5 STRUCTURALLY RELATED MOLECULES OF HUMAN CHORIONIC GONADOTROPIN (hCG) IN GESTATIONAL TROPHOBLASTIC DISEASES
←
→
Page content transcription
If your browser does not render page correctly, please read the page content below
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases 5 STRUCTURALLY RELATED MOLECULES OF HUMAN CHORIONIC GONADOTROPIN (hCG) IN GESTATIONAL TROPHOBLASTIC DISEASES Laurence A Cole 5.1 INTRODUCTION Human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) is a glycoprotein hormone composed of two dissimilar subunits, a- and b-subunit, held together by charge and hydrophobic interactions. hCG comprises an a-subunit of 92 amino acids and a ß-subunit of 145 amino acids (Figs. 5.1 an 5.2). hCG is an extraordinary glycoprotein with 8 sugar side chains (Figs. 5.1 and 5.2). The sugar side chains account for 25% (pregnancy hCG) to 40% (choriocarcinoma hyperglycosylated hCG) of the composition or molecular weight of hCG (36,000 to 40,000). The combination of free and degraded subunits and different N-linked and O-linked oligosaccharide side chains causes significant heterogeneity in hCG structure. hCG, free subunits, degraded molecules, molecules with hyperglycosylated N- and O-linked oligosaccharide side chains, and fragments are present in serum, urine and other bodily fluids. They are detected in all pregnant women, in all women with trophoblastic diseases, in all men with testicular germ cell malignancies and in men and women with a proportion of non-trophoblastic neoplasms. Figure 5.1. Amino acid sequence of hCG ß-subunit and sites of attachment of N- and O-linked oligosaccharides. Figure 5.2. Amino acid sequence of hCG α-subunit and sites of attachment of N-linked oligosaccharides 148
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Figure 5.3. Principal structures of O-linked oligosaccharides attached to regular hCG and its variants. GlcNAc is N-acetylglucosamine, GalNAc is N- acetylgalactosamine, Man is mannose, Gal is galactose and SA is sialic acid. In addition to regular hCG, 4 major structural variants are commonly detected in serum samples: hCG free ß-subunit; nicked hCG; hCG missing the b-subunit C-terminal peptide, and hyperglycosylated hCG. Many other variants (i.e. nicked free ß-subunit, hyperglycosylated free b-subunit, free ß-subunit missing the b-subunit C-terminal peptide, nicked free ß-subunit missing the ß-subunit C-terminal peptide) are less commonly detected in serum samples. The same large mixture of molecule plus the terminal degradation product, b-core fragment, are detected in urine samples. Table 1 summarizes the structure of the key hCG-related molecules. These vary in size from a molecular weight of 9,500 (b-core fragment) to approximately 40,000 (hyperglycosylated hCG). Table 5.1. Structure of hCG-related molecules detected, to different extents, by commercial hCG immunoassays in serum and urine samples (1-9). hCG-related molecule Structure Regular hCG α-subunit with 92 and β-subunit with 145 amino acid residue (MW ~36,000) polypeptide Mono- and biantennary N-linked oligosaccharides Mostly trisaccharide O-linked oligosaccharides Hyperglycosylated hCG 1 α-subunit with 92 and β-subunit with 145 amino acid residue (MW ~40,000) polypeptide Predominance of larger triantennary N-linked on β-subunit, and N-linked with extra fucose on α-subunit Mostly hexasaccharide O-linked oligosaccharides Nicked hCG 1 α-subunit with 92 and β-subunit with 145 amino acids residues. (MW ~36,500) β-subunit polypeptide nicked/cut at β47-48, β43-44 or β44-45 Mono- and biantennary N-linked oligosaccharides Mostly trisaccharide O-linked oligosaccharides hCG missing β-subunit α-subunit with 92 and β-subunit with 92-122 amino acids (C-terminal C-terminal peptide 1 peptide determinant, β93-145 all or partly missing). (MW ~29,000) β-subunit polypeptide also nicked at β47-48, β43-44 or β44-45 Mono- and biantennary N-linked oligosaccharides No O-linked oligosaccharides Free β-subunit 1 Only β-subunit present, no α-subunit (MW ~22,000) Biantennary N-linked oligosaccharides Mostly trisaccharide O-linked oligosaccharides Urine β-core fragment Degraded β-subunit present (2 peptides, β6-40 and β55-92, held (MW ~9,500) together by disulfide linkages), no α-subunit Degraded biantennary oligosaccharide present No O-linked oligosaccharides 1 Combinations of modification are present in serum and urine, such as hyperglycosylated nicked hCG, hyperglycosylated hCG missing the β-subunit C-terminal peptide, nicked free β-subunit, hyperglycosylated free β- subunit, nicked-hyperglycosylated free β-subunit and free β-subunit missing the C-terminal peptide. 149
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Over 40 different professional laboratory serum hCG tests are sold in the USA for quantifying serum hCG. These and many other tests may also be used to qualitatively assess urine hCG (i.e. positive test when urine concentration >20 IU/L). Almost all of these tests work through the contemporary multi-antibody “sandwich assay” method permitting sensitive labeled-enzyme, isotope, fluorimetric or chemilumenescent detection. Few if any assays are sold today using the old competitive radioimmunoassay (RIA) method which was developed in the nineteen fifties and has largely been displaced. Here we review the commonly used hCG tests and their utility for managing gestational trophoblastic disease cases. All hCG tests use at least one antibody directed against the b- subunit. This has led to the commonly used term “βhCG test.” Some tests detect hCG only and are called intact hCG, or simply hCG tests. Other tests detect hCG and invariable detect hyperglycosylated hCG, free b-subunit and possibly the hCG degradation products. These tests are called total hCG tests, bhCG tests, or again can just be called hCG tests. The names are confusing. For the purpose of this publication we will refer to them all as hCG tests. All modern professional laboratory hCG tests use a combination of antibodies to different sites on hCG (Table 5.1). Commonly, tests use an antibody to one site on the core of the b-subunit. A second antibody is then directed to an alternate site on the core of the b- subunit, on the b-subunit C-terminal peptide, on the hCG dimer or subunit interface, on free subunits, or on the a-subunit. Because of these variations in antibody combination, different commercial hCG tests may measure very different mixtures of hCG-related molecules. Some tests may detect hCG only while others may detect all major hCG-related molecules. This may not be a problem for monitoring pregnancy in serum samples, 7 weeks of gestation until term, since regular hCG is consistently the principal molecule present (Table 5.2). It may, however, be a major problem in monitoring patients with trophoblastic diseases and non-trophoblastic malignancies. In such cases, different hCG variants may be the principal molecule present (Table 5.2). These limitations with hCG tests are carefully investigated in this review. 150
