HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...

Page created by Jorge Moss
 
CONTINUE READING
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
HAMBURG IS GROWING
WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES.
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG
MARKET REPORT 2018

zinshausteam-kenbo.de
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES
INDEX

        The market for investment properties in Hamburg                          4
        Käufer sPurchasers searching in eastern areas                            4   EDITORIAL
        Price index for existing properties                                      5
        Sales in the city districts                                              6   Dear Ladies and Gentlemen,                     rate below the ECB’s declared goal of
        New residential districts and locations                                  7
                                                                                                                                    2 %. The problems encountered within
        Oberbillwerder                                                           7
        Horner Geest                                                                 continued record-breaking turnover on          the scope of this consolidation course
                                                                                 7
        Densification along arterial roads                                       8   the investment property market; record-        have mainly been brought about by vo-
        Discount supermarket apartments                                          9   breaking take-up in the office and com-        ters’ protest actions. Italy is, for example,
        The housing market in Hamburg                                            9   mercial property segment; multipliers of       the first major EU country to have elec-
        Highest rent increases in Wilhelmsburg                                  10   over 30 for residential and commercial         ted a Eurosceptic, right-wing populist
        Intervention by Hamburg’s government                                    10
                                                                                     properties in prime locations – almost         government. Viewed in the context of
        The Social Preservation Ordinance                                       11
        20-year lock-in period                                                       the rule, not the exception in Hamburg.        other right-wing populist governments
                                                                                11
        Hamburg’s construction code reformed                                    11   Figures for Hamburg’s real estate mar-         with a nationalistic focus, the current si-
        The rent cap                                                            12   ket in 2017 and 2018 reflect the on-going      tuation is having a greater negative im-
        The future of the rent cap                                              13   strong demand for property.                    pact on political unity and thus the EU’s
        Passing on of modernisation costs and the rent index                    13                                                  economic performance than the prior fi-
        Share deals moderately affected                                         14
                                                                                     Demand is currently high because capital       nancial crisis did. In light of the possibili-
        Constitutional judges push forward property tax reform                  14
        Trends and outlook                                                           is easily available. When considering their    ty of a trade war with China and the EU it
                                                                                15
        Alternatives for investment property investors                          16   strategies going forward, both purchasers      is unclear whether the USA will take any
        Rented freehold apartments                                              17   and sellers should bear in mind that in        further steps to raise interest.
        COMMERCIAL INVESTMENT                                                        June the European Central Bank (ECB)
        Commercial investment in Hamburg                                        18   decided to phase out the purchasing of         International political developments are
        The commercial investment market                                        18   new bonds by the end of 2018. The base         of major importance to Germany, an ex-
        Borough centres on the up                                               20   interest rate is, however, set to remain       port nation which has the world’s largest
        Competing uses                                                          21   at 0 % until at least summer 2019. Ex-         trade surplus – US $ 287 billion in 2017.
        Office real estate                                                      21
                                                                                     perts agree that in the next two to three      One in four German jobs is dependent on
        Sales in the city districts                                             21
        Mixed use causes supply shortages                                            years only small increases in interest are     export and Hamburg, a significant ma-
                                                                                22
        Price index for commercial investment properties                        23   to be expected, if at all. While real estate   ritime port, is no exception.
        Co-working increasingly popular                                         24   yields will thus not fall any further, they
        Lack of small projects                                                  24   will also not rise significantly.              The city began to promote property cons-
        The HafenCity as an alternative                                         25                                                  truction earlier than other major German
        Kleiner Grasbrook, Diebsteich and the west                              26
                                                                                     The economic situation in many Euro-           cities and has had success in this regard.
        Change in the retail segment                                            26
        The southern Überseequartier district                                        pean crisis states has improved consi-         The number of planning permits issued
                                                                                27
        Tourism booming                                                         27   derably, with the most recent inflation        since 2011 has tripled, while the number
        Changes of use in the districts                                         28
        References – Investment properties and commercial properties            29
        Picture credits: Arne Hoffmann/arnehoffmann.de · Matrix Development ·
        MOMENI Gruppe · iStock/istock.com · Andreas Vallbracht/prachtvoll.de
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
EDITORIAL

Matthias Baron       Moritz Gäde        Guido Bennemann       Mitschi Fraatz     David Kenney       Nadja Kruse               Oliver Sieweck              Andreas Boberski    Thomas König       Lars Linnenbrügger
Managing partner     Investment         Managing partner      Marketing &        Managing partner   Assistent to the          Managing partner            Managing partner    Managing partner   Managing partner
                     Consultant                               Public Relations                      Management

         of residential units completed has dou-           off. Limitation of the passing on of mo-         ruction of the U5 and S4 train lines and          subject of lively discussion. 1a locations
         bled. Care must now be taken to ensure            dernisation costs by owners to their te-         the covering of the A7 motorway to pro-           are shrinking, while stores are becoming
         that the consequences of the boom do not          nants to 8 % as well as the collection of        duce a tunnel are upgrading existing re-          smaller. Owners are being forced to con-
         impact negatively on the success story.           rent index data from the last six or eight       sidential areas and creating new ones.            sider changes of use for upper storeys
                                                           years – instead of the current four – in                                                           and secondary locations. Demand is still
         These consequences include rising pri-            order to calculate lower average rents           Developers on the commercial proper-              high, however compromises are neces-
         ces for plots and, in the last two years          are not appropriate instruments to mo-           ties market are faced with a challenging          sary with regard to the rents that can be
         in particular, higher costs and reduced           tivate the construction of rental apart-         trend in the city centre, where competiti-        achieved. The city centre is facing more
         availability of construction companies.           ments. Hamburg, furthermore, must                on exists for office, residential and hotel       competition from the district centres,
         Developers and housing enterprises, not           also contend with widening of the soci-          space. The rise of mixed use is advanta-          while also competing for tenants with
         to mention private owners, are compe-             al preservation statutes to ever increa-         geous for urban flair – and is also taking        the southern Überseequartier district,
         ting to win the services of construction          sing areas of the city centre.                   place in borough and some district cen-           due for completion in 2021.
         companies and trades, often paying far                                                             tres – but exacerbates problems due to
         more than originally budgeted.                    Parallel to this, tenants are displaying         competition and high price levels. Com-           One thing is certain – Hamburg owners
                                                           willingness to consider less frequented          petitors in the office segment are incre-         have no need to fear that their proper-
         In addition to this, state intervention is        but well-developed Hamburg boroughs              asingly providers of co-working spaces            ties will remain vacant in the long term.
         hampering construction activity. The              – particularly in eastern and southern           willing to pay high rents and conclude
         reanimation of the Grand Coalition has            regions. This presents opportunities for         long-running contracts.                           With kindest regards
         resulted in the resuscitation of the rent         owners and developers. The extension
         cap, which had previously been written            of the U4 underground line; new const-           The future of High Street retail is the                  ZINSHAUSTEAM & KENBO

         zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                                                           3
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

THE MARKET FOR INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG

                   NUMBER OF INVESTMENT PROPERTIES SOLD                                              Hamburg’s investment property market         two-figure increases. The biggest jump
                                                                                                     slowed down in 2017. While the number        was in the ‘preferred locations’ segment,
     700                                                                                             of transactions has been moving laterally    where prices rose by 27 % to € 5,538/m²
           614
     600                                                                                             for years now, the turnover generated has    – a figure, however, generated by only
                   495             459     421                                427    438      439
     500                                                                                             now also stabilised. At 439 the number of    15 transactions. The average price per
                          386                      404     411     367
     400                                                                                             transactions concluded in 2017 was just      square metre increased by 6.7 % to €
     300                                                                                             one higher than in 2016, while turnover      2,801 – a higher percentage than in 2016.
     200                                                                                             rose by 4.5 % to € 1.613 billion – once
                                                                                                     again an all-time record figure. This in-    In 2017 multipliers in less attractive loca-
     100
                                                                                                     crease, however, was substantially less      tions grew by over two annual net rents to
       0
                                                                                                     than the turnover growth of 27 % recorded    21.2. The highest multipliers were, as is
            2007

