Building resilience in a time of climate crisis - Environment Victoria News MOBILISING PEOPLE TO SAFEGUARD OUR ENVIRONMENT - Environment ...
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Environment Victoria News MOBILISING PEOPLE TO SAFEGUARD OUR ENVIRONMENT Issue 33 Autumn 2020 Building resilience in a time of climate crisis
INSIDE THIS ISSUE Environment Victoria News Issue 33, Autumn 2020 Design Ciara Denham Print Neo Contributing writers States act 3 Bushfire 4 Jono La Nauze, Greg Foyster, Heather while Canberra survivors call for Bruer, Lena Herrera Piekarski, Tyler fumbles climate action Rotche, Alex Merory, Sawsan Alfayadh, Victor Komarovsky Editors Greg Foyster & Alex Merory (03) 9341 8125 Renewables to 7 How the 7 editor@environmentvictoria.org.au bushfire crisis the rescue! Subeditor Jenny Lee impacts our rivers Membership and supporter enquiries 8 (03) 9341 8100 admin@environmentvictoria.org.au Media enquiries Building our Getting active 9 (03) 9341 8127 inner climate j.lanauze@environmentvictoria.org.au change resiliance from home Environment Victoria News is an Environment Victoria publication. For more information, visit www.environmentvictoria.org.au Authorised by J. La Nauze, CEO, Environment Victoria, 60 Leicester Street, Carlton, VIC 3053 @EnviroVic facebook.com/environmentvictoria Front and back cover images: Doug Gimesy Editorial It is vital that we do everything we can Of course there is no guarantee Jono La Nauze, toward the global climate challenge. Premier Andrews will make the right Chief Executive Officer We can only solve the problem by call, and even if he does there will be acting together, and the pathway to another campaign we have to move global cooperation involves leading by on and fight, and another, and another. example. Victoria is already on the way The truth is that ultimately leadership As dusk settles on the last night of each to proving that a thriving society does comes from the people, and political year, a group of us gather in the bush not need fossil fuels. power comes from organised people and feast at a long table beneath the working together. Whatever Premier open sky. This year, as we reflected on Far from being afraid of the transition, Andrews’ decision, we need to keep 2019 and shared our hopes and fears our community is demanding more working together to push our elected for 2020, the scent of bushfire stained urgent change, and there are signs the representatives step up on climate, the air. By morning, the smoke was major parties are catching up. Since the while we still have time. thick, and in the coming days the horror fires, the Victorian Liberals and now the of the fires became clear. Nationals have distanced themselves As Environment Victoria News was from the federal Coalition’s reckless heading to print, the COVID-19 crisis Horror in the death and sickness climate policies. Our work together to hit Australia. The ramifications are caused by the fires, and horror in shift the politics on climate is having an huge and frightening but we will get the knowledge that this is just the impact. through this together. beginning. This is what 1.1 degree of warming looks like, but 1.1 degrees isn’t By the time you read this edition of Over the weeks and months where we’re headed. Unless we change Environment Victoria News Premier ahead we will have to reassess our course, we will pass 3 degrees and Andrews will have decided how much strategies and how we work together. multiple tipping points. faster his government is willing to drive Most importantly we need to stay the transition to a clean economy, in connected and protect the most And yet amid all of this there is hope. setting emissions reduction targets for vulnerable in our community. We have We’re inspired by the courage and the next five and ten years. These are included some initial advice on how generosity of people across our the targets that matter – by 2050 it will to stay engaged from home on page 9 movement, particularly those worst hit be too late. He has a mandate to drive along with links to resources that we’ll by the fires. real climate action and the political continue to update. We hope you stay This edition of Environment Victoria barriers are dissolving before his eyes. safe through this difficult time. News shares some of their stories. He would be mad not to take the mantle of climate leadership. 2 ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au
