Cardiology - Veterinary Practice
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
SMALL ANIMAL Cryosurgery in veterinary ophthalmology page 32 THE UK’S LEADING MONTHLY VETERINARY PUBLICATION DECEMBER/JANUARY 2019/20 OFFICIAL VET Pets, passports and problems page 52 EQUINE Modern equine cheek tooth extraction page 60 PRACTICE MANAGEMENT Growing through innovation: what can vets learn from start-ups? page 70 OPINION “Young solo vets carrying a bag Cardiology of drugs into an urban housing Managing feline arterial estate: what thromboembolism could go wrong?” page 72 Plus IN FOCUS Approaching cases of congestive heart failure in cats / EXOTICS Cardiac M facebook.com/vetpracticeonline disease in small mammals / SMALL ANIMAL Exocrine pancreatic insufficiency in dogs / LARGE ANIMAL Antimicrobial use in agriculture / EQUINE Achieving high-quality care / N @VetPractice_Mag OFFICIAL VET Do vets understand biosecurity? WWW.VETERINARY-PRACTICE.COM
SENIOR 40% of your clients’ pets are senior. Ensure they are on the right diet. VETERINARY HPM is an advanced low-carb, high-protein formulation specifically developed to support the long-term health and well-being of dogs and cats, the highly evolved carnivores in our own homes. 40% of dogs and cats are classified as senior1, but the pet food market doesn’t reflect this with just 14% of sales within the vet market being senior food2. Choosing the right nutrition for senior pets can help to prevent or slow down some of the metabolic changes associated with the ageing process3. FOR MORE INFORMATION, PLEASE SPEAK TO YOUR VIRBAC TERRITORY MANAGER VETERINARY HPM: advanced preventive nutrition, specially formulated for carnivores. Virbac Ltd, Woolpit Business Park, Windmill Avenue, Woolpit, Bury St Edmunds, Suffolk IP30 9UP. Tel: 01359243243 Email: enquiries@virbac.co.uk uk.virbac.com 1. FACCO survey, 2016. 2. AIEMV, Dry pet food sales of lifestage diets in France, Veterinary channel only, Jan-Dec 2018. 3. Sparkes AH. Feeding old cats-an update on new nutritional therapies. Top Companion Anim Med 2011; 26: 37-42. B
EDITOR’S WELCOME “This month, the focus is on cardiology” H appy holidays to those who Vivash Jones delving into the history of celebrate and welcome to the the profession as we know it. December and January double Reports from two insightful confer- issue of Veterinary Practice magazine. ences form our large animal section this This month, the focus is on cardiology, month – one outlining the proceedings with articles on the management of at the BCVA annual congress 2019 and congestive heart failure and arterial one reporting on the Responsible Use of thromboembolisms in cats. You can Medicines in Agriculture (RUMA) confer- also read about cardiac disease in small ence held at the end of October. mammals in the exotics column. The Official Vet section is back this The small animal section has features month, with two pertinent articles. Nick ranging from an overview of the use Perkins highlights common certification of cryosurgery in ophthalmology to a problems in small animal practice and report of a case of pemphigus foliaceus Alasdair MacNab discusses biosecurity an overview of holiday entitlements and in the dermatology column. Part two of within the veterinary world. what to do when you're "ghosted" by an the feline medicine mini-series on early BEVA President Tim Mair reviews the employee to ideas of what vet practices chronic kidney disease is an interesting implementation of "high-quality" care in can learn from tech start-ups. Sandeep read, focusing on nutritional manage- equine practice. An in-depth overview of Dattani provides insights of how you can ment of the disease. Make sure to check modern extraction techniques in equine start to prepare your practice for Brexit. out part one in last month's issue. dentistry is provided by Tim Barnett, Two interesting articles on the veteri- in which he discusses the diagnosis of nary profession, past, present and future diseased teeth, the indications for extrac- are also in this issue – from Gudrun tion and the different extraction methods Ravetz discussing shared challenges available. and solutions vets may share with other The practice management section this healthcare professionals and Bruce month is full of useful information: from AMELIA POWELL EDITOR A lifetime of LIFETIME £50 the best PET INSURANCE healthcare starts here pets Find out more at: We agriapet.co.uk/VPM EALTH CARE h you P E T H wit or call our friendly, UK team now: FRE r clients to s nd E pe For you 03330 30 10 30 Terms, conditions and excesses apply. Agria Pet Insurance Ltd is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority, Financial Services Register Number 496160. Agria Pet Insurance is registered and incorporated in England and Wales with registered number 4258783. Registered office: First Floor, Blue Leanie, Walton Street, Aylesbury, Buckinghamshire, HP21 7QW. AGRIA 1184.1 HS VP Banner Ad 185x62.5mm AW.indd 1 21/01/2019 12:09 Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 1
in association with Pet ID CONTENTS IN FOCUS 40 Feline arterial thromboembolism Current trends in the diagnosis and management of the condition, both in hospital and at home. 44 Congestive heart failure in cats Teamwork, client communication and a good understanding of available treatments are key. 47 A look through the latest literature The latest academic publications providing further insight into this month’s “In focus” topic. REGULARS 20 Outreach Livestock health training workshop in Kenya. 4 News 23 Education A snapshot of the topics currently hitting industry Creating engaging and informative CPD online. headlines. 24 Exotics 12 The profession Cardiac disease in small exotic mammals. Veterinary and medical professions share parallel challenges, so can we benefit from parallel solutions? SMALL ANIMAL 14 History 26 Nutrition We should recognise the individuals who have An overview of canine exocrine pancreatic carved the veterinary profession as we know it. insufficiency and Purina’s new approach to managing sensitivities to cat allergens. 16 RCVS Knowledge Do daily probiotic supplements improve clinical 29 Dermatology outcomes in cases of canine acute diarrhoea? Approaching cases of pemphigus foliaceus in cats. 17 Insurance 32 Ophthalmology Neutering in dogs: a health and behavioural debate. Cryotherapy in cases seen on a regular basis. 18 Mental health Non-judgement is accepting your thoughts and 35 Feline medicine feelings. Managing early chronic kidney disease. 19 Sustainability 38 Rare diseases Implementing the three Rs in veterinary practice. An insight into exercise-induced collapse in dogs. EDITORIAL ADVERTISING ENQUIRIES Nic Catterall EDITOR 07730 762136 Amelia Powell nic.catterall@improveinternational.com DESIGN Improve International EDITORIAL ENQUIRIES Veterinary Practice (ISSN: 0042-4897) is an independent Amelia Powell Improve International, monthly publication, free to members of the veterinary PRINTING 07704 306843 Alexandra House, profession in the UK. Buxton Press amelia.powell@improveinternational.com Whittingham Drive, Swindon, Volume 51, number 10 SN4 0QJ M facebook.com/vetpracticeonline N @VetPractice_Mag © Improve International (2019): no part of this publication may be reproduced in any form (except for review purposes) without the express permission of the editor. 2