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Table 5.2 This article considers all aspects of hCG detection in trophoblastic diseases. It examines the problems of false positive hCG results. It describes how to avoid false positive hCG results. The experience of the USA hCG Reference service is also presented: problems found with the sensitivity of specific hCG tests; confusing hCG results due to false positive or phantom hCG results; the complications of “quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease” and confusing hCG results due to pituitary hCG.” All of these issues are carefully investigated here. Hyperglycosylated hCG is considered here. As shown by multiple authors, hyperglycosylated hCG is a variant of hCG with completely independent biological functions to regular hCG. Hyperglycosylated hCG appears to be the autocrine promoter of growth and malignancy in gestational trophoblastic neoplasms and persistent mole. The pathophysiology of hyperglycosylated hCG as an independent molecule to regular hCG is carefully considered. The role hyperglycosylated hCG has in the biology of gestational trophoblastic diseases and the use of hyperglycosylated hCG as a test in the management of gestational trophoblastic diseases are considered as are the parallel evolutions of hyperglycosylated hCG and gestational trophoblastic neoplasia. Finally, the use of hCG free ß-subunit measurements is examined. Use has been indicated in the differential diagnosis of placental site trophoblastic tumor. The differential diagnosis of women presenting with persistent low levels of hCG is considered. Examination of the differentiation of false positive hCG, quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease, pituitary hCG, and placental site trophoblastic tumor are all appropriately considered. 151
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases 5.2 PATHOPHYSIOLOGY OF hCG AND RELATED MOLECULES The hCG found through most of pregnancy, regular hCG, has 4 O-linked oligosaccharides on the ß-subunit (Fig. 5.1). These are primarily of the trisaccharide type (Fig. 5.3). Regular hCG has 4 N- linked oligosaccharides, 2 on the α-subunit and 2 on the ß-subunit (Figs. 5.1 and 5.2). These are mixtures of monoantennary (8 sugar residues) and biantennary (11 sugar residues) structures (Fig. 5.4) (1- 3). In choriocarcinoma, gestational trophoblastic neoplasm and persistent mole cases, the principal hCG form found is hyperglycosylated hCG (1-3). While this has the same peptide structure as regular hCG, it has varying proportion of larger N- and O-oligosaccharide structures (Figs. 5.3 and 5.4) (1-3). The N-linked oligosaccharides are fucosylated triantennary structures with 15 rather than 8-11 sugar residues, and the O-linked sugars are hexasaccharide rather than trisaccharide structures. Effectively, the sugar structures on hyperglycosylated hCG are double size sugar structures, comprising as much as 40% of the molecular weight of hCG (1-3). Table 5.3 152
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Figure 5.4. Principal structures of N-linked oligosaccharides attached to regular hCG and its variants. hCG-H. GlcNAc is N-acetylglucosamine, Man is mannose, Gal is galactose and Fuc is fucose, and SA is sialic acid. As published, regular hCG is made by the differentiated syncytotrophoblast cells, while hyperglycosylated hCG is produced only in the stem cytotrophoblast cells, the invasive trophoblast cells (4,5). Clearly, only the invasive trophoblast cells produce hyperglycosylated hCG. Hyperglycosylated hCG has minimal regular hCG-like progesterone-promoting biological activity at the hCG/LH receptor (4,6). The possibility that hyperglycosylated hCG may have a separate biological role to regular hCG, possibly in promoting the growth and invasive activity in the invasive cytotrophoblast cells is considered. Three model systems have been used for investigating the invasive functions of hyperglycosylated hCG with malignant cytotrophoblast cells. The first two were JAr and JEG-3 lines of choriocarcinoma cells. The third system was NTERA testicular germ cell cancer cell line. All 3 cytotrophoblast models produce exclusively hyperglycosylated hCG (7). As shown by 3 independent groups using these models (4,8-10), hyperglycosylated hCG (also called choriocarcinoma hCG), but not regular hCG, directly modulates cytotrophoblast cell growth, tumor formation and cytotrophoblast cell invasion in vitro and in vivo. This was shown by a combination of Matrigel cell culture invasion chamber studies in vitro, cell culture 153
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases growth studies in vitro , and confirmed by examining human xenograph malignancies, athymic nude mice with transplanted growing human choriocarcinoma cells in vivo (4,8-10). As found in our laboratory, addition of monoclonal antibodies to hyperglycosylated hCG completely inhibited the cell growth, invasion and tumor formation in all models in vivo and in vitro, preventing cytotrophoblast cell invasion, preventing cell growth and blocking tumor growth and progression (4,8). Addition of pure hyperglycosylated hCG, but not pure regular hCG, promoted both growth and invasion (4,8). Similarly, addition of antisense DNA to either hCG α-subunit or ß-subunit prevented all hCG production in Jar choriocarcinoma cells (hyperglycosylated hCG is the only form of hCG made by these cells), and similarly blocked invasion, cell growth and tumorigenesis in similar models in vitro and in vivo (9,10). Considering our published studies with monoclonal antibodies to hyperglycosylated hCG (4,8), and these independent reports with antisense DNA to hCG subunits in cells solely producing hyperglycosylated hCG (9,10), it is concluded that hyperglycosylated hCG secreted by cytotrophoblast cells, acts on these same cells through an autocrine receptor on the same cells to promote growth and invasion. While syncytiotrophoblast regular hCG functions as an endocrine, promoting progesterone production at a distant corpus luteal LH/hCG receptor, hyperglycosylated hCG seemingly acts as an autocrine, rather than endocrine, produced by cytotrophoblast cells and attenuating cytotrophoblast cell growth and implantation. Hyperglycosylated hCG is in multiple ways a distinct molecule from regular hCG, it has a different molecular weight to regular hCG (40,000 vs. 36,000), it is produced by separate cells (cytotrophoblast vs. syncytotrophoblast), it is has an autocrine rather than an endocrine action, and has a separate functions, promoting growth and invasion and tumor formation. This is a unique situation, specific genes coding for the α- the ß-subunit of regular hCG and hyperglycosylated hCG (the polypeptide sequences are identical (4)) yielding two independent molecules. The same polypeptides forming the common backbone of two very separate molecules, regular hCG and hyperglycosylated hCG. It is concluded that secreted hyperglycosylated hCG modulates the invasion and growth of cytotrophoblast cells in choriocarcinoma and testicular germ cell malignancies. Multiple publications show that tumor growth factor beta (TGFß) is the promoter of apoptosis in trophoblast cells (11,12). As shown, TGFß directly inhibits invasiveness and proliferation in choriocarcinoma cells and testicular germ cells. Absence of TGFß and smad 3 consistently occurs in cytotrophoblast cells in choriocarcinoma permitting growth and invasion. These findings 154