Construction of Ararat wind farm. Photo credit: RES group States act while Canberra fumbles Victoria’s Opposition Leader and NSW’s The states have shown they won’t keep Jono La Nauze, Climate and Energy Minister. Every waiting for Canberra to deliver. This Chief Executive Officer single state and territory in the country year Victoria and NSW have confirmed has now set a goal of net zero emissions they will lock in 2030 emissions by 2050 – a target the Prime Minister cuts that are higher than the federal has so far rejected. Of course, the government’s inadequate targets. In the past few months, a clear reality is that emissions cut in the next They do so with the knowledge that path to real action on climate five and ten years will count the most. this means phasing out our ageing and change has emerged. State increasingly unreliable coal power That’s why it’s critical that premiers stations and replacing them with and territory governments are such as Gladys Berejiklian and Daniel cleaner sources. aligning on the need for strong Andrews seize this moment to work with their fellow premiers on a national The Andrews government is weighing climate policy. climate change strategy. up emissions targets for 20205 and If the states act decisively and 2030, and it will need to make its This is not without precedent. In 2004, decisions by the end of March this year. act together on setting emissions despairing at the lack of federal action, targets they can reduce pollution via The crucial test is whether state targets states and territories came together to can put Australia back on track to do its an alternative route. Let’s call it the establish a national emissions trading Princes Highway to climate action fair share towards the objectives of the scheme. Paris Climate Agreement. because, like the famous road, it passes through the eastern capitals and Surrounded by pressure and with Kevin This is a critical moment that could shift deliberately avoids Canberra. Rudd rising in the polls, John Howard the national debate. If Victoria adopts agreed. emissions targets in line with the Paris The biggest barrier to action has been a lack of political will and outright Ultimately it was Julia Gillard who Agreement, it is possible for other climate denialism in Federal Parliament, implemented the scheme before states to follow suit, passing similar mainly from the Liberal and National Tony Abbott came to office and legislation and creating a de-facto parties. The Prime Minister has tried withdrew bipartisan support, leading to national climate change strategy – to deflect attentions from his party’s Canberra’s wasted decade of “climate whether Scott Morrison decided to help failure by focusing the debate on wars”. out or not. how we can “adapt” to a hotter, more But the lesson here is that states and chaotic climate, rather than cutting the territories sparked a national process, This article originally appeared as an pollution that causes it. and can do so again to bring about opinion piece in The Age. It has been But at the state level, things have significant cuts to pollution. While edited. been different. After the bushfires, the federal government holds overall senior Liberals have been speaking responsibility for climate policy as out about the need to cut pollution and it relates to Australia’s international have called for strong climate policy – obligations, state governments have including the South Australian Premier, many of the levers needed to cut the outgoing Tasmanian premiers, emissions from the most polluting sectors – electricity, transport and agriculture. ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au 3
BUSHFIRE CRISIS Bushfire Survivors c We’ve been supporting Ian Cane is a third generation Beekeeper in East Gippsland. bushfire survivors to call for Environment Victoria helped him share his story with the ABC, climate action in the media, local papers and online. and their efforts have been heroic. “So help me. Tell your story . . . Do it for those in the flames right now, and those who are getting ready for the flames, because come tomorrow we may no longer be able to speak.” When bushfire survivor Jo Dodd wrote this in January, her words spurred us into action. With fires burning through the wet forests of East Gippsland, including areas like the Errinundra Plateau, which we’ve fought long and hard to protect, we urgently needed to alert the public to this devastating event and its underlying cause. So we embarked on a new project – helping people in fire-affected areas burned beyond recognition. To all of them, we say thank you. tell their stories. More than 50 people This moment of crisis has shown the have done so, and their stories have They’re dealing with shock, grief, the qualities of Victoria’s environmental been covered in the Herald Sun, The daily struggle of life without power community – people who stand up for Age, the ABC, Channel 10, 3AW and or running water, and the prospect of nature even at the most difficult times. even the New York Times. rebuilding from scratch. Despite this, Your work documenting this crisis and they gave their time because it was too calling on governments to act has been Many of these people lost their homes important to stay silent about the need incredibly powerful. or loved ones in the fires and are deeply for unprecedented action on climate connected with the forests and rivers change. THANK YOU! A huge thank you to everyone who shared their stories, donated to make this possible or funded the next stage - a tour of affected areas, producing news stories and short films. 4 ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au