                   2008

                           2009

                                   2010

                                            2011

                                                    2012

                                                            2013

                                                                     2014

                                                                              2015

                                                                                      2016

                                                                                              2017
                                                                                                     by the Hamburg Committees of Valuation       traditionally the case, recorded in the pre-
                                                                                                     Experts from 2015 to 2016. Turnover per      ferred locations – 32.7. In contrast, multi-
                                                                                                     property increased to € 3.67 million in      pliers for poor and good locations fell. The
                           TURNOVER (in million euros)                                               2017 and was thus 4.3 % higher than in       2017 average achieved for all locations
                                                                                             1.613   2016, again a figure never before achie-     was 23.6 times the annual net rent.
                                                                                     1.543
    1600                                                                                             ved. Even in the boom year of 2007 tur-
    1400                                                                                             nover per property was only € 1.8 million.   On average, purchasers looking for sui-
                                                                            1.214
    1200
           1133                                            1188                                                                                   table properties for privatisation into
                                   886     901     873              800                              Turnover development is also reflec-         freehold apartments paid a multiplier
    1000
                   637    687                                                                        ted in the differing directions in which     of 24.9, while the square metre price for
     800
                                                                                                     purchase prices and purchase price           such properties was € 3,372, just over
     600
                                                                                                     multipliers have developed in various        € 100 more than in 2016.
     400                                                                                             locations. While the demand dynamic
     200                                                                                             in 2016 led to rises in prices per square    PURCHASERS SEARCHING
       0                                                                                             meter and multipliers in all locations,      IN EASTERN AREAS
                                                                                                     in 2017 the picture was far more mixed.      Although the number of transactions in
            2007

                   2008

                           2009

                                   2010

                                            2011

                                                    2012

                                                            2013

                                                                     2014

                                                                              2015

                                                                                      2016

                                                                                              2017

                                                                                                     ‘Poor’ and ‘good’ locations experienced      2017 changed very little in comparison
                                                                                                     slight price adjustments (-6.1 % respec-     to 2016, their distribution across the city
                          Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss                    tively -1.6 %) while other locations saw     was markedly different. For the first time

4
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT Zinshäuser
                                                                                                                                        PROPERTIES

                                                     PRICE INDEX FOR EXISTING PROPERTIES

    CATEGORY      DISTRICTS                                             DISTRICTS WITH POTENCIAL           MULTIPLIER      PRICE PER m2/€   TREND

                Blankenese, Flottbek, HafenCity, Harvestehude, Ho-
    PRIME                                                                                                  29 - 35 times
    LOCATION
                henfelde (West), Nienstedten, Othmarschen,
                Rotherbaum, Uhlenhorst (West), Winterhude (Süd)
                                                                                        –
                                                                                                           annual rent
                                                                                                                            4.500 - 5.500   Ò

                Barmbek-Süd, Eimsbüttel (Nord), Eppendorf,
    GOOD                                                                                                   27 - 32 times
    LOCATION
                Hoheluft-Ost, Marienthal, Ottensen, Schanzenviertel,
                St. Georg, Uhlenhorst, Wellingsbüttel, Winterhude
                                                                                        –
                                                                                                           annual rent
                                                                                                                            3.500 - 4.500   Ò

    TRENDY      Altona, Hamm, Hammerbrook,                                                                 24 - 28 times
    LOCATION    Karolinenviertel, St. Pauli
                                                                       Bahrenfeld, Barmbek-Nord
                                                                                                           annual rent
                                                                                                                            2.600 - 3.600   Ò

                Bergedorf, Fuhlsbüttel, Harburg,                       Bramfeld, Dulsberg, Eilbek, Horn,
    SECONDARY                                                                                              22 - 25 times
    LOCATION
                Heimfeld, Iserbrook, Jenfeld,
                Poppenbüttel, Rahlstedt, Sasel
                                                                       Langenhorn, Lokstedt, Lurup,
                                                                       Schnelsen, Wandsbek
                                                                                                           Annual rent
                                                                                                                            2.400 - 3.000   Ò

    TERTIARY                                                           Billbrook, Billstedt, Neugraben-    17 - 19 times
    LOCATION
                Rothenburgsort, Veddel
                                                                       Fischbek, Tonndorf, Wilhelmsburg    annual rent
                                                                                                                            1.800 - 2.300    Ö

    POOR                                                                                                   15 - 18 times
    LOCATION
                Moorfleet, Neuenfelde                                  Süderelbe, Oberbillwerder
                                                                                                           annual rent
                                                                                                                            1.500 - 1.900    Ö

5
                                                                                                                                                    5
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Wohldorf-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Ohlstedt
                                                                                                                                                                                                   Duvenstedt

in ten years no borough had more than         SALES IN THE CITY DISTRICTS IN 2017                                                                                                                                                                                      None
                                                                                                                                                                                                   Lemsahl-
15 transactions, however an above ave-                                                                                                                                                            Mellingstedt
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        1
rage number of boroughs had 10 or more                                                                                                                                                                           Bergstedt                                              2
transactions.                                                                                                                                                                                    Poppen-
                                                                                                                                                                                                  büttel                                                                3 to 4
                                                                                                                                                                  Langenhorn
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Sasel                                                  5 to 6
                                                                                                                                                                               Hummels-                                            Volksdorf
                                                                                                                                                                                 büttel
The Top 5 districts are the perfect illus-                                                                                                                                                        Wellings-
                                                                                                                                                                                                   büttel
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        7 to 9
                                                                                                                         Schnelsen
tration of the interest across the entire                                                                                                   Niendorf
                                                                                                                                                              Fuhlsbüttel                                                                                             		10 to 19
                                                                                                                                                                                 Ohlsdorf
spectrum of locations. The Committees                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  20 and more
                                                                                                                                                         Groß                          Steils-                                   Rahlstedt
of Valuation Experts for Billstedt, Eims-                                                                            Eidelstedt                         Borstel
                                                                                                                                                                    Alster-
                                                                                                                                                                     dorf               hoop
                                                                                                                                                                                                              Farmsen-
                                                                                                                                                                                                 Bramfeld       Berne
büttel and Winterhude recorded 15 tran-                                                                                                     Lokstedt
                                                                                                           Lurup                               Eppendorf              Barmbek-
sactions each while 14 sales each were                           Rissen
                                                                                                                               Stellingen
                                                                                                                                             Hohe-
                                                                                                                                                         Winterhude      Nord
                                                                                                                                                                              Duls- Wands-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Tonndorf

                                                                                                                                              luft                            berg
made in Altona-Altstadt and Harburg.                                          Sülldorf    Iser-
                                                                                          brook                                       Eims-
                                                                                                                                                 Harveste-
                                                                                                                                                   hude
                                                                                                                                                                   Barmbek-
                                                                                                                                                                       Süd
                                                                                                                                                                                      bek
                                                                                                  Osdorf          Bahrenfeld          büttel                                                                       Jenfeld
                                                                                                                                                           Uhlenhorst
                                                                                                                                Sternschanze                             Eilbek Marienthal
                                                                                                                                                Rotherbaum
                                                                          Blankenese                          Groß                Altona                       Hohen-
                                                                                                            Flottbek                                        St. felde
The figure for Billstedt is indicative of                                                                                         -Nord
                                                                                                                                                   Neu- Georg Borg-
                                                                                            Nienstedten                   Otten-             St. stadt Alt-         felde Hamm       Horn
the significant growth of interest in                                                                       Othmarschen     sen    Altona Pauli
                                                                                                                                 -Altstadt
                                                                                                                                                       stadt Hammer-
                                                                                                                                                                brook                                               Billstedt

Hamburg’s eastern boroughs of Wands-                                      Cranz
                                                                                          Finkenwerder                                                            HafenCity
                                                                                                                                                                                 Rothen-
                                                                                                                        Waltershof          Steinwerder                          burgsort
                                                                                                                                                              Kleiner                                Billbrook
bek and Bergedorf, with the sales in the                                                                                                                     Grasbrook
                                                                                                                                                                              Veddel
districts of Eilbek, Hamm and Marienthal,
                                                                             Neuenfelde                                  Altenwerder
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Lohbrügge
all closer to the city centre, above ave-                                                           Francop
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Moorfleet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                         Billwerder
rage. Bramfeld has also become more                                                                                                                       Wilhelmsburg
                                                                                                                                                                                                 Taten-
                                                                                                                               Moorburg                                                           berg                   Neuallermöhe
attractive to investors in the last two ye-                                                                                                                                                 Spaden-
                                                                                                                                                                                              land
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    Bergedorf
                                                                                           Neugraben-                                                                                                                           Allermöhe
ars, as have the peripheral districts of                                                    Fischbek
                                                                                                                   Hausbruch
                                                                                                                                                                                                                            Reitbrook
Billstedt and Lohbrügge. The trend for                                                                                            Heimfeld
                                                                                                                                                        Harburg
                                                                                                                                                                       Neuland                       Ochsenwerder
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                           Curslack
investment in locations which are classi-                                                                                                                                                                                                    Neuengamme
                                                                                                                                     Eißendorf
fied as poor and are thus less expensive                                                                                                                   Wilstorf             Gut Moor                                                                              Altengamme
                                                                                                                                             Marmstorf
is a further reason for the restrained rise                                                                                                                                     Rönneburg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Kirchwerder
                                                                                                                                                       Sinstorf        Langenbek
in capital turnover.

