Behavioral and Self-Concept Changes After Six Months of Enuresis Treatment: A Randomized, Controlled Trial
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Behavioral and Self-Concept Changes After Six Months of Enuresis Treatment: A Randomized, Controlled Trial Sally Longstaffe, MD, FRCPC*; Michael E. K. Moffatt, MD, FRCPC*; and Jeanne C. Whalen, MSc Abstract. Background. Previous studies have sug- cacious intervention for children with nocturnal gested changes in self-concept with successful treatment enuresis. Pediatrics 2000;105:935–940; enuresis, self- of primary nocturnal enuresis (PNE), but behavioral concept. changes have not been reported as a consistent associ- ated finding. Objective. To determine if self-concept and behav- ABBREVIATIONS. DDAVP, desmopressin acetate; PCSC, Har- ior change after 6 months of treatment of monosymp- ter’s Perceived Competence Scale for Children; CBCL, Achen- tomatic PNE by conditioning alarm or desmopressin bach’s Child Behavior Checklist. acetate (DDAVP). Design. Randomized, controlled trial in an inner- T he literature on enuresis has had conflicting city hospital clinic. Subjects were 182 children referred or recruited through media publicity, randomly as- conclusions about whether or not this condi- signed both to 1 of 8 pediatricians and 1 of 3 treatment tion is a symptom of an underlying alteration groups (alarm, DDAVP, or placebo). Included were chil- in mental health or a benign self-limited variation dren >7 years old with PNE, no daytime symptoms, in biobehavioral functioning. Early studies sug- bladder capacity >50% expected, and wetting >3 times gested that enuretic children are likely to have a week. Excluded were children with central nervous more behavior problems than their dry counter- system disorders or developmental delays, and those parts.1–3 Results were, however, difficult to inter- currently on DDAVP or alarm. Subjects completed the Piers-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale and Har- pret because of the presence of selection bias and ter’s Perceived Competence Scale for Children (PCSC) lack of prospective study design. More recent stud- at initial visit and after 6 months of treatment. Parents ies with more representative study samples have completed the Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist shown less difference between enuretic and nonen- (CBCL) at the same times. uretic children with most enuretic children not Results. After 6 months of treatment the Piers-Har- experiencing behavior problems.4,5 It has been ris total score showed a highly significant treatment by shown that enuretic children brought for medical period interaction effect for DDAVP, a significant effect for alarm, and no effect for placebo. For children who help have more behavior problems and distress achieved 75% dryness the CBCL showed a treatment by than those who do not seek such help.5,6 In addi- improvement interaction effect that was highly signifi- tion, most studies have not demonstrated symptom cant for DDAVP and placebo with no effect for alarm. substitution with successful treatment.8,9 A recent For the PCSC there were no treatment or outcome inter- study by Friman et al10 reviewed records of chil- action effects. dren with enuresis compared with a sample of chil- After 6 months of treatment there were significant dren referred with behavior problems, and a non- changes over time unrelated to outcome or treatment in clinical sample, finding no significant behavioral the Piers-Harris Subscales and in the CBCL Internaliz- ing and Externalizing Scores, and the Social Thought comorbidity in the enuretic group compared with and Attention Problems Subscales. The PCSC was more the clinical sample of children with behavior prob- stable with no changes in total score, and positive lems. changes over time in only 2 Subscales, Scholastic and Self-esteem is considered an important psycho- Social. logical attribute thought to be associated with mental Conclusion. Children’s self-concept improved with health. Low self-esteem is seen in various psychiatric the type of treatment and amount of success. Parents’ disorders. There are concerns that low self-esteem, if perceptions of behavior improve with type of treatment and amount of success. Children rate their self-concept present in enuretic children, might be an indicator of and some physical attributes better after treatment with present and possible later psychological dysfunction. any of DDAVP, alarm, or placebo regardless of outcome. Social factors associated with enuresis such as