the ultimate microchip solution OFFICIAL VET 48 News and updates The latest news and updates for OVs. 50 Do vets understand biosecurity? Are our biosecurity standards up to scratch? 52 Pets, passports and problems Certification pitfalls in small animal practice. LARGE ANIMAL 54 BCVA What was discussed at the British Cattle Veterinary Pet-ID Microchips www.pet-idmicrochips.com tel +44 (0)1273 837676 Association Congress 2019? 57 Antimicrobial use in agriculture 66 Employment An update from the RUMA 2019 conference. Understanding holiday entitlements. EQUINE 68 Marketing Making sure your website is optimised for use. 58 Achieving high-quality care 69 Finance How can “quality improvement” be applied to Business protection and making sure you are equine practice? adequately covered. 60 Dentistry 70 Business Teeth can be extracted quickly and efficiently, but Growing through innovation: what can vets learn thorough workups are still vital. from start-ups? PRACTICE MANAGEMENT OPINION 64 Brexit 22 Clifford Warwick How should practices prepare for Brexit? “It is important to recognise the formal responsibility of a veterinarian” 65 Legal What to do when faced with an employee who 72 Gareth Cross resigns with immediate effect. “Young solo vets carrying a bag of drugs into an urban housing estate: what could go wrong?” For Dogs For Cats Topical antibiotic for treatment of acute surface pyoderma The ONLY ORAL LIQUID therapy for management of hyperthyroidism Manufactured and distributed in NI by: Norbrook Laboratories Ltd, Station Works, Newry, Co. Down, BT35 6JP. Distributed in GB by: Norbrook Laboratories (GB) Ltd, 1 Saxon Way East, Oakley Hay Industrial Estate, Corby, NN18 9EY. Legal Category: Betafuse® POM-V gel for dogs contains 5 mg/g fusidic acid and 1 mg/g betamethasone. Thyronorm® POM-V 5mg/ml Oral Solution for Cats contains 5mg/ml thiamazole | 4447-LA(C/D)-v1d-UK-15/02/18 Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 3
NEWS Europe’s first oral vaccine for dogs launched by Zoetis Zoetis announced on 31 October 2019 vaccination compliance and ultimately a organisms. CIRDC is not just a cough the launch of Versican Plus Bb Oral – healthier dog population. picked up in kennels. It can be spread the first oral vaccine for dogs in Europe. “Nearly all dogs are at risk of CIRDC, in any space occupied by multiple dogs, It will provide robust, long-lasting and Bordetella is a common, but pre- including grooming parlours, dog day protection against Bordetella bron- ventable, pathogen. Adding Versican care establishments or dog parks. The chiseptica, a primary component of the Plus Bb Oral to vaccination protocols pathogens have not disappeared over canine infectious respiratory disease offers CIRDC protection for dogs. Vets time and CIRDC is prevalent throughout complex (CIRDC), with new easy oral can propose this new vaccination to pet Europe, with Bordetella bronchiseptica administration. owners at an annual wellness visit in remaining a commonly identified agent Versican Plus Bb Oral offers the knowledge that they will be creating in infected dogs. increased comfort for dogs and a a less stressful experience for the pet “I think it is exciting for European vet- smooth consultation room experience and owner.” erinarians now to have another option for both dog owners and veterinarians. Zoetis established the European in the way they deliver non-core Borde- The single-dose liquid vaccine is easily Canine Infectious Respiratory Disease tella protection. There will be different administered into the mouth and has a Advisory Board – made up of veterinary situations depending on circumstances 12-month duration of immunity. specialists from across Europe – to in which either an oral, intranasal or Eileen Ball, Global Veterinary Medical provide guidance and advice on the injectable route of administration will Lead for Companion Animal Infectious product’s launch. be most appropriate.” Diseases for Zoetis, said: “The new oral Member of the board, Professor Emer- delivery brings a more positive expe- itus Michael J Day, University of Bristol, rience for dogs, owners and vets. We spoke at the launch and said: “The Versican Plus Bb Oral is being expect this new option for vaccination CIRDC has a multifactorial pathogenesis, launched in Europe from November will lead to an increase in recommenda- involving environmental and lifestyle fac- 2019 with rollout across the conti- tions for Bordetella prevention, better tors and numerous potentially causative nent continuing until October 2020 Programme for Vets South 2020 announced in association with lead sponsor, Bayer Animal Health Tickets are selling fast for Vets South 2020, the only veterinary congress In total, Vets South will offer 27 hours of CPD for delegates to choose from SOUTH to take place in the south-west of the through its two veterinary streams and UK. It offers a comprehensive clinical a veterinary nursing stream. Speakers stream. A keynote panel discussion will programme for both vets and veterinary include Dr Kieran Borgeat, an Ameri- take place at the end of the first day. nurses and has become a popular fixture can, European and RCVS Recognised Early Bird rates start at £90.00 + VAT in the veterinary congress calendar. Specialist in Veterinary Cardiology; Dr per day, available until 31 December 2019. During the two days, 16 world-class Ian Ramsey, Professor of Small Animal Delegates can also sign up for a free speakers will discuss best practice in Medicine at the University of Glasgow; six-month subscription to Improve’s On- small animal medicine, surgery and vet- and Dr Owen Davies, an American Spe- line Bitesize CPD, an online educational erinary nursing under the over-arching cialist in Veterinary Oncology. platform. It offers veterinary surgeons theme of “treating patients on a limited Dr Andrew Carrington, an Official an additional 18 hours of free CPD and budget”. Topics covered will include Veterinarian working in practice in an additional nine to veterinary nurses. cardiology, oncology, ophthalmology, Wiltshire, will chair the small animal orthopaedics, emergency and critical medicine stream, while Dr Jon King, care and infectious diseases. Vets South manager of the Wales Veterinary Sci- Vets South will be taking place on is organised by global veterinary CPD ence Centre in Aberystwyth, will chair 4 and 5 March 2020 in Sandy Park, specialist Improve International and, for the small animal surgery stream. Ms Exeter. For more information about the first time, is held in association with Wendy Nevins, RVN and Past President the event and the programme visit lead sponsor Bayer Animal Health. of the BVNA, will chair the nursing vetssouth.com or call 01793 20805 4
Introducing GingiShield EXCLUSIVELY DISTRIBUTED BY THE GLOBAL NAME IN VETERINARY DENTISTRY What is SELDOX ® What is GINGISHIELD™ ? Antimicrobial Technology? GingiShield™ is a clear, light-cured SELDOX® is a patented organo-selenium SELDOX®-enhanced tooth sealant applied by veterinary professionals to at-risk tooth surfaces to neutralize bacteria, inhibit plaque Selenium is a naturally occurring, non-toxic, formation, and reduce the occurrence of trace mineral that is essential to the overall health periodontal disease. GingiShield™ does not of both animals and people. replace the need for brushing or cleaning, but offers an added layer of antibacterial protection lasting up to two years. GINGISHIELD™ PLAQUE CLEANING AND CONTINUOUSLY GINGISHIELD™ NEUTRALIZES APPLICATION BACTERIA ACTIVE BACTERIA Treatment of a 30lb, 9 year-old Sheltie B E F O R E G I N G I S H I E L D™ A P P L I C AT I O N • About 12 months of tartar • No toothbrushing • Cleaning, GingiShield™ applied A F T E R G I N G I S H I E L D™ A P P L I C AT I O N • 7 months later • No toothbrushing (Client unable to brush pet’s teeth) Vetodontics Hawaii Inc 2019 All Rights Reserved. Order Code: GIN001 - GingiShield™ Antibacterial Enamel Sealant Kit - £112.50 Approximately 20 treatments per pack, working out at around £5.70 per treatment! Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 5