                                              Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss

6
                                                                             Keine
                                                                              1
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

                                 MULTIPLIERS 2008–2017                                                                                      Prices per square meter in € 2008–2017

                            Good location      Tertiary location          All locations                                                        Prime location      Tertiary location           All locations
                                                                                              27,1     26,7

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       5.538
                                                                                 23,9
                                                                                                       23,6
                                                                                              22,9
                                                                                                                                                                          4.495                                4.375
                                                                   21,5
                                                                                                                                                       3.894                           3.856       4.012
                                            20,7      20,5                       20,3
                                                                   19,4                                                                        3.428
                                                      18,7                                             21,2                                                     3.101
                     17,8         18,1      18,1                                                                                                                                                                       2.801
                                                                                                                                                                                                               2.624
              16,8                                                                            19,0                                                                                                 2.485
                                                                                                                                   2.229                                  2.256
   15,4              16,0                                                        17,9                                      1.865                                                       2.101
                                                                   17,5                                                                                         1.927
                                                                                                                                                       1.700
                                  16,3                16,8                                                                                     1.599
                                            16,0                                                                           1.319    1.368                                                                              2.132
14,3          15,4                                                                                                                                                                     1.713       1.745       1.861
                     14,9                                                                                                                                       1.481     1.507
                                  14,3
                                                                                                                                               1.231   1.375
                                                                                                                           1.140    1.058
  13,0        12,5
       2008

              2009

                     2010

                                  2011

                                             2012

                                                       2013

                                                                   2014

                                                                                 2015

                                                                                              2016

                                                                                                        2017

                                                                                                                           2008

                                                                                                                                     2009

                                                                                                                                               2010

                                                                                                                                                        2011

                                                                                                                                                                 2012

                                                                                                                                                                           2013

                                                                                                                                                                                       2014

                                                                                                                                                                                                    2015

                                                                                                                                                                                                                2016

                                                                                                                                                                                                                       2017
                                                                                        Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss

NEW RESIDENTIAL DISTRICTS                              ral Parliament thus approved € 50 million                      OBERBILLWERDER                                       with Karres + Brands and Transsolar
AND LOCATIONS                                          for the rejuvenation of social and sports                      Oberbillwerder is the site of Hamburg’s              Energietechnik, a Danish-Dutch-German
Investment property purchasers are                     infrastructures within the scope of this                       largest project within the scope of this             team which won an urban development
not the only ones to have discovered                   model programme. Hamburg is co-finan-                          greenfield strategy. Plans envisage the              workshop process in June 2018, is cur-
Hamburg’s eastern areas, which have                    cing these measures and will contribute                        creation of a district with 7 000 residen-           rently being developed and should be
been neglected in past decades. Project                a further € 50 million by 2025.                                tial units and 5 000 jobs on 124 ha of               completed by the end of 2018.
developers are also looking for affordable                                                                            marshland over the next 15 years. The
plots with links to S- or U-Bahn trains in             In response to strong population growth,                       gross floor area will be just under 1 mil-           HORNER GEEST
order to build reasonably priced housing.              with an annual inflow of up to 20 000 new                      lion m². Chief Planning Officer Franz-               Oberbillwerder is already linked to
In addition to this, the city’s “Stromauf-             residents – many of whom are on low                            Josef Höing hopes to see a “quantum                  Hamburg’s public transport network
wärts an Elbe and Bille” urban develop-                incomes – in 2015 the city expanded its                        leap” with regard to energy, mobility and            via the existing Allermöhe S-Bahn train
ment concept is drawing more attention                 “More City in the City” philosophy of buil-                    social, cultural and mixed use. A master             station on the S4 line. The new urban dis-
to eastern areas. At the end of June the               ding on vacant urban plots to include the                      plan based on the urban planning design              trict of Horner Geest will benefit from the
Budget Committee of the German Fede-                   “More City in New Locations” concept.                          proposed by the Adept Aps consortium                 opening of a station on the extended U4

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                                                                                          7
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

                        underground line, expected to be ready        through increased e-mobility, use of pu-
                        by the mid-2020’s. In early July 2018 the     blic transport and cycling, are, however,
                        Senate approved commencement of the           the primary drivers of better quality of life
                        “Zukunftsbild 2030” project to create the     and housing development in these areas.
                        Horner Geest urban district. It envisages
                        the construction of 3 100 residential units   Within the scope of a national model
                        on vacant urban plots between Horner          project to increase housing density the
                        Rennbahn and Öjendorfer Park and new          borough of Altona has identified potenti-
                        construction projects such as the Öjen-       al to build 20 000 residential units along
                        dorfer Gartenstadt development.               its main transport arteries Sülldorfer
                                                                      Landstraße and Osdorfer Landstraße. Re-
                        There are also plans to construct more        search carried out by the city’s CDU, SPD
                        housing among the low-density buildings       and Green parliamentary groups indicates
                        erected in the Horner Geest area in the       that some 100 000 units could be built in
                        1950’s and 1960’s – and also elsewhere.       Hamburg as a whole. The Department of
                        Chief Planning Officer Höing wishes to        Urban Development and Housing (BSW)
                        make the 60-year old post-war district        is currently working with the boroughs to
                        more attractive while also creating additi-   review urban development potential along
                        onal homes by increasing building density.    arterial roads. In addition to large-area
                                                                      discount supermarkets with flat roofs and
                        DENSIFICATION                                 petrol stations the focus is on detached
                        ALONG ARTERIAL ROADS                          and town house plots near the city centre
                        Arterial roads – the four- to six-lane        and in low-density post-war residential
                        main roads leading out of the city cen-       areas. Wider-ranging building rights are
                        tre – are a key element of this concept.      planned to motivate owners to build more
                        District centres are often located at the     homes on their plots, while municipal in-
                        intersections of these roads with resi-       struments, such as urban planning de-
                        dential areas built after the war and most    velopment measures or planned interior
                        requiring upgrading. Changing mobili-         development measures, are also being
                        ty strategies, such as lower emissions        considered.

8
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

DISCOUNT SUPERMARKET                          high. The “Housing Alliance”, formed in                                      COMPLETED HOMES 2008–2017
APARTMENTS                                    2011 to relieve pressure on the housing
                                                                                                                 Total completed buildings           By companies      By private households
Discount food retailers such as Aldi and      market, under pressure for more than a
Lidl are taking a proactive stance with       decade now, and renewed in 2016, has             9.000                                                                          8.521
regard to such measures. In order to          expanded its objective of gaining planning                                                                                               7.722   7.920
                                                                                               8.000
secure existing sites and obtain appro-       permits for 6 000 residential units annu-                                                                             6.974
val for new ones – particularly near the      ally to 10 000 units. In addition to this, the   7.000                                                       6.407
                                                                                                                                                                              5.874    5.749   5.484
city centre or borough district centres –     boroughs have also become members of             6.000
                                                                                                                                                                    5.080
they are submitting plans which include       the Alliance.                                    5.000                                                      4.294
multi-storey residential buildings above                                                               3.758   3.587     3.520    3.729   3.793
                                                                                               4.000
supermarkets to the planning authorities.     Planning permission was, in fact, gran-                  2.715   2.489              2.422      2.430
                                                                                               3.000                     2.242
                                              ted for over 13 400 residential units in                                                                                                         1.889
                                                                                                                                                           1.629    1.678     1.629    1.552
Aldi, for example, has already realized       2017 – a record figure not seen since the        2.000                     1.213    1.193
                                                                                                                992                          1.131
                                                                                                       912
such developments at Holstenstraße and        1970’s. In contrast, the number of units         1.000
Bahrenfelder Straße in Altona. Frank          completed has, at best, experienced only             0

