Cointelegraph Report: Why are Crypto Funds Investing in Dash? 2022
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Authors, Contributors, and Report Partners Data Providers Contributors REKT CAPITAL Funds Invested in Dash That Opted to Be Mentioned in the Report © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 2
Highlights 8 Out of the 2000 funds surveyed by 8 Dash’s average transaction fee in 2021 was Cointelegraph Research regarding their $0.005 compared to Ethereum’s $21.9 and investment allocation to Dash, 200 Bitcoin’s $10.3. responded. Out of the respondents, 19 8 Dash can theoretically reach about 56 funds hold Dash, and over 40 funds plan to transactions per second, more than 4.8 invest in Dash in the next 12 months. 70% of million transactions per day. In practice, the respondents requested to receive the final highest number of Dash transactions in a results of this investment thesis report. single day was over 3 million in November 8 Dash’s price in 2021 (51.36%) outperformed 2018, when a stress test was performed on Bitcoin’s (45.76%). the network. This was a new all-time-high record for a Bitcoin-based blockchain. 8 If a whale bought $1 million worth of Dash on Kraken with a market order, the price would 8 A research paper titled Block Propagation shoot to $378 per Dash, but if the whale Applied to Nakamoto Networks, published by was savvy and used a smart order routing the blockchain research laboratory at Arizona software like CoinRoutes, the price would only State University (ASU) concluded that the Dash go up approximately $3 in the current market. network can scale on-chain to over half of A $10 million investment would send Dash to PayPal’s current transaction levels with ease. above $4000 in price even if using software 8 Q4 of 2022 will mark an important milestone like CoinRoutes to break up the trade into in Dash’s evolution. With the mainnet launch thousands of little trades on different order of Dash Platform, developers and users will be books. This is because there is only around able to embrace the benefits of decentralized 58,000 Dash in all of the order books on all applications. exchanges right now. 8 The Valkyrie Dash Trust is Dash’s first 8 Dash launched five years after Bitcoin in 2014 investment trust and enables investors to gain and outperformed Bitcoin in four out of the exposure to Dash without having to worry seven years (2014, 2015, 2016 and 2017). about custody and security. 8 Dash solves the scaling problem while 8 The best execution price for people interested remaining decentralized by combining the in buying Dash on exchanges was Coinbase proof-of-work and proof-of-stake consensus Pro and Binance US in 2021. mechanisms. ROI Since Inception: 44,291.76% © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 3
Dear Partners, Explore Investors and Friends, Cointelegraph Research proudly presents the first investment thesis report written on the legacy cryptocurrency Dash. To gain a deeper understanding of how investors feel about Dash, an original survey of over 2,000 crypto funds was Explore conducted during 2021. This 80-page report written by five authors across the globe showcases which funds currently hold Dash and the number of funds that plan to invest in Dash during the next year. This report delves into the unique features of Dash that continue to deliver a value-driven growth story. Dash has set itself apart from Bitcoin and other blockchains by becoming one of the most prominent digital currencies that focuses on payments, i.e., becoming digital cash. Explore True to its promise of providing instant transactions and micro-fees, Dash is now accepted by merchants across the world that embrace Dash’s speed and low transaction fees. But is Dash only digital cash, or are there use cases beyond payments? This report explores how the Dash protocol’s unique design provides security Explore benefits for its users and provides a deep analysis of the tokenomics and value proposition. We highlight how investors can engage with Dash’s success story and what future possibilities for users and developers will arise from innovations that Dash will launch in the near future. The launch of Dash Platform will provide a new ecosystem that features decentralized applications and data storage. Bearing in mind these significant changes, Dash has the potential to evolve from digital cash Explore to a fully decentralized ecosystem adding to the value of Dash as a cryptocurrency and blockchain project. Besides a more in-depth financial and technical analysis of Dash, we also provide an overview of important regulatory developments for cryptocurrencies and Dash in particular. Please enjoy reading Cointelegraph Research’s analysis of Dash. This report greatly benefited from the insights provided by Dash Marketing and Business Explore Development Manager Mark Mason and the technical analysis provided by Rekt Capital. We also want to give a big thanks to the over 200 cryptocurrency funds that responded to our survey. Cointelegraph Research helps blockchain companies communicate their cutting- edge research to the world by writing, designing, and publishing professional reports. We help companies gain wider audiences by developing educational Explore materials in the form of in-depth reports. Our team of academics and seasoned blockchain technologists can cover a diverse range of topics, including tokenomics, macroeconomics, legal, tax, central bank digital currencies, decentralized finance, supply chain logistics, and venture capital. To work with Cointelegraph Research’s team on creating a one-of-a-kind report, contact us at research@cointelegraph.com. Explore Sincerely Demelza Hays Head of Research at Cointelegraph Demelza Hays is the director of research at Cointelegraph, Forbes 30 Under 30, U.S. Department of State Fulbright Scholar, and former fund manager of two regulated crypto funds. 4
Contents 1. Bitcoin Is Digital Gold, and Dash Is Digital Cash 7 1.1 The Transaction Fee Problem 7 1.2 Dash’s Masternode Solution 9 1.3 Dash’s Vision 12 1.4 What is Dash? 13 1.5 Dash Compared to Bitcoin 16 2. Dash Compared to Ethereum 22 2.1The Dash Investment Foundation 27 2.2 What does the DIF do? 27 2.3 Why was the DIF created? 28 3. Blockchain Is Evolving with Dash Platform 32 3.1 Dash Is Becoming a Decentralized Cloud 32 3.2 Decentralized Storage (Dash Drive) 33 3.3 Decentralized API (DAPI) 34 3.4 Dash Platform Name Service (DPNS) 34 3.5 Dash Platform Protocol (DPP) 35 4. Improving Dash as a Store of Value 36 4.1 Introduction 36 4.2 Coins in Circulation and Inflation 38 4.3 Changes to Reward Structure 39 5. Dash as an Emerging Asset: Returns and Liquidity 41 5.1 Dash in a Traditional Portfolio 42 5.2 Optimal Allocation 44 5.3 Dash in a Cryptocurrency Portfolio 52 5.4 Dash Seasonality: The Best Time to Buy and Sell Dash 53 5.5 Best Execution for Large Investors Buying Dash 55 6. 2022–2025 Price Forecast 58 7. Regulation 68 7.1 Dash and Privacy 68 7.2 FATF Travel Rule — International 72 7.3 The United States — Regulatory Asset Classification 73 7.4 MiCA and 6AMLD — Europe 74 7.5 Asia Region 76 7.6 Blockchain Association Memberships 77 8. How To Get More Involved With Dash! 79 9. Future Outlook 81 © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 5