NEWS SUPERB checklist poster produced to assist vets when delegating tasks to vet nurses under Schedule 3 The RCVS has produced a checklist production of a number of case studies ρ Person – can you delegate to this poster for use in the practice setting to and a reference poster to assist veteri- person? help veterinary surgeons remember the nary surgeons in making those everyday ρ Experience – does the RVN/SVN key things they need to consider when decisions on delegation in practice. feel capable and have sufficient delegating work to veterinary nurses. Ian Holloway, RCVS Director of Com- munications, who helped develop the competence and expertise? Schedule 3 to the Veterinary Surgeons Act provides that vets may delegate poster with the Standards Committee ρ Risks – have you considered the medical treatment and minor surgery and the College’s Standards and Advice risks specific to this case? (not involving entry into a body cavity) to Team, explains: “It was clear from the survey results that we could do more ρ Be there – are you available to registered veterinary nurses (RVNs) and to help vets and vet nurses understand direct or supervise as necessary? student veterinary nurses (SVNs) under certain circumstances. and remember the principles of delega- Only if veterinary surgeons can answer Following an RCVS survey to gauge tion under Schedule 3, so hopefully our all six questions in the affirmative, can how well both vets and vet nurses six-point checklist, using the memorable they delegate accordingly. understood the provisions of Schedule mnemonic ‘SUPERB’, will do just that.” 3, it was clear that both groups could The mnemonic SUPERB stands for: The poster is available to download benefit from some additional guidance from rcvs.org.uk/schedule3 where and greater clarity around some of the ρ Specific procedure – is the proce- dure medical treatment or minor further resources about delegation terms and language in the Schedule. are available, including links to the surgery not involving entry into a After the publication of the survey relevant chapter of the RCVS Code body cavity? report, the RCVS Veterinary Nursing of Professional Conduct and the Schedule 3 Working Party made a num- ρ Under care – is the animal under Schedule 3 case studies ber of recommendations, including the your care? Applications for joining the RCVS Shape the future of the veterinary 2020 Fellowship are now open professions as an RCVS or VN The Fellowship is the learned society of the RCVS aimed at Councils candidate in 2020 veterinary surgeons whose activities demonstrate excel- lence in veterinary endeavour and who have distinguished Veterinary surgeons and veterinary nurses are being themselves on account of their ongoing commitment to encouraged to help shape the future of their professions by using their experience and knowledge to enhance the pro- standing as candidates for the RCVS Council and Veterinary fession further. There are three routes to entry, recognising Nurses (VN) Council, respectively, in their 2020 elections. meritorious contributions to: veterinary knowledge; clinical In next year’s RCVS Council election, there are three practice; and the profession. elected veterinary surgeon member places available with successful candidates serving four-year terms. The Fellowship has been given additional impetus with In the VN Council election, there are two elected vet- the development of a three-pronged strategy to help it erinary nurse member places available with successful reach its aim of becoming a learned society. The three key candidates serving three-year terms. aims are: promoting scientific excellence; harnessing the ex- Nominations are open until 5pm on 31 January 2020. pertise of Fellows to further professional skills and practice and to invigorate a curiosity for innovation; and undertaking activities that enrich public discourse about the impact of Further information, including nomination forms, veterinary science to everyone. guidance notes and frequently asked questions for prospective RCVS Council candidates can be found at rcvs.org.uk/rcvscouncil20. The deadline for applying to join the 2020 tranche of the Fellowship is Monday 3 February 2020. All the details on The equivalent documents for VN Council candidates how to apply can be found at rcvs.org.uk/fellowship are available at rcvs.org.uk/vncouncil20 6
We are specialists in ophthalmic Surgical instruments Contact one of our operators now and receive a free copy of our educational guides: Vets Apex ed by produc l guide cationa An edu Vets Apex ed by produc l guide cationa An edu S www.fclveterinary.com ISEASE FECT ections of cat IOUS D s & dogs U? GING IN ARE YO nts EMER Selected zoonoti c inf REEN HOW G me l Instru lly menta surgica ctive, environ rument s th re using al, hig hly cos t effe gical inst use sur sionals cho ice. ted wi Practic SAFE Single profes associa lly menta ction S - the s environ y & infe X VET al cost s ctive, rument friendl from APE The re t effe gical inst ary.com hly cos use sur sionals cho ice. al, hig lveterin Practic Single profes SAFE ction S - the y & infe www.fc 332 321819 X VET friendl from APE ary.com TEL: 01 lveterin www.fc 332 321819 TEL: 01 FCL Veterinary 32 Longbridge Lane Ascot Business Park Derby DE24 8UJ United Kingdom T: +44 (0)133 232 1819 www.fclveterinary.com FCL Health Solutions Ltd Hawthorns House, Halfords Lane Birmingham, UK. B66 1DW Tel: +44 (0)121 272 1885 www.fclhealth.com Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 7
NEWS Veterinary antibiotic sales BEVA provides practical halved over past four years support to encourage further Sales of antibiotics for use in food-producing animals have reduced by 53 percent from 2014 to 2018, the Veterinary reduction in antibiotic use Medicines Directorate (VMD) confirmed on 29 October 2019. BEVA is running a survey to find out more about antimicrobial This demonstrates the strong and committed approach use and antimicrobial resistance in practice and has added taken by the UK’s food, farming and veterinary sectors to further elements to its PROTECT ME Toolkit online resources. tackle antimicrobial resistance (AMR). The figure comes from The survey, launched at BEVA Congress in September, the annual Veterinary Antibiotic Resistance Sales and Sur- aims to assess any changes in prescribing of antimicrobials veillance (UK-VARSS) report published in November 2019. in equine practice since the last survey in 2009. The results The UK’s Chief Veterinary Officer Christine Middlemiss said will also provide an insight on the current frequency and that this is a testament to the improvements industry and types of antimicrobial-resistant infections seen by clinicians the veterinary profession have made in antibiotic steward- and what infection control and audit practices are in place. ship, training and disease control. “This is a great example BEVA’s PROTECT ME toolkit is a free resource for BEVA of how real change can be achieved when government and members, to help facilitate compliance and educate horse industry work together including through initiatives