                  FOR ENERGY        African economies lose 2.1 percent      recognized as one of the most
                                    of their GDP as a result of power       effective ways to combat climate
                  EFFICIENCY IN

GREEN
                                    shortages annually.                     change while meeting rising energy
                  AFRICA            With their metropolitan areas
                                                                            demand; it holds particularly
                                                                            great promise for rapidly growing
                                    becoming some of the fastest
                                                                            urban centers. Countries such as
                  SECTOR:           growing urban hubs in Africa,
                  ENERGY                                                    Ghana and Kenya seek to reduce
                                    Ghana and Kenya are facing a

GROWTH
                                                                            urban energy use through the
                                    critical energy challenge. Rapid
                  SCALE:                                                    use of innovative information and
                                    urbanization strains existing
                  REGIONAL                                                  communication technology (ICT)
                                    infrastructure and natural resources,
                                                                            that can improve energy efficiency
                  COUNTRIES:        while also putting increasing
                                                                            by monitoring consumer behavior
                  GHANA AND KENYA   pressure on municipalities to
                                                                            and prompting its positive change.
                                    deliver public services and
                                    support economic growth and

Feature Stories                     competitiveness. In the Ghanaian
                                    capital of Accra, for example, air      SOLUTIONS
                                    quality is deteriorating at the same    The Negawatt Challenge builds
                                    pace that traffic congestion is         engagement and collaboration
                                    increasing, and energy black outs       between technology and energy
                                    are increasingly common.                communities in Ghana and
                                                                            Kenya through a design-thinking
                                                                            workshop, a series of meet-ups,
                                    CHALLENGES AND                          an ideathon competition, a
                                    OPPORTUNITIES FOR GREEN                 boot camp, and a business
                                    ECONOMIC GROWTH                         acceleration program.

                                    Green Growth offers                     This KGGTF-funded Green Growth
                                    competitive advantages and              program developed a design-
                                    opportunities for economic              thinking methodology and hosted
                                    growth and employment.                  a well-structured challenge
                                                                            competition to engage various
                                    Green Growth strategies can help
                                                                            stakeholders in the identification of
                                    economies become more resilient
                                                                            local challenges and build capacity
                                    as they work to meet demand
                                                                            of high-potential entrepreneurs
                                    for food production, transport,

                                    “The Negawatt is all about empowering entrepreneurs to
                                     contribute to achieving Sustainable Development Goals
                                     through energy efficiency measures. Rapidly urbanizing
                                     cities in developing countries have vibrant technology hubs
                                     that are home to incredible local talent. We want to channel
                                     this creativity toward innovation at the intersection of
                                     energy and ICT”.
                                    ANNA LERNER WORLD BANK ICT AND ENERGY SPECIALIST AND CO-TASK TEAM LEADER
                                     OF THE NEGAWATT CHALLENGE

                                                                                                  KGID 2016 27
“Energy efficiency can play a great role in saving energy in rapidly urbanizing
                                                                                                                 cities, on a household level and beyond. The Negawatt Challenge links
                                                                                                                 Accra to Nairobi in the quest to address this common challenge, and aims
                                                                                                                  to contribute energy-efficient interventions by engaging local startup and
                                                                                                                  technology communities as entrepreneurial problem solvers. As experience in
                                                                                                                 other countries shows, technologists and entrepreneurs are capable of creating
                                                                                                                  lean, innovative, and inclusive approaches and tools to increase urban energy
                                                                                                                 efficiency for their own communities and others.”
                                                                                                                  CECILIA PARADI-GUILFORD WORLD BANK ICT INNOVATION SPECIALIST AND CO-TASK TEAM LEADER OF THE
                                                                                                                  NEGAWATT CHALLENGE