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases suggest that invasiveness and growth in choriocarcinoma malignancy may be controlled through blockage to TGFß activity and apoptosis (13,14). As reported, choriocarcinoma hCG or hyperglycosylated hCG work by promoting cell invasion and growth, by blocking the normally TGFß modulated apoptosis (10). TGFß promotes apoptosis in all tissues. In promoting apoptosis it blocks tissue invasion and proliferation. TGFß activity is limited or absent in most cancers permitting growth and invasion. Malignancy may be modulated by blockage of TGFß activity and apoptosis (over 4000 citations, references limited to recent reviews: 15,16). As published, hyperglycosylated hCG also promotes cell invasion and proliferation through blocking apoptosis in trophoblast cells (10), or works by a TGFß receptor-like controlled apoptosis mechanism. The ß-subunit of hCG has structural homology with TGFß. Both the ß-subunit of hCG and TGFß (and platelet derived growth factor and nerve growth factor) contain a exclusive cystine knot structure in which multiple disulfide bridges uniquely link anti-parallel peptides in the center of the molecule (17). A molecule the exact molecular size of hyperglycosylated hCG, has been shown to bind the TGFß receptor on choriocarcinoma cytotrophoblast cells (18). The binding of hyperglycosylated hCG to the TGFß receptor is inferred by both these molecular size studies and by obviousness (hyperglycosylated hCG functions by blocking apoptosis in choriocarcinoma, TGFß- regulates apoptosis and is absent in choriocarcinoma). It is inferred that hyperglycosylated hCG acts in an autocrine manner on the TGFß receptor, to antagonize TGFß action. In so doing it blocks apoptosis, as demonstrated (10), permitting cell growth and invasion. Through this pathway, cytotrophoblast hyperglycosylated hCG promotes invasion and growth in choriocarcinoma. As described above, blockage of hyperglycosylated hCG with a monoclonal antibody to hyperglycosylated hCG in nude mice xenograph cancer models, completely blocks human choriocarcinoma growth and invasion or induces oncostasis (4,8). It is inferred, that administration of human antibodies to hyperglycosylated hCG or administration of a vaccine to hyperglycosylated hCG to humans would perform similarly in humans, blocking gestational trophoblastic neoplasm, choriocarcinoma and testicular germ cell malignancy growth, inducing oncostasis or effectively curing disease. Efforts have been made to license this technology and manufacturers to produce human antibodies for this purpose. There has been no interest because the diseases are rare and they would not make enough money. A company called CG Therapeutics Inc. in Seattle WA, is, however, producing a vaccine, that should be very useful for treatment of gestational trophoblastic disease and testicular germ cell malignancies in the future. 155
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases 5.3 PARALLEL EVOLUTION OF hCG AND GESTATIONAL TROPHOBLASTIC NEOPLASIA Humans are unique in that over 60% of the energy intake in utero is used to support the developing brain’s nutritional needs, compared with just 20% used by 4300 other mammalian species (19,20). For a human to evolve there was a need for gestational mechanisms to support such a nutritionally demanding nervous system (19, 20). An ultra-deep hemochorial placental implantation mechanism evolved with humans to accommodate this human fetal nutritional need. Examining the evolution of hyperglycosylated CG, reveals that this molecule is the signal for placental invasion in humans, whether as in choriocarcinoma or at implantation as in pregnancy (4, 8). It also reveals the parallelism between the molecular evolution of this molecule and its biological activity and the evolution of the advanced systems in primates and humans. The evolution of hyperglycosylated CG appears to be at the root of the evolution of placental implantation to accommodate nutritional needs for human brain development. It appears that the amount of nutritional support or supply of energy in a species limits brain size and the development of the brain throughout gestation (19,20). Brain size is therefore related to the combination of body mass and the metabolic support of the developing progeny (21). How then did humans evolve an exceptionally large brain relative to body mass? They appear to have evolved a unique very deeply implanted placental mechanism to support the nutritional demands of the embryonic brain (Table 5.3). Primates have a two-fold greater brain to body mass than other mammals (22). At embryo implantation, cytotrophoblast cells of the placenta invade more deeply into the endometrium permitting greater vascular contact than occurs in other species (19-22). Uniquely in humans, under influence of high acidity hyperglycosylated hCG, cytotrophoblast cells invasion is deepest going to the inner third of the myometrium and permitting hemochorial bleeding of spiral arteries directly onto placental cells (19, 20, 23). This nutritionally supports supports development a cranial capacity relative to body mass that is three-fold greater than those of the most advanced primates. Evolution of primates and, to a greater extent, humans is marked by hemochorial placentation, deeper placental invasion, which thus provides the nutrients for brain development (Table 5.3). We ask, what are the mechanisms that have evolved in primates and humans that initiated this sequentially deeper invasion at implantation? CG is part of a family of hormones that includes luteinizing hormone (LH). These hormones are the glycoproteins hormones that share a common α-subunit coded by a single gene, and a separate ß- 156