call for climate action Retired teacher Kate Jackson and her partner Phil have set up a makeshift library for fire victims in Mallacoota. Message from Mallacoota to Canberra: this is climate change Kate Jackson reflects on services that came to help Mallacoota. taken away the wet forest, including the You are all wonderful, and I wish you animal refuge areas. the impacts of bushfires were running the country, because in her town and delivers a it feels like there is a complete Human intervention has made it difficult, but I hope nature will sharp message to our federal lack of leadership from our federal regenerate something of these once- government. government. magnificent forests. My partner Phil and I defended our Everyone I talk to is shell-shocked, angry and bewildered as to why our On our way home we played classical property on Tuesday December 31, music loudly in the car with the windows and did so again on Saturday January Prime Minister shows no leadership on this issue. He is on top of everyone’s down, a symphony for the blackened 4. We are grateful to still have our forest. Some attempt at apology, of love home; many of our friends lost theirs. blame-list down here, ahead of lack of fuel reduction, drought, underfunded and grief for what we have caused. Some were away from town, some down at the water or out in boats, but state and national parks and emergency We are all changed by this experience all of us chose our fire plans against services. Our local catch cry to and holding each other together. We unknowable conditions. Canberra is now too little, too late. feel like climate refugees. How can anyone know how a fire Only once have I been down to see Community is most important, and thinks? All I know is that at 7.23am on the skeletons of our beautiful bush we are grateful that the emergency New Years eve I was standing under beaches, now bare and black. Even the services are listening to us and a red sky in complete darkness with ocean has ash. facilitating what is needed. But we need a solar torch and a hose, protective After the fires, Phil and I drove north to the forest and all its inhabitants back clothing, mask and goggles, listening Eden to witness the burn throughout again. to the deafening roar of the fire, not the forest. We could see how well a Part of the grief of living through these knowing which way it would go, and clear-felled forest regrowth burns fires is the anger at the government’s thinking, ‘This is it. I am standing in – a whole lot of black monoculture lack of action on climate change. We all climate change.’ matchsticks. The older forest areas know that things could have been very I must thank the CFA for their have burnt a little less, and maybe some different. comprehensive fire plan leaflet, and of the magnificent angophoras will ultimately all the Victorian emergency survive, but logging and drought have ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au 5
BUSHFIRE CRISIS “ Why I came to Victorian Parliament ” In February, bushfire survivor No-one should have to go through I didn’t know what I was going to wear what we’re going through. But that’s to Parliament. I lost my entire wardrobe Jann Gilbert travelled from exactly the problem. Everything the in the fire. These past few weeks have Mallacoota to Melbourne with climate scientists are telling us – have been such a struggle, but they have left a message to Premier Andrews been warning us for years – is clearly me determined to focus on the most – set strong targets to cut pointing to our fire seasons getting important lesson from these awful fires. longer and worse. We must stop burning the coal, gas and emissions. oil that is fuelling climate change. This happened to my town after only 1.1 I lost my home when the fires ripped degree of global warming. We cannot I believe governments are meant through Mallacoota in January. We allow climate change to take us all even to do everything in their power to should have been celebrating a New further into this hell. keep people safe. We were not safe Year but instead we were huddled on when the sky turned red-orange and the wharf under a constant shower of That’s why in February I made the those frightening fires hit Mallacoota. smoke, ash and embers. journey from East Gippsland all the way Climate change impacts will keep to Spring Street, Melbourne. When I posing enormous and growing risks to That day I saw first hand the impacts realised that the Victorian government of climate change and it’s almost our safety unless we drastically stop was on the brink of making the most fuelling it via more and more pollution. impossible to describe the terror I felt. important decision on climate change With over 150 houses in Mallacoota for the next ten years I knew I couldn’t gone, our community is still shell- keep quiet. We just don’t have time to shocked. One of Victoria’s most muck around. pristine areas of bush has been utterly devastated. Our ads in The Age! THANK YOU to everyone who donated to get our ad in the newspaper, featuring a message to Premier Andrews from bushfire survivor Mark McCord. “I'm so glad Environment Victoria is connecting the dots to climate change and getting our stories into the media and advertising,” Mark told us. “We need much more of this to convince the public and pressure politicians.” We followed this two weeks later with an open letter also published in The Age calling on Premier Andrews to set strong climate targets. The letter was signed by 285 businesses and organisations across Victoria, a list so impressive it garnered media coverage. Thank you to everyone who signed on! 6 ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au