Cointelegraph Team Demelza Hays, Ph.D. Alexander Valentin Demelza Hays is the director of After finishing his B.Sc. in Economics research at Cointelegraph, and at the University of Mannheim, formerly was a Forbes 30 Under 30, Alexander enrolled in the Ph.D. U.S. Department of State Fulbright program in Economics at Goethe Scholar, and fund manager of two University in Frankfurt receiving his regulated crypto funds. M.Sc. degree in 2018. Ron Mendoza Nikita Malkin Ron has worked in business 3+ years of working experience in development for several investment crypto sphere and finance. Higher firms in Dubai and Abu Dhabi for School of Economics graduate with more than six years. He has also diploma work related to digital asset covered cryptocurrency, blockchain, market. Co-author of Security Token and fintech topics for several Report and research analyst at publications since 2019. Cointelegraph Research. Helen Rosenberg Igor Kravchenko Helen Rosenberg is a research analyst Igor Kravchenko is a research analyst at Cointelegraph, holds a bachelors’ at Cointelegraph. He is currently degree in economics and finance pursuing a master’s degree in and has co-authored three reports at quantitative finance at the Vienna Cointelegraph Research. University of Economics and Finance. Solomon Guy Solomon Guy has a decade of commercial experience with a passion for research, analysis and technology. Since completing a dual bachelors in Physics and Business Management, Sol has worked in commercial, market and venture analysis roles for innovative tech firms across the globe. © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 6
1 Bitcoin Is Digital Gold, and Dash Is Digital Cash Along with Bitcoin, Dash is one of the oldest USA (60) followed by 15% from the United Kingdom cryptocurrencies that is still active today. Over the (30), 10% from Germany (20), followed by Hong last eight years, Dash has set itself apart from Bitcoin Kong, Singapore, Switzerland, Australia, Cayman and other blockchains by becoming one of the most Islands, Malta, and UAE. The respondents managed prominent digital currencies that focuses on payments, approximately $1.2 billion in cryptocurrency and i.e., becoming digital cash instead of digital gold. blockchain investments. To gain more insight into Dash’s stakeholders and Interestingly, this study found that nearly 10% of the community, Cointelegraph Research conducted a first- survey’s 200 asset allocators said they have exposure of-its-kind survey on the investment allocation of over to Dash in the portfolio already. Additional 40 funds 2,000 global crypto funds and certificates. The survey reported that they wanted to invest in Dash during the was conducted via email between March 2021 and next 12 months, and 70% of respondents requested December 2021. Out of the 200 funds that responded to receive the final results of this investment thesis to the survey, 30% of the respondents came from the report. Figure 1 Is Your Company Invested in Dash Currently? 10% No Yes Source: Cointelegraph Research 90% The 19 funds that hold Dash include Digital Capital When asked why they invested in Dash, a similar Management, Liquibit Limited, BN Capital, Postera answer was echoed by several of the respondents. Capital, Blockwall Capital, Hilbert Capital, Smart Block The Dash community is actively trying to become a Laboratory, Asymmetry Asset Management, Resilience medium of exchange. Real-world use drives organic AG, Pecun.io, All Blue Capital, INDX Capital, EZCAMG, demand for the asset as opposed to only speculative Plutus21Capital, How2Ventures, Block Ventures, demand associated with many other cryptocurrencies. Parallax Digital, and Bohr Arbitrage Crypto Fund. As one respondent succinctly stated, “Bitcoin is digital Figure 2 shows the geographic dispersion of the 20 gold and Dash is digital cash.” actively managed cryptocurrency funds and structured In addition to the 19 funds that currently hold Dash, products that hold the cryptocurrency Dash. The fact 40 funds reported that they plan to invest in Dash that almost every continent has a fund that holds Dash over the next twelve months. Some of the notable is a testament to the global brand awareness that funds that plan to add Dash include 31Q Digital Asset Dash has achieved over the last eight years. [Figure 2] Management, Astronaut Capital, Pnyx Ventures, Crypton, Caliberco, and Kadena. © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 7
Figure 2 Funds that Hold Dash Around the World Source: Cointelegraph Research In addition to crypto funds and certificates, there are By using the trust as a vehicle for investment, also trusts that hold Dash. The first Dash trust launched clients can rely on a third-party custodian to hold in 2021. The Valkyrie Dash Trust invests exclusively and secure their coins, which means that investors in Dash and aims to provide an annualized yield of 1 face no additional investment risk stemming from 2.5%–4% in addition to the total return of Dash.2 cryptocurrency wallets and keys. BitGo for Valkyrie Dash Trust will be the custodian, which has also been The trust invests via staking, which means committing listed as custodian for the Valkyrie Bitcoin Trust.4 a certain amount of Dash to the network in order to Investments into the Valkyrie Dash Trust can be made verify transactions, for example. Staking is incentivized via United States bank wires or Dash transactions. through rewarding investors depending on the staking duration and the number of staked coins. While Besides offering a more traditional investment vehicle staking Dash can also be done through running a for individuals and institutions to gain exposure to the masternode, the required amount of Dash to do so crypto space, the trust prepares a tax statement and stands at 1,000 Dash. Given the current price of Dash, can also be accessed through an individual retirement this well exceeds $100,000. In contrast, the Valkyrie account, or IRA. Dash Trust accepts investments starting at $25,000. 3 Dash is a well-known, respected name in the payments space in many areas of the world, and has an engaged, loyal following. One of our goals at Valkyrie is to enable Insider Insight those underserved by traditional financial firms to have access to financial services, and expanding investment into the Dash ecosystem is part of that mission. Leah Wald, CEO at Valkyrie Investments 1 https://valkyrieinvest.com/trusts/dash-trust/ 2 ibid 3 https://www.dash.org/blog/introducing-the-valkyrie-dash-trust-vdash-now-with-staking/ 4 https://cryptoresearch.report/crypto-research/valkyrie-investments-have-launched-the-valkyrie-dash-trust/ © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 8