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases subunit which dictates hormone function (24,25). Fiddes et al., 1980 (24) examined the DNA sequence for the ß-subunits of CG and LH and showed evolution of CG from LH in primates by a single deletion mutation in LH DNA and read-through into the 3’- untranslated region. Maston et al., 2002 (25) examined the DNA sequences of the ß-subunit of 14 primates and showed that CG was not present in prosimians the more primitive primates, but evolved with anthropoid primates. Frequent gene and sequence changes have occurred in the sequence of the CG ß-subunit with the evolution of anthropoid primates to catarrhine primates (orangutan and baboon) and hominids (25). The acidity of CG and LH in species affects their circulating half times and thus their serum concentrations and therefore their biopotency. Human CG has 4 O-linked oligosaccharides, all on its ß- subunit. These acidify it resulting in a molecule with a mean isoelectric point (pI) of 3.5, and a circulating half time of 2400 minutes (26). Human LH, by comparison, has no O-linked oligosaccharides, a pI of 8.0 and circulating half time of just 25 minutes. As such, CG circulates for approximately 100 times longer than hLH and is therefore approximately 100-fold more biologically active than LH. LH was the only progesterone promoting gonadotropin produced by early primates and other species (25). The rapid circulating half- time of LH very much limited its serum circulating concentration or biological activity. The earliest CG in anthropoid primates had 2 O-linked oligosaccharides on the ß-subunit at serine residues 121 and 132 (25). This had a mean isoelectric point of 6.25 (Table 3). As a result of a point mutation at residue 127 (Asn→Ser), the more advanced catarrhine primates evolved further with 3 O-linked oligosaccharides (25,27). Then with the evolution of the hominoid ancestor, a point mutation occurred at residue 138 (Ala→Ser) and molecules were developed with 4 O-linked oligosaccharides (25). The 4 O-linked oligosaccharide molecule was the most acidic CG (26). The sequentially increasing circulating half-time of LH and then CG with 0, 2, 3 and 4 O-linked oligosaccharides (pI 8, pI 6.3, pI 4.9 and pI 3,5, respectively) with primitive species, anthropoid primates, catarrhine primates and then hominoid ancestors was associated with sequentially increasing serum concentrations or biological activities over the 100-fold range. As discussed in this article, hyperglycosylated CG is the cytotrophoblast cell or the stem placenta cell glycosylation variant of CG. The hyperglycosylated CG made by cytotrophoblast cells and regular CG made by syncytiotrophoblast cells status seemingly occurred with all primates. As such hyperglycosylated hCG evolved with increasing numbers of O-linked oligosaccharides parallel to the evolution of regular hCG. 157
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Hyperglycosylated CG therefore evolved with anthropoid primates and exponentially increasing serum concentrations of hyperglycosylated CG with the evolution of species with molecules containing 2, 3 and 4 O-linked oligosaccharides respectively, leading to greater and greater acidity or biological activity which correlated with deeper and deeper implantation (Table 5.3). As discussed in this article, CG-H has separate biological functions to CG in cytotrophoblast invasion. It is associated with cytotrophoblast growth and invasion through a TGFß - apoptosis mechanism. Hyperglycosylated CG with 2 O-linked oligosaccharides seemingly was expressed initially in anthropoid primates, this led to minimal invasion at implantation. Hyperglycosylated CG was then raised in concentration and biological activity with addition of a further O-linked oligosaccharides with the evolution of advanced catarrhine primates leading to deeper implantation (Table 5.3). It was raised further in activity with the addition of a one more O-linked oligosaccharide with the evolution of hominoid ancestors leading to the ultra deep implantation seen in humans. The hyperglycosylated hCG-associated evolution model may be optimal for nutrition and brain development in human but clearly comes with complications. As published, hyperglycosylated hCG is critical for appropriate implantation in humans, insufficient hyperglycosylated hCG leads to miscarriages (28). The incidence of pregnancy failures (miscarriages and early pregnancy losses) is much higher in humans (40%) than in rodents (10%) and all other species (10%). Furthermore, human placentas harbor hyperglycosylated hCG, an invasion-promoter critical for the super-implantation needed for human placentation to support the nutrition for brain development. As a complication of humans having this invasion promoting molecule, humans uniquely develop persistent mole, gestational trophoblastic neoplasm or choriocarcinoma. It is hypothesised that there is an evolutionary connection between the nutritional requirements for brain development in humans, placental invasion and implantation, advances in the development and glycosylation of hyperglycosylated CG, and the development of neoplastic gestational trophoblastic disease in humans. 5.4 SELECTING AN APPROPRIATE HCG TEST FOR TUMOR MARKER APPLICATIONS AND FOR MONITORING PATIENTS WITH GESTATIONAL TROPHOBLASTIC DISEASES In the USA, all professional laboratory and point of care hCG tests are approved by the Food and Drug Administration for serum pregnancy testing only. All tests provide assistance in their 158
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases information leaflet and guidance values for pregnancy testing only. Most test manufacturers recommend that the use of the test be confined to pregnancy testing. Currently, however, only about 65% of laboratory hCG testing is for pregnancy detection, approximately 20% is for Down syndrome screening (triple and quadruple screen protocols) and 15% is for trophoblastic diseases and cancer applications. The proportion of tests for trophoblastic diseases and cancer applications is quite high because the average pregnant women has only two hCG tests, one to confirm pregnancy and one for Down syndrome screening. In contrast, the person with trophoblastic disease has as many as 80 or more hCG tests during multi-year monitoring. There is clearly a need for manufacturer’s to consider these “off label” applications, and to verify and certify use for serum and urine trophoblast disease management and other common applications. As described earlier in this review, hyperglycosylated hCG is the principal form of hCG produced in active choriocarcinoma/gestational trophoblastic neoplasm cases, hCG free ß-subunit is the principal hCG variant made in PSTT and non- trophoblastic neoplasms. Yet very few manufacturers, however, have calibrated their so called “total hCG” tests for equally detecting regular hCG, hyperglycosylated hCG and free ß-subunit (76). This is in part due to a lack of availability from WHO of a hyperglycosylated hCG standard. The FDA in the USA only requires calibration against the molecule called hCG or regular hCG (41, 76). Hyperglycosylated hCG is the predominant form of hCG produced in the three weeks following implantation in pregnancy (Table 5.1. During the first, second, third and subsequent weeks after implantation, hyperglycosylated hCG is gradually replaced with hCG; hyperglycosylated hCG accounting for >80%, 63%, 50% and 25 to
