Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65 - February 2012
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65 February 2012 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65 February 2012 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Introduction Healthcare spending and utilization patterns among the privately insured population are not widely understood, or widely available. With limited access to private sector data, health services researchers have relied on the analyses of publicly available data (predominately Medicare) to advance public policy recommendations.1 To effectively advance healthcare reform, IMS believes a deeper understanding IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics of the privately insured population is critical to successfully address cost growth 11 Waterview Boulevard trends, and ensure appropriate planning for this evolving population. Parsippany, NJ 07054 USA Using comprehensive, proprietary data consisting of more than 10 million info@theimsinstitute.org privately insured members under age 65, we were able to examine the www.theimsinstitute.org distinctions between IMS aggregated healthcare use and spending patterns and those commonly cited among health services researchers, including the Analysis and support from IMS Payer Solutions gratefully Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) and Centers for acknowledged in the development of this report. Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS). ©2012 IMS Health Incorporated and its affiliates. In this report, we highlight the differences, examine healthcare spending All reproduction rights, quotations, broadcasting, patterns among the privately insured under age 65 by considering spending publications reserved. No part of this publication may be on outpatient, inpatient and pharmacy, and discuss the potential implications. reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without express written consent of IMS Health and the IMS Murray L. Aitken Institute for Healthcare Informatics. Executive Director IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics FIND OUT MORE If you want to receive more reports from the IMS Institute, or be on our mailing list, please click here. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Contents Executive Summary ............................................................... 1 Total Healthcare Spending ..................................................... 3 APPROACH AND METHODOLOGY - All Payers The LifeLink™ Health Plan Claims Database, which - Privately Insured comprises 6.7 billion medical and pharmacy claims, 79 health plans, and 79.4 million members from 2001 to Outpatient Spending ........................................................... 14 the present, was used to conduct this study. A more - Privately Insured detailed description can be found in the Appendix. These analyses were derived from an analytic subset of the Inpatient Spending ............................................................. 17 database, covering the time period from January 1, 2009 - Privately Insured through December 31, 2010 for only privately insured health plan members under age 65 with continuous Pharmacy Spending ............................................................. 21 enrollment and medical and pharmacy benefit coverage. - Privately Insured Cost and use patterns in the overall study population, including 17 chronic conditions, 12 cancers, and 10 Top 1% Member Spending Cohort Profiles ............................. 25 auto-immune and other specialty conditions were studied. - Total Healthcare Spending Costs reported reflect the plan allowed amount (i.e., plan - Spending Profile paid amount plus member contribution) for a given service. - RA and MS Spending Profiles Members were identified by condition based on Year 1 experience, and their cost and utilization is reported based on Year 2 experience. A more detailed description of Potential Implications .......................................................... 30 conditions studied can be found in the Appendix. End Notes ........................................................................... 32 Findings in this report may differ from prior analyses of US Notes on Sources ................................................................ 33 and Medicare spending due to inherent differences in the health status and age distribution of the privately insured Appendix ........................................................................... 35 and differences in analytic methods, such as requiring continuous member enrollment and medical and pharmacy About the IMS Institute ...................................................... 45 benefit coverage during the study time period. Unless otherwise noted in this study, all reference to the privately insured population throughout this report refer to the IMS study population. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Executive summary In 2010, 184 million Americans were enrolled in a total cost was incurred by the 50% of members with Among health plan members, spending is highly private health insurance plan and collectively were the least annual spending. disproportionate to prevalence rates. Over one-third responsible for $822 billion in healthcare This reinforces the importance of understanding the of members have one or more chronic conditions expenditures. By 2020, enrollment is expected to be profile, behavior and interventions that can be and account for over two-thirds of total spending for 198 million and expenditures will reach $1.4 optimally applied to the relatively small number of all members. Members with cancer amount to only trillion. This commercially insured segment of the members who have a substantial impact on overall 1.5% of all health plan members and account for healthcare system and in particular the under 65 year healthcare costs. almost 8% of total spending. segment will remain the dominant part of the Other members with auto-immune or other payment system even as the impact of Overall spending levels of the privately insured under 65 population are mostly focused on specialty conditions represent 1.7% of all members, implementation of the Affordable Care Act and consume 7% of total spending. transforms the healthcare landscape. A deep outpatient and pharmacy services, representing 59% understanding of the characteristics, dynamics and and 21% of total spending, respectively. Inpatient OUTPATIENT SPENDING drivers of utilization and cost within the services represent the remaining 20% of spending. Outpatient services represent the largest share of commercially insured under 65 segment is This distribution of costs differs significantly from total spending, averaging $2,251 per member per particularly important as we stand on the threshold that reported by the Medical Expenditure Panel year, or $188 per member per month. Professional of substantial increases in spending and dependence Survey (MEPS) for all payers and for the Medicare and facility visits account for 74% of overall by enrollees in such programs. 