Renewables to the rescue! could take weeks or months. Some renewable energy as essential for Greg Foyster, towns might switch to renewable community resilience. While the fires Communications microgrids, saying goodbye to legacy have laid bare our vulnerability to the poles and wires forever. climate crisis, they’ve also highlighted Manager that the solutions are ready to be rolled Aryana’s story is just one of many we’ve out – fast. heard from East Gippsland. More and As injured animals escaped the fires, more households are starting to see wildlife carer Aryana Row faced a dilemma – where was she going to shelter all these poor creatures? A joey, nicknamed Ruby, needed regular milk. How could she store it with the electricity grid down and no way to power a fridge? The answer is one many people in remote bushfire-affected communities have been turning to in recent months – renewable energy. Aryana got in touch with local company Gippsland Solar, they rallied their suppliers, and now the Bruthen Bat and Roo Wildlife Shelter has a solar system complete with Tesla Powerwall. “We’re just completely blown away by the support,” says Aryana. It all happened very quickly, and that’s the point. Solar and battery systems can be set up in remote areas in a Photo credit Scott Portelli matter of days, while repairing the grid How the bushfire crisis impacts our rivers land. For catchments hurting from There is not a simple engineering Tyler Rotche, drought and bushfires, the rain was solution. We can begin by looking at our Healthy Rivers tragic. own watersheds, how they are hurting Campaigner and where they need communities to It fell on the forests, carrying ash and heal. mud into the streams. Nutrients in the ash increase bacteria, which robs the To find out more, go to Australia’s rivers have been known water of oxygen. Soil smothers the envict.org/evnews-rivers to withstand bushfire and drought. stream beds and eliminates habitat. Or Their resilience was supported by the it can fill the river almost completely. communities around them. But how After the rain, locals described the we live around the river has changed. Macleay river in New South Wales as a When we look at the damage wrought “runny cake mix”. in this summer’s bushfire crisis, we can see years of compounding harm Further inland, Mannus Creek was revealed in an instant. turned to “a river of black porridge,” with crayfish and mayfly larvae seen Too much water has been taken from crawling out. The creek’s Macquarie our rivers. The flows have been altered perch, the last population in the Murray to suit the interests of a few corporate catchment, were all but wiped out. irrigators. Developers have taken over the floodplains, clearing and eroding Fresh flows can help dilute some of the the land. black water. Sediment barriers might block some runoff in areas that can be The recent rains, which answered reached. But we cannot stop the rain. prayers for so many, fell on damaged We need to change how we care for the Photo credit Doug Gimesy catchment year-round. ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au 7
BUSHFIRE Photo credit Doug Gimesy CRISIS Building our inner climate change resilience But according to Psychology for Signs that we are struggling with Heather Bruer, a Safe Climate (PSC) – a group of ecoanxiety are feeling tired or frenzied, Fundraising Officer Australian psychologists supporting less motivated to look after ourselves people to engage with climate change or struggling at work or in relationships. – accepting these uncomfortable That means it’s time to stop and tend feelings can help empower us to take to our needs. It might involve changing After the summer’s horrific action. what we do temporarily, evaluating our self-care, and sharing the load with bushfire season, ecoanxiety is PSC say acceptance of how we feel, others. on the rise. So how do we pick even when it is painful, is the first step to finding a way through. The Remember that when you have a break, ourselves up and keep working alternatives - fighting our feelings, someone else, somewhere in the world, together for a safe climate? actively avoiding them or dwelling on will be ramping up their action. them alone - can be exhausting and This summer felt like a glimpse into a ultimately paralysing. dystopian future. My Christmas was spent