Figure 3 Does Your Company Plan to Buy Dash During the Next 12 Months? 20% No Yes Source: Cointelegraph Research 80% The rest of this report explores the exciting changes by a Decentralized Autonomous Organization (DAO). that Dash is planning to make in 2022. First and Dash’s Cayman-based investment arm called the Dash foremost is the rollout of the highly anticipated Investment Foundation is exclusively funded from Dash Platform. In addition to the exciting future the cryptocurrency’s DAO treasury and profits from developments, this report also highlights Dash’s investments are used to support the Dash network’s investment partnerships in recent years as well as growth. Future developments of Dash and exciting Dash’s impressive price performance and role as a updates are described in Chapter 3 followed by a deep crypto asset with traditional stock and bond portfolios. dive on how Dash has improved its store of value capabilities in Chapter 4. Then we move on to the The breakdown of this report is as follows: Chapter 1 statistical properties of Dash as a financial asset and its explains how Dash works under the hood and focuses performance in a traditional stock and bond portfolio in on how Dash tackles the infamous transaction fee Chapter 5. Rekt Capital analyzes Dash using Technical problem associated with Bitcoin. We then explore Analysis in Chapter 6. We discuss developments around Dash’s staking rewards and the first US-based the regulation of cryptocurrencies and Dash in Chapter investment trust that allows investors to gain Dash 7 and finish up the report with easy steps on how to get exposure like the Grayscale’s Bitcoin Trust. Chapter involved with Dash! 2 dwelves into the first regulated hedge fund owned 1.1 The Transaction Fee Problem Key Takeaways 8 Dash’s price in 2021 (51.36%) outperformed Bitcoin’s (45.76%). 8 Dash’s average transaction fee in 2021 was $0.01 compared to Ethereum’s $21.9 and Bitcoin’s $10.3. 8 In Q1 2022, the Dash blockchain is expanding its capabilities with decentralized usernames, and smart contracts are expected to be available in the following quarter. Before going into detail about Dash’s vision and As more people adopt cryptocurrencies, more technical features, this section will highlight how transactions need to be processed per second. Dash distinguishes itself from other cryptocurrencies More traffic on a blockchain network often leads to through its low transaction fees and impressive price increased transaction fees. The 2017 bull market performance since its inception. increased on-chain transaction volume and led to an © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 9
increase in transaction fees in Bitcoin and Ethereum. with Ethereum smart contracts could lead to costs The higher fees incentivized users to switch to more of more than $1,000 per transaction in 2021. Just as affordable blockchains to complete their transactions, in 2017, users now are switching to more affordable such as Dash, Bitcoin Cash, and Litecoin. In response blockchains in order to complete their transactions, to a decreasing market share, Bitcoin and Ethereum including Dash. developers began working on solutions to the Dash launched five years after Bitcoin in 2014 and transaction fee and latency problem. However, to outperformed Bitcoin in four out of the seven years this day, neither Bitcoin nor Ethereum has released (2014, 2015, 2016, and 2017). In 2021, the price of Dash solutions that have gained significant adoption. (51.36%) outperformed Bitcoin (45.76%). However, In the current bull market, Bitcoin and Ethereum have the Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) of Bitcoin already seen transaction fees of over $100. Interacting stands at 108% while Dash only has a CAGR of 85%.5 Figure 4 Annual Return — Dash vs. Bitcoin (2014–2021) 10,000 7,500 Annual Return (in %) 5,000 2,500 0 −2,500 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 Source: Coin Metrics, Cointelegraph Research BTC DASH Figure 5 Dash vs. Bitcoin 2021 300 250 200 Return (in %) 150 100 50 0 Gold S&P 500 BTC ETH DASH Source: Coin Metrics, Cointelegraph Research This report elaborates on why Dash has been and has already been achieved by Dash. In addition to will continue to be a leading digital asset over the having transaction fees that are fractions of a cent, coming years. The elusive quest for low transaction the network has instant settlement, and transactions fees that layer-two solutions such as Bitcoin’s are instantly respendable. This is all enabled by Dash’s Lightning Network and Ethereum 2.0 are chasing decentralized network of masternodes. 5 Based on first available price from Coin Metrics © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 10
However, the most exciting part of Dash is not its past mobile wallet so that users around the world can achievements, but rather its exciting roadmap for the send and receive digital cash without having to type future. With the launch of Dash Platform in Q4 2022, in cumbersome wallet addresses. Dash Platform also Dash is positioning itself to enter the Web3 arena tackles the business model of Google and Amazon where Polkadot and Dfinity’s Internet Computer are Web Services by decentralizing data storage across the currently making moves. Dash developers have built masternode network. decentralized usernames that work with the DashPay What is the main value that Dash offers compared to other cryptocurrencies? Insider Insight Dash is extremely innovative, as it combines battle-tested historical security with some important evolutions in privacy, technical efficiency and incentive mechanics of the traditional Bitcoin model. Due to these evolutions, Dash has the potential to deliver Fred Pye, chairman and differentiated value in certain niches, particularly in economically distressed countries. CEO of 3iQ Corp The most revolutionary aspect of Dash’s upcoming build fast, cheap and secure smart contract functionality software releases is the data contract. Dash’s data that will form the foundation for decentralized finance. contracts are similar to smart contracts, but they will Unlike Polkadot and Ethereum 2.0, Dash already has enable the creation of tokens and if-then functions to eight years under its belt of fast and cheap transactions be built on top of Dash. Dash is entering the ultimate with zero doublespends, contentious hard forks that race for distributed ledger technologies: the race to disrupt the community, or downtime. 1.2 Dash’s Masternode Solution Dash founder Evan Duffield envisions a world with upon the Bitcoin protocol in order to make this low transaction fees and fast payments for everyday philosophy a reality. This is why Bitcoin has become payments. Bitcoin’s original white paper also shared known as digital gold, and Dash is referred to as digital this philosophy, but Dash made specific improvements cash. Do you think that people will make daily purchases with cryptocurrencies in the future, such as buying a coffee? Definitely, the future is already here, as daily purchases have been a thing since the Insider Insight birth of crypto credit cards. Over the course of this period, infrastructure has grown tremendously, but we are still heavily relying on traditional systems for payment rails. Leonard Neo, head of research This semi-decentralized thematic, or rather transitory phase, will probably be the case at Stack Funds for the next few years, or until blockchains achieve sufficient scalability to handle bulk transactions. This is also evident in the second half of 2021, with several layer twos becoming popular with market participants. Having said that, we are still very early on this development, and it will take time for us to get there. © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 11