65 and over population. In particular, Medicare 65 spending, with emergency room visits a further 10%. and over population spending on inpatient services Outpatient medical drug therapy, including office, TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING LEVELS represents 43% of total spending, while outpatient facility and home-based injections and infusions, For the total sample of more than 10.6 million and pharmacy services represent 39% and 18%, were 5% of all outpatient spending, or $9 per privately insured health plan members analyzed in respectively. The differences in spending distribution member per month on average. However, this report, average healthcare spending in 2010 was between the privately insured under 65 population and outpatient drug therapy for oncology, $3,840, or $320 per member per month. However the Medicare 65 and over population are substantial auto-immune and other specialty condition the 5% highest cost members accounted for 50.6% and highlight the need for correspondingly populations studied were significantly higher, and of the total cost, and over 25% of the total cost was differentiated analysis, understanding, and actions amount to 19% and 18%, respectively. for just 1% of the members. Conversely, just 3% of aimed at bending the overall US healthcare cost curve. continued on next page... Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 1 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
...continued from previous page Executive summary INPATIENT SPENDING Specialty drugs represent about 1% of the total of The distribution of spending among the 1% cohort Spending per inpatient admission was $14,248 on pharmacy prescriptions but 17% of total pharmacy is similar to that of the Medicare 65 and over average, and accounts for 20% of overall spending spending. Relative to total healthcare spending – population, with 45% of spending being for per member. Facility costs account for 84% of the including inpatient costs, outpatient medical costs inpatient services, 45% for outpatient services, and total inpatient spending, with the balance being and non-specialty pharmacy costs – specialty drug 10% for pharmacy benefits. professional costs. Members with chronic conditions therapy and outpatient medical drug therapy are Average spending for the top 1% of members with had 63% of all hospital admissions, and averaged particularly high for members with auto-immune or specific chronic conditions is between five- and ten- $15,566 per admit. These costs include average 4.5 other specialty conditions and represent 33% of their fold the average spending for all members with the days of stay, and 219 professional visits per 1,000 total healthcare spending. By comparison, these drugs same conditions. For example, members with members. Oncology patients had the highest average represent 17% of spending for oncology patients, and diabetes average $11,858 in annual spending, while cost per admission, at $20,074 but admissions only just 6% for those members with chronic conditions. those suffering from diabetes who are in the top 1% totaled 2.8 admissions per 1,000 members cohort average $102,465 in annual spending. compared to 29.3 admissions per 1,000 members for TOP 1% SPENDING COHORT Consistent with patterns across the healthcare Similarly, those with chronic renal failure on average chronic conditions. spend $33,801 per year, but those within the top 1% system, privately insured under 65 health plan cohort spend over $150,000 annually. PHARMACY SPENDING members who are among the top 1% in annual Average pharmacy spending – including outpatient spending are vastly disproportionate users of Efforts to address healthcare spending levels and drug claims for both specialty and non-specialty healthcare resources. They average almost $100,000 ensure optimal care for patients require detailed medicines – amounts to 21% of total healthcare in annual spending per member. Within the top 1% understanding from timely and robust information. spending for the privately insured under age 65 cohort, our analysis shows that 77% of the members This analysis is intended to focus attention on the population. For every 1,000 members, 11,950 had at least one chronic condition, 16% had one or patient segments, care settings, and treatment options prescriptions were filled in 2010, of which 78% were more cancers, and 13% suffered from auto-immune that can best bring improved health outcomes at for those members with chronic illnesses. Members or other specialty conditions (some members had lowest cost to those in need. Understanding the with oncology and those with auto-immune or more than one of these condition groupings). The privately insured under 65 populations and other specialty conditions filled only 4% and 5% of oncology patients had the highest average spending, addressing their health needs efficiently will bring the total number of prescriptions. of $118,000 per year. significant benefits to the entire healthcare system. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 2 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Total Healthcare Spending – All Payers HIGHLIGHTS • Private insurance will remain the largest segment (57%) of the covered population through 2020. • Insurance exchanges are projected to include 12.5% of the privately insured by 2020. • Private insurance expenditures will remain the largest share of insurance spending (41%) through 2020. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 3 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – ALL PAYERS Enrollment in private insurance will reach 197.8Mn by 2020 • In 2010, 63.4%, 183.9 million, of insured Insurance Enrollment in the US(Mn) individuals in the US were enrolled in private health insurance, while 16.1%, 46.8 million, and 18.5%, 53.7 million, of 25.9 insured individuals were enrolled in 25.8 18.8 24.8 Medicare and Medicaid, respectively. 48.5 7.3 5.2 197.8Mn individuals, • By 2016, private insurance enrollment is 195Mn 57% of 21.1 projected to increase by 6%, from 183.9 individuals, insured 183.9Mn 58% of population million to 195 million people. Health individuals, insured 167.8 insurance exchange plans will represent 168.9 population 63% of insured 18.8 million people, 9.6%, of all private 162.8 population enrollment. • By 2020, private health insurance 1.4 enrollees are projected to remain the 5.2 largest proportion of the overall insured 5.9 83.5 80.6 population, at 57.3%, with Medicare and 53.7 Medicaid accounting for 18.1%, 62.3 million, and 24.2%, 83.5 million 55.4 62.3 46.8 individuals, respectively. 