anxiously watching as towns The next step is responding to our were evacuated in the path of a fire that feelings with understanding and was heading directly towards our farm. empathy. This might include saying to Patients in critical care at the local ourselves “this hurts”, “other people hospital were wheeled onto the local feel this way – I’m not alone” or “may oval. I give myself the compassion that I need”. The key is to be gentle with While grief and distress about the yourself. state of our environment is nothing new, according to psychologists, Expressing our feelings to those we ‘ecoanxiety’ or ‘climate anxiety’ is on trust can also be helpful. Being heard, the rise. This represents a very real and knowing others have similar threat to both our wellbeing, and our concerns helps legitimise our feelings. ability to respond to the climate crisis. Taking the next step and engaging in meaningful action on the climate crisis At its most severe, ecoanxiety can then channel our feelings into Credit: Jess Harwood, @jessharwoodart manifests as despair. But even feelings something useful. like fear, worry, grief, guilt and anger can be overwhelming. After all, the When practiced together, these scale of the climate crisis is terrifying, methods of coping foster psychological and the lack of concerted political flexibility, helping ensure our response action to stop it, outrageous. to climate change is sustainable. To get involved in Environment Victoria campaigns go to environmentvictoria.org.au/get-involved/volunteer/ For more information on coping For immediate help please with climate change distress, call Lifeline 13 11 14 or visit envict.org/how-to-cope Beyond Blue 1300 22 4636 8 ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au
Getting active from home How to stay engaged in creating change while we need to physically distance ourselves. Once again we’re in the midst of a Make your voice heard Keep building communities crisis that renders our lives almost unrecognisable. At the time of writing Even now, it’s hugely important that If there has ever been a time to look this article, public events large and we keep talking about environment, out for one another, it’s now. We need small are being cancelled and health climate and justice issues and continue strong communities more than ever care workers are bracing for an influx of to hold decision-makers to account. and we’ll need them in the future. Go to patients. By the time you read this, the environmentvictoria.org.au/active- Write letters to the editor for any from-home to find a mutual aid group situation will likely be very different. papers you subscribe to. Stay tuned in your area. One thing that won’t change is our and call or text talkback radio. We have determination to work together for a a Whatsapp group you can join to be Our society is shaped partly by the just society, our natural environments notified of key media moments. You can stories we tell about ourselves, so and a safe climate. For our own safety sign up at environmentvictoria.org. help tell the story of what resilient and that of people in our communities au/rapid-response communities look like. If you see stories at highest risk of being impacted by of people supporting each other, Get active in the comments section of using their skills, knowledge, time or COVID-19, we can no longer gather in your decision-maker’s Facebook or person to discuss, protest and pressure effort to build connections, develop Twitter accounts, and let them know solutions and make life a little easier for decision makers. So let’s do it from what you think. home. Here’s how you can get started ... the people around them, please share them. Skill up to take effective online action Most social change and environment Many organisations are organisations are shifting their events producing excellent resources online. Is now the time to sharpen some with how-tos, trainings and ideas of your skills, so you can participate? for how you can engage from home. First, get familiar with joining online meetings or webinars. Zoom is a popular tool which makes online To find out more and get meetings easy. If you haven’t used it the latest resources, go to before, sign up to attend a training at environmentvictoria.org.au/ environmentvictoria.org.au/zoom active-from-home Take action from home We can use creative means to make issues visible. Hang a banner or put up a yard sign outside your home Call your friends and family and talk to them about the campaign you’re working on. Ask them if they can create a sign, banner or yard sign. If you’re part of a local group, you can try a ‘virtual rally’ where people gather online at the same time, but in different places. Take a photo of everyone (if you fit in one screen) or make a collage of everyone’s photo. Post on social media and make sure you tag your target. Above: Westernport Bay locals showing their opposition to AGL’s proposed gas import terminal. People printed the sign and uploaded pictures of themselves to social media. ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au 9