Dash is best known as the first cryptocurrency with a optional privacy and ChainLocks, which protects Dash focus on user-friendly payments and fast transaction against 51% mining attacks. This collateralization speeds. What may be less known is that these features ensures that the network is run only by actors heavily are implemented on top of a network of dedicated invested in its success and prevents outside attacks, servers known as masternodes, which enable the both on the network’s infrastructure and on the deployment of many exciting features unavailable governance process. on conventional blockchains. These features include Each Dash masternode requires 1,000 Dash to be instant and private transactions and unparalleled staked. The Dash can be unstaked at any time, and network security, as well as governance of the Dash partial staking solutions exist for traders who want to network development through a monthly budget and stake less than 1,000 Dash. Every month, the network voting. This, in itself, is vital in the crypto world, and pays approximately 4.719 Dash to each of the 4,500 the masternodes are necessary to achieve the optional active Dash masternodes that secure the network. By privacy, security and speed that Dash offers. reinvesting the 4.719 into crowd-staking solutions, traders In exchange for a part of the block reward, can benefit from compounding returns. Assuming the masternodes provide a second layer of services to price of Dash stays the same over a 10-year period for the network. They facilitate advanced functions such purposes of this calculation, the annualized rate increases as instantly settled and respendable transactions, by 2% when the monthly yield is staked. Figure 6 Dash Masternodes Earn 5.71% Annually (+2% If Reinvesting Returns) 6.4 25К Annualized Return (in USD) 6.2 20К Annualized Yield (in %) 6.0 15К 5.8 10К 5.6 5К 5.4 Jul ‘19 Oct ‘19 Jan ‘20 Apr ‘20 Jul ‘20 Oct ‘20 Jan ‘21 Apr ‘21 Jul ‘21 Oct ‘21 Jan ‘22 Source: MasterNodeStats6, Cointelegraph Research Annualized Yield (in %) Annualized return (in USD) Figure 7 Reinvesting Dash Masternode’s Monthly Payout Provides 2 Percentage Points Higher Return Per Year Over 10-Year Period $250K $200K $150K $100K 2024 2026 2028 2030 Source: Staking Rewards7, Cointelegraph Research Without Compouping No Compounding 6 See https://stats.masternode.me/network-report/ 7 See https://www.stakingrewards.com/earn/dash © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 12
Figure 8 ROI for Initial Investment of 1,000 Dash No Compounding With Compounding Amount Total Reward Rate Amount Total Reward Rate 1,000 DASH 58.35% 1,000 DASH 79.16% or 5.84% annualized or 7.92% annualized Term Term 10 years Est. Monthly Earning 10 years Est. Monthly Earning $700.93 VS $702.15 Type Type 4.79599 DASH 4.80428 DASH Run a Masternode Run a Masternode Est. Yearly Earning Est. Yearly Earning Price Price Current $8,528.02 Current $8,775.69 58.35116 DASH 60.04581 DASH Source: Staking Rewards 8, Cointelegraph Research 1.3 Dash’s Vision Dash, whose name is a portmanteau of “digital cash,” users.9 Dash Core Group CEO Ryan Taylor pointed out was launched in January 2014. Dash is an open-source that payment volume has been unaffected by these blockchain and cryptocurrency focused on offering lower numbers, which indicates that this drop is likely fast, cheap and secure decentralized global payments. of technical nature and might be associated with a microtransactions use case. After reaching more than 90,000 daily active users in Q2 2021, Dash saw a revision of active addresses With more than 50,000 daily active users in Q3 2021 in Q3 2021 as depicted in Figure 9. According to the there are more active Dash users each day than the Dash Core Group’s Q3 summary call, there was a number of people that fit in the Baseball stadium of large drop after Q2 2021 in the amount of daily active the New York Yankees. Figure 9 Average Daily Active Users Average Daily Active Addresses 100,000 90,700 83,500 85,200 85,700 85,900 80,900 80,000 60,000 53,200 52,200 40,000 20,000 0 Mar ‘20 Sep ‘20 Mar ‘21 Sep ‘21 Source: Coin Metrics, Cointelegraph Research 8 See Ibid 9 See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W_GJagFdd0g, minute 11:20 © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 13
Figure 10 Dash, Explained Who? Users What is Dash? ā Individuals ā Developers ā Businesses ā Network Operators Goal Why? Problems Financial freedom for everyone ā Traditional payment ā Fiat money is susceptible methods have high fraud to high inflation Your money, your way — move rates ā Most services charge too your money to anyone, anywhere, ā Most cryptocurrencies long anytime. have a poor user experience ā Risks of exposing sensitive Mission user data to theft Make payments as quick, easy, secure and inexpensive as possible. What? Features Features ā Easy to use ā Secure Due to the InstantSend feature, ā Instant ā Borderless payments settle within 2 seconds comparable to credit card ā Inexpensive ā Optional privacy authorizations. Unlike credit card authorizations, How? Specifications the recipient can utilize the incoming funds instantly. ā Payment Network ā Developer Platform ā Currency ā Applications Source: Dash Core Group A similar development can be seen in Figure 11 where As Figure 12 shows, the demand for Dash as a median daily transactions have decreased as well. On currency for transactions continues to be high. In Q3 a given day in Q3 2021, there were around 11,000 daily 2021, there were more than 145,000 Dash wallet apps transactions on the Dash network. This means that installed on mobile devices. As this number refers to within a month, the entire population of Cleveland, devices that have been active within the last 30 days Ohio would be able to make a transaction with Dash. and not all users allow app reporting on their private devices, the number may well be an estimate at the Dash Core Group (DCG) normally presents a chart lower bound. during its summary calls that refers to “economic transactions.” DCG’s results are different from Coin In the recent past, Dash has partnered with exchanges Metrics’ numbers because DCG’s number is calculated and payment providers to accelerate adoption of Dash as on-chain transactions excluding mixing and Coinbase across the globe. transactions, while Coin Metrics counts all transactions. © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 14