                                                                                                       2008

                                                                                                                2009

                                                                                                                         2010

                                                                                                                                   2011

                                                                                                                                               2012

                                                                                                                                                           2013

                                                                                                                                                                     2014

                                                                                                                                                                              2015

                                                                                                                                                                                       2016

                                                                                                                                                                                               2017
Conrad, head of Altona’s Urban Planning       lateral movement since 2015, with 7 920
Department, has identified potential for      units completed in 2017. This figure was
                                                                                                                        Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss
some 800 apartments at 16 discount su-        only slightly higher than in 2016.
permarket sites in his borough, while the
Borough of Eimsbüttel is already pursu-       The strongest upward curve has been              little evidence that there has been a rise in            2018. In the first half of the year permits
ing a „discount supermarket strategy” to      experienced by the construction backlog          speculative purchasing of plots ready for                for 4,295 residential units were issued –
create housing.                               – i.e. residential units which have been         development. The increasing construction                 39 % less than in 2017. Should the slump
                                              approved, however not yet completed. At          backlog is often caused by capacity bot-                 in granting of planning permissions con-
THE HOUSING MARKET IN HAMBURG                 the end of 2011 this figure was 8 000, at        tlenecks on the part of construction com-                tinue, then this would confirm the fin-
Dorothee Stapelfeldt, Hamburg’s Senator       the end of 2017 just under 25 000 units. In      panies in combination with related cost                  dings of bulwiengesa’s project developer
for Urban Development, is forecasting a       Berlin speculation with approved projects        increases for personnel and materials.                   study, carried out in spring 2018, which
relatively conservative figure of 100 000     plays a significant role in the widening                                                                  concluded that the current planned vo-
additional residents by 2030. Projections     gap between approvals and completions.           It does not appear that there will be a                  lume for commercial development pro-
based on current inflow statistics indicate   In Hamburg, however, the boroughs and            new record-breaking figure for the num-                  jects in Hamburg was 25 % lower than
that the actual number could be twice as      institutes such as empirica have found           ber of planning permissions granted in                   the figure for 2016.

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                                                                 9
HAMBURG IS GROWING WITH ITS OPPORTUNITIES - INVESTMENT PROPERTIES IN HAMBURG MARKET REPORT 2018 - Zinshausteam ...
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

HIGHEST RENT INCREASES                         The development of rents is, howe-                              RENTS QUOTED AND RENT INDEX IN €/m2
IN WILHELMSBURG                                ver, less dramatic when considered in                                       2007–2017
Viewed from a statistical perspective,         terms of the Hamburg rent index. At €
the number of newly constructed apart-         8.44/m² the average figure for the April            Rent quoted for new buildings     Rent quoted for existing buildings     Rent index average
ments is already insufficient to house         2017 rent index is 29 % above that of
                                                                                                                                                                                           13,89
the population moving into Hamburg.            2007. This figure is influenced by the
                                                                                                                                   12,98    12,92      13,01   13,04      13,00    13,28
New building projects have thus yet to         new or re-renting of some 250 000 af-                                    12,41
have any significant impact on the deve-       fordable Saga and housing association
                                                                                                              11,00
lopment of rents for existing properties.      apartments which are not advertised                                                                                                 10,52
                                                                                                                                                                                           11,02

                                                                                                                                           10,00       10,08   10,20      10,23
According to figures published by em-          on portals or in newspapers. Never-                     9,61
                                                                                                                         9,23       9,70
                                                                                            9,03
pirica – gathered from Internet portals        theless, the rents quoted by commer-                             8,72                                                                        8,44
                                                                                                       8,24
and daily newspapers – rents quoted for        cial housing companies are indicative        7,86                                                        7,56    7,54
                                                                                                                                                                           8,02     8,02
                                                                                                                                    7,15     7,15
new housing soared by 54 % between             of market trends – also for individual                           6,76     6,76
                                                                                            6,58       6,53
2007 and 2017, to € 13.89/m². The ove-         sub-markets. In the case of empirica
rall increase in rents quoted was more         these sub-markets usually comprise
moderate, rising by 40 % to € 11.02/m².        two or more districts.

                                                                                            2007

                                                                                                       2008

                                                                                                                2009

                                                                                                                         2010

                                                                                                                                    2011

                                                                                                                                             2012

                                                                                                                                                        2013

                                                                                                                                                                 2014

                                                                                                                                                                           2015

                                                                                                                                                                                    2016

                                                                                                                                                                                             2017
As clearly shown by the illustration, incre-   By far the largest increase in rents in                                      Source: empirica/IDN ImmoDaten/BSW
ases in rents slowed between 2012 and          the period from 2007 to 2017, a plus of
2015, after which the dynamic began to         62 % to € 9.76/m², was recorded in Wil-
accelerate again. Causes of this include       helmsburg (together with Veddel and
insufficient, ever more expensive plots;       Rothenburgsort). The surge south of          weakest rental development, € 14.94/m²                  INTERVENTION BY HAMBURG’S
rising construction costs due to stricter      the Elbe was started by the IBA inter-       or + 11 %, was recorded in the second                   GOVERNMENT
energy requirements and contractors’ li-       national architecture exhibition, which      most expensive sub-market, the city                     Hamburg reacted to the emerging
mited capacities; improved incomes due         ran from 2007 to 2013. Rents on the          centre including the HafenCity district.                housing shortage earlier than other ma-
to relatively high collective bargaining ag-   up-and-coming St. Pauli/Sternschanze         Only the area west of the Alster is more                jor German cities, founding the “Housing
reements and also the influx of refugees.      market also rose at an above-average         expensive at € 15.31/m², however it also                Alliance” in 2011. In comparison to 2010
When compared to other major German            rate (+ 48 % to € 13.75/m²) as did those     experienced below-average rental incre-                 the number of planning permits issued
cities, only Munich (49 %) and Berlin (73      in Borgfelde/Hamm/Horn (+ 45 % to €          ases of 28 %, as did the suburbs along                  has tripled, while the number of resi-
%) have steeper rent price curves.             10/m²) to the east of the city centre. The   the Elbe (+ 24 % to € 13.45/m²).                        dential units completed has doubled.

10
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

SOCIAL PRESERVATION                   The city’s red-green Senate does, how-          In May 2018 the Department for Ur-          that 12 000 new homes subject to rent
ORDINANCE                             ever, occasionally also impede housing          ban Development and Housing (BSW)           caps have been completed since 2011.
IN HAMBURG                            construction or investment in existing          announced that social preservation le-
                                      stock.                                          gislation is also being considered for      Within the scope of the Housing Alliance,
ALREADY EXISTING                                                                      large areas of Altona-Nord, home to 22      in 2016 the city undertook to finance 3
Eimsbüttel-Nord, Hoheluft-West,       THE SOCIAL PRESERVATION                         100 people and bordering on the new         000 publicly-funded new homes eve-
Stellingen-Süd (2018)                 ORDINANCE                                       Diebsteich, Mitte-Altona and Holsten-       ry year. Senator Dorothee Stapelfeldt
Nördliche Neustadt/Venusberg (2018)   The Social Preservation Ordinance is a          quartier residential districts. Parts of    emphasized in July that financing was
Bahrenfeld-Süd (2016)                 statute specific to Hamburg. In the are-        Eilbek are also under review. In addition   secure for significantly more than 3 000
Ottensen (2016)                       as falling under the statute applications       to this, following an agreement reached     homes. The initial rent for new apart-
Altona-Altstadt (2014)                for modernisation; demolition; change of        by the Housing Alliance a preliminary       ments funded under the scheme to crea-
Eimsbüttel-Süd (2014)                 use of rental apartments or privatisation       review is underway for the Bahrenfeld-      te housing for people on low incomes
Ottensen Osterkirchenviertel (2013)   into freehold apartments are reviewed           West, Ottensen-Nordwest, Hamm, Horn,        has been set at € 6.50/m² for 2018; for
Sternschanze (2013)                   with the aim of establishing what im-           Barmbek-Nord, Uhlenhorst, Winterhude        apartments funded under the scheme
St. Georg (2012)                      pact such measures would have on the            and Hohenfelde districts.                   to create housing for people on medium
St. Pauli (2012)                      area’s social structure. In 2018 social                                                     incomes at € 8.60/m². The higher income
Südliche Neustadt (1995)              preservation statutes came into force for       20-YEAR LOCK-IN PERIOD                      threshold, also decided in July, means
                                      the northern Neustadt and Eimsbüttel/           From 1 January 2019 onwards planning        that the group of Hamburg households
IN PREPARATION                        Hoheluft-West/Stellingen-Süd, urban             applications for social housing submit-     qualifying for such funding has risen from
Bahrenfeld-West                       districts with a total of 70 000 residents.     ted to the approval authorities will be     61 000 to 368 000.
Barmbek-Nord                          The area in Eimsbüttel, which encom-            subject to a lock-in period extended
Hamm                                  passes 64 000 residents, is the largest         from 15 to 20 years. The obligatory         HAMBURG’S CONSTRUCTION CODE
Hohenfelde                            ever to come under such legislation. A          period for the Saga municipal housing       REFORMED
Horn                                  quarter of all households in the borough        association will be 30 years. The ex-       The modernised Hamburg Construction
Ottensen Nord-West                    of Eimsbüttel are now subject to the So-        tension is intended to stabilise stocks     Code (HBauO) came into force on 1 May
Uhlenhorst		                          cial Preservation Ordinance; in the entire      of publicly-funded housing in the long      2018. The most important reforms inclu-
Winterhude                            city of Hamburg the statute affects 187         term following a decline in the number      de permission to use load-bearing, stif-
                                      550 residents living in residential districts   of social housing apartments from 118       fening or space-enclosing solid wooden
                                      which are primarily located near to the         000 in 2007 to 79 000 in 2017. This nega-   construction components for building
                                      city centre.                                    tive trend has occurred despite the fact    projects up to 22 m in height (floor level