Xanthorrhoea australis (grass trees) have a lifespan of up to 600 years. Join the Forever Green Community Some of us grew up here, others This important work to protect the Should you choose to join the Forever discovered Victoria later in life. Some places we love is powered by acts of Green Community by leaving a gift in of us are climate activists, passionate giving. And the most extraordinary your Will, we would like to celebrate and bushwalkers or environmental gift you will ever give is in your Will. honour your commitment to Victoria’s pioneers. environment. Please let us know if you A gift to Environment Victoria in your are interested or already left a gift in We’re all different, but we share one Will can help protect Victoria’s unique your Will. thing in common: a love for Victoria’s plants and animals, cut the pollution environment. that causes climate change, and ensure future generations can enjoy our home as much as we do. Please contact giftsinwills@environmentvictoria.org.au Leaving a future gift to Environment Victoria in your Will is an exceptional legacy for future Victorians who will live in this beautiful state. It’s a simple change when you next review your Will. The wording below is a guide for your solicitor or trustee: “I give to Environment Victoria Inc. (ABN: 84 495 053 605) of Level 2, 60 Leicester Street, Carlton, Vic, 3053 for the purpose of safeguarding Victoria’s environment [the residue [or….%] of the residue of my estate] or [....% of my estate] or [the sum of $....] or [specified property….] free of all debts, duties or taxes and declare that the receipt of an authorised officer shall be a sufficient discharge for my executor(s).” 10 ENVIRONMENT VICTORIA NEWS | ISSUE 33 | AUTUMN 2020 | www.environmentvictoria.org.au
Photo credit Scott Portelli Dear Jono, I want to help build a climate-resilient future for Victoria. PLEASE MAKE THIS A DONATION BY CREDIT CARD: (All donations over $2 are tax detuctable) $50 $100 $250 $1000 Your choice $ Please make this a monthly donation Please find enclosed Cheque or Money Order (payable to Environmen tVictoria Inc.) Or please debit my credit card: Visa Mastercard Amex Cardholders name: Expiry _ _ /_ _ Signature Card number Please send me info about how I can make a gift to Environment Victoria in my Will Are your personal details correct on your letter? Are you moving soon? Please update your personal information if neccessary PERSONAL DETAILS Title: First name: Last name: Address: Suburb: State: Postcode: Email: Mobile: Home: Please complete this form, cut off this page and return it to Reply Paid 12575, A’Beckett Street, Melbourne, VIC 8006 or visit www.environmentvictoria.org.au and make your donation online. Thank you for your generosity! Personal information is collected to process donations, issue tax receipts and keep you updated about our work. Please contact us at the address below if you wish to limit the use of your personal information or stop receiving direct marketing material from Environment Victoria. Our privacy policy is available at environmentvictoria.org.au/privacy and outlines how you can access or correct your personal information, who we disclose your personal information to (including overseas recipients) and how you can lodge a complaint . Please tick if you do NOT want to receive communications from other organisations. Occasionally we allow like-minded organisations to contact you with information that may be of interest to you, including organisations outside Australia. Those organisations allow us to do the same and this way we can reach more people with vital information.
Who’s who at Environment Victoria Chief Executive Officer Network Organiser Fundraising Director REGULAR VOLUNTEERS Jono La Nauze Lavanya Pant Jonathan Storey Data Support Officer Fundraising Officer Environment Victoria would like CAMPAIGNS & Chante Bock Heather Bruer to thank our amazing crew of regular volunteers, who are now too PROGRAMS Communications Key Relationships numerous to mention. Managers Manager Campaign Manager Alex Merory, Greg Lena Herrera Piekarski Nicholas Aberle Foyster Database Officer Healthy Rivers TALK TO US Communications Karly Roolker Campaigner Co-ordinator Phone: (03) 9341 8100 Tyler Rotche Cameron Wheatley BOARD Email: admin@environmentvictoria.org.au Senior Campaigner President Digital Campaigner Taegen Edwards Emma Humann Sawsan Alfayadh Campaigner Vice-President PO Box 12575 Rai Miralles OPERATIONS Tim Watts A’Beckett Street, Victoria, 8006 Sustainable Homes Finance Manager Paul Bailey www.environmentvictoria.org.au Project & Policy Officer Kate Rogers James Conlan Elaine Montegriffo Accounts Officer Community Organising Tabatha Fulker Jing Lu Program Manager Ralf Thesing Administration Emma Horsburgh Assistants Paul Brown Latrobe Valley Organiser Angela Nicopoulos Conor Costello Laura Melville Fiona Ames Marina Lou Community Organiser Office Manager Tim Lo Surdo Victor Komarovsky Cate Hoyle
You can also read