such as owners about the importance of antimicrobial awareness. the Targets Task Force chaired by RUMA (Responsible Use of “While antimicrobials remain essential for the health and Medicines in Agriculture Alliance). The focus on infection pre- welfare of horses suffering from bacterial infection, it’s vention and control is key to reducing the need to treat with imperative for vets to protect their usage to maintain their antibiotics and maintaining the UK’s world-leading standards effectiveness for the future,” said BEVA President Tim Mair. in protecting animal health and biosecurity.” “The equine veterinary sector is committed to responsible This success in reducing antibiotic use in food-producing stewardship; sales surveillance data shows that sales of animals is also highlighted in the recently published Ninth horse-only antibiotics has fallen by 4.3 tonnes (64 percent) European Surveillance of Veterinary Antimicrobial Con- since 2017 and 13.6 tonnes (85 percent) since 2014. We sumption report which shows that the UK now has one of hope the results of the BEVA survey will provide further the lowest levels of veterinary antibiotic sales in Europe. optimistic data.” Co you g m m for ketin ar nta r F ate Why wait 6 weeks when ct RE ria us E ls nutraquin+ works in 7 days Fast acting joint support for dogs, cats & horses Natural fast acting joint support to aid & soothe stiff joints. ✓ Aids mobility & flexibility ✓ Supports the natural systems that control inflammation ✓ Exclusive to Veterinary Practices ✓ Loyalty scheme for your clients ✓ Wide range of FREE marketing materials ✓ FREE CPD training / lunch & learns ✓ Our Account Managers are trained Veterinary nurses (not sales people) ✓ Guaranteed next day delivery Register to become an Authorised Stockist at www.nutravet.co.uk Support British manufacturing www.nutravet.co.uk 8
Introducing Pro-Kolin Advanced Gentle, fast and powerful enough to return dogs to their tail-wagging best. Pro-Kolin Advanced contains beneficial micro-organisms, several prebiotic sources, an optimal level of a dual-source binding agent and soothing fibres to support gastrointestinal function. It is also available as a specific formulation and palatable flavour for cats. To discover more about Pro-Kolin Advanced, contact your Protexin Veterinary Territory Manager or visit protexinvet.com.
NEWS Evidence-based veterinary medicine at forefront of new veterinary group In a first for the profession, 15 of the impact that evidence can have – and lems, new methods to reduce seizures major UK member organisations, vet has had – on animal health and in dogs with epilepsy and faster means schools and policy-making bodies have welfare. It also provides a convincing of detecting antimicrobial resistance, come together to affirm their commit- rationale for all veterinary profession- among many other valuable advances. ment to veterinary medicine based on als to contribute to the evidence base In their commitment, the signato- sound scientific principles, in a new and put evidence into practice, to the ries state: “When rigorous research landmark publication produced by benefit of animals, owners and veteri- underpins medical decisions, adverse RCVS Knowledge and the charity nary teams themselves. events can be minimised, and patient Sense about Science. The commitment is set in the context outcomes can be improved. We believe Evidence-Based Veterinary Medicine of 14 case studies showcasing that evidence-based veterinary medicine re- Matters: Our Commitment to the Future different types of evidence have been inforces the sound scientific principles represents the first time this broad and vital to significant steps forward in vet- of the profession and strengthens the influential group have formally united in erinary medicine. Evidence has been at commitment to put animal health and support of a single issue. This unprece- the heart of the eradication of the cattle welfare at the forefront of all we do.” dented collaboration is testament to the disease rinderpest, successful strate- importance that veterinary organisations gies to prevent bird flu and the rapid The full commitment and portfolio across the profession place on the use of and accurate diagnosis of colic – one of case studies can be read evidence to enhance all types of veteri- of the most common causes of death in in Evidence-Based Veterinary nary medicine. horses. Evidence has also been core to Medicine Matters, available for free The publication serves to demon- the development of new techniques to online: bit.ly/EBVMMatters strate the profound and wide-ranging treat bulldogs with breathing prob- Latest small animal neutering complication rates released by vetAUDIT The latest small animal neutering ρ 75 percent of neuters were Pam Mosedale, Chair of the Quality complication rates were released in complication-free Improvement Advisory Board at RCVS November 2019, alongside the first ever Knowledge, said: ρ In cats and dogs, spays suffered a benchmarks for rabbit neutering, on “These benchmarks are of importance higher incidence of complications RCVS Knowledge’s vetAUDIT website. to all small animal practices and offer than castrates. However, the The baseline figures in dogs and invaluable insight into the current reverse was seen in rabbits cats are remarkably similar to last levels of patient safety associated year’s benchmarks, indicating neither ρ Spayed and castrated cats with routine neutering procedures… improvement nor deterioration in suffered fewer complications We are also heartened to see a 10 treatment quality across the practices than dogs percent increase in data submitted included in the audit. Rabbit data was to the audit in 2019, which not only recorded for the first time, although the ρ At least 25 percent of dog makes the national benchmarks more small sample size limits the inference spays resulted in some form of accurate, but demonstrates the growing that can be taken. complication importance the professions are placing ρ More than 95 percent of castrated on quality improvement methods.” In total, just under 40,000 cases were cats suffered no abnormality included. Standout benchmarks include: ρ 35 animals died as a result of a Practices can anonymously submit ρ Over 15 percent of animals neutering procedure, including their data to the audit and compare suffered an abnormality related to one rabbit their figures to the national bench- the operation, with around half of marks on the vetAUDIT website: these requiring medical treatment ρ Over 3,000 cases were lost to vetaudit.rcvsk.org/nasan or surgical intervention follow-up 10
Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 11