miss- Frequent follow-up with emotional support and encour- ing peer overnight social experiences, and unmet ex- agement appear to be important components of an effi- pectations of parents or parental frustration could lead to a child experiencing a feeling of failure, with From the Department of *Pediatrics and Child Health, University of lower self-esteem. One randomized, controlled trial Manitoba, Winnipeg, Manitoba, Canada. of behavior and self-concept in a treated group com- Received for publication Aug 4, 1999; accepted Dec 15, 1999. pared with wait list controls showed significantly Reprint requests to (S.L.) Child Development Clinic, Children’s Hospital, 840 Sherbrook St, Winnipeg, MB R3A 1S1 Canada. improved self- concept in the treated group. When PEDIATRICS (ISSN 0031 4005). Copyright © 2000 by the American Acad- the control group was subsequently treated, similar emy of Pediatrics. improvement in scores was achieved.11 Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by PEDIATRICS Vol. guest on March 18, 105 No. 4 April 2000 2021 935
A recent case-control study of self-esteem in chil- guardian. Emotional support and validation of efforts was pro- dren with nocturnal enuresis and daytime inconti- vided on each visit. Ethics approval was obtained from the University of Mani- nence showed impaired self-esteem in patients toba Committee on the Use of Human Subjects in Research. compared with control children before treatment. Informed consent was obtained from the parents and assent was Patients improved to the level of controls after 6 obtained from the children. months of treatment. Self-esteem was better in those who attained dryness than those with persis- Instruments tent problems.12 Another recent nonrandomized The Achenbach Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL)15 was com- prospective study showed impaired self-esteem in pleted by parents. This instrument has been designed to score in enuretic children before treatment with improve- a standardized format, children’s competencies and problems as reported by parent or parent surrogates. For each of the 113 ment after 6 months of treatment.13 specific questions, 1 of 4 possible descriptors is chosen. Satis- A case-control study of enuretic children com- factory interrater and test-retest reliability has been demon- paring the stress of enuresis with 11 critical life strated. There is satisfactory agreement between parents, and events showed enuretic children ranked the stress stability in test scores over 1- and 2-year periods. Children completed the Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale,16 an of their problem high among all possible critical 80-item questionnaire that is a quantitative self-report measure life events while control children attributed minor of children’s self-concepts. The test has been standardized for importance to nocturnal enuresis as a stressor. The use beyond grade 3 reading level. Answers are categorical. Clus- authors concluded that enuresis causes consider- ter scales are included for the domains of behavior–(PH1), in- able emotional suffering for children.14 tellectual and school status–(PH2), physical appearance and attributes–(PH3), anxiety–(PH4), popularity–(PH5), and happi- A randomized, controlled trial measuring behav- ness and satisfaction–(PH6). Normative data were collected from ior problems and self-esteem in enuretic children a large population of public school children in an American compared with matched controls before and after school district in grades 4 through 12. No sex or grade differ- long-term enuresis treatment has not been done ences have been documented. Threats to validity include dis- tortions to socially desirable responses, acquiescence bias in and would provide additional evidence about the responses, and random responses for reasons such as lack of relative importance of treatment in promoting chil- understanding or motivation. Analysis of test results can show dren’s well being. profiles likely to represent the effect of these response patterns. The test is recognized as being inappropriate for children who are overtly hostile, uncooperative, or severely disorganized OBJECTIVE in thinking. In addition, caution is suggested in interpreting To determine if self-concept and behavior im- results in children from institutional settings or from popula- tions of different ethnic or cultural backgrounds from those of proves after 6 months of treatment of primary the normative sample. monosymptomatic (isolated) nocturnal enuresis by Children also completed Harter’s