2010 2016 2020 Uninsured Exchanges Other Private Employer Chart notes CHIP Medicaid Medicare Medicare volume includes individuals under age 65. Medicare enrollees who purchase supplemental private insurance are represented in both Medicare and private Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group4 Dec 2010 insurance categories.11 Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 4 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – ALL PAYERS Spending on private insurance will exceed $1.4 trillion in 2020 • Private health insurance spending in Healthcare Expenditures in the US($Bn) 2010 was $822.3Bn, or 44.5% of total insurance expenditures. Medicare and 145 Medicaid expenditures were 28.4%, 3 $525Bn, and 21.7%, $400.7Bn, $1,402Bn, respectively. 41.1% of 79 insurance • By 2016, private health insurance 4 $1,141Bn, 1,253 expenditures expenditures are projected to exceed 42.6% of insurance $1 trillion, increasing by 38.8%, to expenditures $1,141Bn. 1,058 6 • In 2020, private health insurance 39 $822Bn, 44.5% of expenditures will reach nearly $1.5 insurance expenditures 16 trillion and represent 41.1%, the largest 783 908.1 proportion of insurance spending for healthcare in the US. Medicare and 684.6 12 Medicaid will represent 27.7%, $922Bn, 400.7 and 26.7%, $908.1Bn, respectively, of total healthcare spending on insurance. 922.0 707.4 525.0 2010 2016 2020 Chart notes Exchanges Other Private Employer Medicare volume includes individuals under age 65. Medicare enrollees who purchase supplemental private CHIP Medicaid Medicare insurance are represented in both Medicare and private Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Group4, Dec 2010 insurance categories.11 Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 5 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Total Healthcare Spending – Privately Insured HIGHLIGHTS • Healthcare spending was highly concentrated, with 1% of the population driving over 25% of all spending. • Spending among the privately insured under age 65 population was outpatient driven, in contrast to Medicare. • Treatment pattern differences across conditions were noteworthy, in that they were: • Outpatient driven among members with chronic conditions or cancers. • Pharmacy driven for members with auto-immune or other specialty conditions. • Members with chronic conditions, cancers or conditions treated with specialty medicines represented a disproportionate share of spending. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 6 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Spending was highly concentrated • A sample of more than 10 million Distribution of Spending in the Privately Insured privately insured health plan members, from the IMS LifeLink database, showed 96.9% that over 25% of all spending was for just 1% of the total number of health plan 85.4% members. 80.7% 74.3% • More than 50% of the total spending was for only 5% of all health plan members. 65.2% • Slightly more than 3% of expenditures 50.6% went to treat the bottom 50% of all members, who had average annual spending of less than $874 per member. • Spending distribution nearly mirrored the 25.6% overall US population, where AHRQ also reports that 3% of spending was driven by the bottom 50%, while 22% of spending 3.1% was driven by the top 1%.3 Top 1% Top 5% Top 10% Top 15% Top 20% Top 25% Top 50% Bottom 50% (>=$44,957) (>=$14,947) (>=$8,582) (>=$5,773) (>=$4,169) (>=$3,130) (>=$874) (
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Spending increased with age in the under 65 population • Health plan members between the ages of Average Annual Spending Per Member 45 and 64 expended, on average, $5,900 annually on healthcare services, or nearly By Age and Gender ($) twice that of their counterparts between the ages of 20 and 44, and four times that $6,297 of members in the youngest age group - $5,601 0 to 9 years of age. • Average annual spending for women less than 65 years of age was higher, at $4,278 per year, versus $3,373 for men under 65, $3,893 predominately due to higher rates of healthcare utilization overall. This was especially true for women aged 20 to 44. $2,188 $1,784 $1,779 $1,580 $1,308 F M F M F M F M 0-9 10 - 19 20 - 44 45 - 64 Chart notes Estimates of annual spending are averages based on spending of all health plan members, including members Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 with no service use and no spending in the analysis year. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 8 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Spending continued to increase in the Medicare population • As with privately insured under age 65 Annual Program Payments Per Member ($) individuals, spending for Medicare enrollees increased with age, with average annual spending per enrollee higher than $14,527 for the IMS privately insured population. • On average, Medicare spending was $10,109 per member across the age 65 $10,953 and older age groups. • For low-cost Medicare members, the prevalence of minor age-related illnesses, such as cataracts was higher. High-cost Medicare beneficiaries had higher $6,550 prevalence of chronic conditions, including hypertension, chest pain and coronary artery disease.6 65-74 years 75-84 years 85 years or over Chart notes Graph represents data from 2010. See Appendix for the definition of Medicare program payments. Source: Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Office of Information Services, 2010 Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 9 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Spending increases differed as males and females aged • Males, from birth to age nine, had higher Average Annual Spending Per Member ($) annual healthcare spending, on average, at $1,580, than females, at $1,308. • The average annual per member spending for females, ages 20 to 44 was $3,893, 78% higher than same-aged males at $2,188. This difference might, in part, be due to maternity and other reproductive healthcare services. • Higher per member spending by gender, in the study population, reflected increased utilization of services.7 • Similarly, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and National Institutes of Health (NIH) also reported higher use of health services among females than males in the US population.8 0-9 0-9 10-19 10-19 20-44 20-44 45-64 45-64 F M F M F M F M Pharmacy $172 $242 $331 $415 $670 $454 $1,400 $1,267 Outpatient $941 $1,117 $1,166 $1,086 $2,311 $1,345 $3,725 $3,003 Inpatient $195 $221 $287 $278 $912 $389 $1,173 $1,330 Chart notes See Appendix: Cost and Use by Age and Gender for detailed Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 age-gender spending profiles. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 10 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Spending was outpatient driven, in contrast to Medicare • Among the IMS privately insured study Distribution of Spending by Payer Type population, the proportion of spending for inpatient and pharmacy services was about the same, at 20.4% and 20.9%, respectively. • The proportion of Medicare age 65+ 18% spending on inpatient care was 43%, more 21% 22% than double the IMS population, while spending for outpatient services, 39%, and pharmacy, 18%, were much lower than 39% the IMS population. 47% • Inpatient spending remained a higher 59% proportion of overall spend. 43% 31% 20% IMS Privately Insured MEPS All Payers MEPS Medicare Under Age 65 65 and Over Chart notes Inpatient Outpatient Pharmacy MEPS represents data from 2009. See Notes on Sources for details. IMS place of service definitions differ slightly from Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010; Medical Expenditure Panel Survey2, 2009 MEPS definitions. See Appendix for detail. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 11 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Share of spending was disproportionate for certain conditions • Spending was highly disproportionate to Proportion of Spending by Health Services Channel prevalence rates among health plan members with chronic conditions, cancer, auto-immune or other specialty diseases. Condition Members $PMPM • When the prevalence of these various $PMPM conditions was compared to total Set (N) (%) spending for members affected by these All Members 10,657,042 100.0% $320 100.0% specific diseases, their impact was immediately evident and dramatic. Chronic Conditions 3,862,984 36.2% $216 67.5% • More than one-third of all members, 36%, were shown to have at least one Oncology 162,767 1.5% $25 7.9% chronic condition, and comprised approximately two-thirds, 67.5%, of Auto-Immune/Other 183,393 1.7% $22 7.0% spending for all members. Specialty Chart notes $PMPM is a population-based measure that reflects the proportion of all plan spending attributable to overall members or member sub-populations. Estimates for subgroups will be relatively low, even when spending for each member in the subgroup is high, because the Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 denominator is the overall population. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 12 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Treatment pattern differences across conditions were noteworthy • Treatment patterns were outpatient Distribution of Spending by Treatment Setting ($) driven among members with chronic or oncology conditions, and pharmacy driven for members with auto-immune and other specialty conditions. 14% • For members with chronic conditions, 55% 21% 24% of all spending was for outpatient services, 12% 39% of which 3% was for medical drug therapy. 3% 3% • Outpatient services comprised 65% of all spending for members being treated for 8% cancer, with 12% of all spending for 56% 53% medical drug therapy. 52% • Inpatient spending represented a smaller 37% share of all spending for members with auto-immune and other specialty conditions, while outpatient spending was 45% and 21% medical drug therapy 8% of all spending. 20% 21% 16% • Pharmacy spending was 39% of All Members Chronic Conditions Oncology Auto-Immune / all spending for members with auto- ($320 PMPM ($216 PMPM ($25 PMPM Other Specialty immune and other specialty conditions. N=10,657,042) N=3,862,984) N=162,767) ($22 PMPM N=183,393) Chart notes Inpatient Outpatient Medical Outpatient Medical Rx Pharmacy Outpatient Medical Rx includes injected or infused drug therapy administered in a facility, office, or home health setting. Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 13 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Outpatient Spending • Professional and facility visits accounted for 74% of outpatient spending overall. • Emergency room visits were 10% of outpatient spending overall. • Medical drug therapy provided in the office, facility or home was 5% of outpatient spending overall, but represented 18-19% of spending for members with specialty conditions. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 14 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
OUTPATIENT SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Most outpatient spending was on professional and facility services • Emergency room visits, at $18 per Distribution of Outpatient Spending $PMPM member per month, was 10% of all outpatient spending. • Home health medical services Home Health Laboratory/Pathology, $7, 4% Radiology, $8, 4% represented 3% of all outpatient spending, Medical, $5, 3% followed by radiology and laboratory/ Emergency Room, pathology at 4% each. $18, 10% • Outpatient medical drug therapy, including office, facility and home-based injections and infusions, were 5% of all Home Health $1 outpatient spending, or $9 per member per month. Facility Professional Medical Rx, $9, 5% $2 Medical, $74, 39% Facility Medical, Professional $65, 35% $6 Chart notes Medical Rx includes drugs administered in an outpatient facility, office or home health setting, under the medical benefit, identified by HCPCS or revenue codes. Spending may be understated for this category since not all health plans capture outpatient service usage at this level of detail. Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 15 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
OUTPATIENT SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Medical drug therapy use resulted in different spending profiles • In oncology, auto-immune and other Distribution of Outpatient Spending $PMPM specialty condition populations studied, higher use of medical drug therapy 1% 1% 1% 1% resulted in outpatient spending profiles 3% 3% 2% 4% that differed from the overall or chronic 23% patient populations. 30% 39% 38% • Medical drug therapy represented 19% of all outpatient spending for members with various types of cancer, and 18% for members with auto-immune and other 44% specialty conditions, compared to all 34% members and members with chronic 35% 36% conditions at 5% each. • Professional and facility spending 5% 19% 18% represented the largest share of outpatient 5% 4% 4% spending for members overall, and for 4% 5% 2% 3% 4% members with chronic conditions. 