THE PROFESSION What can we learn from medical professionals? Veterinary and medical professions role. Performance related pay is a controversial area in the veterinary sector, beyond the scope of this article. We know share parallel challenges, so can we that pay is an important hygiene factor, but the relationship benefit from parallel solutions? is not linear and beyond a certain point higher pay does not continue to boost motivation. However, the knowledge that as a vet we’re paid on average 20 to 25 percent less than GUDRUN RAVETZ our doctor and dentist colleagues may be demotivating. Gudrun Ravetz is Head Veterinary Officer for Simply- The move towards larger medical practices and health Professionals and a BVA past president. Gudrun has worked in companion animal practice as well as in corporatisation in the dental and veterinary professions is industry and management. Gudrun joined the Society of also increasing. In dentistry, large pan-European groups are Practising Veterinary Surgeons and went on to be their President in 2012. forming, with the recent acquisition of one of the largest UK dental groups by a Swiss firm. NHS England stated that 85.7 A s veterinary professionals, it’s a natural comparison percent of dentists in England were now performer-only (ie to look at the working life of doctors and dentists. We hold no share of NHS contracts or facilities), compared with often labour under the impression that the human 62.4 percent between 2006 and 2007, and similarly general medics benefit from higher salaries and more defined practitioners are increasingly opting for salaried GMP career options. There can be a hint of envy as we look at our roles. In the Doctors and Dentists Remuneration Report the medical colleagues if we find ourselves financially stretched reasons for the shift towards lower-paid performer-only or stagnating in our careers. However, a recent government or salaried roles are not clear, but were thought to relate review on remuneration of the medical professions reveals to the desire for work–life balance, flexibility and fewer truisms remarkably similar to our own experiences responsibilities. Work–life balance and flexibility are also and mirrored challenges to those facing the veterinary common themes for the veterinary profession. profession. Can we benefit from parallel solutions? Interestingly, while dentists earned more on average as With guaranteed jobs on graduation and public perception young graduates, career progression did not always mate- of being valued and held in high regard, it’s still an attractive rialise as expected. The BDA’s view was that dentists were prospect to be a vet, doctor or dentist, although there has almost at the tipping point where the balance between pay been a recent decline in the number of applicants across the and workload would push them to leave. If a number left three professions. With parallel challenges with recruitment or retired and Brexit had an impact, there could be a crisis. and retention we need to focus on creating good workplaces Again, many similarities with the veterinary profession... to safeguard the future of these professional workforces. There are signs of a clear trend in the medical workforce Starting salaries for new graduates are certainly towards salaried employment and away from the part- respectable and very comparable for the three professions. nership model. All generations are showing an increased The 2018 Society of Practising Veterinary Surgeons Salary desire for flexibility and a better work–life balance, and this Survey showed the average salary for new graduate vets appears to be translating into salaried employment, locum was £32,175. Foundation trainee salary for dentists is a work and part-time working patterns (sound familiar?). comparable £31,992, while the foundation doctor year 1 Interestingly, the RCVS Survey of the Profession in 2014 (FY1) salary is lower at £27,146. found that although women are more likely to work part- The small salary advantage vets see as new graduates time than men (26 percent compared with 11 percent), the soon reverses. The median annual salary for a full-time biggest growth in part-time working in the last four years salaried general medical practitioner (GMP) was £63,493 was from men (5 percent in 2010 to 11 percent in 2014). in 2016. Compare this to the results of the SPVS Salary Reports from all the professions have noted that employers Survey 2018, with a median salary of £47,800 (excluding and planners will need to react to the different work prefer- additional benefits) and the difference in salary progression ences in order to recruit and retain and ensure the effective is stark. The British Dental Association (BDA) stated that delivery of healthcare/veterinary care. there had been a deterioration in dentists’ pay since 2008, This leads us on to the gender pay gap which is prevalent from a median FTE net of £67,880 to £60,200 in 2016 for per- in all three professions. These are often accounted for by former-only dentists (equivalent to a salaried assistant vet). structural factors such as fewer working hours or more jun- An interesting comment is the idea that pay progression ior roles (which in themselves can often have a discrimina- should be linked to performance and competence in the tory basis), versus a more obvious discriminatory gap where 12
equal work is not rewarded with equal pay. The independent report from the Review Body on Doctors and Dentists Re- muneration noted that the prevalence of women as perform- er-only dentists (ie not partners) or salaried GMPs may entail a correspondingly lower income for these individuals. We have heard similar things in the veterinary profession. Here’s where others may learn from vets. The BVA’s gender discrimination report based on an experimental study highlights obvious discrimination and indicates attitudes as key in addressing the issue. Maybe doctors and dentists can also learn from the BVA report to help them shape a thriving, motivated and sustainable workforce for the future. In May 2016, the King’s Fund published research on the pressures in general medical practice, which found that in- creasing demands including a heavier workload and increas- ing complexity and intensity of work had led to a feeling of crisis. It added that the NHS was finding it difficult to recruit and retain GMPs who wanted full-time, patient-facing work. On the positive side, peer support was reportedly increas- ing. With the advent of similar veterinary peer support networks including veterinary social media groups focused on everything from career support, parenting and chronic illness, this is a clear, unmeasured trend for our profession. Changes are afoot for doctors to increase retention of the groups where the pipeline has the biggest leaks. The NHS GP Retention Scheme is aimed at doctors who are seriously considering leaving or have left general practice due to personal reasons (caring responsibilities or personal illness), or requiring greater flexibility. It provides financial support for both the retained GP and the employing prac- Upgrading your CR Image Processor has never been easier tice, providing working hours are limited. Crucially, it also demands CPD and educational support are provided. While the veterinary profession may lack a pot of funds, a similar scheme could reap long-term benefits. Early retirees are the second key group, with a loss of Lightweight yet robust, the skills and experience of doctors over 55 years of age – a DR-14e Digital Detector offers general radiography facilities all similar phenomenon to the buy-out of independent vet the advantages of Direct practice partners by corporate groups, leading to career Radiography, while maximising divergence or early retirement for vets. The NHS GP Career the use of their existing Plus pilot scheme encourages the retention of this expe- equipment. rienced group through vaccine clinics, cover of practice The wireless (or wired) holiday or sickness, mentoring and clinical coaching, and technology and lighter weight specialist clinics or home visit services to augment local offers operator comfort and practice offerings. In this modern era of innovative recruit- improve exam flexibility and ment start-ups, a matching service for those in the twilight convenience, even in challenging imaging situations. The modern of their veterinary careers would be an interesting prospect. design of the detector combines In summary, the challenges around workforce retention ergonomics with aesthetics, with and satisfaction which will impact the future shape of all the sides sealed to prevent liquid three medical professions are similar. By comparing and ingress, making cleaning and disinfection easier. contrasting proposed solutions we can learn from each other how best to adapt working practices to ensure con- tinued provision of excellent care. The bottom line from the TALK TO US ABOUT OUR BVA study suggests that if the profession can facilitate its EASY UPGRADE PROGRAM members feeling valued, fitting in and having role models, this is likely to have multiple benefits in terms of cultivating a cohort of vets who are strongly motivated in their careers and keen to stay within the profession. VP Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 13