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Table 5.4 Circulating hCG (from hydatidiform mole) and hyperglycosylated hCG (from invasive trophoblast disease or choriocarcinoma) commonly becomes nicked as levels diminish after therapy (Table 5.2) (5,6). hCG and hyperglycosylated hCG are nicked or cleaved at ß43-44, ß44-45 or ß47-48. This is a major a-subunit:ß-subunit hydrophobic and charge interaction or linkage point. As such, nicking leads to rapid dissociation of molecules (1), releasing the nicked free ß-subunit (34). In trophoblastic disease cases, when hCG values fall below 100 mIU/ml, nicked hCG and free ß-subunit often become the major or even sole sources of hCG immunoreactivity in serum (Table 5.2) (35,36). Cases have been reported in which a recurrence of invasive disease has been completely missed by use of an assay that does not detect nicked hCG (Table 5.4) (35). False negative results have also been observed using assays that do not detect free ß-subunit or nicked hCG. It appears that measurement of these molecules is essential for accurately monitoring hCG levels until they become undetectable, or reach background (
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases In two independent studies we have observed nicked hCG missing the ß-subunit C-terminal peptide in trophoblast disease patient serum (32, 37). As shown in Table 5.4, only one of 11 tests appropriately detects nicked hCG missing the ß-subunit C-terminal peptide. In a recent study, 5 of 76 cases of complete mole and choriocarcinoma were shown to have significantly lower hCG values when tested with any one of 9 tests requiring the ß-subunit C-terminal peptide to be present (32). As found, 6 of 86 gestational trophoblastic disease cases (about 1 in 14) required detection of hCG missing ß-subunit C- terminal for meaningful management of trophoblastic disease. Multiple blind studies with no financial or commercial bias have been completed by the USA hCG Reference Service to investigate abilities of common commercial immunoassays to detect the different hCG-related molecules associated with trophoblastic diseases and cancers (32,41,76). As found, the Siemens Immulite hCG test is the only one that efficiently detects all of the hCG variant antigens in serum samples on an equimolar basis (Table 5.4). This is clearly the only appropriate test for management of cases with gestational trophoblastic disease and non-trophoblastic malignancies. All other tests either inappropriately failed to detect molecules missing the ß-subunit CTP, or failed to appropriately detect hyperglycosylated hCG, free ß-subunit or other molecules critical to gestational trophoblastic disease and cancer detection (Table 5.4). Centers managing gestational trophoblastic disease cases need to change to the Siemens Immulite test. We also blindly investigated the Charing Cross RIA (Table 5.4). This is the test used by the Charing Cross Gestational Trophoblastic Disease Center. This center has been at the root of many discoveries regarding gestational trophoblastic disease management and they have claimed that their RIA is the best assay alternative for them. As found in blind studies (Table 5.4), this RIA test inappropriately detects hCG free ß-subunit, nicked hCG missing the ß-subunit C-terminal peptide and urine ß- core fragment (32,41). Furthermore, as described later in this review, this type of assay has clear problems with false positive hCG results (41). Blind studies were also carried out examining the abilities of different assay to appropriately detect 76 cases of gestational trophoblastic disease. As shown in Table 5.5, the Siemens Immulite assay once again proved to be the best test, with only 6 of 76 results varying from the median test result for 8 assays by more than 25%. By far the poorest results (72 of 76 values varying from the median result by more than 25%) were observed with the Charing Cross RIA (Table 5.5). 161
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Table 5.5 It is concluded that hCG-related molecules may vary greatly in structure and size. In cases of trophoblast disease or non- trophoblastic malignancies, any one of the variants may constitute the sole form of hCG in serum or urine samples. It is important to talk with your laboratory and make sure that they are using an appropriate test which detects all the pertinent hCG-related molecules, before submitting samples for monitoring patients with trophoblastic diseases or other malignancies, or before making important decisions from the results. Based on blind and non-biased studies the Siemens Immulite is seemingly the only appropriate test for this purpose. 5.4.1 THE EXPERIENCE OF THE USA HCG REFERENCE SERVICE The USA hCG Reference Service was started in January 1998 in response to repeated requests from physicians for help with confusing or inconsistent hCG results (28, 33, 42). It is a consulting service that investigates patient medical history, laboratory hCG records, and brands and versions of hCG tests used. It also independently measures in a single test concentrations of all common hCG-related molecules listed in Table 5.1 (Siemens Immulite hCG test), and regular hCG only, nicked hCG only, hyperglycosylated hCG only, free b-subunit only, and b-core fragment only in parallel serum and urine samples provided by patients (28, 33, 42). Dilution parallelism is investigated (1X value in undiluted sample and 1/3rd and 1/10th of the value in 3-fold and 10-fold diluted sample), as is the affect of HBT (Scantibodies Inc.), a heterophilic antibody/interfering substance blocking agent on all assay results (28,33, 42). A clinical records report is prepared for the physician on the nature of the hCG detected by the clinical laboratory, on the most likely source of the immunoreactivity (malignant gestational trophoblastic neoplasm, placental site trophoblastic disease, pituitary hCG, non-trophoblastic neoplasm, or false positive hCG) and on the suggested management of the case. 162
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases The USA hCG Reference Service is United States Department of Health and Human Services CLIA certified for preparing data/reports for inclusion in patient records (CLIA ID# 32D0972561). The USA hCG Reference Service is monitored for consistency in results by the College of American pathologist. While called the USA Service, they consult on approximately 70 cases from throughout the USA and 20 cases from around the world (from Europe, Middle East, South America, South-east Asia) each year. In seven years there have been over 500 patient referrals to the USA hCG Reference Service for various reasons. Commonly the USA hCG Reference Service data confirms physician’s diagnoses of gestational trophoblastic diseases, persistent mole, ectopic pregnancy, placental site trophoblastic disease, testicular choriocarcinoma, or ovarian germ cell or other non-trophoblastic neoplasms. The USA hCG Reference Service also discusses and advises on a large number of cases of gestational trophoblastic disease on the telephone (over 500 further