                                 to adapt lean business models           technologies. To help source            energy solutions, particularly          ideas. It supported eight startup     policymakers, organizations, and
                                 and develop innovative products,        valuable data sets and publish them     to address the development              teams through a boot camp and         entrepreneurs in an engaging, user-
                                 leveraging technology to respond to     as ‘open data,’ a public sector group   bottlenecks of their communities.       accelerated five startups over the    centric approach. It is also a vehicle
                                 these challenges.                       or local organization is encouraged     These innovators are business           summer of 2015. Software and          to establish mutually beneficial
                                                                         to carry out an open energy data        school students, computer science       hardware solutions emerged that       linkages between the RoK’s public
                                 The methodology and the
                                                                         readiness assessment, thus building     specialists, mechanical engineers,      leverage energy data analytics,       and private sectors and their peers
                                 competition revolve around six
                                                                         the foundations for the emergence       and social entrepreneurship             cloud computing, and mobile           in developing countries.
                                 iterative stages. First, stakeholders
                                                                         of data-driven solutions to the         fellows, among others. In Ghana         platforms. The virtual track
                                 are invited to a workshop to
                                                                         challenges.                             and Kenya, the majority of the          to the competition, occurring
                                 deliberate on their city’s most
                                                                                                                 Negawatt Weekend participants           simultaneously, generated 23
                                 pressing energy challenges.             The fourth stage in the process
                                                                                                                 were university students. For           proposals from 11 countries.
                                 Energy sector stakeholders from         is the Negawatt Weekend, an
                                                                                                                 many of them, this was their first
                                 the public and private sectors—         “ideathon” event that engages early
                                                                                                                 opportunity to publicly participate
                                 including local government and          startups to work on their selected
                                                                                                                 in the development of potential         KGGTF IN ACTION
                                 citizen-led organizations—get           challenge. Upon evaluation of the
                                                                                                                 solutions to their respective capital
                                 together, identify major sources        startups’ live pitches, judges select                                           In 2013, President Park Geun-
                                                                                                                 cities’ pressing energy challenges.
                                 of energy inefficiencies, and           teams to proceed to a boot camp,                                                hye of South Korea put forth her
                                 establish the necessary data sets       dedicated to business, design,          After an intensive boot camp,           signature vision to promote Green
                                 to aid participants in the innovation   technical, and marketing aspects        two teams are awarded a chance          Growth through a creative economy
                                 challenge. In parallel, creative and    of product development. As an           to enter a several-months-long          that calls for innovative business
                                 tech communities gather in a series     open innovation challenge, the          business acceleration program to        opportunities and more jobs
                                 of specialized community meet-          Negawatt taps into a vast pool          develop their business pitch decks      through the fusion of information
                                 ups to improve their knowledge of       of innovators, many who may             and further refine their solutions’     technology, culture, and industry.
                                 energy efficiency, green growth,        not otherwise have traditionally        prototypes. Finally, the Demo Day       This KGGTF-funded program aims
                                 and various applications of ICT         engaged in developing technical         event determines the ultimate           to leverage South Korean and
                                                                                                                 winner of the competition, who is       international expertise to support
                                                                                                                 then encouraged to launch their         a nascent startup ecosystem in
                 “It’s a very interesting and educational program in the sense that it brings                    solution to market (or test it in       developing countries, with an
                 together a number of stakeholders—private sector, public sector, and                            prototype mode).                        objective of raising awareness
                                                                                                                                                         and understanding of the concept      Images
                 academia—to share ideas and see that responsibility for energy efficiency is
                                                                                                                 In Accra and Nairobi, the Negawatt      of Green Growth. The Negawatt         http://www.negawattchallenge.com/
                 not one person’s job.”                                                                          engaged over 150 participants                                                 media/
                                                                                                                                                         Challenge is a good example how
                 LYDIA E. A. SACKEY-ADDY DIRECTOR OF BUDGET AND RATING OF THE ACCRA METROPOLITAN ASSEMBLY        during the Negawatt Weekend,            this Green Growth vision could be     Photo credit: @iBizAfrica-Strathmore
                 AND LEAD GOVERNMENT COUNTERPART FOR NEGAWATT CHALLENGE IN GHANA.                                sourcing around 30 original             effectively mainstreamed to senior    University