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                                    11
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

                        of the top floor) insofar as compliance         concentrate barrier-free apartments on
                        with the required fire resistance class         one floor but instead can distribute them
                        can be demonstrated. This generally ap-         across several storeys, allowing them
                        plies to pre-fabricated modules made            to respond to needs and cost aspects in
                        from cross-laminated plywood which              an optimum manner.
                        can be erected quickly on site. Wood
                        has the additional advantage over con-          THE RENT CAP
                        crete, stone or steel of being lighter in       The rent cap has been the subject of very
                        weight, which can be a crucial factor in        controversial discussions between the
                        providing the structural proofs required,       housing sector and Hamburg’s politi-
                        for example, when adding an additional          cians for over three years now. In June
                        storey to a building. A further reform is       2018 Hamburg Regional Court ruled that
                        that developers wishing to add an addi-         the Hamburg rent cap was invalid on
                        tional storey to a building are no longer       formal grounds – for the period from 1
                        obliged to install a lift (cost per building:   July 2015 to 1 September 2017. The ru-
                        € 70 000 to € 100 000). This obligation         ling is founded on the fact that the “Rent
                        previously applied to all buildings over        Cap Ordinance” was issued on 1 July
                        13 m in height. When building additional        2015, however its substantiation was not
                        storeys it is also generally necessary to       published until 1 September 2017. The
                        insulate the façade. Under the new Con-         reading of the substantiation is asserted
                        struction Code developers will no longer        to be a “precondition for validity”. Fol-
                        have to obtain the consent of neighbours        lowing the ruling a petition submitted by
                        for this, even if such work will result in      a tenant for reimbursement of overpaid
                        the minimum clearance between the two           rent was rejected. The tenant rented an
                        buildings no longer being met or building       apartment in Ottensen for € 14.01/m² on
                        components projecting up to 20 cm onto          1 September 2015 although the typical
                        the neighbour´s land.                           rent for the area, as based on the 2015
                                                                        rent index was € 8.75/m² or € 9.63/m²
                        With regard to disabled accessibility           taking into consideration the surcharge
                        developers are no longer obliged to             of 10 % on the typical rent as permitted

12
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

under the terms of the rent cap.               (CSU) indicates that the rent cap will be-
                                               come stricter. Tenants will, in future, be
In the meantime, on 3 July 2018 the Se-        able to report a breach of the rent cap
nate, which has announced that it does         by means of a simple complaint. Should
not share the court’s legal interpretation,    the landlord cite a higher previous rent
revised and re-published the rent cap –        as grounds for raising a rent, however
including the substantiation. Since, how-      fail to provide the tenant with proof of
ever, the Regional Court suspended the         this before concluding a contract, then
ordinance for the period for 1 July 2015 to    the new tenant can reduce the rent to the
2 September 2017 and the new ordinance         level foreseen by the rent cap.
does not apply retrospectively, there is le-
gal uncertainty regarding ongoing cases
dating from these 26 months. The new           PASSING ON OF MODERNISATION
Rent Cap Ordinance will be valid until 30      COSTS AND THE RENT INDEX
June 2020. Its scope of validity, namely       Legislation regarding the passing on of
for the whole city of Hamburg, is founded,     modernisation costs will also be tighte-
for example, on the fact that the vacancy      ned up. Whereas landlords could, to date,
rate has been under 0.7 % since 2010           pass on 11 % of modernisation costs to
as well as on the high rent increases in       their tenants each year, it is planned
areas which are not popular residential        that this figure will, in future, be limi-
districts, such as Barmbek or Hamm.            ted to 8 % in areas in which the housing
                                               market is under pressure. In addition to
THE FUTURE OF THE RENT CAP                     this, an absolute cap threshold will be
While it is true that the regional states      introduced. Following this, rents may not
are responsible for implementing the rent      be increased by more than € 3/m² for a
cap, it is also a fact that the framework      period of six years after modernisation.
conditions are set by the Grand Coalition      It is foreseeable that future rent index
in Berlin. An agreement between Minis-         calculations will include contracts dating
ter of Justice Katarina Barley (SPD) and       back more than the four years currently
Minister of Construction Horst Seehofer        taken into consideration. The objective

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                          13
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

                        behind this is to lessen the effect which      Federal Ministry of Finance is currently
                        high rents based on new contracts have         developing proposals for supplementary
                        on figures for typical rents.                  legislative texts. It is still unclear when
                                                                       the reform will come into force.
                        SHARE DEALS
                        MODERATELY AFFECTED                            CONSTITUTIONAL JUDGES PUSH
                        At the end of June the regional Ministers      FORWARD PROPERTY TAX REFORM
                        of Finance decided to reform the Land          Since the German states were unable to
                        Transfer Tax Act, thus raising the hurd-       agree a property tax reform two years
                        le for share deals. Under current legal        ago, the Federal Constitutional Court has
                        regulations, a purchaser can avoid pay-        pushed forward the decision with its ru-
                        ing land transfer tax if he acquires only      ling of 10 April. The unit values which
                        94.9% or less of a property which has          have previously been used date from 1935
                        been converted into a property compa-          (for the territory of the former GDR) and
                        ny. After five years he can purchase the       1964 (for the former FRG) and have di-
                        remaining 5.1 % from the seller or a co-       verged so far from current market values
                        investor and must only pay land transfer       that it will, in future, be forbidden to use
                        tax on this 5.1 %.                             them – although municipalities have the
                                                                       right to influence land tax revenue by em-
                        The Ministers of Finance have decided to       ploying assessment rates. At present € 14
                        implement three amendments. Firstly,           billion flows into municipal coffers each
                        to avoid paying land transfer tax an exis-     year. Property tax reforms must be set
                        ting shareholder/seller must continue          out by the end of 2019 and implemented
                        to hold shares in the property company.        by the end of 2024.
                        Secondly, the maximum holding which
                        can be acquired through a share deal has       Three models are under discussion – the
                        been reduced to 89.9 %. In other words,        cost value model; the area model and the
                        in future the existing shareholder must        land tax model. The cost value model has
                        continue to hold a 10.1 % share for,           the advantage that 14 of Germany’s 16
                        thirdly, a period of at least ten years. The   states agreed to it 2016, although it is the