HISTORY Who made our profession? We should recognise the individuals who The baton was taken by his colleague George Fleming, elected RCVS President in 1880. At once he drafted a Bill to have carved the veterinary profession as obtain protection of the veterinary surgeon title. By incredi- we know it ble persistence, and funded by his own money, he was able to get the Veterinary Surgeons Act 1881 entered on to the Statute Book. The profession was now legalised and the BRUCE VIVASH JONES members listed in the RCVS Register. Bruce Vivash Jones, BVetSts, MRCVS, graduated from These two men, Francis Wellington John Fitzwygram the RVC in 1951. After retiring from his consultancy business in 2003, he began studying and writing on the and George Fleming, had saved the profession. They were history of the profession and veterinary medicine. known as “Fitzwygram the Charter and Fleming the Act”. Following the First World War, the profession fell to a low O ebb: horses were being replaced by motor vehicles, farming ur Royal College is celebrating its 175th anniversary was in a desperate situation and veterinary work was in this year. Established by Charter on 8 March 1844, little demand. The veterinary schools were underfunded the objective was to create a professional body of and research was negligible. those trained in veterinary medicine and to govern them In 1938, the Loveday Committee was tasked to report on with both educational and ethical standards to serve the veterinary education. Recalled in 1943 to look into wartime needs of both animals and the public. food shortages, the committee now included Reginald Wool- The question in the title echoes the succinct words of dridge, who was able to ensure that the final report recom- Ralph Waldo Emerson (1803–82): “There is properly no his- mended veterinary schools to be in the university system tory; only biography.” Therefore, as a profession, we should and receive funding to encourage research. These recom- recognise the individuals who have enabled the creation of mendations were incorporated into the Veterinary Surgeons our present working environment. Act 1948, and veterinary colleges were also created at Bris- The story begins when Granville Penn, a member of the tol and Cambridge universities (adding to those in London, Odiham Agricultural Society, and philanthropist, saw the Edinburgh, Glasgow and Liverpool). This was almost solely need for proper veterinary education. In 1789, he happened due to Reginald Wooldridge, who also founded the Animal to meet Charles Vial de Saint Bel, a French veterinary Health Trust. graduate who wanted to open a school in England. Granville There can be little doubt that without the initiative of the soon drafted a plan with the objectives of creating both “sci- Mayers, Fitzwygram, Fleming and Wooldridge, we would entific veterinary education” and a “veterinary profession”. not have the veterinary profession that we have today. The It came to fruition in 1791 with the opening of the London Mayers had the initiative and perseverance to start the College, but Charles Vial de Saint Bel died in 1793 and his process; Fitzwygram and Fleming were the key men who successor had little interest in founding a profession. It took put into place the legislative structure and Wooldridge had Thomas Mayer and Thomas Walton Mayer, a veterinary the foresight and drive to bring veterinary medicine into a father and son, to determine the way forward. They over- university and research-focused environment. came opposition, drafted a petition and obtained the Royal Two other people showed the direction veterinary medi- Charter in 1844. cine would take: Aleen Cust, who in the late 1800s was the This Charter enabled the RCVS to be established and first British woman veterinarian, and Brian Singleton, who was designed to “afford us the same privileges and was leader in the founding of the BSAVA in 1957. exemptions which other professional bodies possess”. A At the time of both of these events, no one could foresee president, officers and a system to oversee new entrants the consequences. Today, veterinary student intake borders were created. But it did not confer legal powers to protect on 80 percent female and small animal work dominates all the title “veterinary surgeon”. A Bill had to be presented to other veterinary activity. Singleton also went on to lead the Parliament to confirm the Charter and enforce legislation. creation of the World Small Animal Veterinary Association In 1875, the RCVS Council elected Sir Francis Wellington in 1959 – now with more than 200,000 members in its 110 John Fitzwygram (later both a Major General and a baronet) member associations. as president. Because of his status he possessed influence Mayer, Fitzwygram, Fleming, Wooldridge, Cust and – he could open doors and twist arms with elegance and Singleton. Remember these six names; they made today’s grace. Almost single-handedly, he drew up a supplementary profession. We can be sure of only one thing for the vet- charter to protect the veterinary name, create a registrar erinary future: veterinary medicine changes as the needs and maintain a register of members from both the London of human society alter. Maybe the forerunners of the next and Edinburgh colleges. It was granted in 1876. Now, the change have already shown themselves. It will not always Act of Parliament was needed. He passed the baton. be as it is today. VP 14
Natural, sustainable & ethical, our beautiful timber windows and doors are the logical choice. Constructed from engineered timber slow grown in cold climates, their strength, stability and beauty are guaranteed. Unlike timber windows and doors of old, our products will not twist, will not rot and require very little maintenance. High levels of insulation and security ensure there is no need to sacrifice beauty for comfort. With a 20% discount off all windows and doors in our Winter Sale, explore the range in over 40 showrooms nationwide. AmershAm CArdiff dulwiCh hereford leAmington spA sheffield BirminghAm (hArBorne) CArmArthen esher highgAte linColn st AlBAns BlAndford ChAnnel islAnds guildford honiton moreton-in-mArsh tAvistoCK Bournemouth CheltenhAm hArrogAte horndeAn olney tunBridge wells Bristol (Clifton) CirenCester hArtley wintney horshAm oxford wimBledon Bury st edmunds ColChester heAthfield ingAtestone ripley winChester CAterhAm denBigh henley-on-thAmes Knutsford sAlisBury woodBridge timberwindows.com/ov ‘2019 National Timber Window & Door Supplier of the Year’ T: 0800 030 2000 Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 15