28   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                                                        KGID 2016    29
INNOVATIVE                                                                                                                               broadband, increase resilience of
                                                                                                                                         ICT system use, and decrease its
AND GREEN         PROGRAM CONTEXT                          PROGRAM SCOPE                           DESIRED IMPACT                        environmental footprint.
                  AND ISSUES
GROWTH                                                     The KGGTF’s two-year program            Broadband Internet deployment
                                                                                                                                         This proposed activity laid the
                  Expanding broadband Internet             with Kosovo aims to increase            and demand-side activities, such
FOR RURAL         access in developing countries to        broadband internet access by            as targeted IT trainings, could
                                                                                                                                         groundwork for a public investment
                                                                                                                                         intervention to finance a rural
KOSOVO:           levels seen today in developed           producing guidelines and a              increase the interconnectedness of
                                                                                                                                         telecom infrastructure rollout in
                  economies can increase                   pilot program to design a rural         Kosovo and drive wider adoption
INVESTING         productivity, generating higher          broadband program.                      and use of ICT. After the broadband
                                                                                                                                         underserved areas, as well as the
                                                                                                                                         groundwork for financing pilot
AND SCOPING,      GDPs and creating more new jobs.         Improved access to high-speed           network is deployed, there will
                                                                                                                                         projects that will benefit from newly
                                                                                                   be additional opportunities to
KOSOVO            This in turn can help people out of      and affordable broadband Internet
                                                                                                   capitalize on the newly deployed
                                                                                                                                         deployed broadband connectivity.
                  poverty and into shared prosperity.      services in the underserved rural                                             This project was included in
                  It is also apparent that broadband       areas of Kosovo can serve as a          broadband connectivity by
SECTOR:                                                                                                                                  the National Economic reform
                  Internet exerts a positive impact on     platform for enabling innovation        developing smart infrastructure,
ICT                                                                                                                                      document as a key intervention for
                  fighting climate change by fueling       and Green Growth in the country.        specifically in the areas of smart
                                                                                                                                         the ICT sector. The World Bank and
SCALE:            innovative software and hardware                                                 energy and water supply. Kosovo
                                                                                                                                         Government of Kosovo have started
                                                           Under phase I, the activity delivered   can then become more competitive
NATIONAL          that increase efficiency.                                                                                              discussions regarding the future
                                                           feasibility studies to help the         in its economy, improve efficiency
                                                                                                                                         World Bank program in the country.
COUNTRY:          Kosovo could reap significant            Ministry of Economic Development        of system and process by use of
KOSOVO            economic, environmental, and             of Kosovo to design an inclusive
                  social benefits from the rollout         and high-impact rural broadband
                  of broadband connectivity in             program. Under phase II, it designed
                  underserved areas. Forty-three           and implemented an innovative
                  percent of rural households in           IT training pilot, called Women in
                  Kosovo are currently unconnected,        Online Work (WoW), to increase
                  and one-third of these households—       help 100 women residing in two
                  without an all-inclusive                 rural municipalities of Kosovo
                  intervention—are unlikely to be          engage in green, ICT-enabled jobs
                  connected to the network anytime         offered through a global online
                  soon. These households are located       work marketplace.
                  in municipalities with a higher
                  concentration of poor people.
                                                           KGGTF SUPPORT,
                  The Government of Kosovo
                                                           PARTNERSHIPS, AND
                  recognizes broadband connectivity
                                                           COORDINATION
                  as one of the enabling infrastructures
                  for Green Growth and the country’s       The WBG KGGTF program team
                  transition to a digital economy.         will reach out to technical South
                  It aims to expand the reach of           Korean public institutions such as
                  broadband Internet services in           the National IT Promotion Agency,
                  rural areas, where the private sector    and the Korea Communications
                  has no commercial incentives to          Commission, as well as international
                  expand network access. A proposed        donors operating in Kosovo,
                  solution is the implementation of a      including the European Commission,
                  rural broadband program modeled          KfW, Helvetas International
                  on a public-private partnership,         Cooperation, the Embassy of
                  because neither private nor public       Norway, GIZ, and others.
                  sector alone can finance such a
                  costly investment.