10% 8% 6% 3% 6% All Members Chronic Conditions Oncology Auto-Immune / Gary Gatyas ($188 Outpatient ($120 Outpatient ($16 Outpatient Other Specialty PMPM PMPM PMPM ($10 Outpatient 11/15/2011 N=10,657,042) N=3,862,984) N=162,767) PMPM N=183,393) Should we add a- Y axis on the right to Emergency Room Radiology Laboratory/Pathology Medical Rx show dollars? Facility Medical Professional Medical Home Health Medical Other Chart notes Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 16 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Inpatient Spending • Facility-based services were 84% of inpatient spending, while professional services were 16%. • Members with chronic conditions had 63% of all inpatient admissions. • Inpatient services spending among members with chronic conditions or cancers was about 20% of their total spending, similar to that of the overall membership. • Inpatient services were only 16% of all spending among members with auto-immune or other specialty conditions. • Members with cancer had the highest spending per admission, at $20,074, which was nearly $6,000 higher than the average spending per admission across all members. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 17 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
INPATIENT SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED 84% of inpatient spending was for facility-based care • Spending per inpatient admission was, Inpatient Spending Distribution and Service Use on average, $14,248. • Each inpatient admission lasted 4.2 days, on average, with 46.4 admissions per 1,000 members per year. Cost Per Admit • Inpatient spending included professional Measure ($)/Rate visits, with 310 visits per 1,000 members Inpatient $PMPM $65 per year. Professional Allowed Amount ($) Per Admit $14,248 16% Average Length of Stay (ALOS) 4.2 Admits Per 1,000 46.4 Days Per 1,000 195.4 Professional Visits Per 1,000 310.0 Facility 84% Chart notes Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 18 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
INPATIENT SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Inpatient was a lower share of spending for specialty conditions • Inpatient spending was 16%, or $4 per Distribution of Total Spending $PMPM member per month, of all spending for members with auto-immune and other specialty conditions. • Spending on inpatient services, for All Members $65 $254 members with chronic conditions and members with cancers, more closely resembled the proportion spent for inpatient services in the overall All Chronic $44 $171 population. Conditions All Oncology $5 $20 All Auto- Immune/Other $4 $19 Specialty 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Inpatient Outpatient & Pharmacy Chart notes Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 19 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
INPATIENT SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Members with chronic conditions had 63% of all inpatient admissions • Members with chronic conditions had All Chronic Auto-Immune the largest share of inpatient facility Description Oncology Members Conditions /Other Specialty admits at 29 admissions per thousand; they also had the largest share of Inpatient $PMPM $65.33 $44.49 $5.33 $3.59 professional visits, logging 219 visits per 1,000 members. Cost Per Admit($) $14,248 $15,566 $20,074 $16,856 • Oncology patients had the highest Admits Per 1,000 46.4 29.3 2.8 2.2 average spending per admission, at $20,074, which was nearly $6,000 higher Average Length of than the average spending per admission 4.2 4.5 5.2 5.1 across all members. Stay (ALOS) • Oncology patients also had a longer Days Per 1,000 195.4 132.1 14.4 11.3 average length of stay compared to the overall member population and members Professional Visits with a chronic condition, making cancer 310.0 219.0 23.7 18.6 Per 1,000 admissions the most expensive. Chart notes Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 20 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Pharmacy Spending • Members with chronic conditions filled more than 75% of all prescriptions. • Specialty medicines provided by a pharmacy were a very small share of all prescriptions, but 17% of all pharmacy spending. • Spending on specialty medicines provided by a pharmacy, or administered in the facility, office, or home, when combined, accounted for: • 6% of all spending across all members. • 33% of all spending for members with auto-immune or other specialty conditions. • 17% of all spending for members with cancer. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 21 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
PHARMACY SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Specialty pharmacy was 1% of utilization, yet 17% of spending • Overall, 11,950 prescriptions per 1,000 Specialty vs. Non-Specialty Rx Spend and Usage members were filled annually, with 174 prescriptions per 1,000 members for specialty medications, the majority of $66.88 11,950 which were branded. 1% 17% • At $11.31 per member per month, specialty prescriptions were 17% of pharmacy spending. 99% 83% $PMPM Scripts/1,000 Chart notes Figures reflect outpatient drug claims typically processed Non -Specialty Specialty by a pharmacy benefit manager utilizing NDC codes. See Appendix for detail. Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 22 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
PHARMACY SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Members with chronic conditions filled most prescriptions • Health plan members diagnosed with a Prescriptions Per 1,000 Members chronic condition filled 78%, or 9,359 of the 11,950 prescriptions filled per year per 1,000 members. • Members with auto-immune and other All Members specialty conditions filled nearly 5% of all 11,776 174 prescriptions, while those being treated (Total Rx=11,950) for cancer filled only about 4% of all prescriptions. Chronic Conditions • Specialty medications comprised 9% of (Total Rx=9,359) 9,237 122 prescriptions filled by members with auto-immune and other specialty conditions, and 3% of those filled by members with cancers. Oncology 447 15 (Total Rx=462) Auto-Immune/Other Specialty 525 51 (Total Rx=575) Chart notes Prescriptions per 1,000 is a measure of the total number of prescriptions attributable to members with the specified Non - Specialty Specialty conditions relative to the overall population. See Appendix for details. Figures reflect outpatient drug claims typically processed by a pharmacy benefit manager Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 utilizing NDC codes. See Appendix for detail. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 23 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