14
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

most complicated method to value the 35       as agreed in the German government’s
million properties around the country.        coalition contract and intended to mobi-
The model combines land values with           lise building land by taxing derelict plots.
retrospectively calculated construction
costs for any buildings. Modernisations,      TRENDS AND OUTLOOK
etc. are taken into consideration on a cy-    The investment property market is at
clical basis. Hamburg and Bavaria op-         its peak. In good and prime locations no
posed this model because it is expected       properties are being sold for less than
to result in significantly higher taxes for   the equivalent of 30 times the annual net
expensive locations.                          rent. Such multipliers form the basis for
                                              classification of districts’ location status.
Hamburg and Bavaria’s declared pre-           A district can become a good location if
ference is for the area model. It taxes       numerous new construction projects are
plot and building sizes at a uniform size-    sold at high price levels. The Schanzen-
based rate. Most of the data required for     viertel district is thus now a good location
this is already available. The solely land    instead of an up-and-coming one. Bah-
tax-based model is even simpler and           renfeld, with its many new construction
offers the additional benefit of presen-      projects, is also on the way to becoming
ting the greatest steering opportunities.     a good location. Northern Barmbek
Under the model, property tax would be        and Dulsberg are experiencing strong
based solely on plot value, regardless of     growth, as is Langenhorn. The latter is,
whether buildings have been erected on        however, too peripheral to become an
it or not. This figure is generally already   up-and-coming area. Hamm and Horn,
available within the scope of official land   in contrast, have all the characteristics
values. Using this model would make it        required to become up-and-coming mar-
possible to increase pressure on owners       kets, while Hammerbrook is already an
of unused derelict land and empty plots       up-and-coming district which should
to erect buildings instead of, for example,   experience good further development.
speculating on increases in value. This       Bergedorf will not become an up-and-
model also includes a Property Tax C,         coming district but instead will remain

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                            15
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

TURNOVER FOR OFFICE & COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES, INVESTMENT                                                                            PRICE DEVELOPMENT FOR FREEHOLD APARTMENTS in €
  PROPERTIES AND FREEHOLD APARTMENTS in € M 2006–2017                                                                                                 2006–2017
                    Office & commercial properties1     Investment properties1     Freehold apartments1                                                         Total purchase price         Price per square metre
1
    in Mio. €
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                              402.000
4.000
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                    366.000
                                                                                                                 3.449                                                                                                    345.000
3.500
                                                                                                                                                                                                                318.000
            2.941                                                                               3.013    2.834                                                                                        296.000
3.000
                                                                           2.612     2.612                       2.564                                                                      278.000
                                                                                                                                                                                  264.000
                                                                                                2.357    2.420
2.500                                                                                                                                                                   234.000
                                               2.014     1.937
                     1.817            1.869                        1.813             1.953                                      213.000   189.000   195.000   200.000
2.000                                                                      1.741
                                               1.610
                             1.281    1.340
1.500
            1.142   1.110                                1.720     1.721                                         1.613
                                                                                                         1.543
1.000                        1.173
           1.114                                                           1.188                1.214
                     1.133

                                                                                                                                 2.233

                                                                                                                                           2.158

                                                                                                                                                      2.212

                                                                                                                                                                2.320

                                                                                                                                                                          2.551

                                                                                                                                                                                    2.889

                                                                                                                                                                                              3.060

                                                                                                                                                                                                        3.328

                                                                                                                                                                                                                  3.573

                                                                                                                                                                                                                           3.828

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      4.185

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                4.628
                                                 886      901       873               800
    500
                               637     687
       0
           2006

                      2007

                               2008

                                        2009

                                                 2010

                                                          2011

                                                                    2012

                                                                            2013

                                                                                      2014

                                                                                                 2015

                                                                                                          2016

                                                                                                                                 2006

                                                                                                                                           2007

                                                                                                                                                      2008

                                                                                                                                                                2009

                                                                                                                                                                          2010

                                                                                                                                                                                    2011

                                                                                                                                                                                              2012

                                                                                                                                                                                                        2013

                                                                                                                                                                                                                 2014

                                                                                                                                                                                                                           2015

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      2016
                                                                                                                   2017

                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                2017
                                                                                             Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss

a less expensive location. The same also                         Prices developed laterally in the first half              further steps to increase interest rates. In                      of Germany’s property boom. Construc-
applies to the districts of Rothenburgsort                       of 2018. Valuation orders have been ac-                   Europe the European Central Bank (ECB)                            tion companies and trades thus have
and Veddel, both located near the city                           cumulating since summer 2017, while                       gave a clear signal with its announce-                            full order books for the next five years,
centre. Thanks to the residential districts                      the order situation has improved thanks                   ment in June that purchasing of bonds                             in turn leading to higher prices and re-
planned along the current axis of the                            to owners wishing to take advantage of                    would be phased out by the end of 2018.                           duced availability.
Wilhelmsburger Reichsstrasse, whose                              market conditions.                                        The base interest rate is, however, set
relocation to the east is scheduled to be                                                                                  to remain at 0 % until at least summer                            ALTERNATIVES FOR INVESTMENT
completed in 2019/2020, Wilhelmsburg                             The market has been characterised by                      2019.                                                             PROPERTY INVESTORS
has exciting potential for upgrading, alt-                       slow interest rate growth since 2016. It                                                                                    Land prices are a further cost driver
hough its proximity to commercial areas                          is unclear whether the Federal Reserve                    The investment property market has                                which can currently only be re-financed
can sometimes present problems.                                  (FED), the US central bank, will take any                 also been affected by the consequences                            by building freehold apartments. Social

16
INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

housing, constructed in line with a 30        to apply for conversion approval in good     average, in 2017 this figure had fallen to
% quota in Hamburg, is therefore beco-        time. They should also obtain certifica-     39 years old. Average apartments sizes
ming increasingly interesting for inves-      tion that units are sufficiently separate;   are also becoming smaller – caused by
tors since fewer privately financed new       have the declaration of aportionment of-     the decreasing size of new apartments,
investment properties are being built.        ficially certified in line with the German   in turn the result of partial compensation
                                              Apartment Owners Act and create land         for high price rises and the wish to crea-
A number of larger portfolio transactions     register entries for each apartment.         te more units per project. Square metre
at the end of 2017 have confirmed the                                                      prices have thus climbed by 10.6 % to €
existence of the phenomenon that lar-         RENTED FREEHOLD APARTMENTS                   4 628; this is higher than the increase in
ger portfolios achieve higher prices per      Rented freehold apartments are an            overall purchase prices.
property than would be the case if the        attractive alternative for private pro-
investment properties were sold individu-     perty investors. Thanks to the virtually     A study of popular locations and corres-
ally or in smaller portfolios, as described   non-existent vacancy rate in Hamburg,        ponding prices provides information on
in the 2017 market report. This bonus,        banks are prepared to provide 100 % fi-      the spectrum of purchasers and interest
resulting from the pressure on capital        nancing. Figures issued by the Hamburg       in districts which have good infrastruc-
experienced by large investors, means         Committee of Valuation Experts show          tures but are not necessarily close to
that prices are even higher for private       that 6 363 freehold apartments were          the city centre. The highest number of
and medium-sized investment property          sold in Hamburg in 2017 – 9.4 % less         sales, 387 apartments, was recorded in
investors, depriving them of investment       than in 2016. Capital turnover, however,     Winterhude (€ 5 148/m² average), ahead
opportunities.                                increased by 5.5 % to € 2.55 billion –       of what is by today’s standards mode-
                                              another all-time high on Hamburg’s real      rately priced Eimsbüttel (343 sales/€ 5
Developers wishing to privatise proper-       estate market. The price per apartment       042/m²). There were also more than 200
ties into smaller units are also experi-      has risen by 9.8 % to € 402 000 – higher     sales in Barmbek-Süd (270/€ 4 039/m²),
encing shortages due to the widening of       than the increase of 6.1 % from 2015         inexpensive Rahlstedt (228/€ 2 666/m²),
social preservation statutes in districts     to 2016.                                     Eppendorf (206/€ 5 596/m²) and Langen-
close to the city centre. Investment pro-                                                  horn (203/€ 3 881/m²).
perty owners who wish to have the op-         The larger number of newly constructed
tion of making flexible decisions which       properties means that the average age        In general it can be said that residential
are not dependent on social preservati-       of an apartment is declining. Whereas in     properties in Hamburg are, and will re-
on statutes when selling should be sure       2008 apartments were 48 years old on         main, secure capital investments.

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                      17
COMMERCIAL INVESTMENT IN HAMBURG   Hamburg is growing. The city’s red-
                                   green Senate expects 100 000 additional
                                   residents by 2030. International quality
                                   of life rankings place Hamburg near the
                                   top – British magazine ‘The Economist’
                                   for example currently ranks the “Gate-
                                   way to the world” 18th in the world.