30    KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                  KGID 2016   31
INFRASTRUCTURE                                             acknowledge that this range is                                                     collaboration with South Korea’s
                                                           and will remain highly uncertain.                                                  National Emergency Management
RESILIENCE        PROGRAM CONTEXT                          For instance, it is possible to base       PROGRAM SCOPE                           Agency. Depending on the cases
                  AND ISSUES
AND ROBUST                                                 decisions on scenario analysis and         The objective of the program is to      selected and methodologies
                  When designing climate-sensitive         to choose the “most robust solution”       develop and support the piloting        developed, other partners include
DECISION MAKING   investments, the long-standing           (i.e. the one that is least sensitive to   of practical methodologies for          the Korea Research Institute
                  practice is to use historical            future climate conditions), instead of     decision-making under uncertainty       for Human Settlements, Korea
SECTOR:           weather and climate data.                looking for the “best” choice under        for projects in the urban, water, and   Environment Institute, and Korea
CLIMATE CHANGE                                             one scenario.                              transport sectors. This will help to    Water Resources Corporation.
                  Engineers use it in the design
                  of infrastructure and buildings;                                                    enable better integration of climate-
SCALE:                                                     But new methodologies need to
                  the insurance industry uses it to                                                   change risks into project design and
GLOBAL                                                     be developed. The robust decision-
                  calculate premiums and capital                                                      implementation, and ensure longer-      DESIRED IMPACT
                                                           making approach has been used in
                  needs, and farmers depend                                                           term investment optimization.
                                                           industrialized countries (especially                                               a. Improved efficiency: The
                  on it to choose crops and                                                           To this end, this KGGTF grant will
                                                           in the U.S.) and pilot projects are                                                new methods that this program
                  schedule plantings and harvests.                                                    support validating the applicability
                                                           running in Vietnam, Sri Lanka,                                                     promotes for investing in Green
                  National governments base their                                                     of these new decision-making
                                                           and Peru. But this methodology                                                     Growth under uncertainty are
                  assessments of energy security                                                      tools in the context of
                                                           is long and sometimes onerous to                                                   designed to include many different
                  requirements on such data.                                                          development interventions.
                                                           apply (i.e. approximately one year                                                 stakeholders’ perspectives and
                                                           of work, and about USD 400,000,            Pilot studies cover different           interests in the decision-making
                  With the projected changes in
                                                           for a single project). Applying this       regions, different income level,        process, and to use multiple
                  climate, however, historical data
                                                           method is impossible for small             and different types of projects         criteria to build investment plans.
                  is no longer fully applicable for
                                                           projects or municipalities and             (water supply and roads in Peru,        This ensures efficiency in the
                  planning, and, in fact, relying solely
                                                           locations with limited resources           urban flooding in Colombo, and          decision-making process and of
                  on it could result in unsustainable
                                                           and data.                                  hydropower in Nepal). These             projects themselves.
                  development programs and
                  investments. Two problems                                                           pilot projects include research to
                                                           There is thus a need to develop a                                                  b. Greater resilience: The ultimate
                  make it impossible to provide the                                                   design more simple methodologies
                                                           toolbox of decision-making tools                                                   goal of these new methodologies
                  equivalent of historical climate                                                    for smaller project, and more
                                                           appropriate for different contexts                                                 for decision-making under
                  data for future climates: There is a                                                comprehensive methodologies for
                                                           and projects, and to test and                                                      uncertainty is to design resilient
                  scale misfit between what can be                                                    larger infrastructure projects, as
                                                           validate them. There is also a                                                     investments—a key characteristic
                  provided by climate models and                                                      well as funding for the additional
                                                           need for a guidance on how to                                                      of Green Growth. The use of these
                  what is needed by decision-makers;                                                  analysis needed in project design
                                                           identify which methodology is                                                      tools, therefore, ensures that the
                  and there is much uncertainty                                                       to incorporate uncertainty
                                                           most appropriate in a given                                                        projects implemented are robust,
                  about future climate change,                                                        and create more resilience. The
                                                           context. For instance, a classical                                                 able to withstand whatever future
                  especially at a local scale.                                                        KGGTF chose these projects
                                                           cost-benefit analysis is perfectly fine                                            conditions may materialize.
                                                                                                      based on local demand to ensure
                                                           in some contexts; sometimes
                  Since climate models and                                                            ownership and participation.            c. Increased competitiveness:
                                                           a more complicated methodology
                  observations cannot provide                                                                                                 Robust planning in transport, water,
                                                           is required to take into account
                  what current decision-making                                                                                                and hydropower infrastructure is
                                                           additional uncertainty). This
                  frameworks need, the only solution                                                  KGGTF SUPPORT,                          necessary for economic growth.
                                                           WBG KGGTF-funded program
                  is to amend our frameworks to                                                       PARTNERSHIPS AND                        The application of these decision-
                                                           aims to provide new decision-
                  take this uncertainty into account.                                                 COORDINATION                            making tools for screening and
                                                           making methodologies and
                  To do so, infrastructure should be                                                                                          managing climate uncertainties
                                                           guidance and improve the                   The team works closely with
                  designed under the assumption                                                                                               and more can attract international
                                                           resilience and sustainability of           the World Bank-hosted Global
                  that it will need to cope with a                                                                                            concessional financing to the
                                                           infrastructure projects.                   Facility for Disaster Reduction
                  larger range of climate conditions                                                                                          private sector, which may in turn
                                                                                                      and Recovery, which already has a
                  than before, and planners should                                                                                            boost economic opportunities.
                                                                                                      strong partnership and history of

32   KGID 2016                                                                                                                                                                       KGID 2016   33
You can also read