Perceived Competence conditioning alarm or desmopressin acetate Scale for Children,17 (PCSC). This instrument provides a profile (DDAVP) nasal spray or placebo. of the child’s estimate of their own competence in the cognitive, social, and physical domains and measures self-worth. Stan- dardization on multiple populations has been done. On each METHODS question several choices of descriptors are possible to offset the This report represents analysis of a secondary objective of a tendency to give socially desirable responses. larger study examining the effectiveness of treatment for noctur- nal enuresis. Procedures The study was a randomized, controlled trial conducted in a Baseline measures included history, demographic data col- teaching hospital-based ambulatory facility. There were 3 bal- lection, wetting diary, bladder capacity, and urine osmolality anced treatment arms: conditioning alarm, DDAVP, and pla- measurements. The Achenbach CBCL was completed and the cebo. The pharmacotherapy arms were double-blinded, but the Piers-Harris and Harter scales were completed initially and at 6 alarm side was open. The randomization scheme used a com- and 12 months after randomized assignment of treatment. Com- puter-generated program kept by the hospital research pharma- plete dryness was defined as dry nights in 12 of 14 consecutive cist. Study personnel had no prior access to the code and as- nights without later relapse during the first 6-month study pe- signment to alarm or pharmacotherapy was only revealed after riod. Other outcomes were 75% dry nights by 6 months on baseline studies were completed. Physicians providing the in- treatment. Diaries of wet and dry nights were maintained by the tervention were ambulatory hospital-based pediatricians who children under parental supervision and inspected by project were not the primary care physicians for the patients. There staff at study visits (3 weekly for the initial 3 months, then 3 were 8 strata for physician assignment. This was not considered monthly after). Compliance was estimated at each visit after in analysis because for patient convenience, continuity between discussion with the children and parents with an estimate of each patient and assigned physician could not be maintained. whether the alarm or DDAVP were being used at least 90% of the Subjects were recruited by various means including physi- time. Children were asked to return medication containers to the cian advisement, posters, newspaper advertisements, and radio pharmacy at each visit to monitor compliance. Children with interview. Eligible children were ⬎7 years old with monosymp- treatment failures at 6 months were given the option of switch- tomatic nocturnal enuresis at least 12 times during a 4-week ing to the alternate treatment. Thus, randomized, controlled trial period, with normal urinalysis, no history of fecal soiling and outcomes could only be measured at 6 months. Children who signs of normal bladder functioning (bladder capacity ⬎50% were successful were continued on the original treatment until expected, estimated by urine collection over a weekend). Chil- 12 months. dren were excluded if they had neurologic or developmental abnormality, diabetes insipidus, diabetes mellitus, chronic renal disease, or history of significant constipation. Those already on Data Analysis DDAVP or alarm treatment for enuresis were also excluded. The Statistical Analysis (SAS-PC) system was used for data Children in the study were followed initially at 3-week inter- analysis. Changes in the Achenbach CBCL and Piers-Harris Self- vals, then monthly. Concept Scale as well as the PCSC were compared by repeated At each clinic visit an interval history was obtained. Obser- measures analysis of variance with scale scores as dependant vations about perceived progress were obtained from both the variables and therapy type, period and success as independent child and the guardian. Issues like possible frustration, embar- variables. The general linear models procedure (least squares rassment, or discouragement were explored with the child and means) was used to assess treatment by time and treatment by 936 SUPPLEMENT Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021