cases), making recommendations or suggesting tests that can be carried out in the patient’s locality. In addition the web site (www.hcglab.com) attracts approximately 200 e-mails from patients each year. Questions about hCG results, pregnancy, trophoblast disease and the soundness of the hCG test are addressed. Often patient inquiries by e-mail lead to home urine hCG testing, and sometimes to further outside hCG testing, physician involvement and USA hCG Reference Service testing to determine the validity of hCG results. Of particular interest has been the observation of numerous cases peri-menopause, post-menopause or following oophorectomy with pituitary hCG. This is very commonly mistaken for gestational trophoblastic neoplasm, or persistent malignancy if patient has no history (42). A very large number of false positive or phantom hCG cases have been identified, in which the patient received unnecessary therapy for the diagnosis of gestational trophoblastic disease (invasive/malignant disease or choriocarcinoma not confirmed by pathology). Also of interest has been the observation of a significant number of women producing low levels of normal pregnancy hCG with no clear physical evidence of tumor or new or recurrent trophoblastic disease, this is quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease. The USA hCG Reference Service now uses the hyperglycosylated hCG test to identify quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease, and an hCG free ß-subunit test to identify patients with placental site trophoblastic disease. Here we will describe each one of these common findings of the USA hCG Reference Service, false positive hCG, pituitary hCG, quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease, placental site trophoblastic tumor. We also describe how the USA hCG Reference Service distinguishes each diagnosis. 163
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases 5.4.2 FALSE POSITIVE hCG In the first few months of operation of the USA hCG Reference Service, 3 unusual cases were investigated for gestational trophoblastic disease or choriocarcinoma (40). In all 3 cases the woman had an incidental pregnancy test prior to surgery which was positive. The positive hCG value persisted with small rises and reductions in reported hCG results. Ultrasound, dilation and curettage and laparoscopy ruled out pregnancy or ectopic pregnancy. The diagnosis of gestational trophoblastic disease or choriocarcinoma was made, even though there was no previous history of trophoblastic disease or physical evidence of tumor. In two of the 3 cases chemotherapy was started, and in 1 case a hysterectomy was carried out. All 3 cases were then referred to the emerging USA hCG Reference Service (the need for the Service emerged from cases like this). At that time the reported hCG concentrations were 17, 53, 110 IU/L, respectively. It was a surprise when false positive hCG results were demonstrated in these individuals. The findings indicated that the hCG test used by the physicians was detecting interfering antibodies rather than hCG (40). Now, after eight years of operation, and multiple publications on the false positive hCG problem (37-40,42-44), over 400 women have been referred to the USA hCG Reference Service for investigating potential false positive hCG results. To date (October 2007) 91 women were shown to have had false positive hCG result. False positive results are due to interfering antibodies in the patient’s serum, whether human anti-animal antibodies gained from exposure to animals or human heterophilic antibodies. Human heterophilic antibodies are gained from immunoglobulin A deficiency disorder or history of mononucleosis (42-45). The interfering antibodies, just like hCG, can bridge the capture and tracer animal anti-hCG antibodies used in the hCG assay. In our experience, false positive hCG results can range from 2 to 1100 mIU/ml. We have never observed a false positive case with erroneous levels exceeding 1100 mIU/ml (42-44). False positive results were identified by the following criteria (42- 44): 1. The finding of more than 5-fold differences in serum hCG results with alternative immunoassays. 2. The presence of hCG in serum and absence of detectable hCG or hCG related molecule immunoreactivity in a parallel urine sample (interfering antibodies are large glycoproteins. The do not cross the glomerular basement membrane so do not interfere with urine measurements). 3. The observation of false positive results in other tests for 164
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases molecules not normally present in serum, such as urine b-core fragment. 4. The finding that a heterophilic antibody blocking agent (Scantibodies Inc. HBR) prevented or limited false detection (confirmatory criterion). 5. The finding that hCG results differ greatly when tested undiluted, and diluted with serum. Other laboratories around the world have also identified cases having needless therapy due to false positive hCG results in modern hCG tests (45-50). Many false positive hCG results were reported in the nineteen eighties using the older RIA technology, and more recently false positive results coming from very few testing by centers still using the RIA technology today (41,51-53). The USA hCG Reference Service has also investigated cases with proven history of hydatidiform mole or choriocarcinoma with recurrence of disease. In 6 cases the recurrence was all or in part due to false positive hCG results. In 3 of these 6 cases chemotherapy or surgery was needlessly carried out to treat a phantom or false positive recurrence. In the remaining 85 false positive cases observed by the USA hCG Reference Service there was no history of trophoblastic disease and no direct physical evidence of a tumor. Patients were investigated and then treated according to protocol for a diagnosis of gestational trophoblastic disease or choriocarcinoma. The history of each of the 85 false positive cases started with a positive incidental pregnancy test. Seventy of the cases had dilation and curettage and/or laparoscopy to exclude ectopic pregnancy. Fifty three received needless single agent chemotherapy or underwent high risk etoposide-based multi-agent chemotherapy. Nine had needless hysterectomy and/or bilateral salpingo-oophorectomy; in addition some had further major surgical procedures. Among the cases, false hCG immunoreactivity (at the time of USA hCG Reference Service consultation) ranged from 9 to 900 mIU/ml. Earlier false positive values of up to 1,100 IU/L were recorded. It is our understanding that in all cases after false positive hCG demonstration all treatment was halted, even though physician’s laboratory test remained positive. It is our experience that false positive results in a specific hCG assay may remain false positive for 3 or more years. Women having false positive hCG results can also have falsely elevated results in other immunoassays. The history of a representative false positive hCG case is outlined in Table 5.6. 165