                                   The city offers investors qualities which
                                   were once considered unexciting – sta-
                                   ble, reliable key economic data and a
                                   diversified economic profile with the
                                   port as a motor. The unemployment
                                   rate is 6 % while the number of people
                                   in work has increased by 100 000 over
                                   the past five years. With an overall eco-
                                   nomic productivity (per capita GDP) of
                                   € 60 000 Hamburg is one of Europe’s
                                   leading cities.

                                   The PWC and ULI real estate study
                                   “Emerging Trends in Real Estate Eu-
                                   rope”, published in early 2018, ranked
                                   Hamburg the 6th most important Eu-
                                   ropean major city out of a total of 30.

                                   THE COMMERCIAL INVESTMENT
                                   MARKET
                                   Figures published by the Hamburg Com-
                                   mittees of Valuation Experts on trade

18
Commercial Investment

      NUMBER OF OFFICE AND COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES SOLD                                                                       TAKE-UP (in 1.000 m2)

                                                                                        1200
400                                                                                                                                                                  1.081
       341
350                                                                                     1000
                                                    300    272    294    284                          911                                     906             867             855
300                                                                                                                                                   786
               241             235    247    225                                229      800
250                                                                                                         649              643     624
                        160                                                                                                                                                          583
200                                                                                      600
150                                                                                                                  380
                                                                                         400
100
                                                                                         200
 50
  0                                                                                        0
        2007

               2008

                        2009

                               2010

                                      2011

                                             2012

                                                    2013

                                                           2014

                                                                  2015

                                                                         2016

                                                                                2017

                                                                                                                                                                                     2017
                                                                                                   2007

                                                                                                            2008

                                                                                                                     2009

                                                                                                                             2010

                                                                                                                                     2011

                                                                                                                                              2012

                                                                                                                                                      2013

                                                                                                                                                              2014

                                                                                                                                                                       2015

                                                                                                                                                                              2016
in office and commercial real estate il-      half of the year the Springer residen-
lustrate the high level of interest in the    tial district in Neustadt, for example,
                                                                                                                               TURNOVER (in MIO. €)
city’s commercial properties. During the      purchased as a forward deal by the Doc-
real estate boom of 2006 and 2007, 334        tors’ Pension Funds of Lower Saxony,                                                                                                   3449
                                                                                         3500
respectively 341 transactions were con-       Saxony-Anhalt and Mecklenburg-Wes-                                                                                     3013 2834
                                                                                         3000
cluded – significantly more than the 229      tern Pomerania; the Veterinary Surge-                                                                  2612 2612
                                                                                         2500
contracts in 2017. Although the number        ons’ Pension Fund of Lower Saxony and                1817             1869
                                                                                                                            2014 1937 1813
                                                                                         2000
of transactions in 2017 was a third lower     the Tax Advisors’ Pension Fund of Lower
                                                                                         1500               1281
than in 2006, turnover, however, was €        Saxony, was one of the largest single
3.45 billion, the highest figure to date      property transactions ever to be con-      1000

and 17 % above the volume for 2006. At        cluded in Hamburg’s investment history.     500
over € 15 million the average transaction                                                      0
volume was also a new record.                 The vendor, the MOMENI and Black Hor-

                                                                                                                                                                                     2017
                                                                                                   2007

                                                                                                            2008

                                                                                                                     2009

                                                                                                                             2010

                                                                                                                                     2011

                                                                                                                                              2012

                                                                                                                                                      2013

                                                                                                                                                              2014

                                                                                                                                                                       2015

                                                                                                                                                                              2016
                                              se joint venture, achieved a sale price
An extremely high turnover volume is          of approximately € 400 million. The
once again expected for 2018. In the first    purchase of the Olympus Campus in the                                Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                                                   19
Commercial Investment

                                 City Süd district by the Doctors’ Pension     ahead, for example, of retail properties
                                 Fund of Westphalia-Lippe together with        in terms of turnover for the first half of
                                 Hines from project developers Campus          2018. Secondly, investors are focusing
                                 Properties 1, held by the Zech Group and      more strongly on district centres such
                                 Olympus, for € 260 million is indicative      as Langenhorner Markt. These centres
                                 of a trend on the investment market –         are the locations in which retail, other-
                                 large pension funds are acquiring large       wise experiencing a decline in district
                                 development projects.                         side streets and along arterial roads,
                                                                               is concentrated. This applies both to
                                 Of the five transactions worth over € 100     online-resistant local retailers such as
                                 million only one was an existing proper-      food sellers and drugstores as well as
                                 ty, the Sumatrakontor office building in      also small, owner-operated boutiques
                                 the HafenCity. The purchaser, Real I.S.,      and specialist businesses.
                                 a subsidiary of the Bayerische Landes-
                                 bank (Bayern LB), paid vendor Black-          In this context, developers, investors and
                                 stone just under € 190 million for the        brokers are focusing on the increasing
                                 mixed-use property with offices, shops        number of new construction areas being
                                 and apartments.                               created in local neighbourhoods –for ex-
                                                                               ample the “Unter den Linden” residen-
                                 BOROUGH CENTRES ON THE UP                     tial district in Langenhorn, where 850
                                 The sale of the “LaHoMa” district shop-       apartments are being built on the for-
     The LaHoMa is supposed to
                                 ping centre, comprising retail and gast-      mer site of a hospital. With its purchase
     be the new quarter centre   ronomy, medical offices and service are-      of the Berliner Platz shopping centre in
     of Langenhorn.
                                 as and also apartments, developed in          Hamburg-Jenfeld Matrix has already se-
                                 Langenhorn by Matrix and SEGDevelop-          cured its next development site, located
                                 ment for well over € 100 million is typical   near to the Jenfelder Au new residen-
                                 of two further important trends on the        tial district.
                                 investment market. Firstly, mixed-use
                                 properties have become an established         This trend in the boroughs is also con-
                                 feature of investor portfolios, moving        firmed by figures released by the Ham-

20
Commercial Investment

                                                                                                                                                                                                               Wohldorf-
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Ohlstedt
                                                                                                                                                                                         Duvenstedt

burg Committees of Valuation Experts          SALES IN THE DISTRICTS IN 2017                                                                                                                                                                                None
                                                                                                                                                                                         Lemsahl-
on the distribution of sales of office and                                                                                                                                              Mellingstedt                                                        1
commercial properties in 2017. Langen-                                                                                                                                                                 Bergstedt
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            2
horn, for example, recorded 11 tran-                                                                                                                                                   Poppen-
                                                                                                                                                                                        büttel
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            3
                                                                                                                                                        Langenhorn
sactions, the second-best result in the                                                                                                                                                                Sasel
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                            4
                                                                                                                                                                     Hummels-                                            Volksdorf
district ranking – behind Harburg with                                                                                                                                 büttel
                                                                                                                                                                                        Wellings-                                                           5 to 6
                                                                                                                                                                                         büttel
                                                                                                               Schnelsen
13 transactions. These districts were                                                                                             Niendorf
                                                                                                                                                    Fuhlsbüttel                                                                                             7 to 9
                                                                                                                                                                       Ohlsdorf
followed by Hammerbrook/City Süd (11                                                                                                                                                                                                                        10 and more
                                                                                                                                                                                                                       Rahlstedt
transactions) and Bergedorf (10). In a                                                                     Eidelstedt
                                                                                                                                               Groß
                                                                                                                                              Borstel
                                                                                                                                                          Alster-
                                                                                                                                                           dorf
                                                                                                                                                                             Steils-
                                                                                                                                                                              hoop
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Farmsen-
comparison over several years St. Pauli                                                                                           Lokstedt
                                                                                                                                                                                       Bramfeld       Berne