Figure 11 Median Number of Daily Transactions 40,000 32,800 Number of Transactions 30,000 26,800 27,400 23,300 23,900 20,100 20,000 10,800 11,300 10,000 0 Mar ‘20 Sep ‘20 Mar ‘21 Sep ‘21 Source: Coin Metrics, Cointelegraph Research Figure 12 Mobile Wallet Installations 149,000 150,000 145,000 150,000 142,300 113,055 100,000 50,000 0 Q3 2020 Q4 2020 Q1 2021 Q2 2021 Q3 2021 Source: Dash Core Group10, Cointelegraph Research Dash and CrayPay Use of Dash in Emerging Markets In January 2021, the Dash Investment Foundation Dash has been particularly successful as a means of (DIF) announced an investment in CrayPay, which payment in emerging markets. It has seen widespread offers instant rewards and savings as part of a adoption in Latin America where commercial loyalty program. As of July 2021, Dash users can now payments saw a 104% increase in Q1 2020.13 profit from CrayPay when paying with Dash using Additionally, Dash has partnered with Mexico’s Tauros the DashDirect app at retailers and restaurants that exchange to issue the first crypto debit card in South collaborate with CrayPay. Merchants partnering with America.14 CrayPay can be found at over 155,000 locations and Dash has increased adoption in Venezuela through on over 75 national U.S. retailer websites.11 This means wallet downloads and merchant acceptance. The surge that Dash is now accepted at “seven times more in- in Dash usage in Venezuela for real-world payments store merchant locations than Bitcoin (BTC) globally.”12 has come as the country continues to grapple with An important factor for why Dash and CrayPay crippling hyperinflation. Dash has become the de could successfully interact was Dash’s InstantSend facto cryptocurrency of choice for payments in technology. As each transaction can immediately be Venezuela. Dash has specific unique qualities that verified, CrayPay can instantly authorize the payment make it perfectly suited to the economic situation to merchants without chargeback risk — i.e., the of the country, allowing instant payments and lower reversal of a money transfer back to the client. transaction fees. 10 See https://dashpay.atlassian.net/wiki/download/attachments/68550659/DCG-Q3-2021-Quarterly-Call.pdf 11 See https://newsroom.dash.org/122917-dash-investment-foundation-dif-invests-in-craypay-and-announces-155000-merchant-instant-savings- app-for-dash 12 See https://finance.yahoo.com/news/dash-launches-payment-app-seven-070738748.html 13 See https://cointelegraph.com/news/dash-sees-100-rise-in-commercial-payments-through-latin-american-partnerships 14 See https://cointelegraph.com/news/dash-launches-latin-americas-first-ever-crypto-debit-card © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 15
Cryptocurrencies like Dash are even less volatile than for payments in 2021. CryptoBuyer has achieved the country’s fiat currency. Given the unprecedented mainstream crypto adoption and acceptance in LATAM currency devaluation of the bolivar, as well as with top brands such as Subway, Burger King, Pizza the difficulty of obtaining foreign fiat money, Hut, Samsung, Papa John’s Pizza, Traki and many more cryptocurrencies are a useful means of payment in using their point of sale (POS) solution. Venezuela. Dash payments have taken the lead with a substantial CryptoBuyer, the leading multi-coin supported total of 26.44% of transactions processed by cryptocurrency point of sale (POS) solution operating CryptoBuyer’s point of sale (POS) solution, surpassing in Latin America, including Venezuela, has published major cryptocurrencies and stablecoins like Bitcoin, results showing Dash as the most used cryptocurrency USDT, Ethereum and Litecoin. Figure 13 Cryptocurrency Merchant Payments Processed By CryptoBuyer In 2021 Dash 26.44% BTC 23.90% USDT 18.90% BNB 7.04% DAI 0.08% BUSD 7.77% XPT 0.07% ETH 2.08% LTC 13.67% Source: CryptoBuyer Dash has not only been successful across South with Dash, both online and at selected merchants. America but has made significant steps in Africa, The African market can especially benefit from the too. Together with AnkerPay, a South African crypto ease that Dash brings to the field of remittances. With payments provider, Dash has set out to bring the Dash many remittances coming from the United Kingdom network to Sub-Saharan Africa. Since May 2020, users and Europe, users can easily convert Dash to local in South Africa have been able to make payments currencies in Africa.15 Dash’s blockchain technology is optimized for instantly settled and secure payments that can scale on-chain to PayPal transaction volume levels while maintaining low transaction fees at a fraction of a cent. Dash’s masternode network transforms Dash in to a super-charged version of Bitcoin that provides real-world utility and a working payment solution that is fit for purpose. Dash’s InstantSend technology eliminates Insider Insight Marshall chargeback risks, which enables DashDirect to instantly authorize payment to our Greenwald, CEO merchant partners. Dash is the most efficient cryptocurrency payment option available at Ionia, Founder of DashDirect and its instant low-cost payments are what enable the significant merchant savings possible on our platform. We could not offer the same solution with blockchains such as Bitcoin or Ethereum in a non-custodial solution, due to high transaction fees and long confirmation times. With Dash the fees are minimal to us and the transactions are near-instant. Dash truly is digital cash and it performs impressively. 15 See https://newsroom.dash.org/95052-dash-partners-with-ankerpay-south-african-cryptocurrency-atm-and-pos-provider-to-grow-ecosystem- in-sub-saharan-africa © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 16
Besides the cooperation of Dash and CrayPay As depicted in Figure 14, Dash is spent for various use described above, Dash continues to explore new cases on CryptoRefills, a website that allows users to possibilities for cooperation with U.S. point-of-sale and buy gift cards, vouchers and top-ups in 180 countries payments service providers. This is related to both that use cryptocurrencies. payments and loyalty programs.16 CryptoRefills saw over a doubling of the use of Dash between January 2020 and January 2021. Insider Insight Massimiliano Silenzi, chairman and CEO of CryptoRefills In more than 75% of all CryptoRefills purchases from Europe, Asia and North America. [Figure 14] using Dash, the cryptocurrency was either spent for In addition to all of the ways that people can directly e-commerce gift cards and vouchers or for mobile spend Dash on goods and services, people can also recharges — i.e., buying call or data volume for convert Dash to cash using the global network of over cell phones. In line with the continents’ economic 6,177 Automated Teller Machines (ATMs) that accept significance, most spending on CryptoRefills came Dash. [Figure 15] Figure 14 CryptoRefills Dash Q4 2020 Spending by Product Category and Region 2% 3% 17% 16% 28% Europe E-commerce Asia Mobile recharge North America Games Africa Retail and food 23% South America 25% 56% 30% Source: CryptoRefills, Cointelegraph Research Figure 15 Worldwide Crypto ATM Supported Cryptocurrencies 40,000 34,612 30,000 26,296 26,103 20,000 11,632 9,535 10,000 6,389 6,177 4,433 1,686 390 0 Bitcoin Litecoin Ethereum Dogecoin Bitcoin Cash USDT Dash Zcash Monero XRP 1 23 2 12 27 4 79 66 39 8 Source: cointatmradar.com, coinmarketcap.com CoinMarketCap Rank Number of ATM’s 16 Dash Core Group Q3 2021 Summary Call © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 17