Fig 1. Study enrollment. improvement effects. Missing points were excluded from the tics of the 2 groups show that the 3 groups were analysis. comparable (Table 1). RESULTS The Piers-Harris total score showed a highly sig- nificant treatment by time interaction effect with or Six hundred seventy-two children were con- without improvement for DDAVP as measured by tacted about the study. One hundred eighty-nine of the children were ineligible by the entrance crite- change in least squares mean between time 0 and 6 ria; 296 families declined participation for several months (P ⬍ .0001). There was a significant effect reasons (Fig 1). Five children did not return for the for alarm (P ⬍ .02), but no effect for placebo (Fig 3). randomization visit. One hundred eighty-two chil- In children who achieved 75% dryness (⬍7 wet dren were then randomized with 61 children re- nights/4 weeks), the Achenbach CBCL total score ceiving treatment with the conditioning alarm, 60 showed a treatment by improvement interaction with DDAVP, and 61 with placebo. Between 0 and effect as measured by change in least squares mean 6 months there were 17 withdrawals who were between time 0 and 6 months which was highly considered as having treatment failures. At the significant for DDAVP (P ⬍ .0002), and placebo 6-month period, 53 children continued or had com- (P ⬍ .0002), but not for alarm (Fig 4). For children pleted treatment with the alarm, 55 with DDAVP, who did not achieve 75% dryness there were and 57 with placebo (Fig 2). Baseline characteris- highly significant treatment by improvement ef- Fig 2. Treatment randomization. Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021 SUPPLEMENT 937
TABLE 1. Baseline Comparisons Between Treatment Groups Variable N* Alarm 61 DDAVP 60 Placebo 60 P Sex-male 48 (78.7) 45 (75) 37 (61.7) .09 Firstborn 23 (37.7) 25 (41.7) 20 (34.5) .7 Past history, urinary tract infection 8 (13.4) 4 (6.7) 8 (13.8) ⬎.1 Constipation (⬎3 days between bowel movement) 14 (24.6) 14 (23.3) 12 (21.4) .9 Previous prescription Fluid restriction 56 (94.9) 54 (90) 55 (91.7) .6 Lifting 54 (90) 52 (86.7) 57 (95) .3 Behavioral 32 (53.3) 35 (58.3) 40 (67.8) .3 Bladder exercises 2 (3.4) 7 (11.7) 11 (19.0) .03* Conditioning alarm 12 (20) 11 (18.3) 14 (23.3) .8 DDAVP 8 (13.3) 13 (21.7) 11 (18.3) .5 Imipramine 8 (14.3) 10 (16.7) 9 (15.5) .9 Oxybutinin 6 (10.9) 5 (8.6) 5 (8.6) .9 Family history Both sides 21 (36.2) 25 (41.7) 26 (45.6) One side 24 (41.4) 25 (41.7) 19 (33.3) .5 (8 df) Mother’s education (y ⫾ SD) 13.7 ⫾ 2.3 13.6 ⫾ 2.2 13.3 ⫾ 2.5 F .43, P .7 Father’s education (y ⫾ SD) 13.9 ⫾ 2.9 13.1 ⫾ 2.6 13.0 ⫾ 3.5 F 1.20, P .3 Baseline first morning urine osmolality (mean ⫾ SD) 828 ⫾ 216 823 ⫾ 263 800 ⫾ 212 F .15, P .9 Baseline dry nights (%) 24.7 24.0 24.4 F .75, P .5 CBCL total score 55.1 ⫾ 10.4 57.1 ⫾ 8.7 56.3 ⫾ 10.1 F .2, P .8 Piers-Harris Self-Concept 53.2 ⫾ 6.0 52.2 ⫾ 6.7 53.6 ⫾ 5.9 F .8, P .7 fects for both DDAVP (P ⬍ .0002) and alarm (P ⬍ stable with no changes in total score and positive .004) with no effect for placebo (Fig 5). The treat- changes over time in only 2 Subscales: Perceived ment by improvement effects were sustained at 12 Scholastic Competence, and Perceived Social Com- months in completely dry children who remained petence (Table 2). on initial treatment over the 12-month study period. For the PCSC, there were no treatment or out- DISCUSSION come interaction effects in any of the treatment This is the first randomized, controlled trial of groups. behavior and self-concept changes in a group of After 6 months of treatment, there were signifi- enuretic children that included a placebo control cant positive changes over time unrelated to out- group and followed children over a 6-month period. come or treatment in Piers-Harris Subscales PH1 Results in this study suggest improvement both (intellectual), PH2 (physical appearance), PH4 in treated and control children in their own and (anxiety), and PH5 (popularity) (P ⬍ .05). There their parents’ perceptions of their behavior and were similar significant positive changes over time self-concept with 6 months of treatment regardless unrelated to outcome or treatment assignment in of outcome or treatment assignment. It is likely that the Achenbach CBCL, Internalizing and Externaliz- the attention, support, and reassurance inherent in ing Behavior Scores and in the Social, Thought, participation in such a study was beneficial to all and Attention Problems Subscales. The PCSC was participant children. It is also possible that other Fig 3. Treatment and period effects on self-esteem. 938 SUPPLEMENT Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021