PHARMACY SPENDING – PRIVATELY INSURED Total specialty drug spending was 6% to 33% of all spending • Medical drug therapy and specialty Percent of $PMPM pharmacy combined share of spending was highest in specialty conditions. $20.38 $14.14 • Across all members, medical drug therapy $4.20 and specialty pharmacy combined were $7.50 $20.38 per member per month, and represented 6% of all spending. • By contrast, medical drug therapy and PERCENT OF $PMPM specialty pharmacy represented 33%, or $7.50 per member per month, of all spending for members with auto- $299.41 $201.71 immune and other specialty conditions. $21.12 • At 17% of all spending, expenditures $14.92 for medical drug and specialty pharmacy were also higher among members with cancers. All Members All Chronic All Oncology All Auto- Conditions Immune/Other Specialty Chart notes Inpatient, Outpatient Medical, Non-Specialty Pharmacy Outpatient Medical Rx and Specialty Pharmacy includes Outpatient Medical Rx, Specialty Pharmacy drugs administered in the facility, office, home, or pharmacy settings. Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 $PMPM is spending per member per month. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 24 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Top 1% Member Spending Cohort Profiles • Average annual spending approached $100,000 per member. • More than 75% of the members had at least one chronic condition; 16% had at least one cancer. • Inpatient spending was more than double the proportion observed in the overall population. • The share of spending for inpatient services resembled the share reported in the Medicare 65+ population. • Members with certain chronic conditions had much higher costs than all members with the same conditions, reflecting higher inpatient spending. • Spending on medical drug therapy administered in the outpatient facility, office or home was: • 6 times higher for members with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) in the top 1% versus all members with RA. • 3 times higher for members with multiple sclerosis (MS) in the top 1% versus all members with MS. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 25 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – TOP 1% SPENDING COHORT Annual spending neared $100,000 per member in the top 1% • Annual spending neared $100,000 per Average Annual Spending Per Member member for the top 1% cohort, in contrast to $3,837 per member for the overall Top 1% Cohort ($) population. • In the top 1% cohort, 77% of members $118,203 diagnosed with one or more chronic conditions had annual spending of $97,652 $98,310 $97,652 per member. $86,289 • Additionally, 16% of members in this cohort had one or more cancers, and average annual spending per member for those with cancer was higher, at $118,203, than for members with chronic, auto- immune or other specialty conditions. • Average annual per member spending for the top 1% cohort members with auto- immune and other conditions treated with specialty medication, was lower, relative to cancer, at $86,289. All Top 1% Chronic Conditions Oncology Auto-Immune / Members (N=82,152) (N=17,230) Other Specialty (N=106,570) (N=13,387) Chart notes Members in this cohort may be more likely to have Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 multiple conditions within and across condition groupings. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 26 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
TOTAL HEALTHCARE SPENDING – TOP 1% SPENDING COHORT Nearly half of all spending in the top 1% cohort was for inpatient • Spending in the top 1% cohort of the Distribution of Spending by Treatment Setting IMS population resembled the Medicare 65+ spending distribution. • Inpatient spending in the top 1% population was more than twice the 10% proportion observed in the overall 21% 18% population. • Pharmacy and outpatient services represented a smaller share of spending 45% 39% for the top 1% cohort relative to the overall population. 59% 45% 43% 20% IMS Privately Insured Top 1% IMS Privately MEPS Medicare Under Age 65 Insured Under Age 65 65 and Over Inpa ent Outpa ent Pharmacy Chart notes MEPS represents data from 2009. IMS place of service definitions differ slightly from MEPS Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010; Medical Expenditure Panel Survey2, 2009 definitions. See Appendix for detail. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 27 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
SPENDING PROFILE - OVERALL AND TOP 1% COHORT Inpatient spending for the top 1% with chronic conditions was higher • The top 1% cohort of members with Average Annual Spending Per Member chronic conditions had much higher, inpatient driven spending. By Chronic Condition ($) • Members with diabetes in the top 1% cohort had spending that was nearly nine $150,226 times higher, on average, than all members with diabetes. $115,445 • The difference in diabetes and other top $104,058 1% chronic conditions was reflective of $102,465 higher inpatient spending. • Pharmacy remained a small proportion of spending for members with these conditions across the top 1% cohort. • On average, more than $150,000 was spent $33,801 annually for each member in the top 1% $22,107 cohort with chronic renal failure, which $11,858 $15,173 was considered particularly high. All Diabetes Top 1% All MI Top 1% All Stroke Top 1% All CRF Top 1% (N=517,997) Diabetes (N=21,146) MI (N=64,457) Stroke (N=39,503) CRF Chart notes (N=17,155) (N=2,054) (N=3,116) (N=5,329) Results reflect Year 2 costs incurred by members with Type 1 or Type 2 diabetes, stroke, myocardial infarction Inpatient Outpatient Pharmacy (MI) or chronic renal failure (CRF) in Year 1 of the study period. Top 1% cohort estimates for these conditions exclude members with cancer, auto-immune and other Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 specialty conditions. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 28 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