We love how easy Dash makes it to locate over 3,500 CoinFlip ATMs throughout the United States from within the official Dash wallet app. At CoinFlip, we strive to provide Insider Insight the best cash to crypto experience possible and we hope that by offering Dash, we’re able to reinforce that goal. Ben Weiss, Co- Founder and CEO at CoinFlip Figure 16 Dash ATM Map Source: cointatmradar.com The majority of ATMs that accept Dash are located in ATM market for Dash, followed by South American and the US, however, six continents have ATMs that accept Asia. Dash. After the US, the second most active © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 18
1.4 Dash Compared to Bitcoin Dash is a fork of Bitcoin that has introduced a user experience. The Dash network is also the longest- number of industry-shaping innovations, including running decentralized autonomous organization, masternodes, long-living masternode quorums utilizing on-chain governance to allocate network (LLMQ), ChainLocks and InstantSend, which target resources toward projects and organizations that scalability, speed, reliability, cost-effectiveness and the support the network without a central point of failure. Dash is a fork of Bitcoin Even with all its improvements, Dash still utilizes the same DNA of the Bitcoin protocol, so it can readily be integrated into the ecosystem already built around Bitcoin! 1.4.1 Governance Dash is a currency and a working decentralized the blocksize should be increased to 2 megabytes. autonomous organization (DAO). Dash was the Within 24 hours, consensus had been reached to first cryptocurrency DAO to have a self-funding, approve this change. Compare this to Bitcoin, where self-governing protocol. In addition to securing the debate on the blocksize has been raging for many network, masternodes govern Dash. The Decentralized years and has resulted in serious splits within the Governance by Blockchain, or DGBB, is Dash’s attempt community and even forks to the Bitcoin blockchain. to solve two important problems in cryptocurrency: governance and funding. Governance in a decentralized project is difficult because, by definition, there are no central authorities to make decisions for the project. Without effective governance, decentralized projects will either trend toward splits or toward centralization. In Dash, such decisions are made by the network — that is, by the owners of masternodes. The DGBB system allows each masternode to vote once (yes/ no/abstain) for each proposal. If a proposal passes, it then has to be implemented by Dash’s developers. A key example is early 2016, when Dash’s core team submitted a proposal to the network asking whether © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 19
Dash’s potential is still valid in a long perspective and shows reinvestment in the ecosystem’s growth. The two-tier network with “nodes” and larger “masternodes” Insider Insight efficiently separates system governance from creation of new coins. Alexander Baldele, managing partner at Caliber Consulting Figure 17 Dash’s Virtuous Cycle: The Dash Treasury Has More Money to Invest in the Development of the Code as the Price Increases Network Develops and Becomes More Valuable Project Devolopment Funding Price of Dash Appreciates More Development Money Available per Month Source: Cointelegraph Research A crucial feature of Dash is that governance occurs proposal to the network and apply for a grant. at the protocol level, similar to Tezos. In Dash, one This creates a positive feedback loop for the Dash masternode can be created with 1,000 Dash, and each network, as more development leads to increases in masternode gives its controller one vote for future the price as investors buy Dash off the market, and network proposals. then the next treasury cycle has more real purchasing A “collateral” of 1,000 Dash incentivizes masternodes power to pay for more development. This is referred to grant money to projects that serve only to benefit to as Dash’s perpetual network effect. the network and its value. Anybody can submit a Figure 18 Monthly Development Budget $1,483,500 2021 $32,000 2015 Source: Cointelegraph Research © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 20
Dash’s development is paid directly from the can stop payments to its current development team blockchain and is not dependent on donations, and start paying another at any time if the network foundations or any third party. The Dash network feels unsatisfied. Figure 19 Dash Can Hire a New Development Team Masternode network Dev Team A Dev Team B “We should implement changes A / B / C “Changes A / B / C aren’t good enough, to the protocol “ X / Y / Z is more effective” “Team A, we like what you've done up to now but you're no longer in line Source: Cointelegraph Research, Dash Core Group with what we want. We voted and we're hiring Team B” 1.4.2 Consensus A unique feature of Dash is its consensus mechanism, masternodes approve (instant) transactions, enable which is a hybrid of proof-of-work (PoW) and proof-of- financial privacy (CoinJoin), and build the foundation stake (PoS). While miners perform the task to secure for the decentralized governance and budget system.17 the network via PoW, the Dash network has a second As the masternodes provide a service for the network, layer that consists of so-called Masternodes. These their role is also referred to as a Proof of Service (PoSe). Figure 20 Dash Consensus Mechanism Is a Hybrid Between PoWork and PoS 40% of rewards 60% of rewards Maximum Maximum 20% of miner rewards 20% of masternode rewards * Previous rewards ratio were 45% Miners, 45% Masternodes, 10% Dash Treasury. Source: Cointelegraph Research, Dash Core Group * This change in rewards ratio will be done gradully over the period of 5 years. 17 See https://docs.dash.org/en/stable/masternodes/understanding.html © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 21