Fig 4. Effects on child behavior of treatment and im- provement in dryness in children ⱖ75% dry. factors separate from the study were operative in DDAVP where there was a highly significant rela- influencing the results over time. The previously tionship for children who achieved 75% dryness. It demonstrated stability of CBCL scores over time is not clear why in the alarm group, a less consis- would not support a simple maturation or test- tent treatment by improvement effect, was present retest effect over time. The Piers-Harris Self- or why the children on placebo who became ⬎75% Concept Scale and PCSC have been examined less dry showed highly significant improvement in pa- for stability over time. rental perceptions of behavior. It is possible that The treatment by time interaction effect on the parental perceptions of behavior are influenced by Piers-Harris Self-Concept Scale in both treatment the amount of effort required for the treatment. The groups but not the placebo group lends support to placebo and DDAVP both require minimal invest- the beneficial effect of the treatment process on ment of time or energy for the child or parent while self-esteem. the alarm requires commitment, sleep deprivation, Changes in parental perception of their chil- and inconvenience for both children and parents. dren’s behavior as measured by the Achenbach The lack of treatment or improvement interaction CBCL suggest a relationship between type of treat- effects for the Harter Scale suggests that children ment and success of treatment particularly for may not necessarily view themselves as more com- Fig 5. Effects on child behavior of treatment and im- provement in dryness in children ⬍75% dry. Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021 SUPPLEMENT 939
TABLE 2. Positive Score Changes Over Time These results lend weight to the importance of Piers Harris Self Concept Scale P treatment in fostering emotional well-being in en- uretic children. Additional studies are needed to PH1 (intellectual) * PH2 (physical appearance) * clarify these relationships further. PH4 (anxiety) ** PH5 (popularity) ** ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Achenbach CBCL This research was supported by a grant from the National Externalizing Behavior ** Health Research and Development Program (NHRDP) and Fer- Internalizing Behavior ** ring Inc (provider of the desmopressin acetate). Social Problems ** We would like to thank the children and families who par- Thought Problems ** ticipated in the study. We would also like to acknowledge the Attention Problems ** contributions of Drs Maureen Collison, Murray Kopelow, Sylvia PCSC Kovnats, Debbie Lindsay, Brian Postl, Milton Tenenbein, and Scholastic Competence * Sue Webb, who helped with conducting this study; and Mary Social Competence ** Cheang, Biostatistical Consulting Unit, University of Manitoba, who assisted with statistical aspects of the study. * P ⬍ .05; ** P ⬍ .01. REFERENCES petent even they have more positive opinions of 1. Rutter M, Yule W, Graham P. Enuresis and behavioral deviance. In: themselves. The physical and cognitive self-com- Kowin I, MacKeith RC, Meadow SE, eds. Bladder Control and Enure- sis. Philadelphia, PA: JB Lippincott; 1973:137–147 petence components of the PCSC may be measures 2. Kaufman N, Elizur E. Infants who become enuretic: a longitudinal that might not be seen as different by a child even study of 161 Kibbutz children. Monogr Soc Res Child Dev. 1977;42(2). although control of enuresis had been achieved. Serial 2, No. 170 Additional studies are needed to explore these re- 3. Michaels JJ, Goodman SE. Incidence and intercorrelation of enuresis lationships further. and other neuropathic traits in so-called normal children. Am J Orthopsychiatry. 1934;4:79 –106 Our study would have been enhanced by inclu- 4. Rutter M, Yule W, Graham P. Enuresis and behavioral deviance: some sion of a wait list group of control children. This epidemiological considerations. Clin Dev Med. 1973;48/49:137–147 would have allowed assessment of behavior and 5. Shaffer D. The association between enuresis and emotional disorder: self-concept in children who were not subject to a review of the literature. Clin Dev Med. 1973;48/49:118 –136 6. Hallgren B. Enuresis–a clinical and genetic study. Acta Psychol Neu- the emotional support of participation in the study. rol Scand. 1956;31:405– 436 Another potential weakness in the possibility of 7. Couchells SM, Johnson SB, Carter R et al. Behavioral and environ- selection bias because of the large number of chil- mental characteristics of treated and non-treated enuretic children dren and families who declined to participate. De- and matched non-enuretic controls. J Pediatr. 1981;99:812– 816 pending on the characteristics of these children 8. Behrle RC, Elken MH, Laybourine PC. Evaluation of a conditioning device in the treatment of nocturnal enuresis. Pediatrics. 