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Table 5.6 In the experience of the USA hCG Reference Service, most false positive hCG results have occurred in patients monitored by their medical center’s laboratory using the Abbott AxSym hCG test, the Siemens ACS180 and Siemens Centaur tests, by the Beckman Access and Dade Dimension tests, and the Ortho Vitro test. No cases referred to us were being monitored by their medical center using the Siemens Immulite or Roche Elecsys tests, indicating that these tests are less prone to false positive hCG test problems. False positive hCG results in the USA hCG Reference Service assay were prevented by pre-treatment of serum with the heterophilic antibodies blocking agent HBR (54). Heterophilic antibodies are bivalent human antibodies against other human antibodies, or against animal-like antibodies. Human antibodies can cross species and bind animal antibodies, like the mouse, rabbit, sheep and goat antibodies used in hCG tests. These cross species, bivalent, antibodies are able to act like hCG linking the capture and tracer antibodies. Their presence in blood can cause persistent false positive hCG results. The USA hCG Reference Service experience with HBR indicates that circulating heterophilic antibodies in patient blood are the cause of false positive results. The problem of human heterophilic antibodies and human anti-animal immunoglobulins is well known by commercial test manufacturers. Commonly, manufacturers add an excess of non-specific antibodies or animal serum to samples to avoid false positive results. Many of the medical doctors that managed the 91 cases referred to the USA hCG Reference Service, in which hCG was shown later to be due to false positive hCG results, observed a transient decrease in the hCG values in the time following chemotherapy or surgery. This 166
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases misled physicians by wrongly indicating presence of disease and successful therapy of disease. The transient decrease may be due to an interim weakening of the immune system as a result of chemotherapy or surgery. This could reduce circulating antibody concentration, leading to decreased false hCG results. 5.4.3 QUIESCENT GESTATIONAL TROPHOBLASTIC DISEASE Among other unexpected results recorded by the USA hCG Reference Service are the finding of persistent low real (not false positive) hCG values in women, lacking evidence for tumor, rising hCG or any evidence of clinically active disease. These inactive gestational trophoblastic disease cases are called quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease cases (quiescent GTD). Quiescent GTD was diagnosed in these cases by the observation of persistent low levels of hCG (always
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Table 5.7 Table 5.8 Quiescent GTD, in our experience, always follows a history of choriocarcinoma/gestational trophoblastic disease, hydatidiform mole or occasionally an ectopic pregnancy or spontaneous abortion. A recent study by Sebire et al (54). indicates that all cases of gestational trophoblastic neoplasm following an ectopic pregnancy or spontaneous abortion are likely following an aborted or ectopic hydatidiform mole, though confirmatory pathology is often lacking. As such, the study by Sebire et al (54) confirms our observation that all cases of quiescent GTD are limited to cases with gestational trophoblastic disease. 168
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Hyperglycosylated hCG (hCG-H) testing aids in the diagnosis of quiescent GTD and the early detection of active GTN or choriocarcinoma. As discussed in a previous section of this review, hyperglycosylated hCG is the promoter or driving force of trophoblast cell growth and invasiveness or malignant disease. As such it is no surprise that absence of hyperglycosylated hCG production marks non-invasive non-propagating disease or quiescent GTD. Choriocarcinoma and choriocarcinoma cell lines comprise mainly invasive cytotrophoblast cells producing primarily the hyperglycosylated form of hCG (1,4,8-10). hCG-H is the predominant form of hCG in the circulation in invasive cases, GTN, and choriocarcinoma (1, 33, 42), but is not prominent or is absent in benign cases of hydatidiform mole or quiescent GTD. It is therefore likely to be a useful marker of invasive trophoblast behavior. Here we review the most recent publications on this possibility and compare findings with other reports. The recent papers by Cole, et al. demonstrates the usefulness of total hCG and hyperglycosylated hCG in detecting active GTN and quiescent GTD (33, 42). In these studies 83 women or histologically proven choriocarcinoma were compared with 95 benign disease controls, 26 patients with self resolving hydatidiform mole and 69 with quiescent GTD. In addition, serial samples were collected from 23 women with recurring disease. All were tested for total hCG and hyperglycosylated hCG. Hyperglycosylated hCG was calculated as the percentage of total hCG (percent hyperglycosylated hCG). There was no significant difference in the spread of hCG values between choriocarcinoma and gestational trophoblastic neoplasm, and no difference between quiescent GTD and self-resolving hydatidiform mole cases. In contrast, the percent hyperglycosylated hCG was very significantly higher in choriocarcinoma/GTN cases than in quiescent GTD (P
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases hyperglycosylated hCG in identifying quiescent disease (55, 56). Follow-up data indicated that most cases of quiescent GTD lead to the diminution of hCG, or loss of hCG producing trophoblast cells. In the majority of cases this occurred within 6 months of the identification of quiescent gestational trophoblastic disease. In one rare case it persisted for 9 years (33,42-44). To date, in 23 cases, active disease followed the diagnosis of quiescent GTN (24% of cases). While the majority of cases that led to active disease were those with history of gestational trophoblastic neoplasm/choriocarcinoma, a few were patients with history of non- invasive hydatidiform mole. We estimate an approximate 40% incidence of recurrent disease in patients with history of gestational trophoblastic neoplasm/choriocarcinoma and 10% incidence in those without history of invasive disease. Data suggests that quiescent GTD is a transient condition or pre-malignant disease. Repeat consultations were performed in 23 of 23 cases in which active disease was subsequently demonstrated. In 12 of 23 cases, proportion hyperglycosylated hCG results were able to first identify active disease 0.5 to 11 months prior to rapidly rising hCG or detection of clinically active neoplasia. In the remaining 11 cases proportion hyperglycosylated hCG showed active disease (needing chemotherapy) at the same time as