$29,602 RA AND MS SPENDING PROFILES - OVERALL AND TOP 1% $16,932 Inpatient spending for top 1% with specialty conditions was higher All MS Top 1% MS All RA Top 1% RA (N=16,361) (N=2,885) (N=53,120) (N=3,131) Inpatient Outpatient Medical Outpatient Rx Specialty Rx Non-Specialty Rx • At $15,141 per member per year, specialty Average Annual Spending Per Member pharmacy was 51% of spending for all members with multiple sclerosis. For the top By Specialty Condition ($) 1% cohort, specialty pharmacy spending was higher at $27,522, but represented a smaller proportion of overall spending at 41%. $79,407 • Outpatient medical drug spending was $66,445 similar for all members with multiple $21,045 sclerosis or rheumatoid arthritis, but six (27%) times higher for rheumatoid arthritis and three times higher for multiple sclerosis for $35,781 members in the top 1% cohort. (52%) $29,602 • Specialty pharmacy and medical drug spending combined were 58% for all $16,932 $17,308 members with multiple sclerosis, and 52% (58%) $5,448 for the top 1%; it was 32% for all (32%) members with rheumatoid arthritis and All MS Top 1% MS All RA Top 1% RA 27% for the top 1% cohort. (N=16,361) (N=2,885) (N=53,120) (N=3,131) • Inpatient spending was a smaller proportion Non-Speciality Rx $2,768 $6,520 $2,255 $6,132 of all spending than for top 1% members Speciality Rx $15,141 $27,522 $3,606 $9,367 with diabetes, stroke or myocardial infarction. Outpatient Medical Rx $2,167 $7,259 $1,842 $11,678 Outpatient Medical $7,175 $16,332 $6,434 $25,780 Chart notes Inpatient $2,351 $8,813 $2,795 $26,449 Results reflect Year 2 costs incurred by members with rheumatoid arthritis (RA) and members with multiple sclerosis (MS) in Year 1 of the study period. Top 1% cohort Source: IMS LifeLink Health Plan Claims Database, Dec 2010 for myocardial infarction (MI) excludes members with cancers, stroke, MI or chronic renal failure (CRF). Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 29 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Potential Implications • Health plan management strategies for • Members with chronic conditions are responsible • Managing health status among health plan privately insured, under 65 members cannot for the majority of healthcare expenditure in the members with chronic conditions may result simply be an extension of Medicare strategies, overall as well as the top 1% spending cohort in cost savings down the road for Medicare, if given their lower share of spending for populations studied.These members and their investment in these individuals reduces or inpatient service spending, and higher shares health plans would benefit from: delays complications. for outpatient and retail pharmacy spending. • Employer-led wellness efforts; • Members with cancers remain a small • Outpatient service pricing, use and • Prospective outpatient service management proportion of all members but have high per management are important to private payers’ and outreach to reduce co-morbidity and patient spending, and higher proportions of ability to manage costs across their complication risks; outpatient spending, including medical drug membership, particularly as health exchanges • Healthcare payment and delivery model therapy. result in large numbers of new entrants to the innovations that reward primary care • These members could benefit from privately insured population. physicians for coordinating specialty care treatment pathway and setting management for chronic care patients and align initiatives that align incentives among incentives to facilitate care coordination providers for care coordination. across providers; and • When possible, providing coverage for • Care management programs that target self-administered therapies through retail reductions in re-admission rates among pharmacy outlets may lead to greater members with conditions like MI, Stroke, efficiency and better quality of life for Diabetes or Chronic Renal Failure, which members with cancer. could lead to system cost savings and improved member quality of life. • Emerging guidelines around cancer screening and treatment may improve treatment effectiveness, lower cost, and improve quality of life for patients with different cancers. Continued on next page... Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 30 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
Potential Implications Continued • In certain disease populations, increased use of • Medicare and private payers face similar specialty retail drug therapy may lead to challenges managing spending and utilization decreased overall member spend. for drug therapy administered in an outpatient • Specialty medications dispensed through facility, office or home setting and paid under the traditional or specialty retail pharmacy the medical benefit. These challenges include: setting are a key cost driver and need • Coordinating the management of contracting and utilization management. outpatient medical and retail pharmacy • At the same time, patients with auto- drug use, spending, and appropriateness immune and other specialty conditions had • Evaluating effects of offering specialty lower spending and use rates for inpatient medications through the retail or home services than members with cancers or for health setting, in addition to or instead of in chronic conditions without specialty drugs. the outpatient facility or office setting, • Additionally, members with auto-immune when clinically possible. and other specialty conditions in the top 1% cohort, including MS and RA, had lower overall per member spending, despite higher shares of retail pharmacy spending. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 31 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
END NOTES 1 IMS Literature Review. August 2011. 10 Office of Information Services; Data from the MEPS-HC Summary Data Tables Technical Notes. Standard Analytical files; data development by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality. May 2Medical Expenditure Panel Survey: Tables of Office of Research, Development and Information. 2004. http://www.meps.ahrq.gov/survey_comp/ Expenditures by Health Care Services. Agency for 2010. https://www.cms.gov/MedicareMedicaid hc_technical_notes.jsp Healthcare Research and Quality. 2009. StatSupp/08_2011.asp http://meps.ahrq.gov/mepsweb/data_stats/quick_ 11 Projections of National Health Expenditures: tables_results.jsp 6 Van Den Bos J. Low Cost vs. High Cost Patients: Methodology and Model Specification. Centers for What Medical Conditions are Most Common. Medicare & Medicaid Services, Office of the Actuary, 3Cohen, S. and Yu, W. The Concentration and Milliman Pharmaco-Actuarial Advisor. 2010. National Health Statistics Group. July 2011. Persistence in the Level of Health Expenditures http://publications.milliman.com/periodicals/pa/p https://www.cms.gov/NationalHealthExpendData/ over Time: Estimates for the U.S. Population, dfs/low-cost-high-cost.pdf downloads/projections-methodology.pdf 2008–2009. Statistical Brief #354. January 2012. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, 7 IMS Clinical Benchmarks, Disease & Condition 12 2010 Glossary. Medicare & Medicaid Services Rockville, MD. http://www.meps.ahrq.gov/mepsweb Product. 2010. Statistical Supplement. Centers for Medicare /data_files/publications/st354/stat354.pdf & Medicaid Services. June 2011. 8 Healthcare in America: Trends in Utilization. http://www.cms.gov/MedicareMedicaidStatSupp/LT 4National Health Expenditure Projections 2010- US Department of Health and Human Services. /list.asp#TopOfPage 2020. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Center for Disease Control, National Center for Office of the Actuary, National Health Statistics Health Statistics. 2004. Group. 2010. https://www.cms.gov/nationalhealth http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/misc/healthcare.pdf expenddata/downloads/proj2010.pdf 9 A Data Book: Healthcare Spending and the 5Table 3.4 Persons Served and Program Payments Medicare Program, June 2010. MedPac. 2010; 27. for Medicare Beneficiaries, by Demographic http://www.medpac.gov/documents/Jun10DataBoo Characteristics: Calendar Year 2010. Medicare & kEntireReport.pdf Medicaid Statistical Supplement. Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services, Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 32 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