1.4.3 Dash’s Technical Solutions Special Transactions a block, no reorganization below that block is allowed. These LLMQs consist of subgroups of masternodes With the implementation of Dash Improvement that are periodically recreated. Proposal 2 in Q1 2019, Dash now allows for “special transactions.” These transactions are not financial in nature but include consensus-assisting metadata. Evidence for ChainLocks This is particularly relevant for the management of In January 2021, the cryptocurrency Firo masternodes. An example of a special transaction (formerly known as Zcoin) suffered a 51% is the masternode registration transaction. As a attack.18 This event is not unique as Ethereum masternode can only be created by proving ownership Classic and Grin have both suffered 51% of 1,000 Dash, this transaction proves ownership attacks as well. However, Firo followed Dash by and also sets certain parameters necessary for implementing ChainLocks. masternode operation. Neither Dash nor Firo has experienced Other special transactions can provide additional successful 51% attacks since the information on masternodes — e.g. updating an IP implementation of ChainLocks. address or other metadata — or assist in managing other system properties. Mixing Long-Living Masternode Quorums In order to allow for cash-like privacy features, (LLMQ) Dash has implemented CoinJoin (formerly known as PrivateSend). This feature allows users to make Long-Living Masternode Quorums (LLMQ) enable transactions in such a way that external observers increased security and scalability of the network. The cannot determine the source of funding. CoinJoin’s main task of LLMQs is to perform threshold signing process involves a sequence of transactions that are of consensus-related messages such as ChainLocks. also known as mixing.19 They also support InstantSend transaction locking. Quorums can be of different sizes depending on the Users can mix coins with other unknown people so security level needed for the respective function. that even an elaborate analysis of transactions through a block explorer cannot uncover the origin of funds. The CoinJoin process breaks transactions into several ChainLocks denominations and uses Dash’s masternodes to ChainLocks protect the blockchain against 51% mining coordinate a specific transaction request with other attacks. An LLMQ signs the first block seen and then users’ requests through a unique session ID. A user can notifies the network not to accept other blocks on determine the amount of Dash to be used for mixing the same level. Thus, a deep reorganization of the after which certain denominations of Dash are sent blockchain prior to this block can be avoided. This to different addresses, so called change addresses. feature enables the instant acceptance of payments. Eventually, all participating users send and receive the same amounts of Dash to their addresses, but there is The way ChainLocks work is for masternodes to form a no way to determine the exact mixture. By repeating quorum (the aforementioned LLMQ). Once more than this process several times, sufficient obfuscation is 60% of quorum members have signalled acceptance of reached so that transactions can be called private. 18 See https://cointelegraph.com/news/privacy-focused-firo-cryptocurrency-suffers-51-attack 19 See https://docs.dash.org/en/stable/introduction/features.html#coinjoin © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 22
Could Chainlocks prevent 51% attacks? You can’t attack the proof-of-work with a 51% attack because the masternodes are checkpointing with a vote using threshold signatures, and once 60% agree on the current Insider Insight state of the chain, that locks in that chain with a checkpoint. It’s a novel and interesting way to do a hybrid proof-of-work / proof-of-stake system, and yes, it will make 51% attacks much Andreas M. Antonopoulos harder on that particular chain. In fact, if you want to do a 51% attack, you actually have to do Technologist, author a 60% attack where you either compromise the code running on the masternodes, or you put and respected Bitcoin advocate enough stake, which probably wouldn’t be possible, to run 60% of the masternodes yourself. Source: Youtube 1.4.4 Development Roadmap Figure 21 The Mainnet Release of Dash Platform will be in Q4 2022 Q3 2021 Q4 2021 Q1 2022 DashPay Invitations (Android) Dash Platform v0.21 Dash Platform v0.22 TESTNET TESTNET TESTNET ā Platform v0.20 ā Error reporting improvements ā GroveDB initial release ā UI Improvements & Polishing ā Design robust state tree structure ā Ability to update data contracts ā Design document secondary indices ā Masternode identities ā Distribute testnet nodes ā Identity key purposes and security levels ā Upgrade Process ā Multi-package repository Q2 2022 Q2 2022 Q3 2022 Dash Core v0.18 Dash Platform v0.23 Dash Platform v0.23.x ā Quorum rotation, stronger IS security TESTNET TESTNET ā Proposal fee reduction ā Platform fee system ā Platform Decentralized API with Added new QT governance UI HTTPS ā ā Masternodes reward system Initial Enhanced Hard Forking ā Internal stress & security tests ā ā Platform credit withdrawal into Dash implementation ā Dash Platform mainnet release ā Complete Identities (DIP11) ā Deterministic InstantSend locks candidate ā BTC v0.18/v0.19/v0.20 backports ā Dash Platform MVP testnet validation ā External security audit ā External security audit Source: Dash Core Group,20 Cointelegraph Research Q4 2022 Q4 2022 2023 Dash Core v0.19 Dash Platform v1.0 Dash Platform ā BLS v1.0 implementation TESTNET ā Smart Contracts Virtual Machine ā Asset lock special transaction ā External security audit remediation ā Inter-Blockchain Communication ā Platform masternode reward MAINNET ā Fungible tokens support reallocation ā NFTs support ā Mainnet rollout ā Bitcoin backporting for v0.19/v0.20/ v0.21 ā Mainnet rollout 20 See https://www.dash.org/roadmap/ © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 23
There are two major sources of development on the well as masternode reward system will be added to Dash blockchain. The first is Dash Core Group’s and incentivize Platform participation.21 the second is the Dash Incubator. The Dash Incubator aims to improve Dash by For 2022, the Dash Core Group aims to reduce developing new features and inventing new technical proposal fees from 5 Dash to 1 Dash. This reduction solutions. Innovation will be the key driver for a is supposed to make the governance system more broader adoption of Dash among consumers. accessible, as lower fees allow a more diverse In 2021, Andy Freer, former Chief Technology Officer base of community members to voice their ideas. of Dash Core Group, stated that a key development However, it may come with the drawback that the for Dash would be to incentivize developers to create quality of proposals may decline. Additionally, the more trustless end-user applications. Decentralized mainnet launch of Dash Platform (formerly known applications (DApps) and the opportunity to monetize as Dash Evolution) is scheduled to take place in Q4 them will be key drivers for growth of the Dash 2022. As part of the Platform launch, a fee system as ecosystem.22 Figure 22 Dash Core GitHub Activity 1,064 29 Dev. Activity Contributors Count (DASH) 931 25 Development Activity (DASH) 798 21 665 18 532 14 399 10 266 7,322 133 3,661 0 0 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 