                                                                                                 Lurup                               Eppendorf              Barmbek-
(9), Finkenwerder (7) or Heimfeld (6) also                                                                           Stellingen                Winterhude      Nord                                    Tonndorf
                                                       Rissen                                                                      Hohe-                            Duls- Wands-
achieved above-average results.                                     Sülldorf    Iser-
                                                                                brook                                       Eims-
                                                                                                                                    luft
                                                                                                                                       Harveste-         Barmbek-
                                                                                                                                                                    berg    bek
                                                                                                                                         hude                Süd                                         Jenfeld
                                                                                        Osdorf          Bahrenfeld          büttel
                                                                                                                                                 Uhlenhorst
                                                                                                                      Sternschanze                             Eilbek Marienthal
                                                                                                                                      Rotherbaum
                                                                Blankenese                          Groß                Altona                       Hohen-
COMPETING USES                                                                                    Flottbek              -Nord                     St. felde
                                                                                                                                         Neu- Georg Borg-
                                                                                  Nienstedten                                      St. stadt Alt-         felde Hamm       Horn
In recent years the city centre with the                                                          Othmarschen
                                                                                                                Otten-
                                                                                                                  sen    Altona Pauli
                                                                                                                       -Altstadt
                                                                                                                                             stadt Hammer-
                                                                                                                                                      brook                                               Billstedt

Altstadt (7) and Neustadt (10) districts,                       Cranz
                                                                                Finkenwerder                                                            HafenCity
                                                                                                                                                                       Rothen-
                                                                                                             Waltershof           Steinwerder                          burgsort
traditionally a front runner, has decli-                                                                                                            Kleiner
                                                                                                                                                   Grasbrook
                                                                                                                                                                                           Billbrook

                                                                                                                                                                    Veddel
ned in importance. This is a reflection
                                                                   Neuenfelde                                  Altenwerder
of both the scarcity of offerings and also                                                Francop
                                                                                                                                                                                          Moorfleet
                                                                                                                                                                                                                              Lohbrügge
                                                                                                                                                                                                               Billwerder
the widening gap between office and re-                                                                                                         Wilhelmsburg
                                                                                                                                                                                       Taten-
                                                                                                                     Moorburg                                                           berg                   Neuallermöhe
tail space performance, which is beco-                                                                                                                                            Spaden-                                                 Bergedorf
                                                                                 Neugraben-                                                                                         land                              Allermöhe
ming ever more apparent on the mar-                                               Fischbek
                                                                                                         Hausbruch
                                                                                                                                                                                                                  Reitbrook
ket. Parallel to this, there are also other                                                                             Heimfeld                             Neuland                       Ochsenwerder
                                                                                                                                              Harburg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                 Curslack
competitors for space in the city centre,                                                                                                                                                                                          Neuengamme
                                                                                                                           Eißendorf
namely hotels and – in future – city-cen-                                                                                                        Wilstorf             Gut Moor                                                                                  Altengamme
                                                                                                                                   Marmstorf
tre logistics operations.                                                                                                                                             Rönneburg
                                                                                                                                                                                                                        Kirchwerder
                                                                                                                                             Sinstorf        Langenbek

OFFICE REAL ESTATE
Office space is in demand – from inves-
tors and from tenants, with office space      Source: Property Market Report 2018, Gutachterausschuss

zinshausteam-kenbo.de                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        21
                                                                   Keine
                                                                    1
Commercial Investment

                          take-up reflecting Hamburg’s diversified      figure space was with the Signal Iduna
                          economic profile. In the first half of 2018   insurance company – an interim solution
                          no one single sector achieved a share         for 10 000 m² in the Vattenfall building in
                          exceeding 20 % of take-up. Logistics,         City Nord. The second-largest transac-
                          public authorities, insurance/banking,        tion illustrates the co-working companies
                          industry and construction & real estate       are becoming an ever bigger force to be
                          were the top five sectors. At some 250        reckoned with – Design Offices will oc-
                          000 m², take-up in the first half of the      cupy 8 600 m² at the Olympus Campus,
                          year is below the record figure for 2017,     currently under construction, also as a
The largest single        however the decline has been caused by        puffer space for Olympus. Also in the City
property transaction in   the scarcity of offerings, not lack of de-    Süd district, at the Economic Center in
Hamburg‘s investment
history: The „Springer    mand. The vacancy rate correspondin-          Heidenkampsweg, municipal company
Quartier“ project         gly fell to approx. 4 % – the lowest level    f&w fördern und wohnen leased just un-
                          since the new economy boom of 2001.           der 8 600 m², while the largest contract
                          Hamburg currently has less than 600           concluded in the city centre was by the
                          000 m² of vacant office space, a figure       Zeaborn shipping company, founded by
                          which is lower than that for annual office    Kurt Zech, for 5 300 m² in the Tower am
                          take-up – for example over 600 000 m² in      Michel building.
                          2017. The room for manoeuvre available
                          to expanding companies is thus severely       MIXED USE CAUSES SUPPLY
                          limited – in particular against the back-     SHORTAGES
                          drop that any specialist employees who        The availability of office space will not
                          are recruited have high expectations as       improve in the next two to three years.
                          regards their workplace. This applies to      Some 320 000 m² of office space will be
                          both office furnishings and also to the       completed in 2018 and 2019, however
                          urban flair of the surrounding area.          just under two-thirds of this space has
                                                                        already been let. New projects are not
                          Turnover has thus been achieved with vir-     actually creating large amounts of office
                          tually no large-scale transactions. The       space. This is particularly the case for
                          only rental contract concluded for a five-    popular city centre locations. Although

22
Commercial Investment

                                  PRICE INDEX FOR COMMMERCIAL INVESTMENT PROPERTIES

LOCATION                                                   MICRO-LOCATIONS UNDER DEVELOPMENT                   MULTIPLIER        TREND

                                                                                                               27 - 32 times
City                                                    Kontorhausviertel, Nikolaiviertel, Springer Quartier   annual rent

                                                                                                               25 - 29 times
HafenCity                                               Baakenhafen, Elbbrücken                                annual rent        Ò
                                                                                                               22 - 28 times
Eimsbüttel, Eppendorf, Hoheluft                                                                                annual rent        Ò
                                                                                                               22 - 27 times
Hafenrand                                                                                                      annual rent        Ò
                                                                                                               22 - 26 times
St. Georg, Uhlenhorst, Winterhude (City Nord)           Überseering                                            annual rent        Ò
                                                                                                               21 - 26 times
Hammerbrook (City Süd)                                  Nordkanalstraße, Sonninstraße, Spaldingstraße          annual rent

                                                                                                               20 - 27 times
Altona, Bahrenfeld, Ottensen, Sternschanze, St. Pauli   Gasstraße, Neue Große Bergstraße, Diebsteich           annual rent        Ò

                                                                                                                                              23
Commercial Investment

                        projects such as the Springer residential     CO-WORKING INCREASINGLY
                        district; new construction on the former      POPULAR
                        site of the Commerzbank or the Burstah        Co-working companies have been pre-
                        Ensemble on the former Allianz premi-         sent on the market since 2017 and are
                        ses in Großer Burstah are creating more       financially strong competitors for scar-
                        gross floor area (GFA), they are not crea-    ce large office spaces in the city centre.
                        ting more office space than previously        Such companies are expanding signifi-
                        available. To obtain planning permission      cantly although projects dedicated so-
                        for enclosed plots developers must ful-       lely to co-working are relatively rare.
                        fil the goal of creating a mixed-use city     Companies such as WeWork, Mindspace,
                        by including housing and office space in      Spaces or Design Offices, strongly re-
                        their plans as well as integrating a hotel,   presented in Hamburg, provide a mix of
                        retail or communal use areas. The con-        separate offices, as offered in business
                        sequence of this is that modern, needs-       centres, with open-plan areas shared by
                        oriented office space is coming onto the      various users (sharing spaces).
                        market, however the volume is not much
                        larger than previously. Office space is be-   In 2017 almost 50 000 m² were leased
                        coming ever scarcer and more expensive.       in Hamburg alone to set up such fle-
                        This applies both in terms of rents, which    xibly usable office space. Contracts for
                        can be up to € 27/m², and purchase pri-       just under 25 000 m² have already been
                        ces. Yields and vacancy rates are falling     concluded in 2018, with the focus on the
                        at the same rate. The Hamburg Com-            city centre.
                        mittees of Valuation Experts identified
                        an average yield multiplier (yield) of 25.1   LACK OF SMALL PROJECTS
                        for office and commercial properties in       Office space is becoming increasingly
                        the city centre in 2017. Maximum yields       scarce and – other than is the case for
                        – for example for the Kaisergalerie office    large-scale projects – there are few
                        and retail complex in Große Bleichen –        smaller development projects to reme-
                        of over 30 times the annual net rent are      dy this situation. Developers working on
                        thus being achieved.                          refurtohment projects are looking for

24
You can also read