continued on next page... NOTES ON SOURCES IMS LifeLink™ Health Plan Claims Database and • A contributing plan’s data submission undergoes healthcare coverage will have different patterns of Study Sample rigorous quality review prior to its addition to the healthcare use and spending. However, this Database, as well as with each subsequent standard design approach ensures consistency in • The LifeLink™ Health Plan Claims Database is transmission of data, and at various stages of the underlying population. comprised of de-identified, commercial health processing and use to ensure end-to-end data plan information obtained from health plans integrity. • Treatment setting definitions differ slightly throughout the United States. It is fully between IMS and publically available sources, adjudicated medical and pharmaceutical claims, • Given the Year 1 identification and Year 2 despite best efforts to align them where possible. including inpatient and outpatient facility, reporting framework, it is possible that members This may account for some differences in spending professional, retail and mail order pharmacy diagnosed in Year 2 would increase the average distribution by setting. experience as well as member enrollment detail. annual cost for some conditions (e.g., myocardial infarction, stroke). However, this standard design • Records in the LifeLink™ Health Plan Claims approach enables reporting of costs and service Database are generally representative of the use across a consistent time frame for all national, commercially insured population in conditions. terms of age and gender. The data are also longitudinal, with average member enrollment • Only health plan members with 24 months of duration of two to three years. Only health plans continuous enrollment and evidence of a medical that submit data for all members are included in and a pharmacy benefit are included in the study. the database, ensuring complete data capture It is possible that individuals with shorter and representative samples. enrollment duration and/or lower levels of Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 33 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
NOTES ON SOURCES Medical Expenditure Panel Survey: Tables of National Health Expenditure Projections Medicare & Medicaid Statistical Supplement Expenditures by Health Care Services 2009 2010-2020 2010 • MEPS Household Component Data contain • National Health Expenditure Projection tables • This supplement provides metrics on Medicare, individual and household-level estimates of present information on enrollment and Medicaid and other CMS programs. We used data health expenditures and utilization. MEPS is expenditure by source of funds and type of from this source to find the weighted average of comparable to IMS in its exclusion of service. We focused on enrollment and expenditure annual Medicare program payments from 2009. institutionalized civilians and foreign visitors to tables with the effects of the Affordable Care Act. the US. Furthermore, MEPS information is We manipulated the data to evaluate specific • The source presents Medicare program payments available by age distribution and insurance type trends between 2010-2016, a time in which a per enrollee, which allows for comparison with which allows for data manipulation into large amount of change is projected after the IMS metrics that also analyze enrolled members. comparable cohorts. In contrast, CMS data immediate onset of the Affordable Care Act. We Not included in Medicare program payments are include US citizens living abroad, military then continued trend analysis up to year 2020. interim payments to institutional providers, personnel, inhabitants of US territories and payments to institutional providers resulting from institutionalized civilians.1 • Trends are consistent with other internal IMS adjustments to the end of first-year cost reports, deliverables, as well as external sources that use capitation payments for prepaid group health • To the extent possible, MEPS treatment settings public data (e.g., Congressional Budget Office) or plans, beneficiary cost-sharing amounts and were classified to mirror IMS definitions. Some private data sources.1 administrative costs. definitional differences remain, however, regarding professional and dental services. • Medicare enrollees in managed care plans are not For example, MEPS data do not distinguish included in the denominator used to calculate between professional inpatient and outpatient average payments, since these payments are not visits or inpatient and outpatient dental borne by CMS directly. services. Additional limitations to the MEPS/IMS comparison include use of data from different • Trends in growth of payments per capita by age is years (MEPS 2009; IMS 2010) and definitional consistent with other publicly available data, such differences in private insurance payment as National Health Expenditure data from 2004.1 amounts. Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 34 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
APPENDIX 1 Conditions Included in Analysis Overall Membership and Disease Population Analysis ALL MEMBERS Chronic Conditions Anxiety/Phobia Diabetes - Type 2 Asthma Hyperlipidemia Back Pain Hypertension Chronic Renal Failure Myocardial Infarction Congestive Heart Failure Obesity Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease Osteoarthritis Coronary Artery Disease Osteoporosis Depression Stroke Diabetes - Type 1 Oncology Breast Cancer Lymphoma Cervical/Uterine/Ovarian Cancer Pancreatic Cancer Colorectal Cancer Prostate Cancer Kidney Cancer Skin Cancer - Melanoma Leukemia Stomach Cancer Lung Cancer Thyroid Cancer Auto-Immune & Crohn's Disease Multiple Sclerosis Other Specialty Conditions Cystic Fibrosis Psoriasis Growth Disorders Psoriatic Arthritis Hemophilia Rheumatoid Arthritis Hepatitis C Ulcerative Colitis Healthcare Spending Among Privately Insured Individuals Under Age 65. 35 Report by the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics
You can also read