Source: https://app.santiment.net/s/Vth_Wehd Development Activity (DASH) Dev. Activity Contributors Count (DASH) How is development activity on Dash? Development Activity is an off-chain indicator that monitors month-to-month commitment to creating a working product, polishing its features, and staying true to its long-term roadmap. While development activity may not tell you where a coin’s price is headed in the next 24 Maksim hours, it is one of the most underrated indicators of any crypto project’s long term success. Balashevich, Founder of Insider Insight According to Santiment data, Dash passes this test with flying colors. Dash’s development Santiment activity has exhibited consistent growth from 2015 onwards, with Dash developers continuing to push code through bull and bear cycles, stretches of price appreciation as well as major Dash corrections. Put simply, Dash’s development activity seems to suggest a lasting commitment to developing a working product, pushing new features and staying true to the project’s roadmap. While this probably means little for Dash’s short-term price action, it may speak volumes about the project’s long-term potential. 21 See https://www.dash.org/roadmap/ 22 See https://www.dash.org/forum/threads/re-post-andy-freer-former-dash-cto-shared-some-interesting-thoughts-on-dash-discord-today/ © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 24
1.5 Dash Compared to Ethereum 1.5.1 Development Roadmap For any blockchain network that puts special emphasis executed, which is directly related to the number of on monetary transactions, speed is a key feature in its transactions the network can execute at each point in value proposition. In that context, speed refers to the time. Benchmarks from the traditional financial system actual amount of time needed for a transaction to be can be found in the Visa system or PayPal. Table 2 Network Speed (Maximum Value for Transactions Per Second Provided Where Possible) Network Block Size Transactions per Second Visa − 65,000 (unverified, avg. at 1,700)23 PayPal − 1,00024 Dash 2MB25 5626 Ethereum ~65kB27 3028 Bitcoin 1MB29 730 Source: Cointelegraph Research Notwithstanding special features such as Dash’s it switches from traditional block propagation to “xthin InstantSend or Bitcoin’s Lightning Network, the block propagation,” a technique that significantly number of executed transactions is a function of speeds up the propagation of blocks among nodes.31 the block size and the block interval. While Dash A block size of 10MB would then allow Dash to reach currently offers 2MB blocks with a block time of over half of PayPal’s transaction levels.32 roughly 2.6 minutes, there is a constant effort to scale However, each new method of block propagation up transaction speed. While Ethereum limits its block comes with additional caveats such as higher latency size by the total amount of gas that can be spent and increased risk of network collision attacks.33 If to per block, Dash and other blockchains operate with bear in mind the numbers from Figure 23, it becomes a predetermined maximum block size for which the clear that while scalability remains an important goal, network has been optimized. current demand for transactions seems not to exceed Research from Arizona State University has shown capacity. that Dash could easily scale to a block size of 10MB if 23 See https://www.businesswire.com/news/home/20210329005171/en/Visa-Becomes-First-Major-Payments-Network-to-Settle-Transactions-in- USD-Coin-USDC 24 See https://time.com/5957001/paypal-cryptocurrencty-bitcoin-dan-schulman/ 25 See https://cointelegraph.com/explained/bitcoin-block-size-explained 26 See https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/9-000-transactions-per-second-bitcoin-sv-hits-new-record-301217145.html 27 See https://ycharts.com/indicators/ethereum_average_block_size 28 See https://www.thestreet.com/crypto/ethereum/ethereum-2-upgrade-what-you-need-to-know 29 See https://docs.dash.org/en/stable/introduction/features.html 30 See Ibid 31 See https://blockchain.asu.edu/block-propagation-applied-to-nakamoto-networks/ 32 See https://dashnews.org/new-asu-blockchain-lab-research-shows-dash-can-easily-scale-near-paypal-levels/ 33 See https://blockchain.asu.edu/velocity-scalability-improvements-in-block-propagation-through-rateless-erasure-coding/ © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 25
Figure 23 Actual Number of Transactions Per Second (30-day Median) 0.05 Transactions per Second 0.04 0.03 0.02 0.01 0 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 Source: Coin Metrics, Cointelegraph Research 1.5.2 Smart Contracts on Dash In early 2021, a testnet version of Dash Platform was A special feature of Dash Platform is the utilization launched. It provides the foundation for DApps on the of Dash’s decentralized API (DAPI). Through this API, Dash network. Essentially, it aims at enhancing Dash it is possible for DApps to easily read and write data with the features of a decentralized cloud service. from the Dash network without downloading the Through the launch of a second-layer blockchain, Dash entire blockchain. Developers will also be able to now provides the sufficient infrastructure to store data easily apply any coding language, such as JavaScript, to from DApps in a secure and decentralized fashion on develop their applications. This stands in contrast to the nodes of the Dash network. (For a more detailed most other DApps that must be written in blockchain- introduction of Dash Platform, please proceed to specific languages, such as Solidity or Vyper.34 Chapter 4.) Figure 24 Value Propositions of Dash Platform Decentralized API Flexible API Usage Decentralized Data Storage Source: Cointelegraph Research DApps on Dash Platform operate through the To be specific, a data contract specifies the data network’s equivalent of smart contracts, which are structure of the application, which is a necessary first called “Data Contracts.” These data contracts put step before storing data on the platform.36 Besides special emphasis on data storage as opposed to data contracts, the protocol of the Dash Platform regular smart contracts — e.g., on Ethereum — which provides the framework for two more data structures, are built for fast execution of code. Dash’s data namely “State Transitions” and “Documents.” State contracts offer a more efficient way to store data that Transitions are responsible for changes to data such may be of special interest to those applications that as updating information on a client or changes to the require fast retrieval and secure data storage.35 way a DApp works. User data is stored in Documents, and any change to data will be stored in a database hosted by the masternodes. 34 See https://ethereum.org/en/developers/docs/smart-contracts/languages/ 35 See https://hackernoon.com/building-dapps-on-dash-an-interview-with-readme-ay3a342g 36 See https://dashplatform.readme.io/docs © Cointelegraph Research, 2022 26
You can also read