RCVS KNOWLEDGE Use of daily probiotic supplements in canine acute diarrhoea Does a daily probiotic supplement in the diet provide better clinical outcomes in cases of canine acute diarrhoea? A dog suffering from acute diarrhoea (under 14 days) has Severity Index”. Given that clinicians and owners may been brought to your clinic and no cause is identified. have different standards when they evaluate the costs and The owners suggest the feeding of a probiotic to benefits of a one day improvement, the clinical relevance of shorten the recovery time, based on their findings on this study is unclear. the internet. You have no experience in recommending a The probiotic group in the first of these two studies present- probiotic supplement as diarrhoea management. What ed a greater decrease of faecal C. perfringens on day seven, evidence exists to support this approach? while the probiotic group in the second study presented a lower abundance of faecal C. perfringens. The clinical rele- The evidence vance of these findings is affected by the undefined relation- Five placebo-controlled studies were identified that have ship between C. perfringens and acute diarrhoea. assessed the clinical outcomes of administering a daily oral It is unclear whether a reduction of C. perfringens in probiotic supplement in dogs that have acute diarrhoea faecal samples can be regarded as a clinical benefit, given with no identifiable cause. that one study reported an association between increased Significant findings were reported for various outcome C. perfringens in faeces and acute diarrhoea, while another measures: the time to diarrhoea resolution; improvement was unable to find an association between the two. in diarrhoea severity; change in the microbiota; and the Two studies showed a lower percentage of dogs in the percentage of dogs that required additional treatment. probiotic group received additional treatment than the Three studies presented a shorter time to diarrhoea placebo group, and a large sample size of 118 was included resolution in the probiotic group, ranging from 15 hours to in one of these. 2.7 days. However, detailed investigations of the underlying In conclusion, the participating dogs in all the studies aetiology of the diarrhoea were either incomplete or presented a better clinical improvement in the probiotic patients with identified causes were included. group than the placebo. This suggests a daily supplement The studies may not be sufficiently strong to support of oral probiotic may provide better clinical outcomes to a faster clinical recovery by the probiotic supplement, dogs experiencing acute diarrhoea without an identifiable because baseline variations between the probiotic and cause. One study offered fairly strong evidence for a placebo group were not evaluated, a standardised definition reduced requirement of additional treatment in dogs of abnormal stool was not given to owners and clinicians, administered a probiotic. there was an unexplained mismatch between the number The clinical relevance of the reduction in faecal C. perfrin- of dogs that completed one study and the number of dogs gens and improvement in diarrhoea severity was uncertain, included in the analysis of diarrhoea resolution and a and the strength of the studies supporting a shorter time to validated stool scoring system was not used. diarrhoea resolution was limited. Two studies measured improvement in diarrhoea severity Additional studies would be beneficial to validate the bet- in the probiotic group. One reported a greater improvement ter clinical outcomes brought by probiotic supplementation, in stool consistency score in the probiotic group than the given there were variations in several factors, which can placebo on day seven. However, the improvement differed lead to different clinical outcomes. VP from the placebo group by such a small degree that it was questionable whether there was an observable difference in Read the full Knowledge Summary: stool quality, and whether the improvement in consistency bit.ly/JacquelineOiPingTong score was clinically relevant. Also, this study did not evaluate baseline variations between the probiotic and The full Knowledge Summary was written by an under- placebo group. graduate student, who was one of the winners of the The second study that measured improvement in 2019 RCVS Knowledge Veterinary Evidence Student diarrhoea severity reported that the probiotic group Awards. The 2020 awards are now open. Find out more: took one day less to achieve a statistically significant bit.ly/VEstudentawards improvement in the “Canine Haemorrhagic Diarrhoea 16
INSURANCE SPONSORED CONTENT Neutering in dogs: a health and behavioural debate How can we help our clients make an Dog behaviour informed decision? Carolyn: Looking at dog N behaviour, thoughts are eutering is a complex topic for dog owners, made even very much the same – it more so by conflicting advice, advances in research is a case-by-case decision. People used to think if you take and almost endless folklore of how it will affect dogs. testosterone away from male dogs they would be easier to To help owners to make an informed choice about what to live with, but that’s not always the case. Aggression can have do, we asked Carolyn Menteith, dog behaviourist and trainer, its roots in fear or anxiety, so by taking away testosterone, and Robin Hargreaves, director, veterinary surgeon and which may be giving the dog some confidence, you could end former BVA president, both members of the Agria Specialist up with a more fearful dog, that in turn becomes more ag- Health Team, to discuss neutering and its impact on health gressive. There is also evidence of similar results in female and behaviour. dogs. In the same way, there can be an increase in other pho- bias and touch sensitivities as well – so neutering to improve Dog health behaviour isn’t as clear cut as we previously thought. It’s true that it will prevent or reduce most sexually driven Robin: When it comes to health, the two main reasons to behaviours, such as running off after a bitch in season or neuter female dogs are the dramatic reduction in mammary excessive territory marking, and it may prevent some dog- cancer in animals neutered at a young enough age and the to-dog aggression and male competitiveness – but it isn’t absolute prevention of the potentially fatal pyometra. the panacea that people always thought it was to calm dogs In male dogs, neutering can reduce the incidence of pros- down; in fact, there are some studies that show increased ex- tatic disease. While we see fewer cases of benign prostatic citability in neutered dogs. We’re simply finding out more and disease in neutered males, it isn’t so clear in prostatic cancer more all the time about how hormones affect our dogs and that neutering makes a difference. Compared with females, about what happens when you alter that hormone balance. the health drivers for neutering males are not so strong. Where population control is not an issue, owners should talk Are there negatives for health in respect of neutering? Yes. to their vets – and if they are hoping to improve behaviour, Most insidiously across animals that have been neutered their behaviourist – and make their decision on a case-by- is the serious potential for weight gain – they simply find it case basis based on what is right for them and their dog. easier to put weight on. And if this is not addressed it can