rising hCG or demonstrable clinical tumor. Hyperglycosylated hCG is made by only cytotrophoblast cells, the invasive trophoblast cells (5,6). Since regular hCG is produced by syncytiotrophoblast and hyperglycosylated hCG by cytotrophoblast we conclude that the absence of detectable hyperglycosylated hCG in patients with quiescent GTD must be associated with conversion of cytotrophoblast to syncytiotrophoblast or by the total loss of all cytotrophoblast cells in patients. Clearly, when quiescent GTD transforms to active disease the number of cytotrophoblast cells must increase sufficiently to produce detectable hyperglycosylated hCG . Currently, multiple measurements of rising hCG results are required to identify new or recurrent choriocarcinoma/GTN. As shown by this data, a single measurement showing the presence of hCG-H is sufficient to demonstrate the presence of active disease and to initiate chemotherapy. This data presented on hyperglycosylated hCG in identifying quiescent GTD and in the early detection of recurrent active disease is seemingly sufficient to encourage the immediate adoption of hhcg as a marker for gestational trophoblastic diseases. With the availability of such an accurate diagnostic tool, physicians can avoid two pitfalls inherent in current hCG testing regimens. First, the use of an hyperglycosylated hCG assay allows physicians to determine the presence or absence of invasive disease, to treat those with active GTD or choriocarcinoma, and avoid unnecessary 170
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases treatment in those with quiescent GTD. Second, the use of an hCG- H test would allow the physician to diagnose active disease in the timeliest fashion (without waiting for serial increases in hCG or physical observance of tumor) and thus initiate treatment at the earliest sign of actual invasive disease Physicians treating gestational trophoblastic disease are encouraged to use the hyperglycosylated hCG test to avoid unnecessary chemotherapy and surgery, and to initiate treatment of neoplastic disease as early as possible. 5.4.4 PITUITARY hCG It is now 30 years since human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) production was first demonstrated in healthy non-pregnant women (57). This hCG was shown in 1980 to be coming from the pituitary gland (59). As described in numerous publications, low level hCG production accompanies luteinizing hormone (LH) production at the time of the mid-cycle pre-ovulatory surge, as a normal part of human physiology (42, 57-64). Furthermore, significant pituitary derived hCG is normally present alongside LH due to the lack of suppression by estrogen and progesterone, and is measurable in serum and urine samples of postmenopausal women (59-63). In medical practice, a positive hCG test prior to menopause suggests a gestational event; either pregnancy or gestational trophoblastic disease (42,61,64). In practice, a positive hCG in menopausal women represents a quagmire, and a malignancy is commonly considered. The detection of hCG in blood after menopause often creates confusion in physicians unaware of the normal pituitary production of hCG which can lead to the erroneous assumption of malignant disease (42,61,64). When this assumption is made, necessary treatments may be delayed, expensive invasive testing initiated or toxic treatments given resulting in poor patient outcomes. In this past year, the USA hCG Reference Service has consulted on 120 cases of peri-menopausal and postmenopausal women with measurable hCG. Nearly all cases had analogous histories and conclusions. In most of these, we informed the referring physicians about the normal physiology of pituitary hCG and suggested how to clinically confirm it. In almost every history, hCG was detected as part of pre-operative or pretreatment evaluation. Surgery, therapy or renal transplants were then postponed pending these consultations investigating the positive hCG result. In multiple cases needless hysterectomy was performed or chemotherapy given for assumed gestational trophoblastic neoplasm or assumed other malignant disease. 171
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases In cases evaluated by the USA hCG Reference Service, the age range was 29-69 year, (median age 52), 9 women were menopausal following oophorectomy (ages 29 to 40) and the balance were naturally menopausal due to age (age 45 to 69). The average hCG results at the time of consultation were 9.5 ± 6.5 mIU/ml and the range was 2.1 to 32 mIU/ml. In all cases low positive serum hCG results persisted from 3 months to 10 years. In the majority of cases attending physicians had inferred the presence of gestational trophoblastic disease or cancer. In all cases serum was tested for hyperglycosylated hCG (indicates active gestational trophoblastic disease, see previous section). No significant hyperglycosylated hCG was detected in any case (hyperglycosylated hCG 15 mIU/ml and >20 mIU/ml). It was concluded in all cases that the source of the persistent low levels of hCG were menopause and normal pituitary gland function. In all cases it was recommended that the source of hCG be confirmed by treatment of these women for 3 weeks or longer with a high estrogen contraceptive pill. If the hCG was of pituitary origin this should suppress production. To the best of USA hCG Reference Service knowledge, from feedback received, a high estrogen pill suppressed hCG production in all cases, confirming the pituitary origin. This information about normal pituitary production of hCG peri- menopause (approximate age 40-55, and post-menopause approximate age 55>) is of great importance to physicians managing cases with persistent low levels of hCG and those managing cases with gestational trophoblastic disease (42-44). These findings show that persistent low levels of hCG (
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases 5.4.5 FREE ß-SUBUNIT AND PLACENTAL SITE TROPHOBLASTIC TUMORS Placental site trophoblastic tumors (PSTT) usually presents with amenorrhea or irregular vaginal bleeding commonly following a normal pregnancy, spontaneous abortion or occasionally after a hydatidiform mole (65-68). PSTT is generally associated with significantly lower hCG levels than choriocarcinoma (
Structurally related molecules of human chorionic gonadotrophin (hCG) in gestational trophoblastic diseases Table 5.9 Two types of PSTT patients were referred to the USA hCG Reference Service. Firstly, those with history of PSTT to determine whether a new elevation of hCG was real (hCG was confirmed as real and not false positive). Secondly, those with persistent low levels of hCG of unknown source, in all these cases PSTT was later identified by histology. At total of 7 cases were referred between 2001 and 2004 (Table 9). When examined collectively, persistent low hCG ranged from 0.77 to 236 mIU/ml, and no significant hyperglycosylated hCG was identified (
You can also read