1956;17: and families, their inclusion in the study might 849 – 854 have influenced the results. There was no analysis 9. Werry JS, Cohrssen J. Enuresis–an etiologic and therapeutic study. according to degree of compliance. J Pediatr. 1967;67:423– 431 10. Friman P, Handwerk M, Swearer S, McGinnis J, Warzac W. Do chil- CONCLUSION dren with primary nocturnal enuresis have clinically significant be- haviour problems? Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med. 1998;152:537–539 Children rate their self-concept and some per- 11. Moffatt MEK, Kato C, Pless IB. Improvements in self-concept after sonal attributes better after treatment with any of treatment of nocturnal enuresis: a randomized clinical trial. J Pediatr. DDVP, alarm, or placebo regardless of outcome. 1987;110:647–52 Parents perceptions of behavior improve with treat- 12. Hagglof B, Andren O, Bergstrom E, Marklund L, Wendelius M. Self- esteem before and after treatment in children with nocturnal enuresis ment regardless of outcome. and urinary incontinence. Scand J Urol Nephrol. 1996;30:79 – 82 Children’s self-concept improved with the type 13. Hagglof B, Andren O, Bergstrom E, Marklund L, Wendelius M. Self- of treatment and amount of treatment. Parents’ per- esteem in children with nocturnal enuresis and urinary incontinence: ception of behavior improve with the type of treat- improvement of self-esteem after treatment. Eur Urol. 1998;33(suppl 3):16 –19 ment and amount of improvement. Children 14. Van Juen N, Messer A, Namdar Z. Perceived stress of nocturnal treated with DDAVP showed the most consistent enuresis in childhood. Br J Urol. 1998;81(suppl 3):98 –99 and highly significant change in both more and less 15. Achenbach TM. The child behavior profile: an empirically based successfully treated children. Given the positive system for assessing children’s behavioral problems and competen- responses on most measures over time, it appears cies. Int J Ment Health. 1997;7:24 – 49 16. Piers E, Harris D. The Piers-Harris Children’s Self-Concept Scale. that frequent follow-up, emotional support, and en- Nashville, TN: Counsellor Recordings and Tests; 1969 couragement are important parts of intervention for 17. Harter S. The Perceived Competence Scale for Children. Child Dev. this group of children. 1982;53:87–97 940 SUPPLEMENT Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021
Behavioral and Self-Concept Changes After Six Months of Enuresis Treatment: A Randomized, Controlled Trial Sally Longstaffe, Michael E. K. Moffatt and Jeanne C. Whalen Pediatrics 2000;105;935 Updated Information & including high resolution figures, can be found at: Services http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/105/Supplement_3/935 References This article cites 12 articles, 1 of which you can access for free at: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/105/Supplement_3/935# BIBL Subspecialty Collections This article, along with others on similar topics, appears in the following collection(s): Developmental/Behavioral Pediatrics http://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/development:behavior al_issues_sub Growth/Development Milestones http://www.aappublications.org/cgi/collection/growth:development_ milestones_sub Permissions & Licensing Information about reproducing this article in parts (figures, tables) or in its entirety can be found online at: http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/Permissions.xhtml Reprints Information about ordering reprints can be found online: http://www.aappublications.org/site/misc/reprints.xhtml Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021
Behavioral and Self-Concept Changes After Six Months of Enuresis Treatment: A Randomized, Controlled Trial Sally Longstaffe, Michael E. K. Moffatt and Jeanne C. Whalen Pediatrics 2000;105;935 The online version of this article, along with updated information and services, is located on the World Wide Web at: http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/105/Supplement_3/935 Pediatrics is the official journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics. A monthly publication, it has been published continuously since 1948. Pediatrics is owned, published, and trademarked by the American Academy of Pediatrics, 345 Park Avenue, Itasca, Illinois, 60143. Copyright © 2000 by the American Academy of Pediatrics. All rights reserved. Print ISSN: 1073-0397. Downloaded from www.aappublications.org/news by guest on March 18, 2021
You can also read