complicate every other health problem as life goes on. Conclusion For females specifically, there is an increased incidence of urinary incontinence. While manageable in most cases, medi- Robin: We wouldn’t just book male dogs in to be neutered cation will probably be required forever. There also continues these days, there’s always a discussion about why. In the sig- a debate on the timing of neutering and whether it is respon- nificant minority of cases, we realise that client expectations sible for an increased rate of urinary incontinence in females. are completely awry and we would be disappointing people It appears that spaying after the first season can reduce this. enormously if we carried out the operation. Neutering male dogs under the age of 12 months, or before With females, we’re confident that it’s the right course of the dog has reached skeletal maturity, is not advised. This is action but it’s still important that people realise what the due to the increased length of time growth plates will take to downsides might be: the potential for weight gain, for example. fuse following a reduction in testosterone, creating a statis- The only certainty with neutering is that that animal will tical increase in the incidence of injuries among animals that have no further part in the breeding process. Any other have been neutered at a younger age. changes cannot be guaranteed, so it’s a risk–benefit analysis. I suspect over the next five years we will see a lot more data and will have greater clarity over the ancillary risks and benefits. But at the moment with male dogs it’s a case-by- To find out more about how your practice could benefit case decision, whereas for female dogs, with the health risks from working with Agria and offering your clients five being so much more significant, I think we can be clear that a weeks of free insurance, get in touch with the Agria Vet non-breeding female is better off spayed. Team by calling 03330 30 83 90 Veterinary Practice December/January 2019/20 17
MENTAL HEALTH Non-judgement is accepting your thoughts and feelings No one ever healed a blow to the head Does that mean that I’m allowing them to win? Or, in choos- ing to suffer less, am I indeed being responsibly selfish by hitting themselves there again enough to be the winner? If your motivation is to feel less hate, less hypertension and less pain, then maybe you will choose to simply feel LAURA WOODWARD LAURA WOODWARD COUNSELLING less angry when the stimulus occurs next time. It is genu- inely a choice. Or maybe the cause of the anger is gone, in Laura Woodward has been the surgeon at Village Vet Hampstead for over 10 years. Laura is also a qualified which case it’s even easier to simply feel less anger about therapeutic counsellor and is affiliated with the ACPNL the past from now on. No matter how justified your anger and the ISPC. She runs laurawoodward.co.uk – a coun- selling service for vets and nurses. is, if you choose to let the feelings of rage go, then you may feel more empowered and more free than the perpetrator if M editation sessions are a perfect time to allow our you choose to defuse it. emotions to envelop us. It takes discipline and inner Once the internal reaction has been chosen, what do I want strength to allow the emotions which have previously my external reaction to be? Again that’s your choice. Maybe been overwhelming to come to the forefront of our mind. you want to send an eloquent email. Maybe you feel like Self-awareness means being acutely alert and aware of throwing furniture. Maybe you want to try (dare I suggest it) what you’re feeling. This is not about burying emotions in showing compassion towards an adversary? a box and ignoring them. In mindful meditation, it is about It may be that, once the internal rage has become so weak being actively aware of your emotions, however distressing that it’s way down your list of priorities, your external reac- or otherwise they may be, and feeling them one by one, so tion is naturally one of calmness and physical non-reactivity that the full force of the emotion is there. Then, and only in the face of what would have previously enraged you. then, can we defuse it, if we wish. Holding on to distressing and painful emotions disem- Give one emotion a name, look it in the face, allow it to powers you. Letting go of them, if that’s what you choose, envelop you and accept that you are feeling what you are relieves the stress and burden on you to feel responsible for feeling. The more you accept and embrace that emotion, the everything, especially those things that you cannot change. more you defuse it and decrease its power over you. Anger is just one emotion which can be looked at in this Now the non-judgement... This begins with awareness of way. Anxiety is a great emotion to work with in a similar your own thoughts and stopping yourself from labelling any step-by-step fashion. Fear, grief and regret may be on your of them as good or bad. They just are. list also. When embracing anxiety and feeling it to its full Accept your thoughts and feelings as natural and allow extent, it can be quite nauseating and stressful. You may them to come. Non-reacting is allowing your thoughts and find your stomach sinking, your pulse increasing, your feelings to be, without resorting to the need to behave reac- breaths becoming gasps. “Letting go” of anxiety is simply tively in the same way you have reacted before. too difficult and impractical for most people due to the bio- Pause for a moment to reflect on your inner experience. chemical aspects of it as well as the external causes. Don’t act hastily and emotionally. So now, you can make Spending extended periods of time focusing on nothing- this space as large as you like. And you can literally choose ness can help with anxiety, as can focusing on your breaths how you want to react to this emotion internally as well as and nothing else for as long as possible (ideally 20 minutes externally. What you choose to do in your morning medita- at a time). It’s hard but it’s very effective. tion, you will do subconsciously later in the day. However, probably the most powerful tool I have used with For example, if I feel angry, I feel angry. Having the emotion my clients, along with the above, is learning to accept that is not good nor bad. It is what it is. There may be many rea- anxiety is not going to go away anytime soon. Acceptance of sons I am angry and the causative effects of how I’m feeling anxiety as a part of your life (if it is), which contrasts so pro- right now are in the past. Maybe the causes will never stop. foundly with trying to make it go away or cure it, can feel like But the way I feel right now is a result of what has happened laying down passively and succumbing to the horrors of it all. up to this point, and the past cannot be changed or undone. However, if fighting against anxiety hasn’t worked this Right now, while allowing the anger to envelop me, I have far, and “letting go” of anxiety is simply too difficult, maybe a choice to make. Would I like the internal reaction to be allowing it to just be, to play along in the background and “to feel less angry”? Is it a sign of weakness that the same be accepted for what it is, will decrease its hold over you. things or people which caused the anger will remain the Hans Selye said “It’s not stress that kills us. It’s our reac- same and I am changing to be less reactive? tion to it” and this is true of every emotion you feel. VP 18
You can also read